How to Look at: Medieval Panel Paintings | Frieze Masters 2024

Vintage Visions
7 followers
#medievalhistory #Frieze #FriezeLondon
In conversation with Nathan Clements-Gillespie, Director of Frieze Masters, Jana Gajdošová, Curator and Medieval Specialist at Sam Fogg (showing at Frieze Masters 2024), offers an insight into the elaborate construction of 15th-century altarpieces and we learn about some of the hallmarks of the late medieval style.
This panel painting is considered a ‘miracle of survival’. Originating in the late 15th century, likely from Vienna, the panel formed part of a winged, double-sided altarpiece. While the exterior side depicts the assumption of Mary Magdalene, its interior portrays the visitation of the Virgin Mary – with the two Mary's having an unusually similar resemblance.
So, Jana, what are we looking at here?
I mean, it's an incredible work of art.
Yeah, so this is a late 15th century
double-sided panel painting
that comes from most probably Austria.
We think Vienna.
So what this actually would have originally been a part of
is a winged altarpiece.
On the exterior side,
we see the assumption of Mary Magdalene.
And so from that we can draw
that the exterior panels of this altarpiece
originally would have shown the life of Mary Magdalene.
And then when the altarpiece was opened,
you would have seen this scene,
but also others amongst it,
and these would have shown the life of the Virgin Mary,
the visitation being one of those scenes.
And what would it have felt like
looking at a piece of an altarpanel
within the context of the full altarpiece?
Altarpieces were absolutely enormous.
Sometimes you could still see some of them
in Central European, German and Austrian churches.
And you often have these wings
that open up into a kind of cabinet
which often houses sculptures.
But they also would have been often topped
by absolutely enormous micro-architectural crowns
that often reached all the way up to the vaults of the church.
What would the effect have been on a contemporary viewer
if the exterior was painted
and then when the panel is opened
it reveals this incredibly elaborate, precious
and also luminous interior with the gold detailing?
Here we're looking at just one panel painting
and the side that we are looking at
is the side that has the more elaborate gilding.
And even today when you go to a church
that still has one of these altarpieces in situ,
what you see most of the time
is that the altarpieces are displayed in their open position.
But in the Middle Ages this would not have been so.
Instead, it was only on special occasions,
on holidays, on feast days,
that the altarpieces would have been opened up
to show the side that is more precious,
the side that has the use of lots of gold.
Coming into a church, especially on a feast day
or on a special occasion
when these sculptures and the gilding on these panels was revealed,
it would have also been something that I imagine would inspire faith.
And what is the visitation?
It actually shows the moment
when the Virgin Mary goes to visit her cousin Elizabeth.
They have this tender exchange where they hold hands.
Of course we cannot hear what they're saying to each other,
but actually it's the moment when they both realise
that both of them are pregnant at the same time.
It's very beautiful and moving
and that really is made so clear by the artist
and almost jumps out from the panel itself,
not to mention Mary's incredible hair.
Yes, and what's actually interesting about the hair
is that on the other side,
obviously you have the assumption of Mary Magdalene
and what you see on that panel
is Mary Magdalene completely nude
and covered only in her long flowing hair,
actually looking very similar to the Virgin Mary on this side.
Stylistically, the artist is portraying these women very similarly,
but the connection between these two Marys
transcends mere juxtaposition.
It implies a deeper spiritual meaning,
linking a sense of redemption with the anticipation of salvation.
Looking at this, what tells us it is a medieval work of art?
What are the telltale signs that this is medieval art,
indeed that this is late medieval art?
It's a difficult one to answer,
but there are certain characteristics
that would suggest that you can call it medieval.
For example, you have a common iconography
depicted in a way that shows that it is copying
popular patterns that have been circulating
for tens of or sometimes hundreds of years.
You have the use of gilding
and that juxtaposition between the pigment and the gilding.
You have a medieval city in the background.
You have a very specific style of drapery here,
this sort of drapery that's often compared
to a scrunched up piece of paper.
And so I think those are the kinds of elements
that often you sort of look for
to say that something is medieval and not Renaissance.
Precisely, they are otherworldly.
They're from hundreds of years ago.
Why should we be looking at them today?
What makes this relevant to our times?
I think we can all learn from the past,
you know, with whichever period we look at.
And I think this panel or artworks from this period
are really a window into that time period,
which is really special.
And I think we're privileged
to be able to look through that window.
And I also think it's important to remember
that there are different percentages that people use,
but often it is said that only something like 5% to 10%
of what existed in terms of art of the Middle Ages
survives today.
And so we often call these things miracles of survival
because to have something here from, you know,
500, 600 years ago is, I think, a miracle.
