An opposed beach landing is the most difficult and dangerous military operation it is possible to undertake. Anticipating massive casualties during the course of Operation Overlord, the British Army devised a series of highly specialized tanks to solve some of the problems – Hobart’s Funnies.
Named after General Sir Percy Hobart, commander of their parent unit, 79th Armoured Division, the Funnies included a mine clearing tank – the Sherman Crab, a flamethrower - the Churchill Crocodile and the AVRE – Assault Vehicle Royal Engineers which could lay bridges and trackways, blow up fortifications and much else besides. The unit also included the incredible floating tank – the Sherman DD, which formed an essential part of the Normandy landings.
The development of this experimental technology wasn’t easy, with lessons having to be learned from the tragic outcomes of both the Dieppe Raid and Exercise Smash. But the minds behind these unique vehicles knew that they must succeed – the operation could not move ahead without them. History was made on the beaches of Normandy, and it was the Funny Tanks of Overlord that led the way.
00:00 | Introduction 01:24 | Operation Overlord 03:02 | Lessons from the Dieppe Raid 05:31 | The Sherman DD 07:21 | Exercise Smash 14:38 | Sherman Crab 17:38 | The AVRE 19:47 | Churchill Crocodile 23:15 | Did the Funnies Work? 28:49 | Conclusion
This video features archive footage courtesy of British Pathé.
In this film, Chris Copson looks at surviving examples of the Funnies and assesses their effectiveness during the D-Day Landings. From the floating Sherman DD, to the Swiss Army Knife Churchill AVRE, to the terrifying flamethrowing Churchill Crocodile, the 79th Armoured Division had a host of unique and highly-specialised vehicles at their disposal. Operation Overlord would not have been successful without these incredible tanks – watch this video to find out why.
No military operation is as difficult and dangerous as landing on an enemy-occupied beach.
In one of the most accurate cinematic depictions of the D-Day landings,
the first 20 minutes of Saving Private Ryan show this in harrowing detail.
Men emerge from assault craft and struggle through the shallows, all the time in clear
line of sight of an enemy that exacts a brutal toll on the attackers. We see anti-landing
None of this was a surprise. Allied military planners knew exactly what was waiting for
them in Normandy. But, largely thanks to one man, the British had a plan to minimise losses.
In this video, we'll be looking at surviving examples of some of the funnies
and asking what they could do, how they worked, why the Americans didn't listen,
and how successful, how effective they were on D-Day. We'll also talk to John Pearson, the man
who's restored the last surviving Valentine DD, and see his tank at one of the original training
locations. Operation Overlord, the D-Day landings, which began on the 6th of June 1944, were always
British, Canadian and US forces would land on five beaches, codenamed Sword, Juno and Gold
in the east, through to Omaha and Utah in the west, while airborne forces made landings to
secure objectives inland and protect the flanks of the beaches. The scale was vast. On the 6th of
June alone, 160,000 troops would land from a fleet of 5,000 vessels, accompanied by an aerial
armada of 1,200 aircraft. By the summer of 1944, the German occupying forces had four years
to create Festung Europa, Fortress Europe. Supervised in part by General Feldmarshal
Erwin Rommel, the strongest and best defended element, the Atlantic Wall, comprised a 20km
deep strip, extending from the Zuiderzee to the mouth of the Loire. This was dominated by coastal
defence artillery and fortified emplacements, smaller guns designed to fire along the beaches
to infilate attacking troops, and Wiederstandmessen, or resistance posts, mounting automatic weapons.
The beaches were festooned with anti-landing obstacles, often bearing telemines,
and any likely field for glider-borne landings was similarly obstructed.
If the invasion was defeated, it would take the Western Allies at least two years to try again,
and the omens, in some ways, were not good. The Dieppe Raid of August 1942, an attempt to
capture an enemy-held port, had ended in total failure, with over half of the mainly Canadian
raiding force killed or captured. The Calgary Regiment's Churchill tanks had also experienced
major problems negotiating the beach and sea wall. This was, however, a learning exercise,
and it taught two things. One, that trying to take a port would be too difficult because of
the concentration of defences, and secondly, the landing force would need specialised help
to crack the nut of enemy defences and obstacles. General Sir Alan Brooke, Chief of the Imperial
General Staff, decided on the formation of a special unit, 79th Armoured Division, and,
possibly against his better judgement, appointed Major General Sir PCS Hobart, DSO, MC, to command
it. Percy Hobart was an officer of the Royal Engineers, who transferred to the Royal Tank
Corps in the 1920s, and became an advocate of using tanks in independent units, rather than
alongside slower-moving infantry. This didn't make him popular with the traditionalist element
of the General Staff. He was also arguably just plain wrong. Despite having successfully
trained the 7th Armoured Division, the Desert Rats, in Egypt in 1940, he was sacked and sent
home. Hobart spent most of 1940 as a corporal in the Home Guard. We have the makeshift pike he was
issued with before receiving the rifle. He was then reinstated by Winston Churchill.
Hobart was appointed to command a new formation, 79th Armoured. Now, the British 79th Armoured
Division was unusual. It never fought as an armoured division normally would, but it's a
holding unit for specialised vehicles that were then lent out for specific missions to other units.
Here, Hobart was right in his element. His ability to think outside the box, to solve problems, and
his huge energy made him an absolute natural for this job. 79th Armoured rapidly became a collection
of some of the strangest armoured fighting vehicles ever to be serviced on a battlefield.
Tanks have revolutionised modern warfare, but you've got to be able to use them to the best advantage.
One of the strangest of the funnies, and the one we're going to look at first,
is the one that solved the problem of how to get armour onto the beach at that critical
early landing stage, minimising the possibility of the saving private Ryan scenario.
Now, what we need to do was ensure that tanks were landing at the same time that infantry were
disembarking from their LCIs. That way, tanks could provide fire support. The answer came from an
emigre Hungarian inventor, Nikolaus Straussler, in the form of the duplex drive, or DD Sherman.
Straussler realised that if you massively increase the displacement of a tank,
even though it's 25 tonnes of very solid metal, it will float. This worked by installing a
rubberised canvas screen around the hull of the tank, braced on the inside by steel scaffolding
and inflatable tubing. At the rear, two steerable propellers meant that not only could the DD float,
but it could swim, steered by the commander standing on a small platform and operating a
long tiller. One of the problems that had to be solved was how to get power from the tank's
forward-mounted transmission to the propellers, which obviously are at the back. Now, the way
they managed to sort this out was to replace the idler wheels at the back with a second set of
sprockets, so the propellers were driven by the tracks. Our DD is the last surviving example,
with the canvas screen, the supporting framework and duplex drive system intact.
The black line you can see up there is the water line when the vehicle is afloat. As you can see,
there is actually very little freeboard. The system was initially trialled using Tetraf light
tank in Brent Reservoir, and then using Valentine infantry tanks at Stokes Bay near Gosport,
and here at Stublin Bay in Dorset. There's one remaining running Valentine DD tank. It's owned
by longtime friend of the Tank Museum, John Pearson, who has brought it here today on the
80th anniversary of Exercise Smash. So, John Pearson, you have had a huge amount to do with
the commemoration of Exercise Smash, and this is your baby. This is the last surviving intact
Valentine DD. Yes, that's right. Now, I know these things, they weren't used in active service.
These were training tanks. Yes. Could you just talk us through the actual operation of the DD?
Yes, how it works. How it works, how you put the skirt up. The first part is, to make it float,
you have to displace its own weight of water, and that is done by inflating these tubes with
compressed air at about 30 pounds per square inch. That lifts this frame, the tube is attached
to the frame, lifts the frame up to about nine feet high, and then when the tank floats, the tank
is actually hanging below the water surface, and the water level is level with the top of the
turret. So, while it's coming ashore, it just looks like a rubber boat. As soon as you land,
you let all the air out, down comes the frame with a crash, and you've got a fighting tank on the beach.
Is there any sort of scaffolding to brace it inside? Yes, there's folding arms there,
they operate just like your own arm, like that, and then when the screen is up, they go clunk
and lock, and then there's a little hydraulic ram that pushes it over center, and down it comes.
So, if the screen is nine feet high, I'm thinking that's just above the level of the turret? Yes,
that's about 18 inches to two feet of freeboard, I suppose. That's not very much,
as the guys out here actually discovered during Exercise Smash. The major problem,
strangely, is not the height of the waves, it's the distance apart of the waves. If they're too
close, then the tank, being so heavy, can't rise to the next wave, and so the wave comes over the
top and down goes the tank. It's actually the distance apart of the crests that's the problem.
I see, I hadn't actually realized that. Now, with the Sherman DD, we've got a different propulsion
system because there's an extra sprocket wheel powered by the tracks. How does it work on the
Valentine? Well, if you come to the back, I'll show you. You have the basic drive, there's an
engine, clutch, gearbox, just like a lorry, and then what would be the back axle runs across and
drives the tracks. From the back of the back axle, there's another cog and that brings the
propeller drive out here, so it's directly driven from the transmission. To put it in and out of
gear, that's taking it out of gear, so it's out of the way for while you're going cross-country.
It was into gear, a dog clutch engages there and that's the drive. The steering is just like an
outboard motor. Right, that's a lot more direct. You've actually got the drive directly from the
engine rather than via the tracks. The lift and the steering controls are duplicated from the driver
by hydraulics. This is for the initial run ashore where the thing was launched at about 5,000 yards
and for the first part, the crew would be all up here on top and would get down under armour
for the last of the run ashore and the driver would be steering by use of a
submarine periscope. A very tall periscope. So there are some differences between this and
the Sherman DD. Now, I know, as we said earlier, the Sherman DD took over from this. These were
training vehicles. Yes, they were. They were intended to be the assault tank for DD. What was
the problem, do you think? Availability? No, I mean it's just by 1944, it was an obsolete design
and the initial plan was that you were going to have howitzer-armed valentines for the initial
attack. Then they'd be followed up with high velocity, in this case the six-pounder, for
attack against armour. The next wave would be wading Shermans and then the last wave
would be the crews left over from the valentines. They would bring new Shermans ashore and on the
night of D-Day you would swap the crews over and then the whole thing would be a Sherman operation
to go forwards on D-Day plus one. They couldn't get the howitzers to work. The anti-tank version
has to float with the gun reversed. So, of course, if you use those, it has to land,
come out of the water, drop the screen and turn the turret before it can fire.
And so, although the later models of valentine had the same ammunition, same gun really,
as the Sherman, they were changed as soon as they became available. The last unit to change was,
I believe, the 4th, 7th Ragoon Guards and they only swapped over the Shermans about 10 days
before D-Day. So, it was nearly a mixed formation that went on D-Day but, in fact,
none were ever used. John, very kind of you to talk to us. Thank you very much indeed.
This demonstrated that the system worked, but also how hazardous it could be. In any sort of
running sea, a wave over the top of the screen would send the tank down very quickly indeed
and probably take the crew with it. This is Fort Henry. It's an observation bunker. It's built so
that senior officers, people like General Dysenhower, Montgomery, King George VI, the
Prime Minister, Sir Winston Churchill, could observe exercise smash. That was a large-scale
live fire exercise in April 1944. It's a real rehearsal for D-Day. But, tellingly, next to it,
there is a memorial to six men of the 4th, 7th Royal Ragoon Guards who lost their lives when
their DD tanks were swamped by the waves out there in Studland Bay. Seven DD tanks sank,
of which five were blown up by the Royal Navy, and two remain still on the bottom of the bay
80 years later. Eventually, 1,093 Shermans would be converted to DDs by the US and British Armies.
They weren't part of 79th Armoured at this stage, though they would be later,
but they're attached to their respective US, Canadian and British Armoured Divisions.
If you want to know more about D-Day in general, or Hobart's 79th Armoured Division in particular,
these books, published by the Tank Museum, are essential reading. Click the link to buy
your copy and support the channel. The beaches and landing grounds of the Atlantic War had been
heavily mined, and clearing these was going to be a highly dangerous business for combat engineers
operating under fire. Mines, and particularly the highly effective Teller anti-tank mine,
weren't just laid at minefields, but they were also fixed onto anti-landing obstacles,
like this hedgehog, and a proportion of them were fitted with anti-handling devices,
or they were rigged in sequence with things like anti-personnel mines to make clearance
a very, very hazardous occupation. The solution for D-Day was the Sherman Crab. Now this is a
flail tank with a rotating steel drum fitted with weighted chains that will cut barbed wire
and detonate mines. The flail idea had first been tried in North Africa, with 25 Matilda II tanks
being equipped with flail drums, powered by a separate Ford V8 engine. Although these were
reasonably effective, the Matilda Scorpion, as it was called, raised so much dust that the crews
were blinded and engine and air filters clogged up. A parallel project with a similar auxiliary
engine, the Matilda Baron, was also underway in the UK, and attempts were also made to produce
a Valentine flail, but the design eventually chosen by Hobart was the Sherman Crab. The M4
Sherman was something of a gift from the gods to the British Army. Available in large numbers
through the lend-lease program, it was that rare thing, a reliable tank that was easy to maintain
and crew. Unlike the earlier prototypes, the Sherman Crab doesn't have an auxiliary engine
to power the flail. It's actually got a power take-off from the tank engine itself. That's
the power take-off, and these are the hydraulic rams used to raise and lower the flail. Coming
forward, we have the rotating drum. That's got 43 weighted chains, and those rotate at 142 rpm,
although there is a gearbox so you can vary the rotation speed depending on ground conditions.
We've then got these discs, which are designed to cut barbed wire. Coming around to this side
of the tank, there's a blast shield to protect the crew from detonation of mines. We've lost the
bow machine gun, because obviously that's obscured by the shield, but we retain the 75mm
main armament and the coaxial machine gun, so the flail can still function as a gun tank once it has
finished flailing. Down towards the rear of the tank, there is a mechanism by which the flail can
drop marker poles, smoke grenades or a chalk trail to indicate the cleared route. The most versatile
of the Funnies was the Avery, assault vehicle of all engineers. Based on a Churchill, the Avery retained
the hull, turret and mechanicals of a gun tank, but was adapted in a number of ways. Firstly, the
Churchill gun tank interior was stripped out to allow for the stowage of engineer stores, and then
the main gun was removed and replaced with this, and this is a weapon called a Petard. It's a 29mm
spigot mortar. The spigot, the 29mm part of the weapon, was a hollow tube over which
the tail of a drum-shaped projectile was fitted. Called the flying dustbin, the tail contained a
propellant charge which would send the projectile and its 18kg explosive charge up to 140m.
This was very effective against obstacles and fortifications, but from the crew perspective,
it's got one big disadvantage. After you've fired it, it needs reloading from the outside, so a crew
member has to climb up through this hatch, put another projectile in. That is not the healthiest
thing to do in combat. The Avery was also equipped to carry and deploy a range of other pieces of
These included the bobbin, a 3m wide reel of canvas reinforced with steel rods which could be
laid as a trackway across soft mud or sand, a small box girder bridge capable of spanning a 30ft gap
and supporting vehicles up to 40t, double onion demolition charges attached to a steel frame,
or a brushwood and timber fascine which could be dropped into something like an anti-tank ditch
to enable crossing. The Avery had a crew of six, a driver from the Royal Armoured Corps and then
five Royal Engineer Specialists, so known in the British Army as SAPPERS. Now quite apart from the
equipment that the Avery carries, inside was a mass of onboard stores, things like demolition
charges and they were deployed through these extremely convenient sponson doors in the side
of the tank. If the Avery was the SAPPERS Swiss Army knife, by far the most intimidating of the
funnies was this, the Churchill Crocodile. There's something really terrifying about the thought of
facing a flamethrower, even the man pack type, and the Crocodile was a lot more powerful.
Captain Andrew Wilson, MC, who commanded 13 Troop C Squadron, 141 Regiment, Royal Armoured Corps,
described the demonstration flaming of a pillbox by a crocodile in his book Flamethrower.
It struck the concrete with a violent smack. A dozen yellow fingers leapt out from the point
of impact, searching for cracks and apertures. All at once the pillbox was engulfed in fire,
belching, twisting, red roaring fire, and clouds of queer-smelling grey-black smoke.
Then another rushing, this time the rod went clean through an embrasure,
smacking, belching, roaring. The flame shot out through the back of the pillbox,
fanning like a blowtorch. Experiments with flamethrowers have been carried out since
the early stages of the war, with valentine tanks, universal carriers, armoured lorries,
and the experimental Oak device fitted to the Churchill. The Oak flamethrower consisted of a
forward-mounted flame projector linked to a fuel tank mounted on the back of the tank.
Three were trialled in the Dieppe raid, but it wasn't a success, and a new system was developed
which was eventually fitted to around 800 Churchill Mark 7s, converting them to Churchill
crocodiles, while still retaining the original 75mm main armament. The flame gun, which replaced
the Beta MG on the front of the tank, could project a jet of liquid fire up to 150 yards,
although 80 yards was more normal in our battlefield situation. Pipes ran underneath
the floor of the fighting compartment to this, and this is a six-tonne armoured trailer. That contained
400 gallons of flame fuel, plus five cylinders of compressed nitrogen, and that acts as propellant.
This coupling is designed so that, in an emergency, the trailer can be jettisoned
from inside the tank. The crocodile was horribly effective. Human beings are naturally petrified
of being burned alive, and the crews found that very often a shot near a bunker would
have the occupants either retreating or surrendering in sheer terror. Crocodile
crews were hated by the enemy, and Captain Wilson, who commanded a crocodile troop from
Normandy through to the Rhine, describes at least one crocodile crew attempting to repair their
broken down tank being shot by their German captors out of hand. Crocodiles weren't deployed
on D-Day itself. The close confines of a beach weren't suitable, but they would go on to be used
in the rest of the campaign in northwest Europe, up to their last action, the flaming of buildings
at the Belsen concentration camp. The camp had been liberated by the British army, and the buildings
were infected with typhus, so the crocodiles, along with flamethrowing universal carriers,
burnt the huts down in order to kill off the disease. Some years ago I met an old soldier
who'd been flame gunner on that occasion. He said he had nightmares about it for years afterwards.
So how effective were the funnies? Did the Sherman DDs and the specialised armour of 79th Armoured
make a difference on June 6th 1944? The assault on Gold, Juno and Sword, the British and Canadian
beaches, was spearheaded by DD tanks, and then by LSTs carrying the assault teams of 79th Armoured
Division. Crabs, avries and armoured bulldozers. The US army landing on Utah and Omaha beaches
used DDs, but they missed out on the use of avries and flails. A request for these from
General Omar Bradley wasn't received until after a demonstration in February 1944,
by which time it was too late to produce the vehicles and train crews, especially for the
Churchill, which wasn't part of US armour inventory. On D-Day itself, the performance of the DDs varied
enormously, largely depending on current sea conditions. They were designed to cope with a
swell of up to one foot at 30 centimetres, and they were supposed to be launched from LSTs,
Landing Ships Tank, up to two and a half to three kilometres out. In the event, more than half
were landed directly onto the beach from LSTs and LCTs. At Sword Beach, the DDs of the 13th
Bazaars left their LCTs, swam ashore, the sea was nice and calm, and cleared their objectives.
They landed 33 out of 40 DD tanks successfully. On Juneau, the 6th Canadian Armoured Regiment
landed 10 tanks from LCTs with 30 more swimming ashore on a heavy shell and mortar fire.
These destroyed two 75 millimetre guns, one 50 millimetre gun, and six machine gun positions.
At Gold Beach, rougher conditions made the journey ashore slower and more difficult. The
Sherwood Rangers Yeomanry landed directly from LCTs, but found their objectives had already
been cleared by flail tanks that had landed earlier. Now an awful lot's been said and written
about the US Army's use of DD tanks during Operation Overlord. It's not all bad news.
The US 70th Tank Battalion actually managed to land all of their DDs successfully, apart from
four that were lost when the ship carrying them was sunk by enemy gunfire. The problem then was
that they were confused by a massive smoke screen and they actually landed two kilometres away from
their aiming point and found difficulty actually getting off the beach. At Omaha Beach, the story
is one of partial disaster. The 741st Tank Battalion had their DDs launched four and a
half kilometres out as opposed to the supposed maximum of 3km. They are battling an offshore
current, waves of six feet, up to 1.8 metres, and 27 out of 32 of their tanks are lost. Fortunately,
most of the crews are safe. On the other hand, 743rd Tank Battalion landed their DDs direct
from LSTs. All 32 got ashore, did their job. This aside, the DDs was a success. Few, if any,
were lost to enemy action while afloat and the device enabled the weight of armour landed early
to be increased by almost 100%. For the remaining funnies, the crabs and the aviaries, just the
process of offloading onto the beach from LSTs and LCTs under fire was fought with danger.
At Sword Beach, LCT 947, carrying two crabs and four aviaries, beaches, drops a ramp and then
manages to offload one aviary. The second aviary is hit while still on the ramp, slews round and
on-board explosives start to detonate. The LCT is forced to withdraw, carrying quite a number of
dead and wounded personnel on board. With the patchy performance of the DDs, a number of which
were landed late, direct from their LSTs onto the beach, crabs and aviaries provided fire support
for the infantry. At La Rivière, crabs of the Westminster Dragoons flailed between the beach
obstacles to reach the coastal road and opened up the route to Vier-su-Mer. An aviary then destroyed
an enemy-occupied house and another knocked out an 88mm gun position and this enables the DDs
or the 4th 7th Dragoon Guards to pass through. By nightfall, 12 out of the 50 crabs and 22
out of 120 aviaries landed had been knocked out, but as the Divisional History put it,
the liberal use of their armament had compensated on beaches where the DDs were late. Of the four
assault squadrons Royal Engineers on the British I Corps front, they deployed eight fascines and 10
small box girder bridges from their aviaries. As the beachhead expanded into the dense Norman
Bokarish countryside, aviaries in particular were in demand, using their petard mortars to breach
the tall hedge banks. 79th Armoured and its range of highly specialised vehicles would go on from
Normandy throughout the rest of the fighting in north-west Europe. Crocodiles frequently
operated in cooperation with petard armed aviaries, the aviary firing a flying dustbin to
crack open a fortified position before it was flamed by the crocodile. DDs, which the Division
inherited after the beachhead was established, would play a significant part in the Valkyrie
and Islands campaign and the Rhine crossings. Other vehicles such as the Centaur tank dozer
and the Ram kangaroo troop carrier would also be added to its orbit and would insist the
Division in playing its part up to the German surrender in May 1945. D-Day though remains the
operation that 79th Armoured were mostly remembered for. This is when a strange collection of highly
specialised vehicles made a real difference to the success of the landings. In the words of the
Divisional history, where massed armour led with specialised tanks in the van, the hard crust was
broken with a fraction of the loss of life, limb and time. Most of our beaches were open to traffic
within a few hours of touching down. The liberation of Western Europe was underway.
Thanks for watching, hope you enjoyed this video. If you did, please like, subscribe and if you can
support us on Patreon. If you want to read more about D-Day and support this channel,
these two books, both published by the Tank Museum, are available in my online shop.
This 2023 edition of David Fletcher's Vanguard of Victory, the 79th Armoured Division, covers the
history and development of the unit and its specialised armour, covering the actions in which
they took part from D-Day onwards. This edition of the Tank Museum Guide to D-Day, previously
published by Haynes, has just arrived. It covers the new technology, machines, systems, structures
and innovations that made this, the largest seaborne operation in history, a success. This
2024 80th anniversary edition includes three new chapters, including one dedicated to Hobart's
funnies. They're only available from the Tank Museum shop. Click the link in the description
to find out more.