Tony and the team are invited by a family of Somerset farmers to answer a question that's been puzzling them for generations: was there ever actually a castle on top of the hill they call Castle Hill? Records show there was a Norman castle in the area, but they are not clear about exactly where and there are several likely locations. Finally the pieces of the jigsaw do join up, but only in a very unexpected way.
It's like Netflix for history... Sign up to History Hit to start watching now https://bit.ly/45CPh5u
You can find more from us on:
/ timelinewh
/ timelinewh
This channel is part of the Little Dot Studios Network. Any queries, please contact [email protected] Time Team investigates a Somerset hill, rumored to hide a Norman fortress. Using geophysics and historical records, they uncover intriguing structures and artifacts. The team's investigation reveals a surprising twist in the hill's history.
One of the great privileges of working at History Hit and making films
together with our team at Timeline is the access we get
to extraordinary historical locations like this one
Stonehenge. I'm right in the middle of the stone circle now. It is an absolutely
extraordinary place to visit. If you want to watch the
documentary like the one we're producing here
go to History Hit TV. It's like Netflix for history
and if you use the code TIMELINE when you check out
you'll get a special introductory offer. See you there.
This hill is called Castle Hill. Local legend
says there may be a castle somewhere in the area possibly dating from the Norman
period.
And the landowners believe that the lost castle is sitting on top of their hill
waiting to be discovered. We have to do a nice flat site and this
is what they've come up with. But there are no clear written records
and no obvious reason why a castle should be here
as there's nothing to defend. So was a castle ever built on this site?
If so who built it and why? As usual we've got just three days to find
out. Mind you it's taken me the best part of
three days just to climb up here. Are we gonna set up base camp here?
At 450 feet Castle Hill in South Somerset
is the biggest hill for miles around. Come on. Until we sort out a vehicle route
it's a real challenge for everyone who wants to get to the top.
He adopts the rambler attitude with a rucksack on the back.
He was walking like that when he left the bar. Jimmy
did nobody tell you you can get a vehicle up here?
The hill lies a couple of miles northwest of the village of Crewe Kern
and one mile southeast of Hinton St George.
John's magnetic survey has given us a promising first target.
It looks like there was something on the summit of Castle Hill.
It's a good place to start and Phil's wasting no time
in marking out the first trench. You ever thought getting a job at a council?
At least we've got a good start with this fantastic geofence.
We have. It looks as though on the top of the hill here
we've got what could be a big structure.
It's the prime location for some sort of tower.
Yeah keep something like that. Do you often get
stone Norman castles turning up? You get stone
keeps even if the rest of it is timber. You get a mound
with a tower on the top or a tower with a mound packed around it.
Well we've got this lovely geofence where do you want to put in the first
trench? Anywhere in the middle there just
to see what we're getting. See what it looks like.
You've got everything to play for with it. Let's have a look. Let's see.
So trench one is going in slap bang on top of the hill
where Geofiz is picking up signs of an intriguing structure.
With a bit of luck it could even turn out to be a castle keep.
That's exactly what the landowners, the Irish's, would like us to find.
Sons Andrew and Paul Irish have been fascinated by the giant hill in their
backyard for as long as they can remember.
So guys that's in your back garden. It is it's been a fantastic feature of our
childhood really having the the hill there all the stories that go with it
and a bit of an adventure playground in
itself really. What's the local folklore that
suggests that there was a castle up there? Well so far as we know
there was some sort of medieval castle there.
So you want us to find some definitive evidence of the castle?
It'd be fantastic it's really hard imagining people living
up on top of the hill so be incredible to try and imagine how
the building was up there and how dominant it must have been in the
landscape. Let's hope we can solve the mystery for
them and prove that their hill was indeed the site of a medieval castle.
Well there we are look that's South Somerset.
Meanwhile Mick and Alex have hauled themselves up the hill
to survey the wider area. Could there be a reason hidden in the landscape as to
why you'd build a castle on this spot? For me it's the sort of strategic
significance of this location. I think that's the thing you know because that's
where the Somerset levels are which is boggy and waterlogged for
probably six months of the year at that time.
So anybody coming from the east from Winchester from London
going down to the southwest peninsula that way have really got to come through
a relatively narrow gap. So this could be controlling
I think so that corridor and the kind of traffic that would be going down here
not just military traffic we've got. I mean you know you've got people who are
trading there are goods moving about but the
significance is when an army comes through.
Yeah. If you could perhaps map just what area of ground it can
dominate. I've got just the tool Mick but it involves a bit of technology.
Okay well let's try it. Whatever was built up here
may have overlooked a trade route and played a vital defensive role.
So it's entirely possible it was a castle.
Mary Anne and castles expert Mark Morris are looking through the local
historical records for any mention of one in the area.
This is a mid-12th century charter. It's given by
Baldwin, Comes, Exxon, Earl of Exeter or Earl of Devon
and at some point midway in the charter he says Castri
Mei de Cruca, my castle of Cruchurn. There you have it in black and white. We
have a castle at Cruchurn and this is a document from 1148.
And are they talking about that castle? Possibly.
It has to be said we're not exactly in the middle of Cruchurn right now. No it's
a couple of miles away. There could be any number of hills or
castle sites around here. So it's back to the archaeology to give us
some answers. I think so. Keep digging. The historical
charter proves that somewhere in the vicinity
there must be a lost medieval castle. But it doesn't tell us what it would
have looked like or precisely where it was built.
Phil's making good progress in his trench and is already unearthing what
could be the foundations of a large building.
How you getting on mate? Oh really well Tony.
I mean this this trench is absolutely
diddled with archaeology and we think we might be getting to get the lines of
robbed out walls. You've got a very very good edge.
Explain to me why you're confident that's a good edge
because I see the same colour there as I see there. There's one
and there's the other. That one has got sand
and nothing much else. This has got loads and loads of little stones in it.
Totally different. Okay yeah I believe you. So we've got
stony stony stony stuff across here and there we think we've probably got
the other edge. You can see here it's very very sandy
and here we've got this sort of stony gritty stuff
and then out on this side beyond where we think the wall line might be
look we've got masses and masses of stone rubble. Now whether or not that's
where they've demolished the wall and thrown out the stone that they don't
need and taken away the stone that they do need
I don't know. So it's looking good and we have also got our first
piece of pot. Can you date that? 12th century
or about there. Yeah. It looks like we've got a really big building here.
But is the building large enough to be a castle?
The results of the radar are now in and as we suspected
confirm the existence of a large rectangular structure on top of the hill.
As we go into the ground you can start to see this
rectangular structure taking form. That's great isn't it? I mean it's looking more
and more like a keep. We've got this clear ditch
following this line so what we plan to do is put a trench
across there to look at that ditch see if it's
related to the structure. Is it me or does that look absolutely
central to this rectangle? Yeah but if it was a hall block
with a first floor hall then this could be
a pillar supporting some sort of vault in the middle.
So where's that on the ground? If we've got this big pier
it's going to be at this point here and that'll be supporting
the upper floors. It's starting to get a bit exciting isn't it?
So we're extending trench one by three meters
to look for this mysterious central feature and to see whether Mick's grand
ideas about this site are correct while Raksha and Matt are
opening up a second trench on the lower slopes
over what appears to be a ditch. You see the orange is coming up there at
the blob that we're coming through could be this
ever so slightly darker bit couldn't it? Because we're trying to look for
an anomaly first and then the ditch should be a bit further up the hill.
Down at our base camp Alex is using some specialist computer software
called viewshed analysis. It maps the entire
area that can be seen from the top of Castle Hill.
What we do with viewshed analysis is we take a point in the landscape which we've
taken from up there in Castle Hill okay and
what we then map is all the other places on the landscape that can be seen
from that point and that's what you can see in green.
That's very good isn't it? We can see all of this with the naked eye when we're up
there but this really helps us to map it.
Just looking here at the Fossway okay the Roman road which is something we
could see parts of from up on the hill well this
confirms we can actually see here where the Fossway
crosses the River Parrot. That's a really important point to control that
isn't it? Yeah. I noticed you've got on the map here
Crow Castle yeah because this might be the earlier castle mightn't it?
Well this is the thing this early documentary reference we've got is
refers to a castle at Crook yeah and for me
the place name Crow Castle is so similar to that early reference
yeah and the proximity to Crewe Kern as well which we know was an important
Anglo-Saxon market town and mint might suggest that this is one of the
first places you put a castle. Yeah I think you ought to go and have a
look at this and see whether there's anything to see at all on the
ground but not before you've had a cup of tea.
I think I will do. So Alex and Mark are going to investigate
another contender for the castle in the documents
nearer the town of Crewe Kern but with its spectacular views of the area
our Castle Hill is still a prime candidate
and some new finds from Raksha's Trench are looking very promising.
Pots lots and lots of them. Look at those isn't that fantastic maybe
got getting on for 20 sheds come out already
just while the guys have been cleaning the top of it. All out of trench tea? Yeah
there's no glazed wares there's none of the early stuff it's just solid
12th century pottery by the looks of it. And it's cookery?
Well there were general purpose pots I mean imagine this was the early medieval
equivalent of a brown paper bag that you could cook in. So we now have
evidence that people may have been living on top of Castle Hill
in the medieval period and all afternoon the archaeologists have been sifting
through the rubble in Phil's Trench in search of building foundations.
Have you established whether this is rubble or could it be something more
That's what we're trying to do now Tony I mean we've got it all cleaned up
we've really got to strip it off and find out whether it's
masking a wall or whether it is just rubble.
This does look like a very very good contender
for a foundation trench you can see we've got a lovely edge
coming along one edge there and then another edge back here so
that if that is a wall it's going to be a really deep
substantial wall. But this is where you've extended the trench
that is some hole you've put in there. Yeah we still haven't got to the bottom
of it this is John's central pillar yeah and I mean it is literally going down
and down and down and down. You haven't found any evidence of it yet?
Not of the wall no I mean I think it's literally the decayed mortar from where
they rubbed that stonework out. Meanwhile Alex and Mark have made
their way a mile and a half down the road to look at another hill they want
to work out if that could be the one mentioned in
the records. So here we go Mark when do we get it
described this site as Crowcastle? Well yeah it's a late reference it's
sort of 18th 19th century it's the first one I can find at the moment.
What I think is significant about this site is the fact that we are much
closer to the town of Crookhurn if someone says my castle at Crookhurn
right there's the town so you know Castle Hill is a mile or so further
away yeah so that would argue in favor of this
site yeah and it's it's not just a hill is it that's been christened Crowcastle
because we've got some actual earthworks this is a
modified hill so there's a number of factors in favor of this site as a
castle and I quite like the idea that in the
immediate aftermath of the battle of Hastings you've got rebellion
and there's a desire amongst the Normans to kind of look down
on the Anglo-Saxons so that they can't get bands together and attack the
invading Normans. So this hill much closer to Crookhurn
could well be the site of the castle in the historical records
if that's the case then what are we digging up on Castle Hill
a forgotten castle or something else we don't tend to see many yurts on
time team but the team have taken to them like ducks to
water reminds you all of Glastonbury doesn't it look at you all
well thank you bunch of hippies having a cup of tea of an evening
end of day one have we got a castle well what we have definitely got
is a mid-12th century castle at Crook whether this
is Crook Castle anybody's guess and I've been out looking at a site called
Crow Castle close to Crookhurn and that's increasingly looking like a
candidate for this this castle that's referred to which
raises the question if this isn't a Norman castle what is it
Mick yeah but I mean look at the look at the latest geophysics
there's our trench which is producing buildings and Norman pottery on the top
but you can now see we've got three lines of ditches that one
this one here and then one outer here and they could be the triple ditches of
an iron age fort a prehistoric fort so you know it might be but it's got an
earlier past as well as the Norman stuff so is this site prehistoric
is it Norman let's hope we find out tomorrow
love and peace
beginning of day two here at Castle Hill in Somerset
and we haven't shown you this side of the hill before
it's the less steep side that our four by fours use to get to the top
sort of tradesman's entrance we're attempting to uncover
a mysterious lost structure on the top of Castle Hill
Phil's put in a trench over the summit where radar
has definitely detected a large rectangular building
and Raksha has been digging in what may turn out to be the defensive ditch
surrounding it initially we thought we were finding
evidence for a stone built castle but a discovery early this morning
suggests we may have been on the wrong track
Phil was pretty confident about what was happening in this trench but he said we'd
know more once we lifted this rubble well as
you can see we have lifted half of it and there's this little scatter of
stones down there which has caused a little bit of a
disagreement between my colleagues what are those stones well we think it's a
post hole we think there's been a big timber in there and those stones are
the packing around it and what do you think that means
i think there might be a big timber building here that's underneath all the
stonework that we've got yeah but you're ignoring the radar go
on then where we put the trench in yesterday
yeah remember was on the magnetic noise we hadn't got the radar results at that
stage we then extended the trench because we'd got what we thought was a
central pier on the radar the big hole that phil
but the strongest evidence for stone footings are either side of this trench
so you're saying that rather than being a wooden building or a building with
wooden supports like mick saying it could still be a stone building
except we just haven't picked up those stone walls yet yes
i think there are other possibilities as well though because i mean we could have
had a timber building replaced by a stone
building or that a rubble that we've got could be
the platform for a big box frame building on big
you know 18 inch square timbers and then you still might have
a stone building which is you're saying we hadn't seen yet but we can get this
wall over here if we extend the trench that way can't we
i think we've got to do that because we've got to test
this theory see how quickly he moved away from his wooden building theory i'm
with you john he's right you wait and see you wait and
see if mick's right this could turn out to be a timber built
castle with stone supports in the meantime we're going to extend
phil's trench and look for any undiscovered stone walls
and in raksha's trench marianne is catching up on some of the many finds
from the previous day that may give us an idea of the date of
the site they've been bring away in trench too
there's some finds that are coming out there are some good finds and we're
actually very excited we are indeed this is what
looks like to be a medieval pin and would that have been used on
clothing yeah so it would have fastened i'm not quite sure if there there was a
class but it's definitely some kind of pin
fastening on on some kind of garment it's really
beautiful it's made out of copper alloy if you kind of move it around in the
sunlight you can almost see the gold gilding on it so very high
status fancy goods yeah but the exciting thing
is is it came out of what looks like to be a pit stroke ditch
um it's full of 12th century medieval pottery
pretty good start for day two isn't it
over in phil's trench we've been opening up a large hole
where we thought there could have been a central pillar but we haven't yet found
a base for it so we're digging deeper and deeper
it'd be nice to actually see where the bottom is
meanwhile alex is listening to farmer's tales about some large stones plowed up
many years ago on castle hill but andy's told me that you were up
here in the 1960s working down this land with the tractor is that right
yeah this was a hill that was non-productive agriculture so we thought
well you know let's have a go at putting a rotavator and try and reclaim it and
get a bit more agricultural use out of that
and then we got the plow up and there was these two big stones
and i could see they were going to be a nuisance they were going to break the
machinery so you know as a responsible person i just dropped
the plow and gently pushed them yeah out of the way so you just sort of
push them to the edge of the this steep slope here thinking you know
well no one will ever want to see them again and it's right the way so we can
play the field and then we turn up and all of a sudden these stones seem to
be quite famous and i can't find them if these stones weren't natural it's
further proof of a man-made structure on top of castle hill
so where do you think this stone came from then oh over there yeah in the
distance you can see the hamhill quarry all the the um the local stone in the
areas comes from that that quarry originally from hamhill
quarry right so potentially then if we've got the normans or later building
a castle up here that's the type of stone they'd
instantly go to yeah that's right and it's obviously
not that far right so maybe we should then think about going over there and
have a look and see what they've got and we should let you get back to your
alex and andrew head off to hamhill quarry to investigate this local source
of building material in the meantime mary ann's trying to
find out whether our pottery finds date from the main period of norman castle
building all the evidence is looking mid-12th
century but the norman invasion was 1066
it was and we do have a the majority of castle was built immediately after 1066
however in the middle of the 12th century you have
a period which historians call the anarchy rather evocatively yeah
we have a civil war between on the one hand king stephen
and his cousin matilda so these are grandchildren of william the conqueror
struggling for the throne and what it leads to
very quickly is a civil war that people have called the anarchy but
people have called the anarchy as soon as government breaks down as
soon as there is a civil war people start building castles
so there's rich men doing big building works but also this kind of idea of
forced labor constructing castles or fortifications
there's a rush to refortify one of the best illustrations of the way that royal
power collapses in the middle of stephen's reign in the
middle of the 12th century is the coinage the coinage had always been
since the 10th century one coin with the king's head on it and
that ran throughout all of the kingdom in stephen's reign
stephen's coins are only found in the east and the southeast
in the southwest where we are there are coins being issued for matilda
and you also get even individual barons issuing their own coin
so you have two sides competing for people's
affiliation and and fighting against each other so
there's always the possibility of extreme violence it's not a great time
to live and it's always the peasants who suffer
the sand is red so it's burnt there's a lot of burn in there and
there's actually quite a bit of charcoal in there as well
this means we could be looking for a lost anarchy period castle
rather than the conquest one it's too early to tell for sure
and in the meantime things seem to be getting ever more confusing
i really don't know you're so sort of convinced that it's a castle
i mean you know it's kind of oh it's a stone castle oh it's a wooden castle
what happens if it isn't a castle we're halfway through the dig
but are we any closer to solving the mystery of castle hill
hello remind me what is the date of the pottery that we've got up here
tony it's all mid 12th century nothing from the 11th century which means that
it can't be a 1066 conquest castle it has to have come
from this king stephen reign of anarchy and if it was an anarchy castle that was
put up in a hurry then that would explain why it's not on
the records because it would have been pulled down again really quickly once
the anarchy was over and also it's not to say that it wasn't
a massive timber structure because you know they've built it to mean it
but it also would explain why there wouldn't be documentary evidence
people weren't sitting down scribbling notes about what was going on where
it was a pretty chaotic time it's exciting the history and the archaeology
are actually fitting together which they don't often do do they
it's a great theory but will it stand up in a few hours time or will the
archaeologists have thought of something entirely
different we just have to wait and see won't we
it's the afternoon of day two in crewkern in south somerset
and we're digging up a large hilltop structure which we're hoping could be a
medieval castle evidence now suggests it may be a
timber castle dating from the anarchy period in the
12th century and a new find in raksha's trench may
help us confirm that raksha word is you've got a good find
the word on the street is correct i have this lovely horse riding spur
a spur yeah it certainly is isn't it yes if you
put it that way up the heel the rider's heel would be here
and then you would be goading the horse with that pointy bit there
any idea of a date well we're actually hoping it's 12th century because it's
come out of this massive pit that we're digging at the moment and all the potty
that's come out of it is 12th century so if it was then that too could be part
of the anarchy wars that's what we're hoping
where there are spurs there must have been horses
so does that mean somebody was keeping cavalry up on castle hill
we've got horses and we've got people spurring them we've got horsemen
the medieval french word for horseman is chevalier so we've got knights
and knights go with castles like ham and eggs you know so
this is good stuff the fact that we've got that spur and what does that mean
for how they're managing this landscape when when we're talking about castles in
this period they're functioning as cavalry forts
okay they're a place where you can keep um 30 40 100 men
horsemen and they can ride out from that castle and
control the area does that mean there should be evidence of more buildings
than just this central squarish tower we certainly expect more than
in a sense the tower is just the sort of pièce de résistance that's the
the the tower crowning the mound it's the lookout it's the symbol of lordship
but we're going to have to have places for knights to sleep
so a hall of some kind we're going to have to have places for horses
to sleep ie stables there should be a bit more evidence on the top i think
there should have been a fair few buildings on that hill
there could be more outlying buildings still waiting to be discovered up on the
hilltop and phil seems to be making a
breakthrough as he extends his trench to where
the first radar survey picked up signs of stone remains
now look that is looking a bit more solid isn't it
so it looks as if we've got a wall doesn't it phil the more
of it we see mick yeah the more it does look like a wall i mean when we first
got down on it yeah well you couldn't we wouldn't
really know whether it was just a block of
block of masonry or something like that but it's getting bigger and bigger
but what is it mick is it a wall phil ah but it might be a wall but is it a
castle is it a keep is it a hall is it a chapel even you know
could be any of those couldn't it you better go and ponder on these things
i'm pondering as i sit here phil so the story turns yet again
substantial stone walls means that the stone building theory
is winning out over the notion of a timber structure
there's not yet enough evidence to prove it's a castle but this digs not
over yet one thing's for certain building any
type of stone structure up on this hill would have required a massive
investment of manpower the best local source of stone is found
at ham hill quarry 10 miles up the road quarrying it and
transporting it in the medieval period was no mean feat
you've got here an enormous block of ham stone
you work in these quarries yes we do this is the stone that they're using to
build all sorts of buildings from the medieval
period right up to the present day is that right yes correct
what's it like to work um it can be very hard
it's it's not the best of stones it's you you've got to pick through it to
sort the best out um it suffers from clay beds and iron
faults but with modern technology you can cut
around the problem sort of thing so with modern technology
it's a lot easier it's a lot easier yeah what would it have been like in the
medieval period very difficult if you want to do you
want to show me some of the techniques they would have used they would have
used a pick similar to this we've been in here
as they got deeper down they would have different picks also with longer handles
so they could work in a more upright position
i guess it's time then i had uh had a crack at this
safety goggles on there you go here we go
right barely having any effect whatsoever here
and that that really isn't easy that
that's that's one pass through i've done there so that'll probably take me about
three weeks in that wood i think yeah let's just say theoretically then i
have worked out a significant block of stone
first you've got to get it out of the quarry face haven't you yes and you've
got a bit of stone over here a piece of stone here
with a bedding fault through it right shows you how you know how we could
how it would have been done how the natural bed is here yeah
and the stone here and they would have driven the chisels in along here to
split the stone on its natural bed should we have a crack at that you can
have a go if we want yeah but this is a two bloke job
yes one has to hit it one has to hold her so one's got to trust the other
so you're the quarryman should i i'll be i'll be chisel monkey
yeah he's gone in there now you see and now
right actually that's really smooth isn't it
so what we're going to do is i'm going to think about how we're going to get it
from here all the way to our site good luck rather
you than me alex that thing weighs a ton back on site we're digging even deeper
we had expected to find evidence of a large supporting pillar in the middle of
this trench but now the picture's looking very
different you got a bit of construction work going on here
yeah tony we've literally taken it down another layer
but we still haven't got the bottom i don't understand though
because you said that you thought that there would be a platform
for a big pillar about two meters down that is literally what we thought it was
going to be but i think we've got to scrap that
idea all we've got is this whacking great hole
that is filled up with with loose gravel why are you still going down
because we'd like to get to the bottom we really do want to know what it is
at the moment we haven't got the foggiest idea what this hole represents
but if you come over here i'll show you something that we do know about
look we've got a wall here and it's not just here it extends
right the way across this end of the trench john you must be chuffed this is
what you prophesied would be here this morning
yes so look this is where phil's got to there's a clear wall there
okay it's been robbed out at the end but there's no doubt there's another wall
that comes back on the far side we have got a stone building here ah
but is it a castle so now we're absolutely certain we've got a decent
size stone building here but we still can't be a hundred percent
sure whether it's a castle are the finds coming out of raksha's
trench able to add anything to our understanding of the site
so what you got there then paul a whacking great tripod picture it's
basically an enormous jug with little feet on the bottom
this is all the same pot and a lot of these sherds fit together as well
raksha's still digging it out oh good grief
as i was saying raksha's still digging it out
these things can be anything up to this high all right you know you've got one of
these it's a big round thing that's an awful lot of pottery
and what sort of date we're talking about it's looking from what i can tell
like late 12th into 13th i mean this sort of pottery starts in
the 11th we kind of get nicer quality as time goes on and this
is quite good quality is it the sort of thing you use for
cooking no i don't think so it's something that it's a jug so it would
but some of them join together already i'll get this cleaned up first time we
can then we can have a look dig more dig more
i'm trying it's really difficult promising finds with pottery dating from
the 12th and 13th century but we still don't know for certain if
we've got a castle here and now we've only got one day left
the wind up there i know it's a different world down here
with a day's digging and some heavy quarrying behind us
mary ann has prepared some medieval workers grub
what's all this then welcome to my medieval mead and cheese evening
kindly supplied by the lovely landowners that's very kind of you so where this
cheese come from then it's all local the bread the cheese the
mead fantastic mead what else are you drinking mead
he's gonna stab the mead workers can't be choosers
you remember three and a half hours ago we had that conversation
where we said we know exactly what this site is
yeah it's a temporary structure thrown up in the civil war
the reason there are no records for it was because it was made of wood so it
all was pulled back down again where are
you going with that john was right phil's just found a stone
wall up there that throws our theory out the window
completely we've only got a day to get to the end of this puzzle
by the end of which will we have a castle
to show the family or will it be something else it'll be a chapel
you think it'll be a chapel what do you think it'll be
cheers mate thanks very much
beginning of day three here on the infuriating castle
hill in somerset which adamantly refuses to give up its secrets easily
over the last two days at one time or another we thought we had a norman
castle up here a stone one a wooden one the fact is we
still know virtually nothing about it at all
it's all castles in the air isn't it mate no
what what we don't know anything i just heard you
whinging away coming up the hill there it's not a whinge it's an objective
statement no it's not come on then what do we know about it
how old is it how old is it well if it's a document it's mid-12th century
if if yeah yeah well we've got very few finds what shape is it
it's rectangular you don't know it's rectangular well
i think we do if that's what the geophysics is showing and we've got a
rectangular building of that so what's your strategy we're going to
put a slot in over there to get the other wall and we're going to put a
slot in over here to get the end why are you going to do that mate
to get the corners to us to prove it's rectangular because you don't know that
it's too early for all these cerebral activities get me a cup of coffee and
then ask me again all right i'll come back in an hour right
so we're going to extend phil's trench to the south and west
to search for the building's corners and see if it is indeed
rectangular as mick thinks it should be with a bit of luck this could give us
the clinching evidence for the foundations of a castle
if we give it another half bucket let's say out there
and then we'll maybe push on back a bit and matt thinks he may just have found
the western corner of the building's stone wall
it's increasingly looking like a castle keep
because i've just got the edge i think i might have the edge here can you see the
sand that's definitely there yeah and there's
the sand again so the corner it's right in front of you there like
this we'll remove this backfill well the
full length of the castle down at base camp paul's got some of the
pieces from the jug he found in raksha's trench
he's hoping that the high powered microscope will give us some clues as to
what it was used for the inner surface of the pot at the
bottom is quite degraded and apparently fermentation causes
pots with uh especially with limestone on the
for the inner surface to flake off the lactic acid in the fermented liquid
attacks the inner surface of the pot when you say fermenting liquids am i
saying beer oh almost certainly yeah that's telling us something about what
they were doing at the top of that hill i mean they were living there drinking
their beer out of their pitchers well they drank a lot of beer in the
medieval period it was it was safer than drinking the water is
you see documentary references to beer being referred to as liquid bread
um i mean it was a good source of calories as well as people drank anything
between four and eight pounds of beer a day
children as well lots of pictures then
with some skillful handiwork paul glues together the 28 shards of pottery
making up the side of this jug it had three little feet on the bottom
a spout and a handle on the top and probably dates from the 13th
century a good find but it still doesn't tell us
who these people were or what they were doing here for the
rest of the day the archaeology team really needs to get
motoring it's hard going but everybody knows this is our last
chance and matt just made another important
discovery matt this is a pretty weird looking
trench isn't it about nine tenths of it seems unexplored and it's just you
beavering away here well this trench was positioned here to find the southwest
corner of the structure and that's what we've
got if you look on the geophysics here we've got a strong corner behind us
there we've got the wall line over there
nothing much over here and so we thought well here ish
we'll catch it somewhere and we did we've caught it right on the
on the edge of the trench here so this is your western edge this is the
foundation trench we're digging it out have you got it where it turns
we have yes it comes along here and that is the southern edge there so the actual
corner of the building is just about there well
done you just got it just about that's the southwest corner of
the building found and in the southeast corner phil's
found a fascinating piece of evidence it's forcing us into yet another
rethink phil are we beginning to understand
what's going on here oh absolutely tony we are looking at the corner of the
building here's the outside corner just in front of us here and you can see the
outside line of the wall you go see it straight through
and you can actually see the edge of the foundation what just sort of
just a little bit in front of you is the edge there you go where you're
standing is the edge of the of the foundation trench
and you can see that line comes all the way through towards me
that is the end of the building can you get out of my trench i've cleaned that
please um so that is the outside corner of the
building the inside building is immediately in
front of where james is james can you show me where the inside of the building
is you know when you said in your po face
way like you always do get out of my trench please yes that was
just when i was coming to this stuff here what's all this
ah well there's a very strong possibility that that's
mortar that has squeezed out of the joints between the stones
as they're actually building the castle why didn't they clear it all the way
yes but that could mean that the the actual building was never
actually finished and the point of it is if you finish a
building you would tidy up all that sort of mud maybe they just
never finished it that's intriguing do you want me to get
a couple of bits of strings and tie them run
too late it's gone
an unfinished castle is an idea that the records seem to support
according to the historians this was nothing out of the ordinary during the
time of the anarchy we've got pottery late 12th century
we've got a massive stone foundation of one building and we don't hear of it
afterwards at all i wonder whether this is started and
unfinished it's not uncommon in actually for people to
start out with some grandiose idea dig the foundations then
political changes or changes in the family or whatever
exactly when you talk about the family with the red verse family
baldwinter redbeard dies in 1155 he's succeeded by a succession of short-lived
anything could have stopped the building program and just thought
we pack up shop so we've gone from a timber castle to a stone castle to an
unfinished stone castle chaps we've only got a matter of hours
how are we going to resolve this we just carry on digging you know we
carry on thinking about it i mean if we've changed our mind that
often in two and a half days who knows what will happen by the end of the day
about seven more ideas between almost certainly
so an unfinished castle is now our favorite theory
and we know it's a real historical possibility
let's get the tailgate on given how hard it's proved for alex to hack stone out
of the quarry it wouldn't come as any shock to him to
learn the castle was unfinished i've certainly never transported anything
quite as heavy as this no it's a fair weight isn't it so it should be fun
yeah let's see how we get on we've asked alex and andrew
to use a traditional means of transport to bring the stone to site
it's proving far from straightforward good boy robbie
large shire horses came to britain with the normans
these are heavy animals and need careful handling
after a couple of hours slogging it out on the roads there's still a fair way to
go let's hope they get back while there's
still daylight back on site it's been all hands to the
hey could you come back a bit longer just a little bit more to have a look
at but has it been enough can we say for
certain what type of building stood on castle hill
back in the middle ages this morning i gave mick a really hard time
about the fact that we hardly knew any more about this so-called castle
than we had done when we first arrived a couple of days ago so mick what do we
know i think we well we know the size of it
which you were whinging on about this morning which was
that's right i mean it in its long dimension it's
17 meters outside to outside and width 13 meters the actual thickness of the
walls is about three meters about three meters yeah the fact that it's
rectangular rather than square perhaps the 1170s something like 1180s
perhaps something like that in style terms
but i mean the other thing is that i i seriously doubt whether it
was ever finished actually why do you say that well there isn't
enough later material for for activity after
1200 you know there's no there's very little pottery and stuff like that
we don't have any bits of romanesque sculpture it's like as if they haven't
got that far yet with it what do you think the walls were made
of or would have been made of it must have been a stone built building i'm
sure it must have been a stone built building
it's not likely to have been timber framed and they must have been intending
for it to go quite a way one thing i think you can be sure about
it was that it was an incredible outlay of labor
yeah all this stone had to be brought up here
what about this huge pit thing that we've got yeah well i think
that's a well layer building there are very few keeps and
and stone towers on norman castles which don't have a well built into them
yeah and sometimes they are the most colossal engineering feats
you take somewhere like um bambara castle
in up in northumberland that we looked at there's a well there
that that is cut through the dolerite that i mean that rocks like steel
and yet they hacked all the way through it to get to the water table
does a well make sense to you well i don't see why not
you see that all adds strength to the idea that it was never finished because
we've dug it down three and a half meters and we haven't got any hint of
lining now i can't believe that if they'd have
lined that well completed it that they would have robbed out three
and a half meters of well absolutely isn't there one thing that blows your
1170 dating right out of the water go on we've found
13th century pottery on the site well we do but we don't have any much of
it and most of it seems to be a some sort of picture
i wonder whether that is not the refreshments for the people
demolishing demolishing isn't that special colluding well it could be but
it's the sort of thing that paul's coming out with there's not at all our
pottery there's not enough of it for occupation
so the mystery of castle hill has finally been solved
there was a castle here but it wasn't quite what any of us were expecting
it's been three pretty hectic days but i think we're finally ready to tell you
what is on top of castle hill it is a castle
but the surprise is though it was never finished
but the reason that it wasn't finished may simply have been that the family who
owned the land fell on rather hard times it might have just been that they
ran out of money and they didn't have anyone to take on the building project
but the truth is the size of the foundations is absolutely epic
three meter wide walls up to 80 feet high
imagine up there imagine what that would have looked like
if there had ever been a completed castle on top of it
from the foundations and walls we've discovered we can now tell what the
castle would have looked like if it had ever been finished the keep
would have measured 17 meters long and 13 meters wide
with three meter thick walls made of stone probably from the local quarry
it's very likely that the big mysterious pit in the middle
was a well that was also never completed and from some of the pottery
we know the unfinished castle was finally abandoned and torn down
in the middle of the 13th century an incredible amount of labor for the
men who brought stone to build the castle
only for it to be torn down again Alex Robbie
Tony we don't need it you don't need the stone
the castle never got finished can you turn around take it back again
no i cannot you don't need a stone for a rockery do you