Chapter 17-Yuan Shu's Imperial Dream
Masterpiece Audio
5 followers
1 Video View·Oct 27, 2025
Romance of the 3 Kingdoms Chapter 17-Yuan Shu's Imperial Dream
Yuan Shu in Huainan. Now this area was rich, right? Land, grain.
Absolutely. Plenty of resources. But the real kicker, the thing that really sets him on this
path to thinking emperor, it's getting his hands on Sun Tzu's imperial jade seal. That was a huge
symbol of legitimacy. Right, the seal. But was that enough? I mean, why did he feel justified
just taking power like that? Well, that's the core question, isn't it? He actually got his
advisors together, called a big meeting, and laid out his case. He basically argued, look,
the Han dynasty's run its course 400 years, chaos everywhere. And his family, the Yuan family,
they were famous. Four generations, three excellencies, meaning they'd held the absolute
top government posts for, well, generations. So he argued, who better? It was almost presented
as a duty. Okay, so family prestige is part one. But you mentioned prophecy. He didn't just rely
on the family name. He thought he had, what, divine backing? Oh, completely. He leaned into
it hard. He claimed his surname, Yuan, which came from Chen, descended from the Great Shun,
an ancient sage-king fit this cosmological pattern. Earth-supporting fire, he said. It
aligned with fate, destiny. Earth-supporting fire. Okay. And even more specific than that,
he brought up this well-known prophecy. The one to replace Han is Deng Tu Gao. Deng Tu Gao. Right.
And here's the connection he made. His own courtesy name was Gong Lu,
Olu, which sounds very much like and can be interpreted as High Road Galu or Deng Tu Gao.
Ah, so he's saying the prophecy, it's literally about me.
Exactly. It's this blend of political ambition with finding signs, mystical or otherwise,
that seem to point right at you. We see this again and again in history,
people fitting prophecies to their own goals. But surely not everyone just nodded along.
His own principal clerk, Zhe Xiang, apparently spoke up.
He did. Quite bravely. Zhe Xiang basically said, hold on. He pointed out that even the
really virtuous Zhu Dynasty founders, they served the later Shang Dynasty, the Yin,
even when it was decadent. And the Han, okay, it had problems, but it wasn't nearly as tyrannical
as the Yin were at their end. How did Yuan Shu take that advice?
Badly. Very badly. This really shows his character. He wasn't looking for a debate.
He flew into a rage, threatened execution for anyone else who dared question him, and then boom,
declared himself emperor right then and there. Founded the Zhongshi Dynasty.
Zhongshi. What does that mean? Ironically, it means the dynasty of loyalty,
which is quite something for a guy actively rebelling against the emperor he supposedly
owed loyalty to. Wow. Okay.
And he didn't just say it. He did it. Set up all the government offices, got himself a fancy
dragon and phoenix imperial carriage, performed the state sacrifices, even named his empress
and crown prince, full imperial setup. Having a good story, pedigree, even prophecy,
it fuels ambition. But how you handle disagreement, that reveals a lot. His instant shutdown of
descent feels like a major red flag. A huge one. It points to a real
brittleness under that confident exterior, a weakness right at the core of his claim.
All right. So he's emperor in his own mind, got the titles, the carriage, but the path to war,
specifically with Lu Bu, starts kind of strangely, doesn't it? With a marriage proposal.
Yeah. It's almost comical if it weren't so serious. He wanted Lu Bu's daughter to marry
his son, the newly minted crown prince, a political alliance, basically.
Makes sense. So what went wrong? Well, the wheels came off pretty quick.
Yuan Shu found out that Lu Bu had sent Han Yin, who was a key go-between in all this,
over to Cao Cao. And Cao Cao, seeing an opportunity, promptly executed Han Yin.
Ouch. So Lu Bu sending the envoy essentially got him killed by Cao Cao.
Exactly. And Yuan Shu saw this as a huge betrayal. Not only did the marriage alliance collapse,
but Lu Bu had, in his eyes, conspired with his enemy Cao Cao, leading to his envoy's death.
This enraged Yuan Shu. It was a massive insult to his new imperial status. War was declared.
Okay. So the failed diplomacy, the perceived betrayal that lights the fuse. And Yuan Shu
doesn't exactly respond cautiously, does he? He goes big.
Big is an understatement. Yeah.
He appoints Zhang Sun as his grand general and pulls together this absolutely enormous army.
We're talking over 200,000 troops. 200,000. Just wow.
I mean, the scale itself tells you how confident Yuan Shu felt, or at least how confident he
wanted to appear. And the resources he could command in Huainan, he didn't just throw them
all in one blob either. He split them up. Seven distinct routes, each with its own commander,
its own target. Marching 50 leagues a day. What's that? Maybe 15 miles? And explicitly
ordered to plunder as they went. Pay their own way, basically.
That sounds like a recipe for chaos, maybe. But let's break down those seven routes,
because understanding that setup is crucial for seeing how Lu Bu could possibly counter it.
Absolutely. It was meant to be overwhelming. A multi-pronged assault to just swamp Lu Bu.
Let's see. First route, Grand General Zhang Sun himself, heading straight for Lu Bu's main base
in Zhu Zhu. Second route, Cao Rui targeting Xiao Pei, another key city. Third route,
Chen Ji aiming for Yidu. Fourth route, Lei Bo pushing towards Langya. Fifth route,
Chen Lan marching on Jishi. Sixth route, Han Jian heading for Xiao Pei. And the seventh route,
Yang Feng targeting Jun Shan. That covers a lot of ground,
basically hitting him from everywhere. Completely surrounds the territory.
And logistics, he appointed a guy named Jin Shang as Grand Marshal to handle supplies.
But Jin Shang actually refused the job. Refused? Why? Did he think it was a bad idea?
Maybe. Or maybe he just didn't want to be associated with a rebellion. Whatever the
reason, Yuan Shu wasn't having it. Jin Shang was executed on the spot. Ruthless.
So loyalty is enforced by fear.
Seems that way. Ji Ling then got the job supervising supplies for all seven routes.
And just to add more weight, Yuan Shu himself led a reserve force of 30,000 troops following behind.
Overwhelming force looks impressive on paper. But if it's held together by fear,
like executing anyone who hesitates, there might be cracks under the surface.
That ruthlessness could backfire.
It absolutely could. And it hints at the kind of internal problems,
the potential disloyalty that someone clever might be able to exploit.
Which brings us right to Lu Bu's situation.
Right. So Lu Bu sees this monster army, seven spearheads coming right at him. He calls his
advisors together. He's got Chen Nong, who's been with him a while, and this father-son pair,
Chen Gi and Chen Deng. What's the mood like?
Panic. At least initially from Chen Gong. Faced with this overwhelming invasion,
Chen Gong actually suggests something pretty drastic. He says, look, this whole mess,
it's probably Chen Deng's fault somehow. Let's just kill them, offer their heads to Yuan Shu.
Maybe that'll calm him down.
Whoa. Blame your own advisors. That's desperate. Did Lu Bu go for it?
For a moment, yeah. Lu Bu, probably panicking himself, actually ordered them arrested.
But Chen Deng, the son, he showed incredible nerve. Instead of begging for his life, he just-
Laughed in the face of execution.
Called Lu Bu a coward, basically. And then he delivered that amazing line about Yuan Shu's
massive army, dismissed it as seven piles of rotten grass.
Rotten grass. Not exactly respectful of 200,000 soldiers.
It wasn't about respect. It was about insight. He wasn't just being defiant. He used the term
a disorganized rabble, literally like a flock of crows just thrown together.
He saw past the sheer numbers to their lack of real cohesion, discipline, and genuine loyalty.
Okay. So Chen Deng isn't just brave. He's sharp. He sees a weakness others miss.
Did he have a plan beyond just insulting the enemy?
Oh, did he ever. He didn't just offer a way to survive the invasion. He offered Lu Bu a plan
to actually turn the tables and capture Yuan Shu himself.
Capture the emperor? How? What was this audacious strategy?
His insight was key. Yes, the army is huge, but it's that disorganized rabble. Unreliable.
Untrustworthy. So he proposed a two-part military approach. Defend key points with irregular troops,
hold the line, but win the battle using qibang, surprise forces, or unconditional tactics.
Okay. Standard defense, surprise attack. But where do the surprise forces come from?
Ah, this is the genius part. It wasn't about Lu Bu's own troops. Chen Deng identified the
weak links within Yuan Shu's own command structure, Han Xian and Yang Feng.
The commanders of the Sixth and Seventh Routes. Why them specifically?
Because Chen Deng knew their background. They were former Han imperial officers. They'd actually
fought against rebels before, then sort of fell out with Cao Cao,
and ended up reluctantly serving Yuan Shu. Chen Deng figured they probably felt undervalued,
maybe even resentful of serving this new self-proclaimed emperor. He called them potential
internal allies. Turn Yuan Shu's own generals against him? Clever. How did he propose doing
that? He suggested sending them a secret letter. Better yet, he volunteered to go speak to Han
Xian directly. He went to Han Xian's camp and laid it out. Reminded him of his past service
to the legitimate Han dynasty. Pointed out that serving a rebel like Yuan Shu basically cancelled
out all his past honors. And crucially, he played on fear too. He warned Han Xian,
look, Yuan Shu is suspicious. He just killed Jin Sheng for disagreeing. Once you're no longer
useful, or if he even thinks you might be wavering, he'll get rid of you too.
So appeal to past loyalty and future self-preservation.
Exactly. Han Xian saw the logic. He felt trapped serving Yuan Shu anyway, and this offered a
potential path back into the good graces of the Han court, or at least away from Yuan Shu's
paranoia. He agreed. The plan was set. When Lu Bu's forces lit a signal fire, Han Xian and Yang
Feng would turn their troops around and attack Yuan Shu's army from within.
Brilliant. Internal betrayal coordinated with an external defense. Was that the whole plan?
Almost. One more piece. Zhen Deng also suggested bringing Lu Bei into the mix
as an external ally. Get him to apply pressure from another direction.
Lu Bei. Weren't he and Lu Bu sort of frenemies at best?
They had a very complicated history, yes. But needs must. Lu Bu, seeing the brilliance
of Zhen Deng's overall plan, immediately agreed. He sent off a report to Xucheng,
that's Cao Cao's capital, maybe hoping for official sanction or at least goodwill.
And he sent a letter asking Lu Bei, who was in nearby Yusu, for help. Zhen Deng then
personally went back to Han Xian to finalize the details of the internal betrayal.
Lu Bu, he didn't just react, he orchestrated, really. It was a bit of a masterclass in
defensive strategy. He didn't meet Yuan Shu with just one force. No,
he split his army into five distinct routes.
Oh, routes. Okay.
Yeah. So you had General Gao Xun sent off to Little Pei to deal with Cao Rui.
Chen Gong, he led troops to Yidu against Chen Ji. Then Zhang Liao and Zhang Ba,
they went to Lanya to face Lei Bo.
Song Xin and Wei Xu headed to Jishi to engage Chen Lan. And then Lu Bu himself took the main
road, directly challenging Yuan Shu's main commander, Zhang Xun.
Wow, that's incredibly specific. So each of these generals had, what, 10,000 soldiers?
That's right, 10,000 each. And then the rest stayed back to guard the city.
And Lu Bu, showing his confidence, I suppose, set up his own camp, a full 30-line,
that's what, about 15 kilometers, maybe nine miles outside the city. Pretty bold.
Very bold. So what happens when Zhang Xun gets there, sees Lu Bu's setup? Did he just charge in?
No, not at all. Zhang Xun looked at Lu Bu's force,
assessed the situation, and basically realized, okay, this guy's strong. So instead of attacking
right away, he actually retreated 20-line a loop, played it safe, planning to wait for reinforcement.
Cautious. But did that caution help him? It sounds like maybe it played into Lu Bu's hands.
It certainly seems that way, because the real game-changer, the big twist,
happens during the night. Tell us about the second watch of the night.
Right, this is where it gets messy with alliances. Suddenly, Han Xian and Yang Feng pop up. Now,
these guys were supposedly allied with Yuan Shu. Supposedly, yeah. But what do they do? They
actually start helping Lu Bu. They set fires, create chaos, and basically open the gates for
Lu Bu's army to pour into Zhang Xun's camp. So a planned orderly retreat just dissolves into,
well, chaos, all because of a betrayal from within Yuan Shu's own side.
Exactly. What did that mean for Zhang Xun's troops immediately?
Oh, complete disaster. Total disarray. Zhang Xun was quickly defeated and had to flee.
It just goes to show, you know, internal problems, betrayals, can be way more
devastating than a direct attack sometimes. Especially when you don't see it coming.
True. And Lu Bu, he wasn't the type to just let someone get away, was he?
Not a chance. He chased Zhang Xun relentlessly.
And meanwhile, Ji Ling, who was actually coming to reinforce Zhang Xun...
Oh, the reinforcements arrived?
May arrive, yes, but too late and into a bad situation. He gets hit by a two-pronged attack
from Lu Bu's forces, who are again helped by Han Xin and Yang Feng. Ji Ling is defeated pretty
quickly, too. Wow. So Yuan Shu's whole plan is just crumbling.
It's crumbling fast. But the drama isn't over. As Yuan Shu's forces are reeling back,
trying to escape, something else happens. What's that?
Suddenly, from behind a mountain, another force appears, cutting off Yuan Shu's retreat
and leading them. None other than Guan Yu.
Guan Yu. Okay, that's a major interest.
Huge. And according to the accounts, he just points and shouts,
Rebel, do you not surrender? Classic Guan Yu.
Huh. I can almost picture it. What does Yuan Shu do? He must have been panicking.
Totally panicked. He just fled. His day was going from bad to worse.
Seriously?
Yeah.
So Yuan Shu's on the run. Does Lu Bu catch up with him personally at some point?
He does. Lu Bu keeps up the chase and eventually confronts Yuan Shu directly.
The sources paint quite a picture. Yuan Shu decked out in golden armor and wielding two swords.
Very regal, even in defeat. Trying to keep up appearances, maybe?
Perhaps. But he's furious, and he lashes out at Lu Bu verbally,
calling him a master-betraying slave. Ouch. That's a deep cut for Lu Bu,
given his history. How does Lu Bu take that? He doesn't flinch. He just thrusts his halberd
forward. Yuan Shu's general, Li Feng, tries to block with a spear, but the sources say in less
than three bouts Li Feng gets wounded in the hand. He turns and flees.
And that's the breaking point for Yuan Shu's army?
Completely. It just collapses. Lu Bu's forces surge forward, capturing tons of horses,
armor, supplies. A major haul. But Yuan Shu still isn't totally out of the woods, is he?
Not quite. He manages to get away, but after just a few, who intercepts him again?
Let me guess. Guan Yu.
Guan Yu again. He hits Yuan Shu's remaining forces hard, inflicts really heavy losses.
This time, Yuan Shu has no choice but to retreat definitively,
all the way back to his base in Huainan. Guan Yu made sure the message was received.
Absolutely hammer home. So, Lu Bu returns to Zhu Zhu victorious. What happens next?
Celebrations?
Oh yeah, a big victory feast. Lu Bu hosts Guan Yu, Yang Feng, Han Xin, rewards his troops.
He's clearly feeling pretty good about his position.
But Guan Yu doesn't stick around, does he?
No. True to form, Guan Yu leaves the very next day. His participation was specific.
He wasn't there to become Lu Bu's long-term ally, it seems.
Right, his own agenda, always. So, with Guan Yu gone,
Lu Bu has these other two, Han Xin and Yang Feng, who helped him. What's his plan for them?
Well, his first thought is, okay, let's keep these guys here in Zhu Zhu.
You know, strengthen his core power base. Makes sense on the surface.
Seems logical. But his advisor, Chen Gui, steps in with different advice.
Yes, and it's really insightful counsel. Chen Gui argues against keeping them in Zhu's.
Oh? Why?
His idea is much more expansive. He suggests appointing Han Xin, as governor of Yudu,
and Yang Feng, as governor of Langya, basically, send them out to govern territories nearby.
Okay, so delegate power outwards. What's the logic?
The strategic thinking is brilliant, really. Chen Gui figures that by doing this,
Lu Bu could potentially bring the entire Shandong region under his influence within about a year.
It's about expanding control through strategic placement, not just hoarding allies close by.
Yeah, that's thinking several moves ahead, using allies to project power rather than just defend
it. But Chen Gui's own son, Chen Dang, apparently had some questions about this.
He did. Later, in private, Chen Dang asked his father, basically,
why didn't we just keep Han and Yang here? We could have used them to get rid of Lu Bu eventually,
you know, kill the problem at the root.
So Chen Dang saw Lu Bu himself as the long-term danger. What did his father say?
And this is a key moment, I think. Chen Gui's answer is profound. He says,
if they assist Lu Bu, it is like adding claws and teeth to a tiger.
Wow. So even though they help now,
empowering them alongside Lu Bu just makes Lu Bu more dangerous in the future.
Precisely. It's this incredibly clear-eyed assessment of power dynamics.
Don't strengthen someone who is already a formidable, ambitious figure,
even if they're currently useful. The danger they represent just grows.
That's a powerful lesson. Okay, so while Lu Bu is dealing with these strategic calculations,
what's happening with the loser, Yuan Shu, back in Huainan? He must be fuming.
Oh, absolutely humiliated and desperate for revenge. His first move,
he sends an envoy straight to Jiangdong, to Sun Tzu, asking for troops.
He asks Sun Tzu for help after everything. How does Sun Tzu respond to that?
Predictably, Sun Tzu is furious. He basically lays it all out.
You stole my father's jade seal. You illegally declared yourself emperor.
You betrayed the Han dynasty. He's completely indignant.
So no troops then?
No troops is putting it mildly. Sun Tzu doesn't just refuse,
he practically threatens to attack Yuan Shu himself.
Okay, so that door slams shut. How does Yuan Shu react to Sun Tzu's refusal?
Predictably again, Yuan Shu flies into a rage. His first instinct is,
fine, I'll attack Sun Tzu then.
Trading one enemy for another.
Seems like it. But thankfully for him, maybe, his chief clerk,
a guy named Yang Da, strongly advises against it.
He talks Yuan Shu down, prevents another conflict from kicking off immediately.
Smart move by Yang Da. Meanwhile, Sun Tzu isn't just sitting around, is he?
He kind of expects Yuan Shu might react badly.
Exactly. Sun Tzu, anticipating trouble, starts fortifying the Jianghu, the river mouth.
He's preparing his defenses. And right around this time, something else happens.
An envoy arrives from Cao Cao.
Cao Cao enters the picture. What's the message?
Cao Cao appoints Sun Tzu as the prefect of Kuaiji and,
more importantly, officially orders him to attack Yuan Shu.
Ah, so now Sun Tzu has imperial backing, or at least Cao Cao's backing,
to do what he maybe wanted to do anyway. Does he jump right in?
He considers it. But again, wise counsel prevails. His own chief clerk, Zhang Zhao, steps in.
Another prudent advisor. What's his take?
Zhang Zhao points out, look, Yuan Shu might be defeated,
but he still has a lot of soldiers, a lot of supplies. He's not a pushover.
Even now. Attacking him alone could still be risky.
Okay. Makes sense. So what's the alternative strategy Zhang Zhao proposes?
It's quite clever. He suggests Sun Tzu right back to Cao Cao,
encourage Cao Cao to launch a major southern campaign against Yuan Shu,
and position Sun Tzu's attack as a supporting move from the southeast.
Ah, coordinate the attacks. What's the advantage there?
Mutual support. If either Cao Cao or Sun Tzu gets into trouble,
the other can potentially help out. It basically guarantees Yuan Shu is caught in a pincer,
makes his defeat much more certain, and it's safer for both attackers.
It turns a potential risk into a coordinated grander alliance.
Ensuring Yuan Shu can't focus his forces on just one enemy.
Exactly. And Sun Tzu sees the wisdom in this. He agrees, sends the message to Cao Cao,
and sets the stage for this larger coordinated campaign against Yuan Shu.
Cao Cao returns to Zudu after a pretty tough campaign.
What's the first thing he does? What does that tell us?
Right. And it's quite revealing because
it's not maybe what you'd first expect from someone often painted as just ruthless.
He immediately mourns his general, Dian Wei. Sets up a memorial. But beyond that,
he takes Dian Wei's son, Dian Man, into his own household, appoints him as Zhong Lang.
That's a mid-level officer rank. This isn't just, you know, being nice.
It's a master class in building loyalty. Cao Cao got it. That genuine care,
even symbolic like mourning, builds a stronger bond with his troops than just military strength.
Hmm. That loyalty. Crucial.
Absolutely.
And that bond. It gets tested almost right away, doesn't it? New reports start coming in.
Sun Tzu sends a letter, a warning. And then really urgent news. Yuan Shu.
He's facing a massive grain shortage and he's started looting Qianlu.
Yeah. Which presents Cao Cao with, well, both an opportunity and a kind of necessity. He has to act.
So he decides to launch this huge southern campaign.
And when we say huge, how big are we talking?
We're talking formidable. 170,000 infantry and cavalry.
Supported by over a thousand supply carts. It's a major undertaking. He leaves Cao Ren,
a trusted general to guard the capital, Su Du. And then he sends out envoys. Smart move.
To try and secure alliances with Sun Tzu, Lu Bei, and the ever unpredictable Lu Bu.
Okay. So the campaign kicks off and it gets dramatic fast.
Yeah.
As Cao Cao's forces get near Yuzu, Lu Bei comes out to meet them. And he's not empty-handed,
is he? He brings, well, two separate heads, Han Xian and Yang Feng.
What's Cao Cao's play here? Does he, like, condemn Lu Bei for this pretty brutal move?
You might think so, but no. This is where you see Cao Cao's pragmatism just shine through.
Lu Bei explains the situation. Lu Bu had put these guys, Han Xian and Yang Feng,
in charge of Yudu and Langya. But they were basically bandits terrorizing the locals,
looting.
Okay.
So Lu Bei sets a trap, invites them to a feast, pretends it's about discussing affairs,
gives a signal of throne cup, and Guan Yu and Zong Fei, his sworn brothers, they kill them.
Just like that?
Just like that. Lu Bei takes control of their troops. And then he presents the heads to Cao
Cao, sort of saying, punish me if you must.
But Cao Cao?
Cao Cao praises him, calls it a great service to the state. He sees the bigger picture
immediately. Two troublemakers gone, their troops now under a potential ally, and he didn't have
to lift a finger or spend any resources.
Right. Turning a potential problem into an advantage. Classic Cao Cao.
Exactly. He's consolidating power even through the actions of others.
So Lu Bei's on board. But then there's Lu Bu. Notoriously difficult.
How does Cao Cao handle him when they meet at the Zuzu border?
Ah, Lu Bu. Yeah, Cao Cao really shows his diplomatic chops here. He doesn't come in
heavy handed. He uses kind words, flatters him a bit, and then offers him something concrete.
The prestigious title of Left General. It's a hiring.
Left General, okay.
And crucially, he promises him the official seal for it when they get back to the capital.
That legitimizes the whole thing.
And Lu Bu buys it.
Reportedly, Lu Bu is delighted. Cao Cao understands that even a temporary alliance
with someone as powerful and, frankly, dangerous as Lu Bu is vital for this campaign's success.
He's playing the political game just as much as the military one.
So the alliances are set. Kind of shaky maybe, but set. What's the battle formation look like?
It's pretty impressive on paper. Lu Bu's army holds the left flank, Lu Bei's army,
the right flank. And right in the center, Cao Cao's main force, that massive 170,000
with Xiaodan and Yujin as the vanguards, the spear tip.
Okay, so the stage is set for the confrontation with Yuan Shu.
What happens when Yuan Shu hears this massive ally force is coming?
Well, Yuan Shu learns about Cao Cao's approach and he sends out his own general,
Qiao Rui, with a vanguard force. About 50,000 troops.
50,000. Still a lot of soldiers.
It is, but they meet Cao Cao's vanguard, led by Xiaodan, at the border near Shaoxin.
And the fight is incredibly quick.
How quick?
Xiaodan reportedly kills Qiao Rui in less than three bouts of combat, three exchanges.
Wow, that's decisive.
Utterly. Qiao Rui's forces just collapse, routed. They flee back into the city of Shaoxin.
So Yuan Shu's initial defense is just shattered. His situation sounds pretty bad.
It's desperate. Think about it. You've got Sun Ci attacking from the west,
Lu Bu from the east, Lu Bei with Guan and Zhang from the south.
And Cao Cao's 170,000 hammering from the north.
Exactly. He's completely surrounded. His general, Yang, gives him some grim advice.
What's the advice?
Yang basically says, look, don't fight them head on.
Shaoxin's suffered years of drought, famine. The people are resentful.
The defenses aren't what they should be. His suggestion, leave a large garrison,
maybe 100,000 troops, to hold the city for as long as possible.
Sacrifice the city, essentially.
Pretty much. While Yuan Shu himself, with his imperial guard and all the treasure,
escapes across the Huai River to safety. Preserve the core, even if you lose the base.
Does Yuan Shu take that advice?
He does. He leaves four generals, Li Feng, Li Yu, Liang Gang, and Chen Ji,
with that large force to defend Shaoxin while he makes his getaway.
Okay, so Yuan Shu himself is gone, but a large force remains.
This leads to the siege of Shaoqin. And this is where things get really interesting and dark.
Very dark. Because now, Cao Cao has this massive army,
170,000 mouths to feed every single day.
In the surrounding area.
Ravaged by drought, can't provide enough supplies. The siege drags on for over a month.
Li Feng and the defenders, they just refuse to come out and fight. They're hunkering down.
So supplies start running critically low.
Critically low. Cao Cao even borrows a huge amount of grain, 100,000 Hu from Sun Tze.
Remember, a Hu is about 20 liters. That's 2 million liters of grain.
A massive loan.
Huge. But it's still not enough. The granary official, Wang Hao,
comes to Cao Cao and basically says, we're almost out. The men are starting to grumble.
This is a nightmare scenario for a commander, isn't it?
Yeah.
An army on the verge of starvation, potentially mutiny.
It's the ultimate pressure point. Logistics win wars or lose them.
What do you do when your army might turn on you because they're starving?
What is Cao Cao's first move? His initial solution?
His first instruction to Wang Hao is clever, but temporary.
He says, basically, use smaller measuring cups when you distribute the remaining grain.
Make it seem like there's more. Stretch it out. Buy some time.
Wang Hao must have been nervous about that. What about the soldier's reaction?
Oh, he was. Wang Hao warns Cao Cao, says, the soldiers will resent this.
They'll know they're being shorted. But Cao Cao just tells him, I have my own plan. Don't worry.
Okay. Famous last words, maybe. What happens next?
Well, just as Wang Hao predicted, the soldiers start complaining.
Loudly. Across all the camps, the word spreads.
The chancellor is cheating us out of our rations.
The move must be turning ugly.
Very ugly. So, Cao Cao secretly summons Wang Hao again.
And he tells him, quite calmly, I need to borrow something from you to quiet the masses.
Borrow something. What does Wang Hao say?
Wang Hao asks, what is it you need to borrow?
And Cao Cao's answer?
Chilling. He says, I wish to borrow your head to show the public.
Wow. Wow. How does Wang Hao react?
He's stunned, obviously. Protests his innocence. I've done nothing wrong.
And Cao Cao acknowledges it. He says, I know you are innocent.
He admits it.
Yes. He says, but if I don't kill you, the army will mutiny. It's you or the campaign, basically.
After your death, he promises, I will take care of your wife and children. Don't worry.
And before Wang Hao can even argue further.
He's executed. Swiftly, his head is put on a pole.
And the notice.
A notice is posted, accusing Wang Hao of stealing grain
and using small measures, pinning the whole thing on him.
That is brutally pragmatic. Horrifying, really. Did it work?
It's a horrifying gamble, isn't it? But yes, it worked.
The soldiers' anger now had a target. They believed the official story.
Their immediate grievance was seemingly addressed. And the potential mutiny just dissolved.
So he sacrificed an innocent man to save his army and his campaign.
Precisely. It's a stark example of crisis psychology redirecting anger.
It's dark, morally deeply ambiguous.
But from a purely strategic viewpoint in that moment, it stabilized his army.
OK, I need a moment with that one. That's extreme.
It is. It shows the lengths leaders might go to under impossible pressure.
So with morale restored, albeit through terrifying means,
what's Cao Cao's next move regarding Shoushan itself?
He doesn't waste the opportunity. He immediately issues a harsh new order.
Breach the city walls within three days.
Failure means execution for the commanders.
He's doubling down on the ruthlessness.
Absolutely. And he leads from the front.
He personally supervises the work, like filling in the moats.
There's an incident where two minor generals hesitate or show fear.
Cao Cao doesn't delegate. He personally beheads them right there on the spot.
He executes his own officers in front of everyone.
Yes. Then he gets off his horse and starts carrying earth himself to fill the moat.
Leading by terrifying example.
Exactly. That combination, the absolute ruthlessness,
the clear deadline, and his own personal commitment, it galvanizes the troops.
Fear and inspiration. A potent mix.
And the city?
The defender's morale finally breaks. The city walls are breached. Shoushan is captured.
What about the generals Yuan Shu left behind? Li Frang and the others?
They're captured alive. But they don't stay alive for long.
Cao Cao has them executed publicly in the marketplace.
Total victory. Total retribution.
And Yuan Shu's imperial pretensions.
Cao Cao orders the burning of Yuan Shu's self-styled fake imperial palaces
and allows his troops to loot the city. A reward and a statement.
Okay. Xiaoshun falls. A major victory achieved,
though at a terrible cost, especially for Wang Heng.
Logically, the next step seems to be chasing down Yuan Shu, right? Finish the job.
That would seem logical, yes. Pursue the leader who escaped.
But this is where good counsel comes in again. His advisor Sun Yu steps forward.
And Sun Yu advises what?
Caution. He points out the reality. Years of drought. Severe food shortages.
The army has already stretched thin. The people are suffering.
Pursuing Yuan Shu further, Sun Yu argues, would likely exhaust the army completely,
with no guarantee of actually touching him or succeeding.
Better to consolidate, return to the capital Zhudu,
and wait for the spring wheat harvest. Rebuild strength.
So logistics and resources, again, dictating strategy, even after a win.
Always. It underlines the importance of knowing your limits,
not just pushing blindly forward after a victory.
Sometimes the strategic move is to pause.
And just as they're debating this, another fire starts somewhere else.
Exactly. As if on cue, reports arrive.
Zhang Ju, who Tao Tao had trouble with before.
The one whose surprise attack killed Dian Wei.
That's the one. He's causing trouble again in Nanyang and Jiangling,
apparently with support from Liu Biao, another major warlord.
And Tao Hong, the general Tao Tao left in that area, is losing battles.
Wow. It never stops, does it? One threat dealt with, another pops up.
It really shows the constant, fluid nature of warfare in this era.
You plug one hole, another leak springs open. Plans have to be incredibly adaptable.
So Tao Tao has to pivot. What's his move now?
He adjusts immediately. First, he deals with the Liu Biao angle.
He sends a letter to his ally, Sun Tzu.
The one who loaned him grain earlier.
Right. He instructs Sun Tzu to deploy forces across the Yangtze River.
Basically create a diversion to threaten Liu Biao's territory.
The goal is to keep Liu Biao pinned down, prevent him from actively helping Zeng Shu.
Smart. Keep your enemies occupied elsewhere.
Then Tao Tao orders his main army, fresh off the Shao Chun campaign,
to turn around and head back towards Zudu.
They need to deal with this Zeng Shu threat directly.
But before he leaves the Shao Chun area entirely,
what about Liu Bei and Liu Bu, his sort of allies?
Ah, yes. He gives Liu Bei orders to stay garrisoned in a place called Shao Pei,
which is strategically located near Liu Bu's territory in Zuzu.
Publicly, he tells them to essentially form a brotherhood,
support each other, maintain stability in the region.
Seems reasonable. But knowing Tao Tao, there's more to it, isn't there?
There absolutely is. This is the real kicker.
Tao Tao pulls Liu Bei aside, secretly.
And tells him?
He tells him, my order for you to garrison Shao Pei, it's a plan.
Think of it as digging a pit to wait for a tiger.
A pit for a tiger?
Almost certainly referring to Liu Bu.
He tells Liu Bei to coordinate secretly with Chen Gi and his son,
Chendeng local officials, who were wary of Liu Bu.
He adds, don't make any mistakes. I will be your external support.
So he's setting Liu Bei up to eventually take down Liu Bu,
while pretending to foster an alliance.
Exactly. It's pure Tao Tao.
Long-term strategic thinking, layers of deception.
He's planting the seeds for a future conflict that benefits him,
even as he seems to be making peace. Masterful manipulation.
Okay, so he leaves that potential trap behind and heads back to Zudu.
What's the situation when he arrives?
More good news, from his perspective at least.
News arrives that two other major thorns in the side of the central government,
the notoriously tyrannical warlords, Lu Zhu and Guo Xi, are dead.
How did they die?
Killed by their own subordinates, actually.
Duan Wei killed Lu Zhu, and Wuxi killed Guo Xi.
And they bring the heads to Tao Tao and Zudu.
More heads.
More heads. And Duan Wei doesn't just bring Li Zhu's head,
he brings Li Zhu's entire captured clan, over 200 people.
What does Tao Tao do with them?
He orders the entire clan executed, publicly.
At various city gates, heads displayed. The narrative says the people cheered,
as Li Zhu and Guo Xi had terrorized the capital previously.
So this is Tao Tao cleaning house, consolidating power in the capital.
Absolutely.
Eliminating these figures removes major rivals and sources of instability near the emperor.
It boosts Tao Tao's image as someone bringing order, even through brutal means.
And the emperor, he holds a peace feast,
officially sanctions these actions by granting titles to Duan Wei and Wuxi.
Which basically legitimizes the killings, and puts the killers under Tao Tao's influence.
Precisely.
They owe their new status to Tao Tao's acceptance of their actions.
With Tao Tao having just returned, having dealt with remnants of old threats,
immediately proposing another campaign.
Yes. No rest.
He immediately proposes marching against Zhang Shu, the guy causing trouble in Nanyang.
And the emperor himself comes out to see him off.
It really underscores the relentless cycle of war and political maneuvering in this time.
Nonstop conflict.
Nonstop. Constant calculation. Constant adaptation.
So Tao Tao, he's left his main advisor, Sun Yu, back in the capital, Zhu, to manage things.
Right.
And he himself is leading this huge army out on campaign.
Right. And as they're marching, they come across these fields, ripe wheat everywhere.
And the local people, understandably, are terrified of this massive army rolling through.
They've fled, haven't even harvested their crops.
Which sets up this first interesting moment, Tao Tao's reaction.
It's immediate. He sends out messengers, like everywhere. To the villagers, the local officials.
And he issues this really strong decree.
He says, look, I'm on an imperial mission here to crush rebellion, help the people.
Right.
But he acknowledges, yes, we're marching through during harvest.
And here's the kicker. Any soldier, any soldier who tramples the wheat gets beheaded.
Now, beheaded. That's, that's not messing around.
Not at all. He stresses the military law is incredibly strict, tells the people not to worry.
And how do people react? The common folk?
They're overjoyed, apparently. Praising him, bowing as he passes. They believe him.
And the army. Do they actually follow this?
Amazingly, yes. The description is quite vivid. Soldiers get off their horses.
They're like carefully lifting the wheat stalks, passing them hand to hand down the line.
Seriously. An entire army.
Making sure not a single stalk gets trampled.
It paints this picture of just incredible, meticulous discipline.
It really does, doesn't it?
Yeah.
That level of control is, well, it's hard to imagine.
It is. And it raises that question, right? How do you actually enforce that?
Especially with a huge army on the move. It's one thing to make a rule.
But to have everyone follow it so precisely.
Exactly. It needs more than just a threat. There has to be something else going on.
And this is where the story gets, well, kind of wild.
Tell himself he's riding his horse, being careful.
And then suddenly a pigeon flies up out of the field,
startles the horse, and the horse bolts right into the wheat.
Tramples a whole patch.
Oh boy. So the leader himself breaks the rule.
Instantly. And he immediately calls for his army scribe.
Tells him, record my crime. I trampled the wheat.
The scribe must have been terrified. The source says he's flustered.
Asks, how can the prime minister be punished?
Right. But you can't punish the guy in charge.
But Tao's response is incredible. He says, I made the law.
Now I've broken it. How else can I gain the trust of the masses?
Wow.
And then he actually draws his sword. Like, he's going to kill himself right there.
Talk about commitment. That's intense.
Extremely. Of course, his officers, they all rush in, stop him.
Naturally.
And Gojia, one of his key strategists, steps up.
He argues, basically, using precedent from the spring and autumn annals.
The foundational text, right?
Exactly. Saying, look, traditionally, the highest authority, the exalted,
sometimes aren't subject to the same letter of the law.
You're leading the whole army, prime minister. You can't just commit suicide.
Okay, so there's an out. A legalistic argument.
Right. And Tao thinks about it for a while. Then he says,
all right, since the annals say the law doesn't apply to the exalted, I'll spare my life for now.
But he doesn't just leave it there, does he?
No, this is the genius part, or maybe the cunning part.
He takes his sword, cuts off a lock of his own hair, and throws it on the ground.
Yeah. He declares, cutting off my hair will temporarily serve as my head.
Okay. That's symbolic.
Very. And he makes sure everyone knows. He has someone take the hair,
show it to the entire army, and announce, the prime minister trampled the wheat.
By rights, he should be beheaded. His hair is cut off as a substitute.
And the army's reaction?
The source says they were filled with awe.
And after that, military orders were followed strictly. Like, to the letter.
So it worked. A masterclass in leadership by example. Or maybe something else.
That's the million-dollar question, isn't it? It perfectly shows that,
let's call it the Machiavellian side of power. It's not just about rules. It's
about managing perception. There's actually a later poet who commented specifically on this,
saying something like, commanding ten myriad soldiers is tough,
but drawing a knife to cut your hair instead of your head. That's when Tao's true cunning showed.
So was it genuine? Or just a brilliant performance?
Exactly. Was he genuinely upholding his law? Or was it a calculated act to instill fear?
Loyalty?
Yeah.
Maybe both. He kind of weaponizes this apparent self-sacrifice to tighten his grip,
blurs the line between being authentic and being, well, manipulative.
It's a really provocative idea. It makes you think about how leadership works, how image works.
Yeah.
Okay, so he's mastered the internal stuff, discipline, perception.
So let's shift gears. How does this strategic mind work against an external enemy?
We pivot to Zhang Xu.
Right. Zhang Xu, here's Tao Tao is coming, and he immediately asks Liu Biao for backup.
Standard procedure.
Okay.
Then he leads his troops out with a couple of generals,
Lei Xu and Zhang Xian, ready to meet Tao Tao head on.
So battle lines are drawn.
Pretty much. And Zhang Xu rides out first, starts cursing Tao Tao, calls him something like,
a man of false benevolence, shameless, no better than a beast.
Ouch. Strong words.
Yeah, it gets Tao Tao furious. He orders Xu Chu, one of his fiercest warriors, to go fight him.
Okay, clash of champions incoming.
Zhang Xu sends out Zhang Xian to meet Xu Chu, but it's quick, like three bouts,
and Xu Chu just cuts Zhang Xian down.
Decisive victory for Tao Tao's side then.
Big time. Zhang Xu's army breaks, routes.
And Tao Tao pursues.
All the way to the gates of Nanyan City.
Zhang Xu manages to get inside, locks the gates. Classic siege situation begins.
Right. But sieges are tough. What does Tao Tao find?
He finds the city defenses are serious. The moat is incredibly wide, deep,
very hard to even get near the walls.
A brute force isn't going to work easily.
Doesn't look like it. So Tao Tao gets methodical.
He orders his soldiers to start hauling earth, filling in the moat.
They're using earth bags, firewood, straw bundles,
anything to build makeshift ramps up to the walls.
Trying to create attack points.
Exactly. And he sets up these huge siege towers,
Clyde Ladders, so they can see into the city.
Smart. Reconnaissance.
And for three days, Tao Tao himself is just riding around the city,
watching, observing.
Taking it all in. Planning his move.
Seems like it.
Then he gives a new order.
Tells his troops to pile up tons of firewood,
specifically at the western corner of the city.
Okay. Why the west corner?
And he gathers all his generals there too.
It looks, for all the world, like he's decided this is it.
We attack the west gate.
Okay. This feels like a setup.
It certainly looks like classic military deception, doesn't it?
A feint. Draw the enemy's attention, their forces, to one spot.
While you plan to hit them somewhere else.
Yeah. But inside the city, Zhang Xu has his own ace strategist, Jia Xu.
Ah, Jia Xu. He's known for being clever.
Extremely. And he's watching all this unfold.
He turns to Zhang Xu and says something like,
I see what Tao Tao is doing. I know his plan.
And now, Jia Xu says, we can use his own stratagem against him.
Ooh, turning the tables.
Precisely. The source even ends this section with that proverb,
strong among the strong, schemer meets schemer.
Perfect encapsulation. So Jia Xu thinks he's seen through the thing.
He's confident he has. It highlights that key part of strategy, recognizing deception.
Tao Tao's big show at the west gate is designed to mislead.
But how would Jia Xu know for sure? Maybe Tao Tao is double bluffing.
That's the game. Maybe Jia Xu knows Tao Tao's typical patterns.
Or maybe the feint itself was too obvious. Like, too perfectly staged.
Ah, like it's screaming, look over here! A bit too loudly for someone as cunning as Tao Tao.
Could be. A really sharp strategist like Jia Xu might think,
why is he making his plan so clear? That in itself becomes suspicious.
The perfection of the feint could be its flaw.
So when Jia Xu says, use his own stratagem against him,
what could that actually look like on the ground?
Well, a few possibilities, right? He could pretend to fall for it,
move troops west, make a big show. But secretly,
position forces for a surprise counterattack somewhere else.
Maybe a gate Tao Tao left lightly guarded because he was focused on his feint.
Using the deception to create an opening.
Or, even trickier, maybe Jia Xu makes the feinted attack point the real trap.
He lets Tao Tao commit forces to the west,
thinking he's fooled Zhang Zhu, and then springs an ambush right there.
Turning Tao Tao's carefully planned deception into his own downfall.
It really underlines that in war, understanding your opponent's mind,
their tendencies, their likely tricks, is just as vital as knowing where their troops are.
