Explaining The Trump Tariff Plan

BizFinance Insights
3 followers
27 Video Views·Apr 8, 2025
Explaining The Trump Tariff Plan
Welcome back, everyone. Today on the Joseph Carlson Show, we have the tariff panic.
Stocks are falling after Trump's Liberation Day, when he unveiled his grandiose tariff plan.
Now, whatever was being liberated, I'm not sure. I'm not confident of what was being liberated,
but it certainly wasn't our portfolios. The Dow Jones is currently down 3% as of right now.
The S&P 500 is down 3.7%. The Nasdaq is down 4.7%. And they're going down further.
This isn't where they've gone down further in their backtracking, they continue to plunge.
And the reason why is simply put, the Trump tariff plan was far more extreme than anyone
anticipated. In fact, out of the analysts' expectations of the range of tariffs, this was
on the most extreme side, in most cases more extreme than the most extreme side that investors
expected. The Trump tariff plan is a broad set of tariffs, at least 10% on virtually every trading
partner across the globe. The tariffs are slapped on so many countries that a lot of people haven't
even heard of some of the countries. Some of them aren't even inhabited. They just have apparently
penguins living on them. But they're getting tariffed as well. The tariff plan is so broad,
so indiscriminate, so extreme with the numbers, so steep of tariffs, that it's almost difficult
to even comprehend how this is going to work out. What's going to happen? Investors are in
full-on panic mode. They're trying to absorb the information right now. They're discounting any
company that has any business outside of the US, which is almost every company. So what we're seeing
here is the market's reaction to a plan that has an incredible amount of unpredictability.
The market doesn't know what's going to happen. Investors don't know what's going to happen.
Business leaders don't know what's going to happen. What's going on is literally unprecedented.
It hasn't happened in the past hundred years. No one living has memory of anything happening like
this. So what we're living through right now is an interesting time where investors are trying
to discount companies for their cash flows in the future, but we have no clue what's going to happen.
So we'll be going through the announcement yesterday, breaking down what it actually means,
the math behind it, and some of the mixed messaging that the White House is giving.
We'll also be going through what I believe are going to be the biggest winners and losers of
this tariff plan, the long-term implications of it, and my game plan going through this.
Now, let's go ahead and start off by just highlighting some of the companies and their
reactions today. This is how investors are reacting to Apple. Now, as of right now,
Apple's down 7.85%. It's not every day you see a company like Apple trade down above 7%.
This is a huge sell-off in this company. Apple has a lot of exposure to China,
and China was one of the places that got the steepest level of tariffs. In fact,
they're almost incomprehensibly high. When we look at other companies here, we have Amazon,
another company that has huge exposure to China, not because they're doing a lot of business in
China per se, but because Amazon has a lot of sellers from China selling Chinese products to
the US. It's nothing new, but Amazon is now down 7% as a result. Nike, of course, manufactures a
lot of its products. Most of it comes from Indonesia, China, Vietnam. Those countries
all had tariffs put on them. Nike has nowhere to escape the tariff. They're going to have to
pay a lot of money additionally, which is a big input cost for this company. So, this one's trading
down big time today. We also have software vendors. Even companies that really don't
manufacture products in different countries, they're just simply selling software, are going
down. Now, part of this is because a company like Salesforce is just high beta. Meaning,
anytime the market goes up or down, Salesforce will likely follow, but to a bigger extent. So,
it's high beta to begin with, but there's also the argument that the tariffs will likely slow
down the economy. They stop trade. They create friction. If that happens, companies will pull
back on the amount of people they hire. Salesforce makes more money the more seats you have. They
have per-user license agreements for most of their companies. So, if business slows down and you hire
fewer employees, Salesforce makes less money. The stock is down 5% today after already being down
quite a bit. It's down 22% year-to-date. We continue on. Shopify. Even Canadian companies are getting
hit hard. Shopify, the online retailer, is down 17%. Now again, this is normally a very high beta
stock. It also trades at a pretty hefty valuation. So, it has a couple things already working against
it, but this company makes money from small businesses that in most cases, they get their
product from overseas. Every place they're getting their product, you name it, is being tariffed. So,
all of these companies that are selling on Shopify now have input costs that are greater.
We have S&P Global right now that's holding up a little bit better than the rest of the market.
Now, this company is obviously a very strong, really wide moat company, but I think S&P Global
probably should be lower based on this news. S&P Global is a market company. They specialize in
markets. They do better when the stock market is higher, when companies are issuing debt,
when economies are growing, when there's more momentum. This company overall makes more money
in every line of business when markets thrive. And tariffs are likely to slow down markets.
They'll slow down all different components of S&P Global's business.
Met is being hit hard today. Investors have sold the stock down 5.6% on the day.
That's after the stock is already down below 20%, below its high. So, this one really is selling
down more today. And investors are concerned because Meta has a lot of advertisers. Lots of
small businesses advertise on Meta. That's how they make all their money. If those small businesses
can't survive the increased costs of tariff, the increased cost of doing business, advertising
demand will likely pull back. If advertising demand pulls back, that of course will impact
Meta's top line. Now, of course, we have Google. That one's down 2.9%. Now, Google's not trading
down quite as much as Meta. I think that's for a couple of different reasons. One of them is
Google's already so cheap. The company's trading at such a low PE ratio that there's just a level
of resistance there. How cheap can this company go? How much can you discount it for future threats?
So, there's that aspect of it that it's already at such a low valuation, much cheaper than Meta
at this point. But Google also is a little bit more diversified than Meta. It's not solely reliant
on small businesses. They have the cloud business. They have YouTube. They have all sorts of different
diversified revenue. So, this one is impacted to a smaller degree. We have ASML down 4.5%.
This company remains right in the center of this whole debate. ASML sells this specialized product
that everyone needs to create these chips. If there's less demand for these chips, less importing,
more barriers, it may impact ASML's business. Now, long term, I think this company is better
positioned than investors believe. But right now, it's being sold off with a pack. Tesla's down 4.22%.
No surprise here. You may believe that the tariffs will help Tesla in relation to other car companies
because Tesla makes most of their stuff in the US. But Tesla does a lot of business in China.
They have manufacturing in Germany. And right now, these tariffs stand to make auto manufacturing far
more expensive. NVIDIA is down 5.8%. This stock is already very high beta. So, part of it is because
this stock simply just trades around a lot. But it's also being grouped in because NVIDIA is going
to face these tariffs as well. They do business all around the world. There's now more friction
and more cost to doing business around the world. Now, finally, we get to Costco, which is moving
up today. It's in the green by 1.46%, defying gravity. Costco's a company that many people
are waiting. They're waiting for the time where Costco finally trades down to a reasonable valuation.
It trades at such a lofty high multiple that there must be some market crash or some time of panic
where Costco finally goes down. And here we have market panic. Here we have real fear,
real uncertainty, real predictions about the future and how things may work out in a bad way.
And Costco's in the green. Well, why is this? For a couple reasons. Costco is a company that not
only does well during good times, but it's considered a safe haven during bad times.
Costco is a subscription company that sells stuff everyone needs no matter what.
They have to buy it. They have to pay for this stuff. So, I view Costco as a company that
investors flee to during times of uncertainty like we have right now. Costco is uniquely positioned
to have better cost structure than other retailers because of their limited amount of SKUs, meaning
they sell fewer unique items so they can have more sweetheart deals in their bulk ordering.
Even though things will become more expensive for Costco, they'll become proportionately far
more expensive for competing retailers, increasing the value proposition of Costco
relative to their competitors. So we have all of these stocks, the majority of which are deeply
in the red. And overall, this is a response of the uncertainty and unpredictability,
the increased risk that was introduced yesterday. Now, before we go into my strategy, what I
personally plan on doing throughout this and how I see it working out, I just want to go ahead and
relive a little bit of what happened yesterday. Just kind of go through what I saw and my reaction
to it. So, this whole thing starts off with President Trump talking about how we've been
ripped off, right? As Americans, we've been ripped off by other countries. That's the story. Now,
personally, I don't believe that's the case. I think if a country somewhere else implements tariffs,
I think that's their problem. I don't think the US is being ripped off because we have to pay
tariffs. That's something you can argue, but that's very much a Milton Friedman way of looking
at things. A free trade, easy to do business, it's better for your country. So there's different
economic arguments here, and everyone's entitled to their view. If you disagree with it, that's
fine. So I don't personally believe as Americans that we're getting ripped off this whole time by
doing free trade. But putting aside whatever your personal philosophical economic views are,
President Trump goes up there and he makes that case. He makes the argument that the US is being
ripped off by other countries. They have these tariffs. We don't. We're paying a tax to do
business with them. They're not paying a tax to do business with us. So he's kind of gauging it.
He's kind of saying this is like implementing a fee, like a membership. It's like paying the
Costco yearly membership to do business with the US consumer. He views the US consumer as this very
valuable thing to have access to our market and our wallet, to have access to all of our consumers
that want to spend money. They have all this economic spending power. You have to pay taxes
to do so. You have to pay the membership to enter. That's kind of the way that he was phrasing this.
And then he brings up this board. Now, the board is comically small. You can't even see it,
even with the cameras. The reason that they made it so small is because he said it was windy. So
if they made a giant one, it would just blow away. So the reasoning behind it was kind of
funny to begin with. But of course, you can't even see what's going on here. He holds this up.
The line items are like 12 pixel font, and we can't see what's going on. So we're trying to
figure this out. And then he's reading it off one by one. Now, I found an HD version of this
same image, the board that he had that he was presenting. Here's an HD version of it. And this
is what he calls the reciprocal terrace. Now, keep in mind, this is just one of the boards.
So if you think it's only these like 50 countries, you're wrong. It goes on and on. There's like six
of these, six different images of every country that you can think of. In fact, I guarantee you,
there's countries you've never heard of before. There's ones listed that didn't even have many
people living there. And we're tariffing them as well. Now, looking at this board,
there's a few columns here. We have the country or territory off to the left, which is like China,
the European Union, Vietnam, so on. Then we have the tariff charge to the USA, which includes
currency manipulation and trade barriers. So this percentage right there looks like it's
an accumulation of all three of those type of factors. You're factoring in the base level tariff
they charge. You're also factoring in the fact that other countries manipulate their currency.
And also there's trade barriers. Now, trade barriers, for people not familiar, are non-tariff
ways that countries make it difficult or taxing or expensive to do business with them. So technically,
they're not charging a tariff, but they're really doing the same thing by making it very
difficult to import your product and flood your product into their country. For example,
China does this all the time. They have forced technology transfers. China has required foreign
companies to share and transfer their proprietary technology to Chinese joint ventures. So if you
want to do business in China, like if I wanted Qualtrim to do business in China, they may force
me to give up proprietary information, to give up the way that I do things, the methods of doing
things to other competitors. So you have to make these decisions, which technically aren't tariffs,
but they're costly and expensive nonetheless. There's a whole list of them. There's quotas,
there's licensing, there's agreements, there's red tapes, there's delays, there's overly
scrutinizing inspections, and so on and so forth. Countries can do things to disincentivize imports
without a blanket tariff. And I believe that's what was going to be factored in here.
So my assumption was that they came up with some type of algorithm or some type of way of calculating
the inclusion of trade barriers, price manipulation, and a base level tariff, and that's how they got
to this number. But upon further investigation, we found out that these numbers have nothing to do
with tariffs or trade barriers in and of themselves. They only have to do with trade imbalances,
trade surpluses. We have an administration official that gave us the exact calculation
they used to quantify this reciprocal tariff number. Here's what the actual formula looks
like. Now, it's been a while since I've done advanced algebra, and I don't recognize a lot
of these symbols, but if you break it down, this is basically what it means. You have the exports
a country does, minus the imports, divided by the imports. So you're basically just taking the
a formula that divides the country's trade surplus with the US by its total exports,
based on data from US Census Bureau in 2024. And then that number was divided by two,
producing the discounted rate. So basically, the number right here, where it says tariffs
charged to the US, doesn't actually represent tariffs charged to the US at all. For most of
these countries, like China, you have a 7% tariff. It's very minor. This 67% is the trade imbalance.
It's the trade imbalance and surplus that the US has with China. The USTR statement said that
while it was technically possible to calculate rates for the actual barriers, this methodology
would achieve Trump's goal of driving down trade deficits. So this is showing the relationship of
trade we have with these different countries. So it's important when looking at this chart to
realize that these two numbers don't represent the same thing. The implication, when you compare
them side by side, is that they're the same thing. That China's charging us 67% to do business in
China, and we're only responding with a 34% tax on them. Therefore, we're taxing them less. That's
not the case. The 67% is a trade imbalance calculation. It's not a tax. The 34% is a tax.
So these two numbers are different. The amount that we're now charging them in tariffs is much
larger than what they're charging us. Now one of the confusing parts of this is President Trump
mentioned that even in the cases where a country's doing specifically what we're wanting them to do,
what Trump is wanting them to do, which means that they're actually buying more from the US
than they're selling to the US, the opposite thing that China's doing, even for those countries where
we're selling more to them than what they're selling to us, we're still slapping on a 10%
tariff. So we're still saying you have to pay a tariff even when you're doing exactly what we want
you to do. So this is a head-scratcher to me. I don't know what the incentive here is for charging
countries even when they're doing exactly what we're wanting them to do. So we know that the
numbers off to the left of what they're charging us aren't exactly accurate, but we can only assume
that the numbers that we're going to charge them, right here on the right, are accurate. This is what
we say we're going to charge these other companies in tariffs to do business with the US. We kick
things off here with a 34% tariff from China. Now obviously we get a lot of stuff from China,
a lot of imports from China. US consumers really like buying stuff from China, but with a 34% tariff
that becomes dramatically more expensive. And there is a little bit of confusion on this one.
We don't really know if this is in addition to the already existing 20% tariff from China
or if it's just going to be 34%. So it might actually be 54%. We don't quite know yet.
With the European Union we now have a 20% tariff on them, so all of Europe. Now notably we have
some big territories and countries missing like Canada and Mexico, so I'm still not sure of what
we're doing there, but we have tariffs all across Asia. Vietnam, Taiwan, Japan, India, South Korea,
Thailand, Switzerland, Indonesia, Malaysia. These tariffs range anywhere from 46% for Vietnam.
Places where Nike's manufacturing a lot of their goods, all of a sudden their supply
chains are in trouble. The cost of doing business in those countries are going to be dramatically
higher. So that's the reason that Nike's down big today. What are they going to do in this
situation? They really have nowhere else to go. Nike sweatshirts and Nike shoes are going to be
dramatically more expensive if this doesn't get removed. And you go through the list here, it
doesn't really get any better. And the calculation overall is that this is around a 20% universal
tariff, which is a staggering number when you think about a new tax of 20% to the entire world.
Now the argument here from many people still is that this is a negotiating tactic. That Trump is
simply shocking the market, forcing other countries to take him seriously, forcing them to think about
their relationship with the US, and forcing them hopefully to lower their tariffs so that we take
ours off, so that we have free trade across the board. That's the argument that many people are
still making, and it's an argument that I had made. It made sense for Trump to use tariffs as a
negotiating tactic to bring other countries to the table, to make deals, to make solutions, to talk
business. That's something that I could see happening on a select basis in a very strategic
manner. That's what he was originally doing a couple months ago. He would tariff one country,
bring them to the table, and then make an agreement, and usually it was resolved within 24
hours, typically before the tariff even went into effect. So that seemed like it was a more strategic
negotiating tactic. But what we're seeing now seems like a change of tone. It doesn't seem like this
is just a negotiating tactic. A lot of the commentary seems very mixed on this subject,
but what I'm seeing is still a response from the White House that they're not really wanting
to negotiate. For example, listen to this interview here. This is a quote from a White
House official. Quote, this is not a negotiation. This is a national emergency. Any country that
thinks that they can simply make an announcement promising to lower some tariff is ignoring the
big central problem of their massive non-tariff barriers. Just on CNN this morning saying the
president is firm in his approach and that if countries had wanted to negotiate, they had 70
years to do it. A White House official also told reporters yesterday that this is not a negotiation,
it's a national emergency, and that cutting tariffs now is not enough that ignores the
decades of trade barriers. So we have the posture from the White House insisting that this isn't a
negotiation. This isn't simply a negotiating tactic because if a country just says they're
going to lower their tariffs, it doesn't address the trade barriers and the other aspects.
So maybe they need to do more? But the attitude right now is that it's almost like it's too little
too late. Other countries simply can't negotiate even if they want to. And it seems like the
opposite message that doesn't incentivize bringing people to the table. For example,
we have the example of Israel. It was hit with a 17% tariff despite saying it would scrap levies
on U.S. goods. This shows that even countries that have given concessions, that have come to
the negotiating table, that said that they want to work in good faith with the U.S.,
are still kind of being ignored as of least right now. We don't know if there's going to be a deal
struck in the future, but right now it seems like every country is being tariffed. So we have this
continued back and forth debate of whether or not this is a negotiating tactic or this is just
the new normal, a new way of doing business under the Trump administration. We have people like
Steve Mnuchin going on to CNBC and he's on the side that this is a negotiating tactic. Still
today, even after seeing what's going on, he still believes that these tariffs will be taken down.
I think it's the larger tariffs that are called the reciprocal tariffs. I'm hopeful that those
be negotiated down, that those are tariffs that will bring people to the table and will negotiate
them down. Now ultimately we don't know what's going to happen in the future, whether or not a
lot of this stuff is going to be negotiated down, or whether it's going to stick around for a while.
We don't know either way, but if the tariffs do stick around like they're presented here,
the market is going to go lower. That is going to be a very predictable outcome of this because
these tariffs are simply too steep to not have major impacts on the earnings of these companies,
on their ability to source these products for the prices they have. So we'll see what happens
in the future, but there's a tremendous amount of uncertainty. Now in terms of what I do in
situations like this, knowing that we don't know a lot and there's a lot of uncertainty,
is in most cases I use any type of weakness like this to buy into stocks. Now that may come across
as glib, that I'm going to be buying stocks during this time period. Or it may come across as me not
taking this seriously, like I'm shrugging off these concerns and that I don't think anything
bad can happen as a result of these incredibly high tariffs, and I assure you that's not the
case. During time periods where this type of stuff happens, causing stocks to sell off dramatically
from prices they were just months ago, is a time period I typically choose to buy. In fact,
the time periods where the market sells off the most, like March of 2020, during a time period
where there is a virus racing around killing millions of people, the entire economy was shut
down, logistics and supply chains were shut down, I continued to buy stock during that time period.
I didn't know what was going to happen. I couldn't have a crystal clear vision of the future. Any time
period where stocks sell down dramatically, there's inherently a lot of unknowns. That is the reason
that investors get cold feet. That is the reason that great companies go on sale. So even though
I don't like the reason stocks go down, I didn't like the reason they went down in March of 2020,
I don't like the reason they're going down today, the fact remains that these companies I'm buying
are not going to be around for a year or two. These are companies that will be around for the
next 20 plus years. So if I can get a more attractive deal on these companies amidst turmoil,
panic, unpredictability, unpredictable futures, that's a time period where I'd like to increase
my share count as much as possible. During the time periods where investors are the most fearful
is when we should be buying the most. So having said that, let's go ahead and go into my trades
today. The first thing I did was I sold out of a company all the way, which was Vechey. I own no
shares of Vechey currently. Now Vechey was doing just fine. In fact, if we look at the company here,
the stock price has barely moved today, only down 1.3%. Year to date, it's up 9.5%. So this company
is in the green. It's doing well. It held up well. It's a very low volatility stock that has really
good fundamentals. There's no panic mode with Vechey. This company will continue to pay investors
dividends. They'll continue to collect rent. I sold this company, which is a low volatility
company that's in the green this year, to buy more into companies that have higher volatility
that are in the red by a greater extent. Now, one of the companies that I introduced new to my
portfolio is Equifax. I just bought $10,000 of this company, and I'll continue to add to this
position. Right now, Equifax is an introductory position. Now I have it here in the financial
category because Equifax is overall a financial and data analytic company. But a lot of people
have a misunderstanding of what this company actually is. Now with Equifax, this is a company
that in the previous episode, I highlighted as being an attractive stock. With the sell-off today,
I believe it provides a unique entry point. So I decided to start building my position in this
company. Now I've already talked a little bit about what the company does, but I just want to
mention a few things that I see in the future of this company. One of them is that most people
know this company by the credit bureau, meaning that Equifax is one of the three big credit
companies. When you buy a home, you'll get your credit ran by them because they know all this
information about you. But that's only one part of the company. The more exciting part of the company,
one that makes up around half their revenue, is their workforce solution. Specifically, they have
a product called the work number, which is basically proprietary information on verifying someone's
background. Where they have your work history, your college information, they know all about you.
Now for employers, especially government jobs or large organizations, they want to know who they're
actually hiring. They want to know if you actually went and did the things that you said that you did,
that you went and worked for the companies you did, that you have the background that you do.
Instead of calling up your old employer to verify that information, they now use the work number by
Equifax. They have the majority share in this verification market, and this is a major growth
path for this company. It's very difficult to create this record base of millions of people
and verify all of this information, so they are very strategically ahead in this important product.
And then the third thing is, Equifax has become a little bit like a data analytics company.
Similar to how Visa and MasterCard have these value-add services, Equifax has the same thing.
For example, they've partnered with MasterCard on offering identity verification solutions. So
they have fraud prevention, and they're building out all these different analytic tools that they
can partner with other businesses. This is another growth path for this company.
Now there's a lot more I plan on going into with Equifax when I do a full video on this one,
with their history and the database breach, how they've moved to cloud, they've re-architected
the company, how they have major efficiencies and headwinds that are behind them. There's lots of
good things going on with this business, but it's one that I decided right now, given the hysteria,
given the panic, I'll likely get a lot more attractive of a deal today than I will any other
time. So I'm starting the position, and I'll continue to add to this one, especially if it
dips. Now in the story fund, I continue to add to this portfolio. I'm really excited about the
story fund. The gains have gone from around $130,000 to now $87,000. Just today, specifically
with Amazon, it's down $11,000. So Amazon has sold off big time. We're down 3.8%. Luckily,
Netflix, again, is kind of holding up this portfolio. Netflix is really carrying a lot
of heavy weight here. While the rest of the Mag 7 goes down, Netflix continues to do well.
But Amazon is now my major focus. I bought another $5,000 of Amazon stock this morning.
Even though trade policies change, elections come and go, there's different leaders, different
policies, different agreements all the time, Amazon's a company that I believe will be around
for 20 plus years. I don't really care too much if earnings get revised lower this year,
or they get revised higher. Either way, I want to own this company because of the earnings power I
see 20 years from now, or 40 years from now. When you look at a discounted cash flow timeline that
goes out 20 years, and you look at a couple years that don't make as much money, that's not such a
big deal. It's not that big of an intrinsic value change in the stock. The best investors are the
that can put all the macro aside and hold on to great quality companies through any environment.
Benjamin Graham and Warren Buffett made their money by holding Geico through decades of time,
during all different types of market volatility and uncertainty. They didn't look at next quarter's
estimates and sell out because they got frightened. That's not the way they made money
in these compounders like Geico. The same thing can be said for many great investors.
You look at Peter Lynch and the times he bought aggressively was during macro environments when
everyone else was panicking. So even though Amazon is going to be impacted heavily by tariffs,
they're not going to avoid this somehow. I will still use it as an opportunity to buy into this
company. Because over the fullness of time, I still see Amazon well positioned to win big.
So that's what I'm doing with my portfolio, and I'll continue to give you more updates
throughout this week and next week. So if you haven't already, subscribe to the channel,
and I'll see you in the next one.
