Dave Chapelle on Andrew Yang's Universal Basic Income

Andrew Yang
1 follower
Dave Chappelle has endorsed Andrew Yang, and recently there was a campaign video featuring
Chappelle and his reasoning for why he feels Yang is the best candidate to represent the
country.
Now, let me just warn you guys, Chappelle has gotten a lot of backlash for what he says
in this video.
I'm really not interested in trashing Chappelle, but I do want to talk about the argument that
he makes here and just kind of dissect it with some facts and some statistics.
With that said, let's take a look.
You would take a poll in Dayton and say, what would you rather have, $12,000 a year or health
insurance?
Everyone's taking the money.
Health insurance is great, but groceries are necessary, too.
And people in Dayton are having a hard time getting the things they need.
I started imagining what a universal basic income would do for my community, and it would
save it almost instantly.
We recently suffered mass shootings and all kinds of, everything that happens in the news
happens in our backyard.
And I like the idea of giving people choices, putting the money in their hands and giving
them the choices.
They would consider things that aren't even an option to consider now.
And they can do things that aren't an option to do.
And that part of his platform I found incredibly exciting.
So there's so much to say about, in response to the argument made by Chappelle.
Again, I'm not interested in trashing him.
But I do think that we as Americans have been conditioned for such a long time to just be
happy with the crumbs that we're given.
That we think that we have to choose between putting food on the table for our children
or having a healthcare system that isn't broken.
We live in one of the richest countries in the world.
We work incredibly hard.
We're more productive every year, and we get less in return every year.
And so I think that this false choice that's being presented there, it's wrong.
And I don't think that, and even if you do have that false choice, right?
If you do have to choose between $12,000 a year, he's referring to Andrew Yang's universal
basic income proposal or healthcare.
Healthcare is, I mean, the system is so broken that almost every single American with the
exception of those at the very top of the economic ladder have suffered the consequences
of this broken healthcare system.
And so just to give you a few statistics real quick, half a million Americans go bankrupt
every single year from medical bills, half a million Americans in the richest country
in the world.
A study from the Harvard School of Medicine says that 45,000 people die every year due
to a lack of health insurance.
And therefore, a lack of access to ongoing medical care for a wide variety of treatable
conditions.
Also, the study conducted at Harvard Medical School and Cambridge Health Alliance found
that uninsured working age Americans have a 40% higher risk of death than their privately
insured counterparts, up from 25% excess death rate found in 1993.
So it actually gets worse every year, every decade.
And we shouldn't be given this false choice.
I don't have a problem with universal basic income.
I do have a problem with turning to that as the problem solver for everything.
It's not going to significantly improve the quality of Americans' lives.
Is it gonna help?
Yes, absolutely.
But I think that we need a more comprehensive approach.
And the way that Andrew Yang's policy is being proposed, it's not comprehensive enough to
address all of the things that Americans are really struggling with.
So that's where I stand on it.
Yeah, I have a few issues with it.
I mean, the starting point that Dave Chappelle seems to have is concern for people, and I
admire that.
I disagree with some of where he goes from there.
But fundamentally, he does care about people, and he's supporting a candidate that he thinks
is going to make the situation better for them.
I will buttress your point.
One of the best things about Andrew Yang running is that 50 times as many people know what
universal basic income is before.
But I hope that they don't come out of his candidacy thinking that all of the things
that Yang or his implementation of universal basic income, which is just one way to do
it.
It is not universal basic income.
It's a form of universal basic income.
It does not have to be at the expense of these other things.
There is no reason why universal basic income couldn't be added on to single-payer health
care, guaranteed employment, right to housing, all those sorts of things.
He has a philosophy that he has embedded UBI in.
It's not the only way to do it.
And I also, first of all, it's not gonna be $12,000 a year.
It will, of course, be taxed.
You'll lose some money to that.
And then for some people, if you don't have a lot of health care costs, then you'll be
up financially from having the money instead.
But for a lot of people, that's barely gonna cut into dealing with your heart attack or
God knows what medication.
And the thing is, that's why we shouldn't be having this conversation about one or the
other.
There's no reason why it has to be one or the other.
Absolutely, yeah.
And the thing is, I don't even know to what extent the way that Dave is expressing it
is necessarily the way that Andrew Yang wants it to be talked about.
And it's not like he doesn't have a health care plan, he does.
It's just not previously what he talked about is Medicare for All.
He's not interested in that anymore.
Right, it's not as robust as what Bernie Sanders is proposing.
And by the way, at this point, it's 100% confirmed.
In a recent interview with NPR, Elizabeth Warren made it clear that she is in favor
of a public option as opposed to Medicare for All.
I'm just saying that because when we say that Bernie Sanders is the only candidate for Medicare
for All, he genuinely is.
Now Yang, look, I think that universal basic income is a great proposal.
And I think that Yang as a candidate has been fascinating.
He's brought important issues to the table.
I think that he's made the Democratic primaries a lot more interesting.
And my hope is that candidates learn from one another, right?
And so I think that universal basic income can be super helpful in a robust systemic
change where you address all the other issues, including housing, including health care.
And you're right, we don't know if Andrew Yang is in favor of the type of messaging
that was portrayed in that Chappelle video.
But what I do know is that we as Americans, as average Americans, people in the working
class and the middle class, we need to fight back and push back against this narrative
where people expect us to be happy with a little bit of change or maybe changing policy
when it comes to one area.
Like no, we produce a lot in this country, and there's a lot of wealth in this country.
The problem is that the system makes it so it's not distributed properly.
And so that's what I think we need to address, and it needs to be a systemic change, not
one policy or the other.
Yeah, yeah, and yeah, obviously they're not enemies, Sanders and Yang.
Like Yang was just talking about potentially his supporters maybe supporting Bernie in
Iowa if he doesn't reach the threshold, which it looks like at this point he won't.
There is some ideological overlap, and they are similar on some issues.
But obviously, their approach to governance, their political philosophy is very different.
I don't wanna oversimplify anything, and I've made clear where my allegiance lies.
Obviously, I've already endorsed Bernie Sanders, so take everything I say about other candidates
with a grain of salt, but that's what I think.
