$50 Silver May Not Hold - Here's Why | Steve Penny

BizFinance Insights
3 followers
Oct 11, 2025
$50 Silver May Not Hold - Here's Why | Steve Penny
So let's just be call a spade a spade the risk reward ratio over the next few months to maybe
even a couple quarters is not super favorable in silver. This is Kaiser Johnson with Liberty
and Finance and these are the Miles Franklin weekly specials for October 6th through October
13th 2025 while supplies last. First this week 100 ounce silver Valcambi bars are just $2.79
next one ounce 2023 Mexican silver Libertad are $6.99 over spot per ounce finally one ounce gold
Valcambi bars are only $85 over spot to order our specials or any of the many other options
we have available call us at 1-888-81-liberty that's 1-888-815-4237 we're available after
hours and on weekends and we look forward to speaking with you. Hey everyone this is Elijah
K. Johnson with Liberty and Finance and back with us today is our good friend Steve Penny
from the Silver Chartist. Steve thank you so much for joining us today. You bet Elijah thank you so
much for having me back certainly exciting times we it wasn't too long ago we spoke and silver was
knocking on the door 50 bucks well yesterday we eclipsed that key resistance level of 50 didn't
close above there so certainly exciting time to be talking about precious metals certainly and
you've been talking about how the US dollar is really key here so did you want to share what's
going on with the US dollar index and how does it play into what's happening in silver absolutely
yeah as I'm pulling it up I'll just mention we were chatting before this this show how I think
the two most important charts right now are the monthly chart for the US dollar and the monthly
log scale chart for silver and you know of course I'm speaking to silver investors if you're a silver
investor those are the two most important charts and you know the this roadmap that I drew out as
I'm sharing my screen here and your viewers can maybe you know I get sometimes people are listening
on the phone or excuse me while driving or whatever you might want to take a look at your
phone if you can because this picture really does paint a thousand words when you zoom out on the
long-term chart of the US dollar what you see going back to you know the 1980s is lower highs
like major major peaks that are lower and that is in fact a downtrend when you zoom way out however
what I think it's overlooked technically speaking from the dollar is that it's actually in an
uptrend now I'm a dollar bear from a fundamental basis so I'm not like a dollar milkshake proponent
so to speak however when the technicals are the technicals and when you look at the chart from
2008 to present 17 years now it's in a gently rising uptrend and the last one two three four
times that we've tested this support well we've bounced and it's interesting that we're right at
that support right here right now and I drew out this potential path you know the very beginning
January of 2025 and it's followed this path almost perfectly now the question remains you know will
it bounce here what what could cause the dollar to bounce I mean there's a variety of different
catalysts but conditions are ripe for a bounce in the dollar because nobody's expecting it I'm not
necessarily predicting like hey this is absolutely what's going to happen but it's a risk to precious
metals right now and this just happens to come at a time where the dollar is testing major support
at a time where silver is testing a major confluence of resistance so I think the monthly
close on those two respective charts will be very important from a technical perspective when I zoom
in here it's kind of hard to see with this path I'll just move that you can see this green candle
right here I'm circling it and it might be kind of hard to see that's the monthly candlestick so
we're bouncing from the support line if we close back but you know below this support line well
that would kind of uh serve to maybe invalidate this this channel but if we bounce from here that
would validate this pattern and you know increase the likelihood of a little bit of a bounce in the
if not a bigger bounce in the dollar and uh you know perhaps a pullback and consolidation
in precious metals you know with respect to silver did you want to share that chart I know
this $50 level is super key that's why we're having you on just a week after uh we spoke last
because you know so much has transpired and now we're above $50 so um but you're thinking that
maybe caution is still warranted yeah caution is warranted and you know I just like last time we
spoke I have to I want to be careful because I don't want to miscommunicate and sound like I'm
a bear I think we're going well into the triple digits in silver I'm irresponsibly long precious
metals myself however on the short term I just I don't like to always be a permable and I like to
view things as in terms of risk reward ratios so let's just be call a spade a spade the risk reward
ratio over the next few months to maybe even couple quarters is not super favorable in silver
yes there is upside potential however there's also downside risk and I look at the ratio the
risk reward ratio is probably about one to one yeah it could go up another 10 15 bucks um that's
not my base case scenario but it's possible but it could also fall by an equal amount so those are
just things to be you know cognizant of when you craft your own strategy you know a lot of people
have maybe big profits in paper positions is your strategy to just sit through any kind of downside
volatility on the way to triple digit silver nothing wrong with that but you want to be
intentional with it that's that's my point and you can see this monthly candlestick chart kind of
looks almost like the opposite of uh the dollar dollar sitting against long-term support well
silver right here is sitting against a major confluence of resistance there's this right
this rising wedge pattern and every time we've come up and tested this resistance going back to
2015 what we've had a pullback a consolidation well we're there right now in fact we're poking
our head above it so this is a monthly candlestick that's why i'm saying where we close this month
is key for both the both the dollar and silver we're above this resistance right now if we close
above this that would serve to invalidate this pattern because we closed above it's no longer
valid however if you have a long wick above it and then you close back below this trim profits
line this red resistance line well um you know that that would indicate a high probability of
now this line just happens to coincide with key horizontal resistance at the $50 area and also
down at 44 is the next uh you know former resistance now support so major confluence
of resistance here um when i think about probably probabilities and potential outcomes
this is admittedly subjective so take it with a grain of salt but how i compartmentalize it in my
mind is you know first i come up with a forecast and probabilities of that forecast coming to
fruition and then i craft my strategy around those probabilities so i'm assigning roughly
a 40 probability that we ran up to 50 so that happened and i've been saying this for a few
months now run up to 50 so that's part has come to fruition 40 probability that we pull back 50
acts as like a wall of resistance pull back consolidate and eventually punch through it
after you know this overbought condition has been worked off probability number two outcome number
two roughly the same probability about a 40 outcome that we break through 50 consolidate
along 50 as now support for a period of maybe a couple few months maybe even a quarter or two
before moving higher and then i think the least likely outcome but within the spectrum of
possibilities is that we keep moving higher into the 60s maybe even towards 70 silver without a
i'm giving that roughly a 20 probability least likely outcome but possible so then the question
to ask yourself is how do you have a strategy in place to prosper in a variety of different
outcomes so to me the way i'm thinking about it yes i have some options as insurance but also
i'm trimming profits and i'm trimming enough so that i would welcome a 30 to 40 pullback
in some of the mining stocks but i'm not selling so much that i would have deep regret if we move
up to 65 silver so i'm positioned yes i like to make forecasts but what i'm doing with my
strategy is positioning myself in a way that i put i'm happy whether we pull back and i'm happy
if we run to the upside and that allows me to sleep well at night there when you say a close
above that uh trim profits line as we see on the screen right there that trend line do you mean a
monthly close i assume since these are monthly uh there's a monthly chart yes sir yeah that's
really close so that's um that's exactly what i was trying to say so this is a monthly candlestick
so we've still got you know 20 days left in the month of october so we've got some time so a
monthly close above here would be very bullish a monthly close in the month of october below
there would indicate likely more consolidation slash pullback and you have the note also about
the rsi uh being extremely high right now and what has happened since the 80s uh when we've
seen our the rsi this high can you expand a little bit on this and and what the significance
of this is sure yeah i put that note in there a couple weeks ago when we just punched above 70
because it is noteworthy technically when you get above 70 on the rsi that's considered overbought
so what i did is i zoomed this chart all the way back i'm not going to do it now but all the way
back to the 1970s bull market and i looked at every single time that monthly rsi got above 70
yes that is an overbought condition and it did precede you know a sharp pullback but however
there was more upside so my point is once it poked above 70 almost every time it continued up
to get even more overbought until that rsi got to around 80 interestingly the rsi peaked yesterday
at just over 78 78.5 so we're getting there you know just another little bit more upside and we're
going to be extreme extreme overbought where historically that precedes a more sizable
correction now when it comes to gold we are kind of riding that line at four thousand dollars an
ounce what is your take on gold and do you anticipate um a correction in gold as well
uh i i do uh so here's how i think about gold the caution signals are piling up but that's
that's a key distinction i'm not what i'm not saying is the there's any sign of a reversal so
there are caution signals extreme overbought rsi second highest in history uh cot bearish euphoric
optimism um extreme overbought uh sentiment these are all caution signals but there's no sign of a
reversal yet so caution signals but there's still no sign of a reversal so i'm kind of again looking
at risk reward ratios not so favorable over the short term in gold although ultimately i think
i wouldn't be chasing gold right here right now now that said if i didn't have any exposure
to physical metal i look at that as insurance so you know i would probably go get some exposure
now if i had none but if i were looking to like speculate for capital appreciation over the short
term uh probably wait for a better opportunity in gold now another market that people haven't
been paying too much attention to because we have uh seen these dramatic moves in gold and
especially silver breaking that 50 level is uranium um that people had been talking about
this a couple years ago as we were you know making uh these uh new highs and all of that
but now we are actually again making new highs can you expand on that sure yeah uranium um is one of
those sectors i i love it because you know i like oil i like hard assets but uranium i like
the simplicity in that it's just a pure supply demand story demand is fairly uh easy to predict
i mean there's potential upside kickers with ai data centers and stuff but if you exclude all that
you can kind of project out demand and you can project out supply within you know reasonable
estimation and uh the bottom line is the price is too low to incentivize the new production that's
needed for all these reactors that are coming online around the world and the price can have
to resolve higher and uh that's beginning to to be recognized by i think the general investing
public you know back in april this sector was just obliterated even before the tariff tantrums
i mean uranium had fallen for this is urnj by the way the sprott junior uranium miners etf
kind of similar to like gdxj for precious metals investors um had fallen from 31 previous all-time
high down to 11 i mean so it has to go up by almost 300 percent uh to just to get back to
where it was well it's done that and we were buying uranium i'm not trying to like pat ourselves in
the back but as a contrarian man i loved the sentiment in this sector uh when everyone hated
it back in april i mean this sector had just gotten decimated and here we are now up almost
3x in in an etf and we're breaking out today as we're speaking right here right now to a fresh
all-time high in urnj the sprott uranium excuse me junior uranium miners etf i think similar to
silver you know this is a key battle line i think a likely outcome is we kind of break through here
and then consolidate what was resistance becomes support so i wouldn't necessarily be chasing it
here i mean that's a massive move but over the long term similar similar to precious metals i
think there's a lot of runway ahead for uranium and i'll show um more one more chart here this
is urnm similar to like gdxj to speak to precious metals investors uh who maybe aren't so familiar
with uranium that one's already broken out so just like gdx had the led the big move higher
and then gdxj followed and then silj the more speculative components that's kind of happening
in the uranium sector right now the the leading stocks the chemicals the uranium energy cores
kind of led the charge higher and now the more speculative components are beginning to play
rapid catch up in uranium so a lot of runway ahead the spot price right now is uh right around
80 i think just touch below 80 on uranium the previous all-time high is 148 back in 2007
so a lot of room ahead just to get back to where it was in 2007 and if you adjust that 148 using
government inflation numbers that gives you an inflation adjusted all-time high around 200
and here we are at 80 so uh pretty excited about uranium wouldn't necessarily chase it right now
but i do like the prospects technically and fundamentally and last week we also touched
on platinum but any other updates um there as it seems like we've continued to see it rally higher
yeah platinum um is one of those metals i'll just continue to say i think it has the potential
potential to outperform silver um however it carries more risk so it's from risk adjusted
basis i prefer silver but platinum i it does warrant consideration considering some exposure
in your physical metals allocation just because of that potential previous all-time high 2309
and here we are as of we're speaking at 1630 so that's another you know almost 700 bucks 600 bucks
650 670 doing math in public of upside potential here just to get back to where it was you know
at its previous all-time high so i really like platinum if you're looking to buy a dip what was
resistance become support so this 1500 area any pullbacks to there i think would be pretty
compelling spots to accumulate a little bit of platinum if you're so inclined before we let you
go steve it's you know a crazy time in the market so there any last thoughts for our viewers um
how to navigate you know all-time highs for both gold and silver and and huge moves as you mentioned
in uranium and platinum how should people be thinking about this all right now yeah that's
that is the most important question i think that every individual investor needs to answer for
themselves because you can't rely on you know some guy on youtube i can't tell you what to do with
your own money because i don't understand all the variables of your own life but you should have a
we just put out a video on silver chart it's called silver swan profit-taking strategy and
swan stands for sleep well at night and the answer is what what allows you to sleep well at night
and i think i would encourage people to try and some of you may already do this but i know there's
a lot of experienced investors but when i was new i i knew all the fundamentals for silver and gold
and i knew you know the potential upside targets and but i didn't have a strategy to navigate the
volatility along the way and i was focused on purely on upside potential i think a better way
to think about it is how do you maximize a risk adjusted returns not just total return but risk
adjusted returns how do you manage risk along the way and these are things like position sizing
what's your plan to take a little bit off the table to take some profits along the way is that
a strategy uh do you know how do you are you experienced in options to manage risk these are
all things to just think about because the the idea that you're just going to hold it all until
the very end of the bull market and then push the sell button at the end that'll be a very very
difficult to execute so having a simple strategy that you can execute and that allows you to sleep
sleep well at night well steve penny we always appreciate your time thank you so much for
joining us again so soon our viewers once again can go to silvercharges.com if they're looking for
more info from you thank you so much and god bless god bless you too thank you so much for having me
this is kaiser johnson with liberty and finance and these are the miles franklin weekly specials
for october 6th through october 13th 2025 while supplies last first this week 100 ounce silver
valkambi bars are just $2.79 over spot per ounce next one ounce 2023 mexican silver libertad are
$6.99 over spot per ounce finally one ounce gold valkambi bars are only $85 over spot to order our
specials or any of the many other options we have available call us at 1-888-81-liberty that's 1-888-815-4237
we're available after hours and on weekends and we look forward to speaking with you
