Grand Hotel (1932) is one of Hollywood’s earliest great ensemble dramas, bringing together legendary stars in a story of intersecting lives within the walls of a luxurious Berlin hotel.
Behind the glittering chandeliers and elegant ballrooms lie private struggles—fading fame, financial desperation, romantic longing, and quiet heartbreak. Greta Garbo, John Barrymore, Joan Crawford, and Lionel Barrymore deliver unforgettable performances in a film that helped define the very idea of the “all-star cast.”
Madame, madame, have you slept well, madame?
Oh, I haven't been asleep. I've been thinking.
It's time for the performance, madame.
I think, Suzette, I've never been so tired in my life.
I can't dance tonight.
You must get ready, madame. Here are your pearls.
Pearls are cold. Everything is cold and finished.
So far away, so threadbare. It's all gone.
Oh, the pearls, madame. What if they should break?
The pearls don't break. They hold together and bring me bad luck. I hate them.
You received orchids again, madame. They must be from that same young man.
He's just down the corridor. Tall. He walks like a soldier.
What do I care of the young man down the corridor?
I want to be alone. I just want to be alone.
People come, people go. Nothing ever happens. That's the Grand Hotel.
I'm Tiffany Brannan. I'm Rebecca Brannan.
Welcome to Real Thoughts on Cinema.
In the early days of Hollywood, movies would usually only feature one or two big stars.
The idea of an all-star film was basically an unknown concept.
That's absolutely true.
But in 1932, everything changed when MGM created the first all-star picture featuring its top box office draws.
A movie which took place all within one building over the course of just a weekend was groundbreaking at the time,
and it started a trend which would inspire many other films with a similar concept.
This film is Grand Hotel from 1932.
It was produced by Irving Thalberg, directed by Edmund Goulding,
and features Greta Garbo, John Barrymore, Joan Crawford, Lionel Barrymore, Wallace Beery, and Louis Stone.
The story takes place on one weekend at the Grand Hotel in Berlin as the lives of different guests at the hotel cross.
One guest is the impoverished baron Felix von Geigern, who has turned to a life of crime because his title does not supply an income.
His next victim is to be the beautiful but despondent ballerina Gruzinskaya,
who is desperate because the audiences seem to have left and her fame is waning.
She thinks there's no reason for her to continue living.
When the charming nobleman meets her face to face, though,
they find that maybe they both have found a new reason to keep living in a newfound love for each other.
Another guest at the hotel is a dying man, Kringlein,
a poor clerk in a textile factory who has decided to spend his life savings on a few brief moments of happiness at the Grand Hotel
when he realizes he only has a short time to live.
He manages to get a good room at the hotel when he is befriended by the baron,
who for some reason feels sympathy for the pathetic man.
Another interesting guest at the hotel is the stenographer Flemchen,
who is a working-class girl who's looking for a good offer from any gentleman who has money.
She flirts with the baron, she attracts the attention of Kringlein,
but, most notably, she works for the businessman Preising,
who claims to be a very upstanding family man but may cast all his scruples aside
when he has to tell one lie to keep his business from going into financial difficulties.
Meanwhile, a World War I veteran, a doctor who is disfigured during the war,
casts a gloomy commentary on everything as he sees the different guests coming and going.
What will happen with these guests? Will they find what they're seeking?
Or will their weekend at the Grand Hotel end in disaster?
I think this movie is really based around these characters.
They are the heart of this story.
Yes, in spite of the title being Grand Hotel, it's not about the hotel itself.
It serves as this enclosed environment to really display these characters and all their interesting facets.
I won't go so far to say this is the first time that there ever was a movie where it all took place in one spot,
but it's sort of considered the first.
Yes.
Maybe there was some obscure silent film that did the same, but it started that idea to the point that years later,
like in 1939, Stagecoach was called Grand Hotel on Wheels.
Right, it was definitely a trendsetter.
The idea of having all these big stars, for one thing, in this one contained space.
So it became a bit of a gimmick, but unlike a lot of movies that have a gimmick, the gimmick worked.
Yes.
And I think the reason why it worked very successfully was that it was based on a play.
Right, both the novel and the German play by author Vicky Baum, which MGM bought both the film and play rights,
and then it was first produced as an American play and was very successful.
Yes.
And then the film was even more successful.
And a play often is very successful in having one locale.
Right.
Or at least more contained.
So this continued with that, but this movie is very interesting in that it's pretty early for a talk
Yes.
So it's going to seem very old if you haven't seen a lot of old movies.
But I think the reason why we're recommending it is because it's like if you want to get involved in movies of this era,
you're just jumping in with both feet.
And you can be introduced to some of the biggest stars of this era.
So let's consider all the stars and the roles they play, their characters.
Well, interestingly, I think the top two, Greta Garbo and John Barrymore, are names that might be familiar to some modern audiences.
Greta Garbo, that name is synonymous with classic movie star, both in silent and early talkie.
Even though she retired very young in 1942, she was still in her under 40s.
She was in her mid 30s when she retired.
And she lived a long life after that, very much a recluse.
So her famous line from this movie, I want to be alone, sort of became synonymous with Greta Garbo herself.
Well, yes. And if you read behind the scenes info about this, she was actually known in Hollywood even when she was very actively working to be so reclusive.
And it was kind of rare that she actually allowed some photos to be taken of herself and John Barrymore on the set in this film.
She was very happy working with him, so she relaxed a little bit.
But she insisted that they had a certain lighting and put a curtain between the cameras and the cameramen, so it would feel intimate in her scene with him.
But she was just very shy of people and couldn't stand anyone watching her.
Lionel Barrymore said she was like a cat that runs under the bed when visitors come in.
I think she brought that neurotic quality as well as the over-the-top pathos that makes sense for a ballerina.
Because silent cinema is comparable to ballet in that it's a silent art form.
You have to express with your facial dramatic emotions, but not words.
And she struggled at first because of her strong Swedish accent, which she turned into a Russian accent here.
I think it's very appropriate that she has a strong accent.
And I don't think half of her lines would be as memorable as they are if she didn't have an accent.
Yes, you can just remember the way she says them with her very distinct accent.
And I think she's believable as a ballerina because of her statuesque frame and her slenderness.
Then of course, it's interesting that both the Barrymore brothers are in this movie.
Certainly not the only movie in which they both starred, they made a lot of movies together.
But it's really a great showcase for both of them to show off their unique talents.
We have John Barrymore as really the romantic lead of the film.
And that usually was his character because he played more of a romantic lead since he was better looking and younger.
The sort of morally grey but still charming kind of rogue that was very much his type.
Byronic hero.
Yes, and this film really exemplifies the ultimate John Barrymore character.
And Lionel was more of a character actor, I would say, in later years.
He's probably more known for being Mr. Potter in It's a Wonderful Life.
That's one of his most famous films now.
You made a lot of Frank Capra films.
And this film is at the same time kind of a unique role for him if you only know some of his later performances.
And you see that signature Lionel Barrymore quality.
But he gets to show such a range in this part.
And does such a brilliant job of riding this line between this kind of...
He's not that old, but he is more advanced in years.
And he's dying, but then he's experiencing everything for the first time.
So he's like a very young child.
And the dynamic between him and his brother, John Barrymore, is really touching to see.
Because their characters are not brothers.
They're just these two strangers who meet and they form this immediate bond.
But having that familial bond makes it so much more special than it would have been with any other actors.
And just the way they play off each other.
You just know they've been working together so long because they're brothers.
But they look different enough that they don't have to be brothers.
Once you know, you can tell there are certain things about their voices, their hair, that they are similar.
But they display very different acting styles, too.
And Lionel Barrymore was, I don't think, ever as glamorized.
No.
So that right there makes them very different.
Yeah, he's not wearing nearly as much makeup.
His hair is more slicked down instead of the bouffant.
They're not trying to make him look good.
That's not the point of his part.
You see very different acting styles.
I think it's appropriate that John Barrymore is Greta Garbo's leading man
because they are both doing the almost over-the-top silent film style acting.
Kind of a cross between silent film and stage acting.
Yes, he was a stage actor, of course.
So it's very theatrical.
Whereas Lionel Barrymore, of course he has the over-the-top stage acting.
He did make some silent films.
Less than John, definitely.
But he also displays a more nuanced that I think would become more standard in the later 30s.
And that leads us into, of course, the other very big star, Joan Crawford.
Also a very famous name now.
Very young Joan Crawford.
But not quite the beginning of her career because she, too, made silent films.
That's right.
But this was when she was really starting to make her ascent to being a top star.
And a serious actress.
Because so many actresses during this era were basically just there to run around with very little clothing.
Which she does.
She does. She did her fair share of just being risque.
But at the same time, in this film alone, I think you see her mature from going to just being a little pre-code cutie girl
to being really dramatic at the end.
And you see where she was going to go by the mid-to-late 40s, becoming an Oscar-winning actress.
As she wasn't necessarily that attractive in the late 40s.
And then Lionel Barrymore kind of ended up being the cut call at the end of the film.
So they both are the more down-to-earth kind of real characters.
And so it's a nice, it's an interesting contrast to the ballerina and the baron.
And then, of course, the fifth really big star is Wallace Beery, playing the villain.
At the time, he was the top-paid actor in Hollywood.
That's crazy.
And he had also been a big star for many years, playing different types of characters, way back in silent films in the teens.
Is it also true that he was an opera singer?
Yes, he played comical baritone roles in opera in his early days.
It's just so ironic when there's actually a lion in the film.
When she pantomimes working on a typewriter, and John Barrymore thinks she's playing piano.
He says, does he sing? And she says, I hope not.
He does sing.
Greta Garbo sings a lot in this movie, as a matter of fact.
Especially for a ballerina.
She actually has a rather nice voice.
And I know that was a selling point for her in a much later film.
Garbo sings.
And, of course, the other few notable characters are Louis Stone, who plays the doctor,
who has a very realistic injury on his face.
It's supposed to look like a grenade went off in his face, and it really does.
It looks like his skin is atrophied.
It's quite amazing.
And then Gene Herschel plays Porter Senf.
He's definitely the smallest part.
Yes, but he's constantly, the whole movie, he's worried about his wife who's in the hospital having a baby.
I don't want to say comic relief.
That would be a disrespect to his character.
He's not that, but at the end of the film, he provides this kind of bright point.
Because it becomes quite bleak, and then seeing his story turns out nice.
Yeah, sort of the only one who really has a normal family life and a happy backstory.
Although you don't really see any of that, because we just see him at the hotel,
and he's relating with the other people.
So something very important to address with this film is the era.
Yes, that's right.
But you referenced a couple of times the term pre-code.
Right, so that's important to consider.
If you're not really familiar with cinema of this time,
you might be surprised even that they had sound cinematography by the 1930s.
But that technology was really being developed in the mid to late 1920s.
Particularly by Warner Brothers, with The Jazz Singer being the first mainstream partial talkie film.
That was 1927.
So by 1929 and 1930, basically everything was partial or all talkie.
So by the 30s, talking pictures were the norm.
And it took them a while to figure out how to do that, how to move the cameras because they were so loud.
The lack of sound effects in this film is kind of interesting.
Have you noticed that?
That's a good point.
It sounds like they throw something down and you don't hear it.
And I understand they actually were trying to avoid having too much noise.
Like in the lobby scenes, the actors wore socks over their shoes,
so there wouldn't be a bunch of clunking banging.
I think the camera, maybe the sound technology wasn't as sophisticated,
so it picked up noises more than talking, so they had to be careful about that.
And they also, at the time, recorded the sound with the picture,
so it was so hard to edit.
And it just made filming very difficult in these first few years of talkies.
But despite that, there were some excellently made early talking pictures.
But at the same time, the introduction of sound in the late 20s
brought a whole new slew of problems to the film industry in terms of content.
At this time, there was no rating system,
but there were a lot of censor boards throughout the nation.
And there were different policies that each board had,
and if there was something in film they didn't like, they would just cut it out.
And that was pretty easy to do.
Not very artistically, right? They would just chop it.
They would chop it. But it was easier to do with silent films.
They would just cut the film, splice it back together, and they had live music.
It would be piano, orchestra, whatever they had, organ.
But with the sound being synchronized with the picture,
that made editing just butchering.
And also, there was a lot more to censor.
Because of the introduction of sound,
all of a sudden, films had become so much more modern.
There was this fast-paced dialogue, risqué lines,
this smart-aleck double-talk that you just couldn't do
in a silent film with the title cards.
They could have nudity, violence, suggestive imagery, but the words.
As Father Daniel Lord was one of the authors of the Motion Picture Production Code,
and around this time, helping Hollywood figure out what they were doing,
and he said, silent smut was bad enough,
but vocal smut called out for vengeance from heaven.
And people were really getting upset, and there was a lot of controversy,
so Hollywood realized they needed to do something
to get this content under control, lest they faced government censorship,
because it was being discussed.
And at the time, all Hollywood had in terms of some kind of overseeing of content
was the MPPDA, which stood for the Motion Picture Producers and Distributors of America.
Which is now the MPA, right?
Yes, it's now just the Motion Picture Association.
They recently rebranded.
Which really is a very governmental organization.
Will Hayes, the first person in charge of it, was a former postmaster general
and very involved with the cabinet of President Warren Harding
when he took over, starting that organization,
as he was called the Movie Czar, in 1921.
But he didn't really do anything for the first few years.
It was all about public relations, politics.
So then in 1930, the Motion Picture Production Code was first put in place, right?
That's right. It was written in 1929.
Most people thought it was written by Will Hayes,
so it's commonly called the Hayes Code.
But he didn't write it.
It was written by Father Daniel Lord and Martin Quigley,
who was a motion picture trade publication publisher.
So he knew about the industry,
and thus he was a very appropriate person to write this list.
A very comprehensive but nuanced list of rules
that talked about what could and couldn't be in Felton's.
But, sort of like the Constitution of the United States,
it needed to be enforced well by wise distributors.
Right. So the SRC, the Studio Relations Committee,
was put in place in 1930, and the code was instated.
But, interestingly, 1930 is considered the start of the precode era.
1930 to 1934 has that name,
and that's because the SRC basically did nothing.
And it's so ironic that that era is called the precode era,
but really, that's not accurate.
The code was in place.
It's the early code era.
It's the non-effective code era.
It's the code-ignoring era.
1934 brought the Production Code Administration, or the PCA,
which was headed by Joseph I. Breen,
and he knew how to get things done.
Right. Rather than introducing a new document,
or it was just a new organization to enforce the old document.
Similarly to being a new president,
if you're comparing it to the Constitution.
That's right.
So the films made during that time,
1930 to the first half of 1934,
have developed a cult classic status in recent years,
particularly since the 1990s,
because they're so scandalous and just shocking.
If you're not familiar with that era or that idea, though,
if you just have this idea in your mind,
like I had for many years,
it's like, oh, you know, old movies.
It's the good old days.
And then if you go early enough, you're like, wow.
Yeah, if you've just seen movies like
Casablanca, Singing in the Rain, The Wizard of Oz,
and then you watch Grand Hotel, you will be shocked.
So what would you say are the main things
that are just blatantly precode about this film?
The number one, just like the most blatant, just like visually,
Joan Crawford.
Her first costume, which she wears a couple of times,
is just very low and kind of loose-hanging.
I'd say both the female characters, really.
Both the female characters. Greta Garbo appears,
and you see her in sort of her undergarments.
They seem like in transparent garments,
in their undergarments, casually undressing.
Yes.
They never get to a point of nudity,
but they're, wow, they're really not in a lot of place.
And then just kind of subtle, not subtle,
but things, just like the way the characters interact.
Yes.
I see there's a man and a woman, like,
standing very close together.
The first scene with John Barrymore and Joan Crawford
is just very...
There's a very suggestive air
in the film.
Definitely.
Even if it's just like kind of a casual flirtation,
it's not even so much the dialogue.
It's the way it's being delivered,
the way they're standing, their posturing.
So much of the dialogue in many movies,
if they'd remade it a few years later,
under the Breen era,
they wouldn't necessarily have changed it.
Maybe deleted a few lines.
In that scene, yeah, there are probably
like two or three lines.
And then at the end of the scene,
he touches her kind of inappropriately.
And then later on, Mr. Preising
offers for her to go to Manchester
with him as his secretary,
but it's very obvious she's not going to be his secretary,
that he gets her room next to his,
and then she's unpacking,
he's like, oh, you're going to be nice to me,
and all this kind of stuff.
That's the point where it goes from just suggestive.
Like, the situation with the Baron
and Gruzinskaya is suggestive.
It's implied.
It suggests that they had an affair,
but it's just suggested.
He comes that night, and then he kisses her hand
and she's wearing a different outfit,
and his collar's kind of open.
And a lot of it is just the way they're acting that scene.
Last scene, they were kind of
just getting to know each other,
and now they're being very intimate.
There's some very passionate kissing,
like too passionate.
There are certain ideas people have
about the code that are really myths,
like certain rules they had,
like the three-second rule.
You can only kiss for three seconds at a time.
That's not in the code.
It's the way you do it.
And it can be much worse
if it's done in a very suggestive manner.
I think it does say in the code
it says it shouldn't be open-mouthed, right?
Or excessively lustful.
Right, so it's all in the manner of doing it.
There are some very long kisses in code films.
It's just the way that you go about it.
And I wouldn't say that they're kissing that long.
It's just the way that they're doing it.
They're doing it so much.
If you're familiar with 1930s cinematography
and film styles,
and watch the movies
from the first half of the 30s
and 30s style,
the things that they learned gradually.
Right.
There were still things you see in 1935 and 1936
that you wouldn't see by 1938 and 1939
because it's between the lines.
It's not really in the text of the code.
Hollywood just began to reform
as they started to move away
from the lurid
and move toward the beautiful.
And in later 1934 or even 1935,
sometimes the film had kind of already been made.
That's right.
So it took a good year at least.
Getting all the old stuff out
and starting fresh.
It didn't take nearly as long then as it would now,
for instance,
because they made movies so quickly.
But I think they started making them faster.
Would you say that's true?
I think that's true.
I think they began to ramp up production
and that kind of helped pull Hollywood
out of the depression
because suddenly films were accessible
and appropriate for the whole family.
As they were making them more and more risque,
trying to draw in audiences,
they were really shooting themselves in the foot
because they were cutting out audiences.
Not only children, not only families,
but moral-minded people.
A lot of people didn't like that kind of thing back then.
Absolutely.
So it's interesting to see the excessive drinking,
the excessive smoking.
Of course there's drinking and smoking in code films,
but there's the way they do it.
And also to bear in mind the fact
that prohibition was basically in place
for most of the pre-code era
and it was gone by the time of the Green Era.
Now, yes, this is set in Europe,
but that was a forbidden fruit in the United States.
I think it's interesting to see
some of the things that are enjoyable
about pre-code films
that aren't inherently connected
to their pre-codishness.
Well, I think a lot of it is just
the style of the 1930s cinema.
It's very fascinating.
If you get a taste for it,
I really love it.
People always talk about Art Deco from Sierra.
If you love that style of architecture
and even the font,
the look of the Grand Hotel,
the sets,
it's just so distinctly Art Deco.
Yeah, there's some great style
in terms of fashion
and architecture from the early 30s.
And seeing a lot of great classic actors
very young.
Yes.
Like Lionel Barrymore, for instance,
is walking around dancing.
By 1938, he was in a wheelchair
for the rest of his life.
So it's nice to see him up and about
on his feet and see very young Joan Crawford.
She's just aging.
Was moving past really being a leading man.
This is one of his last times
as just the dashing leading man.
He famously said to the cinematographer,
I'm 50 years old
and I want to look like
Jackie Cooper's grandson.
Jackie Cooper was a very famous
child actor at the time.
And he's wearing a lot of makeup
to help him achieve that goal,
but he's very charming and debonair.
And I think the character is written
in such a way that he's not
going to pass for that.
Yeah.
And I don't think he's supposed
to be young.
He's supposed to be younger
than Kringlein and Prysing,
which he is.
But he's definitely a mature
world-weary character.
One thing that's interesting to note
about films of this time period
is the background music.
Yes.
I find it's either in excess
or very sparse.
Even Alfred Newman.
A lot of times,
it wasn't really a score.
They're just playing music
in the background.
So it kind of gives you
the impression,
is a radio playing somewhere?
Is there a band in the room?
Because it's not supporting
the action.
No, I think sometimes
it is supposed to be
there's music playing downstairs.
It is, definitely.
There's jazz of the era
and classical music,
especially with Gruzinskaya.
And even some Viennese waltzes
to really set it in that
Germanic locale.
In some of Gruzinskaya's scenes,
it's interesting that you hear
classical pieces,
but jazz arrangements.
Like there's a jazz arrangement
of Tchaikovsky's June.
That's interesting.
And then her first scene,
you hear a bit of
there are some extremely
raw emotions in this movie,
particularly from Lionel Barrymore.
He has at least two scenes
that are just downright
uncomfortable to watch.
He's so emotional.
I know a lot of people feel
that Joan Crawford steals this picture.
I think Lionel Barrymore steals it,
if anyone.
She does a great job.
They all do a great job.
They're all fabulous.
But particularly the scene
when he is...
If you don't know Lionel Barrymore,
you'll love him after watching his work.
And then when he thinks
he's lost his pocketbook.
It's uncomfortable to watch
because he's so into it.
But uncomfortable to watch
in the best possible way.
And I think that those elements,
the things that are brilliant
about this film would have been
just as good in a code setting.
Absolutely.
And I think most of the time
the suggestive lines
weren't necessary
and that the story
had a lot of integrity,
which not all pre-code films did.
This film is a masterpiece.
Some pre-code films
were kind of throwaways,
unless you're a big fan
of the individual actors.
I think the pre-code era
is interesting to study
for that very reason.
It's a little bit more
like modern Hollywood.
It's a waste of this person's talent.
There's a lot of goofiness
in pre-code films.
But then you'll find ones like this
where you can see,
yes, there was that in there
and it doesn't need to be there necessarily,
but you can tell they were trying
to make something meaningful
and something that actually
had artistic value.
And it is interesting to see
this all-star cast
and how they're interacting
with each other.
Well, not everyone's American.
And they're all supposed
to be speaking German technically,
I guess, maybe not Gruzinskaya.
Yeah, they're all supposed
to be speaking German.
Because at one point
she's speaking Russian
and it's notable.
So it is kind of funny
that he just has a German accent.
But it's interesting.
And I think it almost
is to give you a stronger sense
of tying him to Germans
who have a lot of power.
What do you think is noteworthy
about the socioeconomic ideas
in this film?
Well, being during the Depression,
everyone could relate
to people not having enough money.
There's a strong theme
of people needing money
in this movie.
Other than Gruzinskaya
and the doctors,
everyone else is just
concerned about money.
Prizing is that he's scared
his business is going under.
A very real concern.
And this is a bad time
to be having business troubles.
The Baron is just desperately
trying to get money
in the whole movie.
And I think he represents
people who maybe came
from good families
and all of a sudden
didn't have any money.
And Flemchen,
she's a working girl
and she's kind of
sold her soul
just because she talks
about money specifically a lot.
She's always like,
what's the reason
for you doing this?
Money.
It's always money.
She literally only eats
one meal a day
and wears just like
one kind of shabby dress
because she doesn't
have enough money
for more than that.
That's very relatable.
a steady job.
And Kringlein is interesting
because he has this money
that he's spending
but he has worked
his whole life
and his wages
really weren't enough
to live properly on
but he's managed
to save enough
now for the first time
he's able to actually live.
Right.
He's only able
to enjoy himself at all
because he knows
he's going to die
really soon.
So he can afford
to have a good life
for a short time
and he
and the Baron
sort of say the motto
a short life
and a gay one
and then of course
the Doctor
several characters
represent that
forgotten man
lost generation mentality
of World War I
which really faded away
with World War II.
It kind of erased that.
Right.
But there was
a certain morose quality
that those veterans had
which was very important
in the 1920s
and the 30s
before World War II
started to brew
and you see it in works
like The Great Gatsby
F. Scott Fitzgerald.
I believe F. Scott Fitzgerald
coined the term
lost generation.
Yes he did.
And all these characters
most notably
the Baron
and the Doctor
represent that
lost generation feel
because they're both
lost a lot.
It's more prevalent
with the Doctor
because of his having
this vicious figuration
but the Baron
just multiple times
just mentions like
I was in the war
and experienced this
in the war.
He just mentions it
several times
you can tell that
that is some trauma
that he has.
we don't know
why he happens to be
a Baron
who doesn't have any money.
Obviously not every title
comes with money
but he talks about
how he was
as a boy
he was taught
to ride and be a gentleman
in school
to pray and lie
and in the war
to kill and hide.
Sort of like
he learned
how to be this criminal
in the war
and I would go so far
as to say
that he probably
the aristocracy
really was
torn down
after World War I
so he probably
lost everything
in the war
because Germany
did lose
and that sort of
led him
to where he is now.
Yes, I feel like
we get the least
explanation
of his
how he got
to this point.
That's true.
You basically
just get the idea
and it's just like
and she's really young.
She's very young.
Kringlein tells us
very much about
the life that he's led.
You hear a bit about
the Doctor's experiences
and Gruzenskaya
is talking about
back when she was
at the Academy
but there we just
kind of see him
here he is.
He's this kind of
lost soul
and we don't really know
exactly what led him
to this point.
So that adds a fascinating
depth to the character
because you can just
kind of imagine
his backstory.
The other thing
that's really noteworthy
is Gruzenskaya's character
refers to the other
hugely momentous
political situation
that happened
at the same time
as World War I
the Russian Revolution
of 1917.
She multiple times
refers to the fact
that she's from Russia
the Grand Duke.
It seems like
like many ballerinas
of this time
she was
maybe the mistress
at least the
favorite
of a Russian nobleman.
And he gave her
these pearls
which were then
the important
and he was killed
during the Russian Revolution.
So she too
was sort of
cast adrift
because of that
and that could
almost be why
she's a little
on the crazy side
and living in
this fantasy land
of her own
but she
kind of feels like
she lost everything
and
even all these
years later
which many
Russian nobility
did feel.
So you have
the German
aristocracy
sort of lost
the Russian aristocracy
lost
the businessman
struggling to find
his position
the common
working people
and the depression
really was worldwide.
At the same time
in Europe
there was great
depression as well
although we had
other issues
like the Dust Bowl
and the stock market
crash.
It's a study
in the
kind of
like you said
socioeconomic
strata
of the era.
Yes.
So I can just
imagine how
relatable this would
have been
in 1932
even to Americans
who didn't know
that much about
foreign affairs
and if you're a
student of
20th century
economics
history
war
or anything
like that
it's so interesting
to see this.
It just brings
the history to life
because this was
made when it
was really
happening
to see how
people were
really expressing
themselves through
their art
through time.
And if you're
just a real sucker
for like
melodrama
or really
like flowery
romance
some of the
romantic dialogue
in this film
between Gruzinski
and Baron
is just so
beautifully written
and so dramatic
it's just
it's like
a kind of
prose
but it's very
beautiful.
They really
sell it.
Distinct, yeah.
And of course
the 1930s style
is something
that makes it
instantly recognizable.
My costume is
inspired by
the first outfit
worn by Flemchen.
It's a long
black skirt
with a
loose neck
white blouse
a black jacket
over it
and a black
cloche hat.
Gruzinski
spends most
of her time
in lounge wear
really
different sorts
of negligés
but this is
inspired by
several things
you see her wear
because it has
diaphanous sleeves
very full
and beadwork
on it
and since she was
a very tall woman
when she is
dressed to go out
she wears
rather low shoes.
Aside from just
being artistically
successful
this is very
critically acclaimed.
It was very successful
with audiences
made a lot of money
as we said
and was a trendsetter
but it was
acknowledged
by the Academy.
Fascinatingly
it was only
nominated
for one award
Best Picture
and it won
and this is
the only film
I believe
to ever win
Best Picture
without being
nominated for
anything else.
Wow, that's
really interesting.
So it remains
a film
that people
who are real
cinema students
will recognize
by title.
And even though
there are so many
huge stars in it
Lionel Barrymore
was the only
actor in it
who appeared
in another
Best Picture winner.
Interesting.
The other film of course
being Frank Capra's
You Can't Take It With You.
How do you think
this film
being such a
hallmark of the 1930s
how do you think
this could be
relatable to
a modern young person
who hasn't seen
any classic movies
knows nothing about them?
I think that it has
some really
classic
universal themes
trying to make it
in the world
tough times
inflation
economic downturn
those are things
which just keep
coming back in the world
they've been happening
since the beginning of time
and they're always
going to happen.
As well as the struggle
between modernity
and traditionalism
they intersect
a lot in this film
so I think
young people
can relate to
this young woman
who's trying to
make her way in the world
it's tough to have a job
or people who are
maybe they feel like
they're educated
for a career
that's becoming obsolete
that would be
comparable to The Baron
or struggling
with health conditions
all these things
are very universal themes
and I think
they speak to us
in any era
and that's why
classic films
are still relatable
because they're presented
in a very dramatic way
movies like this
we always say
are sort of like an opera
or like a ballet
they have that nod
to the classic imagery
and this film
with the symbolism
of the telephone wires
at the beginning
really is showing
how that's the modern world
the telephone
was something new
and how it is
taking over
for the classic
manners of the past
they always refer to
how The Baron
is a gentleman
he's a dying breed
men like
Preising
not that he's younger
but he's the new type of man
the businessman
who wants to
squelch the
art
like Gruzinskaya
business is killing art
I understand that
in the novel
that was an even stronger theme
and I don't want to
spoil it
but particularly
at the ending
there's a very poignant symbolism
relating to that idea
of the old world
being kind of
taken over
by the new world
and I think that
if you apply it
to what we're seeing today
the themes
are still very relevant
AI taking over
for traditional art
all these themes
are universal
and they can be applied
to any time
from ancient Rome
to the 21st century
and if you're an artist
anyone can relate
to when you're just
tired of performing
and you're depressed
because you're not
getting good audiences
want to be alone
it's a good film
to watch as a performer
because her character
is very relatable
but I think the most
touching thing about it
is how people
who are struggling
in their own ways
manage to make friends
with each other
in very unlikely ways
and help each other
and there are
little small moments
which don't have
direct bearing
on the plot
but they're
very meaningful
when Gruzinskaya
helps this older woman
into the elevator
and the Baron
sees that
and you see that
as the first time
he kind of thinks of her
as a person
instead of just this entity
he and Gruzinskaya
kind of help each other
want to keep living
and have a better life
and the same thing
with Kringlein
and Flemchen
and a movie like this
might seem unapproachable
because it's in
black and white
it's so old
the styles are so different
but the good thing
is that it's so famous
that it's been
remastered beautifully
and you can find
great copies of it
on Amazon Prime Video
to buy or rent
and all the other
streaming platforms
will find it on YouTube
for rent or purchase
on DVD
and it's under
$200
very entertaining throughout
so I think
it's worth
taking the time
to give it a chance
and
you can't really
understand classic Hollywood
unless you see
where it all began
with the pre-code film
after the success
of Grand Hotel
MGM realized
that they'd hit
on a winning formula
so it's no surprise
that 13 years later
they decided to do
another take on this story
join us next time
as we talk about
the forgotten remake
of this classic
which resets the drama
in WWII era
New York City
at one of the most
famous hotels
in the world
thank you for watching
goodbye