With mortgage rates and home prices where they are these days the question of whether it makes sense to buy or rent a home has become more relevant than it has been in a long time. In today’s video we’re going to crunch the numbers and see which housing option comes out on top.
DISCLAIMER: This video content is intended only for informational, educational, and entertainment purposes. Neither PapayaCast, LLC (A.K.A. "Real Estate Watch") or Eric Meux are registered financial advisors. Your use of PapayaCast's YouTube channel and your reliance on any information on the channel is solely at your own risk. Moreover, the use of the Internet (including, but not limited to, YouTube, E-Mail, and LinkedIn) for communications with PapayaCast, LLC does not establish a formal business relationship.
With mortgage rates and home prices where they are these days, the question of whether it makes sense
to buy or rent a home has become more relevant than it has been in a long time. In today's video,
we're going to crunch the numbers and see which housing option comes out on top. Let's get into it.
Welcome to Real Estate Watch, the channel that focuses on forward-looking real estate and
economic analysis. My name is Eric, professional economist and licensed real estate agent.
Today we're looking at a common question that comes up for those thinking of buying a home.
Should I purchase a home as an investment or should I rent a home and save and invest
elsewhere instead? There are many non-financial reasons to buy a home and those are all valid
and worth pursuing if that is your preference. You may want a sense of security that homeowners
brings or the freedom to do what you want with the property. Depending on who you are and your
own preferences, these may be more important to you than the pure financial aspect of it.
But those preferences can be different with each person. So for this video, we're just going to be
looking at the financial aspect of buying a home versus renting and which one makes sense just by
the numbers. Before we go any further, I do need to give a disclaimer here. While I am an economist
with expertise in real estate analysis as well as a licensed real estate agent in the state of
California, I'm not a financial advisor and this video is not intended to be financial advice.
It is intended to be an educational resource and hopefully a little entertaining as well.
You are responsible for your own financial decisions and should seek out professional
financial advice that can help you in your specific situation. Okay, with that out of the
way, let's get into it. When you buy a home, your housing cost is more than just your mortgage
payment. There's homeowners insurance, property taxes, and property maintenance in addition to
the mortgage payment each month. Oftentimes and especially recently, renting a home can have
a lower overall cost, allowing you to save and invest what would have ordinarily went
into homeowner housing costs, less what you pay in rent. But buying a home can be a form of
investment as well since the value of the property usually appreciates over time.
Given where home prices, mortgage rates, and rents are today, which one comes out on top? Let's find
out. We're going to look at a hypothetical scenario here comparing what your financial return
would be after 10 years if you buy a home or if you rent a home and invest in the stock market
instead. Now there are a lot of assumptions that go into this kind of analysis, but I've tried to
make those as reasonable as possible for our example. I'm going to give you the results of
my analysis up front, but for those of you who want to take a deeper dive into how I got the
numbers, I'll cover all that in the second half of this video. So stick around to the end if you
want that information. Let's start with some of the basic assumptions. On the homeownership side
of the analysis, we're going to use a home purchase price of $437,000, which was the U.S.
median home price in October according to Redfin. The average 30-year fixed rate mortgage in October
came in at 6.254% according to Freddie Mac, so we'll use that as well. One thing I didn't do
is factor in the possibility of refinancing at a lower mortgage rate. There's no guarantee rates
are going to go down much lower than where they are today given certain dynamics in the bond market,
so I just kept the mortgage rate the same over the life of the loan. But I will have an additional
example of what things look like at a lower mortgage rate. We're going to assume a 20% down
payment for the purchase and that the home price will grow annually at a 5.6% rate, which is what
I calculated as the long-run historical average in the data I have. Those are the key figures to
consider on the homeownership side. Now for the rental side, we're going to assume a monthly rent
of $1,950, which is the Zillow estimate of the average U.S. rent for October, and that rent will
grow at an annual rate of 3.9%, which is the historical average I calculated. For the investments
that go into the stock market, I'm going to assume an average annual return of 8.3%, which is the
historical average in the data I have. There are a lot of other assumptions going into this, like
the housing costs for insurance, property tax, maintenance, and closing costs on a purchase and
sale. I'll provide the details for that later. Here are the results for this 10-year scenario.
We'll look first at the homeownership side. We started out with a $437,000 home purchase
financed with a 30-year fixed rate mortgage and a 20% down payment. After 10 years, the home
price will have appreciated to $753,151. And the loan balance will have reached at the end of that
10 years, $293,907. That yields a gain in equity of $459,244. Looking pretty good, right? Sadly,
a big chunk of that is going to go away when you sell the property to realize the gain.
Closing costs, including real estate commissions, are going to total $52,721.
This does assume that the seller is paying the commission for both the listing agent and the
buyer's agent. We'll get into why that is the case later. I'm going to assume that there won't be any
tax paid on the sale of the home, so that is zero. So after all is said and done, the cash on hand
after the sale of the home is completed would be $406,523. Still a pretty nice chunk of change.
Here's the bad news. That's not your profit after 10 years. We need to take into account
everything that went into home ownership costs over that time period. These include the closing
costs on the purchase of the home, the monthly interest payments on the mortgage, the annual
homeowner insurance premium, annual property taxes, and property maintenance costs. Add it
all up and the total housing cost over 10 years would be $414,539. Yes, you're reading that right.
It is more than the cash on hand after the sale of the property. When you subtract the total cost
from the cash on hand, you get negative $8,016 for the total return on your investment over a 10-year
time period. This result is probably quite surprising to many of you watching this. For me,
I had to double and triple check my calculations to make sure I was getting it right. There are
a few reasons why there is a negative return in this hypothetical example. First, it just looks
at a 10-year scenario. There is much more mortgage interest paid in the first 10 years of a 30-year
home loan than the last 10 years. Pushing this out to a full 30 years would yield a positive
result. But looking at it over just 10 years is not an unreasonable scenario. This is about the
average number of years an owner stays in their home before selling. The big problem is the
mortgage interest over that first 10 years. And if you'll remember from earlier, the assumed mortgage
rate in this scenario was the October average of 6.254%. That mortgage rate makes a big difference.
Let me show you what happens if I do the same calculations and just change the mortgage rate
on the loan to 3%. The overall housing cost drops to $303,365, and that's entirely due to the lower
mortgage rate. The ending loan balance is lower, which raises the gain in equity, and you would end
up with a $132,109 total return on the home investment. So you can see the interest rate
makes a huge difference in how profitable it can be to buy a home purely as an investment.
Now let's take a look at the rental side of the analysis so we have something to compare this to.
On the rental side of things, the important piece of this calculation is how much you will be able
to invest in the stock market. And for this scenario, we're considering how much would have
been spent on housing costs compared to how much would be spent if you're just paying rent. And the
difference between the two would be invested in the stock market. This includes what would have
gone towards the down payment on the house, as well as the closing costs on the purchase of the
house, monthly mortgage payments, an allowance for maintenance costs, annual homeowner insurance
premiums, and property tax. When you add all these up using our national averages, they are greater
than the monthly cost to rent, so there is some left over to invest in the stock market. Over a
10-year time period, you would have invested a total of $273,042. Given our assumption of an
8.3% annual return from the S&P 500 and reinvesting dividends, your total portfolio value after 10
years would be $558,030. After paying a capital gains tax of 15%, you would be left with $515,282
in cash on hand at the end of the stock sale. From this, we would subtract the total amount of
rent that would have been paid over the 10-year time period, which comes out to $282,586.
And you would be left with a total return on the rent and invest strategy of $232,696.
From before, we found that the total return on homeownership came out to be negative $8,016.
Ladies and gentlemen, we have a clear winner here from a purely financial perspective
when we run the numbers. But wait, not so fast. Things changed quite a bit when we took our
assumed mortgage rate of 6.254% and re-ran the calculations using a 3% rate, and they make a
big difference in the rental scenario as well. The amount invested in the stock market is calculated
as the difference between housing costs and renting costs, so if you are paying less in
interest on the homeowner's side because of a lower mortgage rate, you are also investing less
on the rental side. Let's see what those numbers look like. Your total principal investment would
be $190,819. And after 10 years, the ending portfolio value would be $417,096. Take out
15% for the capital gains tax and the total cost of rent over 10 years, which didn't change from
our previous example because we just changed the mortgage rate, and the total return from the rent
and invest strategy comes down to $100,568. Compare that to the homeownership return of $132,109
from the 3% mortgage rate scenario, and ladies and gentlemen, we no longer have a clear winner here.
You can see from these two examples that the mortgage rate alone can have a huge impact on
which is the better strategy from a purely financial perspective. Now there are quite a
few caveats that we have to bring into our results here. First and foremost, it is a hypothetical
scenario that uses average historical growth rates to project things like home price appreciation
and stock market returns into the future. It assumes that over the 10-year period, there will
be no recession or housing market downturn or stock market downturn. In reality, there's few
such historical cases over 10-year time period, and the future is always uncertain. Also, it uses
national averages for things like home price and rent. Different regional markets can have greater
or lesser disparities between price and rent, which can lead to different results. Another big
consideration is what kind of tax benefits you might have from homeownership, including
deducting mortgage interest and property taxes. For this, you need to seek a qualified tax
professional who can look at your specific circumstance, but generally speaking, to get
these tax benefits, your itemized tax deductions would need to be greater than the standard
deduction to take advantage of them. Potentially, you could have tax benefits that tilt the analysis
more in favor of homeownership, but these are going to be highly specific to individual cases,
and because of that, I left that out of the analysis. Again, you need to seek out the advice
of a tax professional to know what to expect in your personal circumstance. These are all
important considerations when thinking about this kind of situation for yourself and asking if it
makes more financial sense to buy a home and rent and invest. That's the question. As I mentioned
before, make sure to consult with a professional to help you answer that question for yourself
given your specific situation. On the issue of this being a hypothetical example, I did
do another analysis that can give us further insights into which is the better strategy from
a financial perspective. Using actual historical data, not projected values in the future,
I ran the same 10-year analysis for each month between 1993 and 2015 to see how the numbers have
actually played out over that time period. This is the total return from the homeownership strategy
minus the total return from the rent and invest strategy. When it is below zero, that means the
total return from rent and invest is larger than the total return from home ownership.
Over this time period, renting has been the winner for most years. Things got pretty bad for
homeowners for most of the 2000s, and that is because we had a pretty big housing bubble and
downturn during that period. Here's the graph again with the U.S. median home price on the
other axis to highlight why this matters so much. The worst point was in November of 2005
when renting and investing was about $240,000 better over a 10-year time period, and this was
primarily due to the fact that the median home price was about 6% lower 10 years later in November
2015. So you had a big negative return on the home ownership strategy over that specific
10-year time period. This historical analysis on the return between the two strategies shows
how much market performance matters. In my previous example, looking at the numbers from
October of this year, mortgage rates were a big factor in the results, but that example assumed
You can see the question of whether or not it makes financial sense to buy a home or rent and
invest in the stock market is a complex analysis with a lot of moving parts. Let's face it, nothing
in the future is guaranteed. We don't know if there will be a housing downturn, stock market
meltdown, or a severe recession five to ten years from now. The best forecasters in the world cannot
accurately predict things that far out. If you are someone who is asking yourself if it's worth
it to buy a home, my recommendation, not financial advice, but my recommendation is that you ask
yourself a few questions. First, can you afford to buy a home? Is it a personal dream of yours to
buy a home? Are you okay with the additional expenses that go into home ownership like
insurance, maintenance, and property tax? If you answered yes to all of those questions, then
I would say go for your dreams if you're able to. If you are someone that looks purely at the
numbers and is interested primarily in maximizing the return on your investment and that you're okay
seeing your stock market investments go down in the short term, you can wait for them to recover
without adding stress to your life, then renting might be the option for you, especially given
where mortgage rates and home prices are today at the national level. Ultimately, this is a very
personal choice and it's going to come down to an individual's preferences. Like I said before,
this video is not financial advice, but I do hope that it has been helpful in getting you to think
about this question from different angles. We covered a lot of material, so if you have any
questions about any of it, please leave those in the comments section and I'll do my best to answer
each one. If a certain question keeps coming up, I may do another video just to cover it.
If you like today's video and would like to see more of my content, do all those YouTube things,
like, subscribe, hit that notification bell down below. If you have friends or family that you
think would benefit from seeing this video, please share it with them. If you want to know more of the
details behind my analysis, we're going to get into that now. Otherwise, thanks for stopping by,
I'll see you in the next video. Are you still here? You must be an analytical data nerd just like me.
Let's get into the boring stuff. In this section of the video, we're going to cover the data I use,
the assumptions I made for several parts of the analysis, and how I put it all together. First,
the data. In my historical analysis, I had 1993 as the starting year and that is because of a
data limitation on homeowners insurance. I used data from the National Association of Insurance
Commissioners for the US average annual homeowners insurance premium and their data starts in 1993.
So that became the starting point for my historical data. Let's run down everything I did on the
homeowner side first. For the US median home price, I used my go-to data source, Redfin.
But one problem was that Redfin's data only goes back to 2012. So I had to stitch together a couple
of time series from a couple other sources. Let me show you what I mean. Here's the US median home
price from Redfin and the series begins in 2012. To push this further back, I use the median existing
home price from the National Association of Realtors, but their data starts in 1999. So to go
back even further, I use the data from the US Department of Housing and Urban Development.
They have data on new and existing homes, so I calculated a sales weighted average to produce a
median price series for all homes, which is a closer approximation to the Redfin median price
that covers new and existing homes. Now this is an annual series, so I just used a linear trend to
connect the annual values to make it monthly, which is why it looks so smooth here. It's not perfect,
but for this analysis it works just fine. Keeping the level of the Redfin median price, I used the
month-to-month trends in the other series to put it all together and voila! We have a monthly time
series for the US median home price from 1968 to 2025. Mortgage rates were pretty easy. Freddie Mac
has weekly data going back to 1971, so I just took an average of the weekly values to make it a monthly
series. To calculate the monthly mortgage payment, I used this formula, which is pretty standard and
I won't break down all the components. If you're really interested in that, ask your favorite AI
chat bot and it will break it all down for you. Once I had the monthly mortgage payment amount, I
set up an amortization schedule for a 30-year fixed rate mortgage, which then let me see the
total amount of interest in principle over the first 10 years of the loan. I assumed the loan
amount would be 80% of the median home price for a given month, which assumes a 20% down payment,
and I used whatever the average monthly mortgage rate was for that month. Now let's get into how I
handled the other housing costs, starting with homeowners insurance. Here's the annual data from
the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. It's an annual series, so like the annual home
price data I mentioned earlier, I just assumed a linear trend between the annual values to make
it monthly. Given that this is an annual average, I set June as a monthly point for the annual value.
Again, not a precise way to make an annual series monthly, but it works for our purposes.
You'll notice this data is current through 2022, so to bring it up to 2025, I used the monthly
trend from the Industry Producer Price Index for homeowners insurance premiums. This gave me a
monthly insurance premium estimate from 1993 to 2025. For the other two components of total housing
costs, property tax and maintenance, I made some simple assumptions. For property tax, I just
assumed it would be 1% of the median home price for a given month. Now property tax rates are
different in counties throughout the nation, and some places like California even put limits
on how much property tax can increase each year after you buy a home. But for a national average,
1% is a reasonable assumption for annual property tax. For maintenance costs, I assumed it would be
2% of the median home price for a given month. A general rule of thumb is that you set aside
one to three percent of a home's value for maintenance costs, depending on the age of the
home. New homes will require less maintenance, and older homes will require more. For this analysis,
I just split the difference and assumed 2% of the home's value on an annual basis
would need to go to maintenance. All of this gave me the historical data I needed for the analysis,
but I also needed to produce some projections of future values in order to test what the 10-year
results would be going forward from the present. Like I mentioned earlier, home price appreciation
would be 5.6% annually, and homeowner's insurance premiums would grow by 5.1% annually.
Both of these growth rates represent the average annual growth for these series for the full
history of data I had, going back to 1968 for home prices and 1993 for insurance premiums.
Given that these are annual growth rates and I'm working with monthly data, I calculated the
effective monthly growth rate using this formula, as opposed to just dividing the annual rate by 12,
and this is to avoid over-compounding the future values. I also made a few assumptions on closing
costs for the purchase and sale of the home. Rather than make it too complicated, I just
assumed the non-agent commission components of closing costs, things like title insurance,
loan, and escrow fees, to be 2% of the home's value at the time of purchase or sale.
For agent commissions, I assumed the seller would be paying both the buyer's agent and the listing
agent each a 2.5% commission, which is roughly the industry average. For a long time, it was
customary, not required by law, for the seller to pay the commission for both agents in the
transaction. In recent years, there was a legal settlement involving the National Association of
Realtors, and one of the results of the settlement is that real estate brokerages need to ensure
their clients are aware that commission rates are negotiable, not set by law, and that sellers are
not required by any law to pay the buyer's agent commission. It's a bit more complicated than that,
but that's the quick and dirty summary. In practice, there are still a lot of sellers that are paying
the buyer's agent commission, so for my analysis, I just assumed that would be the case. So these are
all the data points and assumptions that went into the homeowner side of the analysis. The rental side
was a bit less complicated. I used Zillow's observed rent index for the U.S. average monthly rent.
However, their series only went back to 2015, so to put together a longer history, I used the monthly
trend from the consumer price index on rent of primary residents. This gave me an estimate of
historical rents going back to 1981. For stock market performance, I used the daily value of the
S&P 500 index from Yahoo Finance, and then averaged the daily values to create a monthly
series going back to 1962. To get an estimate of average dividend yields, I took a bit of a shortcut
and just asked Google's Gemini what the average dividend yields for the S&P 500 were over time,
and this is what it gave me. They looked reasonable, so I went with it. Like with the data on the
homeowner side, I calculated the average annual growth in rent in the S&P 500 over the full history
of the data I had, and calculated an effective monthly growth rate in order to project them into
the future. With all this data in hand, I could then run my analysis on any given month to see
what the total homeowner return would be and what the rent and invest would be. I used Stata for this
and wrote it all in a program. I also produced a spreadsheet model to run the analysis on a single
month to gut check my work. Once I had the program written for analyzing the return for
one month in time, I was able to iterate that analysis in the program for every month, and
that's how I was able to put together this graph on the historical performance. That's pretty much
it. If you've made it this far into the video, I'm impressed. I know it was long and tedious, but I
wanted to let you know that I wasn't pulling these numbers out of thin air, and that it was actually
based on a sound analysis. I also used Google's Gemini to verify my approach. I gave it all the
parameters for one month, and its results pretty much matched my own. I hope all this has been
helpful for you, and please don't hesitate to leave any questions in the comment section if
you would like me to clear anything up. And don't forget to like and subscribe. Thanks for stopping
by. I'll see you in the next video.