Amazon stock on sale? I LIKE IT! Why AMZN is struggling in 2025?

Invest Insight
9 followers
With Amazon's AWS or Amazon Web Services reporting a relatively rare and significant outage today,
I thought it'd be appropriate to reflect on Amazon stock. Why is Amazon down so far year
to date 2025? Along with the question of, is Amazon stock on sale? So we're going to cover
those two questions and more in this video. If you enjoy educational investment content,
I do appreciate you hitting that thumbs up, hit that subscribe button. You're watching
Unrivaled Investing. Now, if you don't have the time to watch this full video, you can go to Flash.
I'm the co-founder of Flash. See the link below where we are leveraging AI, the most powerful
models that are currently available to users to analyze stocks. And this is the take on Amazon,
where it thinks it can go over the next five years. I generally think of AI at this current
point in time as a junior investment analyst. And I look at this framework and I'd say,
yeah, this is actually pretty good in terms of how AI thinks it could perform, let's say,
over the next five years, roughly 100% upside, roughly 20% downside. That's how it's thinking.
I actually have a little bit more of an optimistic take on Amazon, which I'll walk you through this
video, but it's going to require a little bit more analysis than just showing you this slide.
So let's keep going. But if you want to pull up any company anywhere in the world,
check out Flash. It's free to pull up these company reports.
And so the question of why is Amazon stock actually underwater so far,
year to date in 2025, that's going to be the first part of this video. I think part of the concern
is the fact that Amazon is looking to spend so much on their infrastructure, their capital
expenditures on their AWS business. They talk about looking to spend roughly on pace for $100
billion plus, I think just based on the most recent quarter, it's actually closer to $120
billion on an annualized basis. So that does cause investors to go, wait a second, I thought
just a year or two ago, it was about getting back to a significant free cashflow. And they went from
cash burn to a lot of free cashflow. And now that free cashflow is melting away as they're
reinvesting. I personally think management, Andy Jassy, Jeff Bezos, thinking about that alignment,
this management team knows how to invest for the longterm and they're making bets that generally
make sense to me. So if management's saying, hey, we're going to be investing $100 billion this
year, generally they know what a good return on investment capital looks like. So I think
shareholders should actually applaud the news that they're going to be investing more and more.
But I think what actually gives investors pause, one of the things, is also the fact that their
market share in their core business, AWS, their web services actually may have slipped this past
year. There have been signs that they have been losing market share to faster growers like
Microsoft and Google, which do show signs of increasing. And you could just compare it by
growth rates where Amazon is growing, yes, significantly. AWS is still growing at a good
clip, but relative to its competitors, it's definitely growing slower. And so this does
suggest that there are these players that are taking market share. And Microsoft and Google
shouldn't be ignored, in my opinion. I think another key aspect of why Amazon stock has come
under pressure year to date is just the reflection that we are in a AI revolution. This is a very
exciting point in history. Microsoft has their alignment with open AI. Google has Gemini. What
does Amazon have? Now, they do have some investments with Anthropic. So does Google.
Google also owns a stake in Anthropic. So it's really unclear. Wait a second. How come Amazon
isn't really pushing the AI race in the same way that Microsoft and Google have this sort of horse
that can drive their cloud infrastructure? And so that, I think, is a common pushback,
saying Amazon may have missed this. I mean, they do, once again, have a minority ownership. Maybe
someday that turns into an all-out acquisition. But so far, that's not the case. I think another
reason why Amazon stock has come under pressure is just the concerns of, you know, will governments
around the world sort of go against big tech? And we've seen that initiatives across various
different angles, one of which is the Federal Trade Commission, you know, securing a historic
multi-billion dollar settlement against Amazon relating to their, you know, prime subscriptions
and making it difficult to cancel. Personally, that hasn't been my experience. And I think that
does reflect that if the government wants to say, hey, we just don't like you or we want you to pay
me a few billion dollars, governments around the world will figure out a way to do that. They'll
just make it harder to operate. And I think we are going from a cyclical perspective of going,
hey, we should celebrate these companies, which I personally believe in. This is a channel that's
I want more billionaires, not fewer. I'm all for it. But I also recognize that we have
maybe this push from a government perspective to say, maybe I don't like your political angle
because Jeff Bezos also owns the Washington Post. And you know what? I'm going to hurt you where I
can and we're going to do it through trade practices. So you can have that perspective.
Even simpler answer for why Amazon may have come under pressure so far year to date is just the
fact that Jeff Bezos' first wife has been significantly cutting her stake in Amazon,
the share she got in the divorce settlement, where she supposedly cut her stake down something like
40 percent this past year, a huge cut. And now it's the stake is only worth around 13 billion
dollars is my understanding. So that it might just be as simple as that. You might have all these
other concerns, like how come you're not a front runner in the race? Maybe your cash flow is getting
eaten up by these capital expenditures. You know, maybe it's the government squeezing the business.
Maybe it's maybe it's just as simple as that. There was a lot of supply in this past year
as one of the indirect founders, you could think, you know, the wife of the founder,
Jeff Bezos, is, you know, significantly trimming her shares. So let's go back to the core
other questions. So we've sort of covered an overview of why Amazon stock has been under
pressure. I don't think it's really as much fundamentally driven because we're going to
talk about those fundamentals in just a second. So let's let's review. Is Amazon stock on sale?
And so when you think about Amazon, it is important to recognize that Amazon has so many
different business. You have their online stores, you have their physical stores like Whole Foods,
you have third party services like fulfillment, third party merchants, you have advertising
revenues, subscription services like Prime, you have AWS, you have other others becoming
increasingly relevant as they consider things like health care. And so when you're thinking
about this, each of these business lines also have very different profit attributes. And that's what
makes it harder to value something like Amazon, for example, their physical stores. It's really
hard to get some sort of edge where you're saying, yeah, this should be a 10 percent plus operating
margin business. Probably won't be a lot of grocery stores. You probably talk about three,
five percent at most. Now, you're not talking about a 20 percent operating margin. You're
talking about a 30 percent gross margin basis for these types of businesses. For advertising,
however, advertising is a beautiful business for Amazon. And that based on looking at how
other companies operate, that is likely a very high margin driver for this business.
You know, you're you're talking about, you know, probably 40 percent plus operating
margins for something like advertising, maybe even more. And so that could significantly
influence how you think about this business. So there's a lot of different line items,
you know, subscription services. You might think, well, wait a second that,
you know, that requires the logistics to get the truck, to deliver the package. And
the service just keeps getting better in my experience where it's, you know, it's gone
from next day to same day. Incredibly impressive. But the subscription, it's like, OK, well, does
is this a profit driver for them or is this just sort of going to profit neutral? Or,
you know, if you're leveraging, you know, video content, will that actually result in better
profitability? So there's a lot of moving pieces here. I think the way to think about it actually
is to break it down into the individual segments. And that's arguably what management focuses on,
because they don't show you the profit per business line. They show you the different
segments. And you can see North America is actually doing quite well. Most recent quarter,
around 11 percent revenue growth and near record operating margins of around seven percent.
This is one that's really been a wake up call for me personally, because previously it was tough
for me to really underwrite that their core North American operations, including online,
physical, you know, fulfillment services, third party, all that's baked into North America.
I really hadn't seen signs that this could be, let's say, a much higher operating margin
business. I mean, you zoom back far enough and there were articles talking about,
you know, Amazon blowing up. So this is, I think, proof positive that this business,
their core retail business can be very lucrative. And you can see that it's
doing about 20 billion dollars in operating profit per quarter. But most critical is this
idea that maybe this is this could be around seven, eight, ten, maybe even more operating
margin, especially as they're advertising business scale. So I think this is something to think
about. And this is a very clear, positive development, seeing this margin going from
five percent to seven percent in the most recent quarter. And that, frankly, did impact how I think
about valuing Amazon. Next up is international. International, frankly, has hasn't been great
in my opinion, growing only around the same growth rate as North America, which does reflect,
in my opinion, that they're likely losing market share to they're likely losing market share to
local players. And if that's happening, you know, do you really want to keep putting more capital
after this? So that that creates a whole separate argument of maybe Amazon should think about
selling their operations to international players. People will disagree about that.
But it just makes me wonder after so many years in the international arena to only be posting
growth rates that are comparable to North America. And, you know, they're they're not anywhere near
the same sort of profitability. It just makes me wonder thinking about it. You could say that,
hey, they're just going to keep pushing on on delivering. And you could say you could even
argue that they have some sort of advantage in doing it, because, hey, why don't why don't
they take the profits from their North Americans segment and they could just subsidize international
growth? And they don't care about running those profitably if they want. They can possibly take
market share even faster. That would be one theory. But so far, I would say international
is probably losing market share relative to local players that are growing much faster.
One of my top positions is a international e-commerce player, actually a couple of them.
And, you know, they're just growing much faster. They do see oftentimes do see Amazon as competitors,
but it's just not they don't have the local on the ground experience services offerings that
is winning market share. And you're also seeing it, you know, the sort of suboptimal margins.
Amazon Web Services, AWS, I mean, this is doing very well, possibly losing market share,
growing only around 17 percent when the market itself might be growing closer to 20 percent plus.
I've also been impressed with how their profitability has improved so significantly
from 30 percent margins to 37 percent. So this is, you know, it makes me wonder how
sustainable this is, how much of this is based on just sort of accounting for how long their
servers will last, those sort of questions. But overall, this is their most lucrative segment.
It's still growing well above their other segments. So clearly, AWS is a lot of value for
when you're thinking about Amazon. But is Amazon actually undervalued? And before we dig into that,
you know, specific, you know, showing you my framework. First of all, none of this is financial
advice. Also, super quick plug. Last week, Joe R. shared, Daniel, thank you for all your insight.
I've made almost a million dollars following along with your investing journey. This follows San
C. who wrote, I initially signed up for the light subscription to test the waters.
Since then, your analysis and insights have provided so much amazing value. I've regretted
not going all in from the beginning. He's talking about the premium subscription.
We have a new community with the Unravel Investing premium subscription. Prices are
going to be going up later this month. So now is the time to lock it in. And so when I think about
Amazon, you know, I think it is important to reflect this is a business. And if you haven't
read all of Jeff Bezos, his letters and, you know, he has this wonderful book over my shoulder,
you know, invent and wander, which is a collection of his annual letters and speeches.
It's very, you know, it's thought provoking and makes you think they deserve to win. And there's
a reason why they won. And there's it's also helpful as you think about, you know, other
businesses that you may want to invest in. So I think it's important to say this is a company
that's going to keep on making bets where they see huge opportunities and they're just going to
try and they're going to fail a lot, but they're going to try to, you know, unlock huge new
opportunities, one of which I think you could argue is getting into the health care space
where you can see, you know, they're moving into not only providing health care services
and they're talking about pay per visit health care for kids two to eleven. This is using the
Amazon one medical plan, but they're also looking to get into the pharmacy space.
Unclear whether or not this has the potential or will disrupt what is otherwise a huge market. I
mean, US health care as a percentage of GDP is something like 20 percent. It's one fifth of the
US economy. That is just huge. And so no wonder Amazon's thinking about, hey, how can we break
this? How can we disrupt this? You know, historically, Jeff Bezos has sort of a saying,
at least it's attributed to him of, you know, your margin is my opportunity. Maybe they'll figure
that out. And with a which Jeff Bezos literally has been talking about for the better part of
this past decade. You know, I think there's a good chance they do figure out a way to bring
health care costs dramatically lower in the years ahead. Maybe that could be a growth driver for
Amazon in the years to come. Another key aspect for investors to think about is their advertising
business just is doing very well and arguably has years and years of growth rate growth ahead of it,
especially as you know, you're thinking about Prime getting more and more content. Maybe it's
getting live sports. Maybe it's getting more movies. Maybe it's using AI to generate content.
It's going to become even cheaper to create more movies. And you're going to say, hey, this this
custom catalog built just for me that Amazon knows based on my viewing and my shopping.
Here it is. We just made this for you. You know, we know you just bought, you know, cat food. Maybe
you're going to be interested in these videos. Who knows? Maybe you even create that content.
So I think, you know, the the runway for their advertising business is one of their faster
growers, you know, continues to post strong numbers. Another prospect is that, you know,
they reboot Alexa. You know, this is definitely a lead that they've I'd argue they've given up.
And maybe there's some sort of push in robotics. Who knows how that plays out?
So as we think about the different segments, you know, this is hypothetical. Of course,
stock price can go higher or lower. But I want to build into the different I want to
think about the different pieces. And so we have North America. North America is arguably
worth somewhere between one third to 100 percent of the current market cap. Thinking about
how we how we look at these different pieces, I've the big change with this video is thinking
about how North American margins could be long term and just based on how much they've been
able to improve this past year. I think it is important to reset my expectations, which were
previously a little bit lower to closer to eight to 12 percent over time. Currently, it's around
seven percent. Most recent quarter was around seven and a half percent. So I do think that
trajectory might suggest that their margins long term might be around 10 percent, give or take.
So then the question is, well, what's the growth rate in the years ahead? This is,
you know, they've become so big that they are tied to the U.S. economy.
So if there is a bit of a recession, you know, I would expect lower growth rates,
maybe even a contraction. However, it is a very valuable business and a lot of consumers love it.
So I think, you know, a fair market value, I think, seems very reasonable. The market's
currently trading around 25 times, assuming a similar multiple for Amazon's North America
segment seems appropriate as well. AWS, I do factor in international in the summary sheet,
which you'll see in just a second, but it's so small relative to North America and AWS.
We'll just skip it for now. But AWS arguably worth more than half of the current market cap
and possibly worth over 100 percent of the current market cap. And the question is, well,
what's the long term margins? Because margins have improved a lot significantly, have improved
significantly this past year from around 30 to 36, 37 percent. So the question is, is this going
to stay at that rate? Are they not accounting for their server depreciation and appropriate rate,
you know, because of all this capex that they're having to do? And, you know, I'm thinking that
roughly continues growing at a teens rate. Maybe I'm being a little too conservative here. I'm
assuming a slightly higher valuation for AWS five years out. So putting all the pieces together,
you know, based on where the stock price trades today, you know, you're around two point three
trillion dollar market cap. Think about their North American operations. Think about AWS.
Think about international. International, once again, the smallest piece of the three core
segments. And you're effectively looking at, once again, hypothetical stock prices can,
you know, you can have macro events that dramatically impact how things happen.
Sentiment can change. But looking at this hypothetical framework, I'm roughly saying
that over the next five years, it wouldn't surprise me in a low, low case that it actually
compounds around one percent. You factor in a couple percent for the cash flow that goes to
shareholders each year as they're expected to keep generating positive free cash flow.
And then a more of a high case, you might even compound closer to 20 percent plus over the next
five years, closer to, you know, 100, 200 percent type of upside. So I actually am of the mind
that as I look at Amazon now, that it is arguably undervalued. And I do like that asymmetry of like,
hmm, over the next five years, maybe if it's slightly better than breakeven,
possibly, and maybe over, you know, the upside, maybe it's closer to 100,
200 percent. Those are the types of bets I like to make. And it's no surprise to see,
you know, major investors like Bill Ackman say, hmm, maybe I want to own
Amazon because they have these big funds and they're they're trying to find setups like this.
Now, personally, as a smaller investor, I can find, you know, smaller than something like a
Bill Ackman. I can find plays that are, let's say, three billion dollar market caps and have much
faster growth and better risk rewards. And literally just earlier today, I was calling out
to my subscribers at Unravel Investing, a company where the framework's closer to,
you know, 40, 50, 60 percent upside on the low case using what I think are conservative and
reasonable assumptions and closer to 300 percent upside or maybe more on the high.
So, anywho, I think every investor needs to figure out what they want to own,
what are the risks they're comfortable with. But for those investors that want to stick to the
mega caps, you know, the two trillion dollar types of names wouldn't surprise me if Amazon
actually does quite well or very reasonably over the next five years, even though so far,
2025, it's been struggling and it's been slightly underwater.
I hope this video has been helpful for you. Thanks so much for watching. Unravel Investing.
