5-5-2 寫作批改
2 次觀看·2025年12月2日
這篇是學生寫的作文 我們來看看如何修改
這句topic sentence比較像在寫descriptive paragraph
描述性段落 描述最喜歡的歌手
但因為這篇是寫比較與對比的段落 我們建議這樣改
五月天和周杰倫都是我最喜愛的歌手 但他們的音樂風格不同
the first difference between them is the way to sing
把the way to sing改成the way of singing
the first difference is the way of singing
下面這句
Because Mayday is a band, Jay Chou is a male singer
這兩句並沒有因果關係 所以改成
Mayday is a band, while Jay Chou is a singer
用while連接
五月天是樂團 而周杰倫是歌手
a band can spread abundant expressions to influence audience's emotions on the stage by guitarists, bassists, and vocalists
因為樂團是由guitarists, bassists, and vocalists 組成的 所以要放到前面
a band consisting of two guitarists, a bassist, a vocalist, and a drummer
樂團是由兩個吉他手、一個低音吉他手、一個歌手和一個鼓手組成的
can spread abundant expressions 要改成
a band consisting of two guitarists, a bassist, a vocalist, and a drummer
原本的句子是
a band that consists of two guitarists, a bassist, a vocalist, and a drummer
因為let省略consists加ing 所以整句是
a band consisting of two guitarists, a bassist, a vocalist, and a drummer
can express abundant emotions on the stage
However, Jay Chou sings alone on the stage and he has a limitation in expressing various emotions
but he can build a wonderful atmosphere in concerts
這句沒什麼問題
這裡加上still
but he still can build a wonderful atmosphere in the concerts
加上定貫詞的
The second difference is their lyrics
The lyrics from Mayday always bring what we will do at different age and it deeply touches our heart
The lyrics from Mayday 改成
The lyrics of Mayday songs bring what we will do at different age
改成
express what we do at different ages
age 加 s
and deeply touch my heart
五月天的歌曲表達我們在不同年齡階段所做的事並讓我覺得感動
For Jay, the most important thing is his oriental style of music
His songs are put into the textbook by many schools
我們在前面加上
On the other hand, Jay is known for his oriental style of music
is known for 是以什麼文明的意思
第二句我們這樣改
His song lyrics which reflect Chinese culture have been incorporated into the school textbooks
他的歌詞反映了中國文化已被納入學校的教科書
The third difference is about Jim
Mayday wants to be popular around the world like Beatles
They also hope to write more and more unforgettable songs which people can easily whistle their tune
這裡 like Beatles 不用寫
因為不是這篇的主題
後面這一句 which 的用法是錯的
我們這樣改
They also hope to write unforgettable songs which people can easily remember
which 指的是前面的 songs
當 remember 的授詞
也可以改成這樣
They also hope to write unforgettable songs so that people can easily remember and whistle the tunes
As for Jay, he dreams to break his limits
His every popular song or album is a symbol of accomplishment for him
break his limits 改成 push the limits 是突破極限的意思
後面這一句這樣改
Each of his albums is a symbol of accomplishment
Albums 是專輯
a symbol of accomplishment 是成就的象徵
They chase their dreams through music
and use the music to change the world and make it better
因為這一句是結論句
我們在前面加上
Although Mayday and Jay Chou have different styles of music
they pursue their dreams through music
追求夢想 用 pursue 這一個字
and use the music to change the world and make it better
這是修改後的文章
A bassist, a vocalist, and a drummer can express abundant emotions on the stage
However, Jay Chou sings alone on the stage
and he has a limitation in expressing various emotions
but he still can build a wonderful atmosphere in the concert
The second difference is the lyrics
The lyrics of Mayday's songs always express what we do at different ages
and deeply touch my heart
On the other hand, Jay is known for his oriental style of music
His song lyrics, which reflect Chinese culture
have been incorporated into the school textbooks
The third difference is their dreams
Mayday wants to be popular around the world
They also hope to write unforgettable songs
so that people can easily remember and whistle the tunes
As for Jay, he is pushing the limits
Each of his albums is a symbol of accomplishment
Although Mayday and Jay Chou have different styles of music
They pursue their dreams through music
and use the music to change the world and make it better
這是段落的架構
Topic sentence
Both Mayday and Jay Chou are my favorite singers
but their styles of music are different
The first difference is the way of singing
The second difference is the lyrics
The third difference is their dreams
Concluding sentence
Although Mayday and Jay Chou have different styles of music
They pursue their dreams through music
and use the music to change the world and make it better
在這個單元,我們看了兩篇比較與對比的段落
Comparison and Contrast Paragraph
也看了兩篇作文的批改解說
我們學到此類型的文章結構有兩種
第一是Block Method
先列出前者的特點,再列出後者的特點
第二是Point by Point Method
分別就每項特點比較兩者的差異
整個段落裡
主題句先點出要比較的兩個事物
支持句比較兩者的相同點或不同點
結論句與主題句相呼應
為整個段落做結尾
這就是Comparison and Contrast Paragraph的寫法
相信學完這個單元
你也知道如何寫一篇比較與對比的段落

