Avoid These Broadhead Sharpening Mistakes!

The Precision of Crossbowry
1 follower
Oct 28, 2025
Avoid These Broadhead Sharpening Mistakes!
Comments are disabled for this video.
Hi, I'm Chris with Afflicted Broadheads, and today we're going to talk about some of the
most common sharpening mistakes people make when it comes to broadheads.
So of course, we all want the sharpest broadhead possible, and sometimes they just, for whatever
reason on some brands, don't come out of the box sharp.
Or maybe you've practiced with them and you want to touch them up, or maybe you harvested
an animal and you still would like to touch them up so they can be reused.
Let's face it, the goal here is try to be able to reuse broadheads as long as we can.
That's what makes replaceable blades so popular, is the fact that you can go ahead and pop
new sets in and not have to monkey around with sharpening them yourself.
I think one of the first mistakes that people make when they're sharpening a broadhead is
they don't have a wide enough array of availability items, meaning, let's just say, grit sizes,
whether you're using paper, diamond plate, or maybe even a really good file system or
stone system where you only have maybe a couple grits, and maybe they're a real heavy grit,
and you're not able to get down to those really fine grits to put that last polished final
edge on your blades.
And so sometimes we do ourselves a disservice when we just go to the toolbox and we get
out that old rusty file and we figure, all right, I'm going to start on this broadhead
and really all you're doing is removing metal in too big of a way, causing big grooves in
there.
And you may get it feeling pretty sharp, but it's not going to be a nice, clean, smooth
edge.
It's going to be a little bit rugged.
And if you're okay with that, then that's fine.
But you really kind of owe it to the animal to have the sharpest blades that you can when
you're going out in the field.
So this is definitely usually not the best way.
If you have to take a lot of metal off and you're starting with this, but you're going
to finish with a lot of other things, then that's a different story.
For me, I have a whole little tackle box and it's full of different diamond plates, different
stones, lots of different papers.
I have everything here I need based on what I'm trying to do with that blade.
If I'm trying to restore it from some big nicks and things like that, then I'm going
to start really heavy, maybe even with a bigger file to get those out of there.
And then, you know, go to a smaller and smaller grit until I get where I want to be.
Now the other thing that I think that you do a disservice on when it comes to some broadheads,
not all, is trying to sharpen them while they're on the ferrule.
If you have a single bevel or a standard two blade or even a three blade, of course it's
kind of practical to be able to sharpen them without removing them from the ferrule.
There's different guides that are available.
There's different methods that make it really simple.
But when it comes to a four blade, there's just a little bit too much in the way and
you're really doing yourself a disservice if you're trying to get in there even with
a micro file or you got a better, you know, using a plate or a piece of sandpaper of any
sorts, you're really not able to get in there without causing yourself some issues with
another blade.
So it's best to remove those blades.
Now there's some great sharpeners on the market for broadheads.
We really like the Stay Sharp brand.
I just think that they're tremendous for lots of reasons.
First of all, they have a design for just about every broadhead.
They're affordable.
They're effective.
They do a wonderful job and they're really, really simple.
But most of all, they're exact.
You get the angle that you want.
You can keep that angle throughout all of your sharpening, through all of your different
media, all the way down to your finest thing, all the way to your polishing stage when you
use the Stay Sharp.
What I also like about the Stay Sharp and that is another problem that people run into
is that they don't use the correct angle or they try to drastically change the angle without
any consistency.
If you want to change the angle of your current broadhead, that is not a bad thing.
Sometimes you can give your edge a little bit of a wider angle and you can give it some
more durability and still maintain sharpness.
On the Stay Sharps, if I want to change an angle that isn't exact for what he has on
his rollers, I just add tape.
Put some tape here and you can get that angle to be whatever you want it to do.
Tear some tape off and you can get it to be wherever you want it, whether you're gliding
over top of a diamond plate or sandpaper.
So again, I think that not removing the blades can cause a little bit of a problem when you're
trying to sharpen some broadheads, especially when you're looking at a four blade.
Another common thing that you run into when you're sharpening as far as a mistake is stopping
too soon.
I mentioned earlier not having enough medium and those things kind of go together because
you can stop too soon when you're really not sharp.
Maybe it feels sharp, maybe you rolled your finger over and you felt that burr and it's
really sharp because you're hitting the burr and not actually the blade.
So I think it's really important to not stop too soon.
Some steels are going to take longer.
If they're harder, it's going to take longer.
You're going to have to put a little bit more effort into it and don't give up.
If you have the right equipment and you are able just to stick with it, you'll be able
to get the sharpness that you desire by spending a little extra time and going through all
of your different grits.
When I talk about the mistake of changing the angle and then I go ahead and I say, well,
changing the angle isn't bad.
I know it's kind of a contradiction.
But what I mean is you can drastically change the angle when you're sharpening a broadhead
just by not having the right guide or the right system and not being consistent.
Maybe your file or your paper or your stone isn't perfectly flat.
Maybe it's at an angle.
Maybe you started at this angle and then you're over here and you just don't have any consistency.
You want to be able to have a system that allows you to be consistent the whole time.
Changing an angle on any broadhead is not that big of a deal.
If you want to go to a wider angle, wider angle meaning maybe you're starting right
here and you want to go out here, what that's going to do for you is it's going to give
you a little bit more edge retention and a little bit more durability.
But you have to be careful.
When you get beyond that 80 degree mark and bigger, you're also going to sacrifice a little
bit of penetration even when you're sharp because you're dealing with these really
broad shoulders.
So sometimes we're really trying to get this durable angle where I can shoot through a
brick and nothing's going to happen to my broadhead, but you're doing yourself an injustice
because you've made that so steep that you're actually inhibiting your penetration by bringing
in these big shoulders because of such a steep angle.
Now you can also mess up when you have too narrow of an angle, a flat angle, kind of
like a fillet knife if you will.
Fillet knife is great for taking the flesh off of a walleye, but it has no edge retention
or durability.
Super sharp.
Will cut great just like a typical razor blade for a razor or a razor knife if you will,
but it doesn't have any durability.
When you tend to get into those wider angles, you definitely increase your durability.
So if you're considering sharpening your own broadheads, make sure you have the right equipment,
you're taking your time, and you're doing the best job that you can for yourself and
for the animals that you're harvesting.
Thanks for watching.
