Exclusive
Calvin Coolidge: Steady in Changing Times

American Legends
361 followers
Calvin Coolidge rose from a quiet Vermont lawyer to lead the nation through the Roaring Twenties. Known as “Silent Cal,” he championed small government, fiscal restraint, and constitutional order during a time of rapid social change. This episode revisits his understated yet impactful presidency—and why his steady hand still resonates today.
#calvincoolidge #americanlegends #roaringtwenties #smallgovernment #americanpresidents #whitehousehistory #presidentialfamilies #presidentialhistory #classicamericanhistory #history #historyandculture #historyfacts #american #uncoveringhistory #uncoverthetruth
Welcome to American Legends. My name is Tiffany Brandon.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories,
but here in America, our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right from our history
pages. Now, some of these heroes are very famous and some are obscure, but each person deserves to
be discovered because each man or woman stands as a great example of how we can be better Americans
It's difficult to fill the shoes of someone who has come before you. This was certainly the case
with most of the earlier presidents who had to take over the existing presidency when their
predecessor died. Today we're going to talk about one president who was very popular during his own
day and since then has been viewed less favorably but who I think deserves another chance. Calvin
Coolidge was one of several presidents who took his first term in office by accident, it would
seem. He was not elected as president but as vice president in the year 1920 with his running mate
Warren G. Harding. The fact that Calvin Coolidge even was vice president at this point was rather
surprising. When Harding was named the Republican candidate, it was from the smoke-filled room,
the famous all-night party politics session which resulted in his being the candidate.
Harding was very involved and engrossed in the corrupt machine of the Republican party of that
day. After the party bosses decided that they wanted Harding to be the candidate,
they also named the man they wanted to be vice president and then left Chicago which was the
town where the delegation was taking place. These bosses assumed that their power was so great that
naturally all the delegates would go with what they had said. However, as soon as the party
bosses had left Chicago, the delegates decided to show their independence by naming a very different
man to be the running mate. This man was Calvin Coolidge. At the time, he was the governor of
Massachusetts. He certainly was not the sort of person you'd expect to be named at this point
because he wasn't involved with any machine. In fact, that was just what endeared him to the
delegates who originally suggested him. One delegate was familiar with a speech he'd given
a couple of years earlier which was called Have Faith in Massachusetts. In this speech,
Coolidge expressed very calm but rational and wise policies on the idea of government.
Knowing that he wasn't controlled by any party and thus would be a good counterpart to the
quite corrupt Harding, Coolidge was put on the ballot. The Hardings and the Coolidges did not
get along well and Calvin Coolidge quickly established himself a reputation of being very
quiet and reserved. Now, he long had been acknowledged as a man who was so quiet he was
known as Silent Cal. Nevertheless, he did do some campaigning on his own, giving short but
succinct speeches in different regions than his running mate. During Harding's presidency, he
remained in the background, staying in the shadows. Nevertheless, despite his low profile, he was the
first vice president to regularly attend cabinet meetings. Speaking of the cabinet, the Harding
administration was full of corruption in his cabinet with the Teapot Dome scandal and the
Harding gang being some of the most noteworthy scandals which erupted as all of Harding's
corrupt political machine from Ohio started to come to the surface as some of these cabinet
members were less than discreet. However, Coolidge, who was not from Ohio and not involved in any of
this corrupt machine action, remained uninvolved in the corrupt scandals and thus when Harding died
quite unexpectedly in the year 1923, Coolidge was able to begin his presidency with a clean slate.
He was visiting his father's home in Vermont when he heard the news that he would take over
as the president. He recounted in his autobiography that he was sleeping and it was the middle of the
night when he heard his father coming up the stairs. His father's voice was trembling as he
called out to him and immediately Coolidge knew that there must be some very serious news because
he'd only observed that trembling quality in his father's voice before when announcing family
deaths. When he learned that he had become the new president, Coolidge was very solemn about the
matter and first he prayed, then he went downstairs and his father administered the oath of office.
As a public notary and a local justice of the peace, his father was qualified to do so.
In his autobiography, Coolidge remarked that this was quite a singular event in which a democracy
would feature a leader being sworn in by his own father. Being the president of the United States
was one of the more important political positions Calvin Coolidge had had. He was born in Vermont
on July 4th, 1872, making him the only president to date to be born on the 4th of July. He spent
many of his formative years in Massachusetts. His father was a farmer as well as holding
some lower level positions in government such as serving in the state legislature.
Coolidge would go to Amherst College and afterwards he studied law and passed the bar exam
when he was 25 years old. He began his career as a lawyer, serving in smaller cases, first
mainly as a country lawyer. This would eventually lead to positions which were elected but at a
lower level such as serving on the city council or on the school board. He often was quite accessible
when running for these elected positions. He eventually began serving in the state legislature
for Massachusetts and then in the state senate. Eventually he was president of the state senate.
In these positions he showed that he was a calm, very rational man who was dedicated to the
preservation of law, obeying the legislature, and relying on the administration of laws to be
effective rather than hastily changing the legislation. This was something to which he
hearkened throughout his career as a politician, saying that you need to give the enforcement of
laws a chance before you try to change the laws themselves. Eventually he got his biggest break
in politics when he served as the lieutenant governor of Massachusetts. This position was
similar to the vice president to the president in that the lieutenant governor was basically
the assistant to the governor. He served in this one-year position for three years in a row
before his governor running mate declared that he would not be running for a fourth term. At this
point Coolidge declared that he himself would run for governor and he was elected in the year 1918.
He would rise to national prominence in 1919 with his handling of the Boston police strike.
Unions were rising and becoming more important at this point, particularly as World War I had
recently ended, and the policemen in Boston decided that they wanted to have a union themselves.
This caused a good deal of commotion as the chief of police didn't want them to have a union. He
thought that that was going against the whole principle of the police force. This led most of
the policemen in Boston to begin a strike. At first Coolidge wanted to stay out of it, saying
that as he was the governor of the whole state he should leave the matter to the mayor of the city.
But as soon as the events turned hostile and riots began to break out in Boston as the criminal
forces took advantage of this situation, he took decisive action. He sent the National Guard to
get the situation under control and most of the police force ended up being replaced.
The chief of police and the mayor of Boston were writing back and forth to each other and making a
lot of public statements, declaring on one side that it was the right of the policemen to take
this action and on the other side that it had left the city of Boston in a very dangerous position
because of the handling of it. At this point Coolidge established a firm principle that
duty is more important than advocating for some cause or the individual rights, such as the
policemen had tried to do, because this had left the city of Boston in a very dangerous position.
By making this stance, he gained a lot of support from the people who were concerned about
the possibility of communism seeping into the United States at this point.
There was a first red scare at this point in history, as there had recently been the Bolshevik
Revolution in Russia and the Soviet Union was beginning to gain power in that side of the world.
Although he gained some opponents in the labor and union sectors because of this action, he gained
even more support from the heads of businesses and people who were concerned about law and order.
He also established himself as a very wise conservative republican leader and someone to
watch for presidential possibility. Thus it's not a surprise that he was the vice presidential
candidate just the next year and a few years later would become president of the United States himself.
Now this wasn't something he had expected to gain so quickly, although he perhaps had aspirations
of becoming a president eventually. He did not immediately replace the Harding cabinet because
he felt that it was the proper thing to do to continue with one's predecessor's cabinet until
the next election. Instead he focused on the due process of law to seek out and punish those who
had been involved in the scandals and the corruption of the Harding administration.
He left this mainly to the senate to weed out those who had been dealing unlawfully or for
personal gain, and this proved quite effective as most of these people resigned on their own.
Eventually he had to dismiss the attorney general, Harry Daugherty, who was really the head of the
corrupt political machine. He dismissed him because Daugherty refused to cooperate with
the senate hearings, thus basically admitting to his own guilt. Coolidge was a very moderate,
thoughtful president. He presided over the nation during a period of great economic growth,
stability, and peace. The economic boom which took place during the decade of the 1920s has led to
that decade being labeled the Roaring Twenties, partly because business was roaring to success,
as well as because of the changing times, what with the increased rights of the new women voters
and the strange atmosphere that came about because of prohibition. Throughout his political career,
particularly in the teens leading into the 1920s, Coolidge had established himself as having a
strong platform on a few issues. He believed in being fiscally conservative. He supported
women's rights, but he opposed prohibition in a rather gentle, moderate way. Nevertheless,
although he was personally against prohibition, he enforced it himself with his public stance as
a politician and personally by not allowing any alcohol to be served in the White House.
This was in direct contrast to the actions of Harding, who was said to run the White House
like a speakeasy. Coolidge said that the business of America is business, and he went on to elaborate
that the United States is a very business-centric nation, particularly by that point. The business
of manufacturing things, the buying and selling trade, are some of the greatest concerns of the
American people. It's sometimes known as the American business sense or Yankee ingenuity,
but whatever you want to call it, Americans are good at doing business, and business was
only growing during his time. Thus, he believed in policies which would support the nation in its
business growth and would lead to its being run like a business. His style of governing has often
been called the laissez-faire, and he believed in a small central government, instead giving more
power to the individual states. Interestingly, these were the policies which were originally
associated with the Democratic-Republican party, which was more the predecessor to the Democratic
party, but that just shows that the change which the different parties underwent during the history
of the nation. At this point in history, Republicans tended to be more in favor of tariffs versus
income tax as a way to gain the necessary money to run the government. Woodrow Wilson,
his recent predecessor as president, had implemented a more standardized form of
income tax as a Democrat, but Coolidge found a way to balance this without creating an extremely
large increase in tariffs. He decreased the personal income tax and standardized it so that
only the top two percent wealthiest people in the nation had to pay any income tax. Nevertheless,
although fewer people were paying income tax, the government was earning more revenue, even as he had
decreased the amount of taxation. He also cut down on government spending. This was something that he
had been very successful in doing when he was governor. He was able to streamline the budget,
cut the excess waste, cause less spending to take place, but bolster the strength of the government.
Some people have criticized Coolidge for how little he did as president, meaning that he didn't take
as active a role in creating policies and making an agenda and actively making it happen. He did
more as governor, some say, than as president. But this isn't surprising because it shows what
he believed should be the form of government. He thought that the states should take more of an
active role in the actual policies of daily, day-to-day life than the central government.
He thought that the federal government should manage, of course, and oversee things, but that
it should allow freedom of the states. That's one reason why he was more aggressive as a governor
in many ways. When he was the governor of Massachusetts, he vetoed a bill which would
have caused Massachusetts to defy the new 18th amendment, which was the amendment which caused
prohibition. Again, he personally didn't agree with prohibition, but he didn't want his state
or any other state to openly defy the constitution because he stated that the constitution must be
upheld at any cost. Although not an isolationist, he definitely believed in America first.
Rather than focusing on helping other nations or even more making close alliances with
other nations, he thought that the United States should be sovereign and very strong on its own.
Thus, he was against America's involvement in the League of Nations, which Wilson had created
and attempted to make the United States join. He saw it as problematic and that it could be akin
to too much socialism. He wanted the United States to remain very independent. Nevertheless, Coolidge
deserves a lot more credit for believing in the equality of races and civil rights. He made more
improvements in the rights of African Americans than many other presidents around his time.
He was noted to be free from racial prejudice and he was personally against the Ku Klux Klan,
making him one of the few Republicans around that time to not be involved in the Klan. He is not
believed to have appointed any Klansmen to government positions. Because he didn't like
to make extremely bold statements against other people, he didn't denounce the Ku Klux Klan as
strongly as some other politicians, but it wasn't because he was in favor of it. That simply was his
way of doing things. When he was running for president in 1924 for re-election, he maintained a strong
stance of not personally attacking or speaking out against either of his opponents, since he was
running against both the Democrat and a progressive. He simply spoke his ideas on government,
making his the calmest and most polite campaign since at least 1896. He used much more old-fashioned
means of campaigning, even as his opponents were using the more modern tactics. He stated that
black citizens should be given just as many rights as any other person in the nation, and that the
United States should not infringe upon any of their rights. He also applauded black citizens
for doing so much to increase the strength of the United States, particularly during the recent
World War, although they often faced prejudice. He also improved the lot of Native Americans with
the Indian Citizenship Act of 1924. At this point, not all Native Americans living on reservations
were actually American citizens. Those off reservations all were, and those who were
married to American citizens were, as well as those Indians who had served in World War I.
But some people who still lived on reservations were simply citizens of those sovereign Indian
nations, not of the United States. With the Indian Citizenship Act, he granted all Native Americans
born in the United States American citizenship, and because of this, he was made an honorary member
of the Sioux tribe. When he ran for re-election in 1924, which was the first time he actually ran
himself, he followed in the footsteps of Theodore Roosevelt in being very popular on his own merit,
making him only the second president to win his own term after finishing another president's term.
The first few presidents who did this were extremely unpopular and unsuccessful, if they even
were able to attempt to run for a second term. He, however, won in a landslide, showing that his
policies were doing very well, and people were pleased with what he did as president.
The slogan used for his campaign was, keep cool with Cal, and this reflected the fact that he
had a very moderate, reasonable way of governing. Although he was noted for his quietness and his
lack of talking, really, he gave more press interviews than any other president.
520 press conferences, to be accurate. It wasn't that he was completely against talking, he just
didn't believe in idle chatter, and he was very serious and reserved. One of the most oft-quoted
stories about him was that at one state dinner, a lady sitting next to him said that she had bet
a friend that she could get him to say more than three words to her, to which he responded,
you lose. He himself said that this never happened, and it was simply a story repeated about
him, and it wouldn't have been like him to be that rude to someone, particularly to a lady,
but it was one of those oft-repeated jokes which reflect how people thought about him.
He was often nicknamed Red, as well as Silent Cal, because of his characteristic red hair.
He was a very devout Christian throughout his life, commenting on the strong Puritan
background his family had, and he later became a Congregational Christian. In fact, his birth
name was John Calvin Coolidge Jr., in reference to the evangelist John Calvin. During his presidency,
he relied on some of his most influential cabinet members to help him with his economic principles.
This included future president Herbert Hoover, who offered him a lot of advice on policy,
and although he heeded it quite frequently, Coolidge later commented that Hoover had given
him a lot of unsolicited advice. As the 1928 election approached, Coolidge was urged to run
for third term, but he declared that he would not run again, because if he were to win, he would be
in the White House for 10 years, longer than any president up to that point, which he said would
have been too long. Although he was not personally supportive of Herbert Hoover as president,
he didn't want to divide his party, so he didn't make any public statements against Hoover for
president. After leaving the White House, Coolidge wrote his autobiography, had a newspaper column,
which was called Coolidge Says. He served as a trustee at a college, and he even worked
in an insurance company. Nevertheless, he only lived four years after that, and had he run for
and won a third term, he would have died two months short of its ending, as he died at the age of 60
in 1933 of heart failure. Coolidge was one of the more popular presidents during his time in office,
but as the Great Depression began shortly after he left, with the Wall Street crash taking place
the same year he left office, people later criticized him, saying that his non-interventionist
policies perhaps led to the Great Depression. Nevertheless, some later scholars and politicians
and political science historians, who believe in a low involvement from the government,
still revere him as a fine president. Future President Ronald Reagan, for instance,
considered Coolidge one of the best presidents of the 20th century, because he too believed in
less government intervention. Coolidge served in a difficult time period for the United States.
On one side was the Great War, which had just ended, and from which the nation was recovering.
On the other side loomed the uncertainty of re-establishing a nation, as it was facing
these changing times with prohibition and new rights for women, and communism in foreign countries,
as well as countries in Central and South America declaring their independence.
He had to deal with all these things, as well as working on peace treaties with Europe,
to try to establish a world in which, hopefully, there wouldn't be wars of that magnitude.
Obviously, that was not successful, but some of the principles which he helped establish with
certain pacts made with foreign countries did help with the reconstruction after World War II.
I think that Coolidge is a vastly underappreciated president. Reading about his life,
I was extremely impressed by the wisdom which this man had, and the calm and very rational
view he took. He remained both extremely old-fashioned and conservative, and very open-minded,
and willing to accept the new ideas that were coming along, without casting aside the wisdom
and the traditions of the past. He made many great quotes, several of which are from his
autobiography, and a running theme you see in his writings and his speech is the importance
of persistence. He believed in being persistent more than anything else. To quote,
nothing in this world can take the place of persistence. Talent will not. Nothing is more
common than unsuccessful men with talent. Genius will not. Unrewarded genius is almost a proverb.
Education will not. The world is full of educated derelicts. Persistence and determination alone
are omnipotent. Many of his quotes refer to his silence and why he valued it, making it pretty
clear that it wasn't just shyness, but a very intentional choice which made him a man a few
words. He said, the things I never say never get me into trouble. He also said, silence can never be
misquoted, as well as, you can't know too much, but you can say too much. He's quoted as saying,
your ability to face setbacks and disappointments without giving up will be the measure of your
ability to succeed. He was noted as being a very frugal man personally, which reflected in his very
frugal way of government and he said, there is no dignity quite so impressive and no one independence
quite so important as living within your means. In a decade of excess and immorality, Coolidge
remained a valuable source of constancy, I would say. A very old-fashioned man, almost
behind his generation compared to some of the presidents who come before him, like Harding
and Wilson, but I'd say a refreshing example in that case and I think he's a president who deserves
a lot more credit. Thank you for spending this time with me and I hope you'll join me next time
for more American Legends.
