WATCH: Sen. Hawley questions FBI Director Patel in hearing on his leadership
Nov 12, 2025 #Joshhawley #Politicians
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman.
It's very good to see you.
Thank you for being here.
Today is FBI in a very critical time for that nation.
It's a really critical time for our country, and I want to start by talking to you about
the tide of violence that we have seen, ideological violence against people of faith, particularly
Christians.
If you just think here, take a rough catalog, just in the last couple of years we've seen
the Covenant School, Christian School in Nashville, we've seen school shootings, the
Annunciation School, we've seen church shootings multiply, we've seen acts of crime and violence,
vandalism, arson against churches and parishes all across the country, and then of course
last week, Charlie Kirk, who said, I want to be remembered for my courage, my faith,
my God, my college campus.
Let me just start with the assassination of Charlie Kirk.
With the FBI, and I appreciate the tremendous work the FBI has done in this investigation,
is the FBI investigating the Kirk assassination as part of this broader pattern of anti-religious
and anti-Christian violence?
We are investigating Charlie's assassination fully and completely, and running out every
lead related to any allegation of broader violence, and we're producing results on that
that will disclose when appropriate.
Good.
I'm glad to hear that.
Let me just ask a few questions about that, if I could.
Reports have suggested that the FBI is investigating a broader network of groups that may have
had some knowledge of the shooter's plans.
Can you give us any details on that?
How is the FBI working to find other potential accomplices, folks who may have known about
the shooter's plans, folks who may have encouraged him, any of that?
In terms of what we do for an interrogation, we go and reach out to the family community
immediately.
We've conducted those investigations and interrogations with local law enforcement,
and we're continuing to do that because those closest to the suspect are going to know the
most about the suspect, his beliefs, his ideology.
On top of that, unfortunately it has been leaked that there was a Discord chat, for
that the suspect participated in what we're doing, what we've already done, it's a legal
process, not just on Discord, so that the information we gather is sustained and held
in an evidentiary postulate that we can use in prosecutorial proceedings like Discord
does, and we're also going to be investigating anyone and everyone involved in that.
Okay, very good.
I see the public reports that the Discord thread has as many as 20 additional users.
It sounds like you're trying to run down all of that to see if that's accurate, who
else may have been on that thread, what they may have known.
It's a lot more than that.
We're running a lot more.
It's a lot more than 20?
Yes.
And you're running all of that?
Every single one.
Yes, absolutely.
Let me just turn to the broader question here of anti-religious, anti-Christian violence.
Let me just give you a few stats that I'm sure that you're all too familiar with.
It certainly is.
A major report this past year found that there have been over 400 instances of hostility
against churches in the United States in the year 2024.
Those included arsons, bomb threats, shootings, and firearm incidents.
Another organizational report found that there were 500 attacks on Catholic parishes alone.
For that number, 4 out of 15, that's all Christian churches in 2024.
Another organization found 500 separate attacks on just Catholic parishes since May of 2021.
Of course, we have the Covenant school shooting, the Annunciation school shooting in Minnesota
where two children were shot dead as they were praying in a pew.
Here's my question.
What is the FBI doing to take on this rising tide of violence that seems to be motivated
by anti-religious behavior?
Specifically, sir, we have 60 anti-Catholic hate crime incidents that have been reported
to us and are being investigated.
Publicly, I can tell you we have five hate crime investigations against anti-Catholic
bias ongoing currently in the city of Kansas City, Louisville, Houston, Nashville, and
Richmond.
That's what I can say publicly, but any ideologically based attack against any faith as a man of
faith will not be tolerated.
And the full research of the FBI is committed to all of them.
Are you investigating any domestic cells that instigate or encourage or fund or in any way
support attacks on churches or other houses?
Senator, you raise an incredibly important point that most people don't look at.
I've always said we follow the money.
And whether it's terrorism or attacks based on ideology or attacks on institutions of
faith or people of faith, someone's paying for it.
And we are reverse tracing those steps.
We are not stopping at the perpetrators themselves.
We are reverse engineering to hold those accountable in our investigations.
If we funded that and knowingly funded that, we would bring the appropriate steps to get
to the heart of the situation.
Good.
I'm glad to hear that.
We look forward to hearing from you.
I look forward to my brother.
Let me just ask you this in the same vein, Director.
Since the Dobbs decision, the FBI has advertised $25,000 rewards for information on attacks
on churches.
Will the FBI similarly offer rewards for information on attacks on houses?
Yes, when it is appropriate.
Any reward, whether it's an attack on a house of faith or a homicide or whatever, is determined
by a group within the FBI.
But we will work with them to make sure that rewards of monetary value are put out for
all ideologically based attacks.
Good.
You just rattled off some statistics, which I was glad to hear about the number of investigations
you have opened with the Institute for Action Against Prisoners Against House of Worship.
Let me just ask you if you consider designating a senior official as a liaison to House of
Worship, to a Christian or other religious organization, to publish metrics on investigations
and arrests related to church attacks, church threats, vandalism, arson, etc.
Will you set up a system for liaising and then reporting so that everybody can see,
this committee and the public can see, just how many attacks we're talking about, just
what the level of threat and violence is and what the FBI is doing.
Senator, you're speaking my language.
A private-public sector partnership on this specific issue, just like the other ones we've
talked about, is equally transformative to finding those involved in criminal activities.
And with your assistance, I would ask you if you're able to identify someone who is
an expert in that area.
We will work with them.
We will take their information.
Because as great as the FBI is, we're only as good as the information we can get, and
we don't have the reach that the private sector does.
Very good.
Happy to help on that.
Let me ask you about something specific to the FBI, because sadly, as you know, the FBI
when it comes to anti-religious animus has been part of the problem before you got to
this agency.
And I know that you remember the infamous memo generated by the FBI that attempted to
recruit informants in houses of worship, in particular in Catholic parishes.
Your predecessor testified when this information, I just want to reiterate, this memo became
public because of whistleblowing.
It was not turned over to this committee.
It was not disclosed to this committee.
In fact, we were told it didn't exist, and then a whistleblower published it, showing
that indeed the FBI had recruited informants, attempted to, into Catholic parishes.
Your predecessor then testified, sitting right where you are today, he testified that this,
I'm going to quote, was a single product by a single field office, end quote.
That was a lie.
Because we then had additional whistleblowers come forward and say, no, actually, multiple
field offices contributed to the drafting of the report.
And indeed, there was a second anti-Catholic memo that the FBI generated, and indeed, those
memos were distributed to over 1,000 FBI agents across the country.
You know all of this.
You and I talked about it when you were here for your confirmation hearing back in January.
I just want to follow up and see, have you been able to determine how this memo got written
and distributed?
How is it that the Federal Bureau of Investigation came to be recruiting informants in Christian
churches in this country?
Senator, we did dig in.
And we are doing our investigation simultaneously with Congress.
And just to put it in perspective, we've provided 700 documents on the ritual of Capitulation
specifically for this committee, whereas my predecessor provided 98.
And not only that, but we looked into how the source recruitment structure at the FBI
was conducted during this time.
And we made adjustments and permanent fixes to ensure that sources are not put into houses
of worship unless there is an actual ongoing criminal or international terrorism threat.
We will not use sources at this FBI to investigate or cull information just for the sake of culling
information.
Has anybody been part of it?
There have been terminations related to this and resignation.
Good.
But there needs to be.
Because if this is going to be standard at the FBI, nobody is going to trust it.
You want to talk about violating the First Amendment?
This has got First Amendment violations written all over it.
It's one of the most revolting chapters in the FBI's history.
And considering what we're seeing more broadly in terms of the acts of violence against people
of faith, this has absolutely got to be in the FBI.
So I count on you to do that, Director.
Let me just, in the minute or so that I have remaining, let me just shift gears and ask
you about something else you said earlier.
You said that protecting our youth is maybe the FBI's top priority.
Great.
Here, let me ask you about the role of AI chatbots in that, which we've talked about
a little bit already today.
Are you investigating any cases of AI-generated child sex abuse material?
You issued a PSA earlier this year warning that synthetic child sex abuse material is
You warned that that was illegal under federal law.
Is the FBI investigating any instances of the synthetic CSAM material generated by AI?
We are investigating dozens of those matters because, let me just say this.
As far as the FBI is concerned, generative AI that produces CSAM child sex abuse material
under our investigative authorities is treated as equally as if it were actual child sex abuse material.
There's no difference between the FBI.
Let me just ask you one other thing in this vein.
I'm sure you've seen the reporting that MEDA's AI rules, their own internal guidelines,
allow their chatbots to have sensual, there were sensual conversations with children.
We've had instances, multiple instances of children, minors, taking their own lives
at the behest of chatbots that instructed them with specificity on how to do it.
What's the FBI's role here in investigating what is going on with these chatbots,
with these AI companies encouraging, I mean listen, if an actual person did that,
we would say that's grooming, we would say that's child abuse.
These companies are doing it, their own guidelines allow it.
What can we do about it?
You're referring to NVE, Nearest and Final Extremism and 764.
It has been made a priority for the FBI because they are targeting children
and these chatbots and these generative AI are getting coupled with actual humans
who are using them and releasing them because they can do the work faster
and quicker than humans can to get into spaces like social media where humans have a difficulty engaging.
And what we're doing is treating any extension of generative AI as the criminal themselves.
So we have, I think, I've got to get the number back to you,
but over a thousand investigations related to NVE.
We've had numerous takedowns and arrests of 764 individuals and we are educating.
This may be the most important part.
I'm directly engaging with the social media and media companies,
the internet service providers to find a way to shut down.
There's nothing I can do at the FBI to force them to shut it down.
We're leaving Congress to find a way to work with our partners to get that shut down.

