The carnivore diet is one of the most debated approaches to diabetes—some see quick improvements in blood sugar, while others face dangerous cholesterol spikes and gut issues. In this video, I break down the science, real clinic case studies, and the short-term benefits versus long-term risks. You’ll learn why carnivore may reset blood sugar fast but isn’t the magic cure it’s hyped up to be. Watch before you try it, and discover safer, more sustainable options for blood sugar control.
🔔 Subscribe to the SugarMD newsletter and receive FREE access to ""The Ultimate Diabetes Book"" (eBook & audiobook) and ""Doctor’s Guide To Diabetic Diet"" (eBook).
For those looking to safeguard their health, Dr. Ergin also recommends high-quality B12 supplements available at SugarMDs.com. Stay informed and take control of your health with SugarMD! ____________
🩺 Who is Dr. Ergin? Dr. Ahmet Ergin is an endocrinologist with a particular interest and passion for diabetes care. Dr. Ergin earned his medical degree with honors at Marmara University School of Medicine in Istanbul, Turkey. Then, he completed his internal medicine residency and endocrinology fellowship at Cleveland Clinic in Cleveland, Ohio. He is a board-certified physician in Internal Medicine and Endocrinology, diabetes, and metabolism. He is also a certified diabetes education specialist.
⚠️︎ Disclaimer: Any information on diseases and treatments available at this channel is intended for general guidance only and must never be considered a substitute for the advice provided by your doctor or other qualified healthcare professionals. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified healthcare professionals with questions you may have regarding your medical condition.
All right, guys. This is Dr. Ahmed Eran,
your endocrinologist in person, Lucy,
Florida. Today, we are diving into one
of the most controversial diets out
there, the carnivore diet. Some people
swear, and they're right, and others say
it's a disaster waiting to happen. So,
what's the truth? Can eating only meat
reverse diabetes, or could it actually
set you up for more problems down the
road? So stick with me because I am
going to break this down with real
signs, not mumbo jumbo or not gut
talking, okay? Tell you about risks and
real examples from my own clinic. And
I'll even tackle some of the conspiracy
arguments that you see online like
pharma doesn't want you to know about
this carnivore diet as if it is top
secret stuff because it will kill the
diabetes drug market. So eat carnivore
only, right? And this is going to be an
eye openening for you. And obviously
we're not for pharma. We don't want
pharmacology, the pharmarmacology drugs.
But is carnivore the answer for all? And
will you get other problems if you stay
on carnivore? That's the bigger
question, right? So what exactly is
carnivore diet? Simple, right? All meat
all the time. No veggies, no fruits, no
grains, not even nuts. Just steak, fish,
eggs, and maybe some butter. And that's
it. That's all you can eat. It's
basically keto with the volume turned up
to 100. The idea is no carbs, no blood
sugar spikes. Sound logical, right?
Nutrition isn't that simple. And here's
where it gets interesting. First, let's
be fair. Carnivore diet can deliver
quick results, especially for people
with type 2 diabetes, right? So, when
you cut the carbs completely, your blood
sugar stabilizes. That's great. Studies
on ketogenic diets, which are similar,
showed improved A1C weight loss and
lower insulin. However, as you know,
ketogenic diet is a lot more fat than
just protein. And what I have seen in my
clinic is this. One patient dropped his
A1C from 9 to 6.8% in just 3 months of
going carnivore. And some of them drop
even more. Now, this patient also
reduced the insulin requirements by
half. Some of them actually stops the
insulin. That's pretty powerful stuff
for someone drowning in high blood
sugars. Carnivore can feel like hitting
a reset button. But here's where people
get misled. Just because your blood
sugar looks better does not mean your
overall health is better. You will
probably feel better in the beginning,
right? But here's the thing. Science
shows that the diets too high in
saturated fats and too low in fiber can
back they can worsen cholesterol, damage
your gut health and increase the
inflammation. I have had multiple
patients come back with their glucose
under control. Great. But their LDL
cholesterol skyrocketed to 70 to 100
points. Now, one man went from an LDL of
90, which is great for most, to over 180
in just 3 months on carnivore diet.
That's not a good tradeoff when diabetes
already puts you at risk heart disease.
Right? Now, here's where it gets
nuanced. People will say, "LD ain't bad.
Who said that?" Well, what about
particle size? What about HDL going up?
That's true. LDL is not just bad
cholesterol. What matters most is the
particle size which is you know small
dense LDL particles are dangerous large
fluffy ones are less harmful. Now
particle number Apo B even if they are
fluffy too many particles still increase
the risk that's the case. Now carnivore
often shifts LDL toward larger fluffier
particles which sounds good but the
total particle number usually goes up
too and more particles mean more chances
to clog the artery. Then there is HDL,
the so-called good cholesterol. Now, on
carnivore, HDL often rises a lot, which
is good. Patients love this. One told me
that, "Doc, my HDL is 80 now, and I'm
protected pretty much, right?" Well,
yes, higher LDL is generally protective,
but HDL is like a garbage truck cleaning
up the streets. But if you flood the
highway with double the LDL trucks just
dumping trash on the street, the garbage
trucks cannot keep up. So the benefit
gets pretty much diluted. That's why I
cannot just ignore a doubled LDL even if
the HDL looks better. And next is
inflammation and gut health and the
micronutrient which nobody cares about.
Another hidden issue is fiber and again
the micronutrients that goes with it.
Now fiber lowers LDL, improves insulin
sensitivity and feeds your gut bacteria.
On carnivore, fiber is pretty much zero.
The micronutrients like vitamin C,
magnesium, potassium and plant
phytonutrients are also missing. Now
these are crucial for insulin
sensitivity and your overall metabolic
health. I had one patient who was
thrilled that his A1C dropped but after
6 months his inflammation marker CRP
also has doubled. Now his gut health
symptoms worsened and his LDL spiked.
Well, that's a trade-off. You are fixing
one number while you are quietly
breaking the others. Now the next
problem is sustainability. Let's be
real, carnivore is brutal to maintain.
At first, patients love the simplicity,
right? Steak, eggs, repeat. But fast
forward 6 to 12 months. Most either will
quit because they're bored, right? I
want to eat some real food, man. All
right, where's the real food? No, give
me something fun. Now, sometimes they
cheat and then they suffer huge blood
sugar spikes because they lose that
metabolic memory. And some of them
develop food aversions. In my clinic,
only a tiny handful of people have
lasted more than a year on that strict
carnivore. It's just not radical as a
lifestyle for the majority of the
people. Now, you'll find some sticklers
who will say, "Oh, yo, you can do
carnivore. I've been doing this for 10
years, so good for you." Well, we'll see
if you're here for another 10 years.
Now, I know what diehard carnivore fans
are also going to say in addition to
that. They're going to say, "Oh, my is
down. My weight is down. I'm not on
medications anymore for diabetes." Well,
great. Short-term gain. Uh they'll say
LDL doesn't matter. You know, it is the
inflammation that goes to heart disease.
Well, I just told you inflammation goes
up on carnivore diet. Now, pharma
doesn't want you to know about carnivore
diet because it will kill diabetes drug
market. Look, I get it. Okay? Cutting
carbs works for blood sugar. And yes,
big pharma makes billions off of
diabetes meds. I'm not saying eat carbs.
I'm just saying eat your fiber. Eat a
sensible diet. There is definitely not a
financial incentive for pharmaceutical
companies to recommend you a diet that
will reduce your drug dependence like
Mediterranean diet. And here's the
problem. High LDL and APOB still matter.
Inflammation does matter and long-term
sustainability matters. The carnivore
diet might be a fantastic short-term
intervention, which is great for
motivation and all, but in the real
world, it's not a major cure. And trust
me, if carnivore was the permanent cure
for diabetes, I would be the first to
recommend to every single one of my
patient, if it was sustainable and if it
did not cause any other problem. And
here is what I have actually seen in my
practice. So, I had a patient type 2
diabetic lost 30 lbs on carnivore, cut
insulin by half, but his LDL more than
doubled. We had to pivot cuz he was
scared himself to see his cholesterol
numbers. And we had to reintroduce
vegetables, nuts, and omega-3s. Another
patient was a pre-diabetic, got scared.
A1C improved on carnivore, great. But
when she had one pasta cheat meal, her
blood sugar shot up to 250. She was
going to have a heart attack. Her
metabolism had lost the carb tolerance,
which is important. Another patient did
a balanced low carb diet with
vegetables, lean proteins, and omega-3s.
His A1C improved, LDL stayed stable, and
he could still enjoy occasional carbs.
you know, occasionally with certain days
and parties and whatnot. So, would I
recommend carnivore? Here's my bottom
line. In short term, yes, it can improve
blood sugar quickly, but in the long
term, there are too many risks.
Cholesterol problems, inflammation
problems, gut health problems, nutrient
deficiencies, and sustainability issues.
Now, what about HDL increase, which is
good, but it doesn't cancel out double
LDL. And I prefer you increase HDL by
increasing your egg size. Is pharma
suppressing the carnivore? Maybe they're
not interested in promoting it, but
bigger truth is carnivore, it's not the
perfect sustainable solution it is hyped
up to be. If you want better blood sugar
and long-term health, a balanced low
carb and Mediterranean diet style,
plenty of plants, healthy fats, lean
proteins is far safer and more
sustainable. So, here's the truth.
Carnivore can lower your blood sugar,
but it's not the magic cure that people
make it out to be. If you don't look at
the full health picture like
cholesterol, inflammation, gut health,
you might be fixing one problem while
creating another. Now, I want to hear
from you. Have you or someone you know
tried carnivore? Did it help your blood
sugar? How long have you been on it? Or
did you run into problems with
cholesterol or gut health or just
sticking with it? So, drop your stories
in the comments, please. Most of the
time, carnivore fanatics will write
comments, but don't be shy. So, if you
tried it and didn't work for you, put it
down if you find this helpful. By the
way, hit that subscribe button and share
this video with someone who is thinking
about trying carnivore.