Death By 1000 Cuts': Ted Cruz Rips Environmental Lawsuits Meant To 'Destroy' U.S. Energy Industry

Ted Cruz
1 follower
Thank you.
What we're seeing is not the rule of law.
It's lawfare.
These lawsuits aren't meant to succeed on the merits.
They're designed to exhaust, to intimidate, and to destroy America's energy sector.
Death by a thousand cuts.
We've even seen private parties get in on the act.
One of the most infamous examples was Juliana versus United States, where 21 people sued
the federal government claiming that allowing climate change to persist violated their due
process rights.
A federal district judge in Oregon actually agreed, comparing the right to a stable climate
to the right to same-sex marriage.
She was prepared to enjoin the entire federal government effectively putting the energy
industry into judicial receivership at the behest of, quote, children.
Fortunately, the Ninth Circuit, by far the most liberal court of appeals in the country,
shut it down, and eventually a unanimous Supreme Court did as well.
Funded by deep-pocketed climate activists and left-wing dark money, the anti-American
energy lobby and its allies in the plaintiffs' bar have initiated dozens of civil lawsuits
against American energy producers.
These suits, which assert state law claims under dubious nuisance, tort, or consumer
protection theories, are properly preempted by federal law.
Nevertheless, they have proliferated across the country, and they are exposing energy
producers to potentially trillions of dollars in damages.
There are now more than 30 active lawsuits across the country accusing energy producers
of misleading the public about carbon emissions and climate change.
If successful, these suits could destroy millions of jobs and raise the energy cost of every
consumer in America.
Let me start with the legal foundations.
General Kobach, have any of these climate lawsuits, brought under public nuisance or
similar theories, been upheld on the merits by a federal appellate court?
No, Senator, and none of them have been upheld on the merits by a state appellate court either.
The case that is closest to a higher-level decision right now is the Baltimore case,
Baltimore v. BP.
It's several consolidated cases.
That's basically a case where Baltimore is suing the fossil fuel industry defendants
for climate change generally.
A lot of these others are more specific, like shale oil production or plastics, but they're
just global warming.
And the district court in Baltimore ruled against the plaintiffs on all eight grounds.
That's a pretty big deal.
And they now are appealing to the state Supreme Court.
That one will probably be decided later this year, early next year, but that's the biggest
or nearest chance the plaintiffs have to achieving a victory, but they have gotten no victories
so far.
And isn't it true that many of these suits are brought by cities and counties that lack
the legal standing to assert injuries on behalf of the entire public?
Yes, Mr. Chairman, and that's what I was alluding to when I mentioned Parents Patriarch.
The state has the responsibility, Parents Patriarch is Latin, of course, for parent
or father of the country, and the state attorney general, which represents the state at large,
has that sovereignty.
Our Constitution contemplates that states have sovereignty, and they conceded some of
that sovereignty to the federal government.
But localities are creations of state government.
Localities do not possess the sovereignty that a state does.
And so while some people may be upset that we have 50 states and the states take different
positions in some of these legal cases, the states have at least the right to represent
their residents.
Cities do not.
Counties do not.
And so it massively multiplies the potential plaintiffs out there, and it becomes nonsensical
in a legal sense for a city in one end of a state and a city on the opposite end of
the state to both purport to represent the residents of the same state.
And in the cases I mentioned, they're purporting to, in a class action format, represent all
citizens and residents of every county in America.
So they've taken public nuisance theory to a bizarre extreme, and they've also usurped
the authority of state attorneys general.
Well, that may help explain why they are losing so many of these cases.
Mr. Walter, Share Edling has filed dozens of climate lawsuits.
Are they being paid by the government entities they represent or by anonymous left-wing donor
networks like the New Venture Fund?
I believe the vast majority of the funding comes from the outside funders, yes.
Isn't it also true that one of the biggest sources of funding for U.S.-based environmental
litigation groups is Energy Foundation China, an organization run by a former senior Chinese
Communist Party official who helped craft the CCP's five-year energy plans?
Energy Foundation China channels tens of millions of dollars to numerous environmental groups,
yes.
Now, Mr. Walter, my Democrat colleagues have said that's a crazy conspiracy theory.
What is the basis for saying that Energy Foundation China is funneling so many millions of dollars
into these suits?
Well, they're on IRS filings because they're a 501c3 registered in San Francisco.
If this were really about reducing admissions, wouldn't we expect Energy Foundation China
to give a damn about the worst polluter on the face of the planet, that being Communist
China?
That would be logical, yes, Senator.
And yet, their lawsuits are designed to destroy the American energy industry, which happens
to perfectly coincide with the political objective of Senate Democrats to destroy the
American energy industry.
Would the result of that help or hurt America, and would it help or hurt China?
Well, obviously it would help China vis-a-vis the United States, and it would certainly
be highly problematic for everyone in the United States.
Thank you.
Senator Whitehouse.
