iPhone 17/Air/Pro Unboxing - What Apple didn't tell you!

Tech for Change
4 followers
This is a very expensive package,
because inside is all the new iPhones,
the 17, the Air, the 17 Pro, and the 17 Pro Max,
and pretty much all the new accessories too.
And I've been using this stuff
for almost a week at this point.
So let's do the unboxings,
but then I want to show you the things you only realize
when you start to get up close and personal.
The things that are better than I expected,
but also the things that have made me feel pretty misled.
Starting with the 17, which I've got here in Sage.
This feels pretty identical
to the unboxing experience last year.
Same USB-C cable with the same SIM ejector.
You've got a bunch of papers,
which now include an energy score.
So thank you, EU, I guess.
And the phone.
So very first thing I did was connect up the iPhone 17
and the iPhone 16 to the same ultra fast charger.
They started with dead batteries,
but after 10 minutes, the 17 got to 26%
compared to the 16's 21.
So there's nothing crazy,
but the charging is faster enough
that you'll probably notice the difference versus before.
The second test I wanted to do
was on this new anti-reflective coating
that you get on the screen.
So here we've got the iPhone 16 next to the iPhone 17.
And if you look at this part of the screen,
you can see pretty clearly actually
that the 17 is cutting out
about a third of the incoming reflections.
You can still sort of see what's there,
even with the light shining on it.
But then I put it side by side with Samsung's Galaxy S25 Ultra
and well, let's just say that phone
has nothing to worry about.
Compared to the new iPhones,
Sammy is getting rid of, I would say,
an additional third of the reflections.
The new selfie camera on this phone
is so much more useful than I was expecting it to be.
The first thing you'll notice is the detail.
So this is the iPhone 17.
This is last year's iPhone 16.
And then this is the iPhone 14 from three years ago.
So let's take the same shot on all of them.
And there's two key things you'll notice.
Between the 14 and the 16,
the way that it processes my face makes me look better.
My skin is a little smoother
and my skin tone has a bit more of that natural warmth to it.
And in between the 16 and the 17,
the main change is actually just how wide the shot is.
And so when you zoom in up close,
I wouldn't actually say it looks more detailed,
but there is more detail overall
because it is shooting wider.
But yeah, I wouldn't really say
detail is the main improvement here.
So just so we're clear,
pretty much every single camera
on every single other phone
has a rectangular sensor like this,
designed to take rectangular photos
that use that whole sensor.
The iPhone 17's front camera though is a square.
This is the reason why you can take shots in portrait.
So that'll use this part of the sensor.
And then without rotating the phone,
also shots in landscape now,
just by instead using this part of the sensor.
So this also means you can always hold your phone
in the most comfortable position, which is upright.
And then when you use this orientation
to take landscape selfies,
they just look particularly good
because it gives you this really wide shot,
but also while cutting off your arm,
which makes these photos feel less like selfies.
With the extra bonus of keeping your eyes
looking close to where the camera is,
as opposed to now where I'm holding the phone in landscape
and you can kind of tell I'm looking off to the side.
This camera means that when you're on a video call now,
you get center stage.
So we're on a FaceTime right now.
And what you notice is that the camera
is now detailed enough so that
when it's just me on this call,
the viewpoint is actually closer in on my face
than it used to be on the old phones.
But then if a second person enters the chat,
it now goes to way wider than it was before.
But then some part of me was thinking,
isn't this new camera still just a bit wasteful?
Because you got this big old square,
but you're only ever either using this
to take portrait shots or this to take landscape.
But that's actually not true either.
In reality, the full sensor is almost always being used.
Because let's say you take a shot that uses this part,
then the rest of the sensor becomes overscan.
Or in other words, just think of it as extra information
that the camera can see beyond just the frame
that you can see so that it can better anticipate movements
and just leads to better stabilization.
And then the final test I've done on this thing
is to find out how much more powerful
it's A19 chip is compared to last year.
So this is me running the 3DMark Extreme Stress Test,
which is essentially 20 minutes
of simulating high intensity gaming for the phones.
And it's pretty good news
because the 17's peak performance was 4,869,
which is almost 30% higher than what the 16 got,
with also higher stability,
meaning it retained more of that performance
over the course of the test.
So we'll see how this stacks up
with the other iPhones as we go.
And then just before we unbox the Air,
there's also the Apple Silicon case.
Which is pretty comfy.
I'd give it a seven out of 10.
Probably the case I'd go for
if I was going to get an Apple branded one.
Okay, it's Air time.
And gotta say, I was expecting something
a little different with the packaging.
You know, just something to maybe emphasize
just how Air-like the thing is.
But what you actually get
is almost exactly the same unboxing as the 17,
just with no sim ejector tool
because every iPhone Air is e-sim only.
And this is the sky blue color.
Oh, I just realized what they did there.
So very first thing I did with this one
was the performance stress test.
I was just so curious to see
how this thing's technically superior A19 Pro chip
is going to fare,
given that a phone this thin,
made of the not so heat conductive titanium,
is not a good environment for high performance.
And well, it's a complete flop.
This thing's peak score was only 3,863,
meaning that the iPhone 17, the cheaper phone,
which has the non-Pro chip, was 26% faster than it.
I was actually so taken aback by this result
that I was sure I'd done something wrong.
So I put the iPhone Air into the refrigerator
to drastically cool it down,
tried the whole thing a second time,
and I did get a much higher peak score of 4,717.
But two things.
One, that's still a lower score than the 17,
but also two, that level of performance
only lasted for about a minute.
And as soon as the cooling from the refrigerator wore off,
it plummeted right back down
to where it was in the first test,
which is why the performance stability score
is so low this time.
So I am very curious to see if other people
have the same findings with their Airs,
but this is not good.
There is no world in which the A19 in this phone
should be outperforming a chip
that Apple is specifically labeling as the A19 Pro,
because the average user is going to see Pro
and just assume it is better.
And they're even going to base their buying decisions on it.
The speaker on this iPhone Air,
yes, I said speaker, it's single,
is a little bit different.
You remember when all phones
used to have a single speaker back in the day
and it was downward firing.
So you were kind of listening to music like this.
So thankfully, this is not that.
Like it is coming out of the front and it's not terrible.
It doesn't sound tinny or cheap,
but it's also a lot worse than the other dual speaker iPhones
and really any other normal flagship phone.
So this is the Air,
and you can kind of tell it really struggles
to hit the low notes.
Then this is iPhone 17.
So it's fuller, but it is also like 40% louder too.
Okay, historically portrait mode has benefited a lot
from your phone having a second camera,
because kind of like having two eyes,
having two cameras lets your phone better understand
the depth of objects.
Now Apple says that they've redesigned
how portrait mode works
so that it is just as good on this phone as the 17,
but in my testing it isn't.
It's often indistinguishable,
but in those challenging scenarios,
you can tell that this one camera
is preventing it from properly understanding depth.
And then finally, I thought it was kind of interesting
that the phone is so thin
that the normal USB-C port housing
that you see on the other phones
wouldn't actually fit in here.
So the one on the Air is custom 3D printed in titanium,
which is cool, but then you look really closely
and you also realize that this port
is not actually in the middle of the phone anymore.
Maybe I shouldn't have told you that.
You might never be able to unsee it again.
And then the accessories for this phone
are a bit of a mixed bag.
Like the standard iPhone Air case looks decent.
It's slightly frosted and it's not a hard shell.
It's actually a little bit squishy,
but the first time I tried to take the thing off,
I, without exerting a lot of force,
bent it out of shape permanently.
So the thinner materials on this
seem to make it pretty fragile.
So I can't really give this one more than a three.
The $40 bumper case though,
while I'm not sure I've ever tested something
with a higher dollar cost per ounce of material,
does feel a lot more premium
and it does a good job of giving enough protection,
but also while really genuinely preserving
the feel of the Air.
I'd give it a six.
There's also this new crossbody strap,
but I think this is one of those fashion things
that's pretty lost on me.
So every iPhone 17 case now has these holes
that you can wire it into.
It does work.
And you know, the adjustability is super smooth.
You just slide this up and down,
but it's just like the idea of wearing my phone
is so far off my priority list,
especially in a city like London.
Wait, what the hell?
Oh my God.
I don't think this is for me, to be honest.
Five out of 10.
The MagSafe battery though, I find quite strange.
It's a really nicely made accessory
and it's exactly the kind of thing I've been looking for
for one of my other phones,
but it's just buying this for the Air specifically
feels like a bit of a contradiction to me.
Because if you decided, do you know what?
I know I'm giving up tons of things
by choosing an iPhone Air,
but I just love it so much that I'm doing it anyway,
then fair play.
I actually understand it.
But if you then pay another $100 to buy this MagSafe battery
to then also keep around with you,
just to get yourself to the same battery life
that the iPhone 17 Pro Max has anyways,
but while now being about 1.5 times thicker than that phone
when you have the pack on,
it just feels like an extremely poor lifestyle decision
versus just buying the phone
that you'll never have to worry about the battery on.
Oh, and then finally, before the Pro phones themselves,
the AirPods Pro 3.
So these are the same $249 price as the Pro 2s,
just designed to replace them.
And okay, the listening experience
is actually way more of a step up than I expected.
The sound stage is phenomenal.
Like some sounds feel like they're coming
from way off into the distance
and others feel like they're being created
inside of your ears.
The bass is deeper than before,
but also the noise cancellation is super effective.
But just to give you an idea,
this is what me typing on my keyboard normally sounds like.
So now we're gonna put a pair of AirPods Pro 2 in.
It's cut around 50% of the noise.
Now we put the Pro 3s in.
You can barely hear it.
Like there's 20% left of that audio.
The problem is the primary way these things achieve
so much noise reduction seems to be
by just creating a tighter fit.
And that tighter fit does also mean
more of that feeling of pressure.
Plus these buds are also heavier.
So it's a more immersive experience,
but for long journeys,
I do think the AirPods Pro 2s are more comfortable.
Still though, impressive earphones.
I would give them a nine.
I did also have a play around
with the live voice translation these things can do.
And I think it's got all the foundations
of something that could be amazing.
But right now Apple has got to work on their speech engine.
Yo quiero una manzana.
I want an apple.
I don't have an apple.
What you're hearing is a very artificial sounding voice
compared to like the Google Pixel phones.
So all of the tone
of what the other person is saying is lost.
And that leaves us with the iPhone 17 Pro,
which we've got in cosmic orange
and then the 17 Pro Max in deep blue.
It is unusual that there's no black option this time around,
but I mean, let's be honest.
I probably wouldn't pick it anyway.
I actually love the orange.
And then this Pro Max color is pretty toned down.
The safer, more sophisticated option
that I would completely ignore.
I wasn't super impressed by the accessories here.
Like this is the new tech woven case.
So I guess this is Apple's replacement for fine woven,
which was super comfy,
but a bit of a durability disaster.
I like the coloring in the sense
that when you look from close up,
what seems like one color
is actually tons of colors threaded together.
And when we durability tested this one,
it is basically the toughest case Apple has ever made,
but it kind of feels like they over-corrected a little bit
from fine woven.
It just doesn't feel nice.
It's giving me grandma's itchy sweater vibes.
And then there's the clear case,
which I actually don't understand
why they've made this whole back section white.
It doesn't fit the phone's colors.
And it's also not clear.
4 out of 10.
So first thing that surprised me
about the phones themselves is
how much more comfy they are to hold
compared to the 16 Pros.
I guess because the metal bends around the sides,
as opposed to there being a sharp divide
between metal and glass.
Then I tested signal strength
and it seems a lot better than previous phones.
Even though there's tons of metal now,
which can block signal,
I guess this extra antenna band that you now have
going all the way around the camera island
and better networking hardware on the inside
is more than countering that.
Like first location I tested this,
I managed to get 5G on my 17 Pro Max
while my 16 Pro Max was only getting 4G.
So my speeds were over 10X.
Second location, both phones got 5G,
but the 17 Pro Max was still faster 5G
by more than enough to notice.
And then we went remote where I was still managing
to get some signal on the new phone,
but zero on the old one.
So signal is naturally very case-by-case,
but it's looking good.
My third finding though, wasn't as enjoyable.
So Apple was pretty loud and clear
about how the iPhone Air is eSIM only.
But what was not made as clear is that for the Pros,
there are actually two versions.
Ones with eSIM, which will be in the US
and a few other countries,
and then the ones with physical SIM.
And that the physical SIM version has,
according to Apple, two hours less battery life
than what they referenced in their event.
The only upside is these regional phones
have a clean design all the way around,
whereas the US ones have to have this weird forehead thing
to support millimeter wave 5G.
The amount of thought that has gone into
keeping these phones cool is kind of insane.
Like as well as the big things,
like a design that has as much heat conductive
aluminium as possible all around,
just lots of tiny things.
Like instead of the chip being here on the last phone,
it's now in the middle,
which lets heat spread in all four directions better.
Or like how this new vapour chamber is laser welded
instead of glued to the phone's chassis.
But all this stuff only matters if it actually delivers.
So let's run the performance test
and we can also stick in the 16 Pro Max
to see the generation on generation improvement.
And solid result.
The 17 Pro Max does have the highest peak score
and stability, no surprises there.
It's good to see the smaller 17 Pro
isn't far off that either.
And compared to last generation,
we're about where we expected.
We're looking at around 22% overall increased performance.
Got to say, I was kind of expecting this stability number
to be much higher on the 17s versus the 16s,
considering just how much Apple talked about
the thermals and sustained performance.
But in reality,
the difference doesn't appear to be paradigm shifting.
What is kind of cool though,
is if you look at how the 16 Pro Max did,
that's actually lower than the base iPhone 17.
So in one generation,
the $799 phone now actually outperforms the $1,199 phone.
And then the key new camera upgrade
is meant to be this 48 megapixel telephoto lens.
And it's a little bit underwhelming.
Like in this example,
compared to last year's 16 Pro Max,
this is the one time shot,
then we get to four times.
So this will activate this new phone's telephoto camera,
but even then there really isn't that much in it.
And then by the time we get all the way up until max zoom,
I actually think the older phone's shot
looks just as good, if not better.
Now don't get me wrong,
I do think on balance,
the 17 Pro Max telephoto is an improvement.
More often than not,
you will get better shots when you're very zoomed in,
but this is just a PSA that you shouldn't be expecting
any kind of transformational change.
Funnily enough, the bigger change I noticed
is actually with portrait mode photos.
With no change to the hardware,
this is just software.
It looks like the image processing
is now quite a bit better at getting detail
out of the shots.
And skin tones look spot on.
It's only when you see the new phone's results
that you actually realize the previous one
wasn't quite there.
For an actually generational leap in camera performance
the Insta360 Flow 2 Pro, our sponsor, is insane.
Partly because all you have to do to start the thing
is unfold it and it takes the already very stable footage
to, well, new heights.
But mostly because this gimbal does everything.
It's also an extendable selfie stick,
it's your tripod, it's your selfie mirror,
it's your teleprompter, it's your power bank
that you can use to top your phone up.
The craziest bit is it can track you, right?
You tap on a subject and the gimbal automatically moves
so you're getting ultra smooth footage
that's trained on that subject.
But because this is the only gimbal
to natively support Apple Dock Kit,
you can use this tracking in any camera app,
including the default iPhone camera and Instagram.
Link below to get a Flow 2 Pro with the first 30 orders
also getting an exclusive 15% discount
and a free MagSafe phone mount.
