FULL: Texas governor's debate between Greg Abbott and Beto O'Rourke
Incumbent Greg Abbott. He wants to go take your guns and deny you your Second
Amendment rights. We will not let that happen.
Challenger Beto O'Rourke. An abortion ban with no exception for rape or incest
that is not us. That may be Greg Abbott. Now in their only debate before Election
Day we go after answers on the issues you care about most. Immigration,
abortion rights, gun violence, and how far we'll go to protect our children at
school. Tonight the heat is on in South Texas. Live from the University of Texas
Rio Grande Valley. The Texas governor's debate starts right now. We are coming to
you live from the Performing Arts Center at the University of Texas Rio Grande
Valley in Edinburgh for the Texas governor's debate and we are so happy
that you're joining us tonight. I am your host Britt Moreno anchor at KXAN in
Austin. This debate is airing live from El Paso to Tyler and from Amarillo to
Brownsville. Carried by 14 Nexstar Media Group stations in Texas as well as five
partner TV stations and we want you all to join in the conversation on social
media use the hashtag TXGovDebate. You'll see it there at the bottom of your
screen. You're all here to watch these two men share their vision for the state
of Texas. Asking the questions tonight our panelists from KSAT in San Antonio
anchor Steve Spreester. My colleague at KXAN anchor Sally Hernandez and from
the Dallas Morning News political writer Gromer Jeffers. Candidates let's briefly
go over the rules for tonight. Each candidate will have 60 seconds for each
question. If there are follow-ups candidates will then have 30 seconds and
there will be up to 30 seconds allowed. At the end of the debate each candidate
will have 30 seconds for closing statements and when your time is up
you're going to hear this bell and with that let's get started. I'm going to send
it over to my colleague Sally with the first question. Brit thank you and again
thank you both for being here tonight. I can tell it's gonna be an exciting night.
Got a lot of questions to ask you both but I just want to remind you please pay
attention to the time cues. This way you're not talking over each other and I
don't have to interrupt you and our viewers at home can hear your answers
tonight. Let's get to it. Immigration. Immigration issues are
especially relevant here in the Rio Grande Valley. For years U.S. Customs and
Border Protection has ranked it as the number one area for migrants crossing
illegally along the entire southwestern border. Many communities here have
suffered enormous monetary costs. Governor Abbott let's start with you and
you have 60 seconds with this question. What would you do to alleviate the
financial burden placed on these communities? We've been working to respond
to the disaster caused by the Biden administration that has caused such an
economic burden on these communities. Farms and ranches are run over.
Communities are disrupted. Homes that are invaded. Remember this just two years ago
we had one of the safest borders in decades but under the Biden
administration we have more people coming across the border than ever in
the history of our country. Texas has responded by making sure that we have a
National Guard and DPS deployed where they're making arrests and turning back
illegal immigrants as well as what we're doing to help local communities
by busing them from the area where Border Patrol is dropping them off to
sanctuary cities in northeastern parts of the country. But what we're doing is
making sure that we are keeping our community safe and this is completely
different than the way things would be under Beto because he said months ago
there is no problem on the border. He said that he would reduce immigration
enforcement. He even said that 95% of people come across the border illegally
who are allowed to stay. Mr. O'Rourke, I want to give you a chance to
respond and let me just repeat the question first for our viewers and for
you. What would you do to alleviate the financial burden placed on border
communities related to migrants crossing over? 60 seconds please. What we just
heard from the governor is what we are likely to hear over the course of this
debate. He's gonna blame people like President Biden. He's gonna try to lie
about my record and he's gonna distract from his failures, whether
it's his failure to keep the lights on in the grid, his failure to address
school shootings or his failure in immigration. We are eight years into his
time as governor and this is what we have on our border. In fact, $4 billion
into Operation Lone Star. We're seeing not fewer but more encounters at our
border right now. What we need is a safe, legal, orderly path for anyone who
wants to come here to work, to join family or to seek asylum. If you come to
this country, we expect you to follow the law. But on our side, we're gonna
make sure that our laws reflect our values and our interests. And I'm going
to work with local leaders, Republicans and Democrats alike to make sure that
we have a Texas based guest worker program to alleviate shortages that we
have in our state for labor demands and reduce inflation and address supply
chain issues as well. Thank you, Governor Abbott. You just heard your
opponent talk about Operation Lone Star and have a follow up question about
that. About $4 billion in state funds has been directed to the Operation Lone
Star Border Security Initiative. The program is seen as funding increase as
recently as this past July. So the question, Governor, in 30 seconds, if you
can't answer this, should more money be allocated towards Operation Lone Star?
And if so, Governor, how much? Well, candidly, we shouldn't have to allocate
any money for it because this is all because of Joe Biden's failure to do
the president's job to secure the border. We're only having to do that
because of Joe Biden's failure and because it would be the same pathway
that Beto would take us down. Speaking of which, he talked about this guest
worker program. He could have done that had he won the race for the Senate or
won the race for president. That's not a job for governor. The job of governor
is have to deal with the chaos caused by the Biden administration and his open
border policies that Beto would replicate. Just what we have is chaos
thanks to Governor Abbott right now. Okay, let me give you 15 seconds to
answer the question for me. How much money should be going toward Operation
Lone Star? And I'm telling $0 should be going to Operation Lone Star, and
that's what it would be if we had a president who is enforcing the
immigration laws of the United States of America. Mr Work. I want to go over
to you 30 seconds for this question. It's the same one. Should more money be
allocated towards Operation Lone Star? No, it's clearly failed. The numbers
are in. We're seeing not fewer but more engagements at our border. When the
governor spent four billion of our tax dollars on what has turned out to be
political theater for his political career, he promised us that it would
deter people from coming to this country. We've only seen more people
come. Now they get a bus ride to Chicago or Washington, D. C. Or New York. We
don't need any more stunts. We need solutions. We need those coming here to
follow our laws. We need to make sure our laws follow. I'll give you 15
seconds, Governor. Sure. So these are efforts to protect our state. There is
a record amount of fentanyl coming across the border. This deadly Texas
law enforcement has seized enough fentanyl to kill every man, woman and
child in the entire country. And this is because of Joe Biden. Governor Abbott,
I assure you we have a lot of questions, a lot of topics to get to you and Steve
has the next one. Thank you, Sally. And thank you, gentlemen, for both being
here tonight. Uh, Mr Work. I want to continue with the immigration topic.
Now, you've criticized the deployment of National Guard troops to the border.
Here's a clip of you speaking at a March rally in College Station. Guard
members from Texas A and M who are on the border right now and Sabata and
Webb and Hidalgo counties to will be part of a solution in search of a
problem,
a solution in search of a problem. More recently, you told the Houston
Chronicle that you will put some troops on the border as governor in 60
seconds. Can you explain why your view on deploying troops has seemingly
changed when it comes to the border? It hasn't. I've actually been to Sabata
and Webb and Maverick counties and listen to these members of the guard
who had less than a week to say goodbye to their families into their careers
and into their communities to be part of the governor's political theater.
Those aren't my words. Those are their words. So far, we've lost the lives of
eight guard members. Four of them have taken their lives, and four of them
have died in questionable circumstances, none of whom, by the way, was killed by
anybody coming in to this country. These guard members say they have no powers
to arrest or detain anybody. 10,000 guard members, $4 billion, and it's been
a complete failure. Much is everything that the governor has done has been a
failure for this state. What we need are solutions, not more stunts where we
could have a strategic deployment on a voluntary basis for guard members. Let's
do that. I've been consistent on that, where we can partner with local sheriffs
with DPS troopers. Let's do that. But we need to work on things like a Texas
based guest worker program to meet labor needs in our communities and ensure
that our laws match our values. Thank you, Mr Ward. Governor, I want to talk
to you. You talked about migrants and the busing of migrants. Many migrant
advocates and Democratic elected officials have expressed concerns about
the treatment of migrants being bused from Texas to other states and cities.
Here's New York Mayor Eric Adams talking about that just last week. And
when we reached out to Governor Abbott and stated, can we coordinate? Can we
identify, you know who's traveling here that we don't have to guess this? They
refuse to do so. The White House has called this a political stunt.
Governor Abbott, is this a political stunt? And has there been coordination
with the states and cities these migrants are being taken to? And if not,
why not? You have 60 seconds. So this operation began after meeting with
local officials, sheriffs, mayors, police chiefs and county judges where
they were overrun with the number of migrants that Border Patrol had dumped
into their tiny little communities. They needed relief and busing was one
of the ways of providing them relief and thus began the process of busing the
migrants to cities that self identified as sanctuary cities. Mayor Adams has
never called my office, never talked to anybody in my administration. And so
what he's saying is just flat out false. There has been communication
between non governmental organizations in Texas as well as the ultimate
location, whether it be Washington D. C. Or New York. But going back to what
Beto said, he's what you showed on video earlier was what happens throughout
this entire campaign where Beto continues to flip flop on issue after
issue after issue. He's flip flop on the border issue. He's flip flop on the
energy issue, such as energy jobs and the Green New Deal. He's flip flopped
on defunding the police. Whether it's one issue or another, he keeps changing
positions. I want to be clear, though. You say that Mayor Adams has never
called your office, correct? Thank you, Mr O'Rourke. I want to follow up on
this. You've called the busing of migrants of political stunt as well. Why
shouldn't sanctuary cities share the burden of what's happening on the Texas
border? You have 30 seconds. Look, I live on the border. No one cares more
about the security and safety of the border than those who are raising our
Children there. I also serve as a city council member there and in my time
working with law enforcement, working with state and federal partners, we
were able to help make El Paso, Texas one of the safest cities in the United
States of America. It's because we were looking at solutions instead of these
stunts. I just want to remind everyone this guy's been governor for eight
years, and this is where we are today. Some of the worst levels of engagement
encounters, fentanyl trafficking and human smuggling that we've seen. That's
the result of stunts instead of solutions. Stick to the time, please.
Thank you. Steve, I've got to respond to what he just said. Absolutely. I'll give
you 15 seconds. He mentioned El Paso. The fact of the matter is the El Paso
mayor, a Democrat, the El Paso City Council Democrats, they are now busing
more people than the state of Texas is busing, and he's not calling them out
for them busing people to other regions. It's a completely different program. It is
apples to oranges. And I'll tell you, this hateful rhetoric, this treating
human beings as political pawns, talking about invasions, we're gonna
we're gonna move on, defending themselves. That's how people get killed
at the Walmart in El Paso. The gentleman in Hudspeth that we just learned about
yesterday. This is incredibly dangerous for Texas and is not reflective of our
values. Okay, Governor, I want to give you 30 seconds to respond to those
charges. Sure. I mean, it's clear that Beto just wants to perpetuate the open
border policies and mischaracterize exactly what's going on. He refuses to
acknowledge that the city of El Paso, because they were so overwhelmed by Joe
Biden's open border policies. They, too, are having to bust migrants out of
their communities because they have no way of keeping them there. That's what
we're trying to do to help our local communities and make sure that we're
going to lighten the load. No one is for open borders. Not the least of us who
actually live on the borders. This is the kind of stunt that you get from
Greg Abbott. We need solutions right now. I want to go to a follow up for you,
Governor Abbott, and it's on the bus in question. These migrants are being sent
to states and cities with Democratic leadership. Why aren't these migrants
being sent to so-called sanctuary cities in Republican-led states like New
Orleans or Metro Atlanta? You have 30 seconds. So, again, because these cities
of New York and Washington, D.C. and Chicago are so large and have the
infrastructure that's available, they have the capability of accommodating the
number of migrants that are being sent better than these other cities that you
talked about. There will be other cities in the future that also will be
on the receiving end of migrants because we will continue to have to move
migrants because Joe Biden continues to allow more illegal immigrants to come
into the state of Texas. Thank you, Governor. My colleague, Gromer Jeffords,
has the next question. Thank you, Steve, and hello, gentlemen. Good to see you
both. You too, Gromer. Let's pivot now to the topic of gun control. Following the
Uvalde massacre, many community members made this one specific plea.
Here's one student who survived the shooting at Robb Elementary. You have to
be 21 to buy a case of beer, but an 18-year-old bought a gun to kill kids.
That does not make sense. To be clear, that's a call to raise the age limit to
buy an AR-15 style weapon from 18 to 21. A Republican governor in Florida broke
with the NRA to sign this into law after the Parkland mass shooting.
Governor Abbott, you say this can't be done in Texas. Mr. O'Rourke, you say it will
be done if you're elected. Can you please explain your positions? Let's start with
you, Governor Abbott. You have 60 seconds. First, there's no reason why a little
girl like that should ever have to say anything like that. There's a reason why
these parents are angry, and they're rightfully angry, and I can feel their
pain. No parent should lose a child, and we want to do everything we
can to make sure that does not happen. We want to end school shootings, but we
cannot do that by making false promises. It's a false promise to suggest that we
can pass a law that will be upheld by the Constitution to raise the age, and
here's why. The most recent federal court of appeals decision on this particular
issue said that it was unconstitutional for a state to raise the age from 18 to
21 for a person to buy an AR-15. So any attempt to try to raise the age is
going to be met with it being overturned. So we need to get to the bottom of what
is really ailing our communities, and that is the mental health that is
leading people to engage in school shootings, and Texas is already addressing
that. Just a quick follow-up, Governor. Take 15 seconds to answer this.
You're a former attorney general. You've never shied away from a legal fight. Are
you against this proposal because you feel like it's unconstitutional, or you
believe that it's unnecessary?
Purely from a legal position, based upon what that court of appeals decision
ruled, and importantly, based upon what the Supreme Court decision said in a
June opinion that changed the way that that Parkland case was determined. I know
how the Parkland case was determined. Florida is going to have its law
overturned because of this new Supreme Court decision. Thank you, Governor. Mr.
O'Rourke, in 60 seconds, can you please explain your position on raising the age
limit to purchase AR-15 style weapons?
I'm going to follow the lead of those families from Uvalde. That's who I'm
doing this for. In fact, many of them drove more than five hours, 280 miles to
be here today, even though they're not allowed in this theater because of the
governor's conditions, because they want to hold him accountable, because it's
been 18 weeks since their kids have been killed, and not a thing has changed
in this state to make it any less likely that any other child will meet the same
fate. All we need is action, and the only person standing in our way is the
governor of the state of Texas. In Florida, after the Parkland shootings, it
was 23 days for that Republican governor to raise the age, and in those states
where the age has been raised, mass shootings are down 80%. So yes, we can
raise the age to 21, and as governor, I'll bring Republicans and Democrats
around the table to do that. After all these mass shootings, this governor has
done nothing except make it easier for people who should not have a firearm to
carry them publicly, and this is what we get as a result. We need change.
Governor Abbott, the last time you ran for governor, we asked you about red flag laws,
and those are laws which could stop an individual with a potential intention to
harm others from purchasing a gun, and you said about that, quote,
I would not support a red flag law that would take guns away from people without
due process. Now, a lot has happened in those four years. Are you open to
implementing red flag laws today? You have 30 seconds.
Well, let me tell you what I support and I don't support. What I support is making
it a felony for someone to lie on a background check. I signed that into law
last year. I approve of expanding background checks to include juvenile
records, also approve of making it a crime for criminal gangs to buy or to
possess a gun, but I'm still against red flag laws for the reason that it would
deny a lawful Texas gun owner their constitutional right to due process.
Thank you, Governor. Mr. O'Rourke, you have been criticized at times for your
positions on gun control, including this comment you made in 2019 while
running for president.
Hell, yes, we're gonna take your AR-15, your AK-47. We're not gonna allow it to be.
But in February, you told reporters and Tyler that you were, quote, not
interested in taking anything away from anyone. So which is it, Mr. O'Rourke?
Are you for confiscating AR-15 style weapons or not? You have 30 seconds.
After losing 23 of my neighbors to somebody armed with a weapon of war,
after talking to these families who could only identify their Children in
nuvality by the shoes that they were wearing, it's clear to me that the only
place that an AR-15 or an AK-47 makes sense is on a battlefield. But as
governor of the state of Texas, I need to be focused on what we can get done.
Raising the minimum age of purchase to 21. We can get that done. A red flag
law. We'll get that done. Universal background checks. We will get that done.
We'll make progress and take action where this governor has failed. Thank
you, Mr. O'Rourke. So just to be clear, yes or no, are you for confiscating AR-15
style weapons? I'm for making sure that we make progress. Those families that I
was just with from nuvality want us to take action. This is the common ground.
I've listened to Republicans and Democrats alike on this. We can agree on
this much. Raise the age to 21. Okay. Red flag law and universal background
checks. Thank you, Mr. O'Rourke. Steve has the next question. Thank you,
Gromer. We want to focus in now more on the Uvalde shooting.
A gunman killed 19 Children and two adults. Its effects, though, go far
beyond Uvalde. Mr. O'Rourke, I want you to speak to parents of victims and
really all parents statewide worried about their Children's safety at school.
What would you do if elected to prevent this from happening again? You have 60
seconds. Just like you. I'm a parent with Amy. We're raising Ulysses and
Molly and Henry in El Paso, and we are well aware that it's been 18 weeks and
this governor has not lifted a finger to make it any less likely that any of
our kids will meet that same fate. We need change. The governor just talked
about mental health care. We are dead last in the nation when it comes to
mental health care access, and he took $211 million from the mental health
care budget of the state of Texas. He'll talk about police funding. He
failed to fund the police radios in Uvalde, even when that police
department asked for them. And you know what? Those radios failed on that day.
I want every parent out there to know that the lives of your Children are
more important to me than the N. R. A. Or any special interests or any other
political consideration. I will prioritize them ahead of everything
else, and we will take action and we will make progress. We'll bring
Republicans, Democrats, independents alike together, and we'll get the job
done with this. Governor has failed to do so. Governor Abbott to you. Now the
families of the victims, the Uvalde School district, the Uvalde County
commissioners, the Uvalde City Council all asked for you to call a special
session in the wake of the tragedy. You did not, despite calling them on
several other issues in the past. Can you explain why you didn't call a
special session? You have 60 seconds. I will, but I must first respond to what
we have to respond to every single day. Beto's campaign continues to spew lies
and false information. He said two things that are completely false. He
said that we're last mental health care. The fact of the matter is, Texas
is now 27th mental health care because of funding that I provided. Texas has
provided more than $25 billion for mental health care in the last three
sessions. He also said that we did not fund police radios in Uvalde completely
false. We provided $1.6 million for Uvalde alone for their police radio
systems since I've been governor. So Beto continues to provide false
information. What I want to make sure that the leaders in Uvalde know is, as
we've shown, we don't need to call a special session in order to take action
for six consecutive days. After the shooting took place, I issued
directives to make school safer and respond to the emergency in Uvalde. And
then I remain engaged with the mayor, with the local leaders. It could have
been worse. That's what you told those families. That's what you told that
community. Thank you. Nothing to help them. Mr. We're not done with this
topic yet, so you will have your say. But Governor, I want to follow up with
you. There's a regular session coming up in January. Will you make school
safety an emergency item for lawmakers when they meet? You have 15 seconds.
Absolutely. Just like I did in past sessions, this is going to be an
emergency item. Over the summer, I requested special legislative
committees to begin working already so that they will have ready when we begin
the session to address Uvalde, but the broader based issue across the entire
state of Texas. If it's an emergency call a special session now, why wait
till the next year? Mr. O'Rourke, a question for you now. Gun violence is a
leading cause of death for children and teenagers in this state. Why are you
waiting to save lives? Sir, please, we need to move on. We've got a lot of
topics we want to get to, but we want to stay on Uvalde because there's still
some questions that we have here. So I appreciate you staying within your time.
Mr. O'Rourke, Uvalde School District Police Chief Peter Arradondo, who led
the initial law enforcement response at Robb Elementary, was fired. Is there
anyone else who should be held accountable for the mistakes made in
that hallway in Robb Elementary that day? You have 30 seconds. The governor said it
himself in an interview to Gromer Jeffers last month. There should be
accountability up and down the ballot, beginning with Greg Abbott. I think he
has lost the right to serve this state and most important position of public
trust. Furthermore, we know that there were 91 DPS troopers for whom he is
responsible who were on the other side of an unlocked door, some for more than
70 minutes. There is a complete failure to hold people responsible,
accountable. Those families still do not have justice. As governor, I will make
it my priority. Thank you, Mr. O'Rourke. Governor, now to you. There was it. Go
ahead. I'll give you 15 seconds if you want to respond to what you said. I was gonna
answer your question. I thought you were gonna ask me. I've got another
question for you. Right after the shooting, you said this. But the reality
is, as horrible as what happened, it could have been worse. It could have been
worse. You heard Mr. O'Rourke bring it up. You later said you were misled about
what happened inside Robb Elementary. If my memory serves me right, that was the
day after. So we were just moments after what had happened. Who misled you and
will they be held accountable? You have 30 seconds. Everyone in that briefing
room that provided me the information about what law enforcement did, what that
comment was based upon was information by law enforcement about all the
children and all the other classrooms that they evacuated during the time when
the shooter was on the campus. What they did not tell me at the time, however, was
that there were dozens, if not more, of other law enforcement that were hanging
around in the hallway for over an hour without engaging in the Columbine
protocol and going in and immediately removing that shooter, which is what
they were supposed to do. And because they failed to do that, there does need
to be accountability, not just for Pete Arredondo, but also for local law
enforcement. DPS officers are under investigation as we speak right now.
There needs to be accountability for law enforcement at every level for not
following the Columbine protocol. You won't be sure to hold DPS troopers
accountable. So, yes, in a word, yes. But second, there are at least seven who are
under investigation as we speak right now, two of whom are on suspension as we
speak right now. And so we, I expect DPS officers and law enforcement across the
state to follow the Columbine protocol. Governor, the buck stops on your desk.
You blame everyone else. You blame Joe Biden for other issues. We need to move on.
You blame people for misleading you. You are misleading the state. Sally will ask the next question.
I do, and I think you're both going to want to talk about this next topic. It's the topic of abortion. A recent Next Star, Emerson
College, and the Hill poll shows more than a half of those polled say they are
more likely to vote in this election because of the overturning of Roe vs.
Wade. You both are very outspoken on this issue, but what I want to do tonight is
really drill down on specifics. Governor Abbott, you recently sat down with my
friend Gromer over here, and you talked about what women can do if they are
victims of rape or incest, and here's a clip of that interview. Those victims can
access health care immediately, as well as to report it. Both of those have very
meaningful consequences. By accessing health care immediately, they can get the
Plan B pill that can prevent a pregnancy from occurring in the first place. Some
health care advocates say emergency contraception, like Plan B, is often
unavailable or it's too costly for women to afford, and trauma could prevent them
from taking emergency contraception in the timeframe that it's effective. So
Governor, we're going to start with you with these concerns that I just laid out.
Is emergency contraception a viable alternative to abortion for victims of
rape and incest? And you have 60 seconds, sir. So to directly answer the topics
that you raised on the availability of it, it's incumbent upon the state of
Texas to make sure that is readily available for those who are victims of
sexual assault or survivors of sexual assault. The state of Texas pays for
that, whether it be at a hospital, at a clinic or for someone who gets a
prescription because of it. And so not only is it should be readily available,
but the state of Texas is going to pay for it to make sure that it is available
for them. Governor, 30 seconds or, you know, I'll give you, I'll give you 30
seconds to answer this one. I still want to know, is Plan B the alternative when
it comes to somebody who is pregnant from rape or incest? Well, it depends on
what you mean by alternative. An alternative, obviously, is to do what we
can to assist and aid the victim. And that is to help get them medical
assistance that they need and the care that they need, but also to know what
their options are. They're going to know that the state, through our
alternatives to abortion program, provides living assistance, baby
supplies, all kinds of things that can help them. Also, we've increased funding
for prenatal and postpartum care. Thank you, Governor. Mr. O'Rourke, we're going
to stay on the topic of abortion here. Governor Abbott has said that you
support abortion on demand. Do you support any limit on when a woman can't
have an abortion? 60 seconds for this question. This election is about
reproductive freedom. If you care about this, you need to turn out and vote. I
will fight to make sure that every woman in Texas can make her own
decisions about her own body, her own future and her own health care. And I
will work with the legislature and my fellow Texans to return us to the
standard that Texas women won in the first place, Roe versus Wade. That's the
standard that answers your question. But I've got to respond to this, this
silliness on Plan B, this comment he made about eliminating rape in the state of
Texas. This is an attack on women. More women have been raped in the state of
Texas than any other state. There are 3,000 untested rape kits at DPS
headquarters, meaning that our ability to bring rapists to
justice has declined by half on this governor's watch. And it's arguable that
rapists enjoy more victims, more rights under Greg Abbott than their
victims do because they can sue the families of their victims if they help
their victim get an abortion and be able to win a $10,000 bounty in the process.
Mr. Orr, I'll give you a chance to respond, Governor. 30 seconds. So once again, I'm
going to be doing this a lot. I have to point out a misstatement by Beto. I
signed a law that eliminated the rape kit test backlog at the Texas Department
of Public Safety. As it concerns abortion, listen, Beto's position is the
most extreme because he not only supports abortion of a fully developed
child to the very last second before birth, he's even against providing
medical care for a baby who survives an abortion. He is for unlimited abortion at
taxpayer expense. That's not true. It's completely a lie. I never said that and
no one thinks that in the state of Texas. He's saying this because he
signed the most extreme abortion ban in America. No exception for rape, no
exception for incest. It begins at conception and it's taking place in a
state that is at the epicenter of a maternal mortality crisis, thanks to
Greg Abbott, three times as deadly for black women. I will fight to make sure
that every woman makes her own decisions about her own body, her own future, and
her own health care. That's what most of us, Republicans and Democrats in this
state, believe. Mr. O'Rourke, just in 15 seconds, is there a limit that you support on
women getting an abortion? That limit was decided in 1973 through a victory that
Jane Roe and Linda Coffey and Sarah Weddington won before an all-male United
States Supreme Court. I want us to return to that. It was the law of the land for
nearly 50 years until we had the most extreme abortion ban in the country.
Thanks, thanks, Sally. Let's move to the law enforcement. Mr. O'Rourke, you have
been accused by Governor Abbott of supporting efforts to defund police. He
may have mentioned it tonight, actually. Here's a chance for you to set the
record straight. Do you support measures to defund police? You have 60 seconds. Of
course I don't, and no one does, but let's look at my record. I think that's
the best thing to look at, and then we'll look at the governor's. On the El Paso
City Council, I raised police salaries 12% in the six years that I served here.
In Congress, I funded $11 billion to local and state law
enforcement across this country, including in Texas. I want to fund law
enforcement, fund training so that everyone is treated equally under the
law, and I want there to be accountability for when those officers
abuse the public trust. But let's look at what Greg Abbott's done. When police and
law enforcement begged him not to sign permitless carry because it allows
anyone to carry a gun in public without a background check, he turned his back on
them, did it anyhow. Homicides have gone up 50% and we now have gun violence as
a leading cause of death for Children and teenagers in this state. When the
Evaldi Police Department asked for funding, he turned his back on them. He
is not doing what keeps us safe. That's why you see the level of rape, violent
crime and homicide up on Greg Abbott's watch. Just a quick follow up, Mr.
O'Rourke. Can you take 15 seconds to answer this? Uh, after the summer of
2020, did you, uh, voice support for cities that cut their police budgets?
Minneapolis comes to mind. Did you support those efforts? What I supported
and what I continue to support is full funding for law enforcement, full
funding that includes training to ensure that we're treating everyone
equally under the law. And we definitely need accountability and justice. If
someone abuses the power of life and death over our fellow citizens without
accountability, we lose the ability to keep our communities. Thank you, Mr.
O'Rourke. Governor Abbott, you have spoken about the growing crime in Texas
in your commercials and on the campaign trail. You've been governor for more
than seven years. So why is crime up? Don't you bear some of the
responsibility for it? So fully answer that question. Let me first. You have 60
seconds, by the way. Let me reply. And that is once again, Beto misleads by
saying that we denied you Valley Police Department any money. We we've
answered every call that ever made to make sure they have whatever funding
they need. And Beto clearly said that in response to Minneapolis that he
supports their idea of defunding and dismantling, dismantling police. I got
to add this. He didn't say a word to criticize the city of Austin that
defended their police by more than $100 million. The law I passed will prevent
any city from defunding the police because in Texas we support our law
enforcement officers, period. The reason why there's been a rise in crime in
some areas, Gomer is because of another issue we're working on. And that's
what's happened in Harris County and some other counties were in Harris
County to have these easy bail policies that Beto supports, which is cashless
bail. There's letting dangerous criminals such as people recently
convicted of murder last year back out on the streets now who killed a police
officer recently in Texas. Take 15 seconds to answer this again. You've
been governor for seven years. Crime is up. Do you bear any responsibility for
that? So let me again explain what happened in Austin after they defended
the police. The year after that, they had the highest number of murders ever
in Harris County, where they have this easy bail policy. In the past couple of
years, there have been hundreds of people killed by people let out on bail
who had been previously arrested for murder. Thank you, Governor. Our next
topic comes from one of our one of our viewers. Actually, Brett has more on
that. Yes, Grover. Thank you so much. Candidates. I have our first viewer
question for you. And just so you know, we use this as a jumping off point to
then craft our own question for you. So here is Douglas Tyler out of Hayes
County with his question. Douglas
Governor, what steps would you take to ensure that there is not another
failure like we had during the winter of 2021? How would you increase the
generation capacity and reliability? Is it time for Texas to face reality and
join the rest of the country in the cooperative grid system?
Okay. Clearly, Douglas asked a lot of questions about the grid. Many Texans
have similar questions, so we're gonna break them down one by one. And for
that, I will send it back over to my colleague. Thank you, Britain. I want to
thank Douglas for that question and Governor Abbott first for you. Following
the outages in February of 2021, the Legislature passed 18 different pieces
of legislation aimed at improving the grid. An energy expert, Ed Herz from the
University of Houston, said last month, quote, No question. The grid's better
than it was at this time. Last year, the governor says it's never been more
reliable. But if you're getting up off the floor, any kind of movement is
better than what it was, end quote. Governor Abbott, what do you make of
that assessment of the state grid? Are you confident in its reliability? You
have 60 seconds. Very confident. In fact, even guaranteed the power would
stay on before we face that winter. Afterwards, when Beto was campaigning,
saying that the grid was gonna fail in the winter and summer, his campaign
hopes fell apart because the laws that I signed did secure the grid. Ever
since I signed those reform laws, no Texan has lost power because of the
Texas power grid. And know this, Steve, and that is, this summer, we set 11
all-time records for heat. Time and again, the power grid was able to keep
up, and it's because of the reforms we were able to make. And so the power
grid remains more resilient, more reliable than ever before. To go ahead
and answer Douglas's question, which we appreciate, one reason why it's more
reliable is because we have greater power available to us and a greater
ability by the Public Utilities Commission to address it. But also, we
are going to be adding more renewable power, I mean, non-renewable power, such
as natural gas, to make sure that the power stays on. Thank you, Governor.
Mr. O'Rourke, same question. You know, there hasn't been any major issues with
the grid with outages since the winter of 2021. What do you make of the
changes that Governor Abbott and the legislature put in to make the grid
more reliable? They say more reliable. What would you do differently? You have
60 seconds. Governor Abbott's grid failure is part of a pattern over these
last eight years. Warned about, for example, school violence and gun
violence, specifically against children, does nothing. Warned about problems
within Child Protective Services, our foster care program, does nothing, and
it gets worse. Warned before February 2021 that we had problems in the grid,
he did nothing. When the blackout started, he ordered the price of
electricity pegged at its highest allowable rate. Gas started trading at
200 times what it had sold for the day before. Now we are all paying 45 bucks
more on average in our monthly utility bills. It's the Abbott tax that all of
us pay. 700 of our fellow Texans lost their lives because of his incompetence
and his inability to do what was necessary before February of 2021. And
the kicker is the grid is still not fixed. Just ask Toyota. They stopped
their third shift in San Antonio because it was drawing too much power.
We had 33 conservation notices this summer. We are not ready for this next
winter. We need a governor who's going to do the right thing. Thank you, Mr
Roar. Governor, I'll give you 30 seconds. All Beto does is fear monger
on this issue, when in reality the grid is more resilient and reliable than
it's ever been. I do want to respond to the price because importantly, Texans
need to know this. And that is after Yuri, after the reforms that we passed,
Texas has one of the lowest electricity prices in the country, far below the
national average and less than half of what the electricity price is in
California. It's one of the fastest growing costs in the state of Texas. And
when you look at our higher energy bills, our property taxes, 20 billion
more under Greg Abbott, you see that he's the largest driver of inflation in
the state of Texas right now. I'll give you 15 seconds, Governor. So it just
makes this stuff up because again, the reality is the electricity costs in
Texas remains one of the lowest in the entire United States of America and far
lower than the national average. Ask the people who are paying it. Thank you,
gentlemen. Sally has the next question. Got to talk about education tonight,
gentlemen. Okay, there's a lot of teachers who are watching and who would
like to know the answer to this next question. Texas school districts are
hampered by an unprecedented teacher retention crisis. A Texas teacher
workforce report reveals there were more than 13,000 new teachers in Texas
for the start of the 2010 2011 school year. Look at that number. Flash
forward. The 2019 2020 school year, less than half of those teachers
remained. Former teachers cited everything from pay to burnout to
safety as problems. Mr Work, I want to start with you for this next question.
How are you going to keep qualified teachers in the classroom when you have
60 seconds? I mentioned earlier that Amy and I are raising our three Children
in El Paso, where they attend the world class public schools there, and we know
firsthand the important job that those educators do. And I want every educator
out there to know that I've got your back, and I'm gonna make sure that we
pay you enough not to work a second or third job because of Greg Abbott. Our
teachers are underpaid on average by $7500 a year. I'm gonna ensure that you
have more valuable classroom time to connect with those kids. So we're gonna
stop the star test and allow you to focus on drawing forth that lifelong
love of learning from every child before you for a retired teachers. I'll make
sure you have a cost of living adjustment every single year going
forward. You haven't had one in 18 years, eight of those on Greg Abbott's
watch, and most importantly, I will treat you with the dignity and respect
that you have earned and that you deserve. You sacrifice and give so much
to our kids into the state. We need to make sure we're holding up our end of
the bargain as governor. I will 30 seconds to respond to this follow up.
You say that you do support teachers. Do you support giving them a pay raise if
you're elected? And if so, how are you gonna pay for that? Absolutely. I want
to give them a pay raise. I want to make sure again that they're not working
that second or third job. What I propose to do, and there's Republican and
Democratic support for this, is raise the state's share of school funding.
Right now we ask property taxpayers, the homeowners and renters out there to
shoulder the majority of the burden. I want to make sure that the state is
shouldering its fair share. We do that. We can reduce your property taxes at
home and provide more funding for our schools, increased teacher pay and more
per pupil funding in every district in Texas. Thank you, Mr Work. Governor
Abbott. Same question. How are you going to keep qualified teachers in the
classroom is the question. Can you answer that for me in 30 seconds? I will,
but I got to say that raise the state's share of education funding is exactly
what we did both in 2019 and 2021. In fact, I provided more funding for
education than any governor in Texas history. I provided more funding for
teacher pay raises than any governor in Texas history. As we gather here tonight,
Sally, the per pupil funding in the state of Texas is at the highest that's ever
been. So we will work with the teachers to make sure I created a new program. I
can tell you about. I'm gonna give you 30 more seconds. This is your 60 second
answer. I created a new program that provides a six figure salary for
teachers more than $100,000. It was used very effectively and broadly in the
Dallas County or Dallas Independent School District area on its catching on
around the state. If teachers will dedicate themselves to be these master
teachers, they will be able to earn a six figure salary. Educators watching
tonight, 15 seconds or less. Are you gonna give them a pay raise if you were
reelected? Yes, we just as we have given them a pay raise in the past, we will
continue those pay raises going forward. He's been governor for eight years.
They're still underpaid $7500 against their national counterparts. People
funding. Let me give you 15 seconds. Go ahead. I'll give you 15 seconds, but we
can't talk over each other. Go ahead. Per pupil funding in the state is $4000
less than our counterparts across the country. Educational attainment is at
an all time low pre pandemic in the average fourth grade classroom in Texas.
Um, most of those fourth graders could not read at time is up. We need to get
the backs of those teachers. Time is up. We're gonna go to grow more for the
next question. Thank you. Thank you, Sally. Um, the next two questions are
personal questions directed to each of you. Only there will be no opportunities
for rebuttals. So let's start with you, Governor Abbott. University of Houston
political scientist Brandon Rotting House said the following quote in Texas
politics is adapt or die. Greg Abbott didn't start his career as a right
wing Republican, but he certainly ended up there. Governor Abbott, you signed a
law banning nearly all abortions without exceptions for rape or incest and a law
allowing the permanent list carry of firearms. Critics, including some
members of your own party, say you have moved too far to the right. Have
you moved too far to the right? Governor, you have 60 seconds. Let's
look at the issues that you brought up, and that is for one, uh, as a Catholic
and my wife and I, we've been pro life our entire lives so much so that it
grew even stronger when we adopted our daughter on the day she was born. I was
the very first person to hold her after she was born, and I've seen firsthand
the power that adoption can have, and it just further strengthened my belief in
the power of giving life to every child possible, seeing how it can happen so
successfully. I want others to be able to have that same sense of joy, not
only that my wife and I've had, but also that our daughter has had. In general,
one thing that we've been able to achieve across the entire state of Texas,
we've been sure that we provide opportunity for everybody. Gromer, as we
gather here tonight, Texas ranks number one in jobs created by black business
owners and jobs created by Hispanic women business owners. Governor Abbott,
just 10 more seconds.
Have you moved too far to the right, though, in recent years? What I tried to
explain to you, Gromer, is that I'm governing from principles. I'm not
looking at chaining and constantly flip-flopping positions like other
people do. I'm governing from my principles. Thank you. Thank you,
Governor Abbott. Mr. O'Rourke, you served as a congressman from West Texas
from 2013 to 2018. Since then, you had a close but unsuccessful run for Senate
against Ted Cruz in 2018. Two years later, in 2020, you had an unsuccessful
run for president. Now, you're running for governor. Why have you run for so
many different offices? Is it about ambition or public service? You have 60
seconds.
You know, I feel so lucky that through so much of my life, I've had the
opportunity to serve others. As a small business owner in El Paso, Texas,
creating high-skill, high-wage, high-value jobs in our community, as a
member of the City Council, as a member of Congress on the House Veterans
Affairs Committee, delivering for those who put their lives on the line for
this country, for all of us. It has been the honor of my lifetime. And now, to
run, to be able to overcome these failures that we see in Texas right now,
whether it's a grid that doesn't work, teachers who are leaving the profession
by the thousands, leading the nation, a number of school shootings, being able
to deliver for people who are counting on us at this moment of truth to make
sure that we come through. And it's not just me, and it's not just my political
party. There are hundreds of thousands of people across the state of Texas who
want change and are working for it. And it's my honor to be able to lead this
campaign and to serve as the next governor of this state, to make sure that
we deliver for them.
Thank you, Mr. O'Rourke. Let's go back to Britt now for another topic
inspired by a viewer question.
Yes, another viewer question for you tonight, candidates. And we did use this
to then craft our own question as a heads up. So first, that initial
question from a Netstar News Nation viewer. It's from Missy Pena out of
New Braunfels. Here's Missy.
What are your plans to help get mortgage rates under control and make sure that
housing stays affordable for everyone to avoid the issues we had in 08, 09,
where everyone was losing their homes to foreclosure?
Now we have our own question that includes things on property taxes. And
for that, I will send it over to Steve.
Thank you, Britt. Thank you, Missy, for that great question. You know, property
taxes make up a hefty amount of most people's mortgages in the state of
Texas.
Mr. O'Rourke, I want to ask you this question first. The governor's proposed
using half of the $27 billion budget surplus to provide what he says is the
largest property tax cut in state history. That does not relieve the
long-term property tax burden that many Texas residents feel. How would you
provide long-term property tax relief? You have 60 seconds.
You know, about the governor's proposal, you have to ask yourself where this
guy's been for the last eight years. People across the state are hurting. The
average Texan now is paying more in taxes than the average Californian. When
you combine that with his failure in the grid that has sent our energy bills
through the roof and the cost of housing, he's a single greatest driver
of inflation in the state of Texas. This is how we can turn it around. One,
let's expand Medicaid. We'll go from a state that's the least insured to one
where everyone can see a doctor or be able to fill a prescription. It will
also reduce our property taxes because right now you are on the hook for
uncompensated indigent care. Two, let's up the share of state spending for
public ed. I talked about it earlier. The state spends 40%, local property
taxpayers 60%. Under my leadership, we'll get that to 50-50, reduce the
pressure on local property taxpayers. And third, let's make sure that there's
property tax fairness. Corporations in this state are not paying their fair
share. That means all of us pay more. Thank you, sir. Governor Abbott, I want
to ask you the same question. How do you provide long term property tax
relief? You also have 60 cents. Property tax relief is central to this
election and to Texans at home, just like missing. And know this, there's
only one person on this stage tonight who's ever raised property taxes, and
that is Beto. Beto raised property taxes three times when he was on the city
council in El Paso. I will never raise property taxes. And one thing he knows
also, and that is the state of Texas does not levy a property tax. That's only
done at the local level. And so what the state of Texas has done, and we will
continue to do, is to drive down the ability of the local governments from
being able to raise taxes. And I'm the only one with a bold vision for
actually cutting property taxes. As you pointed out, because of our strong
economy in Texas, we have a budget surplus of $27 billion. I want to use
at least half of that $27 billion to drive down property tax rates. Steve,
it can be done in a long term basis. We use that to lower the school property
tax component. Thank you, sir. He raised my name in that. Yeah, okay. I'll
give you 15 seconds. Thank you. Like many local leaders, we have to deal
with unfunded mandates sent down by Greg Abbott. That's our mental health
care system, where the county jails are the largest provider of mental health
care services. Our schools. As governor, I'll make sure that we expand Medicaid
so we reduce that demand and up the share of state spending. That's how we
get things done. I want to move on because this is an important topic.
We've got a lot of things we want to try to get to in this short hour. Mr
O'Rourke, you say you would take the burden off property tax owners by
creating other revenue streams, most notably legalizing marijuana, expanding
Medicaid and closing loopholes enjoyed by commercial property owners. But how
will you get those proposals through a Republican controlled legislature? 30
seconds. Republicans and Democrats alike across the state want to make
sure that we reduce property taxes. I think we all have a vested interest in
that outcome. They also agree on common sense, bipartisan solutions.
Expanding Medicaid. All that means is getting $10 billion back of our federal
income taxes to this state to reduce our property taxes. Why Greg Abbott has
not done it when every border state has is beyond me. Making sure that we
legalize marijuana so we never no longer spend half a billion dollars locking
people up and forego another half billion dollars in revenue again makes
no sense. Let's legalize marijuana. We need to move on because I want to make
sure that we give the governor a chance to answer my next question. Your
campaign team has said since taking office, property taxes have been
reduced by $18 billion. Yet those reductions have not kept pace with
rising property values that increase the taxes homeowners pay. How do you
solve this problem without introducing additional revenue streams? You have 30
seconds here. So one way that we have reduced property taxes is through those
homestead exemptions. Another way that we've done it is by buying down the
property tax rate at the school district level. And what I propose to do with
this $13.5 billion, if not more, is to drive down those property tax rates
even further. My goal is to eliminate the school property tax that's imposed
in the state of Texas so that people can genuinely own their own home without
being taxed out of it. Mr Rourke, I want to give you 15 seconds. He's a he's had
eight years to get this done. If it's such a good idea, why are we talking
about another four years to accomplish that? I will reduce your property taxes
as governor. This guy has has raised them by $20 billion, 40% increase since
he first took office. You want more property taxes, vote for Greg Abbott.
Governor, I'm going to give you 15 seconds. So anybody who knows anything
knows the state does not raise property taxes. The only reason why it would have
gone up is because of valuations that would mean that I get credit for the
biggest enrichment people have had. I will not take that. One thing we have to
do to add on top of it, we need to reduce the appraisals. We've got to completely
change the appraisal system. Thank you, sir. We're running out of time. Let's
actually throw it over to Brit now. Thank you. And thank you, gentlemen. You
made it. That's all the time we have for questions tonight. And now it's time for
your closing statement. So Mr O'Rourke, we'll start with you tonight. 30 seconds
for your closing statement. Your time starts now. Thank you. Look, I don't
think that Greg Abbott wakes up wanting to see Children shot in their schools or
for the grid to fail. But it's clear that he's incapable or unwilling to
make the changes necessary to prioritize the lives of our fellow Texans. That's
why it's on all of us to make sure that we have change at the ballot box this
November 8th. I'll keep your lights on. I'll make sure that I keep your kids
safe. We'll reduce property taxes and will prioritize the lives of each and
every single Texan in this state. Mr O'Rourke, thank you so much. Now,
Governor Abbott, your 30 seconds starts now. Texas ranks number one for the most
new jobs added since you reelected me. We're number one for blue ribbon
schools, number one for Tier one research universities and number one
in so many categories. I'm running for reelection to keep Texas number one to
cut your property taxes to secure the border, to keep dangerous criminals
behind bars and to keep deadly fentanyl off our streets together. We will keep
Texas number one. Governor Abbott, thank you so much. And that concludes our
debate tonight. I want to thank the candidates and our moderators for being
here with us tonight and for participating. I also want to thank the
University of Texas Rio Grande Valley for hosting us here in South Texas
tonight. Up next, you will be able to watch the Texas governor's race post
debate speech. Now you can watch this online or right here. If you don't see
it, check your local listing. Thank you so much for joining us tonight and to
all of Texas. Good night and take care.

