Why the Strong Jobs Report Hides an AI Problem

Andrew Yang
1 follower
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis discussion explores the paradox of the current job market, where overall employment growth masks a crisis for young graduates. While AI drives GDP and infrastructure growth, it simultaneously disrupts entry-level white-collar roles, leading to widespread underemployment and a need for a new social contract regarding skills and economic security.
Well, the October jobs report was surprisingly strong.
Unemployment fell to 4.1%.
Moody's Mark Zandi, he tweeted this.
It's a kind of provocative argument.
AI is actually creating more jobs than it is.
destroying. It's not really provocative here in San Francisco,
but elsewhere it certainly is.
Let's widen the lens, though, because tech companies,
they are cutting jobs. We saw this
from ServiceNow, Block, Canva over the last few weeks.
Sometimes it's not cutting, it's just
lowering hiring. And you hear words today like efficiency
and de-layering on earnings calls.
For young workers, some of those entry-level opportunities,
they're just disappearing before
they can even get a foot in the door.
So two things can be true here. AI can be an engine
of economic growth i
It can also fundamentally disrupt the way that people make a living.
Our next guests are approaching
this from two very different perspectives.
Clara Shai helped build the AI tools driving
this transformation as Salesforce's former AI CEO.
She was also at Meta.
She's now executive director of the New Work,
Foundation. We've also got Andrew Yang, CEO of Noble Mobile.
He's been warning about automation
and job displacement for years,
founding investor to that same organization. And the foundation
focused on helping workers adapt to an economy being reshaped by AI.
Clara, Andrew, thank you
so much for being here with me today. Thanks for having us.
Thanks for having us.
OK, so, Clare, maybe let's start with you.
When you see a chart like this from Zandi that says sort of,
look at this picture, jobs
are growing, I know that's not what you hear
from the young people that you work with that
you're trying to help.
Yeah, well, I mean, first of all,
I think it's fantastic that we are adding more jobs overall.
And I very much believe in AI as an engine
for driving growth in our economy and in the global
economy. We very much need that.
But I think among these aggregate stats, we lose a lot of the
specific granular data around who's actually getting these jobs.
It's really more tenured
folks versus the junior folks
who are entering the worst job market in 37 years.
And then it's also a lot of these jobs
are not as high paying as some of the jobs that
college grads expect to go into.
And that's really the problem we're focused on solving.
Right. And that's what sort of this chart
from Mark Zandi glosses over. Andrew, I said it was
kind of a provocative argument,
maybe outside of Silicon Valley, but everyone I talked to here,
at least, is sort of pitching saying, you know,
maybe there's going to be an initial period of
discomfort while we figure it all out.
But ultimately, there's going to be more jobs.
There's going to be more productivity.
There's going to be better jobs. How do you see it?
I think there's going to be top line GDP growth
and productivity growth among
public companies and enterprises.
But you have to take into account that right now,
a lot of the growth that Mark Zandi is pointing out
is infrastructure spend to the tune of $2
to $3 trillion. So of course,
that's going to end up creating many jobs in the build-out.
Simultaneously, you have Microsoft offering to buy out 60,000 employees
and public companies laying people off right and left.
What Clara is saying is,
Very much represented right now in the 42
to 50 percent of recent college graduates
are underemployed and 25 percent
of small private colleges are set to close in the next
10 years.
So you're seeing a massive compression
in the benefit that college graduates used to
enjoy, which is thinking that you're going
to have a stable white collar job in front
of you.
Some of the opportunities that are getting created
are in different parts of the country
for people who are much, much handier.
Right. So what you're saying is essentially sort
of the huge data center build out,
which is costing hundreds of billions, trillions of dollars a year,
maybe masking some of the white collar jobs or jobs for early grads.
Clara, what can they do about it?
Well, I think that's the key is let's focus on what type
of action we can take across different stakeholder groups.
For what we're doing, we're focused on DRCC. It's a Gen Z platform.
We want to give people real time job market data
so that they can be smarter about.
Which jobs are applying to what they're studying in the first place,
whether they even want to go
to college. Two is giving them the AI skills,
hands-on skills to build AI agents, whether it's
for marketing or for a law job or for accounting.
Everyone needs to be very proficient with AI.
And so many colleges and universities today
are just not preparing people.
And then third is we want to give people a community
because, you know, I think it feels
isolating sometimes to be at home
and move back into your parents' basement after finishing
your degree.
And we want young people to know that they're not alone
and this isn't their fault, but
it is their future and they can own it and we're here to help them.
So you give them access to real-time job market data,
but what if the whole picture is shifting?
I mean, what can they do if just
those jobs aren't there anymore, Andrew?
No, I think they do have to get scrappy and resourceful.
I talk about folks going old
school, and I'm old enough to remember
when parents were calling other parents, nudging
them to say, hey, can you find my son or daughter an internship?
Even if it's not the kind of job
that you ordinarily need a college degree to do.
Right now, the labor force participation rate in
the U.S. is under 62%,
which is anomalously low among industrialized countries. One third of
Working-age American men is out of the workforce right now,
and this is before AI really starts
eviscerating white-collar jobs in various organizations.
So the folks who think this is going to magically sort itself out,
I mean, it's not happening
in the numbers right now.
Americans are moving across state lines at generationally low rates,
which is the opposite
of what you would be seeing if we
were actually dynamically rearranging ourselves.
So that the young people, instead of trying to become accountants,
were getting on tool belts
and becoming electricians or HVAC repair people.
Like a lot of that stuff right now is wish casting.
But in reality, more people are going home,
living in their parents' basement,
Thanks, man.
and unfortunately becoming further away
from the workforce, not closer to it.
I guess as a country, too, which way do we want to go, Andrew?
I mean, when you say go old school,
kids ask their parents, friends for jobs.
That doesn't sound particularly encouraging for everyone, right?
There's only a certain group of people who can do that.
And it leads to things like nepotism and such.
So how do you fix this structurally?
Very much so, Deidre.
I mean, I wish I had better news.
But the big thing is for young people to take what's there,
which in many cases will be the—
service job, the retail job,
the job that actually will help them stay out in the world
and not just be at home getting depressed
that no one cares about the degree that they got
and then hope that you end up creating opportunities
and develop skills that
will actually be relevant.
That's actually the push I would urge for young folks,
along with what Clara is saying, which is as a parent,
and I'm a parent, I've got teenage
Kids, you know, it's not their fault.
You want to be like Robin Williams in Good Will Hunting,
where you give them a hug and
say, it's not your fault.
It's not your fault.
But then, you know, get out of the house.
Right. I mean, even this idea, Clara, of upskilling,
of making sure that you know and you have the right tools,
they are improving so quickly.
Like even yesterday, you know,
something that Claude released in terms of sheets that looked
a lot like Excel caused Microsoft to drop in the markets.
It's moving like how can individuals,
especially young graduates looking for jobs, keep up with all of this?
And even if they learn the right tools, like...
Those tools could just displace them.
So speak to that argument that I hear a lot
from folks here is that we're not going to
eliminate jobs.
We're just going to upskill.
I remember like a few examples is, you know, a sales rep can do more.
They're going to be upskilled.
They're going to do things that they're more interested in.
You clearly aren't agreeing with that.
Well, I think you're right.
I mean, it's not just about a specific skill
and a specific point in time.
AI is improving so fast
and we're now at a point of AI is improving AI.
So it's called percussive self-improvement.
And so what that means
and what the message we always give to people
when they join DRCC
is it's not about your credential.
It's not even about your skill.
It's your ability to continuously skill.
And it's that first derivative that is so important.
And it's hard to take that first step, right?
It's like going to the gym.
But once you're there, then you're in, you're committed.
It's actually not that bad.
And the more you do it, the more you actually enjoy it
and start to see the benefits.
A quick one for you, Andrew.
Are you seeing recursive self-improvement becoming closer to us?
And what happens then?
Yeah. Well, once that happens,
the goal post starts sprinting away from us. And I do have
a joke in this. I'm a little bit older than you guys.
So I'm 51. And so if I don't get dumber in
a given month, it was a good month.
Meanwhile, AI might get twice as smart that month. So having
people somehow get a certificate or adjust their approach
and expecting them to remain relevant in
the workforce, it's just going to get harder and harder.
You know, we have to think bigger and
And society-wide, Dario Amodei, a number of months ago,
said, look, tax us, like tax tokens,
start allocating the gains more quickly and broadly.
I think that's a conversation we should be having.
You know, I obviously ran for president in 2020
on universal basic income, and I get stopped
in the street every day saying, man, you know, we wish we had that now.
So I'm like a...
An all hands on deck, both approaches,
like I'm for anything that's going to help.
But I also want to be realistic.
What percentage of folks do you think are cut out
to be entrepreneurs or entrepreneurial
even?
I mean, in my mind, it's like five to 10%.
So having that be a nationwide recommendation
to me just isn't realistic.
Yeah, I would say and.
I would say, we need to make sure we're,
we address the affordability issue. We have to
people need to have enough money to feel secure.
And I would say that a lot of the young people
who are coming to us, they don't want a handout.
They want an opportunity, right? They want a
purpose. They want to be part of something that matters.
And so that's, that's what for so many
years jobs gave us that. And so we need a new,
new social contract in this country.
Well, Claire and Andrew, great to get
your insights. I hope you'll come back.
This issue is not going anywhere. Thank you both very much.
Thanks so much.
Thank you.
Thanks for having me.
You're welcome.
