01:49 What Is Medieval? 05:45 The Book of Kells 06:53 Notre Dame Cathedral, Paris 07:31 The Cloisters Unicorn Tapestries 08:38 Renaissance 11:08 Primevera, Sandro Botticelli 11:50 The Duomo, Florence 12:39 Perseus and Medusa Art Title: ""Battle delivered under the walls of Antioch between the crusaders led by Bohemond and the army of Karbouka, general of the Sultan of Persia, June 1098"", Frederic Schopin, 1804-1880
Bibliography & Sources:
A feather on the breath of God: Sequences and Hymns from Abbess Hildegard of Bingen, Gothic Voices, Hyperion Stereo, 1981.
Britannica
Diffley, Anne-Marie. “Why Is the Book of Kells Important?” Visit Trinity, 20 Jan. 2025, Fossi, Gloria. Romanesque & Gothic. Sterling Pub. Co, 2008.
Henry, Françoise. The Book Of Kells: Reproductions of the Manuscript in Trinity College Dublin. Alfred A. Knopf, 1974.
Le Roy Ladurie, Emmanuel, and Barbara Bray. Montaillou: The Promised Land of Error. Vintage Books, 1979.
Meyer, Isabella “Famous Medieval Paintings.” Art in Context, 1 Aug. 2023, artincontext.org/famous-medieval-paintings/.
Monty Python and the Holy Grail, dir Terry Gilliam & Terry Jones, 1975, Python (Monty) Pictures.
Nyberg, Jeanette. “45 Alarming Creatures in Medieval Art.” This Is so Fun!, This is so fun!, 12 Nov. 2023, sofun.substack.com/p/creatures-in-medieval-art.
Toman, Rolf. The Art of the Italian Renaissance: Architecture, Sculpture, Painting, Drawing. H. F. Ullmann, 2007.
The Secret of Kells, dir. Tomm Moore & Nora Twomey, 2009, Ireland.
The Hunchback of Notre Dam, dir. Gary Trousdale & Kirk Wise, 1996, Disney.
The Sword in the Stone, dr. Wolfgang Reitherman, 1963, Disney.
Wikipedia
What's the difference between the medieval times and the renaissance fair? I mean,
the medieval times and the renaissance. Both are eras of European history that lasted for
centuries. The medieval times and the renaissance both took place so long ago that they almost feel
like another dimension. Some people think they're the same thing, especially when it comes to
costumes. I did an art history deep dive to try and get to the bottom of each movement's main
themes and historical contexts. I read quite a few books, but still, this is a very brief overview
of many centuries of history. This is my researched perspective. I'm sure this analysis has
some blind spots, but this is what I learned. In a nutshell, the middle ages comes between
the fall of Rome and the renaissance. That covers almost 1,000 years. The word medieval
comes from the Latin medium evum, which literally translates to middle age. You may also hear the
ages referred to as the dark ages, medieval, and when appropriate, gothic. Some movies that
take place during the middle ages are A Knight's Tale, Braveheart, and Camelot. The renaissance
lasted from about the late 1300s until the 1700s, when it evolved into the age of enlightenment.
The word renaissance comes from the Italian word rineschitta, which means rebirth. The
renaissance is also called the age of discovery, the early modern period, and in England,
the Elizabethan period. You can see the renaissance in films like Shakespeare in Love,
Ever After, and Franco Zeffirelli's Romeo and Juliet. This video focuses on the European
middle ages and mainly the Italian renaissance. Were the so-called dark ages really that dark?
Let's take a closer look. Before the year 400, the Roman Empire basically ruled all of Europe.
Around the year 400, barbarians, which is just a word that means not Romans,
like the Goths and the Vandals, invaded Rome from the east because they were fleeing the Huns.
Their influence would emerge in medieval art and architecture, with gothic architecture being the
most obvious example. The barbarian invasions destroyed or obscured a lot of art and philosophy
from the ancient world. After the fall of Western Rome, most European communities were tribal,
isolated, and superstitious. This was a time when some people believed people of other races
actually looked like this. This was a time when people thought the devil could enter your body
if you sneezed. This was also a time when dragons, unicorns, and griffins were just
regular old animals. Belief shaped the hearts and minds of medieval people, and one organization in
particular wanted everyone to believe in them, the Catholic Church. The Catholic Church was the
most dominant force in medieval history. You know the phrase, history is written by the winner?
The Catholic Church was basically winning history for hundreds of years because they
were the only ones who knew how to write. Monasteries were some of the only places
you could get a formal education. Today, interpretations of medieval history are
largely in flux as historians take a closer look at obscure perspectives about what life
was actually like in the Middle Ages. We do know the Catholic Church promised a glorious
kingdom of heaven to good peasants who gave what little money they had back to the Catholic Church.
The Church used this money to create stunning art, cathedrals, altarpieces, and illuminated
manuscripts. If you were a peasant, going to church was probably your best chance to experience
fine art or music. But the Church wasn't all calligraphy and choral music. As one TV special
puts it, it's the Middle Ages when religious messages of peace, unity, and tolerance inspire
humankind to fight to the death for hundreds of years. They called these religious wars the
Crusades. During the Crusades, the Christians fought the Catholics, the Catholics fought the Muslims,
and basically everyone fought over the Holy Land, especially Jerusalem, which was sort of the center
of the known world. The Catholic Church also launched something called the Inquisition.
The Inquisition wanted to convert heretics, pagans, and non-believers to Christianity,
usually through torture, imprisonment, and or death. We also have the Black Death,
aka the Bubonic Plague. During the Middle Ages, it is estimated that the Bubonic Plague killed
one-third of all people living in Europe. People in the Middle Ages lived very closely with death.
Even though the term Dark Ages is a bit outdated, the legacy of the Middle Ages is quite dark.
This was a time of kings and castles, although even they usually had to answer to the Catholic Church.
Most modern ideas we have about the medieval period, like princesses and chivalry, actually
come from the Romantic era, which romanticized medieval times. We can see a strong desire for
hope emerging in medieval art. You've probably seen medieval art that looks like this. It wasn't
that artists actually thought humans looked like two-dimensional noodle people, this was simply
stylish. Art historian Angelica Semenina writes, artists were tasked with conveying complex
theological concepts through visual symbols and allegories, rather than realistic representations
of the physical world. You'll notice medieval art usually doesn't have much of a background,
it's mostly symbols and figures. Medieval art looks flat and amateurish compared to Renaissance
art. Simple shapes work well for tapestries and stained glass, two popular forms of medieval art.
Figures were used to decorate text, which means they were actually quite small.
Let's look closer at some medieval art.
The Book of Kells is an iconic piece of Celtic history. The text is not so unique,
it's simply the four Christian Gospels written in Latin, but the illustrations practically glow.
This illuminated manuscript features Celtic knots, baffling creatures, and intricate details.
Anne-Marie Diffley of the Old Library at Trinity College writes,
Every medieval monastery held copies of sacred texts, but the Book of Kells is one of only a
tiny fraction that have survived. The Book of Kells survived a brutal Viking raid where 68
monks were slaughtered. There was a legend that the Book of Kells was written by angels,
and that the unworthy would go blind if they looked at it. We know that monks created the
Book of Kells, not angels, but that doesn't make it any less stunning. Some of the images are very
tiny, and some appear to move. The book is made of pigment on vellum or animal skin. It's called
the Book of Kells because it ended up in Kells, Ireland. It's the subject of the animated feature
The Secret of Kells. You can see the Book of Kells at Trinity College in Ireland.
The Notre-Dame de Paris is one of the world's most famous churches. Notre-Dame means Our Lady
in French. This cathedral took almost 100 years to complete and has stood for almost a thousand.
It has many trademarks of Gothic architecture, such as Moorish arches, rose windows, and gargoyles.
The cathedral is the setting for the animated feature The Hunchback of Notre-Dame, although
this film takes place during the Renaissance. Notre-Dame is still a functioning Catholic church,
and you can visit it in Paris, France. I think the unicorn tapestries are so popular because
they're just good design. They have contrast, symmetry, and a big circle. In the Middle Ages,
the unicorn represented virginity. Some said only a virgin could approach a unicorn.
Some say the unicorn is a virgin, and the unicorn in captivity represents marriage.
Some historians believe these tapestries were actually a wedding present. The tapestries use
a millefleur, or millions of flowers, motif. The tapestries come from Brussels, and the weaver
is unknown. Medieval and Gothic design imply otherness, mystery, and a touch of the arcane.
How does one emerge from a dark age? I have to believe medieval artists saw the humor in their
confusing world. Today, high fantasy takes inspiration from medieval history, with kingdoms,
creatures, and heroes. The end of the medieval times depends on where you lived. The Renaissance
happened not suddenly like with the fall of Rome, but slowly, like a blooming flower.
If the Middle Ages were all about surrendering a chaotic universe to a higher power,
the Renaissance was all about humanism. Humanism is a belief system that places value on human
experience and interaction, rather than on divine or supernatural dogma. For example,
this means inventing something to solve your problems instead of relying on prayer. As a result,
the Renaissance art depicted lots and lots of humans. These humans looked natural, anatomically
correct, and often nude. Historian Johann Huizinga writes, The Renaissance marks the rise of the
individual, the awakening of a desire for beauty, a triumphal procession of joyful life, and a
renewal of the pagan pursuit of happiness. The Renaissance was also nostalgic for ancient Greece
and Rome. They loved using Greek gods and goddesses, marble sculpture, and frescoes.
Frescoes were huge, literally, and they were very trendy. Frescoes are paintings made on fresh,
wet plaster. They are challenging because the artist must complete the painting before the
plaster dries. The most famous Renaissance fresco is the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel,
painted by Michelangelo. The Renaissance gave us our first celebrity artists, like Botticelli,
Michelangelo, or Leonardo da Vinci. These men were famous and well-compensated during their
lifetimes. Legend has it that artists actually started signing their work because of Michelangelo.
Art historian Vasari, in his Life of Michelangelo, describes the young artist's anger upon hearing
a loudmouthed Lombard claim that the work had been made by a certain Gobbo of Milan.
So, later that evening, Michelangelo rapidly chiseled his name on the sash across the
Virgin's chest. Renaissance art making was expensive and required much skill. Artists
usually did not get to choose what they made. They made whatever the church or wealthy families
wanted. Some of the most famous art of all time is Renaissance art. Some of the greatest hits are
the Mona Lisa by Leonardo da Vinci, The Last Supper by da Vinci, The Birth of Venus by Botticelli,
the Sistine Chapel by Michelangelo, David by Michelangelo, and the Creation of Adam,
which is actually just part of the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel by Michelangelo.
Let's look at some slightly deeper cuts of Renaissance art.
Primavera was commissioned by the prolific Medici family, who commissioned lots of
Renaissance art. It hung next to The Birth of Venus in the Medici's summer home.
The painting features Mercury, the god of commerce, and Venus, the goddess of love,
looking slightly more clothed than she does in her companion piece.
Zephyr, the west wind, creates a sweeping sense of motion, moving the figures from right to left,
or from east to west. This could suggest the Renaissance itself, as the Renaissance
considered itself a rebuilding of Western civilization.
The Medici's commissioned Primavera specifically to commemorate the Renaissance in Florence.
The Duomo of Florence, or Firenze, is one of Italy's most popular landmarks.
The Duomo, like Notre Dame, is a cathedral. Although the construction of the church began
in the Middle Ages, the Duomo, or dome, was missing for almost 100 years.
That's because the Florentines did not want gothic buttresses like on medieval cathedrals.
They wanted an octagonal dome inspired by Rome's Pantheon. This proposed dome was supposed to be
the highest and widest in history, and you best believe they stuck a fresco in there.
Florentines hoped the Duomo would bring Florence into the Renaissance.
It did, and has remained a symbol of both the city and the Renaissance ever since.
Cellini's patrons told him this pokey, unbalanced sculpture couldn't be made,
and it almost wasn't. Cellini's workshop caught fire and his furnace exploded during the making
of this bronze sculpture. Cellini wrote,
There was a sudden explosion and a tremendous flash of fire,
as if a thunderbolt had been hurled in our midst. The cover of the furnace had cracked
open and the bronze was pouring out. Then, seeing that the metal was not
running as easily as it should, I sent for all my pewter plates,
bowls, and salvers and put them in. And then, in an instant, my mold was filled.
So I knelt down and thanked God with all my heart.
I think this quote and this piece show an interesting relationship between the Greek
gods and the Christian one. The thunderbolt sounds like Zeus,
and the artist thanks God for helping him finish this essentially pagan sculpture.
Perseus and Medusa was placed in the Piazza della Signoria,
facing stone statues of David and Hercules. David is from the Bible and Hercules is a demigod.
Medusa is a gorgon whose gaze could turn you to stone.
The placement of the statue implies that Perseus, a human,
has petrified the blessed David and the hero Hercules.
It's very cheeky and also very humanist.
The Renaissance is sometimes called the early modern period because it set the stage for the
world we live in now. The Renaissance gave us Shakespeare and Machiavelli.
The Renaissance led to enlightenment, which led to democracy.
And it's commemorated each year with a Renaissance fair.
But really quickly, The Medieval Times is a medieval-themed dinner show with jousting,
and the Renaissance fair is like an old-timey version of the mall, also with jousting.
It's really more like a Elizabethan fair in my arrogant opinion,
but that is a topic for another video.
What do you think? Do you prefer the Renaissance or the Middle Ages?
What are some of your favorite pieces? Let me know in the comments.
Thank you so much for joining me and watching. If you have something to share,
please leave it in the community so we can all learn from each other.
It's so fun and enriching to explore your recommendations and share your love of art
and history. Take care, everybody. Cheers.