How ransomware bans, regulation, and emerging threats are reshaping the market

Business Insurance
4 followers
3 Video Views·Oct 29, 2025
In this Cyber Insurance Power Panel, Insurance Business TV examines the forces reshaping the global cyber market—from the potential ban on ransomware payments and evolving regulations to shifting capacity and emerging threats. Featuring insights from Gülsah Dagdelen, Cyber Manager for EMEA and Latin America at Tokio Marine, Vanessa Leemans, Head of Cyber UK at AXA XL, and Sam Cheshire, Head of Cyber UK and Ireland at Gallagher, the discussion highlights how these developments are impacting coverage, underwriting, and the opportunities ahead for brokers and clients.
Today we're zeroing in on the forces reshaping the cyber insurance market
from a potential ban on ransomware payments and evolving regulations to shifting capacity
and emerging threats. We will explore how these changes are impacting coverage,
underwriting and the opportunities ahead for brokers and clients. Joining me is Gusha Dargalan,
Cyber Manager for EMEA and Latin America at Tokyo Marine. Vanessa Lehmans, Head of Cyber,
UK and Lloyd's AXA XL and Sam Cheshire, Head of Cyber, UK and Ireland, Gallagher. Welcome everybody.
How do you anticipate a potential ban on ransomware payments if implemented in the UK or
elsewhere? Would this affect the demand for cyber insurance and the type of coverage clients seek?
Thank you Chris for asking this question. So this is actually a very interesting
and challenging debate which has been ongoing for many, many years since cyber
arrived in continental Europe or EMEA. So we still see a huge amount of
cyber claims arising from ransomware and to be honest we have never, and regardless of
soft or hard market, we were never concerned about the ransom payment itself.
We have always, as Tokyo Marine HCC, focused on the technical assessment of each risk
and how companies can actually become more resilient and limit their exposure. That goes
in hand with, as I said, the risk assessment, focusing on the resilience of the company, on
redundancies, on recovery of systems etc. Our experience is that the ransom itself is not a big
deal for companies or it should not be a big deal. The costs related to recovery of systems is the
main problem for companies mostly and what we also see is a link between the amount of ransom demand
and how resilient the companies are. So if the company has proper backups and is able to recover
the systems in short time, the ransom demand is usually not as high as for a company that is
having encrypted backups and not being able to recover the systems so fast. So instead of
focusing so much on the question if ransom itself could be banned or not, we prefer to
focus really on the resilience and the technical maturity of the company. In claim scenarios,
there is always the question, can the company finally afford not to pay a ransom? So this is
very important to mention because there are publications that say, especially in the SME
sector, a company on average could survive a maximum of six months and then it could end up
being bankrupt. And then the question is, at the end, what is the bigger loss for the economy
and for those clients? We as insurers of course never recommend to pay a ransom,
but these are all considerations that should be taken into consideration when
discussing if ransom payments should be banned or not. Even though they are not banned, it's
always not clear if they are actually insurable. So from a cyber insurer perspective, I would say
it is less relevant for us. And I would also like to stress that ransomware payment is indeed not
the biggest claim expense to insurers, but a ban would encourage organizations to do what they
should be doing already, getting the right coverage, planning for preparation, prevention, and
recovery. And actually, AXA Excel recently published a global cyber claims report, which highlights
that non-ransomware claims are significant. And our report actually finds that the top three
triggered coverages are, first of all, data breach response and price management. Secondly,
business interruption. And thirdly, privacy and cybersecurity coverage. And only in fourth place,
the ransomware extortion coverage would be the fourth largest portion of a claim coverage figure.
So I think that's important to highlight. We very much look at how to prepare, prevent,
and recover. That's obviously still the best option. So a ban may encourage organizations
to do what they should be doing already. So it's very much at preparation and protecting
effectively rather than relying on the last resort of ransom payments. And I think it's also
important to highlight that ultimately the bigger goal is very much over the longer term.
I would hope that a ban would deter and discourage ransomware attacks in the UK.
I think it's safe to say we all agree it's probably unlikely to impact the demand for
cyber insurance because the claims are highly unlikely to just go away overnight. We've
already seen in the UK that it's not illegal, but there is a ban on public sector entities from
paying ransom demands. However, we haven't seen it as an absolute stop that the threat actor groups
are still making those ransom demands against public sector companies. They're just choosing
not to pay them now, whereas historically they may or may not have the option. But the thing for
me that's really interesting is how is this actually going to be policed? If there is a ban
on making ransom payments, how do we know whether that's actually happening and whether people are
doing it or not? Are we going to be fining companies, companies that have gone through
a very large cyber incident, felt that their only route to save themselves is to pay a significant
sum to a criminal activity group, and then what? Are we going to fine them?
Kick a man's wealthies down. It seems like a very odd thing to do. Whilst this is potentially
a thing that we're going to be having to look at in the future, I'm very eager to understand
how the policing of that looks, because if it is fines, a lot of our clients may not be able to
pay the fine. How else do we stop it? Thank you. A very interesting point.
But what steps should insurers and brokers take to help policyholders better prepare for the
possibility of a random payment ban, both in terms of risk management and incident response?
I think there it's really important to build a dialogue between insurer and clients so that
the new legislation is a transition, not a shock. And there it seems very obvious,
but effective cyber security comes down to the relationship, the collaboration between client,
broker and insurer, and that exchange of information. And not all cyber security
providers are created equal. So I think it's important to really rely on expertise.
And that's where AXA Excel can help prepare and protect clients against that cyber risk.
I think the good brokers are already doing this. The good brokers are already not just talking to
their clients about cyber insurance. Cyber insurance is one cog in a very large wheel.
And most of our clients are actually aware that they need to be doing more from a cyber risk
perspective, coming up with a cyber incident response plan, practicing it, making sure it
works. And if the good brokers are helping their clients with that, they're more prepared for this
ransomware ban than they actually think they are. We've seen across our book recently that we are
seeing fewer of our clients actually pay the ransom, mostly because they've got a plan, they've
been there before, they've tested it, and they know what they need to do in order to prevent that from
happening. We're also seeing a lot of our clients that have previously had to pay a claim due to the
data being exfiltrated from their system, implementing tools like data loss prevention,
which is making sure that that part of the ransom demand is actually entirely irrelevant to them.
So we are definitely seeing our clients be better prepared than they ever have for a ransomware
incident. And if this ban does come into place, our clients, we hope, will be in a good position
to answer it without having to pay the ransom demand. What new or emerging cyber threats are
having the greatest impact on underwriting decisions and claim trends in the market this year?
I think we're seeing an increase in supply chain attacks, impacting multiple organisations and
amplifying the claim sizes. The threats are particularly concerning because they can
compromise multiple entities simultaneously and are really harder to detect and defend again.
That's where cyber criminals are very much exploiting those weaker links to gain access
to larger organisations. We mentioned ransomware attacks already, that continues to be
the top concern due to increased sophistication and impact. The threat actors are employing advanced
techniques, targeting critical infrastructure and demanding higher ransoms, often causing
significant operational disruptions and financial losses. And then AI-generated attacks and the
automation. As the rise in AI technology has enabled threat actors to automate and scale
attacks, including creating highly convincing phishing emails, scams and automated malware.
The increase in the volume and sophistication of the threats makes the defenses more challenging.
And then business email compromise and social engineering also continues to be a primary
cause of claims. And AI as well is making the business email compromise and social engineering
attacks more convincing and targeted. And these attacks exploit human vulnerabilities of leading
to financial losses, breaches and loss of sensitive information and often with minimal
initial technical breach signs. I think those are four key threats we're seeing.
I think the key word there, Vanessa, is sophistication. I think everything that we're
seeing this year, we've normally seen before, but it's just that level of sophistication from the
threat actor groups that's much higher than ever before. It's taking things that have potentially
worked on a few people and really honing those skills, whether it's social engineering or using
those social engineering employees to exploit vulnerabilities. We've really seen that increase
in the level of sophistication this year. Whilst there's not many new attacks, it's just
the threat actors doing what they do, but better. And it has been mentioned already several times,
but what we also see is, of course, the artificial intelligence. I mean, artificial intelligence is
being used by hackers, of course, also by companies to protect against those attacks.
The question is always, companies are regulated, hackers not. And that is always something to
keep in mind, that the question is, who's always one foot ahead?
How are recent or upcoming changes in UK or EU data protection or cyber regulations
influencing policy wording, coverage limits or client risk assessments?
Regulatory developments in the UK and the EU are shaping the way businesses approach cyber risk
management. So we're seeing an enhanced focus on compliance and accountability. So the regulatory
frameworks like UK GDPR or the UNICEF Two Directive and the upcoming UK Cybersecurity
and Resilience Bill are emphasising stricter data protection and cybersecurity requirements,
which prompt businesses to prioritise compliance as a core element of their risk management strategy.
These regulations also mandate a timely breach notification and transparency,
which incentivise companies to develop robust detection, response and reporting protocols.
And with these regulations, we really see a shift towards more of a risk-based and
preventive measures. So we're moving away from purely reactionary measures towards encouraging
proactive risk assessments, routine vulnerability testing and adoption of best practices like
zero trust vulnerability, zero trust architecture, sorry. So that's very much that promotion of a
culture of resilience rather than compliance. And then maybe I also want to highlight that
an increased demand for expertise and external support. As the regulations become more complex,
the businesses are looking for more external expertise, such as cyber risk consulting and
specialised insurance solutions. So that's again where we are there as experts to help businesses
prepare, prevent and protect and ultimately prevail. I think it's a key message.
I would like to distinguish here a bit between the client's perspective and the insurance market's
perspective. I mean, from a client's perspective, a new regulation can always suppose a burden
to companies, especially smaller ones. Cyber frameworks have to be implemented. They have
to comply with all the new regulations. They have to implement a new risk assessment, etc.
But it is also very helpful because it gives the companies a certain guidance, let's say,
on the minimum requirements that protect these companies against future cyber losses.
And from an insurance perspective, I can say that, of course, our risk assessments are based
on different frameworks such as ESO, NIST, etc., different ones. And when you compare these
frameworks with all the new regulations, you see that there is a huge overlap between the
requirements of these regulations and the frameworks. So from our perspective, it's
actually very positive. Also for the client on the long term, when we see that these clients
comply with NIST 2, DORA or AI Act or whatever, because we know that these companies become more
resilient to future cyber attacks, then the question of these ransom payments might become
a bit less relevant for the future because the companies focus more also on recovery
and resilience of their systems. So understanding the fact that for clients it might seem as a
huge burden to comply with these regulations on a midterm, we are convinced that this will
help the cyber product to evolve and continue offering proper solutions.
Have you observed any shifts in market capacity, premium rates or appetite for certain sectors
within cyber insurance over the past 12 months? And what are the main drivers behind these trends?
We've definitely seen a lot of change in the market over the last 12 months.
We went through that period of real hardening through 2021, 2022 and the beginning of 2023
and we've come out of the other side of that now and I feel like we're in a position where the
market's softening. But really what we're seeing is that insurers have got a much better understanding
of what a good cyber risk looks like and are asking the right questions, which then means that
our clients that are investing into the correct lines of security are being better rewarded for
the good work that they've done. What we're really seeing is our clients that are protecting
themselves properly and investing into cyber risk management are actually seeing the largest
benefits and there's really now in the IT world it's difficult to provide an IT director with a
bit of return on investment where normally they'll go to whoever holds the purse strings and ask for
something and they say well why would we invest into this instead of something over here that
could help us produce more goods or be more efficient in work. And now if we can say actually
if you do invest into this your cyber insurance premium is going to reduce that really helps the
conversation. We've really started to see our clients that are doing that properly get that ROI.
I agree and I would like to distinguish here again between the SME market and the large
corporate business because there is still a difference I would say for the large
corporate business I fully agree. For the SME sector I would say the market is still a bit
more stable although we have new players especially the new MGAs entering especially the SME market
we see that the market is still being less affected of the soft market than the hard market
than the large corporate sorry and we see change in underwriting philosophies so especially in
the SME sector we see these scanning tools outside in scans which need to reduce questions
in the proposal forms well we can discuss if this is always risk adequate then in the assessment or
not but that's another that's another topic but especially in the large corporate
segment we see huge premium discounts also new players entering huge capacities huge limits being
available in the market again and the risk assessment is still being conducted quite
properly especially in the large corporate segment still conducting using risk dialogues with
security teams etc etc so yes we see a shift especially in the terms and conditions
wordings becoming broader and that is per se not an issue it becomes an issue when we start
offering extensive coverage without underwriting it so there is a little trend that we offer or we
see new coverages in the cyber policies but when we ask questions around it we don't really get
any answers from the client and that is making things a bit more tricky or more complicated
because as I said before cyber is especially a risk that should be underwritten and that also
of course applies to new extensions that a cyber policy could enhance. Indeed I agree that the
cyber insurance rates continue to be competitive for the large corporates now on SME and
yeah that small and medium-sized business there's definitely a protection gap as a lot of SMEs
don't buy cyber insurance yet they're also still on a journey of getting to cyber security maturity
so that's a real gap in protection so we need to develop more of that SME cyber market.
Thank you a really fascinating panel and a huge thank you to our panelists
and thank you for watching Insurance Business TV.
