Next Steps: • 💸 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ramsey.solutions/2wufkc • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
A woman seeks advice on how to handle an inheritance of two commercial properties ($4.2M and $2.4M) shared with her sister, who has a history of theft and financial irresponsibility. Despite the sister's 60% stake and the trustee's reluctance to deviate from her wishes, the advisor urges the woman to use legal counsel to force a separation of assets to avoid a joint business venture.
Brought to you by the EveryDollar app. Start budgeting for free today.
I am needing to be pointed in a direction. My mother passed away in 2024,
and my sister and I have inherited her commercial properties, and they have tenants in them
currently, so there is rental income coming into the trust. The properties are going to be deeded
over to my sister and I, and I was told that we will likely need to establish an LLC for the
rental income to flow into and then expenses to be paid out of. The caveat is is that my
sister has a history of stealing half of $756,000 and not paying her share of our father's
income and estate taxes timely, so that led to me being threatened with garnishment from the IRS
because I was the only one gainfully employed. How many properties are involved in this transaction
and what are they worth? One was appraised at $4.2 million and one was appraised at $2.4 million.
I don't want to be on a bank account with someone who has stolen money from me.
I don't blame you. Why don't you just sell both properties and you guys go on your way?
That was the original plan. However, there is someone interested in purchasing the lesser
valued property, but he can't purchase it right now, so he wants to leave it for five years.
Well, then he's not your buyer. Why don't you just get somebody else to buy it?
Unfortunately, the decision is not up to me. My mom left all decisions to be made by a trustee,
and I am a lesser beneficiary. My sister's 60%. I'm 40%, so I don't really have a say.
Is the trustee aware of her behavior?
He is, and personally, I think it's a conflict of interest, but he is also my sister's trustee.
You need legal counsel to force the trustee to liquidate the properties,
because you don't need to be in any kind of a deal with her, period.
You know those free samples at the store that are up for grabs for anyone? Well,
that's basically what's happening with your personal information
online. Data broker sites collect stuff like your address, phone number, email,
even your family's information, and just post it online for anyone to grab,
and that's why I use Delete.me. They remove your personal info from hundreds of data broker
websites and keep it gone. So stop letting random websites treat your data like it's free samples.
Get 20% off your annual plan at joindelete.me.com slash Ramsey.
Because you don't need to be in any kind of a deal with her, period.
Yes, okay.
Because of that, and so I don't care what we facilitate here. I mean, you could sell the
$4 million one, and you take $3 million, and she takes the other property in a million.
It's not 50-50, but yeah, whatever 60-40 works out.
But I mean, you could sell that property and take your share out of that.
It's about $1.68 million.
So there's $6 million, and you have 40%. So $2.4 is yours, right?
Right.
And the other property, the little property is worth what?
$2.4.
Why don't you just take that and give her the other one?
I offered to do that, and the trustee declined.
Why?
Because the person who is in the process of purchasing it,
he really wants to give this person the chance of the opportunity of owning that property.
Why? Who is this person?
This person was a longtime manager for my parents' business.
Is the business operating in that property?
Our family business ceased in March of 2024.
There is another retail business in there now, and he is managing that business.
I think you and your attorney need to sit down with the trustee in person and explain to them
that we're not going to accept a process by which I end up in business with my sister.
If you continue to push that agenda, we're going to sue you.
Okay.
I think that's you and your attorney need to sit down with your trustee and explain that.
Because the trustee's job, their fiduciary responsibility is not for someone that's
not a member of the trust to do good for the family general manager.
That's not his job.
He's violating his fiduciary responsibilities,
fiduciary responsibilities to the beneficiaries of the trust, which is you and your sister.
So what benefits the two of you?
And when you explain to him that you are not going to accept being
pushed into business with your sister, that we are going to break this up.
You know, as a matter of fact, there's nothing that keeps him from
deeding the 2.4 to you and the four to your sister.
And then you deal with the guy.
You don't have to sell the 2.4.
You could become the owner of it.
And you're waiting on the other guy to take five years to buy you out.
You could do that.
We could.
However, my sister is refusing.
My sister wants to make sure that I end up with as little as possible.
That's not up to your sister.
Your sister doesn't have a say in this.
I understand.
But because she's the bigger beneficiary,
the trustee has explained it to me that if he doesn't follow her wishes
as the majority beneficiary, he doesn't follow your wishes.
He's going to get sued.
He needs to understand.
OK, yeah, it's time for you to take the gloves off and punch some people in the nose here,
because these people are just, you know, you don't have to be mean about it,
but you just got to be real tough.
And just like guys, I am.
Let's start with a baseline here.
She's a crook and I'm not going to be in business with her.
So we're not forming an LLC and we're not going to own and operate property together.
That's not an option.
If you continue to push that agenda, I'm going to sue all of you.
And we're going to be in court.
And I'm going to screw up your lives for the next five years.
And I'm going to have to spend $100,000 in legal fees, but I'm going to do it.
Or we can work out something where I get my share of the property and go on my merry way.
It's a pretty obvious thing that the 2.4 mathematically lines up with that.
And she can have the four and I'll have the two.
And Mr. Trustee, God help you.
You're out of business.
You got nothing to do now.
It's actually a good deal for them because she's legally owed 2.64 out of her share.
And she's going to take on the 2.4 property.
So I would take a loss to get rid of this barrel of fish hooks.
Yeah.
I mean, but they're going to gain 240 grand just by going through with this,
by giving her this other property.
So it sounds like it's just vengeance.
And then I may or may not deal with this general manager from the
former business and all this stuff.
I don't, it'll be up to me because now I own that property.
You don't have to sell it.
And you want to work with a guy that'd be an added thing to make the deal work.
Right.
But if you don't want to work with a guy, you don't even have to do that.
So yeah, I think you need an attorney that has a really, um, titanium backbone, uh,
that walks in there and just smiles and says, uh, we're going to dance.
Do you want to dance?
We don't have to dance, but if you continue to play the music, we're gonna dance.
And you just kind of have to have these discussions and take all their
mythology and their feelings off the table, uh, because I'm threatening you.
That's what I, you know, that that's where, that's where it needs to come down to.
I'm coming after you.
And, uh, because otherwise you're going to end up getting screwed again, some more.
And you're right.
Um, leopards don't change their spots.
LLCs don't protect you from people who are irresponsible and crooked.
It's just a more fabulous, sophisticated way to get screwed.
You can't change people.
Don't do business with them.
Don't just don't stay.
You know, if you know somebody, you know, crocodiles bite.
So don't put your hand in their mouth.
Hello.
Not hard.
Create your free every dollar budget today.
The simplest way to budget for your life.