Hillary Clinton's Full Interview With Foreign Policy’s Ravi Agrawal at Doha Forum 2025 | AC1G

Hillary Clinton
2 followers
#HillaryClinton #DohaForum #USPolicy
Hillary Clinton sat down with Foreign Policy’s Ravi Agrawal at the Doha Forum for a wide-ranging conversation on President Trump’s new U.S. security policy, global power shifts with China and Russia, the Ukraine war, the Israel-Gaza conflict, and the future of the Democratic Party.
Hillary Clinton, Doha Forum 2025, Ravi Agrawal, Foreign Policy interview, US security policy, Trump administration policy, China US relations, Russia US tensions, Ukraine war analysis, Israel Gaza conflict, Middle East politics, Democratic Party strategy, US elections 2025, global diplomacy, international relations, geopolitical analysis, world news, DRM News, political interview, breaking news
And now we can start.
Secretary Clinton, welcome to the show.
Thank you so much, Ravi.
So let's start with something in the news.
The Trump administration just dropped its national security strategy.
What do you make of it?
Well, I think it's fair to say that I'm still digesting it.
There is a very clear message from the strategy that was issued
that the United States is taking a very big turn
away from the kind of alliances that have been the hallmark of our foreign policy
and I would argue our real strength in influencing events in the world.
So if you look at it, there's a very strong indictment of Europe.
And in particular, the openness of Europe and the composition of the population of Europe.
And that, to me, is an unnecessary division between us
and countries with whom we have a lot in common and a lot that is necessary to our security.
The sort of updating of the Monroe Doctrine that goes back to a very early president of ours,
James Monroe, about dominating the Western Hemisphere,
is something that is going to be very difficult to pull off.
And we're watching the administration with its buildup of military power and its use in the
region and wondering where that will lead.
But in general, it raises more questions than answers about what actually will be done
to implement these kind of very broad statements that are found in the strategy.
So if a lot of that is in theory,
let's just talk about what we've seen so far in the last 11 months.
When you look around the world,
what is your sense of the impact Trump has had on his second term on countries around the world?
Well, personally, I am quite concerned about the impact because there has been a very heavy
emphasis on moving away from what I think are core American values in a number of ways.
And that's not to say that there haven't been some success.
Can you describe those values? What do you mean by that?
Well, for example, supporting Russia's invasion of Ukraine, both in an affirmative way by
very rarely criticizing Putin for the brutal war that he has waged on the Ukrainian people,
and then attempting to try to coerce the Ukrainians into accepting a negotiated ceasefire
and peace deal that would be, by any objective measure, leaving them vulnerable to further
Russian activity. Remember, Russia has been in Ukraine since 2014. So this didn't start in 2022.
So I think that there's a lot that needs to be reviewed and looked at from the perspective of
what are the long-term consequences. And I just find that very often it's difficult to wrap your
arms around what is the objective. If it is to cause disruption and hope that that will lead
to a better outcome, I've seen a lot of disruption, but we're still not yet at the
point where we see what the actual effects will be. So take a couple of quick things.
I very quickly supported the 20-point peace plan to bring about the Gaza ceasefire and gave the
president and his people credit for getting that terrible war to finally end. But it's a 20-point
peace plan that takes an enormous amount of work and effort and diplomacy and negotiation
and carrots and sticks to make sure you get all the parties around the table and try to figure
out how to move forward with it. That's where we'll really find out if that is going to stick.
I already mentioned Ukraine. I think it's a terrible position for the United States to
be in. I was thinking 35 years ago, another dictator invaded a neighbor, namely Saddam
Hussein, crossed the border to seize parts of Kuwait. And the world rightly reacted because
you cannot reward that kind of aggression where efforts are made to literally invade your neighbor
and seize territory claiming that by some theory it belongs to you. So the world reacted,
Saddam Hussein was obviously pushed back. In this situation, Putin is intent upon taking as much of
Ukraine as he can. I think we could have played, both in the Biden administration and now in the
Trump administration, a much more assertive role in trying to help Ukraine continue to do the very
heroic job it's doing, defending itself. With China, if you look at the national security
strategy, there's a lot of very important points about economic competition. And we also,
though, have to recognize that along with the economic competition, there's a strategic
competition with China in the region. And the buildup of the Chinese military assets are ones
that pose a direct threat, first and foremost to our allies in the region, but then also to the
United States. So when you look at diplomacy of any kind, whether it's trying to end a war or
trying to prevent a war, deter your adversaries, there has to be so much follow-up. And there is
an aversion within the administration to the kind of work that is done by foreign service officers,
diplomats, others who are on the front lines trying to fulfill these national security objectives.
And there's a very small group around the president who he trusts to do all of this.
And I think in many ways, that is just not adequate for the complexity of the problems we face.
You know, but part of the criticism that the Trump administration has often had,
say, for example, of the Obama administration or even the Biden administration was that
there was too much of all of that stuff. And so they claim that they right-sized the China
strategy, which was a direct critique of the Obama years. And in a sense, there's bipartisan
agreement in the United States. I'm not saying that's right, but there is, that we needed a
different approach to China. Look, I think that there's a lot to critique in any presidential
administration. But I think that there's also a lot to learn from any presidential administration
about what works and what doesn't work. For example, I recently saw an analysis of peace
agreements, which ones actually stick and how you get to them. And, you know, obviously in the 90s,
there was the Good Friday Agreement in Northern Ireland. There was the Dayton Agreement in the
Balkans. And so I know how much effort went into actually getting those agreements made.
And in the case of Northern Ireland and in the case of the Balkans, what it took to demilitarize,
decommission the weapons of the combatants, all of that, that is the boring, hard work
of actually achieving diplomatic success. And I think there's a lot to be said for the kind
of dramatic and bold action that we see from this president. But that standing alone is not
sufficient. It may be necessary to get the world's attention, get the party's attention,
get something done in the immediate effort to show progress. But then you've got to do
all of that hard work. So it's not either or. You know, when I think about the kinds of
diplomacy that I saw, you know, in the 90s, that I saw when I was in the Senate, that I was part of
in the Obama administration, there are a lot of tools in the toolkit. And among those tools
are soft power development, which we have unfortunately decided is not going to be a
prominent tool in how we try to, you know, influence people, persuade them. China's filling
that gap, particularly in Africa. So it's, you know, to me, you don't get into office and say
everything that was ever done going back to the founding of the country was wrong, and we're going
to, you know, do it differently. You say, hey, I've got a different style. I've got some different
ideas. I'm going to learn from the past. I'm going to apply what works. And then we're going to go
from there. That just makes sense to me. And I worry that we are, you know, shutting a lot of
doors, cutting off a lot of our allies, and not learning some of those lessons right now.
So I'm going to come back to Trump and also the future of the Democratic Party.
I want to talk about you now. You've been in the news this past week for some comments you made at
an event in New York organized by the newspaper Israel Hayom. And I'm going to paraphrase here,
but you said that smart, well-educated young Americans are getting their news from social
media and from TikTok. And you went on to say that this is how they're learning about what
happened on October 7th and then what happened in Gaza in the months that followed. And it appears
that this was a broader lament on your part about declining support among Americans for Israel.
That comment has generated a lot of controversy, and it's led Congressman Ro Khanna, for example,
to point out that I don't think the answer is to disparage the intelligence of young people.
It's been a few days now since you've said that. How are you reflecting on
your words and the controversy around it? Well, I think it is a provable fact that most
Americans and an even bigger percentage of young Americans get their news from social media. If
that is controversial, then people are not paying attention to how... Is that a bad thing?
I don't know if it's a bad thing, but I think it's an incomplete... Well, let me rephrase this.
They should be listening to you, Ravi. I mean, obviously. People do listen to me for what it's
worth, and I am also on Instagram and TikTok. But I guess the broader point here is that if
Americans are shifting in their views about Israel, and poll after poll shows that that is the case,
that is based on some information that they're getting not just from social media, but also
from very reputable journalists operating in the region, also Palestinian journalists in Gaza.
Why is that not accurate? I'm not saying it's not accurate. I am saying that in... I teach at
Columbia University, and I teach a course called Inside the Situation Room. And so it's a very
large course. I co-teach it with the Dean of the School of International and Public Affairs.
And so I've had many, many conversations with very smart young people, not just Americans,
but literally from around the world. It's worth pointing out that Columbia,
of course, has been a center of some protest and action on this issue.
And it was. And I talked to students there. I've talked to students elsewhere.
And in talking with them about their views, they were certainly entitled to those views,
based on whatever information they had. But they did not always know why they were saying
what they said. And all I'm asking for is that people have a historical context,
both for what has happened to the Palestinians and what has happened to the Israelis, because
we are not going to implement the 20-point peace plan or any other peace plan unless people come
with some sense of historical perspective and empathy about how we're going to move
people toward what I still believe is the only realistic outcome, a two-state solution.
And we're not going to get there if people, you know, when they say from the river to the sea,
and you say what river and what sea, and they don't know, which has personally happened in
conversations that I've had. I just, you know, but this is a larger issue, because even on other
matters in this class that I teach, we are not doing a good job teaching history. We're not
giving young people the kind of context that I think they need to be decision makers.
But with all due respect, and I can't gauge how well young people grapple with history,
but what I can speak to is they're grappling with the here and now. And they are witnessing
images that are live streamed, that are coming out every day, you know, and yes,
there is misinformation and disinformation, but a lot of it is real. And I think there's a genuine
anger in the United States and around the world that some of that anger is deflected.
But Ravi, I'm angry about all of the human rights abuses. I'm angry about all of the excessive use
of force. I'm angry about, you know, what happened on October 7th in Israel and what
happened in Gaza. I'm angry about what Russia is doing in Ukraine. I'm angry about Sudan.
I'm angry about the Eastern Congo. I mean, I think we should be all looking at the tragedies
and the conflicts that are bringing about so much suffering and be dealing with them. That's why the
national security strategy is not to my liking, because I think the United States has an important
role in trying to resolve these conflicts and alleviate the suffering and give people
a chance to have peaceful, prosperous lives. That should be our goal. That is in America's
interest. I don't care where in the world you are. So, of course, the suffering in Gaza is
horrific. Full stop. Suffering everywhere is horrific. So, let's look at what we can do to
try to resolve, you know, what is being done to people in so many different settings right now.
And I think that the emphasis on one terrible conflict sort of doesn't do justice to the
challenges that we are confronting. And I don't want to see my country basically say, you know what,
you know, those other presidents, they tried to resolve conflicts. They tried to stand for
democracy and freedom. They stood up for human rights. What a waste of time. That is, to me,
an abdication of leadership. And I want to see us involved everywhere trying to stop
the kind of horrible abuses that are going on.
I'm with you in all of that. I think the argument we often hear, of course, is that
America has a different role in the Middle East. Of course, it supports Israel and therefore is
complicit to a degree. But I want to draw a line from all of this to 9-11 and America's
misadventures after 9-11 and the war in Iraq, the war in terror. And one could make the case
that at some level, America has been unable to maybe curb Israel in this particular case,
or even impose its will and talk about values and rules and norms and conflicts around the world,
in part because it too has skirted rules and norms in several instances in its history.
Is it your sense now that we're entering a world where the rules and norms don't matter as much?
And what can the United States do? Look, I think it's an interesting analogy because
when a country is attacked, and as you know, I was a senator from New York on 9-11. So
I was deeply involved in dealing with families who had lost loved ones, dealing with the people
who had been grievously injured, dealing with the, you know, horrible cleanup and everything
we had to do in lower Manhattan. That is a traumatic event. And people don't always make
the best decisions post-traumatic events. You have to understand that. And I'm not sure that,
you know, that was well understood after 9-11 in American decision making.
And I think you can see other examples of that, obviously. That's part of the reason why we
established all of these norms and laws after the Second World War. You know, when you talk about
how the, you know, the rule of law, how the expectations of militaries in combat are supposed
to be judged, all of that was an effort to try to construct a system that could rein in bad leaders
like Vladimir Putin who wants to dominate and destroy his neighbors, leaders who are traumatized
by horrific events and therefore lash out and may not be, you know, restrained in acting the
way that they should. That's part of why we constructed this whole system. To move away from
norms and laws in the international system will only benefit the worst actors in the
international system, whether they are heads of state or criminal cartels or whoever.
So, I really believe it's a mistake for the United States not to be upholding all those
rules. Does that mean we're always going to follow them perfectly? No, nobody ever has.
But we need not just to give lip service to them, but to try our best to set examples to,
you know, be a nation of laws, not men, as the saying goes. And it will be, the world will be
much worse off if the United States retreats from that position. You know we have a big dispute
going on right now over the bombing of these fishing boats. Off the coast of Venezuela.
Yeah, in the Caribbean and the Pacific. And there has not been an adequate showing. You know,
I was on the Senate Armed Services Committee and the Bush administration, which I did not
always agree with, you know, we would require them to come up and explain things and provide
information in the Obama administration. You know, even in the most secret negotiation,
in the situation room I was ever involved in, the decision to go after Osama bin Laden,
the leaders of Congress were briefed on that. So, there were norms, there were rules, there were,
you know, both legal and kind of moral expectations. I'm sure you get asked this all the time,
where is Congress today? Well, the Congress has abdicated its responsibility and it's very
sad to me because no president likes to be questioned by the Congress. I don't care what
party you are. But that's part of the way our system was set up under our Constitution.
The Congress is supposed to serve as a check on the executive power and I think it's unfortunate
that they have failed to do that. And, you know, basically it's the Republican Party that doesn't
want to in any way hold the administration accountable. That is not in keeping with our
Constitution and it is not smart because presidents need to be held accountable. It's a heady feeling,
you know, being in the Oval Office. And part of the way our founders, and we're about to celebrate
the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, understood human nature was to say,
hey, look, there have to be separation of powers, there have to be checks and balances. The first
article sets up the Congress, the second the executive, the third the judiciary. And there's
supposed to be all of this tension so that nobody goes too far and leads the country astray. So I
think the Congress has abdicated that responsibility. What about Democrats? Could Democrats
be doing more and are you advising them in any capacity to try and come up with a better strategy?
Well, look, I think the Democrats actually came out of that shutdown in a strong position because
they put affordability, particularly the affordability of health care, front and center
on the domestic agenda. It was very hard to get any kind of, you know, smart political strategy
in the beginning because the Democrats had so few tools. But I think that there is a growing
awareness that the Democrats are being more effective in their opposition to the President.
And I think the recent elections prove that voters are, you know, beginning to ask a lot
of questions. Obviously, you look at polling and favorability ratings and all of that.
But what bothers me is that I was in the Senate for eight years. I know a number of the Republicans
who are still in the Senate. I don't recognize them because they were more than happy to
criticize and question Bush and certainly Obama and certainly Biden. And they, you know,
they are either intimidated or, you know, in agreement, whatever the reason might be,
that they're not doing the same now. When you look at why Democrats lost to Trump,
what do you think in general they're missing about where the country is at? You know,
what have they gotten wrong? What are they misreading? Well, look, I think that we are
about to see political changes come and go, as you know so well. And I think that there
were a lot of missed signals in the Biden administration. Obviously, you know, Democrats
lost the presidential election. I think there was a lot of uncertainty about how best to take
on the president in the initial months of this term. But I think they have found their footing.
And I think the candidates who are running, whether it's the new mayor-elect in New York,
who made affordability the center of his campaign, or the newly elected governors in New Jersey and
Virginia, who also made affordability the key message of their campaigns, that is beginning
to resonate because it reflects the reality of Americans' daily lives. You know, President Trump
ran on affordability in large measure. You know, I'm going to get the prices down. You're going to
have a better economic future. That hasn't happened. And so you can only tell people
something for so long before they say, wait a minute, because that's what happened with Biden.
He kept saying, you know, the economic indicators are really good. And people were saying, yeah,
I'm looking at my grocery list, and I can't afford half the items on it. I'm looking at my
electricity rates. I'm looking at my health care costs. And so they turned on Biden, even though,
you know, he had tried very hard to lay the groundwork for new jobs and all the rest of it.
Now you see people turning on the president. You see his favorabilities, you know,
in the 30s in some polls. Why? Because their lived reality does not reflect the messages
that are being put out from the White House. And I think there are concerns, you know,
about what some of the other actions are. You know, one of the things that really broke through
to people was demolishing the East Wing of the White House. And, you know, look, you can have
an argument. The White House needs a big space for people to gather. That's fine.
But it was just such an abrupt decision. And the pictures were so incredibly disturbing. So people
all of a sudden started saying, wait a minute, what's going on? That's the White House. So
there's a lot that is beginning to penetrate, not just among Democrats, but independents as well,
about, wait a minute, maybe this is not exactly what I voted for.
Last question. 30 years ago, you went to Beijing and you gave this iconic speech
in which you said women's rights are human rights. And in many senses, I mean, that opened
so many doors around the world and, you know, was formative in creating a feminist foreign policy.
There have been some reversals of all the gains in the last three decades to the last few years.
They're disappointing. I know you're not despondent, though. What gives you hope on this?
Well, specifically on this issue, you know, 30 years ago, I did make a speech. But what was
more significant is that 189 countries reached consensus on something called the Platform for
Action, which was the most historic effort to lay out all the ways in which women were not
being treated equally and fairly in societies around the globe. And we made a lot of progress.
For example, domestic violence was not considered a crime. It was a norm. It was like, oh, well,
that's what happens in families. And that was changed. And all of a sudden, countries began
to pass laws against domestic violence and train judges and law enforcement people to deal with it.
Child marriage was seen as, you know, a norm that, you know, really cut into a young woman's
potential for her own life, for education and her health and so much else. So on so many grounds,
we were making all this progress. And women across the globe were advancing toward a greater sense of
opportunity. And there has been a reversal started in COVID with real intention, in part
because economically, a lot of families found themselves in terrible trouble. And so child
marriage started going up, domestic violence started going up again. And what I'm seeing now
is that even in countries that are, you know, advanced economies, there are a lot of doors
shutting. I mean, it's a very sad commentary that there is now a lot of corporations that are
saying, well, wait a minute, I don't want to get in trouble if I put a woman on the board,
even though I'd like to hear from a woman. You know, I ended up on the Walmart board because Sam
Walton called me and said, I think I need a woman on the board because, you know, most of my
customers are women and we don't have any women. And I want to know what women think when they go
into my store. Well, that was common sense. That was not revolutionary. That wasn't DEI. That was
like, we have a big market out there. We want to sell to everybody. And that includes women and
people of color and everybody else. So I just see that there's a very real pushback in ways that are
endangering women's lives, cutting back on healthcare, child marriage, once again, being,
you know, an economic necessity, what the Taliban is doing, you know, the continuing campaign
against women with forced hijab in Iran, but also in Hungary, in Russia, in Turkey, turning back
laws that were meant to protect women. Xi Jinping saying, I wish more women would go back into the
home because we need more children. Well, they need more children because they had the one child
policy and they have a 30 million male surplus because they didn't keep their baby girls alive
because they could only have one child. I mean, all of these decisions have consequences and
authoritarianism often picks on women first because they're more vulnerable and they can be,
you know, pointed to as the problems in society are because of what women are doing or failing
to do. So there has been pushback and there are reversals, but I am optimistic because I think
that is out of step with reality. And I still believe that women's rights are human rights
and that women's equality is the unfinished business of the 21st century and every nation
will do better the more they give opportunities for women to make their own decisions.
That's a great place to end. Secretary Clinton, thanks for joining us.
Thank you.
