Documentary about reconstructing medieval castles. Credits, Contributions & Sources in the description below. - Special thanks to the Historical Consultants: Leif Plith, Archaeologist, Museum Lolland-falster. Kjartan Langsted, Archaeologist, Museum Nordsjælland. Jesper Hjermind, Archaeologist. - Script, Animation, Music & Production: Lasse Skovmos Nielsen, Middelalderkanalen. - Voice: TTS. - Drone footage & old photos of Hald: Viborg Museum. Hald Ruin footage, ground level: Own/original. - Archival Footage and images from both own and third-party stock libraries. -
Chapters:
00:00 - Introduction 00:30 - The Bayeux Tapestry and Motte & Bailey Castles 01:35 - Bastrup Tower Reconstruction 03:00 - Hammershus Reconstruction 04:40 - Hald Castle Reconstruction 07:50 - Teutonic Castles/Malbork - A Source for Inspiration?
Sources: Bastrup - Europe: A massive Danish donjon from 1100, Klavs Randsborg, 2003.
Sources in Danish only: Porthuset på Bispens Hald: Istandsættelsesrapport 2007-08 Hammershus: Bornholmske Samlinger 3, rk. 11. bd. 1997.
Europe is dotted with castles. They are an important cultural heritage.
But they are also shrouded in myth, and many castles are now in ruins.
So how do we really know what they looked like?
This video aims at discussing the methods and considerations
going into reconstructing medieval castles.
Normandy 1066
William, Duke of Normandy, invades England.
A few years later, an embroidery is made depicting the events.
This embroidery, though called the Bayeux Tapestry,
is a visual narrative of how William conquered England.
But crucially, it also has depictions of wooden towers being constructed on top of mounds,
known as motte and bailey castles.
Through studies of the Bayeux embroidery and comparing it with archaeological findings,
it is possible to get clues on what these imposing strongholds once looked like.
This also applies in other countries like Denmark,
albeit this type of castle seems to appear here a bit later.
However, not all early medieval castles are made of wood.
Situated in northern Zealand, Denmark, is a peculiar ring of travertine bricks.
These are the ruins of the 12th century Bastrop Tower.
Its huge dimensions allow for a height of up to 30 metres.
However, nobody knows the actual height of the tower,
but studying another similar 12th century tower in Kerrfurt, Germany,
may hint at how to illustrate the Bastrop Tower.
In this reconstruction, a horde is placed above the staircase.
Its function is to allow defenders to get closer to the intruding enemy
and attack them from above.
Even though no evidence exists for a horde on the Bastrop Tower,
there exists plenty of evidence elsewhere in medieval illuminations.
The reason this horde is not going all the way around the tower
is for the purpose of illustrating uncertainties.
The model then allows one to perceive the tower
both with and without a horde simultaneously.
Having several models of the same tower,
each with different architectural features,
could lead to a misunderstanding,
and one may get the impression
that they are not reconstructions of the same tower.
A very similar dilemma of choice was faced
when reconstructing Hammershus Castle.
This is the grand keep of Hammershus,
known as the Mantle Tower.
Through detailed analysis of the wall,
crenellations come to light.
They reveal this tower had earlier stages.
There are also putt-log holes in the wall
which could have facilitated a horde.
Alternatively, they were used for scaffolding
during time of construction.
To illustrate the tower with its crenellations,
a previous version depicted it with a flat roof,
a so-called fighting platform.
However, on the actual ruins of the Mantle Tower,
there seems to be no drainage for rainwater.
A later version, therefore,
depicts the tower with a roof,
as well as a horde.
Either version of reconstruction
may have been a real possibility.
Ultimately, a choice has to be made
when making reconstructions,
and one should always ask
which time period is chosen for the reconstruction model.
A decision was then made
to make a model of Hammershus,
spanning the years from 1325 to 1525.
And yet another model
that encompasses its next century of its heydays.
Which means,
not all the buildings seen on this model
may necessarily have existed simultaneously.
Due to historical uncertainties,
it is impossible to make historically accurate models
for each time period.
Reconstructing anything,
when all you have are ruins
and scarce contemporary depictions,
can be a difficult puzzle.
And nowhere is that more evident
than at the ruins of Hal Castle in central Jutland.
Situated in a lake at the hills of Dollerup, Denmark,
it was built by a local bishop
a few years prior to the Protestant Reformation of 1536.
What seemed to be a quick and simple attempt
to illustrate the gatehouse
proved a difficult task.
Only a 17th century copper plate engraving
exists of Hal Castle.
However, it contains a very inaccurate depiction
when considering the actual ruins
and its unusual floor plan.
As this 19th century photo reveals,
Hal was once an earth-covered ruin.
The gatehouse wasn't excavated until 1903.
When it was unearthed,
they found two vaulted cellars.
And during a restoration in the 1980s,
archaeologists also found two pits
for drawbridge counterweights.
A first attempt to reconstruct the gatehouse
was made in 2017.
The two vaulted cellars, or casemates,
were then depicted as earth-covered.
Though this building is, in fact,
the main building.
In contemporary written sources,
it is called the Large Stone House.
It wouldn't have been known as such
if it was that small.
So was the gatehouse wider, after all?
On the ruins, there are two niches,
one for each casemate.
They cannot be explained as gunports.
However, it has been suggested
they were cesspits.
If true, the latrines must have led
to an upper floor,
which means it would make no sense
if the cellars were covered by earth.
A decision was then made
to draw inspiration from another
contemporary 16th century,
then Danish, Monstorp Castle.
Located in Scania,
it is now part of modern-day Sweden.
Monstorp's curved gable
is similar to the near-semicircular shape
of the ruins of Hal Castle.
This is another attempt
to reconstruct the gatehouse.
There are two pits
for the drawbridge counterweights.
Above the pits are both
a narrow entrance for pedestrians
called a wicket gate
and a wider entrance for wagons.
The idea behind it
is that if there are enemies around,
the large drawbridge is rarely lowered.
And the small drawbridge
can be raised faster
than the large drawbridge.
Every castle is unique
and has to fit to the regional,
cultural and natural environment.
Even though some features
are common across many cultures,
the choice of materials
is often reflected in the architecture.
And many North German,
Baltic and Danish castles
are made of red bricks.
Unfortunately,
several castles in this region
are now in ruins,
making it difficult
when deciding on how to reconstruct them.
This is Malbork Castle in Poland.
During the 18th and 19th century,
it underwent several changes
and yet another restoration
after the Second World War,
though it largely maintained
its original appearance.
We know this because
15th and 16th century paintings
of the original Malbork Castle
actually do exist.
Malbork is a castle
of the Teutonic Order of Knights,
a prominent power in the Baltic region.
Another major power in this region
is Denmark.
It is therefore likely
that Danish and Teutonic castles
share the same architectural features,
possibly through trade,
travel and warfare,
allowing for an exchange of culture.
If that is indeed the case,
it may be worth studying
other Baltic castles
and then applying some Teutonic features
on reconstruction models
of Danish castles.
Though this hypothesis
is not set in stone,
future investigations
in both art, literature and archaeology
may provide alternative insights
on how to reconstruct architecture
of the Middle Ages.