Join us as we delve into the intriguing debate on Blue Origin's potential to successfully land and reuse a booster. We compare their timeline to SpaceX's achievements and explore the challenges of non-destructive testing and forensic analysis. Will Blue Origin's booster ever fly again? Tune in to find out!
I do have a serious question for all of
you though. Whenever Blue Origin does
successfully land a booster, I believe
it'll happen eventually. Um, how long do
you think it'll actually take for them
to turn around and reuse that booster,
relaunch that booster for the first
time? Cuz correct me if I'm wrong, but
didn't it take SpaceX about a year to
refly their first booster? So, the
question for everybody here and for the
chat room, too. How long do you think
it's going to actually take for them to
turn around their first uh reflight like
that?
>> They won't. I I don't think they will.
>> 70 72 weeks.
>> 72. My my theory is uh the first one
that they get back they're going to do
forensic analysis on to understand what
re-entry did to it. That forensic
analysis is going to make it a
non-flyable object.
>> Uh
>> that's my theory. I don't actually know,
but I think they're going to have to
they're going to dig into the tank.
They're going to see how much of the
walls got, you know, battered and and
like did we get micro cracking and
things like that. And by the time they
do that type of forensics, you you can't
repair the vehicle. It's no longer It's
no longer a worthy pressure vessel. So,
I don't think the first one in my the my
theory is the first one does not re
refly. Having said that,
>> wouldn't you be able to do that?
>> They can do whatever they want.
>> Wouldn't you be able to do that with NDE
like X-rays and stuff like that like
inspections
>> to a point? It's really hard to NDE like
some of the COPV if if they've got I
assuming they have COPVs. It's really
hard to do NDE and get really a lot of
the micro micro kind you got to kind of
cut them in half. COPVS are are internal
to the vehicle. I don't see how re-entry
would affect them in any way.
>> Yeah. But but you'll do the same.
Generally speaking, I expect them I
expect them to do the same thing to most
parts of the vehicle. I expect they're
going to be drilling holes in a good
chunk of the vehicle. I don't think
they're going to NDE test it. I think
they're going to de test it.
Skip the N.
>> Yeah. Only so can be done.
>> Hang on. Hang on. You dy, you might be
right. Right. like like not
>> for you've got X-ray and ultrasound.
There's a lot of ways that there's there
there's a lot of things that you can do
and yes there are limits to it to to
EA's point but
>> like
>> there's a lot of thing a lot of systems
that would not be affected by
return to earth. So all you need to do
is make sure that the the the structure
is okay
>> and anything else that would that is in
that chain that would be
>> uh you know exposed to damage from heat
and what and whatnot you can easily
replace engines and connectors and
wiring harnesses and all that.
>> So the the note is so first for those
who don't know NDE is basically
non-destructive testing, right? It's
it's your ability to go in and um make
sure that whatever part you've got um
you you test it and make sure that it's
it's ready for flight uh without
destroying it, without having to cut it
in half. But notice I said part and not
overall entire vehicle. Generally
speaking, you NDE test individual
components before you integrate them
into the final vehicle. Once you've got
your COPVS and whatnot and then you you
you know stir weld everything together,
it is it's not like you can just go in
and take these things out generally
speaking. Again, I don't know new Glenn,
right? So maybe new Glenn you can
totally go in and do this and it and
it's not a problem. But I would be I
miss I misspoke. Thank you.
>> They have to do
we call it NDE. Uh it's
>> not non-destructive engineering
non-destructive.
Yeah. Yeah, we call it NDE. I've seen,
>> but like you you can take a you can take
a a playbook page out of the airline
industry where you you you do NDT on
airframes and stuff. You don't you're
not destroying an airplane when you do
go for a major inspection. You may
disassemble some, but there's you're not
like destroying the airflame airframe to
find cracks.
>> And they do find cracks and they they do
repair them.
>> Maybe I think some of their first
vehicles they actually do destructive
testing, right? Like you look at you
look at um like Boeing or an Airbus and
they do the wing testing. They they they
go in, they're like, "All right, let's
let's break the wings."
>> Not not to a flyable aircraft there.
That that mule is made specifically for
that.
>> That's fair. Again, I don't know. I do
not know what New Glenn is going what
they're going to do with New Glenn. My
note is I don't think they're going to
ever fly it again. I think they're going
to do destructive testing on it. I think
it's just going to be faster, cheaper,
and easier for them to do that. Let's
find out, right? like uh like you might
be correct.