Protecting the future: Navigating rising risks and evolving demands in corporate insurance

Business Insurance
4 followers
4 Video Views·Sep 23, 2025
In this Q3 edition of the Professional Risks Power Panel, Insurance Business TV explores the evolving landscape of directors’ and officers’ (D&O) liability, ESG pressures, AI developments, and more. Featuring insights from Ruth Kochenderfer - Managing Director at Marsh, Larry Fine - Management Liability Coverage Leader at Willis North America, and Dwight Williams - National Account Director of Executive Risk Solutions at Risk Strategies, the panel addresses rising reserve uncertainty, elevated claim severity, and the shifting risk environment facing today’s professionals. Stay ahead with expert perspectives on how insurers, brokers, and clients can navigate these challenges.
Hello everyone, welcome to Insurance Business TV and welcome to the Q3 edition of our Professional
Risks Power Panel. This time around, we're going to delve into D&O structures, ESG pressures, AI,
and more. And to do that, we welcome back our experts. Well, no Jacqueline Waters this time
around, but we do have Ruth Kokendurfer, Managing Director at Marsh, Larry Fine,
Management Liability Coverage Leader, Phoenix North America at Willis, and Dwight Williams,
National Account Director, Executive Risk Solutions Practice at Risk Strategies,
part of the Brown and Brown team. So welcome once again, everyone. And since we last met,
insurers have continued to flag reserve uncertainty and elevated claim severity
in financial lines. So how should brokers advise corporate clients on structuring D&O and management
liability programs, particularly, of course, around limits, retentions, defense costs,
in an environment of ongoing pricing pressure and selective underwriting? Ruth, I'll start with you.
Absolutely. So I feel like we have been operating in this environment since I became a broker more
than 10 years ago, right? This is kind of a, the heightened claim severity has been one in the
management liability space for a while now. So I think it's really, we're talking about what are
the best practices that we should always be operating under, right? And I always start with
prepare by underwriting your own risks. And so what do I mean by work? What do I mean by that?
Well, we have to work with our clients to identify our client's strengths and weaknesses.
And I really want to stress that, right? I think our clients are great about highlighting their
strengths. It's the weaknesses part, right? That we really need to be on top of and help them
explain what's going on, right? Hey, maybe sales are down, but maybe that's because you decide,
hey, we're going to exit an unprofitable line and we're going to be really investing here, right?
It's that story that's always there, but it's really making sure you're highlighting in a
positive way and you're in front of it before the underwriter is. And I can't stress this enough.
This is critical turning to kind of what you're really doing with your DNO insurance program.
You need to make sure you pick the right carriers, especially when you are in an area time of
elevated claims. Picking the right carriers means you're picking the carrier that has a track record
of paying claims, that has a track record of being responsive, that is willing to negotiate with you
when you aren't using their panel counsel, right? And you need to, you want to use your own counsel
and it's all of those things and that's what your broker is going to help you do.
So in these times, it's always important to always have your best practices.
Dwight, do you agree with Ruth's comments at the top there? Is this perennially the
environment that we're in?
100% agree with Ruth. This environment is perennially the one that we need to sort of
operate under. And to Ruth's point, we have to help our clients to understand their own
exposures to make sure that they're articulating that well to the underwriting community. Underwriters
are underwriting with a great degree of scrutiny given the uncertainty in our environment. And so
we have to prep them as best we can to proactively sort of highlight those highs and address the
lows in the way that is constructive. When you talk about limits, retentions, and premiums,
obviously we want low premiums. Obviously we want to have best-in-class coverage. But to Ruth's
point, the relationships we build with those insurers is critically important. And we want
to make sure that when the rubber hits the road, that we're partnered with an insurer that
understands the business as articulated by the client, but also can respond to claims in a way
that is fair and equitable. Our policies tend to be defense inside the limit policies, and we know
that. That's historically how our policies are structured. We want to make sure that if there
is an opportunity to get additional limit for defense only, we take it. If there is an opportunity
to increase, you know, side A DIC limits, that we do that. If there's an opportunity to increase a
sublimit, we take that opportunity, particularly on a derivative sublimit side. So there are a
myriad of things that we can do, but it all starts to Ruth's point with making sure that we
present and help our clients to present themselves in a light that is favorable to the insurance
community. Brokers are clearly looking for the opportunities, Larry, but are carriers offering
any incentives? Well, I know Ruth mentioned defense arrangements, and so sometimes the broker's most
difficult job is getting a defense firm approved that maybe wasn't on the list or whatever. That
can be hard work. But on the other hand, sometimes it's useful for us to highlight to
clients that some carriers offer pretty good incentives to use some good firms where you might
get retention relief or something like that. So they should perhaps have an open mind. You know,
sometimes some clients do, some clients don't. They have their strong opinions. But in general,
to the extent your question is, you know, how do you make this all work in this tough environment
and get what you need in terms of insurance? I think one of the most important things is analytics.
So because all brokers do benchmarking, but if you have good analytics that give you,
you know, benchmarking, it's just kind of like family feud. It says like what people think,
but not necessarily what's right. So analytics gives you another important data point so you
can cross-index and figure out, you know, product-specific information about what
your exposure is on that product. But also, at least as important, we do some holistic analytics
where we can figure out the benefit you're getting from each dollar that you spend on
different products and how to maximize your overall insurance spend benefit. I think that's important.
Family feud reference. So I'm pretty sure if people were guessing what would be on the board
for today's discussion, they would no doubt have picked out AI regulators and investors,
of course, increasingly scrutinizing corporate claims around AI use and capabilities. So,
Dwight, how should underwriters and brokers approach risk assessments and disclosure
practices to mitigate the growing DNO exposure from allegations of misrepresentation or indeed,
as it's called, AI washing? It's a great question and probably a difficult one to answer in one fair
swoop. What I will say is that whether it be sort of AI-related risks or any of the others that we'll
talk about today, the buck inevitably stops at the board level. And whether or not disclosures
are done properly, whether or not misrepresentations are made, the mere allegation will implicate the
board. And so what we want to make sure that we have is a policy that responds in a way that you
would expect it to in that sort of unlikely event of a claim. We've seen over the last few years,
whether your source is Cornerstone or some others, that the claims related to AI are on the rise.
We've seen from 2023, they doubled in 2024. We're already probably sort of halfway. We're to the
mark at 2024, already halfway through 2025. And so we're going to see that trend continue.
And so boards need to prep for that exposure. They need to, more importantly, have a policy
that can respond in a way that is favourable to them. So I'm curious to know from some of
the other panellists what their insights are and how they prep boards accordingly.
Yeah, well, let's take it to Larry next with that in mind. And Larry,
are underwriters actually asking questions about AI?
Yes, I think they mostly are, but I think we're still mostly the check the box stage where they
should ask, do you have procedures in place or are you using a lot of AI, but not necessarily
getting very into the weeds, which is fine. Most underwriters don't have the high-tech experience.
Relatedly, if your client has anyone on the board who has some relevant experience in any
particular category, particularly though here, this cutting edge area, it's good to highlight
that if you have it to work with. And so of the cases we've been seeing, the increasing volume
of cases involving AI, it's mostly been AI washing, companies being accused of exaggerating their AI
capabilities. But I think in the future, we're going to see more cases arising from AI-related
risks that weren't fully disclosed, particularly the indirect effects of AI use by competitors
and others up or down market. So the scope of what could be relevant AI-wise is greater than
some companies may realize, and they're going to be called upon to give more fulsome disclosures.
Okay, so we're starting to see more variety in AI-related claims,
perhaps, than Ruth. Any examples to share around this?
Absolutely. So I think Dwight and Larry hit on a lot of things. So I'm going to hit on
just a bit of trends. And we had a law firm that did some really interesting research.
So they looked at the 2024 filings, probably to come no surprise to anyone. There, I think, were
14, 15, but maybe I'm not exactly spot on that number, but eight were in the technology sector,
foreign communications to an industrial one and consumer. But I really think those numbers are
going to start to change where it's not going to matter. It's not only going to be technology.
A really interesting data point from that same analysis, though, was they looked at
kind of the motion to dismiss trends from the 20 to 23 period for AI-related cases.
And they found that it was less, 30 to 50 percent less likely that the AI-related cases from that
time period will be granted, will be resolved in a motion to dismiss. So what does that really mean?
That means that you're probably looking at longer litigation, potentially much more expensive
litigation. And cases that get past a motion to dismiss, once again, unfortunately,
are more likely to hit settlement. So what's driving that unknown? It's maybe AI is still
new technology, relatively new cases out there. But I think a really interesting point when you're
talking about AI is kind of what we're seeing our clients ask about. And my number one question that
I get from clients about AI is, is there an AI exclusion in my DNO policy? Insert any policy
there. And as of right now, and I can tell you at Marsh, we look at this very closely. We have
committees that meet on a very regular basis across the world about this. We are not aware
of AI exclusions in the management liability space. We are aware of carrier draft of one,
but they have not used it anywhere at this point in time. But I do think that's something that
we're going to have to continue to keep a close eye on as these AI cases continue.
And one thing that I'm always kind of concerned about, though, is when you're talking about AI,
what do you mean by AI, right? AI has been around a very long time. So if you're dealing with kind
of insurance, you know, kind of the insurance world and what we have to deal with, what do
you mean if you're going to exclude AI? How are you defining it? Right? And to me, that's a really
important and really critical issue that I think the insurance world is going to have a hard time
getting their hands around, but not to say that they're not going to try.
Yeah, an interesting point that you raised there about the AI exclusions. I'll just put that to
Dwight and to Larry as well. Dwight, have you seen any AI exclusions?
No, I haven't. But to Ruth's point, right, we saw this happen as it relates to cyber, right? We saw
cyber clarification endorsements come out a handful of years ago, which sort of migrated
to the almost exclusion of the cover. And so we've got to be careful and mindful as these
exclusions go from draft potentially to on paper and onto policy that they are not expanding
exclusionary language more than we would expect. And to the earlier point, hope that the policies
respond in a way that we would expect them to in this scenario.
What about you, Larry? Any AI exclusions that you've come across?
No, but this is another classic example of where brokers and insurers need to be
alert and nimble because obviously this is potentially a fast moving area. But so I think
it's interesting that there are some AI specific policies available now that just cover AI risks,
which I think assume more exclusions than may be out there. And they're all different,
standalone policies, DIC policies being offered. I think the main benefit they offer right now
is that some of them affirmatively cover things like penalties in the EU that might not otherwise
be covered. So it's worth looking at. But I think right now it's a solution to a problem
that doesn't really exist. Yeah. And I think, Larry, you raised a good point earlier about
making sure that our policies that we have operate in conjunction with one another, because
even though we don't see those exclusions yet from a DNO front, we have to make sure that those
exclusions don't find their way into some of the other policies that we have, whether it be
from a crime, EPL, and cyber perspective. So good point.
I would mention that at least one of these DIC policies for AI risks is kind of an umbrella,
which does, again, that does make it a little more attractive.
Well, let's move from two dreaded letters in AI to three in ESG, because even without the new SEC
climate rules, boards are facing investor pressure and involving disclosure standards around ESG. So
Larry, how should brokers structure their management liability placements to ensure
that directors and officers have adequate protection and support when ESG or climate
related disclosures are challenged? Right. So I think this is kind of similar to the
last question in that first, of course, we have to prepare clients for questions that could come up.
And of course, ESG is a big topic. So it could be climate questions. It could be DEI type questions.
So, and not every carrier asks every question, but we do want to be prepared. Again, like AI,
we're not seeing ESG exclusions. But then, so now, as you mentioned, the SEC pulled back on the
climate disclosure rules. They're not going to make them official. The EU has pulled back somewhat
on climate disclosure rules as well. So that leaves California as the main
entity seeking to heavily regulate climate disclosures, which may lead to a showdown
between California and the federal government. But all of this leaves companies sort of
uncertain, you know, between, you know, what regulations apply to them, which stakeholders
to try to please, you know, that you have to please the government regulators, but then
there's shareholders, customers, et cetera. And then when you look at DEI, that's a whole
separate category, which is particularly controversial in the US. So with the federal
government mostly being, you know, opposed to DEI initiatives, many states still encouraging them.
And then, you know, some shareholders being for or against, and many customers having strong
opinions for or against. So all of that is difficult for companies and boards to navigate.
And so then by extension, difficult to discuss with insurers. And so that's why,
but I think when insurers now ask questions about ESG, they may not even be sure what
answer they want to hear. I think in general, disclosing no more than you have to seems to be
a pretty good policy that we take advantage of in pitching the risk.
That's a great point that Larry's made, isn't it, Dwight? I mean,
what happens when administrations change?
It's a good question. And I think Larry's right in that, you know, we are seeing our underwriters
continue to ask the questions about ESG. What they do with that information from an underwriter
perspective is still yet to be seen. We haven't seen that exclusionary language exist just yet.
But, you know, to the question about the change of administration, you know, think about it,
that our policies, particularly on the DNO side and the other executive liability policies,
these are claims made on reported policy. So there's a tail element to this coverage that
we have to think about. So even if the ESG policies, whether it be related to climate
change, DEI or otherwise, when those philosophies change by administration or when the laws change
by administration, there's still going to be this ability of underwriters to look back and say,
well, what did you do as a client back in 2025? You know, did you do the right thing?
Were you in compliance? And that might not come, those questions may not come until 2030. But that
look back is going to still force the client to think about, you know, today, what do I do to
make sure that I'm in compliance, to make sure that I'm following the rules of disclosure and
the like. And so it's really important in general for our policies to maintain continuity of
coverage. And so this topic makes it critically important that we continue to have that
continuity so that when those questions arise five years later about something that you did
five years ago, that coverage is still intact and at a minimum, you can defend yourself via the
policy against those allocations. Is it fair to say then, Ruth, that global clients have different
priorities? Well, I think they have similar priorities, but they have more challenges,
right? Because they have to address the laws, policies, procedures of multiple countries,
right? Just because the U.S. is doing one thing, and we can even say the U.S., right? The states
in the U.S. could be doing something different than the federal government in the U.S., and
our company has to comply with that. But you add extra level of complexity when you're dealing with
global clients who have to do that in an environment where they're dealing with the
various laws in different countries. One way clients address that in the D&O world in particular
is in some, you know, in certain areas, you actually buy a local D&O policy. It's just a
policy that covers the D's and O's in that country for those exposures in those countries.
And once again, it's really interesting kind of how client inquiries are changing around these
local D&O policies because we're seeing many more of them really inquire about, well, what's the
coverage under that local D&O policy? Does it cover this new climate-related disclosure rule
or this new, you know, civil rights-related law for the ESG, for the, you know, the
social part of the ESG component? So we're really seeing some, you know, more interest and really
more knowledge from our clients and understanding the risk and how their regimes are actually,
how their insurance programs are responding to it.
Any thoughts on global clients as well, Ari?
Yes, well, so it is, there's only a small number of insurers that really have a global presence
to, you know, seamlessly offer the local policies and to also have claims people on the ground
to coordinate claims handling if it comes in, and probably maybe even fewer brokers with
the international capabilities for claims. So that's something to keep in mind if you're a
multinational, especially, well, to certain countries where you need to have local policies
by law, and then others where just logistically it will make your life a lot easier.
All right, well, let's talk about something completely different because, of course,
there is heightened regulatory scrutiny now on governance practices from
cyber oversight to financial reporting. So how should D&O programs evolve to address those
increasing expectations of board accountability? And indeed,
what role can brokers play in aligning coverage with these emerging governance risks?
Ruth, any thoughts on this?
Absolutely. And this is what we've been talking about, right? Because AI,
ESG, all of those are the emerging risks from the last few years. And there's going to be new ones
that no one on this panel can think of that will be coming up in the next few years. So it's all
those best practices, right? And brokers have always been there doing, I think, about what we,
you know, Larry already talked about some of the enhancements that came along with cyber, but,
you know, and, you know, making sure their coverage is there. But one of the things I
know that we did on the management liabilities side with respect to D&O was making sure that
cyber and security professionals were named and insured under certain policies when perhaps they
weren't actually board-level directors or offices, right? So it's always making sure you're looking
at coverage and thinking about it. How is this going to respond to the new risks? And I know
one of the things that we're talking about at Marsh is creating new coverages because our
clients are asking about it. One of the things that we've been looking at is coverage for
shareholder activism, because we've seen that become a greater emerging risk and addressing on,
you know, on top of all these emerging risks, we have shareholders out there talking about them
and really pushing our companies with them. So I know one of the things that we created was
shareholder activism coverage, and we had clients really pushing us on that. And we have one that's
actually triggered by a proxy fight. So you're really getting kind of early into the fight of,
you know, kind of securities claim, you know, you don't even have to get there, right? You're really
earlier in the process of making sure your D&O policy is responding to that. But on the flip
side, if you broaden coverage, you always need to think about if I'm going to be spending even
more money earlier in the process, do I have enough total limits available to me in my D&O program
in case that later, that proxy fight leads to a securities claim? So you have to always be
thinking about how doing one thing impacts other things in your D&O program. And you have to always
be thinking, Dwight, and indeed, I guess you always have to be talking to your clients as well,
because nobody has more insight to their own exposures than they do. 100% agree. You know,
Ruth talked about, you know, trying to understand what the emerging risks are. And I think we
understand them as they emerge, and we want to be proactive in thinking about what next. But
she just said, we can't think of every emerging risk. But there is, you know, one sort of party
that thinks about risks differently than even we do maybe, and that's the client. The client
understands their industry, their space better than anyone. And so sometimes we need to take a,
you know, lesson from their book and really allow them to help us to understand what the emerging
risks are, and then see if we can come up with a solution to solve for it. So it's really about
the collaboration with the client that is critically important. You know, Larry mentioned
analytics. That's a big thing, right? We can show from a, you know, predictive perspective,
you know, where we think you will wind up based upon legacy claims and scenarios,
but it's the client who can help us to understand better what some of those emerging risks are and
how we solve for those. So to me, that's the most important piece is listening to the client.
Yeah. Collaboration is key, Larry. And Brooke has helped really as needed here, isn't it?
Well, just generally, right. We just, we're always have to be vigilant. As we mentioned a few times
before, we have to be on the lookout for new exclusions and mindful that sometimes they come
disguised. You know, some carriers might have like a, you know, some omnibus enhancing endorsement
that gives additional coverage in a few ways, and then slips in a little exclusion or a sublimit
that limits what might have otherwise been available for the full limits. So just really
have to be vigilant. As we mentioned lots of times, you know, use the good carriers with the
good, reliable claims handling and payments. And we keep track both on a periodic and, you know,
in a real time basis of our experiences with different carriers. And we can share that with
clients, which they really appreciate. Be sure to have enough, you know, side A, DIC type coverage,
possibly with a same type endorsement to expand the scope of the side A coverage on the primary
ABC and up the tower. And you have to coordinate as we've mentioned between that coverage and the
cyber and other products, just make sure there's no gaps. So there's a lot to do just to make sure
that you're keeping up with things. On the subject of who's insured, you know, it's gone, I think,
beyond the CISOs who got really nervous after the SolarWinds case to now, you know, other sort of
new and emerging positions that aren't historically thought of as, you know, C-suite officers and try
and make sure that they're all taken care of. And on the subject of shareholder activism,
I've seen that there are some endorsements out there that don't actually provide additional
coverage because they still require that the situation meet the definition of securities claim,
in which case it would have been covered. So yeah, I'm sure Marsh has a good endorsement,
but there are some out there that are deficient. So again, even when you think you've gotten what
you asked for, you have to make sure that it really is giving you what you asked for.
And I just want to throw one final question to each of you, if I may, because we're seeing
something of a contrast right now, aren't we? Demand for higher DNO and management liability
limits is contrasting with capacity growth, perhaps lagging. So what sustainable strategies
can brokers use to secure adequate excess placements right now, whether that's through
layering alternative markets, perhaps negotiating terms that address emerging governance and
operational risks? Dwight, any thoughts on this? Yeah, I think the response to this is really an
amalgamation of all the things that we talked about here today. Making sure that you present
the client in the most favorable light, having the client be honest about what the challenges are
and how they will address those challenges. Those are the things that lead to the availability of
more limits and more insurance markets interested in undertaking the risk. I think we're at a space
in the market where there is still significant capacity out there. You know, to Larry's point,
there are fewer and fewer that play at that primary level and that we've got those developed
relationships with and that we believe can handle claims in the right fashion or those who have
international experience with local placements. But there is a plethora of markets that can offer
coverage on an excess basis. And so we really have an opportunity if you want to increase those limits
at considerable amounts to the extent that you can create a story, a true story about what your
exposure is. I think there's significant excess capacity there, whether it be in traditional ABC
coverage, side A coverage. And Larry talked about some of the great nuances of same endorsements
that we've seen out there. There's a significant amount of capacity even on the UK side
that we can tap into, which is important. And I think it's really a good time also to,
where possible, grow and expand the existing coverage. There are sublimates that are
available. We talk about crisis management coverage. We talk about additional side A
coverage. There's also an important piece to this from a derivative standpoint to make sure that
those sublimits that we get are properly dropping down at every layer of coverage the way they
should be. And just to throw in social engineering, we see policies from a crime perspective that are
now increasing that limit even to full limits sometimes. And the sublimits are increasing and
are able to drop down respectively on later programs. So there are so many things that we can
do, but it all starts with the story you tell, and it starts with the partnership that you create
with those markets that can help us get there. Okay. So capacity is still level, perhaps not a
lot of new entrants right now, Larry? Right. So, I mean, it has slowed. Like they're not new carriers
coming in every day as they were for a while. As we discussed, some of that capacity is pretty untested.
We're pretty picky about markets we work with and certain newer markets that were not even really
approved to use. So, which, you know, I think is for the benefit of the clients. With the new
carriers, we try to make sure that they have, you know, good experience management coming from
carriers that also were good and that they have an actual claims department with actual
experienced claims people. Because many new carriers don't really have a claims department yet
and they're caught flat-footed if they get a claim. And as some settlement values may have
gone up overall, you have to be careful because the, you know, the most important layer in your
tower might be, you know, your eighth layer or something like that. And certainly you can bring
through the primary on defense. So, you need to make sure the second and third layers are pretty
experienced in handling big claims. But also, you know, we do work with clients who are interested
in captives. It's a good viable opportunity for some clients, especially if the client already
has a facility and it's well-funded, it can be very attractive to add other things to it. In the
our squeamish about putting side A risk into a captive, although it's become more theoretically
possible, but certainly for the BC risk, I think it's a good thing for some clients. So, we can
find limits where necessary for whatever people need. Have the gents left you with any room for
some final thoughts, Ruth? Dwight and Larry were spot on, you know, and I will go back to where we
started. For the most part, capacity is available, right? You can go out there and get your D&O
program built, but the price may not be optimal for everyone, right? So, and, you know, one piece of
advice I always give my clients when we're looking at building a D&O program, it's engineer the tower
and don't just stack it. What do I mean by that? It is all the points that Larry and Dwight and I
have been talking about today, right? It's picking the right carriers, right? That critical primary
carrier, right? The ones that sit above it, right? What we call our next best friend at that point,
you ever have to change that primary carrier. You want to have that carrier in the first or
second access that can become your primary. It's so critical, right? So, it's not just stopping that,
but how do you make those decisions? It's like what Larry is talking about. It's having analytics to
make sure you're buying the right amount, and it's having the experience to know which carriers
are the right carriers, right? Who have come through, who have paid the claims, who have not
taken those coverage positions that we as brokers become very frustrated with. And it's going to go,
I'm going to go back to where we started to end this, which is making sure you're prepared when
it comes to discussing your program and your client with the underwriters, right? I cannot
underscore that enough. I have had risks that look almost identical on paper. They get very
different results because of how, you know, the clients present themselves, how everything looks,
and it's just, you know, being untimely with submissions, right? So, it's making sure your
client understands the value of the process, preparing them for the process, right? And that
means they're going to get the best results. Great thoughts. Another terrific episode with
these fine folks. Remember, they will be back for our final edition of the year in Q4.
Until then, keep it right here on Insurance Business TV.
