What's Next for Basic Income?

Andrew Yang
1 follower
Oct 14, 2025 #Andrewyang #Politicians
I wish that we could have done a better job of really getting people to see the importance of UBI
by doing a lot of other things. I really want to see, say, a coal miners pilot somewhere like West
Virginia or something like that. That would be great. It's like if you have different types of
populations in different more rural areas, I think it would be compelling to different groups. And we
need the data. From my perspective, we have the data. We know that it works. It's just that I
want people to see the importance of it themselves and see themselves in these pilot participants.
That's where kind of what we're not doing. By focusing on these like a lower,
smaller subset of demographics, it's not reaching everybody that it could.
It is my pleasure to welcome back to the podcast, my guru in all things UBI,
the man who came up with not left, not right, but forward, which he's wearing, if you can see him.
Advisor to Humanity Forward, Scott Santens. Welcome, Scott.
Hey, Andrew. Good to see you.
Yeah. We were just joking and laughing how you were the one who said to me,
UBI is not left or right, it's forward in 2017 or 2018. And I said, ooh, that's genius.
Then a couple of years later, I used that as a closing in one of the debates.
And then now it's on a t-shirt or actually multiple t-shirts as I think about it.
But you got into UBI before it was a thing. And I'm sincere in saying that I just learned
most all of it from you. You and I first met in New Orleans in, was that 2017?
That wasn't where we first met, I don't think. I think we met for the first time in California.
At the Cache Conference?
Yeah. Or before that, even. One of the smaller conferences before the Cache Conference.
Yeah. So I learned a lot from you. And then we fought it out all the way through Iowa,
New Hampshire. I vividly remember hanging out with you in Iowa in January 2020.
Yeah. Before everything turned upside down.
Before everything turned upside down. Yeah. And then it's been a bit of a buzzsaw,
shutdown for COVID and a bunch of other things. But I wanted to talk to you about the latest and
greatest with UBI. And I'm going to precede our discussion talking about my outlook for UBI and
on UBI. So I run for president on it. I like to think that we helped, you, me, and a lot of other
people in the Yang gang helped mainstream it, where before that presidential campaign,
it wasn't really a thing. And then it became a thing. We had some version of it during COVID
with the relief checks and the enhanced child tax credit. It gets mistakenly blamed for inflation
later, which is very upsetting and frustrating and troubling. Because everyone's like, oh,
you sent checks out and then prices go up. It's like, well, if you do the math,
you realize that the checks were a very, very small component of the 5 trillion that went out.
I try to explain to people, it's like, look, $5 trillion is 15, 16,000 ahead. Do you remember
sending out 15, 16,000 ahead? You sent out maybe one or two grand ahead. So what the hell happened
to the other 13, 14 grand? And I try and paint a picture. It's like, well, it went into the
financial system, it went to big corporates, it went to states, it went to cities, went to
all the stuff. So they flood the zone with money. The efficacy of cash relief actually gets borne
out during this period, particularly through the enhanced child tax credit. You and I team up to
start Humanity Forward in 2020 to try and advance these policies that you are, I'm right that you're
still officially an advisor, right? And you moved from New Orleans to Washington, DC. Good fun.
So you and I helped kick off Humanity Forward that's still trying to advance these policies
in a nonpartisan, bipartisan way with a focus right now on trying to revive the child tax credit.
And I got to say, I was so sad and frustrated when the child tax credit was discontinued
at the beginning of last year. I'm still pushing for these policies. I concluded, and I think you
agree because you were one of the people that also put me onto this, since I tend to take your
lead on a lot of things, that the two-party system actually is part of the issue because it
locks things up and makes it so it's very hard to advance meaningful policies that stand the
test of time. And I became convinced that reforming our democratic structures actually
precedes solving very meaningful problems. So I'm still marching after the same stuff,
but I feel like there are some things we have to resolve in order to get these things done.
So that's my very lengthy preamble, most of which is old news to you. So during that time,
you have been tirelessly advocating for UBI day in, day out. What is the latest on your front?
I would also just say too, just as a little bit more preamble, and maybe we'll get into a little
bit more later too, because I think it is important about any discussion about UBI
when it comes to inflation and people blaming the stimulus checks and everything that we did
on the inflation that we're seeing. It's just kind of crazy to me too that we were in a pandemic,
like a once-in-a-century pandemic just happened and over a million Americans are dead now because
of it. And it's just crazy to me to think that we just look at that kind of extreme circumstance
with heavily constrained global supply lines and just all sorts of things happening, and then look
at the cash as being something we did wrong when absolutely we need to do that. And then the other
side of this too is that people don't see what we didn't see because we did the cash. And so even
the debate then too at the time was, if we don't do this, if we don't get money to people, then we
could potentially lose over $10 trillion. The GDP would have been depressed. It would have
taken a lot longer to get back to where we are now. It would have been worse in the Great Recession.
It's incredible that we were able to do what we did. And I think it's absolutely smart what we
did. But then we actually ignore what we're not seeing. We're not in another second Great Depression
because of what we did. But people are complaining about inflation. Sure, inflation is something that
impacts everybody. But really, it could have been so much worse than what we saw. So you just want
to get that out of the way too. But part of this that I observed is, sure enough, because of the
pandemic, UBI started to be talked about in a different way. And people started to see this as
something that was important that we actually should have had before the pandemic happened,
how positively that would have impacted everything to actually have the floor underneath people.
We saw what happened when people suddenly had to go through the unemployment insurance systems
state by state, and how some states were better than others. And we saw massive food bank lines.
The grocery stores had food. It could have been so much better if we had UBI. So I think people
felt that and see that now for themselves. Then we come out of this, and people start
complaining about there's a labor shortage, that nobody wants to work anymore. And they're
blaming this on the stimulus. They're blaming it on unemployment and everything. But really,
it's just kind of amazing that we actually were able to get where we are now as far as
getting the labor participation rate back up. But at the time, as it's going back up,
people are looking at a labor shortage, and there's coming up all kinds of stuff.
And then at that point, automation became like a joke. I thought it was crazy how you were even
like the butt of jokes of being like, oh, Andrew Yang said that everyone would be out of a job,
and yet we can't find anyone to work. So that was laughable. And so automation became like this joke.
And then all of a sudden, I feel that all changed last November when ChatGPT launched. That was a
total game changer in the entire conversation, where suddenly people were like, oh my gosh,
this is serious. AI can do some magical things. And so suddenly we're in this world
where AI is just like, it's right there. It's happening as we see it. It's happening in real
time in a way that people were making fun of even just a year ago. And now here we are.
One of the things I find frustrating, Scott, is people are like, what do you mean automation?
People can't find people to work. And it's like, well, you know those two things actually
can happen at the same time. Companies can be investing gazillions of dollars in automating
various roles, and you have a hard time getting people to show up for job X or job Y,
particularly if those jobs are frankly punitive or undercompensated or whatever the heck the
situation is. So I agree with you that the conversation definitely changed when ChatGPT
came online. Everyone was like, wait a minute, this thing can do what I do.
This thing scores an 88th percentile on the bar exam. It's like better than most attorneys
probably manage. So for me, the trend has just been ongoing the whole time. I mean, even during
COVID when people were sent home, I saw one survey that said that almost half of companies said they
were investing more in automation. And by the way, if you're working remotely, you are one step
to automate. And to your point, it's just going to get stronger and faster. I saw a tweet you put
out saying, hey, I thought that maybe we could get UBI up before AI came and got us all, but
now it's too late. And I did not disagree with your estimation. I do think it's changed the
conversation. I would love to hear some more of what you've been seeing on that front. So November
happens, ChatGPT comes online, it gets better in March. And then now is everyone saying like,
huh, maybe we should revisit UBI? What's the tenor? So for years now, I've made a point of
just regularly kind of tracking what people are saying about base income on Twitter. And yeah,
there was during the pandemic, it was pandemic stuff. And then there was that kind of like a
dead zone where it kind of dropped off with inflation rising and automation not being
cared about. ChatGPT comes out. And now I would say since then, there's just like a growing
conversation, just all sorts of people on Twitter. Like I know that I didn't notice them before,
because I also make a point of trying to follow anyone who is like speaking favorably about basic
income. So I kind of like can keep track of, oh, this is a person is new or not in talking about it.
That's one reason we love you, Scott. You catalog all things UBI related.
Yeah. And so recently, I've just, there's so many new people that people I hadn't already
been following speaking favorably about basic income. And a lot of this is just the automation
argument. Like it'll be in response to someone talking about automation, something talking about
ChatGPT or mid journey or some other AI tool that's out there. And people will be like, oh,
this is crazy. I don't know what's going to happen. And then there's just so many times
there's someone in the replies saying, we're going to need to do universal basic income.
And so it's really just part and parcel of this conversation in a way that it wasn't prior to
the pandemic. So I had gotten into UBI even originally through the automation argument
back in 2013. And that kind of kicked off this kind of new wave of interest in basic income.
But even then, people were talking about automation, but they weren't talking about
basic income. I was trying to inject that into the conversation. And you wrote a book about it,
trying to inject that into the conversation. So here we are both trying to get people to
connect automation with basic income. And now it's on autopilot now. People who are talking
about automation and talking about what's going on, UBI is part of the conversation.
You guys already know all about ExpressVPN. I've talked before about why they are the go-to
service for protecting your online activity. Big tech should not be snooping on us and profiting
from what we do in our private time. ExpressVPN can also help access content, including thousands
of Netflix shows that might be available in another market. You just beam in, encrypted
surreptitiously, and you can be a UK user. And all of a sudden, all that fun BBC content can be yours.
I could go on and on about ExpressVPN. It's the VPN that I trust. And I'm not surprised that
CNET, Wired, and others have rated it number one. Visit expressvpn.com slash yang right now and get
three extra months of their service for free. That's E-X-P-R-E-S-S-V-P-N dot com slash yang.
Expressvpn.com slash yang to learn more. So now people are into, okay, we're definitely
going to automate away a significant number of jobs. And then they also think, well, we're going
then they're going to think, well, we're going to need UBI. So what should we do next? I had a
conversation with a member of Congress yesterday. And she was favorable on UBI and the child tax
credit and some other things. And one of the issues that we discussed was that mayors for
guaranteed income, the organization got started in 2020. And I want to say the vast majority of
the mayors and mayors for guaranteed income are Democrats, maybe all of them actually,
and not just Democrats, but also Democrats of color, often black. It's thrilling that
there are so many basic income pilots and trials being rolled out around the country.
Yeah. So a couple of things along those lines. First, I would say that it was a great thing
that mayors for guaranteed income formed and over a hundred mayors so far have signed on to this. And
I believe over, I think 50 now have either been done already or are active or in the planning
stages. So that's great. One thing I feel that I wish would have been more part of this was
contextualizing UBI more through these. So one way of, I think it's important to look at these pilots
is people will look at this and go, well, that's not universal. That's not testing universality.
That's testing some specific demographic. So maybe it's kids exiting foster care or pregnant
mothers. A very worthy population. Yeah. There's some various populations out there, artists,
just so many others. And if you look at this and say, okay, if there was a universal basic income,
then all artists would get it. And so how would that impact artists? So then if you look at just
a subset and look at 2000 artists, then you're actually able to see what would be the impact
of UBI on that group. And then so hopefully all artists after seeing this can see, oh,
this is how much of a benefit it would have to me. And then you can build up these constituencies,
each of these pilots. That's how I wish they would have gone to really try to get all sorts
of different demographics and not to repeat the same one in another place, but really try to do
different things all over. Unfortunately, that's not what happened. And some cities are even just
boosting their earned income tax credit or something like that, where that already exists.
It's nothing new. It's just utilizing this excitement for basic income pilots to just
channel funds through existing mechanisms. And so on that, I'm disappointed in that way about those
kinds of things. I wish that we could have done a better job of really getting people to see the
importance of UBI by doing a lot of other things. I really want to see, say, a coal miners pilot
somewhere like West Virginia or something like that. It's like if you have different types of
populations in different more rural areas, I think it would be compelling to different groups. And we
need the data. And I would say we need those stories. From my perspective, we have the data.
We know that it works. It's just that I want people to see the importance of it themselves
and see themselves in these pilot participants. And I think that's what we're not doing, is
by focusing on a smaller subset of demographics, it's not reaching everybody that it could.
So that's one thing. On a more also kind of a depressing point or a frustration point for me,
this is another result of the pandemic and everything that we saw. So as the pandemic
happens, you see this boost in anti-vaccination and conspiracy groups and even just conspiracy
theories in general kind of get a boost and they spread in a way that I've never seen before.
I think social media is especially designed to amplify this kind of stuff. And so as part of
this, I think that the origin point of this was the Freedom Convoy in Canada. And when the
Prime Minister Trudeau there in Canada responded to the convoy and how that they were there in
Ottawa and just blocking everything and preventing things from happening there and not leaving,
then he took actions there that just really inflamed this whole community. And as a result
of that, UBI is now something that a lot of people in this conspiracy theory world now fear.
And they see it as a tool of control. They say that it's the World Economic Forum and Klaus Schwab
wants to control everything. He's the real world leader and he wants to trick you into being under
his control by having a basic income. What's funny, man, is if you send me money, it probably
makes me freer, not less free, but go on. Yeah, yeah. So a lot of the times I'll say,
do you think seniors on social security are less free? And of course not. Seniors on social security,
they're the ones who the government responds to. Like they vote in large numbers. Yeah,
they're the most important constituency out there. Right, right. And so I think they see
basic income and they say, oh, you're supported by the government and therefore the government
can take it away from you and utilize that as a means of control. And even though that's exactly
how welfare works, that's something that's controlled and conditional. But basic income
is not that. It's universal and unconditional. But they're kind of like afraid of this, say,
fake UBI, this UBI that isn't. And now they're saying like, oh, it's going to be attached to
CBDCs. CBDCs are programmable money. So the government will prevent you from buying what
you actually want to buy. They're getting rid of cash. Like all these things and UBI is right up
in there. So it's like if you talk to somebody who is, say, anti-world economic forum,
they're also anti-15-minute cities, they're anti-vaccine, they're anti-bug eating, which
they think that like the like Klaus Schwab and the elites of the world want to force us all to
eat bugs instead of hamburgers. Like there's some really weird stuff out there, but UBI is part of
it. And that's been really frustrating to see. So I wouldn't say that UBI has become polarized,
but I would say that there is a constituency that's mostly on the right that believes in
this stuff and therefore has come to see UBI as this like evil thing. And yeah, that's very
frustrating me to have seen that be one of the outcomes of the pandemic.
There's been this like giant plummeting in institutional trust and capacities and it's
been, I mean, it's been like bizarre. I felt it too at times. If you had a more functional system,
so we're talking about automation as one topic. One of the things that makes me incredibly
frustrated is that, let's say that ChatGPT does eat a few million jobs in the next year,
two years, whatever the time frame is. How would we even know at this point? You know what I mean?
Would there be this media consensus saying like, yup, that happened, you know, like we used to
have X million office workers and now we don't, like this thing's real, time for the government
to do something. Like that entire set of steps that you might imagine would happen in a more
functional system now, even I don't believe would happen. You know, it's like, I mean,
I'm continuously looking at it. I can always get to try to parse. It's like, what is happening out
there? And you have the party in power saying like, things are great. And then the party out
power being like, things are terrible. And folks are responding to those arguments really based
upon which side they favor. You know, if you had, let's say nonpartisan primaries and ranked choice
voting, and then everyone had to like actually deliver or lose their jobs as opposed to now,
it's like, you know, I can deliver, I cannot deliver, it doesn't really matter. As long as
I try and keep the 10 to 12% of the primary voters happiest, you know, then the problems don't really
matter. That like the automation doesn't matter. It's like, you know, really the question is how
our political system will respond in real life. And I confess, you know, like my optimism about
that is lower than it might have been back in 2018 or 2019. No, mine's plummeted. I'm so glad
to hear you say that. I mean, I'm not because it's super upsetting. But also I see you as extraordinarily
lucid. You know, you're like lucid, rational and practical. Things that I imagine myself to be on
good days, you know what I mean? It's like, okay, how are we going to get this ---- done in real life?
And yeah, like you're, you're like looking at it. I mean, hell, you even moved to DC to help try and
make this ---- happen. And, and, and your faith in these institutions being rational, it sounds like
has gone the same direction mine has. Yeah, it's and it's not only the, like, it's not only, let's
say the American institutions, I think it's even just an issue, you know, with with just government
itself. So even if we had like a highly reactive government, I think that we're looking at a
situation where, you know, a highly effective government has to be highly effective in trying
to figure out just how far ahead of the player to throw the football in order to, you know, get the
like, technology is happening, you know, AI is happening so quickly. That, you know, even even
if you're in it, and you're like focused on it, and you can you can still just be just taken aback
by how quickly it's happening. Yeah, I mean, technologists are freaking out about how fast
yeah, they're like, no way. The rate of paper publication right now is there's already up to
4,000 papers a month. And this is growing at a logarithmic scale, it's just a straight line
going up. But at a normal scale, it's just, you know, you're looking at the hockey puck.
But even just like trying the process of like, all right, what are all the things that are happening?
Where is the state of the art right now? And then suddenly, something new happens. And then
something new happens again, another new study. And that's just one person me trying to keep up
on everything. So if one person is having a hard time, how the heck do you like actually get members
of Congress to be up to speed on this? Like, even if they had, if each person had a staff member,
right, like they would each have to have one full time AI staff member whose entire job was to stay
up to date. And then they would try to, let's say, get them up to speed, maybe like a half hour a day
or something. But even then, they're not going to be fully up to date, because of the difficulty
of doing that. And then how do you actually legislate this kind of stuff? Like, there's so
many unknowns, and the unknowns are constantly shifting. And so yeah, we're just in a situation
where I'm just thinking, oh, my gosh, like, we so desperately need UBI to be in place already,
just to handle all these changes. And just people have no idea. And they're, they're not going to
get it until like, even when things are going so quickly. And you know, it's even more important
than I don't know when they're actually going to figure this out. But I definitely have no hope
in them doing this before. Like, people have a lot of issues, you know, there's going to be,
you know, I think maybe something like we saw before, like during the pandemic, you know, like,
just kind of this feeling of anarchy is as people, you know, get really upset and, and go out in the
streets and stuff. Like, I don't know, I don't, I'm an optimist at heart. But I just think that,
like I said, like you mentioned earlier, it's too late. And the question is, what can we possibly do
now to do this as as quickly as possible and to do everything else we need to do about AI?
Indeed, my friend. So I'm on the same wavelength, I will say that, according to my wife, who's an
excellent authority on these things, she said that, hey, if someone were to run around championing UBI
on the presidential trail, she's like, they would do really well. Because at this point,
there's so many Americans who are like, oh, we actually could do that.
You know, like, I quite liked it. I mean, my wife has very good instincts. Like I haven't seen any
of the latest numbers to that effect. But I do think that there's a lot of pessimism, a lot of
confusion around the inflation phenomenon. I also think this economy is likely to tip into recession
sometime this next number of months. And so in many ways, like I'm starting to project forward
being like, okay, well, you know, after things head south, like there still will be a rebuild
of some kind. You know, one thing I'm optimistic about with the Ford Party is like, people are
going to be like, well, you know, it's time for something new. Like, what the heck do I do? And,
you know, if you're busy building something new, then people might be attracted to it.
I also have a belief that there's going to be a surge in interest in the Ford Party as soon
as people realize that their choices might be Joe Biden and Donald Trump again. They'll be like,
wait a minute. This doesn't seem very functional, very smart. I'm not that excited about that. It's
like, wait, what was Yang doing? I think Yang was trying to do something that maybe makes this
less carved in stone. So I'm with you on being pessimistic. You know, I'm with you,
one, I'd like, I consider myself an optimistic fellow and a can-do fellow. I mean, you know,
like what you've done, holy ----. Yeah, yeah. I mean, what you've done is like epic. I mean,
you were like, hey, I want to write about UBI. Maybe I should get myself a UBI. Hey guys,
you want to get me a UBI so I can write about UBI? It's like, oh, hey, UBI is awesome. I'm like a
example. I mean, that's a very can-do positive spirit. You know, at the same time, you know,
it's like, like I'm also seeing the same things you're seeing and being like, wow,
this system doesn't really care. This system doesn't really care so much about
whatever the heck is happening. Yeah. Everything gets transformed into partisan talking points.
And you know, I'm not looking forward to AI being transformed into a partisan matter either. Like,
fortunately right now, it's not. So it's really interesting that there's at least
one thing that people don't know what side to be on right now and what that side is and how to talk
about it. Because, you know, the politicians, again, they're so far behind when it comes to AI
that they don't even know how to talk about it in terms of partisanship. But that's coming. And,
you know, I really am not excited about when that comes and how that plays out.
This podcast is sponsored by Helix Sleep. Having a good mattress has always struck me as one of
the best investments you can make because you spend a lot of time on that mattress and having
a healthy night's sleep gives you energy for the day, keeps you healthy, makes you capable of doing
all the things you want to do. Why would you sleep on a mattress that's made for someone other than
you, especially in 2023? With Helix Sleep, you can take a personalized quiz, get one of their 14
unique mattresses sent right to your door, have a 100-night trial and a 10-plus year warranty.
Yeah, they have that much confidence in their products in part because they're manufactured
right here in the USA and it's the number one mattress picked by GQ and Wired magazine.
Helix is offering 20% off all mattress orders and two free pillows. For our listeners,
go to helixsleep.com. This is their best offer yet and it won't last long.
With Helix, better sleep starts now. If someone wants to follow you and support you
on your explorations, how can they best do so and what do you feel your time doing aside from
voting up on all things AI and then being pushed out of date like days later?
I recommend that people follow me on Twitter. That's my main location. I have a pinned thread
there of evidence that I always recommend people check out. My site is scottsantans.com. I got a
UBI FAQ there to help people learn about basic income. My Patreon is patreon.com. People can
help with that. One of the things I've been working on lately is that I think this is
important. This goes into what we were just talking about as far as what do we do and if
government isn't doing what it needs to do. I feel that we just need to get UBI going.
I think CoMingle is a platform that I think is potentially key to this. I've been focusing more
on hopefully trying to get that off the ground. CoMingle is a platform where essentially people
would sign up and self-impose a 7% flat tax on themselves. That would result in a full UBI that's
equal for every participant. I think that's a real demonstration of people being net recipients
and net payers. People go, if they hear about basic income, why does Bill Gates get a basic
income too? Without understanding that Bill Gates is going to be paying a lot more into UBI than he
is getting out of it. It's just this really great way of, instead of means testing and phasing out
naturally through the tax system, through the math of it all, having it such that those who
receive the most have the lowest incomes and those who pay in the most are net payers and not net
recipients. I want that kind of tool. I want to be able to actually put my money where my mouth is
and say, I want to donate a net impact of say, whatever it is, $200 a month or something that
would go to hopefully tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of people in small increments across
everybody. That tool doesn't really exist yet. It can exist and it's in alpha stage right now.
It's not just vaporware. I think that tools like that, tools that actually just go, okay,
technology is here. We need to do something about it. Let's just use technology. Let's just try to
actually get these things going. Hopefully, if you can get some kind of small basic income to people,
some kind of increased economic security to people, then that will empower them and enable them
hopefully tone down a little bit of the insecurity and stress that's leading to these other issues
and hopefully open people's minds and open the door to legislation by people actually
understanding it and being more empowered by it. That's even what I'm thinking that we need to do
at this point is just like figure out ways of directly doing this in order to spark what needs
to be done at a larger level. I love it, Scott. We can't wait around for government to get its
act together. Let's just try and take shots on goal and solve problems ourselves. It actually
reminds me of a meeting I had this week with this incredible entrepreneur who's working on a data
rights plan and startup that I think could actually work in the real world where it's like
no one's waiting around. If you said, hey, what do I think the prospects are of the government
making it so that we have agency over our own data and maybe we can get paid? I'd be like,
in the US, pretty slim, but this guy is like, oh, I've got a plan to make it happen.
I heard his plan. I was like, that plan's really good. It's similar to what you're
saying. It's like, look, maybe there are solutions that can be built independent of
policy because that's what we should be doing. These solutions need to help illustrate the
arguments to really make them real for people. Even when it comes to an AI dividend utilizing
the data, it's interesting to see this kind of conversation unfold the way it's been.
I've been making the argument that, especially recently, that, hey, when it comes to large
language models, basically the internet trained all these things. That was me, even. You can ask
GPT-4 about me and it'll know me based on my writing and it can actually write like me based
on my writing because it's been trained on my work. I'm happy about that. I'm glad that I actually
had a bunch of stuff out there on the internet. You're glad there's a smidgen of Scott Santens
in the AI. There's a little slice of me. There's a bigger slice of you than there is of most of us,
Scott, because you've been putting a lot of stuff out there. This thing is 1 billion Scott and 1
trillion the rest of us. From that perspective, I'm happy that my voice, my work is part of this
and it can reach people that way. But shouldn't you get 1 billionth of the value? Right. It's just saying
that all of us contributed to this. All of us, through all of our writing and texts and tweets
and everything that we've done has helped to make this possible. Your tweets made this possible.
All of our ridiculous tweets helped train AI to learn how to predict the next word
based on everything that we've done. This is just recently. In the last week or so,
you've seen a lot of companies starting to clamp down on their API usage and saying,
we don't want these large models to actually be using our data anymore. You should pay us.
There's these walls coming up. On the one hand, you can think, well, okay,
put up those walls and make sure that your users get the money for it. But we all know that's not
going to happen. These walls, if they do that, they're just going to make sure that the company
itself gets the money. It's going to help profits. It's going to help shareholders.
It's not going to go down to the users. Users still don't get anything.
I think that it's important to communicate UBI as an AI dividend where we are now.
I think part of the barrier to UBI is people thinking, oh, people are going to be left with
nothing except for this poverty floor level basic income and that's all that they'll get.
Speaking of it as a dividend, as you did in your campaign, it gets people to see that people think
of a dividend as the better the company does, the better I do. If you have a true dividend,
let's say it's tied to GDP per capita, as productivity increases, as AI is able to
become more and more capable, then the floor rises. That floor can be seen as something that
people deserve, that it's earned. It's an earned dividend. It's not welfare. It's not something
that somehow limits them. It's something that is supplementary to everything else that they do
and is enabling everything that they do and continues to increase as the nation improves.
It's a dividend on freedom, my friend.
I am pumped to announce that I have a novel coming out on September 12th, The Last Election.
It's a political thriller co-written with my friend Stephen Marsh, who wrote the book
The Next Civil War. If you listen to this podcast, Stephen's been a repeat guest. Stephen and I
became friends and thought we should collaborate on a way to scare the ---- out of people,
but also entertain them with a story of what could happen in this upcoming election or the
election thereafter. Do check it out at andrewyang.com books and there's a special discount
code, Last Election, that you can use for 30% off at the publisher's website. I'll be talking more
about this book, but I'm so pumped to get this out into the world. Last Election, coming your way.
One personal question I have for you is you've been living in D.C. for a number of months now.
How is it? What's the jam? I have never lived in D.C. Do you hang out at these events at night
and then people are like, I do this, I do this, and you're like, I'm like the walking example of
Universal Basic Income. What's your social life like? What's the vibe like? Is it great? Is it
terrible? Is it somewhere in between? I really wouldn't say that my experience is all that
different because, again, I'm very much a remote worker. From my perspective, I moved here because
I feel that we're entering the end game part of UBI where at some point, hopefully in the next
five years or something, we'll actually get something passed that looks like UBI. I think
that Windows definitely has the potential to open after the next election. First of all,
who knows how AI is going to advance between now and November 2024.
For all we know, let's say GPT-6 or 7 comes out. It's like the October surprise.
What does that mean for even that election? People are going to be a lot more interested
in AI and in economic security programs like UBI, like the child allowance,
trying to figure out what do we do. Also, during that time, you've got the Trump tax credits
expiring. You're going to have to do stuff that involves the tax code. That combination of a need
to actually reform the tax code in another new big way, combined with hopefully calls for responses
to AI and hopefully that being UBI, then a window can potentially exist. I just want to be here
for it to do what I can when the opportunities arise. Well, you're doing everything possible
every single day, my friend. Glad to be on this journey alongside you. Hopefully, we will have
that celebratory signing in DC upcoming. The stepping stone I can see that's within grasp
really, maybe even before 2024, is this enhanced child tax credit revival.
When people ask me about UBI and the data, I say, hey, what if I were to tell you that we gave like
$93 billion to a few million families around the US and their mental health improved and their
educational outcomes improved? We just did this literally years ago. To your point, it's like we
have plenty of data that this would be tremendous. Most people don't think of that child tax credit
as UBI, but you and I both know it's very much an enormous anti-poverty measure. I think that can be
something we should be aiming towards because the people love it, economists love it, the data love
it. A lot of legislators I talk to love it as well, including some folks who are not ideologically
where you'd expect. Families were on average receiving $428 a month, and that was a floor
for them. There's so many multiple papers written about this. It went to 90% of kids in the US.
The effects were just amazing to see. Even when they canceled it or when it expired and
didn't restore it, we actually watched the parental employment rate go down.
Here we are. The conversation is, oh, we can't give money to people or else they'll stop working.
It's like, well, that's not what we saw. Then you've got people going, oh, well, that's only
because it lasted for six months, but if it lasted for longer than that, then that's not the case.
The same thing is in Canada. They've had it for years, and it's great up there. The evidence is
so strong for people who actually look at it and even base their decisions on evidence.
But I feel the anecdotes, you've got your welfare queen mythology, you've got your,
oh, I know one person who did this, or only caring about one person. If only one person
uses their basic income to start drinking or doing drugs, then that's bad. But the evidence shows
that overall drug and alcohol use goes down. Isn't that what we want? We've got this anecdotal
evidence problem. I think key to that is being able to really richly and powerfully tell these
stories. Another project I'm excited about to get off the ground is Bootstraps. This was a
two-and-a-half-year basic income program that was filmed over that time. There's like a thousand
hours of footage of 21 people living with a basic income, both before and during the pandemic.
The demographics are a very diverse amount of people, including a Southern conservative
Trump supporter. To be able to see these stories and see how it impacted them,
I think is just really powerful. We need to get those kinds of stories out there for people to
connect with. I think that's one of the things that's missing, are these really powerful stories.
Can people see that Bootstraps film now?
No, it's in post-production right now.
Very exciting. Red carpet. UBI movie.
Hopefully, it'll end up being on Netflix or HBO or something.
I like it.
I think that's the kind of thing that people need to see. When Maid came out on Netflix,
that was a great show. I think people gained a better understanding of what it's like for
a single mother fleeing household domestic abuse and even trying to get a job and going
through the welfare system and then jumping through those bureaucratic hoops and being told
all that stuff. It was great. We need stories like that that people can connect to.
Sometimes art can move the culture in a positive direction. I'm taking a shot or two in that
direction. I've got this political thriller coming out in September that's meant to paint
a picture about... I got to send you the manuscript, bro. It's just meant to paint a
picture about what our last election could look like, I guess. Unfortunately, that's not the
very distant future anymore. It's a possibility. Scott, so thrilled to have this opportunity to
pick your brain a little bit more. Learn a lot from you every single time. If we get to UBI,
you're going to be one of the big reasons why. I say that as a public figure that is commonly
associated with UBI, but I'm also the first to say, it's like, look, guys, UBI is definitely
not my idea. It was like MLK, Thomas Paine. I don't always say Scott Santens because it doesn't
go with that historical figure. But people in the know know it's Scott Santens. Hope you and Katie
are great down in D.C. and that I get to see you soon. Thanks. One other thing, too, I wanted to
mention to you... Titus wants to show up. Titus just turned six yesterday. Really? Wow. I guess
one other thing, too, before I go is, I don't know if you noticed the press release that the
Gerald Huff Fund for Humanities put out yesterday. That was our response to the open letter that you
signed for the pause in AI. That was our response to saying, as part of any pause, that UBI needs to
be part of this conversation. This is just such an important element of this. We should focus on
responsible AI development and everything that goes along with the other dangers. But we absolutely
have to keep our eye on the ball as far as the labor market transformation and what's going to
happen to people's economic security. And that UBI is just a foundational element for everything
that we're going to see. I love it. I certainly hope that we can advance UBI as really the only
logical response to AI becoming smarter and more powerful every single day. Oh, and another thing
I think that you would enjoy, too, is... I don't know if you saw this yet, but it's a Japanese
translation of my book that I'm pretty excited about. Congratulations, Scott. You're an international
author now. Multiple languages. I thought it was so cool. There's original illustrations for it,
and it just looks really neat. I hope that it does well in Japan. If other countries are
out there listening, South Korea, looking at you, Nordic nations. But for anyone, go to
scottsantens.com. S-A-N-T-E-N-S for all of Scott's writings and wisdom. And buy his book.
scottsantens.com. Thanks. Yeah, and I've got a really exciting project coming up. Can't talk
about that one yet, but just so people know that there is something I'm cooking up that I'm hoping
to be able to announce in the next couple months. Well, thanks so much for coming on. See you soon,
my friend. scottsantens at scottsantens.com. Thanks. Good to see you again, Andrew.
