Over the past two decades, discoveries made in museums around the world have led to a new understanding of the early career of one of the towering masters of the Italian Renaissance, the artist known today as Fra Angelico. Now, conservation work at the Yale University Art Gallery has uncovered what may be Angelico’s first documented painting—long thought to have been lost—and opens new perspectives on the key role he played in the opening years of the 15th century in the formation of a modern style of naturalistic representation. Laurence Kanter, Chief Curator and the Lionel Goldfrank III Curator of European Art, addresses the early work of Fra Angelico.
Generously sponsored by the John Walsh Lecture and Education Fund.
When Jock asked me to deliver a lecture in this series honoring our friend and colleague John Walsh,
my first thought was to share with you one of the recent discoveries we have made among the paintings and storage here at the Yale University Art Gallery.
Plans changed shortly before Christmas, however.
I'm looking around, I don't see him here yet.
When the title of the lecture having been announced, my very good friend Richard Feigen decided that he wished to make a gift to Yale.
He chose one of his three paintings by Fra Angelico, the earliest, thinking that if we were indeed searching for the artist as a young man,
we ought to be able to find him a little closer to home.
Described by two distinguished critics as the missing link and a tiny miracle,
the painting is a fragment, but of what we do not know.
Could this powerfully sculpted head with furrowed brow and intently focused gaze be Joseph of Arimathea from an image of the Lamentation?
Could this be St. Joseph looking protectively and with some concern at his family from a lost scene of the Adoration of the Magi?
At least one of my colleagues, Karl Strelky, thought it might be a fragment of a documented altarpiece that in a roundabout way will become the final subject of today's lecture.
Whatever it is, it is strikingly beautiful.
Thank you, Richard. We all thank you.
This lecture is dedicated to you.
For many hundreds of years, the primary source of our knowledge about the works of the greater and lesser Italian Renaissance masters
was The Sweeping Lives of the Most Excellent Painters, Sculptors, and Architects by Giorgio Vasari,
first published in 1550 and then again in a much-embroidered second edition in 1568.
Vasari was himself a painter, not a historian.
And his aim in writing this magisterial work, the edition many of us use today comprises nine fully annotated volumes,
was to establish a venerable tradition and context for his own art and that of his friends and peers,
rather than to insist upon accurate historical records.
Hearsay, studio gossip, patriotic local legends, partisan bickering, and professional spleen are some of the information streams feeding his narrative.
Given equal weight by the author to documents, signatures, or reliable eyewitness accounts.
19th and 20th century archival research has corrected some of Vasari's assertions and adjusted the biographical outlines of many of his subjects.
But before that, for 300 years or more, Vasari's word went unchallenged.
It was considered unimpeachable roughly twice as long as it has since been recognized to be fallible.
Few artists discussed by Vasari remain so long or so completely under the cloud of his image of them as did Fra Angelico.
Born Guido di Pietro at an unknown date, probably around 1395,
the artist chose for himself the name Fra Giovanni when he entered the Dominican order sometime between 1419 and 1422.
It was not until 1469, 14 years after his death, that he was for the first time called Pictor Angelicus, the Angelic Painter.
Vasari assures us that it was with very good reason that this excellent monk was ever called Fra Giovanni Angelico,
since the saints that he painted were so full of life and sweet and delicate in expression that they appeared to be by the hand of a saint or an angel like themselves.
Actually, when it was first used, Pictor Angelicus was not meant to be a description of Fra Giovanni's painting style.
It was intended as a play on words, a literary parallel to Doctor Angelicus, the Angelic Doctor,
an honorific title assigned by the Dominicans to the greatest philosopher and theologian of their order, St. Thomas Aquinas.
Pictor Angelicus was an epithet revealing the deepest respect for the artist's genius and seriousness of purpose, not his sweetness and delicacy.
But it was the sweetness and bright coloring of his paintings that appealed to Vasari, and that he in turn made appealing to subsequent generations.
In the early 19th century, the post-Napoleonic revival of Catholic spirituality and its Protestant coefficient,
a return to the aesthetics of the pure, the simple, and the so-called primitive, raised Angelico's reputation to near cult status.
Vasari's characterization of him as a humble and saintly man, utterly devout, withdrawn from the world,
and living a life dedicated to prayer and piety, so infused the interpretation of his paintings
that it became all but impossible to judge the artist's work separately from his personal merit.
I have no doubt that Angelico was a deeply devout man. There is no need to call into question the sincerity of his spiritual commitment.
After all, he did elect not merely to join the Dominican order, but the observant branch of that order,
submitting his daily life to an exacting regimen of prayer and liturgical obligations.
It is clear from the record, however, that Angelico was not a simple man withdrawn from the world around him.
He was commercially and politically savvy and a constantly efficient administrator.
He was the advisor to Pope Eugenius IV and to Bishop Antonino Pierotti of Florence.
Please forgive the pixelated image of St. Antonino on the right.
He was prior of a thriving Dominican community. He was a businessman par excellence.
Vasari's biography of Angelico took none of this into account.
Writing in the spirit of counter-reformation polemics, Vasari strove to praise his subject's talents as a painter,
but even more to adduce the sincerity of Angelico's spirituality as a foil to the corruption and hypocrisy of
some members of the clergy, and thereby to demonstrate that he, Vasari,
knew which side of the inquisitorial debate was the right one to be on.
Nearly 300 years later, as the 19th century was drawing close to its midpoint,
Vasari's encomium was enthusiastically revived, if not quite in the counter-reformation spirit of its original intent.
Influential books like Alex and François Riau's De la poésie chrétienne, published in 1835,
would come to exalt Fra Angelico above all other Christian painters,
while critics in the 1840s like George Darley and John Ruskin would single out Angelico's work for its beauty, to be sure,
but even more for being morally uplifting.
Between 1568 and 1835, Angelico's reputation was relatively modest.
Unlike most 15th century painters, he was never truly forgotten,
not in Italy or in the Catholic Southern Europe more generally,
where memory of his name was kept alive both by Vasari's rhetoric and by the eulogistic efforts of the Dominican Order.
Such publicists, however, were unlikely to appeal to tastes in the Protestant North,
were an artist who, according to Vasari,
never painted a crucifix without the tears streaming down his cheeks,
or of whom it was said, again by Vasari,
that the saints that he painted have more the air and likeness of saints than those of any other man.
Such a painter was more likely to be shunned as a papist than embraced as a paradigm of religious virtue.
As a result, the first record we have of a painting by Angelico,
this masterpiece now in the collection of the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in Boston,
being publicly exhibited in Great Britain, occurs no earlier than 1816.
Just the previous year, 1815,
the beautiful Miracle of St. James by Angelico, now in the Kimbell Art Museum in Fort Worth,
found no buyer at auction in London,
and when offered there again 12 months later, it finally changed hands for a mere 24 pounds.
In that same year, again 1816,
this virgin child with five angels, now in the Thyssen collection in Barcelona,
was presented by King George IV to his daughter Princess Charlotte as a gift
upon the occasion of her marriage to Leopold of Saxe-Coburg,
later King Leopold I of Belgium.
We cannot, of course, know whether the wedding gift was esteemed for its exceptional size and quality
or for its morally uplifting attribution to Angelico,
though I suspect it was the latter.
Being a wedding present, it would have been considered a wholesome influence on the young bride.
One year later, in 1817,
the 12th Duke of Alba purchased in Florence
this Madonna by Fra Angelico,
one of the greatest paintings that would ever be associated with his illustrious family,
excepting perhaps the even greater Madonna by Raphael
that had been sold by the Casa Alba generation earlier
and is now admired as one of the greatest treasures at the National Gallery of Art in Washington.
Again, we have no idea why the Duke chose to buy this painting,
the only work he or anyone in the family owned by an early Renaissance artist,
but it is only logical to wonder whether the motivation was moral rather than aesthetic.
Whatever the answer to that question,
the echoes of the debate have persistently floated around Angelico's work down to the present day.
While scholars began as early as the 1940s,
slowly at first but with steadily gathering momentum,
to poke holes in the pietistic façade behind which the true artist, so to speak, was lurking,
books about him continued to appear at an astonishing rate,
and these were about evenly divided between dispassionate historical criticism
and unabashed or even sentimental hagiography.
One of my colleagues from Oberlin actually opined recently
that instead of being appointed patron saint of painters, as he now is considered,
Angelico should have been named patron saint of art book publishers.
Bibliography is now so long to get through.
Our task now is to seek out the real Fra Angelico,
to understand how the meaning of his art intersects with the quality of his art,
and how both relate to the great cultural upheaval into which he was born in Florence.
Whatever the actual date of his birth, a detail we may never know for certain,
the approximately 45-year span of Angelico's active career
between about 1410 and his death in 1455
coincides with one of the most fertile and rapidly evolving periods
in the entire historical sweep of Western culture.
Adding in perhaps a hundred years on either side,
we have come to call this period the Italian Renaissance,
and we use that term, meaning rebirth,
revival of the philosophy, literature and art of classical pre-Christian antiquity
to chronicle a movement away from what was supposedly the autocratic faith of the Middle Ages
towards an idealized and supposedly liberating secular enlightenment.
Following this schema, conventional histories of the Renaissance
tend to be descriptions of the progressive triumphs from 1425 onward
of democratic realism and naturalism over the aristocratic and courtly Gothic style,
and they tend to begin with Masaccio and Brunelleschi as their protagonists.
Masaccio, a brilliantly gifted and probably rough-edged young man from the provinces,
was born in 1401 and died in 1428,
having achieved in 27 short years a seismic influence comparable in later generations
only to the accomplishments of Mozart, Keats and Jimi Hendrix.
So large does his profile loom in the historical imagination
that it has become commonplace to assume that where a painting by Masaccio
and one by any other artist share an attitude, an intention or an achievement,
Masaccio by definition got there first.
Fra Angelico was traditionally thought to have been 14 years older than Masaccio.
Vasari claimed he was born in 1387.
Yet his earliest paintings were almost without exception dated after Masaccio's death.
The first document mentioning one was a payment of 1429.
Angelico, therefore, was regarded as a retardateur late bloomer
whose career began at age 42 and followed an unwaveringly derivative course.
The great Italian art historian Roberto Longhi,
in a groundbreaking essay of 1940 that still today provides the foundation
for all study of the opening decades of the Florentine Renaissance,
did try to show that Angelico had an earlier career
that had not up to that point been recognized.
He pushed the dates of Angelico's first artistic efforts back about 10 years
to shortly before 1420.
And he argued that these first efforts proved that the great Masaccio
was even greater and more precocious than had been thought
since Angelico could not have painted such things
if he did not have a now lost work by Masaccio to imitate.
In 1940, the historical facts at Longhi's disposal were fewer and less nuanced
than those available to us today.
Longhi, for instance, still believes that Angelico must have been 30 years old or more
when he produced his very first works.
In other words, that he was anything but precocious.
He did not have access to the documents that would soon be discovered
disproving most of the supposed facts of Angelico's biography.
But his brilliant analytical skills enabled him to intuit
the fallacies on which they were based.
He built a case for the genius of Fra Angelico
and for its appearance at an unexpectedly early date
in order to prove how much greater an intellect must have been his hero, Masaccio.
For Roberto Longhi, the famous Virgin and Child with Saint Anne
from the Church of San D'Ambrogio in Florence, now in Uffizi,
was Masaccio's earliest surviving work,
painted together with his sometime partner Mazzolino around 1424,
when Masaccio was perhaps 23 years old.
Deploying his florid literary style to emphasize
the different levels of both craft and concept
that separated Masaccio's masterful evocation of mass and volume
from the flaccid, decorative contributions supplied by his older partner, Mazzolino,
Longhi argued that the younger painter was responsible
for the convincingly three-dimensional platform of the throne,
the irrevocably seated group of the bandana and child,
and the angel holding the first loop of the cloth of honor on the right,
who is as round and geometrically precise as any work of sculpture.
All the rest, he noted, is by Mazzolino.
The Saint Anne, hoisted somehow or other against the invisible back of a throne,
with a honey-sweet hand so gentle it interferes with the foreshortening,
the two angels at the top and on the left,
the two sensing angels flanking the throne,
weary of being flushed so pink and weary of their sensors swinging.
I should have read that to you in Italian.
Longhi's Italian is impenetrable, but it's even more poetic
than the rather pedantic English translation.
Longhi recognized that a 23-year-old boy,
even one aided by powerful mentors like Brunelleschi or the sculptor Donatello,
could not have arrived at so revolutionary an approach
to two-dimensional image-making,
not to mention so mature a command of technique,
without some sort of prior experience and practice.
He cautioned against trying to discover Mazzaccio as tadpole,
as embryo, amoeba, etc.,
in order to then get him to climb nicely,
respectively, all the biological steps of glory.
This was Longhi's way of dismissing several reckless attributions to Mazzaccio
that had been advanced by German professors, with whom he disagreed,
and Italian colleagues, whom he mistrusted.
Instead, he proposed that if we could only discover, and I quote,
some Florentine painting from the end of the second decade,
in which the light models rather than modulates,
a hand grasps rather than strokes,
a belt clasps rather than adorns,
it would be sure evidence that Mazzaccio has already passed this way.
This was his introduction to Fra Angelico,
whose function was to serve as proof that the teenage Mazzaccio
was already the artist we have come to admire
when we encounter him years later in Distant 1424.
The fly in this elegantly worded ointment
appeared only shortly afterwards,
with the fortuitous discovery of a nearly intact altarpiece dated 1422,
the so-called San Giovanale altarpiece,
at Caccia di Rigello in the fairly remote Florentine provinces.
Its discoverer, Luciano Berti,
did not hesitate to recognize it as a youthful work by Mazzaccio,
a claim immediately rejected by the acolytes of Roberto Longhi,
who recalled the words of their revered mentor warning against
the marvelous hope of being able one day to discover incunabula
of the Mazzaccio of those years of immaturity.
The two parties crossed swords,
and the debate raged on for nearly four decades,
although today I believe that Acceptance of the San Giovanale Triptych
as the earliest known work by Mazzaccio is all but universal.
The difficulty, of course, is that the San Giovanale Triptych,
which reveals a young painter of strong but,
I hope you'll agree with me, relatively crude talents,
a bra, is dated a mere two years earlier
than the putative date of the Virgin and Child with Saint Anne,
not five or even six years earlier.
The implication is that Mazzaccio became almost overnight,
sometime between New Year's Day 1423 and New Year's Day 1424,
the genius at whose feet we all worship,
and that the majestically paced development Longhi assumed
must be lost to us never actually occurred.
So, if Longhi was correct in dating Fra Angelico's beginnings before 1420,
he could not at that time have been inspired by Mazzaccio.
If anything, Longhi may have been too cautious by half a decade or more.
For the first glimmers of Angelico's genius to capture our attention
actually appear in the years between 1411 and 1414.
Longhi could not have pushed himself that far,
since Mazzaccio had just turned ten in 1411
and was barely thirteen years old in 1414.
No one would have accepted arguments for his pervasive influence as a pre-adolescent.
Nevertheless, it is at this moment that we first become aware
that a brilliant new star has arrived on the Florentine artistic scene,
a painter with a pictorial imagination unlike anything that had appeared before this date.
Not surprisingly, the debut occurs within the workshop
where Angelico must have received at least part of his artistic training,
that of another gifted artist who had embraced monastic vows,
the Camaldolese monk and painter Don Lorenzo Monaco.
In February 1414, that artist appended an inscription
to the frame of the largest, most elaborate, and by a considerable margin
the most expensive altarpiece commissioned in Florence at the time.
The Coronation of the Virgin, once installed on the high altar
of the seat of the Camaldolese order in Florence,
Santa Maria degli Angeli, and now in the Galleria degli Uffizi.
I hope you've all seen this picture.
Six small narrative scenes,
surrounded by elaborate embossed in gilt decoration,
fill the predella beneath this towering monument.
The two center scenes portray the nativity and the adoration of the magi.
Two scenes to the left of these and two more to the right
recount episodes from the legend of Saint Benedict.
Two different artists are responsible for this suite of images.
The three left-hand scenes are unmistakably by Lorenzo Monaco.
The nativity, for instance,
is organized with the same calligraphic elegance and compositional wit
as other examples of the same subject by him.
This is the predella of the altarpiece.
This is another painting of the same subject by Lorenzo Monaco,
now at the Metropolitan Museum in New York.
And the Robert Lehman Collection.
While the death of Saint Benedict displays his typical disregard
for the rules of perspectival rendering or architectural accuracy
in the interest of good emotional storytelling.
Notice how the figures clustered around Saint Benedict's beer
grow larger rather than smaller as they move further back from the picture plane.
No doubt so that they can get a better view of the proceedings
over the heads of the monks in front of them.
And the relationship of one architectural surface to another
is impossible to determine.
This wall is supposed to be parallel to this wall
and theoretically it should end at the same place this one does,
but you can't get there from here.
Windows, doorways, corbels and moldings are all drawn freehand
and are meant to be approximate and suggestive rather than convincing.
The three openings in the rear wall
are in fact drawn from two different viewing points.
The center opening is centralized
and the right opening is therefore viewed from the left as it should be.
But the left opening is also viewed inappropriately from the left.
These delightfully naive solacisms do not occur
in the right half of the Santeria degli Angeli Perdella
where all architectural forms are precisely ruled
with compass and straightedge.
Space is constructed lucidly
and with measurable accuracy
and narratives are faultlessly logical.
This scene, for example,
shows two separate stories from the legend of Saint Benedict.
The meeting of Saints Benedict and Scholastica
and the rescue of Saint Placidus by Saint Egedius.
The composition is essentially repeated
from an earlier version of the same two subjects
painted by Lorenzo Monaco in 1407
for the Perdella of a different altarpiece.
The earlier panel is again typical of Lorenzo Monaco's elegant
and casually irrational approach to narrative,
managing to crowd into one relatively small picture field
all the complex elements of two extended stories.
Saint Benedict dines with Saint Scholastica during a hailstorm.
Saint Placidus falls into a pool while filling a pitcher with water.
Saint Benedict, miraculously knowing of his disciple's distress,
sends Saint Egedius to rescue him.
And Egedius miraculously walks on the water
and pulls Placidus up by the fringe of his hair.
There is nothing casually irrational, however,
about the young artist who reimagined these scenes
for the Santeria degli Angeli Perdella six years later.
Rather than place Saint Benedict in front of a chapel
that is somehow to be found outside a church
with a desk floating mysteriously above his lap,
he painted a real monastic cell isolated in the wilderness
inside which Benedict is firmly and comfortably seated.
Placing Benedict inside a real building
while still needing or wishing to paint a highlight on his left shoulder
created a logistical problem,
so the artist cleverly added a small window
to admit the necessary light
and placed an awning above it to keep out the rain.
So easily overlooked and apparently simple
a pictorial device was revolutionary in 1413,
no less so than was depicting the hailstorm
that accompanied Saint Benedict's meeting with Saint Scholastica
as a cascade of real hail emerging from thick dark clouds
and bouncing off roof tiles,
rather than simply as sprays of white dots.
Most astonishing of all is this painter's solution
to the difficulty of justifying the only access to a church
opening directly onto a lake,
as it does in his model by Lorenzo Monaco.
Not only did he add a second doorway
with a step in front of it,
in case the water level rises,
but also he troubled to explain
why a monastery should have been built so close to a lake to begin with.
For Lorenzo Monaco this was simply a convenient device
enabling him to squeeze two essentially unrelated scenes close together.
But for his young apprentice,
every pictorial convenience needed to be rationalized.
A lake, of course, is needed to provide fish
for the brethren to eat on Fridays and during Lent.
Major monasteries not so fortunately endowed by nature
build a large fish pond somewhere on their grounds.
Knowing this, our artist painted a fishing net
tied to an iron ring
affixed to the monastery's outer wall.
It goes without saying that no such detail occurs
in any of the written versions of St. Benedict's life,
nor is it to be found in any other known painted version of this scene.
The same relentless insistence on representational logic,
on optical realism,
characterizes every painting by Fra Angelico
from every period of his wonderfully prolific career.
This exotically beautiful youthful work in Rotterdam
was first attributed to Angelico
and dated around 1418 by Roberto Longhi,
despite its having been heavily and clumsily overpainted when Longhi saw it.
In fact, when I first saw it in Rotterdam, it looked like this.
But it was quite clear that there was something underneath it,
so we persuaded them to send it to New York.
We cleaned it at the Met, and these amazing colors
came out underneath this black-brown overpaint,
as well as losing the golden toast, I think,
didn't make anyone unhappy.
One arm of the Virgin's throne
is longer than the other,
and the pattern decorating the cloth of gold covering it
is denser on the short side than it is on the long side.
Was this a miscalculation and clumsy readjustment?
No.
For example, it is an optical device
indicating that the left arm is more steeply foreshortened than the right,
placing you, the viewer, off-center to the left,
and thereby explaining why the angel at the left
is seen in full profile,
while that at the right stands in three-quarters profile.
A similar device quietly distinguishes
the great Alba Madonna in Madrid,
recently acquired by the Museo del Prado.
This painting, which had been in the Alba collection for 200 years
with a choice shown outside of Casa Alba,
was long known to Renaissance scholars
only through black-and-white photographs of indifferent quality,
and it was frequently dismissed as an imitation of Angelico's style.
When I was first permitted to see it
hanging above a sofa in the Duchess of Alba's drawing room
fifteen years ago,
I was lost in admiration of the purity and depth of its color,
the poetic simplicity of its symmetrical composition,
and the dazzling effects of modeling that the artist achieved
through delicate layers of oil glaze
covering the tempera and gold surfaces.
The deep folds of the Virgin's blue robe
seemed no less solid and tactile
than did the shallow ripples in the cloth of honor
pulled taut behind her by two choirboy angels
with their unforgettable green and red wings,
and their green silk tunics embroidered with gold patterns.
Small, gratuitous,
but humanizing details
like the Virgin's finger
caught in a fold of her cloak
betrayed the hand and mind of Fra Angelico,
confirmed by the barely noticeable difference
in the widths of the decorative gold bands
reaching from the two angels' collars down their chests.
The steeper foreshortening of the band on the left angel,
less wide than its counterpart on the right,
sets the viewer's position off-center to the left,
allowing us more of a view
behind the cloth of honor on that side,
I can't see at this angle, can you?
You can actually see behind the cloth of honor
to the gold ground on that side, not on the other side,
and more of a glimpse of the angel's shoulder and arm.
It also explains how we can see the Virgin's right leg
without needing her to break symmetry
by pivoting on her throne,
allowing us to see the child more nearly frontally
while he perches safely across both his mother's knees.
This is a painting that I first encountered
in the storerooms of the Yale University Art Gallery
not quite 20 years ago,
inventoried there as Anonymous Florentine, 15th century.
It was immediately apparent that this was not one painting,
but a jigsaw mosaic composed of three fragments
from two paintings that would originally have been
the upper sections of the wings of a triptych.
It became apparent that no one but Fra Angelico
could have painted them, but it took me an additional
five years to notice what a conceptual tour de force
the image of the Virgin was.
Angelico painted a white border along the bottom of the panel
as though it were a pavement on which rests
the Virgin's left foot.
Actually, this is not a pavement,
but the roof of a structure cut off from the bottom part
of the triptych wings, preserved today
bearing in mind, then, that the Virgin was intended
to be seen as though seated above eye level.
The artist included a loop of fabric from her blue robe
falling over the front edge of the roof
and showed the hem of her robe, of her red dress,
vanishing behind the roof edge,
obstructed from our line of sight.
Wishing, however, to show the book on her lap open
and the writing on its pages visible,
Angelico needed to find a means of justifying
an implausible angle of vision.
So he created an excuse to raise the Virgin's back leg
in order to tilt her book forward.
That is the only possible explanation for his having added
this minuscule white highlight,
indicating a step entirely hidden beneath her dress,
on which she may prop her right foot.
Not more than a few millimeters in length,
this detail probably went unnoticed by anyone
for nearly 600 years, yet for the young Fra Angelico,
probably in his mid-twenties at the time,
it represented an essential intellectual component
of the scene.
One last example will do for all,
this one from the easily recognized period
of Angelico's maturity.
Or is it so easy to recognize?
25 years ago, I was asked to prepare a catalog
of the Italian paintings in the Isabella Stewart Gardner
Museum in Boston.
Studying this panel portraying the Dormition and Assumption
of the Virgin, I counted 65 published references to it,
predating 1994, only 10 of which,
a paltry 15%, treated the painting
as an autographed work by Fra Angelico.
This seemed to be a case of the old prejudices
asserting themselves, according to which
Angelico was a disaffected spiritualist,
painting lovely singing angels and weeping
otherworldly saints.
Lovely singing angels are to be found here aplenty.
But the astonishing quality of the Gardner Dormition
and Assumption of the Virgin lay not in the otherworldliness
of the saints in its lower scene,
but in their earthy realism.
In barely half of a panel quite small to begin with,
the paintings painted on an intimate scale
are fully individualized, unmistakable one from another.
The cloth of gold coverlet draped over the Virgin's beard
is a breathtaking feat of technical accomplishment.
It is rendered in flat sheets of burnished metal leaf,
patiently engraved, then modeled in translucent glazes
to simulate the pull of a heavy fabric
across the carrier poles,
lightly depressed by the ethereal but nonetheless
human weight of the Virgin's body.
Three of the apostles,
their feet spread and planted firmly on the ground
to brace themselves for their task,
bend to lift the beer with its divine burden.
One of the three grasps his pole with one hand only
and points with the other.
Only by following his gesture
do we come to notice
that the fourth pole of the beer is unmanned.
A fourth apostle, pulling back his cloak
to free his arm, hurries to reach the pole,
lest the Virgin be indecorously tilted,
possibly even spilled from her beer,
while being transported to her sepulcher.
The scene is not silent.
One can hear the pallbearers whispering agitatedly
to each other as St. Peter intones a requiem at the left,
and the other apostles join their voices
in antiphonal response.
The exceptional quality of its execution aside,
St. Peter, 200 years later,
could have animated a sacred image
whose form and content were otherwise rigidly codified
by injecting such touching, vibrantly real
and altogether human notes to this story.
But are we justified in taking a leap
from the revolutionary intellectual achievements
of the first group of works
to the profound accomplishments of the second
simply by asserting that the same artist,
St. Peter, was the one who created them?
The lynchpin connecting them has eluded
even the most determined scholarly searches,
though like the grapes of Tantalus,
it has long been recognized as hovering just out of reach.
In the course of archival research undertaken in 1955,
as part of the commemorations of the 500th anniversary
of the artist's death, two documents were unearthed
that changed everything we thought we knew
about Angelico's early life.
In 1417, he had not yet joined the Dominican order,
but was already a painter.
While it did not provide firm evidence of a date of birth,
it did shrink to zero his supposed quarter century
of contemplative inactivity in Dominican seclusion.
The second document was potentially just as significant,
but in actuality more frustrating.
This was a notice that between 1415 and 1417,
the captains of Orsanmichele,
a charitable confraternity,
in their capacity as executors of the will of Giovanni Ghirardini,
paid the artist Ambrosio di Baldese
for an altarpiece in the chapel of St. John the Baptist
in the church of Santo Stefano al Ponte in Florence.
Ambrosio di Baldese received final payment
for the altarpiece in April 1417,
but some months later,
on 28th of January 1418,
exactly 600 years ago last Sunday,
Guido di Pietro,
the future Fra Angelico,
was paid 5 florins for further unspecified work
on the altarpiece,
work that he had finished by 15th of February
when he received an additional 7 florins as final payment.
12 florins total payment being far too little
for a complete altarpiece,
scholars logically concluded that Angelico
must have been working as an apprentice
for a residual payment for having completed
the older painter's commission,
or for having executed it entirely.
This conclusion could not be verified, however,
as the altarpiece itself was lost,
and in any event no one knew who Ambrosio di Baldese was.
Though the name appears frequently in documents from the period,
no signed or unequivocally identifiable works by him survive.
It was not therefore possible to determine
whether he might have been Angelico's teacher,
or whether his collaborative works by the two painters might survive.
As I said at the beginning of this lecture,
my colleague Karl Strelke at one time expressed the hope
that Richard Feigen's beautiful Head of St. Joseph
might be a surviving fragment of this all-important missing work.
We concluded, however, that the subject was wrong.
We probably needed to be looking for a painting
that featured St. John the Baptist,
yet its scale and probable date
still made it the best available indication
of what the Ghirardini altarpiece must have looked like.
About twenty years ago,
an esteemed Florentine colleague, Sonia Chiodo,
discovered in a small country church outside Greve in Chianti
the remains of the altarpiece
that must originally have been painted
for the Ghirardini chapel in Santo Stefano.
Is that even visible? I apologize.
The painting is hanging several dozen feet up
in a very tiny church.
Boasting a 16th-century provenance
from the Ghirardini family,
and including among its crowd of figures
the three saints most intimately tied to the commission
St. Stephen, patron of the church
in the position of honor at the Virgin's right,
St. John the Baptist, patron of the chapel
and named saint of the donor,
and the rarely-portrayed St. Michael,
patron of the confraternity of our son Michele,
the altarpiece in the document seems incontestable.
The discovery establishes the identity
of the otherwise mysterious Ambrosio di Baldese
named in the document.
He and the anonymous artist conventionally known
as the master of the Strauss Madonna,
the author of these paintings, must be one and the same.
Unfortunately, there is no trace of Angelico's presence
anywhere in this altarpiece, and no evidence in any other work
by the Strauss master, also known as Ambrosio di Baldese,
to do with each other.
Sonia Chiodo suggested that perhaps Angelico
had been responsible for some painted part
of the now-missing frame, such as a predella
or small standing saints in the side pilasters.
That suggestion proves to be worth investigating more closely,
though not perhaps in the straightforward way
Dr. Chiodo might have intended.
Since the receipt for reimbursement to Ambrosio di Baldese
in April 1417 specified that it was final payment,
and the work on the altarpiece was complete,
we really are not free to imagine that Angelico
collected an additional 12 florins less than a year later
for finishing his partner's project.
What if Ambrosio di Baldese was not his partner,
and Angelico was paid instead for changing the altarpiece,
not completing it?
Under what circumstances could such a hypothetical scenario
have played out, and what forensic clues would we need
to seek either to bolster or demolish such an argument?
Examples of artistic alterations in the 15th century
are common, and typically stem from one of three motives.
The most noticeable, because it involves
the most radical transformations,
was an urge to update an outmoded painting format,
to turn a Gothic altarpiece with pointed arches
into a Renaissance altarpiece that fits inside
a rectangular frame.
This painting is at the Metropolitan Museum.
But this is hardly likely to have been the case
with the Ghirardini altarpiece, as only nine months
separate Ambrosio di Baldese's final and Angelico's
initial payments.
A second motive was repairing damage.
Angelico himself was hired for this sort of
free-form restoration only slightly later,
when he repainted this small panel of St. Jerome
in the wilderness, now in the Princeton University
Art Museum, to correct gilding and paint loss
from the port, having warped and shattered
its engaged frame.
It is possible that Ambrosio di Baldese's
altarpiece for the Ghirardini chapel had been
accidentally damaged very shortly after completion.
But it is difficult to see any evidence of this
from the surviving panels now engraving.
The third motive for remaking a work of art
in the early Renaissance was the desire or need
to change its iconography, its meaning.
Is it conceivable that the Ghirardini altarpiece
It is reasonable to suppose that the predella
of the altarpiece contains scenes from the life
of St. John the Baptist or St. Stephen, or both.
Is it conceivable that the captains of Orsanmichele,
who paid for the work, preferred to have their
own patron saint memorialized?
St. Michael appears among the crowd of saints
in the main panels of the altarpiece, to be sure,
to reassert the saint's prominence in this commission
by rededicating the predella to him?
These questions would be pointlessly hypothetical
were it not for the discovery, in storage here
at the Yale University Art Gallery, under my nose
for twenty years and I never saw it, of a painting
that I believe to be a damaged early work by Frangelico,
and that could answer to this bizarre combination
of circumstantial events.
The painting is clearly part of a predella.
There are two scenes, neither of which is commonly
represented, either in the Renaissance or at any
other period, and may need elucidation.
At the right is a miracle associated with the
first apparition of St. Michael the Archangel,
as recounted in the 14th century compendium of
the lives of the saints, known as the Golden Legend,
written by Jacobus da Varagine.
St. Michael, we are told, first appeared on
Mount Gargano in Apulia.
This man, who had sheep and cattle beyond counting,
grazed his herds on the flanks of the mountain.
It happened one day that one bull separated himself
from the rest and climbed to the top of the mountain.
When the bull's absence was discovered,
the landowner mustered a band of his people to
track it up the mountain trails, and they finally
found the animal standing in the mouth of a cave
at the top. The owner, annoyed at the bull
for having wandered off alone, aimed a poisoned
arrow at it, but the arrow came back, as if
turned about by the wind, and struck the one
who had launched it. This dismayed the townsmen,
and they went to the bishop and asked him what
he thought of the strange occurrence.
The bishop admonished them to direct their
questions to God. They did, and St. Michael
appeared to the bishop and said,
Know that it was by my will that the man was
struck by his arrow.
I am the Archangel Michael, and I have chosen
to dwell in that place on earth and keep it safe.
The bishop and the townspeople formed a procession
and went to the cave, but, not presuming to enter,
stood around the entrance praying.
The miracle of the bull and the Episcopal procession
both appear in the painting, where a church
surrounded by a fortified wall and tower has
been erected on the site of the cave.
This may be an image of the actual shrine of
St. Michael on Mount Gargano, since the same
building, seen from the opposite side, appears
in an illustrated pilgrimage roll dated 1417
that was painted in part by Fra Angelico.
This fragment of the roll is now in the
Houghton Library at Harvard.
The second apparition of St. Michael occurred
at a place we know today as Mount Mont Saint-Michel
on the coast of Normandy in northern France,
where the archangel again revealed himself to
the bishop and ordered that a church be built
there in his honor.
According to Jacopo Stavaragini, the mountain
on which St. Michael's church was built is
surrounded on all sides by the ocean, but twice
on the saint's feast day, which, by the way,
is 16th of October, a path is opened to allow
the people to walk over.
One such day, when a large throng was crossing
to the church, it happened that a woman who
was pregnant with St. Michael's child was
carried with them. Then the tide came in with
a rush and the crowd, terrified, made for the
shore, but the pregnant woman could not move
fast enough and was caught by the waves.
The archangel Michael, however, kept her
unharmed, in such a way that she brought forth
her son in the welter of the sea and nursed
him there in her arms. Then the waters again
opened a path for her and she walked joyfully
over the throngs fleeing the tide and imagined
the mountaintop as disconcertingly close to
sea level, but as otherwise, to the best of
my knowledge, the only known representation
of this singular miracle of St. Michael.
My colleague Irma Passeri, first called my
attention to this remarkable panel, pointed
out to me three highly significant peculiarities
about it. First, impressions of a punched
halo are distinctly visible beneath the figure
of the newborn child in the left scene.
Can you see these dots, like a circle?
And another similarly appears beneath the
archer's forward hand in the right scene.
These even still have remnants of gold in
them. These are remnants of earlier scenes
that were completely obliterated before
painting the present images. Not only were
these areas once gilt, but also the punch
strikes decorating the halos pressed so
deeply into the gesso ground beneath them
that they were not completely filled by the
new surface prepared for the later images.
Second, along the perimeter of both scenes,
in visible and raking light, you can see
are scraping marks in the gesso underlayer,
tapering and becoming shallower as they
approach the edges of the painted field.
The artist scraped away the original
paintings from the center outward, taking
pains to save the gilded frame moldings
and the decorative gold band dividing the
two scenes, since gold was far too expensive
to replace unless absolutely necessary.
These ghostly images on the sides, at the
left, are not pentimenti, initial thoughts
abandoned by an artist and covered over
with layers of paint that with time grow
thinner and more transparent. They are
surviving relics of the first scene, not
completely scraped away by the second
artist. They suggest the typical Gothic
fantasies of emblematic architecture
employed by nearly every Florentine artist,
including Ambrosio di Baldese, in the early
years of the 15th century. The brilliantly
rational structure that we now see atop
them is one of the many clues pointing to
the possibility that the artist asked to
repaint the scene with a story of St.
Michael may have been the young Frangelico.
Where does all this leave us? There is no
proof, in the form of fingerprints or a
signature, either that Ambrosio di Baldese
first worked on this panel or that
Frangelico changed it. All we have is
evidence that fits a hypothesis suggested
by one of a number of possible
interpretations of an open-ended document.
Could the images originally painted on
this panel and then so painstakingly
scraped off have shown either the
painting or the painting itself? We will
never know. Could this predella have been
attached to Ambrosio di Baldese's
altarpiece, now engraved in Chianti?
Plausibly. It is very suggestive that
each scene in the painting is exactly one
centimeter different in width than the
lateral panels of that altarpiece. But
again, there is no physical evidence that
could prove or disprove the point. We
have been told by students that in art
history, questions matter a great deal
more than answers. The available supply
of surviving works of art and of original
documents concerning them is so paltry
that in many cases answers may never
materialize. But if we put our energy
into getting the questions right, we
will move much further and much faster
along the path of discovery that leads
to inquiry. Thank you.