Should People Who CAN'T SAVE MONEY BUY A HOUSE?

Wealth Wizards
9 followers
#finance
#financement
One of the most common things I get asked about being in the real estate business is this. Should I buy a house because it's a forced savings account? Meaning that when you buy the house you're forced to pay it off and once the mortgage is paid off. You have an asset that you can now borrow against in retirement. The thing is it's not that simple and there are many nuances that can make this more problematic than you think.
Today I want to talk about something that gets brought up very very often in the comment sections
of my videos. Every time I talk about whether it makes more sense to buy a house right now
or to rent, especially since buying is more expensive in pretty much every region of the
country now compared to renting. And that question is this, is buying a house really a forced savings
account? Should people who can't save money buy a house because at least if they can't save money
then after all is said and done in the end they will have a paid off house. And there are
definitely some reasons to do this and some definite reasons not to do this and that's what
I want to talk about in today's video. Because one major issue today is that renters typically
don't save the difference of what they would be actually paying if they were to buy a house
and they're not investing that difference. That's what makes all of this a game changer essentially.
If you are investing the difference as a renter then it can easily make more sense not to buy a
house but if you aren't then the lines become a lot more blurry and that's why the advice for
the average person is to get a house that way if nothing else you have a forced savings account
in the end. So let's go through a made-up scenario here to give you guys an idea of how this would
work. In 2012 a woman who is 29 years old who's barely scraping by in Orlando Florida decided
she would buy a house and she was making $42,000 a year. Rent was going up and her landlord just
added a surprise $75 maintenance fee to her monthly bill. That's even more of a reason to
say you know what I'm tired of renting let's buy something. So frustrated with the landlord and the
rent situation she bought a two-bedroom starter home in a modest neighborhood for only $145,000.
Everybody was telling her it was a bad idea she had no savings no fancy career but one thing she
did have was a stable paycheck at least at the time. So she's paying off the house and paying
off the house and fast forward to 2024 that house she paid $140,000 for was worth $260,000.
She paid down about half of the mortgage by then and so over that 12 years she ended up building
up about $110,000 in equity in the home. Not bad. Hence the forced savings account. Here's where
things start to fall apart. In 2025 her finances got turned upside down once again and she needed
some emergency cash. So what did she do? She had to refinance her house at a much higher interest
rate than she got back in 2012 and now her payment went up much higher than it was before
and now she has additional debt attached to that house that if for some reason she can't pay she
will end up losing the house. So in this case was it worth it for her to buy the house? Well it
depends on which angle you look at it from. From the angle that she had that $110,000 in equity
to actually borrow in an emergency? Yeah. Was it worth it? Yes. Is it worth it scraping by for 12
years of your life and working extremely hard to have to only refinance the equity that you did
build into this house and end up with a much higher debt payment and paying a ton of interest
on that money? Probably not but it gave her the option to do it and I think that's where people
argue that if you have nothing else at least you have that house and from that point of view alone
I would agree but I want to dig even deeper into this and give some of the pros and cons of both
sides of this. So let's start off with the pros of this and then we'll move on to the cons. So
the first thing is you are building equity. You know each mortgage payment you make reduces the
balance you owe on the house and over time this can result in significant wealth especially
if you see a large uptick in home prices like we saw over the past five years. Nobody who bought
pre-pandemic probably ever dreamed that their property would be worth what it is today.
Even at normal appreciation rates if you buy a house worth $300,000 and it appreciates at 3%
annually in 10 years your house could be worth $400,000. So you know the market and inflation
is essentially doing a lot of the heavy lifting in terms of increasing your equity and your home
value. You know yes the mortgage payments do help but really inflation is what really does the trick
when it comes to home ownership. The second pro to having the house is it gives you forced
discipline. You have to make that mortgage payment every single month or you lose your house. You
know they'll take it from you in foreclosure if you don't make those payments. So it kind of forces
you to save the money by investing it into your house. Now obviously if your mortgage payment is
$1,200 a month you're not saving $1,200 a month because a large chunk of that $1,200 is going
towards interest especially in the first half of your loan. But the portion of it that is going
towards paying off your principal combined with inflation is helping you build equity over time.
But that doesn't apply in a housing market where home values are going down. Like for example
right now people who bought a house like say two or three years ago especially anywhere in Florida
essentially is now seeing a situation where they could be upside down. They could have negative
equity and the house could be worth less than what they just paid for it a few years ago. Now
the third pro to this is that it's kind of a hedge against inflation because home prices tend to go
up with inflation. But as you can see right now home prices are stalling out in many areas across
the country and even going down in many instances. So that is a little bit debatable. But in general
real estate is an asset that will appreciate the more inflation that we get which is an increase
in the money supply. The more of that money will inevitably flow into the housing market.
And the fourth reason is probably the main reason that a lot of people say it's better to own the
house and the reason why it's a forced savings account. And that's because if you're a middle
income earner in this country you earn the average wage your household earns $75-$80,000 a year.
This is going to be your primary asset when you retire and then you can end up tapping into that
equity assuming you pay off the house or pay off most of it by the time you retire
in the form of a reverse mortgage or home equity loans things like that. So people are essentially
saying buy the house so that way you have something to tap into later when you might need it when
you're no longer working. And then of course there are some tax benefits to owning real estate as
well which is the fifth pro because mortgage interest up to I think as it stands right now
is $10,000 per year can be deducted against your personal income. They're looking at changing that
with the big beautiful bill that hasn't passed yet. Now let's move into some of the cons of
buying the house and using that as a forced savings account. And number one is a big one
and that is there is no liquidity in buying a house. When you buy a house it's not easy to
sell like a stock. You can't just say I don't want it tomorrow and turn around and sell everything.
It's not that simple. When you buy a house there's a lot of closing costs involved. There's
a lot of other selling costs if you want to turn around and sell and those things alone can make it
unprofitable to sell your home. And also from the very beginning once you first buy the house you
won't be able to tap any of the equity of the home unless you put a significant down payment.
We're talking 30, 40, 50 percent down then you might be able to tap some of that equity right
after buying the house or if you pay cash. But if you're the standard borrower and you put down
10 percent you won't have any equity to tap for a very long time. Now the second reason it's not
a good forced savings account is the one I talk about all the time and it's because it has high
transaction costs and high maintenance costs. Buying and selling a home involves closing costs,
real estate commission, thousands and thousands of dollars per year in maintenance.
The average homeowner spends anywhere between one to four percent of their home's value annually
on home maintenance. So think about it if we're talking in normal years appreciation makes your
home go up in value two to three percent per year but you're spending two to three percent per year
of your home's value just on maintaining the place you're essentially gaining nothing. Especially
when you're talking about inflation the value of those dollars is continually becoming more worthless
and you have to pay more and more in order to be able to maintain your house. The third downside
to it is you have market volatility. You know a lot of people are brainwashed into thinking that
home prices only go up they never go down and recent times are proving to be that untrue once
again. We're seeing many markets start to turn negative year over year now across the country
and as the next couple years go by it's probably going to be more and more of them. You know in
2008 housing crash home prices fell on average 30 percent in most places throughout the country
and in some places it fell much more severely like here in Miami went down 50 percent. Is that going
to happen again this time? Nobody knows but the potential for it is always there especially as
these asset bubbles continue to get over inflated. Number four is a big one and that is that you're
there's opportunity costs when you buy a house. That money you have tied up in your home and your
home equity might yield better results elsewhere such as an index fund or retirement or nowadays
gold and silver or bitcoin. And the fifth con to buying the house and using it as your forced
savings account is that it can reduce your job flexibility especially when the market is down.
It means you might end up having to sell at a loss so if that happens that's not a very good position
to be in and so it's better to look at it like not really a forced savings account but you're
taking a risk just like everything else. It can end up being a forced savings account if you hang
on to the house long term or talking paying off that 30-year mortgage and keeping that house for
many many years then it can end up like that. So I would say for people who struggle with self-discipline
you know a mortgage forces you to pay off the house and to save and it's the only real asset
most middle class Americans are going to build in their lifetime so in that sense it might be worth
using it as a forced savings account but on the other hand it's not actually a savings account
it's a leveraged investment and if the market turns like it is right now you're exposed and
you have to deal with the consequences. Now I'm not sitting here saying that an actual savings
account is much better because obviously your money sitting in the savings account even if
it's earning four and a half percent right now is still losing money to inflation with how bad
it's been but at least you don't have as much of the risk you can go in there and grab that money
anytime you need it whereas when you're talking about buying a house it's not that simple.
And by the way today I'm walking in the newly opened Maurice Gibb Park here in Miami Beach.
This park has been closed for well over a year now. I used to shoot my videos here back in the day
and it's been closed for quite some time. This is the first video I've done here in probably like
a year and a half at least. So is a house a forced savings account? Let's answer that question.
Well I think the answer to that question is both yes and no. Yes it is because you are going to end
up with some money in the end due to inflation and appreciation assuming that you don't refinance the
home or borrow against it along the way and that's the big caveat that most people fail with. Most
people at some point in time feel like they're rich because oh look I have three hundred thousand
dollars in home equity let's use it to buy something else let's use it to go on vacation
let's use it to remodel this house and that's how people end up getting in trouble and end up not
actually having that forced savings account. And that is the actual true problem with home ownership
in America today in general is that people are looking at it as an investment whereas you know
50 plus years ago buying a house was just a place to live it wasn't looked at as an investment like
it is today. And so because so many Americans view it as an investment and they're constantly
being bombarded with advertisements to borrow against it and learning about different ways to
leverage against that so-called investment people end up getting in trouble. So is it better than
having nothing in retirement and have nothing else to show for if at least if you have nothing else
you have that paid off house? Absolutely I am not going to argue with that or deny that I agree 100%
from that point of view. But is it the absolute best thing to do in order to save for retirement
or have money when you get older? I don't think so it's just one way to do it but it's definitely
not the only way or might not even be the best way. And speaking of buying a house check this
out people who are getting married right now are spending on average $36,000 to get married right
and the average home down payment is $55,000 today. Now the smart people are not having the big
expensive wedding and are using that money they would have spent on the wedding and buying the
house now especially if you want to have both if you want to get married and buy the house that's
definitely the smarter move. But now what a lot of people who are getting married are doing is
they are asking guests from the wedding to give them cash to help buy the house. Imagine that
they don't want the kitchen utensils anymore they don't want towels they don't want knickknacks or
things for the bathroom no no no no we want a down payment for the house. Check this out in a
survey of over 6,000 couples on Zola this year 87% of them are asking for cash for their wedding
and 41% are specifically requesting it for a home down payment. I don't have any problem giving
people cash for a wedding present in fact I gave my sister and her husband cash for a wedding
present I think that's the best thing to give actually and then they can do whatever they want
with it. But specifically outlining and asking people to help pay for the down payment on your
house I think there's just something that doesn't really sit well with me about that like here you
are spending a large chunk of change on this wedding but yet you want everybody coming to
it to give you more money so that way you can go ahead and buy a house. Like how does that make any
sense especially when probably half the people if not more than half the people attending your
wedding probably can't even afford to buy their own house. This is definitely a no shame approach
when it comes to wedding gifts I don't think I would even have the guts to ask people for the
money to help me buy a house if I'm sitting here spending ten twenty thousand dollars on a wedding
you know especially if you know for a fact that a lot of people are not doing well financially and
don't own their own home they're renters and you want me to give you my money so you can become a
homeowner. Like literally everybody wants the easy way out with everything now guys especially when
it comes to owning a home oh yeah give me a wedding gift to help me buy the house oh let's
see if mom and dad will just give me the down payment stuff like that they don't want to earn
it on their own anymore. And then the crazy thing is a lot of people asking for this money might not
even realize or know if they can even really afford a home or not because having the money for a down
payment doesn't mean that you're going to have the actual money to own the house and pay for all
the maintenance costs you know a 2024 study from bankrate found out that homeowners are spending
about eighteen thousand dollars a year on additional costs beyond the mortgage we're
talking things like your property taxes your insurance the maintenance around the house
I have covered this in the past and it's a lot of money and here's the funny thing about it too
they say well it's okay to do this but you got to be thoughtful about how you ask you should be
specific about the house you want to buy or where exactly the money's going things like that and
generally most people will be happy to contribute to it like okay whatever man but if you are going
to do this you better keep proper documentation because there are strict guidelines when it comes
to where the down payment money comes from when you're getting a loan so you need to be keeping
track of exactly how much you got from everybody and it all needs to be documented otherwise you
might not even be eligible to use that money for a down payment if you're going to go through
underwriting especially with a conventional mortgage you're going to have to show extensive
documentation on how you got that money if you didn't have it before you got married now for
anybody who's looking at where you can still find an affordable house to buy these days the good
news is there's actually still a lot of places out there according to the latest data from realtor.com
there's about 140 locations across the u.s. where the median listing price is sitting at
three hundred thousand dollars or less and i know that's still a lot of money for a house
but compared to the median price home in the united states being four hundred thousand dollars right
now that's still 25 percent cheaper now the majority of these places are in the south and
in the midwest and realtor.com marked these places as anywhere in the country where there's at least
1,000 listings and the median price was three hundred thousand dollars or lower and i'll put
up this infographic on the screen there's too many to read through here but their top 22 picks
are actually quite affordable and they're also all under three hundred thousand dollars sometimes by
a lot like the number one here being detroit michigan and the most expensive is san antonio
texas and there's still quite a few florida cities on this list as well and just by looking at this
infographic in the map there are places to go guys there are places where people can afford homes
it's just a matter of can you get a good paying job there and do you want to live there maybe you
can just get married and ask your friends and family to give you 50 grand and just move
but going back to the beginning of this video about a house being a forced savings account or
not i think that you really need to know yourself and you really need to understand how good you are
at saving and investing money and if you know you're somebody who's not very good at it then
buying a house could put you in a position where you have some money later down the road
but also if you're that irresponsible you may end up actually missing mortgage payments and you may
end up not being able to afford the home because too much of your money is going towards other
things so if you're somebody who's financially irresponsible it's a double-edged sword if you
never borrow against the house and you never miss your payments it could work out for you
but if you're somebody that's completely irresponsible you may end up blowing the
whole thing and would have been better off renting the whole time well let me know what
your thoughts are on it down below if you enjoyed this video make sure you subscribe to the channel
and if you don't want to wait for my next video to come out check out this one on the screen
right over here and i'll see you in the next one
