Maytime (1937) is a lyrical musical drama that weaves together romance, music, and the quiet passage of time. Centered on a young woman torn between love and ambition, the film reflects on choices that shape a lifetime—and the memories that remain long after.
With its operatic performances and elegant storytelling, Maytime captures both the beauty of spring and the bittersweet nature of love that cannot fully endure. Rather than focusing on spectacle, the film offers a gentle meditation on devotion, sacrifice, and the enduring power of music.
We came to see the Andorra
Three boys, three girls
On the Pelouse, it's beautiful
And we'll dance in Andorra
In the sound of Castanets
Tell me, neighbor, if I'm good-natured
And if my bass doesn't go well this morning
Where can I find a fine size?
The girls say I'm good-natured
Barbara!
Oh, oh, Miss Morrison,
I think I'm going to cry.
Do you mind?
Oh, there, there, child.
It really isn't as terrible
as it seems, you know, here.
How can he be so selfish?
I have a right to a career.
All I want is a chance
to be a really great singer
like Tetrazzini or Jenny Lind
or Marsha Mornay.
Can you understand that?
Yes, I can understand,
but I can understand other things.
What other things?
I've never talked to you about myself,
have I, child?
No.
I don't talk to anyone, usually.
I'm going to talk to you
about myself now.
You see, I was Marsha Mornay.
You?
Yes.
It was many years ago.
I was very young.
It was a day like this
in Maytime.
I'm Rebecca Brannan.
I'm Tiffany Brannan.
Welcome to
Real Thoughts on Cinema.
Many classic film couples
are remembered best
for their partnership,
whether it was on the stage
or on the screen.
However, most of these duos
are immortalized
because of a real-life romance.
That's true,
but not all of them
were married couples
or pebble-sized items.
Classic Hollywood's
favorite screen sweethearts
were a pair of singers
whose real-life relationship
remains shrouded in mystery.
This pair of singing sweethearts
is Jeanette MacDonald
and Nelson Eddy,
whose tragic real-life romance
was mirrored by their greatest film,
Maytime, from 1937.
This is the story
of a young American soprano
who makes her debut in Paris
only to have to choose
between a life as a prima donna
married to her overbearing manager
or a life of true love
with the impulsive,
flighty young baritone
she has just met.
When she makes her debut
at the court of Louis-Napoleon,
Marsha Mornay is greeted
with great acclaim.
The same night,
a famous composer agrees
to write an opera for her.
Afterwards, her manager, Nikolai,
asks her to marry him,
and she happily agrees,
knowing his reputation
of asking for favors
from his female students.
However, when she feels restless
that evening,
she goes out on a carriage ride,
and in a café,
she meets this handsome
young baritone, Paul Allison,
who sweeps her off her feet.
Against her will,
she keeps agreeing
to meet with him,
and after only a few meetings,
they both feel a growing love
for each other.
However, she tells him
at a beautiful festival on May Day
that she's already given her word
to Nikolai,
so she must marry him,
and they must remember
this one day
to last them a whole lifetime.
However,
when they meet again
seven years later
back in America,
as they are starring
opposite each other
in an opera
written specifically for her,
they find that their love
has only grown stronger.
This film was produced by MGM.
It was produced by Hunt Stromberg,
directed by Robert C. Leonard,
and stars Jeanette MacDonald,
Nelson Eddy,
John Barrymore,
and Herman Bing.
Jeanette MacDonald
and Nelson Eddy
were two of the biggest stars
in their day,
but I would say these days
their names are not recognizable
to anyone except
the most devoted
of classic film fans
or someone who's really
into operetta music.
Yes, that's very true.
Unlike Fred Astaire
and Ginger Rogers
or Bogie and Bacall,
Spencer Tracy
and Katharine Hepburn,
they're not a duo
who's really recognizable,
but they made eight movies
during the height
of their fame at MGM,
spanning from 1935
to 1942,
which was the year
when they both
ended their contracts
at MGM.
Do you have any theory
on why you think
they're not as remembered?
Is it because their music
is more highbrow,
so maybe it's not as appealing
to a wide audience?
I think that's a good part of it,
and it's also because
they made their movie
so long ago,
with their last film
being in 1942,
and then neither one of them
made that many successful films
after that,
so their legacy
really ended much earlier
than many of those
other couples.
But despite that,
I think their films
are masterpieces,
which are so insightful
for what was happening
in America at the time,
and the music of the era,
helping to really introduce
operetta, but also opera,
to the United States.
Absolutely.
There were so many
Hollywood sopranos,
Jane Powell and
Catherine Grayson,
that sort of followed her,
but I feel like Jeannette
was one of the first ones,
and their films really
kind of began that trend
of having real opera in films.
Yes, because she often played
an opera singer
in their movies,
beginning with their second film.
She played an opera singer,
I think, more than he did,
even though he was
classically trained,
and she was not.
That's right.
But it works better
for the story, I suppose.
Jeannette McDonald
began her career
many years before
her partnership with
Nelson Eddy began,
but her partnership with him
really elevated her
to the status of superstar.
Yes, in the earlier days,
the early 1930s,
she collaborated with
such actors as
Maurice Chevalier,
they made several films together,
which were very successful,
but she really was elevated
by her collaboration
with Nelson Eddy,
and I think that's
really fascinating
to kind of see how
her screen image changed
by working with him.
Yes, she always was
a musical star,
even on the stage,
before beginning
to make movies,
and she would do
not exactly like
the latest hits of the day,
but she sang the music
of people like
Rodgers and Hart,
you know, more Tin Pan Alley.
She did a few
operetta-type things
in her first few days,
and she was known
as the lingerie diva
during her first few years
because this was during
the pre-Code era,
when films were very risqué,
often exploiting the figures
of the leading ladies,
and Jeannette,
who was known
for having good legs,
would often pose
in her lingerie
while singing
and doing other risqué things,
but in her films
with Nelson Eddy,
the lingerie part
began to be hidden
under many
beautiful period costumes
as she became
just like this opera diva,
although she really
wasn't operatically trained,
until years later,
in the 40s,
when she had more
opera training.
Yes, in the 40s,
she began to really want
to live up to
her on-screen image,
and she studied
with Lottie Lehman,
a famous opera singer,
and studied a lot
of Lieder,
and she ended up
playing both
Marguerite and Faust
and Juliet,
and Romeo and Juliet,
with some opera companies.
Which, interestingly,
were both operas
from which she did excerpts
in her early movies
with Nelson Eddy
and with other actors.
Meanwhile,
Nelson Eddy
often didn't play
an opera singer
in their films,
yet he actually
was an opera singer.
That's right.
He had a great
baritone voice,
and he was really
well-trained in opera,
even performing
in some real operas
before he came
to Hollywood.
with the Philadelphia
Civic Opera.
He had a repertoire
of 28 roles there,
some really big ones
in Aida,
and Marriage of Figaro,
some very famous roles,
Pagliacci,
and, interestingly,
he worked for 10 years
as a newspaper reporter,
so he had a very
interesting kind of
storied background,
and then, interestingly,
because she studied
with Lottie Lehman,
he had to take over
for Lottie Lehman
when she was ill
on a concert
to great acclaim,
and that was
how he got to Hollywood.
It was at the
Hollywood Bowl.
It was at the
Hollywood Bowl, yes,
and he got offers
from multiple studios
after that.
That was like 1933.
And he was a little torn.
He wasn't sure
if he wanted to go
into movies
because he really
wanted to focus
on concertizing,
especially.
That was his passion,
but he thought that
by being in movies,
he could kind of
advertise that in a way.
Yeah, he got the notoriety
to kind of propel
those concerts,
so he signed
with MGM,
and it was a couple
of years
before they knew
what to do with him,
and then beginning
in 1935
with Lottie Marietta
opposite Jeanette,
that really catapulted
him to stardom.
That was his first
feature film,
and his agreement
with MGM
was that he would
have three months
off a year
to go and concertize,
and he would always
put just classical music
on his concerts
and then sing
his hits from movies
as encores
because he wanted
to introduce people
to this great music.
Yes.
But I think
the greatest movies
they made together
were the ones
which incorporated
a lot of operetta
or opera music.
Maytime was the first
film they made together
in which he played
an opera singer.
That's true.
Or really a singer
of any kind.
Before that,
he was kind of
a law enforcer
in both their first two movies.
In Lottie Marietta,
he's a type of soldier,
and in Rosemary,
he's a mountie.
Right, and he sings
in both of them
just like a fellow
who sings.
In this film,
he's an aspiring
opera student,
and so he ends up
performing in an opera
near the end of the film.
We often like to
compare films,
especially very melodramatic
ones, to operas.
Yes.
But this one can't help
being compared to an opera
because it is so based
around the operatic world
but just the storyline of it.
It has the classic
Puccini melodrama
of love at first sight
and the man to whom
she's already given her word.
It's a brilliant combination
of both things
that you often see
on the opera stage
and things that go on
behind the scenes
in opera all the time.
The diva marrying her manager,
that's been going on
for absolutely years.
Yes.
It was a very common move
of many of the most
famous opera singers
to be married to their managers,
not only because the managers
often had more money,
but it was like a good
two-way business arrangement
because there was a lot
of money to be made,
so managers would want
to have some of that money
personally as well
as professionally,
and also,
the divas would hope
that their husbands
would care more about
their interests than a manager
who might try to steal
all their money.
Right,
and just to kind of have
someone to look out
for you in a way.
Yeah,
and if you have
a good marriage,
it's a good arrangement,
and if not,
it can end up
being rather bad.
Now,
we realized,
remarkably,
we'd never talked
about one of
Jeanette MacDonald
and Elsa Nettie's
movies yet,
and it wasn't a hard
decision to determine
which movie
we should discuss
because I would say
we wholeheartedly agree
that Maytime
was their greatest film.
And it was Jeanette's
favorite of all the films
she made.
She loved this movie,
and it's still
very widely acclaimed,
even though,
as you pointed out,
they aren't that well
remembered by people
who know.
People who have seen
this movie,
pretty much everyone
who's seen this movie
agrees it's brilliant,
and it has a 100%
approval rating
on Rotten Tomatoes.
That's very rare, yes.
Can't get any higher
than that.
I think one of the things
which contributes
to this film's greatness
is the fact that
there's another
really excellent
star in it.
Absolutely.
John Barrymore,
who played
her husband,
Nikolai.
And this is
really one of
his last great roles.
Yes.
This is five years
before his death,
and he was 55 here,
and if you compare it
to, say,
Grand Hotel
five years earlier
when he was really
his last great
leading man part,
by this point you can
see the effects
of alcoholism
quite a bit.
When we first watched this,
I really didn't know
John Barrymore.
I didn't know
who I ever saw
with John Barrymore.
Yes, I knew the name,
obviously,
but I hadn't seen
much of his work,
and I thought,
you know,
he's a little older,
but he looks good.
But yes,
knowing his earlier
career more now,
I was like,
it really is
kind of sad
how much he's aged.
But his talent
has not aged.
He's still brilliant.
And he put
that kind of bitter
alcohol-soaked
personality
into that menace,
that cold,
brooding menace
that Nikolai has.
Yes.
And going back
to the sort of
opera comparison,
it's kind of fascinating.
He's very much
like the baritone part
in an opera,
while Nelsonetti
is more like
the tenor part.
But because
John Barrymore,
only five years earlier,
was still a leading man,
he really has
more the energy
of an older tenor,
and that's even
more dangerous
than a baritone.
Like, maybe you can
get away with
cheating on a baritone.
If you cheat on tenor,
it's going to be in trouble.
It's like the story
of Pagliacci.
Yes, very much.
Where she's married
to the tenor
and then has an affair
with the baritone.
Now, speaking
about the music,
the fact that Nelsonetti
was a baritone
was both beautiful
and challenging
because most
of the great opera music,
and even operetta music,
is written with a tenor
as the leading man.
Exactly.
You can't just have him
go in there and sing
a duet from La Boheme.
It just doesn't work.
Because even if he could
technically hit the notes,
it would feel strained.
So as a result,
instead of having them
sing in unison
as a soprano
and tenor would,
he sings harmony
a third or so down.
Right.
And that way they were able
to keep many things
in the original key
or they would have them
go back and forth
and work in a clever
modulation to go
into a lower key
for him to sing it.
And you notice this
in several of their works
because the music
for most of their works,
at least primarily,
came from operettas
written by composers
like Zygmunt Romberg
did several of theirs.
Some of them
were Victor Herbert.
And the interesting thing
is how different
the source material was.
Like in this film,
for instance.
Yes, the source material
was a wildly
successful play.
It is the only show
to ever be playing
in two places
on Broadway
at the same time.
It was so successful
it opened another theater
on Broadway.
So there were
two simultaneous runs.
And it ran for hundreds
of performances.
Very successful.
The story follows
this wealthy young woman
who falls in love
with this penniless
young musician
and her father
won't allow them
to marry.
So she marries
another man
and then he goes away
for years.
I believe he gets married too.
And then years later
when they're both
much older,
both of their spouses
have died.
So they're still in love
but then still
their societal things
keep them apart
so they never
are able to be together.
But then
years later
his protege
and her
granddaughter
fall in love
and get married.
A little bit like
Wuthering Heights.
Yeah.
The only thing
that it really retained
was the title
and the title song.
Will You Remember.
The only Zygmunt Romberg
song that is left
in the movie.
Which isn't surprising
because there are
very few other songs
in this
that are really
anything other than
classical music.
Absolutely.
He sings that little song
about the prima donnas
kind of in a cafe.
Yes, he has three
sort of novelty songs
and one of them
is a song
all about
Virginia ham and eggs.
It's very clever
because it's a compilation
of a bunch of
really famous
opera melodies
which they put together
with new English words
and the whole
people on the street
get in on the chorus.
It's a very operatic
sequence.
It's very funny.
It's funny.
And then
she sings
excerpts
from like
every top
soprano part
from various voices.
Especially during
that seven year
montage.
Yes, it's a brilliant
montage and there's
so much opera
packed into that.
You see her singing
every role.
Beautiful costumes.
A lot of money.
They built 80 sets
for this movie.
Wow.
The biggest of which
was Louis Napoleon's court.
I was looking at that
and thinking
they had to have
filmed this in a palace.
Nope, they built that set.
You can tell they spent
a lot of money on it
but they made a lot
of money too.
It was really successful.
Definitely worth it.
And multiple
montage sequences
which are brilliantly
done by Slavko Vorkapich
and she sings
two full arias
in the film
as well as
excerpts from
others in the
montage.
And that would be
she sings
Les Filles de Cadie
which isn't from
an opera
but it's a very
popular
showstopper
kind of
plagiarized.
When she did
concerts
I was like
the number one
requested song.
Everyone wanted
her to sing that.
And then of course
she sings the page
aria from
Les Huguenots.
Yes.
Which is an actual
opera performance.
And it's beautiful
to see the way
they're replicating
opera of this era.
That's right.
And just making it
look fun,
dramatic,
glamorous.
Really encapsulating
the spirit
I'd say in a
very honest way.
It shows
the messy stuff,
the sacrifices,
the beauty,
the fact that
she's called
a prima donna
but she's playing
more minor roles.
They're not being
unrealistic enough
to have her playing
the lead in
Faust or something
when she's just
starting to be recognized.
Yes.
Even if they have
her doing a trouser part
where she's playing
a boy's role,
a page,
that's something
that you do
when you're starting
out in opera.
And it's very realistic.
I think they really
tried to show
that behind the scenes
look at the singer's life.
And this is interesting
in the production
of this film
and how it struggled
to get to the screen
because it was
the project
originally of
Irving Thalberg
who was the
boy wonder of MGM
but he died
during the production.
And Louis B. Mayer
had to kind of
figure out
how to finish it up
without him
and so Hunt Stromberg
took over
and they really
changed it.
They basically
just made a whole new movie
because it was going
to be in Technicolor
originally for one thing.
And Paul Lucas
was playing
the other part.
Paul Lucas was playing
the Nikolai part.
There are photographs
of early production
with like
Jeanette Nelson
and the costumes
are very different
but the whole production
was really,
really different.
And they had filmed
in Technicolor
the climax of the film
which was going to be
from act two of Tosca.
The confrontation
between Tosca
and the villain
a baritone role
of Scarpia.
That's so interesting
because
Fascinating.
And it gave her
an opportunity
to sing Visidarte.
Yeah, and for Nelson
to be playing
a villain like that
but that's what
baritones usually do
in opera
in the Verismo era.
Presumably the story
was very different
in a way that
that made more sense
and it's generally
agreed that
with the way
the story ended up being
it wouldn't have made sense
to have that
and unfortunately
that doesn't seem
to have survived
which is a shame
because that would be amazing.
Boy, would that be
amazing to see
Nelson Eddie as Scarpia.
And I bet he could
really bring the menace
but the interesting thing
is that
John Barrymore's
character Nikolai
really is like Scarpia.
Very much.
Now, in place of that
they had
an original opera
which was supposed
to be Zarezza,
this original opera
which Trentini
is commissioned
to write for her
right at the beginning
of the film
and it's set in Russia
but it's in French
and the fact that
they need a baritone
for the lead
is what gives
Paul Allison
the chance to reunite
with her in America
seven years later.
Brilliant, brilliant
writing there.
And the opera
is taken from
the first and second movements
I believe,
of Tchaikovsky's
Symphony No. 5
with French lyrics
put to it.
It was arranged
by Herbert Stoddart
and it was the first time
that an opera
was written
for a film.
But certainly
not the last.
No.
MGM would continue
doing that
and not just MGM,
Universal did it too.
That's right.
Tchaikovsky's
Symphony No. 4
is very prominently
featured with
Nelson Eddie
and Phantom of the Opera
from 1943.
Yeah, I would say
that was kind of
inspired by this.
Yes, definitely.
But it's so brilliantly
done here.
The fact that someone
wrote these
original French lyrics
is so impressive to me
and the melodic lines
of that symphony
are some of Tchaikovsky's
most beautiful
works of opera singing.
Because it can be
really comical or goofy
to have people singing
instrumental music.
There are countless
examples of lyricized
versions of the Nutcracker
which show just how
stupid it can be.
But you can believe
this is an opera.
Yes.
It's really good.
I think because
they took the themes
and then rearranged it
or Herbert Stoddart did.
So I don't think he'd
just tie them too
stuck in the box
if you have to sing
every note of the symphony.
That would be unnatural.
But that love theme
from it was also
made into a popular song.
Moon Glow?
Moon Love.
Moon Love,
which Frank Sinatra recorded.
And so it lends itself
to being sung very well.
Yes.
So you mentioned
the Nutcracker
and the 2010 movie
of the Nutcracker,
the same theme is used
as a vocal piece.
So it works well
for singing.
But definitely
the best here.
This is the best use
of this as a vocal piece.
And it's unusual
that they chose
to write it in French
because a lot of times
later ones,
they'd write it in English.
But because it's in French,
it's even more believable
and so realistic
because although
it was an Italian composer,
Trentini,
it was in France.
And if it were
for the Paris Opera,
it definitely would have
been written in French.
And I think
in the world now,
you know,
we're so concerned
about having subtitles
and that sort of thing.
Yes.
This is such a brilliant
example of storytelling
without knowing
what words they're saying.
And how opera was
used at the time.
Yes.
They didn't use
subtitles.
They made it simple enough
that even though
you come in right at the end,
it's the final scene,
you know exactly
what's going on
just from seeing it visually.
You don't have to understand
French to know
what's going on.
I know you can understand
a few of the words.
But even without that,
if I had no idea
of anything they were saying,
which I mostly don't,
you really can see
exactly what's going on
and it mirrors
what's happening
in their real story
at the time
so beautifully.
And then John Barrymore,
he doesn't have any lines
in this part,
but they just show him
in the wings several times
and it's very...
He gives an extremely
nuanced performance
as definitely the villain.
I mean, you can't...
I saw someone in a review
refer to him
as an anti-villain
which I thought
was actually...
Yeah, because...
...very accurate.
Deep down,
he is the husband,
kind of like
the wrong husband,
but he's sinister.
From day one,
he's sinister.
You kind of get a feeling
like maybe it's not
a good idea to marry him
like she had maybe
one chance
to safely get away from him
when he proposed.
And she said,
you have only
to say yes or no.
But once she said yes,
he was going to
hold her to that.
And she underestimates
just how much
brooding menace there is.
And sometimes,
there are moments
in the film
where it's like,
she seems so calm.
Can she not tell
he's just like
crazy with jealousy?
But I think
it's the kind
of relationship
where she's gotten
so close,
and especially
at this point,
they're married.
She's been with him.
He's been this presence
in her life
for so many years now.
She can't see
kind of past
her relationship
with him.
And she sees him
as sort of like
a protector to her.
So I think
in a situation like that,
a lot of times,
you have to kind of
get away from the person
to fully appreciate
how crazy he is.
And so she just
doesn't think
he's quite as manic
as an audience member.
As an outsider,
you can see
how it's just
bubbling underneath.
And he does it
so brilliantly.
And there's a moment
which always stood out
to me from him
that really puts
this performance
on a whole other level.
And it's during
this opera sequence.
There's a moment
where she has
this sort of reflex action
that she touches
Paul's hair.
Definitely not
something they were
staged to do.
And you see her
maid kind of looking
at Nicolai like,
oh, did he see that?
And he just,
he gets this kind
of pained look.
And then he makes
you feel for him
in that moment.
It would be very easy
to not feel
for this character at all.
Yeah, because he is
the bad guy.
You're rooting
for this couple
even though you know
you shouldn't
because she's married
to another man.
So either she's
going to get divorced
or they're going
to have an affair.
And that's not good.
She had the opportunity
to marry him first.
She didn't take it.
So now anything
they do will be
the wrong decision.
But in that moment,
you realize he loves
her very deeply
in his own
possessive,
manipulative,
evil way.
And that he just
feels so betrayed
because earlier
they give you
all the insight
into their relationship
when you see
they've been married
seven years.
They're checking
into this hotel
in New York.
And she's just
so dead inside.
She's so tired.
And it's not...
He thinks it's just
how she's worn out
from being an opera singer
and she's tired
of being in the limelight.
And he just kind of
figures that's who she is.
She doesn't really
have that much to give.
She's just all
about her career.
And then he kisses her
very passionately
and she just acts
like it didn't even happen.
And she's a little
cruel in that moment.
And he's like,
oh, I should have
forgotten that excites
you even less
than anything else.
And he doesn't like
how she treats him
but he kind of
has resigned
to the fact that
that's just who she is.
But when he sees
her being that tender
with this other man
he realizes it's not
that she can't love anyone
she just doesn't love me.
He sees his passion
and then when he realizes
that is what has been
between them
all this time.
Yeah, that she was
always in love
with this man.
Always thinking of him
when she was married to him.
So that's really
what motivates him.
And it brings the drama
just to that next level
because they usually
have some barrier
between them as sweethearts
whether it's she's a princess
in the first movie
or he's hunting down
her brother
in the second movie
or all sorts of things.
But in this one
it's the only time
where she's married
to another man.
There's this
next level love triangle
and it's handled
so delicately
and so beautifully
with such great
moral messages
as well as
operatic drama
which honestly
opera has too.
People often focus on
the numerous affairs
in opera
but they overlook
the fact that it always
results in somebody dying
showing that the wages
of sin are death.
Absolutely.
There are very strong
messages in opera
and this continues
in that tradition.
I'd say making it
more operatic
than the operetta was.
Yes.
It's more like
a movie opera
if there could be
such a thing
with that level of drama.
This film
really cemented
and created
their reputation
as the singing sweethearts
which was a nickname
they would have
for the rest
of their careers.
Yes.
It became kind of
a hallmark
of all their films.
They always find
some way to sneak
a little reference
to that in there.
It comes from
during the most
beautiful moment
the May Day scene
when they're
enjoying the festival
they're so happy
and in love together
and that's the one day
that's going to last
them their whole lives
and then
to culminate it
it's this beautiful scene
under a tree
with the flowers
and it's just so lovely
and as vibrant
and springtime
as a black and white
scene can be.
As a matter of fact
in the original prints
those scenes
were tinted pink
but unfortunately
there's currently
no copy of that
survived.
All the flower petals
were tinted pink.
I'm sure with
modern remastering
they could find a way
to tint that again.
It would be nice.
Yeah it would be nice.
But the main song
which is called
Will You Remember
the only Zygmunt Romberg song
it starts with
sweetheart
and he says
oh this song
is about sweethearts
you see
you're mine
only in the song.
So that became
they were always called
sweethearts
and then to the point
that two films
after this
it was called
Sweethearts
and they actually
played a married
singing team
who star in the show
Sweethearts.
They overused
the term
sweethearts so much
in that movie
it's like
the sweethearts
of sweethearts
in Sweethearts.
It's a bit heavy handed.
But they would
continue to make
reference to
sweethearts
in trailers
and in dialogue
even re-lyricizing
songs to throw it
in there
because that's
where they were
the sweethearts.
Part of the beauty
of this film
and it's
operatic style
is the historic setting
as it begins
in the court of
Louis Napoleon
and it has
gorgeous costumes
from the mid to late
Victorian era
and the late
19th century
first with full
hoop skirts
and then later bustles.
My costume
is based on
a gown
which Marcia wears
when she goes
to a rehearsal
at the opera house
in New York.
It's a very
beautiful
what was called
a walking suit
at the time
because it had
two pieces
and she has
the bustle
signature of the era
and a lot of fur
on her outfit.
She often wears
a variety of
different hats
and beautiful jewelry.
The film begins
at the end
of the story
when an elderly
Marcia gives
advice to another
young singer.
My outfit is
inspired by her costume
a simple
light dress
for the May Day
festival
with a long
but straighter
skirt
signature of the era
and little bows
in her hair.
I think that
in many ways
Nelson and
Jeanette's
screen partnership
has been
almost overshadowed
by the
controversy
about their
personal lives.
The rumors about
were they in love
in real life
did they
did he
propose to her
did they have
an affair
and the fact that
they both ended up
getting married
to other people.
It's all very
confusing.
Honestly you hear
so many different
accounts.
I mean if you read
like on Wikipedia
it's like 100%
they had an affair
and she'd like all
these miscarriages
that she had
were from him.
But it's just
if like everyone
has a different
story on it
it's one of those
things a little bit
like Margo Fontaine
and Rudolf Nuryev.
Nobody knows
exactly what the
relationship was.
And their personal
comments on it
were also different.
I think it's pretty
undisputed that
Nelson was madly
in love with
Jeanette McDonald.
And he did propose
to her.
And he did propose
to her.
That's a known fact.
So at this time
this was around the
time that she had
announced her
engagement to
Jean Raymond
whom she ended
up marrying
shortly after.
So I think that
we know enough
to say with
a good deal
of certainty
that the situation
that happens
at least in the
earlier part of
this movie
is pretty close
to real life.
They met.
They were in love.
He wanted to
marry another
man whom she
no doubt
well at least he
didn't love her
the way Nelson
did.
We're not sure
how she felt
about Jean.
Yeah.
They're bearing
reports about
their relationship
too.
We don't know
exactly how she
felt about
either of them.
But I think
that there's
a certain magic
they had
which you know
comes from
what Nikolaj
calls in this
film a living
emotion.
Brilliant description
then because
starting out in
their first movie
Nelson had
not done
this kind of
just plain acting.
He had acted
as a singer.
And back then
they didn't do
that kind of
passionate staging
in opera.
No.
And while you
do see him
acting brilliantly
in his few films
that he made
without her
there is
something
you can see
more with
certain performers.
Some people
it's like this
person is just
such an actor
he can make
it happen with
anyone.
And some people
you see
it's different
depending on
who you're with.
And that's so
true especially
from him.
Yes.
I mean you see
something special
coming from her
too.
She's on a
different level
when she's
with him.
But it's
even more
from him.
And you
just see
the Zaritsa
sequence,
the climax
of the film
is so
striking to me
because you've
got like
three layers
of emotion
happening there.
There's the
drama of the
onstage characters
who are in
a tragic love
story.
The drama
of the
characters
who are
playing them,
Paul and
Marcia,
in a tragic
love story.
And then
Nelson and
Jeanette's
personal feelings
beyond that.
And there's a
moment when they
just show him
looking at her
coming down the
stairs and he
looks like there
are tears in
his eyes and
it's just so
beautiful.
And there's
just always an
energy between
them when you
see them on
screen together.
And I think
that is what
kind of sets
their films
apart.
Because as
we were
discussing,
not every
famous
partnership had
the same
kind of
relationship.
Fred Astaire and
Ginger Rogers,
they were just
colleagues and
friends.
Or Lauren
Bacall and
Humphrey Bogart,
they were
married.
But there's
something about
the, not
unrequited
exactly, but
the romance
that didn't
work out.
They weren't
actually together.
never publicly
in a
relationship.
So although
the studio
seemed to
enjoy
kind of
hinting at
calling them
sweethearts,
they couldn't
go too far,
especially
because they
both were
married after
a certain
point.
So it's
really interesting
to see that
and to know
that to
some degree
they definitely
were in
love and
that their
tragic,
unfulfilled
love story
is represented
in these
movies.
And this
film was
sort of
their mayday
because this
was their
last film
before she
got married.
That's
right.
Why do
you think
this movie
is a good
one for
modern audiences
to watch?
I think
that for
anyone who
is interested
in discovering
their screen
partnership,
it's their
greatest film
and a
perfect
introduction
to what
they did.
I think
that it
would be
great for
anyone
who loves
opera,
operetta,
classical music
because it's
such a
tribute to
that.
And if
you are
an opera
fan,
you'll
recognize
so much
wonderful
opera music.
If you're
a fan of
1930s
Hollywood,
you'll
see some
of the
greatest
character
actors of
the day
and this
combination
of the
rising stars
of Jeanette
Nelson
alongside
the falling
star of
John Barrymore.
But for
someone who
maybe hasn't
really seen
a lot of
old movies
or isn't
necessarily
into it,
I think
that this
movie could
really
introduce you
to several
concepts and
maybe kind of
get you
interested in
them.
The drama
of old
Hollywood,
the grandeur,
because I
think a lot
of people
think old
films are
maybe a
little
fluffy,
a little
silly.
I've heard
people refer
to these
movies as
like comedies.
Their movies
weren't comedies,
because a lot
of them end
in death.
They were very
dramatic, even if
they have
plot-free endings.
Some of them
were definitely
lighter than
I would only say
two of them
really could
be called
comedies,
and certainly
not this one.
The movies
by Robert
Z.
Leonard,
because he
directed four
of their
films,
are far
better than
the ones
directed by
W.S.
Van Dyke,
to me.
But those two
directors directed
all their films,
and you see
very different
styles.
And there's a
whole study you
could do just
on the
differing styles
between those
two directors
and the
different
composers.
But I
think if you
think that
old movies
maybe were
all happily
ever after,
fluffy,
funny,
silly,
you'll see
with a movie
like this,
how dramatic
it could be,
and the
inclusion of
the great art.
So anyone
who appreciates
classical art
history will
appreciate this
film.
You don't have
to be a huge
opera fan to
like it,
because they
give you just
the right amount
in small doses,
interspersed
with dialogue
and other
things to
keep the
action going.
And I just
have to note
that I was
looking at the
reviews of
this film on
IMDb.
And usually,
especially if you're
looking at classic
films, you've got
a lot of people
saying like,
oh, you know,
old movies are
cheesy or boring
or whatever they
say.
They were all
so positive.
I remember
saying, this film
makes me cry,
it's so beautiful.
And one that
kind of stood
out to me was
a lady who
said, even
my husband,
who can't
stand Jeanette
McDowell and
Mel Sneddy,
will sit down
and watch this one.
So even if you
don't like them,
you might like this one.
So I would
definitely recommend
it to anyone
who wants to
see the musical
melodrama of
old Hollywood
and get an
introduction to
these two
great singing
stars, the
singing
sweethearts.
And I try not
to throw this
around too
freely, but I
think I would
say this is a
perfect film.
Yeah.
Definitely.
It's very
readily available.
You can rent
or purchase it
on Amazon Prime
Video, on
YouTube, on
other streaming
services, and it's
available for
purchase on DVD
at Barnes &
Noble, Amazon,
Walmart, both as
a single film and
as part of a
collection, which
there are two
volumes of the
Jeanette McDowell
and Mel Sneddy
collection, each a
four pack.
Jeanette and
Nelson's films
really constituted
their own genre,
popularizing the
operetta format
in films.
Similarly, famous
director Frank Capra
really created his
own genre of
films, an
inspirational type
of movie really
based around the
truths and freedom
of the American
way.
Join us next time
as we talk about
one of his most
powerful and
lastingly relevant
films.
Thank you for
watching.
Goodbye.