Hillary Clinton on AI China Israel Geopolitics

Hillary Clinton
2 followers
Hillary Rodham Clinton, Former Secretary of State, United States speaks with John Micklethwait, Editor-in-Chief, Bloomberg at the 2023 Bloomberg New Economy Forum in Singapore.
They talk about the war in Israel, artificial intelligence and the US relationship with China.
#politics #neweconomyforum #china #israel #ai
AI Generated·May contain errors
Thank you so much. Throughout this whole event, and indeed throughout my travels in Asia over
the past 10 days, there has been a consistent demand, I think, for an authoritative American
voice and for a sort of vision of how the world might look. I'm delighted to say that we are
very lucky to have former Secretary of State, former Senator, former many things,
Hilary Rodham Clinton with us. Thank you very much for being here.
You are, in my experience, the first person to get a round of applause before you've even begun
at this forum. So you are already ahead. And I should point out, you have notably come
at a fairly late time in New York. And our idea was to do a tour d'horizon and begin in Asia
and gradually head west towards America. As Secretary of State, you talked about economic
statecraft and the importance of binding together national security with economic policy. And the
message you get here repeatedly is that that message is gone. There was a time when America
come here and talk about trade policy. Now, when countries around here talk about trade,
they tend to get pushed away. Do you think that idea of economic statecraft, particularly in Asia,
is missing nowadays? Well, John, thank you for that question, because I think it's a complicated
one now. I think there's always room. In fact, there's a necessity for economic statecraft.
But the definition of what we mean by that and how it's practiced certainly has changed in the last
10, 15 years since I first started using it. Because you're absolutely right. Post-COVID,
post the challenges with the supply chain, post one, now two wars that are challenging
the global order. What do we mean by economic statecraft? Well, I think it does mean to continue
through diplomacy in any way appropriate to find economic connections, networks,
agreements that will enable countries to cooperate peacefully, to enhance their own economic
positions, to find a way to satisfy the needs of their own citizens and to add to the global
economic output. And it is very different today than it was. And I think whether we're talking
about how we create economic statecraft around moving toward a clean energy system, or we
look for ways to create more connectivity, both through actual trade and through the kind of
cooperation that countries need to engage in. The definition is changing, but the necessity
for us to practice economic statecraft remains. Can I just push you on that a bit? If you visit
any country here, Indonesia, even Singapore, Malaysia, all these places, they will all say
the same thing. What they want with America is a trade deal. When they deal with China,
they get a whole menu of economic possibilities. With America, they really want some kind of formal
trade alliance. But that seems to have gone. Are you saddened by that? Well, I am. I do think that
it would be beneficial to the United States, as well as to the countries you named and many others,
if we could define trade agreements for the age in which we find ourselves.
That has to take into account, particularly in the United States, some of the concerns that
citizens and businesses, workers, unions all have about whether trade agreements will really
benefit them. We have to take into account with many other countries, what really is the openness
on the other side of the agreement? How willing will countries be to open their markets to
American businesses? I think we need a new era of realistic trade agreements that take into account
where we are in the world today, that understand we have new stresses and pressures, and that can
make a case, particularly in complicated societies like Indonesia, like the United States, that any
agreement is going to benefit not just a very few large businesses, primarily multinational ones,
but will get into medium-sized and small businesses, will benefit consumers and workers.
We ought to be able to make that case. But historically, those have not been high priorities
for many trade agreements. And one of the things that happened with the TPP is that it did not
adequately explain what the benefits would be beyond a very relatively small set of sectors
and businesses within those sectors. So it's up to leaders, both government and business leaders,
to make a better case. And I think we could do that, but it means adding that to the big agenda
that many people are already facing. And so we have to make a special effort to try to
begin once again to talk about trade agreements, but with an eye from the beginning to make the
case for those trade agreements, not negotiate behind closed doors, then come out and then have
people express their disappointments and opposition. You talked about realism. We now have the meeting
between President Xi and Joe Biden next week in San Francisco. There was a nice line from the
Singaporean foreign minister here where he said, yes, the weather might get a bit better. We might
have a deal on fentanyl, but the climate generally is getting worse between the US and China again.
I think people would say it was better when you were around. Is there any sign of things
getting better or are they just going to get worse for a while and then maybe stabilize?
Well, I'm hoping that more comes out of the meeting. It certainly is a confidence building
opportunity. There hasn't been as much interaction until relatively recently between the Chinese and
the United States governments. There has been a real chill coming from China about businesses,
American businesses, other businesses inside China. And then there are, of course, political
pressures against China within our own political system. So this meeting is a terrific opportunity
to try to reset the table, so to speak, to try to create some opening. But it has to be followed up
on with a lot more interactions. I was very pleased that Secretaries Yellen and Raimondo
and others have been going to China in recent weeks. Nothing substitutes for the effort being
made to have those kinds of meetings about strategic and economic concerns. I think a lot
of what happens in the future really depends upon what Xi Jinping's goals are. Part of the reason
it was somewhat more positive when I was there and we had a very regular set of meetings is because
Hu Jintao was a Chinese leader who decided he would not stay for life. He would fulfill his
term. He would follow the guidance of the Chinese Communist Party. There would be a transition,
a new group of leaders, some holdovers, but other new faces would be in power.
So there could be a constant renewing of both the Chinese government and, through that,
the American relationship. Once Xi Jinping decided to stay in office for life, that creates
a lot of challenges within their own system. I think we're seeing some of that with the removal
of top officials, some of the economic problems in the Chinese economy. But it also creates a
chilling effect in terms of relations. How do you deal with somebody who's not going to be
held accountable? Their system of accountability was certainly different from ours, but it existed
and now it doesn't. Part of what I hope will come out of this meeting is an attitude by
President Xi that he wants to get back to some kind of regular order, that he sees it in China's
interest to really dig in with President Biden, develop a platform for discussions,
for problem solving, look for ways to cooperate on whether it's climate change or other matters
that may be of mutual interest to us, really sending that signal. I think he will find a
receptive partner with President Biden if that's available. That's a very interesting perspective.
I'm going to rush you slightly towards the Middle East, which I've seen you've been talking about
this week, Israel and Hamas. I think you are in favour of a humanitarian pause or pauses,
but you're against the ceasefire, which many people in this region are asking for. The numbers
of dead are rising rapidly, 10,000 according to Hamas, admittedly, but you've still got like 89
dead at the UN, which is a gigantic number for the United Nations,
the Red Crescent and so on. Can you perhaps explain why you don't want a ceasefire?
Well, I think there is a difference between a ceasefire, which would, in effect,
freeze the situation in Hamas's favour. I negotiated a ceasefire between Israel and
Hamas in November of 2012, and at that point, both parties did not want to go any further.
The breaching of a pre-existing ceasefire by Hamas with rockets being sent into Israel
had not caused a lot of damage. There had not been the horrific massacre that we saw on October 7th,
and there also had not been the development of the infrastructure of terror that Hamas has built
in Gaza. I don't know any nation represented at the New Economy Forum faced with the kind of
assault that Israel was faced with by Hamas that would not be, number one, defending itself, and
number two, trying to prevent it from happening again, because with every other ceasefire,
it did happen again until finally we got to the breach of a ceasefire, which was in existence
on October 7th with the terrible attack by Hamas. So a ceasefire, if it were possible,
which frankly I don't think is possible, I don't think Israel is interested in a ceasefire at this
point, but they are perhaps willing to have what we do call humanitarian pauses for the purpose
of both getting aid in to try to assist the civilians in Gaza, but also getting the more
than 240 hostages out. These hostages are not just Israeli. One of the biggest groups of hostages
are workers from Thailand who are working on farms in Israel. So there is a global dimension
to the hostages that a pause could perhaps inspire some willingness on the part of Hamas to let the
hostages go, but a ceasefire that would freeze the situation at this point is not something that
is going to, you know, really undermine Hamas's capacity, especially with 200 miles of tunnels
that they have constructed over the last decade to launch yet another attack on Israel, and that
would be intolerable, and I think it would be intolerable for, you know, any nation represented
at the forum. There seem to be kind of two big theories going on about this war. One is that
this is the end of the peace process, which you've championed. The other is that this is,
if nothing else, this will prompt finally some move towards a two-state solution. Which side
of that do you fit on? Well, I actually try to fit on both, and I'll tell you, John, I think
it's important to have some aspirations, some goal that we can look toward. Many of us, my husband
particularly, worked very hard on trying to get a two-state solution, and it frankly, in retrospect,
is heartbreaking that Yasser Arafat walked away from the deal that Bill had brokered between
Israel and the Palestinian Authority back in 2000. There could have been a Palestinian state
on up to 97% of the land from the 1948 division that would have been in existence for 23 years
now. So I think you have to create the environment in which there is a chance to revitalize the
peace process and a potential for a two-state solution. Hamas is not interested in a two-state
solution. They are dedicated to the destruction of Israel. That is in their charter. If you've
been watching lots of different outlets over the last month, that is what the leaders of
Hamas say. They want to destroy Israel. So Hamas is not a partner for any kind of peace or two-state
solution, but the Palestinian Authority might one time again be. New leadership in Gaza might again
be. So you have to get to a point where that's possible. Very quickly, do you think that Benjamin
Netanyahu is a partner for a two-state solution? I don't think there is any evidence of that. I
have to decide about his leadership. I think there will be investigations about what led up
to and what happened on October 7. But I think there needs to be new leadership of the Israelis
and the Palestinians in order to have any chance at some kind of peace deal, especially a two-state
solution. Can I jump a little bit more optimistically towards Europe? You've had a
You've had people I suspect you would support winning. In Britain, you're heading towards
election. The place which went through Brexit, Boris and this trust, we now have two rather
boring men, but they are nevertheless within the general field of what people would regard as
compatible, competitive, normal politics. Do you think there is a sign of politics changing at all?
I certainly hope so. I want to make boring popular again. I want to get back to people
who get up every day and do the job. I don't think that they are entertainers and performers
who need to be outrageous and get a lot of attention on social media. I'm for the boring
public servants and government leaders right now.
Bring back boring. On that subject, in your own country, there has been something of a
split from the point of view of the Democrats. You have had the big success
in terms of some of the state elections this week with abortion particularly seeming to help
the Democratic side, but you've got some pretty bad polls from the battleground states.
I think you've come out already saying that Joe Biden is still the answer, but do you want to
explain that to people here? First of all, I'm not a fan of polling a year out from an election.
To go back to what we were just talking about, there's a tendency among voters, and particularly
I would say among Democratic voters in the United States, to always be looking for the next cool
thing. Who's the really exciting candidate that we're going to have? There's a lot of the churn
about what we really are going to look for and end up with, but I believe Joe Biden will be the
nominee. I believe he will be reelected. I believe that both on the merits of his record, which is
quite remarkable given the difficult political environment in our country, but also because
of the alternative. It still looks likely that Donald Trump will be the Republican nominee. I
know that's hard for people to believe with everything going on, but that seems to be the
likely outcome. There very well could be a rematch. I think in that kind of a rematch, as we've seen
in the elections just yesterday, people are moving away from the drama, from all of the chaos. They
want to just have regular order again. They voted yesterday for people who are standing up for
issues that are popular, like the right to have women make their own reproductive decisions,
for example. But you had a governor in Kentucky, a deeply red state, a Democratic governor get
reelected. He made abortion a central issue. He made red flag laws so that people who are dangerous
don't get guns, which seems like a very sensible position. He made those really central to his
campaign, and he won a very big victory. So I think that Joe Biden will be the nominee. I think
Trump right now will be the nominee, and I think Biden will be reelected. Vote Democrats and dare
to be dull. That's right. That's right. It's the new cool thing, John. You know, just get out there
and show your dullness, but get the job done. Be productive and dull. There's one area,
I'll ask you one serious one, then a slightly more amusing one. But on the serious side,
you look at things like Ukraine at the moment. There is definitely a strategy
among America's enemies. You could see Putin waiting, perhaps for Trump, trying to dig in
and wait. But also, I think also counting on Congress, where you feel that Congress feels
overextended. It's got the border, it's got Scotland and Israel. Do you worry about America
feeling as if it's overextended and unable to carry out the kind of global policies that you
believe in? Well, up until now, the Biden administration has done quite a remarkable job.
I mean, they put together a coalition to support Ukraine, which I think many people would have
thought unlikely when Biden took office. So I do think the legislative agenda that Biden got
passed is also another very strong indicator of being able to get things done. I do agree with you
that it is going to be challenging in the Congress to get more funding for Ukraine,
to provide the funding Israel needs, to provide the kind of support that is required to keep our
alliances strong around the world. But at the end of the day, I think the president will get that.
And I also think there's an opportunity for the president because the Republicans in the Senate
have said, you know, we're on board with all of this, but we want to make some changes at the
border. I think that, you know, the Democrats should negotiate to see what kinds of changes
would be palatable for the Democrats in order to secure the border, in order to make it clear
that, you know, Democrats want a secure border and a humane system for people who are trying to
enter the United States, but we want it to be orderly. So I think there's going to be a lot of
tough negotiation at the end. I think the president will get what he needs.
Just one quick thing on Ukraine, because you mentioned it. Do you think there is any hope
of persuading China to come in and help on that? So far, China has had an effect on Vladimir Putin
in terms of saying don't use nuclear weapons or saying those are off the ground. Is there any
room of persuading them to kind of push him into something closer to a ceasefire there as well?
I don't know the answer to that, John. I think China has played an important role in trying to
send a message to Putin not to over, you know, stretch, particularly when it comes to tactical
nuclear weapons. But I think China has also been surprised at how difficult it has been
for the Russian military to achieve their military objectives. I think that's caused
China to do some serious evaluation internally about their own military. I think that's part of
what we may be seeing with some of the changes in military leadership with the assessment that,
you know, everybody thought the Russian military was very effective. It turned out not to be.
What are the lessons we can learn? I think the more important, you know, decision right now
is for the United States, Europe and other like-minded countries to continue supporting
Ukraine, support them with the military equipment they need in order to, you know,
hold the line and push back as much as they can. You know, the more equipment that we can provide
Ukraine, the more they can defend themselves and try to take back the territory that has been
seized since 2022. That should be our objective. That's what we should be focused on. But you said
something earlier, which I think is absolutely right. I mean, I think Putin is waiting to see
whether Trump can come back. I think, you know, the fact that Trump said when he was president
before that he would pull the United States out of NATO is like the fulfillment of Putin's dreams.
And so if he can figure out how to hold this in a frozen conflict position, not lose any more
ground to the Ukrainians and wait to see whether there's some opportunity, in fact, probably try
to help Trump in the election as he has before, then I think, you know, there may be, you know,
a kind of stalemate for a while. And the West cannot be discouraged by that. We have to keep,
you know, supporting the Ukrainians to push as far as they can push.
One very last thing. You mentioned the Republicans. On the Republican side,
you will have noticed how much traction Nikki Haley has been getting as a woman who was the
American ambassador to the UN. Do you think that if Biden were to stumble,
there might be room for another woman with slightly more foreign policy experience?
Well, I don't know the answer to that, but I hope Biden doesn't stumble. I hope that
he goes all the way to, you know, the finish line, because I think he's earned it. He deserves it.
And, you know, honestly, the only real argument or complaint is that he's old. And you know what?
I think everybody who's his age would be very happy if they were as productive as he is,
and has gotten as much done as he has, and traveled the schedule he's traveled. So,
you know, I'm going to continue to support him. And I think he's our best candidate for 2024.
That was an impeccable answer on which to finish. We are very grateful for
you staying up and doing that. Secretary, thank you very much.
Thank you, Don.
