Quality vs. Quantity: Panzer IV vs. M4 Sherman in Normandy 1944
26 Video Views·Dec 20, 2024
In the summer of 1944, the bocage of Normandy set the stage for fierce tank battles between the German Panzer IV and the American M4 Sherman. Both vehicles were similar in design and capability—but which one held the advantage in real combat?
In this video, Chris Copson breaks down the key differences between these two iconic tanks, comparing their armor, firepower, and mobility. He also revisits a real-life engagement at Mouen near Caen on June 28, 1944, to analyze how these machines and their crews performed under fire.
Chapters:
00:00 – Intro
01:45 – Meet the Tanks
03:08 – Armour
07:37 – Firepower
12:19 – Mobility & Operation
13:29 – Tank Crews
16:37 – Summary
17:15 – Mouen, Normandy, 28 June 1944
23:10 – Conclusion
What happens when two evenly matched tanks face each other in combat?
That's what happened in 1944, when the success of the Normandy landings still hung in the balance.
On the one hand, the American M4 Sherman. On the other, the German Panzer IV.
Both of these medium tanks have similar capabilities in terms of firepower,
arm protection, mobility, and they are both the most numerous tanks fielded by their respective
sites. It wasn't the first time these two tanks had met, and it certainly wouldn't be the last
either. But here, there's a lot more at stake. Here, the winner could determine the outcome of
the war, because in the days after D-Day, Allied armoured struggled to push out of the beachhead,
and now German armoured units were positioning themselves to throw the Allies back into the sea.
This would be a disaster, so those early tank engagements after D-Day really mattered.
In this video, we'll compare the strengths and weaknesses of the M4 Sherman
with the Panzer IV. Then we'll look at what happened at Norn on the 28th of June,
who came out on top, and what made the difference.
If you've ever wondered how one tank would perform against another, there are few better places to
satisfy your curiosity than in the vast battle maps of World of Tanks. With over 600 vehicles
from 11 different nations, World of Tanks allows you to master the tactics of tank warfare.
It's free to play, and new players can sign up today and support the Tank Museum
using the link and invite code in the description below. And now, back to the video.
By far the most numerous Allied tank in Normandy was the M4 Sherman. It had a crew of five,
boasted good mobility, and mounted a 75mm gun.
Entering service in 1942, the Sherman proved to be reliable, economic, and good to crew.
You could build four Shermans, or for that matter two and a half Panzer IVs, for the price of one
Tiger I. Now by this point, 1944, the Sherman's shortcomings have been exposed against the heavier
German armour, but that's not going to be a factor in this encounter. The most numerous tank in the
German Army's combat inventory by 1944 is this one, the Panzerkampfwagen Vier, Panzer IV. It's
got a crew of five, good mobility, and it mounts a 7.5cm gun. Now, Allied tank crews most fear
encountering, you know, the big boys, things like Tiger I,
King Tiger, but in fact this is the enemy tank they are most likely to be facing.
Panzer IV proved itself to be upgradable, ensuring it was still extremely potent and relevant in the
conditions of 1944. Now let's take a closer look at the differences between them. First thing to
think about is armour, and that represents one tank's ability to survive a hit or multiple hits
from another. When you look at the shape of the two tanks, obvious differences hit you.
The Panzer IV is quite boxy, whereas the Sherman has sloped armour on the glacis.
The thing to remember here is that the Panzer IV is a pre-war design. The original spec goes back
to 1934, and sloped armour, which not only increases the line-of-sight thickness of the
metal itself, but it also increases the likelihood of a ricochet, isn't widely adopted until later.
In fact, the Panther is the first German tank really to use it. The earliest model, Panzer IV,
the Ausf. A, was pretty thinly armoured. This is actually an Ausf. D, but it's been
fairly heavily upgraded, so it's not much different to the Ausf. H later model, which is the one you'd
most often encounter in Normandy. Now this tank originally had 30mm armour on the turret and on
the glacis, but it's been beefed up. There are multiple Vorpanzers on the glacis, there's a
armour on the hull, so actually it's a much tougher nut to crack. It would also have had
scherzen, skirts, or I think in German it's more properly aprons, around the turret and also along
the sides. They, I'm afraid, are now missing. The Sherman has often been criticised for poor
armour protection, but in fact it's better than the Panzer IV in quite a few aspects.
The Sherman's frontal armour, totally different to the Panzer IV, is a large single plate,
51mm, that's 2 inches thick, but it's sloped back at an angle of 55 degrees,
giving a line of sight thickness of 90.8mm. Add in the applique armour that was fitted to later
Shermans, or supplied to some vehicles that are already in theatre as what they call blitz kits,
and you've got frontal armour of 51mm plus 45mm, which is sloped at between 35 and 55 degrees.
That gives you a line of sight thickness of 144mm. Contrast that with the Panzer IV's maximum
armour thickness. The glacis in front of the driver has an original armour thickness of 30mm,
with spaced 30mm and 20mm plates added. With the standoff distance between those plates,
that gives you 210mm. The problems start though when you come around the side and you realise
that this plate, the sponson armour, is only 38mm, one and a half inches thick. Now, there's been a
lot of controversy over the years about the supposed vulnerability of Shermans, and a lot
of the old nicknames, the Bronson, the Tommy Cook and stuff like that, they have been debunked.
But, the fact remains, a lot of crews thought the Sherman caught fire too easily. Lieutenant
William Steele Brownlee, 2nd, 5th and 4th Army Yeomanry, and this guy commanded a Sherman
throughout the North West Europe campaign, wrote, "...a hit almost inevitably went to brew up,
and those who are prone to dismiss veteran accounts should know that 50 RTR in Italy in 1944
recorded, it brews up too easily, near the top of their list of tactical defects of the Sherman,
as listed in the regimental war diary." The problem was inadequate sponson armour,
with ammunition stored just behind it. Now, these applique patches were an attempt to remedy that,
but, again, according to Steele Brownlee, they just acted as aiming marks. Now, they did realise
this, and the problem was fixed. When there was a redesign, the ammunition was moved further down
the hull and into wet stowage, which stopped it cooking off. But that doesn't happen until later
in the war, until late 1944, and the tanks we're talking about in this engagement, our Shermans
didn't have it. So, both of these tanks have benefited from some up-armouring, but the Panzer
IV in particular has a lot more protection than it would have had as it originally came out of the
factory in the 1930s. From taking hits to giving them out, both the Panzer IV and the Sherman
have 75mm guns which are capable of putting the other out of action. Not only was the Panzer IV
up-armoured during its service life, it was also up-gunned. Now, it starts out as a Begleitspanzer,
and that's a support tank for the Panzer III, which is intended to be the main gun tank. As such,
it was equipped with a short-barrelled KWK 37 75mm gun, and what that's supposed to do is deal
with things like anti-tank guns, similar targets that the Panzer III's 37mm gun wouldn't cope with.
As the Panzer III became obsolete, the Panzer IV assumed its role as a gun tank,
and it was up-gunned to the long-barrelled KWK 40 7.5cm gun. The British in North Africa,
when they first encountered the up-gunned Panzer IV, soon realised the potency of this gun,
and turned the tanks Panzer IV Specials. The Sherman was built to carry one gun,
this one, the M3 75mm. Now, earlier on in the war, this is more than equal to take on
most of the German armour that was on the battlefield, Panzer I to Panzer IV. But, later on,
it would struggle against the up-armoured Panzer IVs, and that's before you start to think about
the heavier German armour. The guns may be the same size, but the performance is quite different.
In terms of firing against another tank, penetrating armour, both the Panzer IV and the
Sherman use an APCBC round, which is armour-piercing, capped, ballistic, capped. This one is the
Panzergrenadier 39, and this is the Sherman's M61 round. Now, in terms of achieving velocity,
and therefore penetration, a lot of this is down to the weight of propellant. You can see the
difference in the actual size of the shell cases. Panzergrenadier has 2.4kg of propellant, the M61
0.98kg, but it's also down to barrel length. This is measured in calibres, so it's basically the
width of the inside of the barrel. Now, the KWK 40 gun, Panzer IV gun, is an L60, 60 calibres.
Now, if you times 7.5cm by 60, that gives you 3.6m. The M3 gun on the Sherman is 38 calibres,
38 times 7.5cm is 2.85m. So, cutting to the chase, a longer barrel means better obturation,
and what that is, is pressure build-up from the propellant gases, therefore greater muzzle
velocity. So, the longer barrelled KWK 40 has a muzzle velocity of 740-790 ms, whereas the
shorter barrelled M3, the Sherman gun, is only 620-625 ms. Now, both of these rounds weigh about
the same, they're both about 6.8kg, but greater muzzle velocity means greater kinetic energy
transferred, therefore better penetration. The Panzergrenade 39 will penetrate up to 96mm
of 30-degree sloped armour at 500m. The M61 will only penetrate 67mm.
So, tank on tank, gunnery-wise, Panzer IV has the edge over the Sherman. However, by mid-1944,
Shermans mounting the high-velocity 76mm gun are beginning to appear, and some British
Shermans are being fitted with the 17-pounder, creating the Sherman Firefly. But neither of
these are involved in the encounter we're going to look at. So, whereas the Panzer IV has got an
advantage in hitting power, it's limited in its ability to exploit that by the speed of the
turret traverse. Now, both of these tanks have got power traverse, but whereas the Sherman can
do a full 360 degrees in 15 seconds, it takes the Panzer IV 23 seconds. In combat, and particularly
the shorter ranges encountered in Normandy, that can make a big difference. The ability for a tank
commander to be able to put his tank where it needs to be is essential in ensuring a tactical
advantage. The Panzer IV engine is a Maybach 120 TRL, the same as used in the Panzer III, and the SGR
76 transmission, synchromesh gearbox with six forward and one reverse gears, is very sophisticated.
This makes the vehicle easy to drive, but it comes at the cost of ease of maintenance and repair.
This M4A4 has the Chrysler multibank engine, which is surprisingly reliable despite being
complicated, and it has a Caterpillar synchromesh gearbox with five forward and one reverse gear.
The downside of this engine is the impact it has on the height of the tank.
It's only 30 centimetres taller than the Panzer IV, but it's got an almost top-heavy appearance.
This is because the engine itself is tall, so the engine bay had to be tall to accommodate it.
It's also because it's rear-engined, but with a gearbox at the front, meaning the drive shaft
has to pass under the turret basket, and that gives you the humped effect.
Both tanks have a crew of five, which is quite normal for the time, so you've got a commander,
gunner, loader, driver, and hull machine gunner, but the ergonomics and the actual crew dispositions
vary. Where the Panzer IV does score over Sherman is the commander's position here.
This is what we call the throne. He is centre-rear of the turret, and he's got an armoured cupola
with seven vision blocks, so that's excellent situational awareness even when closed down,
and of course if he needs to, he can open the hatches and stick his head out.
Sherman commanders, certainly in the early marks, just had a periscope and a traversing mounting,
meaning they were forced to spend a lot more time with their head and shoulders exposed to the hatch.
Another difference between the two is that in the Sherman, the radio kit is in the bustle at the
back of the turret, and that means the commander, assisted by the loader, has the job of keeping the
set on net, which must have been something of a distraction. In Panzer IV, the bow gunner also
acts as a radio operator. Now that frees up the commander, but against that, the Funkgerät 5 set
is low-powered. It's only got a range of about four kilometres, and that is less than a third of
the number 19 set used in British crewed Shermans. Oh, and being an AM set, the FUG 5 suffered from
massive static interference when the tank was moving. The bow gunner also has a dedicated sight
for his MG34, which could put accurate rounds on the target, compared with the bow gunner in the
Sherman, who can only aim his .30 cal MG through a basic periscope. This lack of a dedicated sight
means the Sherman's MG can only really be used for suppressive fire. Panzer IV, the gunner sits on
the left-hand side of the gun, and you can see his manual elevation and traverse wheels, and also the
azimuth indicator. We've also got the excellent Termsil Föhnrohr 5B, 2.5 times magnification
telescopic sight. In the Sherman, the gunner and loader's position are reversed. The loader's on
the left, and the gunner on the right. Initially, the only gun sight was periscopic, but in an early
improvement, the gun mount was redesigned to add a telescopic sight. This meant greater accuracy
through the three times magnification M55 coaxial telescopic sight, and a wider field of view
through the M4 periscope. The best of both worlds. For the driver, both tanks are easy to drive and light
Both have similar mobility, a top speed on the road of 35 to 48 kilometres an hour for the Sherman,
and 38 to 42 kilometres an hour for the Panzer IV, although both speeds are more or less halved
off-road. The vertical volute spring suspension of the Sherman gave a notably smoother ride than the
leaf spring arrangement of the Panzer IV. If you're doing a lot of miles, particularly across country,
that will make a difference to crew comfort and performance. So, by mid-1944, there's not actually
a great deal to choose between the Panzer IV and the Sherman. Panzer IV has got the edge in terms of
firepower and the commander's situational awareness, but the Sherman has got a faster turret traverse,
and the gunner's got an advantage because of course he's got a periscopic and a telescopic sight.
To understand how these tanks would perform against one another, we then look at a short but
violent action which would be repeated across Normandy when Sherman and Panzer IV went head to head.
The date is the 28th of June 1944. It's three weeks on from D-Day landings. The Allies have yet
to secure a breakout from the Normandy beachhead and capture the strategically vital city of Caen.
As part of Operation Epsom, 3rd County of London Yeomanry, part of 11th Armoured Division,
are attacking enemy positions on the River Odom. The Germans were wrong-footed by Allied deception
into thinking the landings were going to happen in the Pas-de-Calais, not in Normandy, but what that
means is most of the major armed formations weren't able to intervene until the Allies were preparing
to break out. On top of this, the Norman countryside, which is known as the Bocage,
consisting of small fields surrounded by high hedgerows, is far from ideal tank country.
Consequently, lines of sight are very limited and tank actions that occur in the early days
are small scale and fought at close range. Instead, the Allies are making the most of
air superiority and massive artillery bombardments to inch inland. Despite this,
the countryside favours the defenders, so progress is agonisingly slow and costly.
Among those on the receiving end of this overwhelming firepower is 21st Panzer Division,
who've been in continuous action since the invasion started, sustaining heavy losses.
Between 6th June and 8th July, the division lost 54 Panzer IVs and only received 17 replacements.
Many of the Panzer crews were experienced, they'd seen service over on the Eastern Front,
but there are others, replacements, who are fresh from the Panzerschule, the tank training schools.
Man for man, they are generally more experienced than the Allied tank crews they faced.
They'd also been used for the vast open spaces of the Russian steppe, which favoured massed
formations. They'd have to adjust to a very different form of tank warfare in Normandy.
On the 28th June, they are ordered to support Panzergrenadier of 1st SS Panzer Division
Leibstandarte in a counterattack on British positions at Moor. Due to the losses it's
already sustained, it's only able to spare 4th Company of 22nd Panzer Regiment.
4th Company's lead ZUG of 5 Panzer IVs, avoiding the dense bockage and using the
embankments for cover, follows the cutting of a single track railway towards Colville,
passing the wrecks of tanks the British 23rd Hussars knocked out the previous day.
As they near Moor, three Stuart light tanks of 3rd CLY Reccey Troop emerge from a forest track
and blunder into their path. Realising their mistake, the Stuarts attempt to reverse,
but they're in big trouble and all three are hit by the lead Panzer IV as they reach the railway.
With the railway now blocked by burning Stuarts, the Panzer IVs scale the embankment into the
hedged field to the side, before supporting the Panzergrenadier in an assault on an
isolated company of British infantry holding Moor. Having rolled up a position, the Panzergrenadier
dig in, with the Panzer IVs as flank cover north of the railway. The Panzers wait, hull down,
for the counter-attack. They don't have to wait long. Three squadrons, 16 Sherman tanks from the
3rd CLY, supporting a battalion of infantry, are advancing towards them, expecting only light
opposition. At three to one, the Panzers are heavily outnumbered and that makes the outcome
more or less inevitable. Three CLY advance with B and C squadrons in the lead, one each side of the
railway and each accompanied by a company of infantry. A squadron is in reserve to provide
fire support. The attack begins with an artillery barrage, but this hasn't dampened the defenders'
resolve. They open up with MG fire, which disorganises the infantry and forces the
push on in front. Concealed and firing from a hull-down position at a range of about 80 metres,
one Panzer IV dispatches the three lead Shermans. Before its commander, Unteroffizier Eichler,
is decapitated by a shell and the tank, in trying to retreat, is knocked out.
This is the high point of the German defence. After that, the weight of fire tells and one
after the other, the Panzer IVs are picked off. 422 is hit on the turret and suffers damage to
its Scherzen, which makes it impossible to reverse the turret. Having jettisoned the Scherzen, the
tank is then hit again. 413, its crew having successfully repaired a broken track under fire,
is hit and destroyed, as is Stabsfeldwebel Neuwohn's 434. Feldwebel Korfleur's 425,
suffering damage to its engine, catches fire and is abandoned by its crew.
4 Company has now lost a total of 12 Panzer IVs in two days, leaving it with only five remaining.
These are losses it couldn't afford. Meanwhile, the CLY had lost four Shermans,
but in gaining the ground they are able to recover three of those knocked out,
rated damaged rather than destroyed, either for repair or salvage for parts.
In this small victory, we can see how Germany would eventually be defeated. In this engagement,
we've seen that Sherman and Panzer IV, 1944, are fairly evenly matched, but here's the crucial
thing. It's often said that wars are won in factories and this has demonstrated that. The
ability to produce the colossal amount of material to supply armies in the field would be the war
Just under 50,000 Shermans were built, making it the second most prolific tank of the period
after the Soviet T-34. Crudely put, this made Sherman losses more affordable.
The Panzer IV was built in much smaller numbers, just over eight and a half thousand. Now,
why was that when the actual production run was several years longer than that of the Sherman?
German tanks were the product of highly skilled engineering. Each vehicle,
right up to the end of the war, was almost hand-built to exacting standards.
And throughout the war, German tank production was dogged by the need to produce more complicated
and probably over-sophisticated vehicles, which of course slowed production overall.
Putting it simply, Germany produces some very good tanks, but never in sufficient numbers,
and certainly not enough to replace losses on days like this.
Sherman's story is the exact opposite. Using the American genius for mass production,
in particular things like the automobile and the railroad industries,
tanks were produced in huge numbers in factories that had probably never even built one before.
But what counts in the end is the ability to throw a huge volume of men and especially material
at a rapidly depleting Wehrmacht. For the German Panzerwaffe,
the situation would continue to deteriorate. Once the breakout had been achieved, Allied victory
in Western Europe was more or less assured. It wouldn't be easy, but it would come.
So, how did the Sherman and Panzer IV fare in World of Tanks?
The Sherman has several offerings in World of Tanks, with variants available from the US,
UK, France and even the Soviet Union. One of the most mass-produced tanks in World War II,
the M4A1 Sherman is a solid Tier V medium tank that delivers good damage per minute,
firing rate and a decent top speed. Best to play with the hull hidden due to the vehicle's thin
armour. The Panzer IV was the most prolific tank for Germany during World War II. Specifically,
the Panzer IV Ausf. H can be equipped with cannons that range from 75 to 105mm.
That 105mm gun can deliver some of the highest damage per minute amongst its tier,
and its front hull armour is better than that of the same tier Sherman.
Just be aware of the average to below average top speed.

