Masculinity, unemployment, & bad ideologies | Forward with Andrew Yang

Andrew Yang
1 follower
So, the jobs are drying up, the family is drying up, the opportunity to have a solid
mate is drying up, but there's a different men and women who are in this similar situation
who maybe lose their job.
The 25% of women that were in manufacturing losing their same job, they are responding
different to this economic situation.
Women are more adaptable than men to that kind of change in circumstance.
They're more likely to go back to school as one example.
If you look at men who are unemployed, their propensity to go to church or volunteer at
a non-profit actually goes down, not up when they're unemployed, even though they have
more time.
So one of the issues for guys is that without a livelihood, their sense of self-worth plummets
and then their desire to go out and volunteer also plummets.
Do you know why that is?
I mean, I think that's like the core of this.
And we've been trying to get to a better quality of opportunity for men and women, but men
and women are so different and the numbers are screaming off the page.
I have thoughts too, but it goes back to kind of where we're talking about video games too.
Men are more likely to dive into video games or spend a lot of their new free time spent
on the computer in this situation.
Why do you think that is?
So here's a quote from George Orwell, a man with no means of filling up time is as miserable
out of work as a dog on the chain.
Saying that if a guy, there's that other saying, you know, idle hands are the devil's tools.
I think they're referring to men primarily.
So women deal with idleness better than men.
Women in a way are not ever truly idle, you know, like they'll be able to improve their
environment, improve themselves, go back to school, spend time with each other.
They don't have the same kind of negative social externality pattern that men do.
Men who are idle start gambling, drinking, doing drugs, and become anti-social pretty
quickly.
And a lot of people listening to this have seen some version of this in their own lives.
Maybe they've felt that.
And it's something that I will say I personally sympathize with a great deal.
One of the things I say in The War on Normal People is that every guy has the seeds of
a failed man inside of him.
And so you can see when someone does fail, when a guy fails, you're like, oh my gosh,
like that could be me.
Because you kind of know yourself.
You know that there's some part of you that just wants to go to the basement and hang
out and play video games and avoid the world.
What are those seeds in your eyes?
What are the seeds of a dysfunctional man?
You know what I'm saying?
I think every guy has it.
One of the things I joke about with Evelyn sometimes is that if you're an unmarried man,
your life will likely end earlier.
You will die.
By the numbers.
You will die, what is it, 7, 10 years earlier?
Yeah, it's almost a decade, right?
And if you are an unmarried woman, no effect on your lifespan.
Guys do not make women live longer.
We have no impact.
Women make guys live longer.
And now that I am married, I understand why.
So I'm 47.
I have friends who are unmarried and may never marry.
And you can see that the kind of returns on male activities are going down over time.
I am so grateful to be married in part because the things that you get a charge out of as
a young man give you a little bit less joy as you get older.
And so you start shifting gears where now I get pleasures of being a dad and bringing
the boys to a sporting event and living vicariously through them and mellowing out and watching
Succession with Evelyn or whatever it is.
So you have these simple pleasures.
And I think the seeds of failure for guys are that we need to feel some degree of progress,
achievement, stature, virility, appreciation.
And video games form a perfect avenue for this because if you spend a bit of time, you
get stronger, you get more powerful, you get richer, you get more friends, you get to win.
And so here's a quote from Jonathan Gottschall, who writes about gaming.
Virtual worlds give back what has been scooped out of modern life.
It gives us back community, a feeling of competence and a sense of being an important person whom
people depend on.
Yes, yes.
And that is what a lot of what a job does.
Yeah. And then what what's fascinating to me and this is what I kind of want to get
into is that the job or that sense of duty or responsibility or appreciation or respect
that men are craving when when it's not there, there's seeds of the seeds of dysfunction,
seeds of dysfunction, dysfunctional masculinity, masculinity or the dysfunctional male
start to seep in, start to plant.
And those are either I wrote down, I was like, it's either thinking with the wrong head,
which is the Robin Williams quotes like God gave men two heads and only enough blood to
run one at a time. It's probably accurate.
I think avoiding responsibility, like almost hiding and numbing the pain, whether that's
drugs or alcohol or kind of that escapism.
This is one thing that makes men subject to toxic ideologies, in my opinion, is that
there's this thirst for significance.
And so if you don't get that significance in your day to day life and then someone has
some idea being like, oh, you know why things are going badly for you?
Because these people are keeping you down.
And here's how I can fight them.
Then you start getting attracted to that because it makes you part of something
important. Yes.
And men crave that.
Yes, there's a crave to take things like be a man and like, that's yours or go get it.
And that can be done well or very poorly in the way that men approach women and things
like that. There's the competition, the ego, the hubris, but also turns into apathy or
hate or racism.
These darker pieces of otherness or other people are causing this.
And so to me, as a society, we need to talk about that and understand that.
Frederick Douglass, what did he say?
It's in your book. He said.
It's easier to build strong children than to repair broken men.
And when men start getting these seeds, it gets very, very, very difficult to to come
back. And I've seen that in terms a lot of the ministry work my dad does.
You have men, they're just they're just broken.
They're beat. This is in some ways a grossly oversimplified way to think about the
struggle that America is going through, where you have this disintegrating way of
life for millions of men and a need for significance and anger.
And and the question is, can we manage this process in a way that keeps people strong
and whole and healthy and even understanding what's happening?
Or is it going to be like, you know, oh, like, screw you, like your perspective is
unimportant, you know, like we don't care about you.
And so one of the things I want to switch to is what's happening among the college
educated cohort that ends up in many ways obscuring a lot of these struggles.
Correct. Yes.
So let's go there. So among the college educated crew, it's a very different environment.
So let's say you have 58 percent women, 42 percent men in college.
That might not seem that dramatically different, but it's it's a lot.
And over time, it gets so if the numbers, if you change the number slightly to 60, 40,
what that would mean is that one third of college educated women will not have a college
educated man to marry when they want to get married.
And that is the case in part because college educated women will essentially not consider
any non-college educated men to get married in most circumstances.
Yeah. By the numbers, by the by the numbers.
So you'll wind up with a very significant number of college educated women who will
not marry. I mean, they might decide to have kids independently.
And then they're going into environments that varies wildly by industry.
But the the overwhelming narrative is that if you look at certain environments.
Finance, tech, media to a large extent, some of the most highly visible industries,
they tend to be somewhat male dominated.
And so the movement is for women who are going into this environment say, hey, we have a
number of men at the entry levels.
But then you go up to the top.
Let's say it's a law firm.
So I have some experience with that environment.
The number of law school graduates is essentially a gender gender parity now, male, female.
But if you look at the partnerships, it's like very, very male dominated.
Right. And so the active movement is to say, hey, this stuff is out of whack.
We need more female CEOs, more female partners.
We need more female board members.
And so the narrative is around men marginalizing women in these environments, which is a very
different environment than what we were just discussing, which is like there are legions
of men who don't have meaningful opportunities among the less educated set.
So in among the educated universe, it's like, hey, why do guys have all the power and money?
Right. And our response to that has been promoting women faster, I guess, slowly but
surely, like we are.
I mean, have you seen people or companies start to level the playing field or you still
think it's a dynamic?
It's still very, very out of whack.
Is it improving marginally?
My perspective on this is that a lot of these environments are almost intrinsically women
unfriendly and somewhat family unfriendly.
Yeah.
Where and you worked on Wall Street, so you might be able to speak to this.
So you worked in like a slightly gentler sector.
A little gentler, yeah.
So we have this winner take all marketplace.
And if you look at finance and tech and media, the winner take all dynamics are all consuming
where it's like, look, if we get this deal or we get this market or whatnot, like we're
all going to be rich.
And then if we don't, we are all going to be poor.
So everyone needs to go, go, go.
And you come and be like, look, you need to work around the clock and be available all
the time and you do it for years on end.
And then you'll reap these massive rewards.
And so these cultures are completely subject to these market dynamics.
And so then if a woman enters this organization is like, hey, like maybe I don't feel like
80 hours a week.
If you adopted the same standard for everyone, like women would look up and be like, you
know, let's say I want to have a kid at some point.
I'd say I actually want some like, you know, family time and the rest of it.
Then they'll naturally self-select and be like, hey, let me leave this place at a certain
point.
And then the organization will be back to square one being like, you know, where all
the women in senior management leadership.
So there are certain cosmetic things they could do around it being like, maybe we should
have more generous policies and this.
But the culture itself is going to be geared towards the market that they're in right now.
Do I think that this is great?
No.
Do I think there should be a four day work week, which, by the way, would would end up
help, you know, like help everyone because like, you know, this is burning dudes out
to like this is like everyone's kind of going crazy so that it's it's not purely a gendered
thing.
So I would love it if organizations adopted more humane cultures and paces and you didn't
have to answer your phone and your email after a certain hour and like the rest like
all that stuff would make me very happy.
Right.
But I will suggest that if even if you made these cultural shifts, it's a very, very
different struggle than the struggle that most men or families are experiencing, because
like the tendency is for media employees to think of things in the same way as happening
in their company.
Right.
But, you know, what's happening in their company is completely distinct from what's
happening in, you know, some working class town in Missouri.
