In this powerful live discussion, Kevork Almassian and Nare Navasardyan examine the alarming political crackdown unfolding in Armenia under Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan.
The same man once hailed as a symbol of democracy during the Velvet Revolution is now presiding over one of Armenia’s harshest political crackdowns in modern history.
This episode of Syriana Analysis explores: 🔹How Armenia’s democracy is being dismantled from within 🔹Why Western silence enables repression 🔹The deeper consequences after the loss of Artsakh
📢 Disclaimer: Guest opinions featured in this video do not necessarily reflect the views of Syriana Analysis.
🎥 Syriana Analysis is an independent platform providing in-depth geopolitical insights, founded by award-winning journalist Kevork Almassian. This channel aims to offer well-researched commentary that broadens understanding of international relations, conflict zones, and media narratives.
Kirill Kalmasyan. Thank you very much for tuning in to today's live streaming
whether you're joining us on YouTube, on Rumble or on Gun Jink World. What is
happening in Armenia right now should alarm anyone who still believes in
democracy and national sovereignty. The same man who once rose to power as a
so-called Velvet Revolution is now presiding over one of the harshest
political crackdowns in Armenia's modern history. Opposition figures, church
leaders and even local officials are being detained or silenced, all wrapped
in the language of anti-corruption and security. But the pattern, my friends, is
unmistakable. Critics are punished, loyalists are protected and the
machinery of the state is being used as a tool of political control. To discuss
the political and social implications of this crisis, I'm very happy to be
joined by Nareh Navasardian, a writer, journalist and activist whose work has
examined Armenia's shifting political landscape in depth. Nareh studied writing
and marketing at Johns Hopkins University, served as copywriter for the
EU delegation of Armenia and co-founded the Eye for an Eye NGO in 2021. She is
also co-directed, she also co-directed the 2019 documentary Pazaran, which
explores the cultural changes that paved the way for Armenia's 2018 regime
change or the, as they call it, revolution. From 2024 to 2025, she worked
until this moment as a correspondent for the Hyrenic Media. Nareh, welcome to
Syrian Analysis. It's really a pleasure to have you on the program today.
Thanks for having me.
I would like to start this conversation with you about the situation inside
Armenia. When you look at the arrests of opposition figures, mayors and even
clergy, do you see this as an attempt by Pashinyan to consolidate power or has
Armenia already crossed the threshold into authoritarianism?
Well, the last wave of repressions has truly been unprecedented. The scale was
just unimaginable. Starting from May of this year, it was everyone. Opposition
figures, parties, clergymen, there was a concentrated campaign against the
Armenian Apostolic Church. And all of this, I think we need to view this in the
context of both domestic politics and then the pressures of foreign policy. So
domestically, Pashinyan no longer has the support that he once had. In 2021, he
secured the kind of majority that effectively enabled him to pass any law
and even strip the opposition from mandates. And this was when he proclaimed
that, you know, the party was still going to stand in defense of Artsakh's
self-determination, in defense of their rights. And nowadays, in 2025, after the
ethnic cleansing in 2023, after Pashinyan recognized Artsakh as
Azerbaijan in 2022, in Brussels, I believe, or Prague, one of the European
cities. After this, he says that opening a conversation about the return of
ethnic Armenians, about their right to return to their ancestral lands, is, as
he says, dangerous and is within the context of reigniting the conflict. How
far the mighty have fallen, as they say. So he no longer has the support.
According to a recent survey, only 12% supports the executive branch of
government and only 15% fully supports like civil contract. And he knows this.
And in contrast, the church has, you know, it's one of the it's after the
armed forces. It is the most trusted institution. And within the framework of
this, like, constant concessions that Pashinyan has to make to Baku, the
church, especially last year in 2024, became the unifying force, like, led by
the protest, the holy movement led by Archbishop Bagrat Galasanyan, was the
largest protest movement to this day. And it was sparked by his giveaways in
Dabush region. He gave away heights, gave away territories. And so now we know
that he, Baku is pushing for more concessions, he needs to give this trip
corridor, unintended access through the Armenian South. So he has to, you know,
paint the opposition as this one group of mafiosis, Russia type people, and just
paint himself as the person that is nobly unable to win in foreign relations.
He wants to at least have this internal victories. And also, especially this is
this has to be viewed in the context of the upcoming elections, which are
scheduled for the summer of 2026.
This sounds like a script from some of the capitals in Europe and also in
Ukraine. And nowadays, this has become so normalized, to call the opposition
Russian collaborators, and they're receiving funds from Russia, or they're
simply repeating Russian talking points. This is what they say when they crack
down on the Orthodox Church, for example, in Ukraine, and on opposition
parties in Europe itself. It seems that the outcome of polls or elections do not
really matter any longer, as long as the leader who is embedded with a certain
project in the region and abroad says that the opposition is pro-Russian. And
in this case, they have accused the mayor of Gyumri, I believe that he is a
pro-Russian politician, right? And is that the trigger or there are serious
corruption cases against the Gyumri mayor?
It's very interesting, because in Armenia, in general, winning a local
municipal elections can be quite dangerous, sometimes for your health,
sometimes just for your freedom. You can just look at many cases, you can look at
the case of Vartanis, the case of Balaverdi. In Vanadzor, the mayor was
just simply arrested and there was this indefinite interim candidate installed
and that was that. So wherever they're not, they proceed with many different
strategies. For example, the Gyumri elections, they were triggered. Why were
they even triggered? Because Pashinyan refused the coalition logic with the
Balasanyan alliance. And he triggered early elections himself because of civil
contract. The ruling party triggered these elections. And then this consensus
minus one was formed, surprisingly, in Gyumri, where all the opposition
candidates, they ganged up against Pashinyan and left like civil contract
out of it. And they couldn't tolerate something like this going to elections
with, you know, the second largest city in Armenia being under an opposition
mayor. And even when he got elected, immediately people started saying this
is going to get arrested because like this is just the logic in which he
operates.
And eliminating the opposition in this way, it's sending lots of signals and one
of which I believe, like you described how like this could basically spread
fear and fatigue right into the Armenian society. But what do these arrests mean
for the social fabric of Armenia? Like, are we seeing the erosion of public
trust in state institutions? Or is there still a segment of society that refuses
to be silenced?
There has been definitely an erosion of trust and all surveys show it. And over
80% of the population, according to a recent survey, opposed further
concessions to Azerbaijan, Baku, which is something that Pashinyan has to do. And,
you know, the church itself, it's, this is the reason why it is so important
these days, because, you know, the military, as soon as Pashinyan came to
power, he made amendments to the law, so that any high ranking military
official now can just be simply dismissed by the prime minister's
proposal. So the, you know, trust in the army, like the army's ability to act in
the circumstances, and stand in defense of the country's sovereignty, it has
been eroded. And similarly, with the judiciary, for example, you know, all
these cases with the opposition, there were two key figures there, the
prosecutor general and the head of the investigative committee. And both of
them are supposed to be independent, but we know de facto that they're not
independent. Like previously, we've seen cases of judges dismissed at Pashinyan's
request, like, and the NSS appoint, it's all under one person. So this is
basically, as he recently himself proclaimed, this is, I am the state. This
is just, this is like Pashinyan's, and he even wants to proclaim a fourth
republic, which will likely...
What is, what is this fourth republic? Like, I've been hearing this for quite
some time. The other day, I have read some Turkish reports claiming that, and
this, those Turkish reports are from the secularists, Turks, and they are
anti-Erdoganists, let's say. They're claiming that Erdogan is preparing to
give up on territories in the south of Armenia in the Sunni region, as part of
the fourth republic that he's envisioning. What is this fourth republic
that he's promising the people?
You mean, Erdogan will gain control of those lands?
No, Armenia will give up on, on territories in the south, to give access
for the corridor that they're going to establish, basically, that connects
Turkey to Azerbaijan. And this is an overland access, basically, for Turkey to
have an enormous business, financial, geopolitical leverage, not only over
Armenia, Armenia is a very small country, it will extend all the way to
the Caspian Sea and beyond that. But without this concession from Pashinyan,
or the alleged agreement to concede more territories to Azerbaijan, to this
project, Turkey cannot extend its influence to Central Asia. So basically,
in this case, when I think about it, I don't see the benefit, I don't see the
business benefit for Armenia, I don't see the logic, I don't see the
geopolitics. I'm sorry, I'm really trying hard to understand Pashinyan,
because I'm not naturally like to attack people or criticize people. Like
if Pashinyan truly serve the interests of the Armenians, I mean, I will bring
the chapeau, I will, like, why not, you know, but I'm seeing, I'm seeing what
is happening in Armenia is Armenia will be swallowed by the Turkish economy,
because it's a huge economy with a huge industrial base. And Armenia has no
means to compete with Turkish production, basically. So Turkey will de
facto occupy the country financially. This is how they dump all their products
into the neighboring countries like they did in Syria. And I'm coming from a
place where I saw how Turkey operates and how they use this soft power. So in
this case, I'm still wondering what is the Fourth Republic of Pashinyan? Should
we be a little bit optimistic or it's all pessimism there?
Well, you know, it's, these are objective realities. Whenever someone from the, say,
Russian opposition, whenever we have a conversation, and they start complaining
about Pusin, I'm like, well, that's a little bit different, because Pashinyan
assumed control of 42,000 square kilometers of Armenian territory. And he
promises to leave us with less than 29,000 square kilometers in the best
case scenario. Like there is no silver lining to any of this, because this is
all going back to, you know, the kind of Armenia that Turkey would tolerate, is
the Armenia that is delineated by the Alexandra Pole Treaty, which is the
First Republic of Armenia at the time, you know, occupied, barely resisting
Turkish forces, signed the Alexandra Pole Treaty, which gave Armenia 10,000
square kilometers only, with no military and only a police force in this, you know,
surrounded, basically besieged, permanently besieged by Turkey and
Azerbaijan. And this is their long term strategy. Now, will there be any, you
know, effective trade in this type of republic? I don't think so. But also, you
know, it's just with this type of countries and this kind of people that
are installed, they are completely disconnected from the interests of their
land or things that they control. What they care about is their personal
enrichment, because, you know, Pashinyan is nobody, didn't even have like a
higher education, he just waltzed in on the, on this.
This has become the norm. This has become the norm nowadays. I mean, Jolani
doesn't even have the sixth grade. He's completely illiterate. And those people
are leading countries nowadays.
Yes, exactly. Because your goal is not to have an Armenia in defense of its
interests. You want Armenia under this Turkish umbrella that will also maybe
act against Iran.
Well, I will show you this report, which I read the other day in this Turkish
website. And this website, I have double checked and verified the authenticity of
this website. And it has millions of followers in in Turkey. And it has a huge
traffic as well. And they have not known of spreading fake news. However, a
spokesperson for Prime Minister Pashinyan, she posted a tweet on X. And
she said this is categorically false, according to her. But we have heard many,
many times in the past, how the Pashinyan government said those are false news,
fake news, and then that turned out to be correct, one of which was the
surrender in 2022. And the signature of Pashinyan to recognize the Azeri
sovereignty over Artsakh. And this is this article says the step that will
change regional balances, Armenia gives up those lands. Armenian Prime Minister
Nikol Pashinyan announced or is allegedly willing to transfer 200 square
kilometers of Sunni province to Azerbaijan and the regional normalization
agreement stipulating limited border access to Turkey. The plan is part of
Pashinyan's fourth Republic of Armenia vision. So I'm happy that the
spokesperson of Pashinyan denied this allegation. And I hope that she's being
genuine this time. And I would retract this report after publishing it on my
account, if it turns out not to be correct in the next two years, because
everything is fake news until they happen. And when they happen, they
always have a side to blame. It's very easy to say the the people who in the
past, Nakhkinev, it's the Russian meddling, the Russians forced us, the
Russian betrayed us. It's it's it's not us always taking responsibility and
accountability, unfortunately, is missing in the discussion here. But if I see
one of the most alarming aspects of this crackdown, I think this has been the
direct targeting of the Armenian Apostolic Church, something
unprecedented in the post Soviet era. Why is the church suddenly being treated as
a threat to begin with? And the second part of the question would be what does
this assault on religious figures tell us about Pashinyan's broader political
strategy and his relationship to Armenian national identity?
Well, part of this is the church standing in guard of Artsakh's right to
return of Artsakh's heritage. For example, this recent crackdown, it started one
day after the church organized this conference on the Artsakh heritage and
religious freedoms that he organized it in Bern in Switzerland, the Catholic
Kosovo Armenians. And so one day after this, Pashinyan at a meeting started
saying that churches have been turned into storage rooms. And then his
girlfriend, Anna Hakopyan, posted saying that they're the biggest pedophiles of
the country. And they started mocking the statement after the conference, which
was talking about the Artsakh's right to return. So that's one aspect is Artsakh.
Another one is that we have Allah Gulum Pashizadeh, which is presiding over the
Caucasus Muslims, according to Baku. And he called Armenian Apostolic Church, this
was again, days before this campaign started, revanchists and that they're a
big threat to the neighboring countries. So this is Azerbaijan also like they
demand to meddle in Armenia's internal affairs. And thanks to Pashinyan, they
already are meddling.
Wow. When I when I follow the aftermath of this so called Velvet Revolution, it
looks more it's it looks more than just an attempt by Pashinyan to have good
relationship with Azerbaijan and Turkey. Like if I'm someone who wants to destroy
the foundations of a nation, and Armenia is a nation with a very rich history and
civilization in the region, you will start with the pillars, like what what the
Armenian nationhood stands on, what are the legs basically of the Armenian
nationhood, you in you start with the historical symbols, you follow with the
national identity and then go after the church, the church is a symbol for the
Armenians and Armenia, Armenian people were the first people to accept
Christianity as a religious religion of the state. So I think it goes even beyond
the symbolism, it's it's a deliberate attempt to destabilize what the Armenians
stand for. And when I think with my conspiracy mind, because this is
sometimes where I go deep into my mind, it looks literally like the globalist
agenda to destroy a national identity, to destroy the religious identity of the
people in this attempt to create the illusion that we are, everyone is the
same, borders are open, there is no identity, people no longer identify
themselves as an Armenian or as a German, but rather with sub identities, for
example, in the country, some of them related about gender, others related
about sexuality. So it's not an identity that you would like to defend, like if
you are attacked by Azerbaijan or by Turkey, and rest assured, guys,
Azerbaijan and Turkey have increased their military budgets, and also their
nationalistic sentiments in the country in order to bring the country together
in case of a foreign threat. In contrary, Armenia is decreasing the military
budget, and destroying the national identity and the church which combines
and unifies the Armenians. It looks to me, Narejan, it's like it's like a recipe
for suicide from outside and I'm really fearful for the Armenian as a nation.
Am I exaggerating or my fears should be taken at least with a little bit of
consideration?
No, I think this is like an accurate assessment. But I think with this
globalist forces, a lot depends on what their overarching goals are. For example,
in Ukraine, where there is so-called like lack of lasting constant identity, what
they do is that they encourage this identity, right? Because its opposition is
the Russians. So they give Ukraine their own little church. They encourage
Ukrainian nationalism. Same with Georgia, right? In Georgia, you never hear about
giving up claims to Abkhazia, to Ossetia, because the adversary, the identity is
opposed to a factor that is in favor of this so-called like globalist forces. So
with Armenia, it's like when you want to push the country under this like Turko
NATO umbrella, and you know, because Turkey is the, you know, the regional
administrator, then it requires the deconstruction of Armenian political
identity. And that's why, you know, they just, they claim that this identity was
given to us by USSR, which is partly true when Turkey joined NATO, USSR wanted to
fortify borders in a sense. And so they started the genocide memorial, the, they
loosened up, it was like later stage already in the 60s. And they, the
nationalist sentiments were more and more accepted. And then it led to the 1988
Karabakh movement, which was always there, like in the form of petitions, claims to
Moscow. So it just depends on their local agenda, right? Like, they're not going to
go to Taiwan and say, like, oh, you know, you're just like the Chinese, like you
have so many similarities, but they come to us, and they're like, oh, you're
nothing. All this history that you have all the church, all these testimonies
that you're indigenous, that you have history, all of this, it means nothing.
Because, you know, only France is allowed to have this like lasting values and
institutions, like, who are you, an Armenian, to have this type of pillars
for your identity?
This leads me to the question that, I mean, who, like, does a weakened, divided
and demoralized Armenia simply make, make Baku's job easier or not? Like, if you
have a neighboring country that is vertically divided, social tensions and
political crackdown, basically suppression or oppression against the
church itself, you're giving a service on a golden plate to Azerbaijan. And I
understand that he wants to normalize ties with Azerbaijan and end this. But at
least, I'm saying at least with some dignity, right? Like, I see, I come from
West Asia, I was born in Syria. And when I see some of the, for example, Arab
leaders, crawling after the US and Israel for to sign a deal with them.
Meanwhile, 10s of 1000s of their countrymen or from the borders in
Palestine have been slaughtered daily. It creates some perception about how these
politicians think about politics, right? For them, human, human beings do not have
any value. But probably in the Middle East, people say, yeah, those are Saudis,
they don't really care about the what is happening in Palestine, right? Or those
are Lebanese, why should we care about the Palestinians? This is how they see
the region. But Pashinyan is the Prime Minister of Armenia. And those are
Armenian lives, including 120,000 Armenians who should have the right to
return to their homes. Even if that means living under Azeri sovereignty, if there
is, there are securities and guarantees for these people to live in their in
their homes and continue their lives as they used to do in the past decade. And
Azeris are coming and not only occupying these territories, they're erasing all
the historical monuments, let's say, and the history behind this. So complete
erasure of the Armenian identity and the Christian identity there. And Pashinyan
is continuing this path inside Armenia itself. I'm, I'm sorry that I'm making
these statements. But I'm very upset. Because people think that nations and
civilizations do not die. But they do die and happens so many times during the
cycle of history and Armenians have become too small and stuck between two
hostile nations in this case. And they truly need a leader who can navigate
them through these turbulences. You know, it's it's a serious issue. You need
someone to understand geopolitics. But I don't see Pashinyan is able to do that.
Unfortunately, we are headed towards a huge catastrophe. I really want to know
more about the detainees and the prisoners of war of the Artsakhs and the
people from Artsakh who are in the prisons in Baku and in Azerbaijan. How
many Armenians do we have at the current moment approximately in Azeri prisons?
And is the Pashinyan government doing anything at their minimum to protect
their rights?
Well, I think we should just answer with the statement made by the National
Assembly President Assembly, Alan Simonian, who said in this, you know,
leak of a private conversation, that the hostages are dead to him. So he's from
Pashinyan's ruling party. And this is the statement that he made. It is clear
that the hostages are not really a priority. Their absolute priority is just
having some type of document to sign to call it peace, even if it's the piece of
the grave. And to be able to go to elections and then just continue
remodeling Armenia according to their own ugly image.
Now, Narejan, you worked with the EU delegation of Armenia, and you
understand how Brussels usually usually reacts to democratic backsliding. So how
do you think the European Union and Western institutions, why do you think
they are in the European Union and Western institutions largely silent
about what is happening in Armenia today? Is this only like a double
standards, as some people say, or a deliberate choice to protect an ally
who serves their geopolitical interests?
Well, it's clear that before the 2018 regime change, what we had was a civil
society that was masquerading as one that was in defense of certain European
values that, you know, the Armenia is included in a number of is like an
underside. It is an undersignee of those norms and standards. But then a lot of
them were incorporated into the Pashinyan's administration. And now we
have this process of forming new systems of control that nevertheless don't really
have this validation systems that the West usually provides for this cases. I
mean, NGO civil society in general has been proven not just in Armenia, but in
many other cases to just be like an infiltration network where they take
upon a segment of the government's job, they do the paperwork, and then gradually
as they speak, come to shape public opinion, as they have more and more
control, they actually like seize the country. And then it does it, it stops
mattering what sort of human rights abuses we encounter. For example, right
last year, there was the holy struggle movement, and then they just fired flash
grenades directly into the peaceful protesters. And over 100 people were
injured, and nobody has been held accountable for this. Au contraire, we
see the police force, it's bigger, it's better equipped, funded by the EU, funded
by America, they get more money than the, you know, the people in the military. So
it has become a police state. People are always surprised they come to Yerevan,
one of the safest cities, and they see so many police everywhere with their
sirens making a show. I mean, even this recent case, right, like where they
invaded the Etchmiadzin with this like mask, like doing this great show of
strength, or with when they were detaining the mayor of Gyumri. This is
basically it has turned into a country that is run like, like a yellow
journalist would run it, which Nikol Tashkent.
You know, I'm personally worried, I'm personally worried to go to Armenia. And
every time I land in Armenia in the past few years, after 2018, like, I, you know,
I land, because I know that they are kicking out Armenians in the airport, and
they're just deporting them. They're calling them persona non grata for
criticizing Nikol Pashinyan on social media platforms, like how far Pashinyan
has gone against even Armenian diasporans, who simply criticized him on
social media, they have the time to read and filter names and and put their names
in the airport because they criticize Nikol Pashinyan and ban them from even
visiting their fatherland. It's, it's, it's going beyond. I always had the
impression that this camp which claims to be championing democracy and human
rights are hypocritical. But they have gone too far, even for their taste. I
think even their people are no longer have the appetite to support such a
movement, even in Armenia.
Well, yes. I mean, when it comes to true democracies, my friend and I are always
discussing that Iran, when it comes to separation of powers is like the
exemplary democratic state, because there are so many different institutions,
whereas here in the so called democratic Armenia, we just have like one person and
he just does whatever he wants. For example, right, my friend, Njdeh
Garagosan, he was just protesting Pashinyan and egged his convoy in Paris.
And this is like a regular practice, like the French always do this, and then even
worse. And then now he can come to Armenia. And this case is like delay,
delay, delay, like there's no conclusion. And he's just banned based on this one
thing where you can't even protest him in France nowadays. And it's like similar
to the case where they don't actually care about the ultimate justice or about
the ultimate how verifiable their statements are. Like there was this case
right with Badiashvili versus Georgia, again, similar to the case that we have
now with opposition, where there was a wiretap recording or like a recording of
a telephone conversation that was montaged. This was 2006. So they started a
case against him. They arrested him, said that he was taking aid from the Abkhazian
armed groups in Abkhazia. But they edited the part out where he said where he
refused the offers. And then in 2019, so like 13 years later, we find out that,
well, actually, you know, it was wrong to convict him, but nobody cares anymore.
It's not about if it's true or not, it's just the new cycle.
So your friend is barred from getting into Armenia because he threw an egg on
the convoy of Nikol Pashinyan. I think this was a few weeks ago, a few months
ago, when this, I think the Munich security event happened in Munich, and
then he came to Berlin, and he was driving a bike in the streets. And then I
watched the video. And I find it hilarious, because one of the places that
he passed through, I pass through that place almost every day. And it would have
been fun to meet him. And Pashinyan, listen, well, I'm not threatening you and
those who work for Pashinyan, but I would have had some conversation with him to
tell him what I really believe about his politics, not about him. Anyways, I
wanted to show you a few comments on this issue. For example, a friend of mine,
Alex, he posted on his account on X says the fact that Pashinyan sent a military
detachment to detain Gumeri's anti-government mayor betrays any
suggestion. His arrest was over corruption, like a teampot dictator.
Pashinyan is making an example of his opposition, using excessive force to
intimidate and suppress critics. Another friend published this post, and I found
it also interesting. He says, when they came to power, the Nikola Gans or the
people of Nikol Pashinyan didn't realize that taking over the government wasn't a
joke and that their actions or inactions could have serious consequences for the
country. Now these people don't realize that political prosecutions and witch
hunts are serious crimes that can have serious consequences for them in the
future. Most of them are still young and don't realize that as soon as they lose
power, which is inevitable, most of them will have to stand trial and suffer the
consequences of their actions. Now I think from here I want to ask
something, and this is about the people in Armenia. I think one of the
red lines in Armenian society has always been the church. There is persecution
against the politicians, but now against the church as well. If Pashinyan were to
go as far as arresting the Catholicos of all Armenians, for example, would
that finally awaken the public or has the population become too disillusioned,
too frightened or too apolitical, let's say, to resist? Do you see the people
starting to become more active than passive as we've seen in the past few years?
It's clear that now people are way more anti-Pashinyan than they have ever been.
And it's clear that Samvel Karapetyan, who is now under arrest for stating his
support for the Armenian Apostolic Church, he is pretty popular and he is
going to take part in elections. And there are many other opposition
groups and civic initiatives that are becoming popular. The question is
political organizing, because no matter what you feel, how you feel, you need to
know how to act. You need to have leadership. You need to have
instructions. You need to know and trust the people you're in political
alignment with. And I don't think that we have this, even though the majority of
the people are against them. They don't really know what to do. Also, because
Pashinyan has really upped the price of dissent with, you know, the arbitrary
jailings. You know, even the lawyers nowadays, they're like constantly called
for these like NSS questionings, like five hours is spent there. So even
defending these political prisoners, it has a cost. So everything in Pashinyan's
army, opposing anything, is pretty costly.
Narayan, if you want to take a step back and look at the bigger picture here,
after everything we've seen since 2018, the loss of Artsakh, the erosion of the
institutions of the Armenians also in Artsakh, the silencing of dissent inside
Armenia proper, and the indifference of the European Union and the collective
West in general. In your opinion, what future do you see for Armenian democracy?
Is it possible to thrive again under Pashinyan or there has to be a political
change in the country?
Well, I mean, I'm part of the people, the group of people that are more worried
about Armenia than I am about Armenia's democracy. Because, you know, Artsakh as
well, it has great democratic institution. It was constantly ranked very well in all
this, you know, this European ranking systems. And still it was overtaken by a
power that has close to, I don't know, zero ranking in any of these metrics. So I
think what matters most is to follow the logic that the Gyumri elections did,
demonstrated, which is like everyone against the ruling party. And if we are
able to consolidate people and draw the right demarcation lines and unite against
those who every day are threatening our church, our identity, our beliefs about
our history, our self-confidence as a state, self-confidence in our ability to
thrive long term within our political unit. So if we unite against them, then I
think we will be able to add a couple of more years to the Armenian history of
statehood.
This is very important what you said. And I really want to hear your final thoughts.
And this is the last question, I promise. What would you say to the Armenian
intellectual class in this case? It doesn't matter the politics here. You are
with, you are against, you are in the middle, you're a journalist, you're an
author, you're a podcaster, you're an opinion leader, you're an activist, you're
just someone who is interested in politics, because everybody should be interested in
politics. Even if you're not interested in politics, guys, politics is interested in
you. So we really have to be engaged in this. So if you want to say a final word
for the intellectual class in Armenia, we spoke about to be organized, to truly, for
example, follow the example of Gyumri. But we have time till the next year. And I'm
not here to call for extraordinary things. I'm just really logically trying to figure
out what could be done until next year, to have a certain balance in the political
landscape in Armenia so that the voices of the people and their concerns would be
heard. So what is the role of the intellectual class here? And how could they
deliver their concerns to the people, like mobilizing the people to unite around at
least the principles of what Armenian nationhood stands for? We're talking about
its national identity, we're talking about its sovereignty, we're talking about its
church.
Well, I think Pashinyan and his clique, they rely, they seem to rely on the part of
the population that is able to read and understand Armenian only on a high level.
For example, right, they will have unimpeded access to Nakhijavan written in the text of
this trip agreement that they signed. But then they just continue to just deny, deny,
deny, deny through all their channels, the public radio, public TV, everything is just
directly subordinate, there's like a very high level of consolidation. So I think it's
very important to do basically translation works to just inform the public because they
have a largely good instincts about what's happening. I think the majority, according
to recent survey, the majority are very pessimistic about the future of Armenia if
Pashinyan stays in power. And these are just, you know, I'm just citing the numbers
here, I'm not making my own assessment. So there is a lot of ground. But I think what's
most important is to think beyond any election cycle, because, you know, these are your
people, this is your country. It's very surprising to me that sometimes I see Armenians
that are apolitical, because even if maybe your work is not tied to this country, you
have a cousin who is probably serving somewhere on the border. You have your parents
here, you have your real estate, you know, grandmother, grandfather. It's like Armenia is
not really the kind of place where you can just be effectively apolitical. Yes, it's not
really like Denmark, it's a matter of life and death, like you, not the price of you not
doing politics, is Pashinyan inciting a war, and then using it like sending your cousin
or brother to die or your father, and then using this as a, you know, scare to scare off
the population seeing saying like, Okay, this is what you want. I will give you this
disorganized mess of a war, and no general will be able to take part. And no general
that could be meaningful to the war effort will take part. And you will get killed. And
then I will give up those territories anyway, and then laugh at you and say that you gave
you fought for nothing, that it was all for nothing. It was a mistake. It was for Moscow
or something. So this is the price and you have to feel it, you need to have like an
intuition. And you need to, first of all, you know, you need to convince some some of
the population that they're not, you know, temporarily embarrassed Americans, because
when this Charlie Kirk started, I see, Armenians are writing like, this is simply
terrible, terrible, like worst day of my life. And I'm like, Hey, you're not American, like
you're here.
Yeah. Unfortunately, look, guys, please listen to what she said about the intuition. And
especially when it is about life or death. And this is something that I want to give
an example just to reiterate what she said. And this is a brilliant way to end up this
conversation. I will give you an example, guys in the past. I've been in Germany since
2015. Right. So I'm, I'm here for around 10 years. But I moved to Berlin six, seven years
ago. And since I moved to Berlin, I was engaged in demonstrations, sit-ins for the
Armenians and for the Syrians. But I haven't seen, for example, people who are more
passive about it than the Syrians who came recently to Germany. And they were like, what
are you doing? Like, we just came to Germany. Like, things are fine for us. Why do you go
and stand in front of the American embassy and calling for lifting sanctions? Like, you
know, we're here now we're comfortable. And I used to ask him, but don't you have a family
in Syria? Don't you have friends, colleagues? Don't you know one person that you love still
in the country? And so they were so it like as if what is happening in the country is
irrelevant for them. And then because of the sanctions, the regime change happened. And
the parents of these people and the families of these people who used to tell me what are
you doing here? Like, don't be too political and this. Their parents were slaughtered in
Syria because of the inaction of the people to participate in political activity to change
the outcome and the course of this conflict. So the indifference of these people and the
difference of the other people, the Jolani people who were always present and lobbying
and they were pressuring governments to change their policies or continue in their
policies. What happened later? It led into a regime change, which led into massacres
against ethnic and religious minorities, something we were trying to stop in the past years.
So what is not a saying today is unfortunately the bitter truth. What happened in Syria also
has to be a lesson for the Armenians inside Armenia because the major player and the dynamo
behind these policies is Turkey. It was Turkey in Syria and it is Turkey now in Armenia itself.
So just to be cautious, guys, people really have to be engaged and be active. I know that
life is hard. I know that economic burden is heavy on everyone. But when it comes to
the existence of a nation, I think we need to have more collective responsibility in this.
That is my final statement on this. Navidjan? One last thing. I think your example with Syria
is very important because I know that Hayastansis in general, they didn't really have the framework
to contextualize what was happening in Syria. Even the protests that we had, they were only
concerning this one village of Kesab and they didn't have a bigger picture. So Armenians need
to have a bigger, at least the political elites in the class. They need to contextualize Armenia
correctly and understand its role in regional matters in the Middle East in general,
because we're very close to Iraq. What Armenia, what Stansi, what Hayastansi knows
about Iraq? So it's important. Navidjan, thank you so much for joining us and for sharing your
insights tonight. What is happening in Armenia right now is more than just a political crisis.
It is also our fatherland and it's a place where what we believe in, our values, our culture,
our identity has started for a very long time ago, thousands of years ago. Ladies and gentlemen,
this has been Kevor Kalmasin of Syriana Analysis and I want to thank you for watching this stream
on YouTube, on Rumble or on Ganjing World. If you found this discussion informative,
please take a moment to like this stream, thumbs up, share it with your friends and consider
supporting my independent work on Patreon so we can continue bringing fact-based analytical coverage
of global and regional affairs. Many thanks again to Navidjan and to all of you who participated in
the live chat. Until next time, my friends, stay informed, stay rational and see the world as it
is, not as they tell you it is. Peace.