How Historians Know Jesus Existed

Christianity
6 followers
To study history is to confront the reality of one's own mortality,
and to come face to face with the ultimate impermanence of all human endeavors.
The reality is that few of us ever leave a lasting trace, and for every artist,
leader, or thinker that we celebrate today, there were millions of people who lived and died in
Soon, even their names will be forgotten as time marches inexorably on.
History is the autobiography of humanity, but it has not been written by all humanity.
Until very recently, even the best records were frustratingly fragmentary
and biased toward the elite perspectives of their overwhelmingly upper-class authors.
Fortunately, historians have developed a complex approach to assess the accuracy
of ancient sources. This methodology involves dissecting and analyzing the context of the
source as scholars consider the author's purpose, biases, and proximity to the events described.
They then compare the accounts from other sources, both written and archaeological,
to further gauge validity. By examining inconsistencies and identifying potential
agendas, historians can build a more nuanced understanding of the past, acknowledging the
limitations inherent in ancient sources while piecing together the most accurate picture
possible. It is the rigorous application of this approach that has allowed us to speak
with a high degree of confidence about many events from the ancient world,
separating fact from myth, even when ancient authors fail to make the distinction.
But in addition to helping us see things more clearly, historical methodology is also useful
for injecting doubt or skepticism into official narratives where appropriate. When outlandish
tales appear which are uncorroborated by other sources, we know better than to take our sources
at face value and to investigate how their own biases or purposes may have led to the inclusion
of untrustworthy material. This painstakingly nuanced approach forms the backbone of scholarly
consensus for all knowledge of the ancient past, and it is through this approach that
scholars are able to state with certainty that Jesus of Nazareth, the ancient world's
most influential figure, existed as a real historical individual. Though still a popular
theory on some corners of the internet, no scholars with relevant credentials today advance
the claim that Jesus was a purely mythological figure. The fact that some semblance of debate
even exists on this matter is indicative of a mass failure by the general public to understand
historical methodology, and is much more an example of wishful thinking on the part of those
who take issue with the modern practice of Christianity than it is a serious historical
inquiry. By blinding themselves to historical realities, and even to the discipline of
history itself, those who argue for a mythic Jesus ironically resemble not discerning scholars,
but instead the most ardent fundamentalists. Like fundamentalists, deniers of a historical Jesus
seem to believe that the traditional narrative is either 100% true or 100% false, and they cannot
stomach shades of gray. And they can't, or won't, accept that reality may not demarcate itself
so conveniently as to adhere to their rigid ideological preconceptions. Because of the
abundant literary evidence that Jesus was a real historical person, the first arguments made by
those holding to a mythic view is that all sources are unreliable and of no historical value whatsoever.
Frequently, this manifests in claims about the reliability of the four canonical gospels,
with detractors highlighting that they are theological narratives written decades after
Jesus's death. Their contention is that the gospels are not meant to be read as historical
biographies, but rather as testimonies of faith that emphasize the miraculous and supernatural
aspects of Jesus's life and ministry. The argument goes that because the gospels contain inconsistencies
and embellishments that they cannot be trusted. This same objection is then extended to all other
New Testament sources, such as the epistles of Paul, with the line of logic being that because
they were written with religious and moral convictions in mind that they cannot be utilized
by historians, even to testify to basic facts such as the existence of a historical Jesus. Yet the
standard proposed here, that the presence of supernatural elements or a clear agenda on the
part of the author discounts the entirety of a source, is clearly flawed and cannot be universally
applied. For example, Plutarch's lives is regarded as a flawed but largely reliable source, even
though in places it contradicts other ancient sources, often integrates miraculous elements,
and the work was written with the express purpose of providing moral instruction. Plutarch's editorial
gloss is so heavy that he rearranges events and presents direct quotes in their entirety,
which seem highly unlikely to be authentic. Yet this is not, and has never been, a reason to
discount his work, as the historical method which has helped highlight these flaws in turn illuminates
what is of value. This is why the Gospels, and the entirety of the New Testament beyond them,
are valuable sources to scholars, even if they do not accept that they accurately portray
the life of Jesus, or the evolution of the community of followers that became the early
church. One must not agree with sources to understand their importance. Consider the
historical Socrates for a moment. He wrote no works of his own, and is chiefly conveyed to us
in the writings of his student Plato, which scholars have long recognized as more reflective
of Plato's own views. The fact that Plato inserts many sayings into the mouth of his mentor that he
likely never uttered does not imply that these sources cannot be used to infer the existence of
a historical Socrates, nor does it prohibit us from speculating as to what his original teaching
may have been. Similarly, the declining popularity of Platonism as a philosophical school does not
mean that the sources are any less valuable. One does not need to adhere to the theory of forms
to see the value of Plato for historians studying ancient Athens. When it comes to the study of the
historical Jesus, employing approaches such as multiple attestation, coherence, dissimilarity,
embarrassment, and contextual plausibility are employed to evaluate the probability of an event
or a saying being historical. By using these criteria, historians can sift through the layers
of tradition to reconstruct the most plausible portrait of Jesus that is compatible with the
available evidence. Because so much is left to the interpretation of each scholar, it should come
as no surprise that there are a wide range of views on the historical Jesus, ranging from a
failed apocalyptic prophet in the Jewish tradition to the position espoused by conservative Christians
today that he was the divine son of God. There is robust debate and will be for the foreseeable
future, but even amidst this there is no doubt at all that he was a real person, even if there is
substantial disagreement about what he did and said. But because references to Jesus are not
limited to the Gospels, efforts to deny his historicity must also extend to encompass all
the non-Christian and non-canonical sources that acknowledge Jesus. References to him appear,
for example, in the Talmud, as well as the writings of the Jewish historian Josephus
and the Roman historians Pliny, Suetonius, and Tacitus. These references are brief and often
hostile, indicating that they were not fabricated out of whole cloth by later Christians. Though
there is a consensus that a certain passage in Josephus concerning Jesus was embellished by later
Christian scribes, it is this same textual critical approach that validates the others. One cannot
consistently claim that all are fabrications along the lines of the embellished Josephus passage
without invalidating the very approach that allows us to infer alterations in the first place. To do
so is to apply an inconsistent standard to historical evidence, a tactic frequently employed
by those arguing a mythic position, and one that betrays the paucity of their argument. Often,
after whittling down the number of acceptable sources to near zero, mythicists will point to
the absence of archaeological evidence for Jesus to support their claim that he was a fictional
creation of later writers. But if this were the standard for establishing the existence of
historical figures, which would remain? Among countless other issues, such an approach would
yield little more than a history of the hyper-elite. Anyone who has wondered the Louvre or
the Prado knows that having the desire and the means to leave definitive proof of one's existence
is largely the domain of forgotten nobles. Insistence on an archaeological record highlights
the absurd standard to which Jesus is uniquely held by those advocating a mythic position.
So, while we don't have as much evidence of the existence of Jesus as we do for Augustus,
we must recognize that the radically different social positions of the two men would naturally
lead to different types of historical records for each emerging within their lifetime and the
subsequent decades. The evidence that we have for Jesus is precisely what we would expect for a
a region that was marginalized and despised by the Jewish elite and the Roman authorities alike.
Though he built a strong following, Jesus never held any political or religious office, nor did
he write anything or leave any material traces of his existence. His marginal status is underscored
by his execution via crucifixion, one of the two facts about his life that is universally accepted
by all scholars in the field. For his entire life, Jesus was of no real significance to the powerful,
so we should not be surprised that he cannot match the attestation of the emperors or those
that existed at the upper echelons of Roman society. Evidence for Jesus, however, outpaces
that available for similar historical figures in his region and era. We have more sources
and more details about Jesus than we have about Pontius Pilate, for example,
and yet no one holds the position that Pilate was a metaphorical representation of the Roman state.
Furthermore, if we examine literary evidence alone, then we have more biographical works on
Jesus than even giant figures of world history such as Caligula. For the third Roman emperor,
we are left with only two detailed accounts of his reign, the historians Suetonius and Cassius
Dio, both of whom were heavily biased and wrote politically motivated works attacking the legacy
of the emperor. Were we to apply the mythicist standard consistently, they should be the first
to admit that nothing can be said with confidence about the reign of Caligula. Furthermore,
Suetonius' history was written 80 years after the death of Caligula, while Cassius Dio's account
came over 150 years after Caligula's assassination. This helps contextualize
the appearance of the canonical gospels 30 to 60 years after Jesus' life, as relatively recent
when we consider the timing of such works in the ancient world. For those who still believe this
is too late to have any historical value, we must remember that the earliest surviving account of
Alexander the Great's life comes roughly 275 years after his death. Again, this is not to suggest
that one must consider the gospels or any ancient sources to be 100% accurate, but that's not
necessary to concede that Jesus did actually exist. The ancient sources could very well be
unintentionally or even intentionally misrepresenting the words of Jesus, or perhaps
accurately reporting things he did say which may not have been true, but the sheer wealth of
documentary evidence, both Christian and non-Christian, testifies to the existence of a historical person
at the core of the Jesus story, one who aroused curiosity, admiration, hostility, and devotion
like few men in history. To acknowledge the existence of Jesus is not to become a professing
Christian, it is to indicate respect for the historical method and reality itself. At times,
this video may have appeared overly uncharitable, dismissive, or harsh towards the mythicist's
position. If that is so, then I apologize, because it was my aim to be noticeably uncharitable,
dismissive, and harsh throughout the entire video. In doing so, I would be treating the mythicist's
position with the respect that it deserved, and the respect that I have for those who advocate it.
None at all. The denial of a historical Jesus is so bothersome to me because it relies upon
the implementation of an arbitrary and overly skeptical standard that is never universally
applied to other historical figures. Inconsistency is a feature of the mythicist's position,
because they know full well that if we were to demand the same level of unimpeachable evidence
for every person and event in history, we would effectively be forced to wipe out much of our
knowledge of the past, or ability to speak with any certainty about the Roman world. Such a
standard would not only eliminate Jesus, but also many emperors, generals, and thinkers, not to
mention the rare instances when a typical working-class Roman manages to break into history
through a quick aside or anecdote. To dismiss the abundant evidence for Jesus as insufficient
or entirely fabricated is to ignore the nature and limitations of ancient historiography,
and to impose an unrealistic and unfair criterion of historical verification. As such, it is a war
on the discipline of history itself, an assault on our ability to understand the past, to learn from
it, and to change how we live in light of those who came before us. It's disappointing to me that
so many would adopt a rubric which throws out so much in order to avoid admitting that there may be
the faintest kernel of truth at the heart of the world's largest religion. I'm disappointed,
but I'm not surprised, because for as long as history has been studied, there have been those
who seek to abuse it or twist it for their own aims. Fortunately, the truth does win out,
but only if educated, responsible, and honest people rise to its defense.
