Sen. Cruz Speaks At POLITICO’S AI & Tech Summit

Ted Cruz
1 follower
Nov 12, 2025 #Tedcruz #Politicians
If I could ask everybody to please take their seats.
You're still mingling. Come on back inside. We're going to get the program started.
We're going to kick off the second half of our program today with a conversation
led by Rachel Bade, the Capitol Bureau Chief and Senior Washington Columnist for Politico,
in conversation with Senate Commerce Committee Chair Ted Cruz.
Hear me okay? Everyone hear me okay? They're all rested. They just had a break,
so they're all caffeinated and ready to dive in. Guys, I'm happy to welcome Senator Cruz.
Caffeinated is good, but if it were an evening event, liquored up is even better.
Can we maybe start that a little early today? We could all use a drink these days, let's be honest.
Obviously, no introduction needed here. Senate Commerce Committee Chair,
at the center of all things AI. Happy to have you here. Let's start first with this new bill
that you rolled out. I have a two-part question. You have this new bill you rolled out last week
creates a legislative framework to try to lighten the load for experimental AI. It would allow AI
developers to apply for two-year waivers up to a decade from federal rules, hoping that they can
grow and not have to worry about these regulations. Two things. One, what are you trying to do with
this bill? But secondly, we've heard from some critics, including at Public Citizen, who said
this proposal, quote, treats Americans as test subjects. And they were arguing that it's a sob
story that AI companies are being, quote, held back by regulation. So first, what are you trying
to do with this bill? And what do you say to critics who are concerned about what this means
for consumers? Well, let me start by taking it more broadly about what the objective should be,
and then talk about how this bill is one part of the solution. The objective, very simply,
is to win the race for AI. And I think we're at a moment of transformation. And it's a moment
of transformation that I think is very much like where we were in the 1990s with the rise of the
internet. And you think about it, the internet changed everything about how we live our life.
And at the dawn of the internet, the U.S. government made a series of decisions that
were the right decisions. And in particular, I'll do something that might surprise you. I'm
going to praise a Democrat president. I'll praise Bill Clinton. Bill Clinton signed an executive
order that memorialized a light-touch regulatory approach to the internet. We also put in a
moratorium on taxation on the internet. And the internet at the time was this nascent technology
that was just coming into existence. At the same time, Europe took a dramatically different
approach. And the EU put in place a heavy regulatory approach, a prior approval regulatory
approach. The consequences of that fork in the road have been utterly transformational. Here's
an amazing statistic. In 1993, the economy in the EU and the economy in the United States were
virtually identical. Today, the United States economy is more than 50 percent larger than the
EU. And there are two drivers of that, tech and the shale revolution. That's it. So that we made
the right call in the 1990s, 30 plus years ago. We are at a similar inflection point. And I believe
AI is going to be even more transformative than the internet is. It's going to change everything
about how we live our lives. And from my perspective, I want to make sure we don't
make the mistakes that Europe made. If you look at, there were virtually no major tech companies
in Europe. They just missed the tech revolution. And that has driven out of the United States. And
that has produced jobs and productivity. AI right now, we are in a race with China. And if we lose
the race to China on AI, the consequences will be devastating. They'll be devastating
for jobs in the United States. They'll be devastating for prosperity in the United States.
They'll also be devastating for global values. Because whoever wins the race for AI,
that nation's values are going to be reflected in AI. If China wins the race for AI, AI will be a
tool for global surveillance and control, as carried out by a communist nation. So,
we cannot lose that race. And China set an audacious goal of winning the race for AI and
having AI embedded in 90% of their economy by 2030. What's the regulatory sandbox bill?
Regulatory sandboxes are an approach that have been employed all over the world. Over 50 nations
have used regulatory sandboxes. So, this is not some curious idea with no precedent. It's been
implemented in many countries. The idea of a regulatory sandbox is that when you have new
innovation, you create an ability to ensure that the regulatory system doesn't prevent that
innovation from occurring. And so, the regulatory sandbox, this is an idea, by the way, President
Trump has proposed as well. It's part of President Trump's AI framework. And so, I'm drafting the
legislation that is reflected in what the President has called for. This would let innovators
go to regulators and ask for either an exception or modification to existing regulations to allow
them to innovate. What does that mean? Let's take a look at something like aviation.
Our existing aviation rules were designed in a world where the only possible way to fly
was with manned aircraft. And so, nobody was thinking about the possibility of not having a
pilot because unmanned drones didn't exist. There's massive innovation that can come from
unmanned drones. And so, allowing the ability to modify rules to allow that innovation is
important. That's what the regulatory sandbox is designed to do. Are there certain rules and
regulations that you think these companies definitely shouldn't try to get out of, like,
when it comes to consumer protections that folks are worried about? Oh, look, of course. And the
way this is structured is it's not just willy-nilly abolishing all regulations. It's creating a
mechanism for modifying regulations to allow innovation. And the mechanism would be that a
company would make an application and the Office of Science Technology Policy in the federal
government would decide that application and could choose to grant either an exemption or
a modification from rules. I'll give you another example. The United Kingdom has allowed modifications
to their rules governing healthcare. And they have seen, by using AI,
a tripling of the rate of moving to independence from stroke victims. So, they've seen massive
health benefits by analyzing how you get back to functional independence after a stroke. That kind
of innovation, I think, is critically important. And if we end up hamstringing our innovation in
the United States, China's not hamstringing what they're doing. That's a recipe for losing the race.
And I think losing the race would be catastrophic. Let's talk about something that's actually not in
this bill, I believe. And that is this notion that you previously championed of a 10-year
moratorium on state AI laws. That, obviously, was taken out of the recent mega bill that went
through both chambers of Congress. Is that dead or do you have a comeback here with this issue?
Where are talks on this matter? Yeah, it's not at all dead. And I will say the one big beautiful bill
was a remarkable piece of legislation. In my view, there are more conservative victories in
the one big beautiful bill than any legislation that has ever passed into law. And it's astonishing
everything that was accomplished in that bill. I will say, in the course of that bill, I was
privileged as chairman of the Commerce Committee to write major portions of that bill. And I got
to say, we won virtually every battle. We had about 20 battles, and I think we won 19 of them.
So I feel pretty good. Another one you're well aware of was the battle over Spectrum.
And I will tell you, I said at the outset, we are going to authorize a Spectrum auction. We're
going to put a Spectrum pipeline in this bill. And nobody in this town thought that was possible.
In fact, I sat in the Speaker's office, and Mike is a long time and good friend. And I said,
we're going to put Spectrum in this. And Mike laughed in my face. He literally laughed at me.
He said, Ted, there's no way on earth I can get Spectrum through my defense hawks in the house.
That ain't going to happen. There's a good behind the scenes story right there about
your lobbying campaign. There's a whole lot. And it was tooth and nail.
Actually, here, I'll make it a little less behind the scenes. So the process as we went through,
the very end of it where we cut the deal. So the pipeline bill that I had had for a long time,
allows for the auction of 600 megahertz and mandates actually the federal government auction
600 megahertz. And there was a big fight over exceptions. And DOD and the intelligence
community wanted exceptions. I didn't want exceptions. The final negotiations happened
on the floor of the Senate. That doesn't often happen. It was not on the microphones and on
C-SPAN. It was just standing in the back of the floor of the Senate. And I was there with Roger
Wicker, the chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee, and with Tom Cotton, the chairman of
the Intelligence Committee. And we negotiated the final deal. And Deb Fisher and Mike Rounds were
there too. And they care a lot about this issue. And at the end of the day, they really wanted
exceptions. I did not. And as we're arguing, we ended up, the president had tweeted about this.
That always moves things a little bit.
And said, we need to pass a pipeline bill in the one big, beautiful bill,
and it needs to have 600 megahertz, and it needs to have no exceptions. Now, that's not an accident.
There had been four months of vigorous lobbying at the White House. I had been at the White House
over and over and over again, trying to get that tweet to come out. And so when my colleagues are
saying we need all the exceptions, I had a printed out copy of the tweet. I said, that's very
interesting. The president of the United States disagrees with you. So I appreciate your views on
the matter. Nevertheless, as Bismarck said about sausage and legislation, there are compromises
that are made. So I ended up giving in to some exceptions at the very end and said, all right,
fine, we can carve narrower exceptions than you're asking for. But my view on negotiating
is never give up something without getting something back. So I said, if I'm going to
give you exceptions, instead of 600 megahertz, I want 800 megahertz. And I got to say, we walked
out of the deal with 800 megahertz, and everyone went, where the hell did that come from?
And the honest answer, I'd like to say I had scientists studying the optimal amount of
spectrum to allocate, and it was a careful technical assessment. That ain't true at all.
I just made up the number. And it really was the spinal tap principle. If any of y'all remember
the movie Spinal Tap, and their amplifier, instead of going to 10, ours goes to 11.
There's 800 megahertz, because 800 is bigger than 6.
And that sounded like a good number to you.
So I said, all right, fine, you want exceptions, give us 200 more megahertz. But look,
and by the way, the next day, I get a call in the morning from President Trump on my cell.
And he's in the Oval, and Scott Besant and Lutnick are both sitting in the Oval with him.
He goes, Ted, this is an amazing deal. How did you get this deal? And Rachel, I said, the only
possible answer to that, which is, Mr. President, it's entirely because of you,
which I will note, happened to have been true. Without that tweet, we don't get the deal.
And so that tweet, which I explained to him, that tweet is what gave us the leverage to get the
deal. We got that through. So we won in One Big Beautiful Bill virtually every battle. The only
one we didn't win was this one, the 10-year moratorium. Yeah. And I got to tell you,
on the 10-year moratorium, so the House had it in its version of the One Big Beautiful Bill.
But when it came to the Senate, nobody thought we could get it through the Senate parliamentarian.
In fact, it was almost accepted wisdom, this is going to die in the birdbath.
And miraculously, and I just want to give credit to my team, my team went in, they got very
creative, they rewrote, wrote it, they litigated it, and we got it through the parliamentarian.
So it was in the Senate bill. And what happened at the end of the day is, is the leading opponent
of this was Marsha Blackburn. Right. And I negotiated an agreement with Marsha, and we
reached a compromise. She agreed, I agreed. It was in the bill. In fact, she was the author of
it. It was Blackburn Cruz. So she wrote the codification of our agreement. And then what
ended up happening is that there was criticism from outside players, and Blackburn decided to
renege on the deal. So she backed out of the deal. And that ended up tanking the moratorium.
And I ended up, look, it was clear when she backed out that we no longer had the votes to
cross the threshold of 50. So I withdrew. I withdrew and said, look, we'll keep talking,
we'll work on this, but there's no point in having a vote that we're not going to get to 50 today.
Are you still working with her on this issue?
You know, she is doing her own thing, but I'm working very closely with the White House. I
will point out, when the president rolled out his AI framework, an integral component of it
was a moratorium. Because look, what sense does it make to have 50 states all issuing different
and contradictory regulatory and legal frameworks for AI? AI is by its nature, at a minimum, a
national, if not a global technology tool. And we run the risk. And there were people who said,
well, what about states' rights? And listen, I am a ferocious believer in federalism and states'
rights. But there is a reason the Constitution has an interstate commerce clause. And we have
an interstate commerce clause because we want interstate commerce. And it is Congress that
should be setting the rules for interstate commerce and not contradictory rules that
would end up making it, if we stay in the status quo, the people who win, the biggest winner of
the status quo with no moratorium is China. Why? Because we're going to see contradictory
regulations. And I would just ask, you know, do you want California and New York, do you want,
not just states, but do you want Karen Bass and Comrade Mondami setting the rules for AI? Because
that's who's going to be regulating is far left wing governors and mayors. California is already
trying to do so. Colorado has passed a law basically mandating woke AI that you do audits
to make sure the results from AI meet DEI quotas. It's so bad that Colorado's governor, Jared Polis,
a Democrat, has said we need federal preemption because these state laws are not workable.
And so the current outcome, look, I think this played out at about 3 in the morning.
I think a lot of people don't understand this issue, but there's a reason the president and
the Trump administration are united in saying we need one clear federal standard,
because having contradictory standards from every state and every city ensures failure,
and failure should not be an option. And realistically, just very quickly,
because I want to get to another couple topics before we run out of time. Do you think
realistically you could get like a three year or a five year? Is there something some deadline
that's coming that you're hoping to attach to? Or like, what do you think is possible for this?
There are lots of moving pieces. There are pieces within the administration.
There's pieces within Congress. What I would say is we cannot let political dysfunction in
the United States hamper our ability to win the race for AI. And I want to be clear also,
to say that we want to win the race for AI, to say we want state preemption, for example,
like people were using examples of, well, what about child safety and online predators? Well,
the moratorium didn't cover any of that. So there was a lot of misinformation where people said,
oh, online predators will be empowered by the moratorium. No, the moratorium explicitly was
linked to the regulation of AI as AI, not to generically applicable laws.
And I want to point out when it goes to combating bad conduct online,
AI is an incredibly powerful tool. Every tool that has ever been invented,
there has been bad conduct that has used that tool. And the reason is we have criminals and
criminals will use whatever tools they have to commit crimes. We need to fight them. I would
point out that I've authored and passed the only law in modern times going directly after AI and
regulating that, and that is the Take It Down Act. Now, the Take It Down Act goes after
non-consensual intimate images, two kinds. Number one, real images, so-called revenge porn. You have
a couple in an intimate relationship, they take pictures or videos of each other,
and then they have a breakup and one or the other is ticked off and releases those pictures or
videos to the world. That's a grotesque violation of privacy. Nobody has the right to do that.
And then a more modern manifestation of it that comes from AI is the explosion of deepfakes. And
we are seeing last year deepfake non-consensual intimate images rose over 3,000%. More than 95%
of the victims are women and teenage girls. And so the Take It Down Act does two things. Number
one, it makes it a crime, it makes it a felony to post non-consensual intimate images, either real
or deepfakes. And that was important because state laws and federal laws had a hole. So,
for example, if you posted, as was happening frequently, deepfakes of a teenage girl that
appeared to be naked but were not, that was not child pornography. Because it was a deepfake,
it didn't meet the legal definitions for child porn. And so the people who were doing this were
going, getting off scot-free. Now there are consequences, it's a felony. And then secondly,
the Take It Down Act puts a legal obligation on the tech platforms to immediately remove that
content. And so that's an example where absolutely we need legislation and we need regulation for AI,
but it needs to be targeted to real problems rather than just a brooding omnipresence in
the sky of a giant regulatory system preventing innovation. So speaking of bad conduct online,
in the wake of Charlie Kirk's assassination, we have seen something that I never thought
we'd see in American politics, and that is this notion of some people on the fringes,
fringe corners of the internet, even celebrating, mocking the murder of an innocent man who was
engaged in civil discourse in this country. In response, we've seen a number of Republicans,
including Vice President J.D. Vance, talking about, basically naming and shaming some of
these people, calling out these ugly comments, highlighting them, trying to get them fired,
basically putting pressure on them to say, this is not okay. But then we also heard AG Pam Bondi,
Attorney General Pam Bondi, suggesting in Katie Miller's podcast recently that DOJ would look at,
potentially prosecute, hate speech. Now you are a constitutional lawyer and wonk.
What do you make of this? Where's the line here? Just start there.
Well, look, I think the Attorney General's comments have been misconstrued, and she actually
put out a lengthy social media post afterwards clarifying what she was saying. Here's what the
legal standard is, and as you know, you and I were talking backstage. I do a podcast every week
called Verdict with Ted Cruz, and I do it three days a week, Monday, Wednesday, and Friday. By
the way, for every reporter in the room, you should be following and listening to the podcast,
because we try to break news literally every podcast. And we've got millions of listeners.
We're also on syndicated radio and over 230 stations. The last podcast, I did a deep dive
analyzing this question, so in more length than we've got here. But the basic standards, number
one, the First Amendment absolutely protects speech. It absolutely protects hate speech,
it protects vile speech, it protects horrible speech. What does that mean? It means you cannot
be prosecuted for speech, even if it is evil and bigoted and wrong. The Klan can advocate horrible
racist ideas, and they cannot be prosecuted under the First Amendment. Nazis can advocate horrible
and racist ideas, and they cannot be prosecuted. However, that does not mean that any individual
is immune from the consequences of your speech. The First Amendment doesn't just give you a free
pass. And I'll give anyone an illustration. If you don't believe that, you can carry out a simple
test. Walk into your boss and say, go screw yourself. And you will discover that there are
consequences to speech, because you can't be criminally prosecuted for saying that, but your
boss can most certainly fire you, and you almost certainly will be fired. Likewise, we have seen
in the wake of the Charlie Kirk assassination, and I want to say Charlie was a good friend of
mine. I think last week was just a horrific week in this nation's history, and he was assassinated
for believing in free speech, for engaging in his views. He was assassinated not because he was
spreading lies, but because people were afraid of what he was saying. And I will say the courage he
had to go to college campuses and engage with people who disagreed, even if you might disagree
with him. He would engage in civil debate, going back and forth. That is the very finest of the
traditions of our First Amendment. We have seen, as you noted, across the country, people on the
left, not everybody, but far too many people celebrating Charlie Kirk's murder. We've seen
teachers in high schools and elementary schools posting online, celebrating. We've seen university
professors posting. In my view, they should absolutely face the consequences for celebrating
murder. And I'll give an illustration. Let's say you're a student at a university, and you decide
to go to your university and dress in a Klan outfit and burn a cross and advocate for murdering
African Americans. Under the First Amendment, you cannot be prosecuted for that. So you will not go
to jail for doing that. But you know what? You absolutely can be expelled for that, and you
should be. And I think the same is true that the people who are facing, and naming and shaming is
a First Amendment consequence. Just like John Stuart Mill said, the best response to bad speech
is more speech. And naming and shaming is part of a functioning and vibrant democracy.
Well, that's all the time we have right now. But I guess one more question related to this. I was
going to ask, what is the role in tech companies when it comes to what's going on this ugly,
this vitriol online right now, following this murder? Is there a role? Or maybe it's not,
because I know you've been on the opposite side of this. I mean, you led the charge criticizing
tech companies for censoring and sort of monitoring conservative speech. And that's
a big issue for you. Do you not want to see them do anything on this right now?
So look, what I will say is two principles, because some people have been confused. Wait a
second, you've been a huge critic of tech when it comes to censorship, and now you're a champion of
tech when it comes to AI. And it's real simple. Jobs are good, censorship's bad. So I'm going to
fight for us to win the race for jobs, because I want Americans to have good jobs and enjoy
prosperity. But I'm also going to fight against the abuse of power, because censorship is wrong.
And I will say big tech censorship, I've long been vocal on this, I think is the greatest
threat to free speech in the country, because it is invisible and insidious, that they can silence
views they disagree. And I think big tech got in bed with big government and silenced views
they disagreed. I think big tech is behaving better now with the new administration. I'll
confess I had mixed sentiments. We all saw the array of tech CEOs behind President Trump at the
inauguration. I had mixed sentiments. And so my view right now towards tech is much like Ronald
Reagan's view towards the Soviet Union, trust but verify. If you allow your platforms to be
platforms of free speech, great. And I'll say related to that, the single most important
development for free speech in this last generation was Elon Musk's buying Twitter.
Because, and it was an extraordinary step, because Twitter is the public square right now.
Look, the people who are hatefully celebrating Charlie Kirk's murder,
we only know about that because of Twitter. If Twitter was still old Twitter,
you wouldn't find out about any of it. So they should not do anything on that.
I think they should allow free speech. Now look, I will say I was glad when they pulled down the
video. The video was horrific. Like I said, Charlie was a friend of mine. I've talked to him
just a number of weeks ago. I got to say on my feed, he kept over and over again showing the
video of his being shot and blood spurting out of his throat. I was really glad when I could pick
up my phone and not see the image of my friend being murdered over and over and over again.
Not pushing that video is fine. What we should not see is censorship designed to silence either
side, by the way, to be clear. I'm not calling on tech to censor liberals. I actually think
more people should listen to Bernie Sanders and AOC because I think what they say is idiotic.
And so I want lots of people to hear it. And I'm happy to counter it on substance.
The answer is not silence those you disagree with. The answer is respond with substance. And that's
what what Charlie did so effectively. And it's one of the reasons I really admired him.
Thank you, Senator. That's all the time we have for.
Thank you.
