Is this end of an era? After the Phillies' stunning Game 4 loss to the Dodgers, questions abound as to whether how many of these players will be back in 2026. How did this happen? Again??? Hosts John Stolnis, Justin Klugh and Liz Roscher react to the incomprehensible Orion Kerkering play, the most underrated reason why they lost Game 4, the offense that disappeared once again, and whether it's time for manager Rob Thomson to be let go.
Chapters:
00:00 - Introduction to the Season's End 02:06 - Reflections on the Phillies' Performance 05:58 - The Emotional Rollercoaster of Playoff Losses 09:01 - The Need for Change in the Team 11:55 - Analyzing the Offense's Disappearance 14:46 - The Impact of Key Players' Performance 17:51 - The Decision-Making in Critical Moments 20:35 - The Fallout from the Final Game 31:40 - The Impact of Umpiring Decisions 34:46 - Offensive Struggles and Playoff Performance 37:35 - Rethinking the Phillies Roster 41:41 - Managerial Decisions and Future Changes 53:44 - Reflections on the Season and Looking Ahead
It's all over folks 2025 Philly season is all over after game
fours.
I mean, I've used the word excruciating I think in every
game in this series, but it wrapped the excruciating game
for loss on on Thursday to the Dodgers 2 to 1 in 11 innings
that ended in one of the most bizarre hurtful crazy maniacal
sadistic ways that you could ever end a season let alone a
baseball game.
That's what happened in Dodger Stadium on Thursday night as
the Phillies lose in four games in the NLDS.
Once again, the fourth straight year super of not Super Bowl
hopes World Series.
Hopes are dashed and Super Bowl Super Bowl hopes are probably
go ahead and dash those Super Bowl hopes.
Yeah, right ahead do it.
Please.
I think you're probably right.
But here we are here.
We are on a roundtable edition of the podcast.
We didn't want to do it last night after the game because
I think we everybody just wanted a chance to rest and sleep
on that game a little bit, but we are recording here on, you
know, on Friday afternoon and we're going to try and make
sense of this whole thing and we'll look ahead just a little
bit but there obviously will be plenty of time for that here
over the next few weeks.
Justin clue and Liz Rocher joining me here.
Justin, you know from baseball perspectives, of course, and
also our hit and season patreon podcast the dirty inning and
absolutely hammered in right now.
You want as much Phillies content as you can possibly get
your hands on.
So make sure you head on over to patreon.com slash hitting
season to get all that good stuff, Justin.
I mean, I would ask how you're feeling and I guess it's a
good question given that we've we've been through this a
number of times before just in this is a very different way.
Yeah, this is more just a sadness that the Phillies really
couldn't do it like in four tries.
They really couldn't do it.
I was up there for games one and two and wound up writing
what was like 3,000 words that I wound up cutting down to
about 1,600 just about how this team refused to be a part
of any kind of narrative and that was something of a strength.
I don't know if I'd even call it even a little bit of a
weakness, but they certainly adhered to that to the end where
it just seemed like there's a million ways these things can
go and the Phillies choose a way no one seems to have been
able to imagine and yeah, that was just yeah, that's just
kind of how it goes.
But it's I'm just I'm what I'm what I'm sad about is that
it I'm just tired of feeling this way at this point and
you know, you could put a positive spin on that and say
well, hey, this is what it's like being a team that we
think the Phillies are now a franchise the Phillies are
now a team that has graduated to the level of like always
contending at least a little bit or never not contending
for very long.
This is what life is like for those teams for those Cardinals
teams for long stretches those Giants teams for long stretches
the Dodgers now the postseason almost becomes like the regular
season and that you're like, all right, we'll get them next
year and you don't have that little thing of like what if
they don't get back next year, obviously for the Phillies
this year.
It's a little different.
There's roster changes coming in the middle.
It'll be a different.
It'll be a different team next year.
But yeah, the whole point is you're not starting blowing
things up and rebuilding which I see a lot of people talking
about my yeah, you're staying close and when you stay close
and you always have a shot you go to the postseason a lot
and you don't win it a lot.
You don't win it all a lot.
So you could look at it positively.
That's probably the last time I will do so on this episode
of this show and for vibes.
I also we brought milkshake for the vibes.
So good milkshake air.
She there he is.
She is he is he is there.
He is at the end of the podcast.
I'll give you a peek at the dog that I am dog sitting all
this week.
She refuses to come into the frame so I can do anything.
She's tired of me because I needed to do this instead of
taking her out for a walk.
Well, I mean Liz Rocher you the editor.
You are the editor for Sable Sabres baseball research journal
and last night's loss with Ryan Kirkering throwing that ball
away ending the series on an error was historic.
And so I wonder how many chapters in the edition of the
baseball research journal will be devoted to this historical
moment not only in Philly's history, but in baseball history.
I mean, I'll take any and all pitches, you know, write it
up and send it to me.
I mean write it up and email me or whatever and I will get
you to the right place.
I personally don't pick the articles.
They're peer-reviewed, but you know, I could choose which
one to get through to that stage.
So well, there you go.
Yeah.
I mean, it's just well as I mean, I don't think I mentioned
at the top because like a Ryan Kirkering I was frazzled for
just a few moments there, but we are with whyy this is hitting
season and I just thought I'd squeeze that in here.
Right.
Thank you.
I'm a professional at this for crying out loud some.
I mean, I really really tossed that opening three four feet
away from where you were going.
Huh?
Yeah, I hit the back the opening at the back.
Stop.
It's just a way it goes sometimes when you're not standing
there like pointing to say the opening beginning.
You were just like, nope, gotta do it this way.
Yep.
No, I I figured I figured right here.
It was closer.
So I could just do it.
Does it matter?
No, truly.
Just during this.
No, ultimately, ultimately the amount of mistakes we've made
in this episode to creating the ultimate failure that it was
right, right will will be at fault for rather.
We were always going to lose.
We were always going to lose this podcast.
There's just no way.
Yeah.
Yeah, there's no way we're winning this podcast.
We were missing Liz for like the back half of the season due
to that do that injury.
So yeah, it's what were our chances?
Anyway, that's right.
That's right.
Oh God.
All right.
Well, I mean it is just it is I mean it's this was one of
those things where I mean, I there are different stages of
feelings after each of these four seasons, right?
I think after 2022 most of us felt it was disappointing,
but it was more of like a grateful feeling and like we
couldn't wait to look back on all the moments that led up
to it and you felt like this is something to build on and
there was it was something to build on and then in 2023
I said at the time was my heart is not broken.
It is full.
There you tell emotional and and wholesome.
I was feeling at that time were man.
I was feel different now.
Yes.
Go back to go back to that is impossible.
And I think every the crowd is always wanting to go back
to that where there's just incredible moment after incredible
moment.
And unfortunately, most playoff teams are totally like that.
But if your team isn't giving you those incredible moments,
that's a sign.
Well, and it's like you said, it is impossible to go back
to that moment where you're the upstarts and you're going
on an improbable run because there's no pressure on you,
right?
And the Phillies these last few years played as if they
had all the pressure on them.
And I don't know that, you know, I don't I don't we could
dive into the psychoanalysis of all the players and what's
going on in their heads and all this kind of stuff.
But at the end of the day, you know, they went from a
wonderful run in 2022 and they look like they were on
another wonderful, wonderful run in 2023 until the pressure
got to them.
Then, you know, they realize, hey, geez, we're one win
away from the World Series.
This is our name.
They folded that series destroyed them.
And so I think after that one, we were we were more like
shocked or like in and crushed after that series loss and
then against the Mets last year.
We were just mad that the Phillies did what they did and
just played with no heart against a divisional rival.
And this year, I think the feeling is sadness because
96 wins a National League East title that you won by 13
games over the Mets seven straight years in which you as
a franchise have increased your win total, which is a major
league record.
This season ends with more heartbreak, more sadness, more
despondency and even more questions about the future and
the direction of this franchise because a number of players
that we've come to know and love are not going to be here
after this.
Many will be many are here on long-term contracts that you
can't do anything with even if you wanted to and with a
lot of these guys who have come up small in the postseason,
you don't necessarily want to move on from them because
they're your Stars.
If you don't unless you want to go back to a rebuild, you
kind of have to keep some of these things in place.
So, you know, I just Justin.
I mean as we think about this team, I mean the psychology
has has to spur on change, right?
You can't go into next season running it back and Jason
Stark of the Athletic wrote this on Friday as well.
Like they can't run it back again.
They can't come back with with as many of these same players
returning it for no other reason.
Yes.
We've seen physically what they're what they're incapable
of doing.
But just now the psychological impact of falling short each
and every year and the way this thing ended.
There's just no way big changes aren't coming.
Yeah, I don't think that's a particularly hot take.
I think we've known that was the case too big free agents
couple other smaller free agents.
People have been assuming Ranger Suarez is is just gone.
There's been no one thinks that he's coming back.
So yeah, I think it's just it's almost like it's set up that
way, you know, some of these guys have they signed these
guys to deals that sort of parallel what they envisioned
to be a window when you sign Kyle Schwarber and Nick Castellanos
in the same offseason then yeah, you're thinking these are
guys that are going to help us win a World Series and therefore
the lengths of their deals are kind of considered a window
of sorts because they will be they will be fundamental members
of this offense and when the time comes for them to either,
you know, resign or go will have potential will probably
accomplish something.
The idea is that we will have accomplished something by
them. That is like that is kind of like the parameters of
these windows.
So that's kind of what I've been struggling with is just
so we've picked something to kind of focus on every time.
They've they've been eliminated in the postseason said, well,
they got to do this to address that and they got to do this
to address that and I think this year.
Yeah, I mean you do kind of I how many times does this group
of guys like if you gave him infinite chances, how many times
would it take to win a World Series?
I mean eventually they would but also in that scenario.
They're not I guess they can't be aging.
So you got to factor in like how their games are evolving
or devolving as well and you're just looking at a group of
guys who and we're going to like, you know, talk about what's
to blame and what's not and you know collectively there was
just a big mess and everything but like they went over for
they had four really good chances to win a World Series
and they went over for it couldn't do it for a variety of
reasons.
They couldn't do it largely comes down to just not hitting
when they're supposed to hit and I kind of looked into this
a little bit if you don't mind me expanding this answer
even further, but I started thinking.
Okay.
So like if the issue last year was oh they keep chasing pitches
out of the zone and they need a better plate approach and
we just got to get jerks and Provar and then all those problems
will be solved but this year I kind of concluded, you know,
maybe the Phillies just can't hit good pitching.
Yeah.
Now that's not just like a Phillies problem.
The reason a pitcher is good is because people struggle against
them, but I guess I'll just point out some a statistical
note that I found which was I was looking at a list of I
looked at the best pitchers in the National League.
I just went by era because I was doing a grab bag.
It's not the best statistic for something like this, but
that's what I use top 30 lowest NL eras and I put all those
guys in a list and looked at their numbers specifically
against the Phillies and then I limited it even further based
on like exposure to them because you face a lot of guys one
time and never again.
So at least seven innings of work against the Phillies with
guys who had some of the top eras in the National League you
wind up with 11 guys.
Two of those guys were on playoff teams.
And those are the guys like of these guys the Phillies face
they struggled against pretty much every guy that you would
consider a good pitcher.
There's no like guy that they were like, oh they really had
his number like obviously scenes mode them down Mackenzie
Gore crushed him on opening day and he wound up not even
really having that good of a season but like as far as good
pitchers who the Phillies could hit this year, you're looking
more at guys like Justin Verlander Robbie Ray like that level
of guy Landon group of the Giants not even sure I said his
name right Andrew Abbott of the Reds like that's the level of
guy that the Phillies like that's those are the best pitchers
the Phillies have had good numbers against and I think part
of that also is that you were seeing a Dodgers team at full
strength for pretty much the full time Blake Snell's not on
that list because he pitched in 11 games this year in the
regular season just 11.
That's a fresh arm for the playoffs and the Phillies got killed
by him every time so the Dodgers having their pitching at
Roki Sasaki coming back full strength, you know Dodgers having
all these pictures that are suddenly ready to go and the top
of the game, which is like what the Phillies were kind of
hoping Aaron Dola was going to be when he came back and what
Andrew Painter could have been if he popped up but the Dodgers
got that and the Phillies aren't good against really good
pitchers and that's what happened.
So the answer to that is get better at hitting the league's
best pitching but also you're probably going to be doing it
somewhere else.
Yeah, and I imagine that against for a lot of teams their
numbers against the the best starting pitching is also going
to be is also going to be pretty low, but we saw it in this
series and we've seen it all year how the Phillies really
struggled against good starters Liz.
I mean, and that was that was something that I just don't
know how we fix and you know, I want to get into the big fixes
later but like just in terms of of kind of moving forward
with with this group in the psychology.
I mean, like I don't know how much can you how much can you
run back?
Like how how big just without getting into specifics?
How big do the changes need to be really?
I mean, you'll have to convince me that they're going to make
a lot of big changes aside from the ones that seem like they
are already going to be done.
Like what can they put a tea a better team together than this?
Why not?
It's a good but how yeah, I don't know.
It's that's kind of my thing putting trades together.
I mean using Dave Dombrowski for what he sweats what he's here
for you built this team.
Why can't he build another one?
True.
I'm just trying to think of players specifically that would
make the team better that would not make them worse due to
the cost of the trade because if you're looking for a Major
League guy, you're going to have to send a couple of Major
League guys along with prospect.
I'm just thinking like how what kind of changes are do we
need like we know that this group of guys can do it and
could do it just because they haven't doesn't mean that they
are physically unable to but I keep coming back to the fact
that we'd sign up for this every year no matter what the
what the outcome is and at this point in my life.
I just sort of have to accept that they tried their hardest
and it wasn't good enough.
It wasn't things just didn't go right whether it was them
whether it was the situation.
It's usually a combination of the two, but what do you do?
Like you put them on a different day you put them at a different
times things might be different.
So I'm just trying to I don't know about that because they
don't know.
I'm just trying to reconcile mean it's three if this was just
this series.
I could argue that that's a that's right.
But I mean, you've got three different seasons and three
years.
I mean three and ten in their last 13 playoff games that and
it's it's largely the same guys doing the same things wrong.
I mean, it's that's that's wrong.
That's wrong.
But my head up against and maybe it is just like the this
particular group the way they all have the same foibles.
But you know, you've got a bunch of guys in this lineup who
can't hit pitchers who throw from a certain arm like, you
know, if you you know, and if it's just too much of that,
there's too much of that in this lineup, but I mean you come
back to the big three of Turner Harper Schwarber.
Those are your three culprits and and I think Liz's point is
that those are the three guys who aren't going away.
I mean, yeah, they're not going anywhere.
They're actually going.
They're actually going to resize.
I mean if if all sides point to yes, they're going to resign
one of those guys former they're going to have trouble.
They're going to resign him because his overall value is
worth it.
Despite this, you know, the playoff outage.
So you look at your roster at that point.
And if you really think that's the point you're at then you
say, okay, instead of these guys being the big three Bryce
Harper is now a supporting player in the offense.
Cal Schwarber.
We're looking at for power and nothing else and Trey Turner.
I mean, he's coming off the batting title and improved
defense.
So I don't know how far down we really want to consider him
having tumbled.
But then when you're considering players that you want to
acquire you're looking at all right.
We're looking for a new guy to fill out our big three.
That's why we're going to give Kyle Tucker a bunch of money
or something like you're recasting players and then you're
recasting the types of players.
You're then going and acquiring if you're going out there
and thinking well, we have a big three.
So let's just swap out our supporting cast for more supporting
cast members who can't hit guys who throw left or can't play
well in day games or don't know where their helmet is half
the time have some some exploitable flaw.
That's just a different exploitable flaw than the guys who
are already here then.
Yeah, you're going to get more of the same but this is the
point of this being a different team.
Isn't just that the players are going to be different the
players who are still here are also different players from
when they signed and joined the Phillies.
So you got to keep that in mind when you're building this
next roster to and that I kind of opens the door for different
types of players because you're not looking out there for
another Kyle Schwarber.
If you lose him, there is no other Kyle Schwarber.
So you're kind of changing the entire philosophy of the team
at that point.
You're changing what kind of team it is and I think that's
something you got to consider when you're building this next
version of the Phillies.
Yeah, and and Justin Crawford will be here.
Aiden Miller will see you know, but I mean again, I don't
want to mean we can get into the specifics because Dave
Dombrowski is going to address the media early next week.
I'm sure and we'll probably get some answers on that.
We'll get some answers on the manager and whether the
manager will be back.
I've got serious doubts that Rob Thompson will be back next
year after after this retiring.
Honestly.
Yeah, I think he could retire.
I mean, I think I heard somebody meant to say about Rob
Thompson.
He's a fantastic regular season manager.
Exactly the kind of guy you want for the regular season
and for the playoffs.
Not that guy, you know, and that may or may not be true.
I don't know.
I feel like that it does feel true if only because he turns
it to a different guy.
Yeah, it's a little bit of decisions are just different.
Yeah, I just a quick note also that I'll throw in there.
We mentioned Harper.
I would and like what we're going to hear at the end of
the season.
I'm not going to be surprised if we get a little note a
couple days from now that Bryce Harper was really dealing
with some right wrist inflammation for the rest of the
way that's happening because hit and his his antidote for
that was well, if I just swing at every pitch as hard as
I can something might make contact and then it'll happen.
I think that was his whole plan in the postseason and it
did not work.
I want to have at some point a very serious conversation
about where Bryce Harper is in his career and his abilities
and what he might be moving forward because he has been
the superstar on this team, but we'll leave that for another
podcast.
I do want to talk about the series.
I want to talk about the game a little bit and just I don't
think a Ryan Kirkering and what happened that he was the
main reason even they lost this game on Thursday night.
I mean, it's the ultimate play that ended the season and
he was felt to feel real bad for a long time.
He's going to feel terrible and I'm heartened that most
Phillies fans.
I think feel sorry for him and aren't throwing all of the
blame for this at him.
I don't know how he can come back with and pitch for the
Phillies after this like that's going to be really really
difficult for him to pitch effectively, but he might be
able to do that.
I'd love to think he can but he it's what I mean just a
Utterly shocking way to lose that ball comes right back
to him as soon as he kind of fumbled it a little bit.
You can see the the hamster in the wheel kind of start
going into overdrive there.
He reminds me of like a kid in my in my son's kid pitch
Little League who you know, gets a ball hit to him at
second base and somebody's, you know, they catch ball
and somebody's running and yet he wants him taking everybody
start screaming at him.
Throw it to third throw it to second throw what what what
and then they just throw it over the fence and left field
because they get so rattled and they don't know what to
do with the ball when it comes to them.
And that's what happened to Kirkering in that spot.
He doesn't feel the ground or back to him cleanly.
He's trying to locate it.
And at this point utter panic sets in for this poor man
and because he knows it's over and he can hit the clock
is running in his head.
How much time do I have to get the guy how much time
do I have to get the guy out?
And so he I'm sure is not thinking even though even
though real Mutos pointing a certain direct for him to
go to first.
He's not hearing real Muto.
He can't see like he's just on survival mode in that
moment.
And ultimately the sad thing is the runner missed home
plate.
And if you'd actually thrown it to JT real Muto, I think
the runners out but it goes four and a half feet over
everyone's head and this season was over.
But again, Liz, that's not the reason they lost this
game, but just your reaction when that happened.
I mean, it's the moment that hurt the most.
Yes, I think the one single moment where you could see
it all slip away, but it wasn't the reason that they
lost, you know, they had chance after chance, you know,
they were getting guys on base.
They were they were doing it.
They were they were making some attempts and they
could have gone.
Well, but I like a number just like the night before
a number of scoring chances were just completely wasted
by the offense.
It was really frustrating, especially since the pitching
continued to be so good.
Well on a human on a human level, I thought the generally
the response of offense has been yeah, very like he'll
probably get like if he comes back, he'll probably get
a standing O and his teammates reading the story about
how Castellanos and real Muto both immediately ran to
him and put their arms around him just because they
knew they knew that that was going to be hitting him
hard. That is wonderful.
It's exactly how you want your team to react in that
situation. Here's the thing though.
You compared it to a confused child and I don't think
that's a fair comparison.
It's a tough situation the hardest situation playing
they were playing footage from the Roy Halladay's
no-hitter and that play Chooch makes at the end of
the game is, you know, he makes it look simple, but
that is a really hard play in general area that that
Kirkering had to fill in your right this loud circus
music going off in his head and it's great to see
everyone saying you can't put all the blame on him.
Here's the thing.
You got to make that play.
You are a major league baseball player.
Of course.
It's hard.
Could I make that play?
No 10 times out of 10.
I'm not making that play right?
You are a professional baseball player.
You don't know where that you got to know where that
what you're doing with the ball before it gets to you.
I'm repeating every coach that's ever lived and I'm not
saying that to Ryan Kirkering because you know percent
and I get in that moment.
It just but the whole point is in that moment, if you're
going to win a World Series, you are good enough to win
that moment.
I know it's not fair to put all the blame on him and
I'm not right.
Imagine if that play happens in the fifth inning and
the game ends on like an ugly Nick Castellanos strikeout
or something.
Everybody is jumping on Nick Castellanos, but they're
probably there is probably still an argument of like,
well, that wasn't the reason they blah blah blah.
But in that argument, then you're saying moments like
a Ryan Kirkering overthrowing home plate or like the
reasons they lost because it's you know, not at the end.
It's just in somewhere in the middle like all the things
from last night that Liz was talking about.
So I think it's great.
Everyone is willing to say he didn't deserve any blame,
but like I guess you'll have to excuse me from not wanting
to cradle him.
So gently in my arms because this his mistake was a part
of the mishmash of mistakes that got the Phillies to
the position they're in now, which is at home on the
couch.
Like you got it.
Sorry, man.
You got to make that play.
I'm not saying it's easier than I could, but you got
to make that play.
Well, it is a story.
That's why you're there.
It's fair.
And that was an easy play like it just was if he fields
it cleanly.
It's a broken bat single right back to him.
He scoops it cleanly and throws the first but he just
he if you're going to be a professional athlete trying
to win a championship and you want that ball in the 11th
inning of a game in which you're you're going to be eliminated
if you lose you got to have it.
You got to slow your heartbeat down and he just just wasn't
able to do that.
He absolutely deserves blame.
I think it's I think it's warranted and you're right.
100% he has to make that play and he knows and he knows
that too.
The other thing is his everything he said is like, yeah,
I mean, you know again, I'm not trying to make the guy
feel bad.
It's just an objective truth.
Like you got to make you got to make that play man.
That's it.
And honestly for anybody who's saying like you got to
get rid of them either because they're currently mad at
him or like you're saying John, how does he psychologically
come back out there?
I got bad news man.
There is not a lot of right-handed pitching depth available
for the Phillies and their farm system or like, you know,
you want to go out there and make a deal for somebody that's
fine.
But the Phillies had an opinion of Orion Kirkering and an
idea for his future coming into this season.
And I don't know if they really let him go as as easily
as people are imagining.
I mean, he had a warm-up multiple times.
Yeah in that inning because there was no other option before
he came into a really ugly situation and I'm not advocating
they do.
I'm just saying I question whether he can come back.
Yeah, you know, I think honestly a kid like Kirkering this
winds up being motivation for him to like try and improve
like a bench.
Yeah, he winds up just seeing it as like, you know, and
there's going to be, you know, like an Alex coffee style
feature in spring training thinking.
We'll get two weeks of we'll get two weeks of hardcore Orion
Kirkering rehabilitational PR push and you know what?
That's fine.
That's great.
Well, they'll talk about what he did and where he went and
you know, maybe maybe comes back stronger.
Maybe he's not on the team anymore.
I don't know but yeah, I I wonder I don't think that situation
is this situation in total what happened and what will happen
next is more layered than anybody as emotionally as emotional
as we are right now is going to be able to parse out.
Yeah, I want to get into the offense here in just a second
because of all the reasons they lost this series of all the
reasons their season is over.
It is the disappearing offense, but I want to talk about
the moment that few is the fewest people seem to be talking
about or the thing that fewest people seem to be talking
about and that's that's the bases loaded walk by Joanne
Duran that 40 minute in the tying run and that that was
that was a killer obviously because it's what forced extra
innings.
I mean, you just you handed the Dodgers a run Phillies pitchers
did not allow a single hit in this game to score run.
It was an it was a I was joking with Justin on text right
before the the Kirkering mess up with and we just said,
can you imagine if both runs scored in this game is because
they got walked in turned out.
It would be much worse than that.
But but John Duran, I first may ask you what do you think
about the decision?
I'll start with you Liz to walk show.
He Ohtani intentionally, right?
There's two outs runners on second and third.
You've got the right-hander Duran against show.
He Ohtani.
Who's the lefty show Ohtani has had a miserable postseason
one for 18.
I think it was one for 17 at that point with having a miserable
postseason but had only faced a right-handed pitcher.
I think once in the series to that point and that was Aaron
Nolan the first inning.
Otherwise, it was all lefties.
And so Rob Thompson did not want to have Duran face Ohtani
righty on lefty and instead loaded the bases because he wanted
to go righty righty with Mookie Betts.
Mookie Betts is a great player.
I still think that was the right decision.
But what it did was it left no margin for error for Duran and
Duran who has never walked anyone with the bases loaded in his
career.
Can't for whatever reason can't in that moment find the strike
zone.
I don't know what's whether he was afraid of Betts making
contact.
He was afraid of a big hit.
He wanted to get Betts to chase whatever it was when you after
you start off to a no, that's when you kind of really felt
boy.
This is not you've lost control of this plate appearance.
If you're Joe on Duran and so I don't know.
What did you make of the decision to walk Ohtani?
I mean in the playoffs
Topper likes to make decisions that have
that have part of the outcome already figured out
like whether it's to the advantage or not the advantage.
Like if you do this,
you already know the outcome of the next play.
It's going to be bases loaded and you know, like he did.
I don't know why he wouldn't want to let him face it.
He's doing so badly.
Does he not trust Johan Duran to get him out?
I would have.
So even though he's a righty like I just don't understand
that to begin with.
I don't like the decision to load the bases no matter if
he's done it in his career or not.
Now, you're making it.
You're giving the chance of him loading walking in a run.
You're making those much greater
much much greater because now you've loaded the bases for
him.
I just didn't like it at all.
I didn't understand why he made that decision or what led
him to like I do understand it.
But like why limit yourself so much in the playoffs?
Well, on the one hand, I mean I get him wanting to play
the matchups.
That's a playoff Rob decision and I get trusting Duran probably
of all people to not do exactly what he did because he when
he did it it was for the first time ever.
So I probably trust Duran with the bases loaded in that
situation and but the counter to that is how well the Phillies
just controlled Otani the entire series.
He was a non-factor.
So like are you worried about him like this being the moment
he puts it together and you know that that everybody's waiting
for or do you I mean, it's not like again, it's not like the
top of the Dodgers order you get past Otani and you're like,
okay, these are manageable hitters, you know, any one of
those guys can beat you.
I don't know.
It didn't jump out to me as like a particularly egregious
decision, but what it did after what happened happened, you
know, the unthinkable.
It kind of goes into this bigger reason as to why the Phillies
lost which was, you know, look at how well they were and
they're how well they played in the regular season how good
they were how many people picked them to win the World Series
because of how well they were playing going into the
postseason and one of the big reasons we credited to that
was how successful trade deadline they had when again, it
was pretty much universally agreed.
The Phillies had the best trade deadline of any team.
Yeah, and then you hit the postseason and where's your
trend that trade deadline?
Well, one of them is walking in a run for the first time and
deeply impacting the elimination game.
The other one pulled his groin then isn't really playing or
at least not in a way that his all of his value can be on
display playing in center field.
So and then in 11th, you're kind of kneecapped.
Well, and the 11th inning with a chance to knock in Harper
from second base.
He had a Harrison Bader battled but then then chase the ball
two feet out of the strike zone to end the at bat.
So yeah.
Yeah.
So that was one of your biggest strengths.
One of the things you'd point to as something that really gave
this team a boost that wound up just being a non-factor for
him in the in the playoffs, but I don't have a conclusion
there.
That's just no, it's just what it is.
And one of the factors that led to that run being walked in
was the umpire missing that called third strike.
Oh, baby.
Did he ever.
That's sweet of him to apologize.
You got to know how little that means after the fact, bud.
Yep, it means literally nothing.
It's like it's actually makes it worse.
Yeah, what does he do?
He meets Christopher's or yeah, Sanchez.
You got the apology.
Yeah, and he meets him.
What in the hallway and he's just like, oh, hey Chris, I just
I just watched the footage from that pitch.
Get this totally out of the zone.
My bad crazy, right?
Anyway, see you out there.
Like I don't know great man.
I hope you great.
It's great.
You can sleep at night now.
That's fantastic.
Well done because we're going to look at.
We're going to look at next year.
Once abs is here and everyone's going to say they had that
if they had that last year Philly's probably win game for
I mean, that's how that's how razor close this thing was.
So yeah, I think the John Duran moment was an enormous moment
that whole inning obviously, but Alex call of all people.
I'm freaking out around Alex.
God, they don't put it down the middle or anything.
I can't.
Yeah, him and Kike Hernandez just giant annoying bottom of
the order rats.
Tell me Tom.
Exactly.
Edmund.
Tommy Edmund started on Tommy Edmund.
Universal power threat.
Tommy Edmund.
Yeah, the Phillies cannot get these guys out.
These horrible guys.
Well, I'm here.
Kike Hernandez turns into a monster in the playoffs always
turns into a monster in the playoffs.
I don't know what it is, but he turns into Superman.
Well, and I'll tell you this.
The Phillies have a couple guys just like that.
Like Brandon Marsh Bryson Stott Alec Boehm that they're all
of that caliber, right?
They're all kind of the same ability, you know, the same
kind of production.
Andy Pajes, you know, throw him into the mix here.
Like all those guys are the same kind of caliber as those
Phillies guys.
I just mentioned and yet those guys find a way to elevate
their game in October and Bryson Stott looked utterly lost
in the series.
Brandon Marsh didn't do a thing in this series.
Boehm had some moments.
So you can't you can't really throw as much on Boehm as you
can.
Some of the other guys but you know, he wasn't a world beater
in this didn't come up with any really big moments.
So, you know, it's just again and that's that's a good way
to transition to the offense here because this is the reason
they lost the series right as a whole overall you score three
runs in game one three runs in game two.
You have the nice game in game three and then one run in game
four in 11 innings and I get it that the Dodgers pitching was
really good.
I mean the stuff was amazing the starting pitching throughout
the series was incredible.
The Dodgers top four starting pitchers at a 2.28 era in 23
and two-thirds innings as starters and relievers when the
starters were asked to be in the bullpen.
Those guys did and the same thing with the Phillies Matt
Gelb noted this in his article on Friday, the Phillies top
four starting pitchers a 203 era in 26 and two-thirds innings
as starters and relievers neither offense did anything in
this series with the exception of the Phillies in game three,
but the Phillies hit 212 in this series against the Dodgers
Dodgers at 199 in the series, but a few more big hits here
and there the big home run by Tasker Hernandez in game one,
like you just have these these little things that happened
the big moments the Will Smith to run single right in game
to just couple of big moments here and there you just why
you just needed you needed someone to just come up at some
point and do something you didn't need the team to hit 300
in this series.
Like the starting pitching was so good, but it all ultimately
Justin showed once again starting pitching is not the most
important thing in October.
It's offense.
It's bullpen and starting pitching in that order and in
my mind as long as the Phillies continue to focus all of
their energy and effort on starting pitching.
This could continue to happen.
Yeah.
I mean, that's another reason why I'm more ready to see a
different Phillies team than before, you know, be we could
talk about making changes been all last offseason talking
about trading Alec Boehm and that you know, obviously didn't
happen but there's been changes, you know, casually or more
aggressively threatened for this roster and this lineup and
everything for the past few years and each time I'm like,
you know, ultimately I'd be a little sad to see that guy go
or like, oh, it's a shame to like change things up without
this team kind of like having a World Series title to stake
to this era.
There's a point where I would have even said it was I don't
want Nick Castellanos to go anywhere because like this, you
know, as much as Castellanos he as he is, he's still like a
funny guy to have around who can, you know, who was an all-star
at one point for the Phillies.
But yeah at this point, I think like a lot of people it's
played out, you know, and I'm ready to see this see this
roster kind of clear its throat a little bit and see, you
know, four or five new guys like regulars just in the clubhouse
guys who are here for a reason and to make this team into a
different team because the more we're talking about it the
more it feels like that's that's the move is everything we
talked about last year like God changed the approach.
I think you can just change the approach by like changing
who's around to make the approaches and just have guys in
and just change what kind of team this is because I think
I think that's what you do at this point.
I think you realize okay, the kind of team we focused on
having just isn't the kind of team that gets it done.
You know, you can look at it and be like, oh, we were two
big moments away from moving on to the next round, which by
the way, I had a hard time remembering that.
Oh, yeah, our reward for winning this series and probably
will be two more series that will probably be just like this
for the rest of the month.
So again, my body and mind.
Thank the Phillies for getting a little bit.
Oh my God.
Yeah, seeing a different team next year.
That's got like a little more whiz defensively a little more
pop offensively, you know, that's how you address problems.
Like we were two big moments shy of moving on from the NLDS.
You don't think well, let's let's get in the batting cage.
Let's get a guy who hit two more home runs than Kyle Schwarber
that guy doesn't exist in the National League.
Let's let's let's let's address these things specifically
at this point.
I think it's more of a wholesale thing and I'm not saying to
blow up situation.
I just mean enough changes to kind of change how this team
is put together and how it operates.
I'm I'm ready to see something different.
I think the Phillies probably are too.
I think that's I think that's why this is going to be probably
more interesting offseason than we've seen in a while because
the Phillies are going to be a different team come spring.
So who do we think?
Definitely won't be back Liz.
I don't think I think we all got it.
I mean, I don't think I don't think Castellanos is going to
be here.
I honestly, you know, in the past couple weeks have been
thinking more and more about well, let's just run through
the rest of the list first.
I think I think you can see up to two of the three out of
Boehm, Marsh, and Stott moved as part of a trade somewhere.
And I think I really don't think it's a guarantee that Kyle
Schwarber comes back.
Well, I agree 100%.
Yep.
I honestly starting to think more and more about, you know,
again, we got this view from a thousand miles away, but every
statement he's made and whether it's in text or video and
obviously he's not going to say exactly what's going on,
but every response has been aggressively non-committal and
I don't know.
I just kind of this is just my opinion, but I get to get the
feeling that he's ready to move on and just, you know, he's
got this kind of Puff the Magic Dragon quality to him and
that he goes where he's needed and like makes a lot of people
happy and then moves on and he's done that a couple of times
now.
I think that's Pete's dragon not Puff the Magic Dragon.
I think you're thinking are you thinking of Pete's dragon?
I am thinking of Pete's dragon.
Yeah, there's a different dragon.
Because I'm singing through this song in my head and like
nowhere is any of this mentioned. There's lots of songs in
Pete's dragon too.
To be fair, yeah, and Pete also, yeah, Pete is, he did, he
was magic because he was invisible.
So, but you did say Puff the Magic Dragon.
He did.
Well, that's a different, that's a different famous dragon.
It's a different P-dragon.
It just, there's, there's two and it's easy to get them
confused. Two famous dragons and it just so happens. The
creatively starved dragon artists of bygone eras are not
what I'm here to talk about.
There is a window.
Oh, Schwarber.
Yeah, I think in general, I think there's just a little bit
of, I don't know, kind of like bittersweet sadness in his
eyes and his statements every time people have been like
look, look, there's like a poster from some fans that are
like, please re-sign with us, Kyle Schwarber, we love you.
And he's just like, this is really great.
This means a lot to me and then just like puts it in his
pocket and everyone's like, yeah, do you want to say anything
else though?
And he's like, I'm good.
You guys.
Yeah, I mean, I, let's just, maybe like he goes to the Reds.
Maybe that is like a thing, you know, I can, I don't know,
I can, I can see it happening and really the good news there
is then like a bunch of money is freed up and it creates
an opportunity for, for new players in the new kind of like
situation that I'm talking about, you know, like you're saying
goodbye to the lion's share of your power, which you either
need more of, or I guess abandon it entirely and become a
different kind of team that just doesn't hit for a lot of
power.
But in any case, I can see, I really don't think it's a
guarantee he comes back.
I honestly think it's more likely that RealMuto comes back
really out of necessity than Kyle Schwarber at this point.
Suarez is gone and I think you see a little bit of churn in
the bullpen, but Strom's coming back.
I wouldn't be surprised to see Kirkering back, Duran's coming
back, you know, so I think the names I said, I think are the
most likely ones.
Bader's kind of interesting.
Yeah, I could see them kind of doubling down on him because
he is a true center fielder, even when he's not hitting and
they haven't had one since Shane Victorino.
Yeah, and I like the energy he brought, Liz.
Yeah, I'm a huge fan of the guys that they acquired, like I
know that Duran is staying, but Bader should stay.
He was a perfect fit for this team, even if they change some
of the personnel.
It's more about his personality, I think, and he was just so
good, like I would, it's really a shame.
I think if he had been healthy, things might have ended a little
differently, a little, I'm not saying it would have wholesale
changed the outcome, but it could have ended a bit differently
that would have us feeling differently.
Who knows?
Yeah, I'm just looking for anything I could cling to that
might mean that this would be different.
Right.
In terms of who's leaving, I think, I think Bohm is gone.
They reported, I think Jason Stark reported in his article on
Friday.
They, they tried to move him a lot harder than they let on, like
they really were ready to move on a shock face, right?
Are you saying Rob Thompson called Alec Bowman lied about the
aggressiveness of the Phillies wanting to trade him?
He told him we're not trying to trade you, but there's interest
in you and we're just responding to it.
Yes, we're just reacting to it.
I don't subterfuge possible.
That was not a true, a truth.
It might have been a fib there and I think, I think, I think
Stoddard Marsh, frankly, if you're bringing back Harrison Bader,
Brandon Marsh can go.
Yeah, because if you're going to bring Justin Crawford up, you have
Justin Crawford in one spot, Bader in another spot and then you
figure out, try and get another bat to replace Nick Castellanos
who will absolutely be gone.
I would say right now, I agree with you Justin, I think the odds are
better Kyle Schwarber is not back and I don't know that as valuable
as he has been for the clubhouse and as valuable as he is with
everything, I, I, that place might need a little bit of different
energy.
It might need someone, someone different to come in and kind of
rattle, not rattle cages.
Like, what are you guys doing?
But just some brashness, you know, like not Jimmy Rollins himself,
but like somebody like that to come in and just kind of put like
a, of some fresh air into the room because the one thing you can't
do is come in and breathe that same air with those same guys, you
know, and maybe that I'm not saying Kyle Schwarber is in any way
to blame for any kind of negative vibes or anything like that at
all, not in the slightest.
And if they bring him back, I'll be very, very happy that they do
but it's a way to change things up.
It's a way to kind of make the lineup look a little bit differently.
It's a way to try and get rid of some of the streakiness that we
see in this lineup.
So I think right now, I'd be leaning towards Schwarber probably
not coming back to because I agree that I think the sounds are
kind of similar that he's not coming back and I don't think Rangers
Juarez is coming back.
So that would be a lot of change and then it's just a matter of
like how you go about changing, you know, filling those different
guys out and you're going to have to I think one of the things
they absolutely, absolutely have to do and if they let Schwarber
go, they're going to have to get two impact offensive bats because
man, they need somebody who can clean up on this team.
Like every trying to figure out who's hitting number four based
on who had the last hottest three games, whether it's Bohm or
Real Muto or Castellanos or whoever it is, like just who's been
hot for the last 72 hours.
Okay, you're hitting fourth.
Give Harper some protection.
You know, that's just like it's like picking a defense every week
for your fantasy team.
Who's playing the Bengals?
That's right.
Exactly.
So yeah, a lot of notes you saw about the Brewers coming into
the postseason was how and like their success was how well they
do fundamentally, you know, and it's corny to say like, oh they
hit the cutoff man.
It's like, well, yeah, you got to hit the cutoff man.
Who's not hitting the cutoff man and going to the postseason
and then you watch your Phillies game and you remember, oh, yeah,
even when this team is winning eight to one, they still run the
bases like trains that are off the tracks and careening through
small towns.
They still, you know, dive for balls.
They're not going to catch and like being in a playoff game
doesn't change the approach that like, look, it's it's great
to be aggressive.
But like this, you're not, you're not aggressive, right?
Like a lot of time and that balls rolling back to the fence and
in the postseason that's costing you three times as much as
it's costing you in the regular season.
So I guess what I'm saying is one of the Phillies big problems
and that I would love to see changed is a team that does kind
of like have focus on and have accountability for not doing
the fundamental things, right?
The little things just being sharper at the little thing.
Let's start there.
You know, we this was a team that did a lot of small things,
right?
And then graduated to let's bring in let's bring in superstars.
Let's like let's get these guys who are who are capable of
performing in those big moments because maybe you had like
a lot of guys are like, yeah, I can I can play well for you
every day.
But if I come up with runners in scoring position in the ninth,
you can't really rely on me.
So you bring in the Schwarbers you bring in the Harpers you
bring in these guys and I don't know.
Maybe the Phillies just got a little top-heavy where it was
like we have a bunch of guys who want that big moment and
they kind of when they're not hitting well in those big
moments than the team's just like, okay.
Well, we got to do the little things, right?
And they don't really they don't you can't you certainly
can't rely on the Phillies to do everything small, right?
You know, they'll they'll have streaks of base running gaps
and we saw that those streaks of defensive miscues.
We saw that throwing errors.
We obviously saw that so that would be an interesting new
vibe for this team with to be like look more at the Brewers
who are this small unsung team.
I'm sorry.
I'm just inwardly rolling my eyes at the cliche of it all
but still they are that is that is what they are.
And when you say they do the little things, right?
That is also a cliche but it is also something that can be
true and it's something that is not true.
I think about the Phillies not consistently and that would
be an area to kind of focus on when you're looking at more
perhaps Harrison Bader's on your roster.
I will say it is interesting.
And again, I've been screaming about the fact that the by
week shouldn't affect teams.
Maybe it does affect the Phillies and it doesn't affect
other teams.
I mean, this is the second straight year.
They came out of a by and a week off unable to function.
Whereas in the two previous postseasons, I've always resisted
that I've always resisted that.
Well, I think the difference here is that they should
they should if they if they are incapable of doing that that
is a problem for them without it at all, you know, it's not
like oh, well like we need to change like the while the
Braves like we got changed the system.
No, don't do that.
It's messes up all teams.
No, no, no, it doesn't mess up all team.
That is a weakness of your team, correct?
If you come off a by week cold.
Yeah.
Yeah, I'm not saying that it's right and I'm not saying they
should change the rules.
I'm just saying I think it's a weakness of the Phillies and
I think that yeah, you know, the going all out for the division
title and are trying to get the number two.
So we maybe it's I'm just saying his fans with this group.
Let's not make that such a such a big deal next time because
I think we've seen at least in two years very small sample
size.
They've had to buy and played like horse dung coming out of
it looking like they hadn't played in a month.
So I want to go.
Go ahead.
No, go ahead.
This is that's better as a final thought.
I was going to say I'm going to ask one last thing because
I think we'll get news about this one way or the other probably
before we record again.
Just get you on the record as far as Rob Thompson goes.
Would you make a change at manager?
I at this moment only I at this moment, I would lean towards
making a change at manager.
I think you're not going to be able to change out a lot of
the players.
It's just kind of the nature of the business, right?
And I know that Rob Thompson's had more success as a regular
season manager than just about any other manager in Philly's
history.
But I do think there is some truth to the fact that he manages
the regular season really well and his mentality and his style
and his decisions are what's best to get you through 162
games.
And that is the most important getting to the tournament, but
I for whatever reason he has he has not been able to get his
team ready to play in the playoffs and what that means.
I don't really know.
I don't really know what a manager needs to do, but the
messaging can't be well tough out last year guys, but this
you know, this year is our year unfinished, but like I this
this might be this I think calls for a situation where you
need a new voice where maybe the players have to do things
differently than they did it under Rob Thompson.
Maybe they have to change their habits.
Maybe different.
Maybe they they're doing different things in spring training.
Maybe they're maybe they're focusing on different things
and Rob Thompson had them focus focusing on maybe the communication
is different than it was under Rob Thompson.
I don't know what it is.
This ain't working whatever they've got going on here.
And I think one of the one of the surest ways that you can
change things up is is making a change at manager.
Could it blow up in their faces?
Absolutely 100% but right now if the Phillies tell me that
Rob Thompson is coming back in 2026, I think I would be more
disappointed than encouraged by that news.
Liz, let me throw this your way first.
What would you do with Rob Thompson?
What do you think we will do?
What would you do and what do you think they will do?
Okay, I think they will keep him.
I think they will I don't think despite all of the racket
about people wanting changes to be made and the Phillies
themselves wanting changes to be made.
It doesn't feel like they're ready to make that particular
change yet.
They trust Rob Thompson a lot though.
Maybe his actions in the playoffs should make them reconsider
that I would probably stick with him.
If it were me for all the reasons I just said but it feels
hard.
It feels like it's going to be hard to find someone.
No, it's not right.
It could be anybody.
It just doesn't feel like the Phillies are ready to do it
yet.
And I think I think maybe I think maybe they're right.
If you're in a position where you need to change things
and you don't feel like you have a lot of buttons to press
player personnel wise then the manager is what you turn to
so I can totally see that happening and I can totally seeing
it being a healthy change.
I mean, this is why when a Girardi gone because a different
voice was just needed in the clubhouse.
I don't have any anger towards Rob Thompson the way I was
ready to be getting done with Joe Girardi, but I am I think
I feel like formally at the point where I could I would support
him being removed.
I feel like he would be given as all managers who leave in
good terms from the Phillies are an opportunity and like the
front office or something.
I don't think he would take it but I think that you know,
they probably like you want to be like some kind of assistant
to the whatever you can come sit in like just get an ID badge
or whatever and you can still hang out.
But I think I think he would just kind of quietly move on
as he was planning to before he was, you know, the manager
of a World Series team.
Yeah, I would be I would find it refreshing if they let
him go.
I wouldn't be totally disappointed, but I'm with you
John.
I think I lean a little more like 55 45 towards towards
feeling better about the Phillies going into the year
with a with a different manager just because change is needed
even sometimes even things that seem like they're working.
It's not it's not that you're changing it because it's not
working.
You're just changing it because change is required and that's
that's kind of what we're talking about here.
Change is required the theme of the 2025 Phillies yearbook
video as that'll be in stores at your mobile sporting goods
coming in January everybody.
So make sure you get your pre-orders in now.
All right, let's finish up with some final thoughts.
The Philly season is over.
We are going to enter an offseason.
And so let this be our final thoughts for this episode
of the podcast and I guess the official end of the 2025
Philly season Justin.
Let me start with it.
Well two things one.
There's an article on Phillies.com right now that that
the headline refutes exactly what we were just talking about
in terms of Kyle Schwarberg.
The headline reads despite crushing loss Schwarberg wants
back in Philadelphia that is on the Phillies website and that
is the headline then you look at the URL.
The URL is different from the headline.
The URL says Kyle Schwarberg discusses potential return to
Phillies after Dodgers loss.
I am now looking through this article for a Kyle Schwarberg
quote that says something that would mean I want to come back
that would mean those words together.
I'm going to read you the entirety of the quote that Mark
Lupica put in to this article that has the headline again
despite crushing loss Schwarberg wants back in Philadelphia.
It doesn't feel good.
You know, you just make a lot of different relationships
in the clubhouse.
You never know how it's going to work out, right?
You just make so many personal relationships with guys and
you spend how much time with these guys throughout the course
of the year and they become family and you just never know
how it's going to go.
How you guys doing so far?
You feel like how Schwab is coming back to Philadelphia.
Me neither, but these guys all know how I feel about them.
I've got a lot of respect for the guys in here our organization
the coaching staff every everyone top to bottom.
This is a premier organization.
A lot of people should feel very lucky that one night you're
playing for a team that is trying to win every single year.
Hey guys doing so far here about Kyle Schwarberg coming
back to the Phillies.
Definitely me neither.
And you have a bit and you have a fan base that cares.
You have you have ownership that cares and you have coaches
that care you have everyone in the room that cares.
There's no other reason we're all about winning and it's
a great thing.
I think that's why it hurts just as much as any other year.
Okay, so that's the end of the quote and I can't help but
notice that there is not a guarantee that Kyle Schwarberg
is coming back or wants to come back to Philadelphia.
One paragraph later the article ends and that paragraph is
full of people who could become new free agents that would
replace Kyle Schwarberg.
So I think that headline might be intended for people like
me to click on it and get reassured.
Read the article.
In fact, that is not what the article says second point.
This is the first year I realized as we were talking.
I'm actually very excited to continue watching the MLB
postseason.
There's some scene.
There's some teams.
I really want to see what happens.
There's there's a very it's very likable.
I think a remainder of the ALDS, you know, I know the Tigers
organization has some awful awful stuff come out about it near
the end of this regular season and that's not what I'm rooting
for but the players on the field seeing a Tigers Mariners and
LDS go five games and then watch one of those teams take on
the Blue Jays and the ALCS.
I mean that is so refreshing and like Cubs or Brewers fighting
the playing the Dodgers.
I mean Dodgers are a boring playoff entry at this point, but
like one of those teams winning would be very cool as well and
make for a fairly interesting World Series that without the
Dodgers in it.
More importantly, Robin Banford would hate a Blue Jays Brewers
World Series.
Yes, he would which is really good for baseball and me and I
would watch that and additionally sidebar out of this.
This is the first year out of these four years where I don't
I don't like the Dodgers, but I don't have any visceral hatred
for them leaving this like it's not like a
It's just it just never happened.
There was never like an Orlando RC a moment or like the Mets
obviously or the Astros a hateable team already.
I don't know.
I'm not saying the Dodgers are particularly likable.
I just didn't leave this playoff loss with just like a visceral
hatred of the Dodgers.
I'm more frustrated just like with the diamondbacks.
I'm more frustrated with the Phillies than anybody.
Yeah.
Yeah, the Dodgers are very corporate and that's kind of how
you felt how it feels and yeah, there's nothing I'm not rooting
for them now, but like there's no player that I was like that
guy really got our guy.
I was waiting for like Max Muncy to have some kind of smart
comment.
That was going to be like, I don't know if somebody said
something I missed it.
No, I don't know.
I think you're right.
They don't have a reason to feel that way.
They won.
They won and pretty decisively.
So yeah, Liz final thoughts.
My main emotion coming out of this season is just like
disappointment.
It's barely even anger.
It's just it's disappointment because it seemed like they were
set up.
Well to actually do it and they didn't and I thought it would
be a very nice poetic end to the season in which my grandmother
passed away, but my grandmother like so many other Phillies
fans over their lifetime will unfortunately not see this next
World Series championship and I blame the Phillies for that.
I'll also add that at the very least in this for this this
era, which I do think is over.
We can call it over of playoff runs.
The Phillies never won the World Series.
They did make sure that Albert Pujols, Yadier Molina, and
now Clayton Kershaw all went out quite crappily at the end
of their careers.
There's a positive and there's no victory.
There's some satisfaction.
Just an always good outlining.
Yeah, Kershaw is always, you know, he's the only pitcher
that they have in this series, but it's very satisfying to
watch a guy like Clayton Kershaw get lit up in his last
appearance.
Yep.
All right guys.
Well, that's going to do it for this edition of hit and season
out. We'll be back when news warrants.
There'll be a there'll be an end of season news conference
at some point next week and we'll be will certainly be updating
everybody on any news that comes down the pike here over the
next few weeks in the meantime folks.
So thank you for joining us here on this on this season of
ups and downs.
It was a fun regular season.
Most of the time and here in the playoffs, obviously a crushing
disappointment, but we're going to keep we're going to keep
going.
We're going to keep going because that sentence John, come
on. That's our lot in life.
But what I want to encourage everybody to continue to subscribe
and and listen to the podcast.
We'll keep you.
We'll keep you company during this offseason.
That is sure to be a very very interesting one.
Indeed for Justin clue Liz Rocher.
Thanks everybody for tuning in.
We'll talk to you next time right here on hitting season.