Next Steps: • 💵 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ter.li/bvvnxk • 🏘️ Find a Ramsey Trusted Real Estate Agent - https://ramsey.solutions/i9wi7g • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
Brought to you by the Every Dollar app.
Start budgeting for free today.
>> Was I right to break off my engagement
because of long-term money issues and
bad spending habits? I've always been
disciplined with saving and planning for
money, but he struggled with
overspending and staying employed. Now
that he's moved out, I've taken on full
full financial responsibilities myself.
How can I stay on top of my bills while
saving and protecting my future?
>> Oo, that was like 20 20 things in one.
Okay. Well, we'll tackle the first part
first. So, um, were you right to break
this off because of red flags that were
not attended to that he clearly this was
a value you had?
>> And this is a value every woman has is
if I'm going to marry some guy, he's got
to be able to do at least two things.
Provide and protect. Right. That's the
reason why we find a mate,
>> primally speaking. And you're saying he
can't provide for the future. This was
red flags that this guy can't hold a
job. He's going to continually go into
debt, put us in a financial bind,
therefore I'm out. And essentially, he
opted out of this engagement by
continuing these habits that you made
clear. Am I hearing that right?
>> Yes, that's correct.
>> Wow.
>> I mean
>> I mean that's your choice. That's your
prerogative.
>> I say bullet dodged cuz this is it's
either this or a divorce later on. I'd
rather, you know, nip it in the bud
while we can.
>> Yeah. So many people I would really I
mean I wasn't there. I'm just going by
what you said, but based on what you
said, I would applaud you for it because
so many people
>> ignore red flags because you get so far
down the line, it's like, I can't turn
back now and it's kind of like a sunk
cost
>> scarier. They go, well, he'll change
once we're married.
>> Well, never going to happen.
>> Okay. Now, if he called into the show,
Briana, what would he say if he were to
defend his honor?
>> You know, I I I would say that he he's
always tried to maintain a job, but it's
just never worked out. Before I
previously knew him, he was employed for
seven years doing software sales. And
now he just can't ever since I got
together with him. He can't hold a job
just because the market's been so
unsteady.
>> And how long was the entire thing? How
how long was the dating and then the the
the engagement?
>> Um, total everything was about two and a
half years.
>> Listen, I think that's long enough to
get a a read on the situation. It's not
like this was super fast. I I think that
again I wasn't there but you made the
choice. You had enough time to see a
track record and you seem like your
thoughts are composed. So I'm going to
ride with you on this because
you are the one telling us your side of
it and it makes sense to me. Now he
could call in and say something
different but still at the end of the
day it's your choice. So
>> yeah, thank you.
>> So what's the second part of the
question?
>> Yeah. So I would like to be able to
better now that I've taken on I've asked
him to move out. I've taken on full
financial responsibility of like paying
our rent and then um while we were
together, I purchased a car um because I
was able to make up that payment with
having him here. Now that I have taken
>> Hold on, Briana. You went into debt
during the engagement.
>> Meet Every Dollar Budgeters Christy and
Steve. Their life is chaotic, but their
money is simple because they budget with
Every Dollar.
>> Budgeting with the spreadsheet took a
ton of time,
>> but now with Every Dollar, I can do a
budget in 5 minutes.
And tracking purchases is just as
simple.
>> It's so freeing to know exactly where
your money is going.
>> It just takes that stress out of the
day-to-day life. You got this, Hanigan
family. Every dollar. Create your free
account today.
>> Hold on, Brianna. You went into debt
during the engagement.
>> Yes. And that was primarily because he
kept telling me that I needed a new car.
>> What were you driving before? I was
driving a Nissan Ultima that needed
quite a bit of maintenance.
>> Got you. And what did you get? What did
you
>> I got a 2025 Mazda CX70.
>> What do you owe?
>> I owe about 50 on that.
>> Shoot.
>> What do you make?
>> I make about um about $100,000 a year.
>> That's a lot of car even for your
income.
>> Is that your only debt or you have more?
>> Um I have about uh 15 grand in student
loans and then I have like two grand in
credit card debt, but that's it. Okay,
here's my thing, Briana. I was really
team Briana, and now the more I hear
you, the more I go, I'm not sure you
believe in your own principles because
you wanted this guy to clean up his act
financially while you were an accomplice
to the crimes.
So, it's like, how am I supposed to take
you seriously if I'm the fiance going,
you really need to get better with your
spending habits and then I'm over here
financing a $50,000 car. You know what I
mean?
>> Yeah. Yeah. And it's difficult because
he drives a BMW X4M competition. So it
was just that is really difficult able
to get a nice car.
>> So you were trying to keep up with him
and it's his fault. But still lifestyle.
>> It does seem like though it was more Can
I I'm a ride on the fence on this. I I
hear what George is saying and he is not
wrong. Uh but the other part is I feel
like you were more on the why doesn't he
have a job regularly
>> side of things. Is that too
>> is the fact that it will this guy be
employed or will he be sitting on my
couch all day when I come home? Is that
Did I get that right?
>> Yeah. And that's kind of what it had
been before too. So that's why I had
asked him to move out.
>> Because to your I I am playing devil's
advocate here. I'm just I'm just letting
you know.
>> She got me riled up. That's all I'm
saying. She got a plank in her eye and
she's looking at the spec in his.
>> Because here's the thing. There are
plenty of people in the world who are
fine with debt. We know that. We don't
agree with that. But plenty of people
are like, "Yeah, I got my car note, my
credit card." For a lot of people,
that's not the problem. The problem is
when you have somebody who's not working
and seems like they might not be able to
hold a job and seems like they might be
a tad bit lazy. I could see how that's a
bigger red flag to you. Um, in the grand
scheme of things, that being said, you
can't be the what is it the pot calling
the kettle?
>> Black.
>> Black.
>> Yeah. No, I see both sides. I think you
were right to break off the engagement
and I think we need to accept a little
more responsibility that we weren't
quite the angel that we maybe made
ourselves out to be and he's the devil
here. I think both of you had bad money
habits. Both of you um struggled uh with
money moves and you were looking to him
to be a leader and guide you and he
couldn't do that.
>> He was in a place of weak weakness too.
And so it's hard to fault him for that
as much as I want to be like well this
guy's trash and you should I think you
both have some things to work on. Can we
agree?
>> Yes. No, I completely agree.
>> And I hope that if you if this is a
value you have, I want someone who can
provide for me. I don't think that means
I want someone who can float my
lifestyle no matter what and afford a
payment. I want you to reframe this and
go, how can I put myself in such a good
financial position? Then when I do meet
the right guy, we are building wealth
together instead of just making stupid
decisions together.
>> And there's part of this where if let's
say you, you know, you've you've broken
it off, you guys have gone your separate
ways. If it's meant to be, you could go
get back together. Like, you could give
him a that could have been the kick in
the butt that he needed to go out and
really show and prove who he's going to
be because the truth is you've just
never seen it. And it's hard to like you
want to see. You don't want all the
talking. You want somebody to be about
it.
>> I love that Jade is not giving up on
love here. Is there is there a shot this
could still work, Bion, or is this like
long gone?
>> You know, we have tried to make it work.
Um, we still like sometimes see each
other and stuff, but it's just I don't
see any motivation from him to want to
be better. Um, he's determined to get a
job that's been in the process of about
six weeks now, and he's still
>> Has he been doing any kind of work?
>> Um, no.
>> What's he doing all day?
>> I mean, you don't know.
>> I think you better cut it loose.
>> Yeah.
>> Well, the writing was on the wall,
Briana. And uh the good news is you're
going to be real busy cleaning up this
mess of your own for a while. And I
think you also we need to own up to the
fact that we made a lot of decisions
that were codependent and hinging on
someone we weren't married to.
>> I can make the rent as long as he pays.
I can make the payment as long as he's
in my life. And I think all of that is
why we tell people never combine
financial lives or for that matter
physical lives living together before
you're married. It just gets too messy
because this could be on the other side.
Mhm. And yeah, now you're going to now
you're going to feel that being the only
one covering that rent.
>> Yeah, I'm wishing you the best as as you
clean this up. Personally, I would sell
that car as soon as possible. I wouldn't
even work on paying it off. I would get
rid of it. There's no reason you you
need to be driving a $50,000 car walking
out of this mess. So, best of luck to
you, Briana. Create your free every
dollar budget today. The simplest way to
budget for your