Next Steps: • 💵 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ter.li/bvvnxk • 🏘️ Find a Ramsey Trusted Real Estate Agent - https://ramsey.solutions/i9wi7g • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
Brought to you by the Every Dollar app.
Start budgeting for free today. My
sister um so I'm one of three children.
I'm the middle child. My older sister is
going through a divorce,
>> which is terrible situation. Of
>> course,
>> she's got three kids. Her eldest I think
is about three years away from starting
college.
>> Okay.
>> And um previously like my sister, all
three of her kids were attending private
private schools. Mhm.
>> Um her and her husband driving luxury
vehicles, fancy vacations, living
extremely well.
>> And no judgment there. That's fantastic.
Happy for them. But appears from an
outsider, they had a very high burn
rate. Recently, we've discovered um as
just kind of the discovery process going
through figuring out how the divorce is
going to play out, but they have under
$50,000 in savings and that includes
retirement accounts. That's that's
>> Oh, wow. Okay. So, my sister is
expecting to buy her husband out of
their current home
>> and her dental practice and she needs
$800,000 to do that.
>> Now,
>> she doesn't have expecting to do this.
>> Great question. So,
>> she had she had reached out to me um and
it turns out she had reached out
initially to my parents and they had
agreed to provide her with 400,000.
>> Oh my gosh.
>> Do they have that money?
They they do in their retirement.
They're retired, but
>> but it's it's their nest egg.
>> Are they multi multi million?
>> Yeah. How much money do they have? Your
parents?
>> It's a great question. I I don't know
the number, but
>> Okay. Did it feel like that's a that's a
significant part of their retirement?
Like a fourth or a third or is it like
Oh, no. That's
>> 400. 400 they wouldn't miss.
>> Okay. Okay.
>> Maybe. Okay.
>> Dang, Gina.
>> It's great.
>> I would I'd miss it a lot.
>> A lot.
>> Definitely. And so my sister then
reached out to me um and asked if my
husband and I had an extra $400,000 she
could borrow.
>> Meet every dollar budgeters Christy and
Steve. Their life is chaotic, but their
money is simple because they budget with
every dollar. Budgeting with the
spreadsheet took a ton of time,
>> but now with every dollar, I can do a
budget in 5 minutes.
>> And tracking purchases is just as
simple.
It's so freeing to know exactly where
your money is going.
>> It just takes that stress out of the
day-to-day life.
>> You got this, Hanigan family. Every
dollar. Create your free account today.
>> And so my sister then reached out to me
um and asked if my husband and I had an
extra 400,000 she could borrow.
>> And and we're we're pretty good with
money. Um so we wouldn't have 400,000
sitting
getting destroyed by um
>> by inflation. So, I mean, I I told her
that, you know, without selling one of
our properties, we we wouldn't be able
to get her to 400,000, but, you know,
we'd still be willing to help. And then
she called me back and told me, "Don't
worry about it. She can make other
arrangements."
>> So, I spoke with my parents and turns
out they're the other arrangements.
>> Oh, no. They're going to give her the
full 800.
>> Full 800. So, they claim that she's
overleveraged on debt and she can't get
a loan from a bank. She's got a mortgage
and
>> so we're gonna we're gonna let her go
almost a million dollars in debt to us.
Awesome. Great plan,
>> right? Well, I that's I don't even know.
Is it going to be a loan or is it going
to be a gift at this point?
>> I'm not sure.
>> Okay. Okay. Okay.
>> But, you know, my parents have this
parental guilt. They feel that she's a
victim of the situation. She trusted her
husband to manage finances. This is
where I I disagree a bit on the point.
>> We're with you, Mike. Yeah, we're with
you.
>> It's It's trust but verify at this
point. You're you're an adult. Yep.
>> Um, and then they also want assurances
that in the event that she were to get
back to together with her soon to be
ex-husband, you know, they would want
all of this money back immediately,
>> right? All the strings attached. All the
strings attached.
>> Don't don't. Yeah. All this is a
horrible idea.
>> So, what what can we do to help, Mike?
>> I totally totally understand. Yeah. So,
from my my perspective, and first of
all, I want to know if I'm crazy, but
from my perspective is my my parents
have worked hard and lived frugally
their whole lives. They've provided us
with fantastic childhoods. They paid for
our college and I want them to, you
know, enjoy their retirement and spend
their money on what brings them joy.
>> Well,
>> yeah, but but you can't control that
mindote. That's what they're choosing to
do. Are they asking your opinion at all?
>> I gave it to them because I also happen
to be the executive of their will.
>> Nice.
>> Okay, that's fair.
>> And um and we have similar financial
behaviors. I mean, we're we're in
similar situations. Find a CEO.
>> All right, but here here's the here's
the brass tax. Let's say 100% and Rachel
and I take these calls. So, it does
happen that your sister was lied to,
manipulated, and just got hit by a by a
steamroller
>> with this divorce. The financial
position, she had no idea. She thought
everything was different and bam. Okay.
There is that mess. And in my world, we
say not by her hand, but in her lap. She
didn't cause this and boom, here it is.
>> Mhm. that doesn't give license to avoid
reality moving forward.
And that what does that mean? That means
she can't afford the house she lives in.
She can't afford to buy a dental
practice as much as she wants to own
one.
It it it's it's a because I got screwed.
I'm now owed X, Y, or Z. And that's how
our country is in almost $40 trillion
worth of debt.
That's how student loan debt is almost
$2 trillion. I
>> credit card debt set at an alltime high.
>> I didn't get this, so I deserve to go to
the college. I want to I deserve to have
this. I deserve to have this program or
that. And and
>> her world blew up.
>> And it sounds like her world before it
blew up, she never was told no either,
right? She never has had to
>> to rational face reality of, oh, there's
not enough money here and my kids can't
go to the school I want them to go to. I
I there's not enough money to buy a car
that I really want to buy. So, I'm going
to choose a different one. You know, it
sounds like her conditioning for years
and years and years has been I kind of
get what I want and we're going to use
debt for it because that's that's
exactly what the savings show. They have
no money save. They've put nothing away.
They've spent everything or more. And
so, for her to want these things to me
is pretty obvious. I understand why she
does cuz she doesn't have another way of
thinking.
>> Well, and we all want our kids to go to
the best schools on the planet. We all
want fancy cars, big house.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. But but and then your
parents to a degree enabling that by
continuing to just,
>> you know, fund a little bit of her not
facing reality to what a little bit
of here's the way to have this
conversation with your dad. It's not
about money.
>> It's a because he's going to say, "I
have it. It's my money. I can do what I
want." And he's right on all counts.
>> And he can. Yeah. He is guaranteeing
by his participation in this in your
sister's pain, not just sitting with her
in the pain and saying this is awful.
He's participating in guaranteeing that
there will be a there will be a rift in
their relationship forever. And after
him and your mom pass, that rift will
get passed to you guys,
>> his other kids,
guaranteed. Because when he gives her
$800,000 and she shows up in a new car,
his first instinct is going to be, "Why
didn't she pay me back?" or "Why?
Where'd she get that money to buy that
car?"
>> Yeah, that that was supposed to go to
the house in the different
>> that was supposed to go to this and what
about that? And and then when this guy
comes back a year later, which happens a
lot, and realizes his life's awful and
wants her back and sees her thriving
practice and she's going to be like,
"Oh, well, it is the father of our
kids." And then
>> and in a wonderful way, just going to
blow things up. the marriage is, if
that's the case, and the marriage is
redeemed in a healthy way. That's an
applause.
>> There's an $800,000 price tag.
>> Now, there's a million dollars, you know
what I mean? That gets that gets dragged
in the middle of that into a beautiful
redemption story. So, I'm like
>> all the way around, it's not it's not
wise. But, Mike, what sucks about your
position is you have no control. You
really don't. Like, he he's going to
they're going to do what they're going
to do. And you can say everything you
want to say, say it in the way you think
he's going to all the things, and at the
end of the day, they're going to choose.
And then you're going to have to you're
going to have to deal with yourself in
that decision, whether it is pain and
sadness and feeling like that's unfair
to you and your other sibling. I mean,
whatever it is, that's going to be yours
to carry from then on out.
>> Is is it normal for her to call you and
ask for money?
>> I'm sorry.
>> Is it like her calling you and asking
for money that just after asking mom and
dad and then asking you and your wife,
that feels like a level of desperation
of someone who's scared that their life
is unraveling? And sometimes the
greatest gift is to let it all the way
unravel and sit with somebody in the
ash.
>> Create your free every dollar budget
today. The simplest way to budget for
your