2023 Honda Pilot | How To Fix Forgettable SUVs

SUV review
33 followers
2 Video Views·Sep 17, 2025
The all-new Honda Pilot. This is a ground-up new three-row SUV from Honda, replacing the aging
prior generation Pilot. This video is going to be combining some footage we shot here in Illinois
with my original launch footage shot in Sedona, Arizona. You're going to see footage of me driving
this thing off-road, on-road with Mark, and you'll be hearing from all the senior engineers who
worked on this product, as well as us putting this thing up in the air. Let's talk about the
interior and exterior. This is replacing an aging variant of the Pilot. It was fairly egg-shaped
and basically a minivan with all-wheel drive on stilts. This is now focusing on more truck-like
capabilities with a more butch or squared-off visual look of the vehicle. It is supposed to
be able to take moderate and somewhat more aggressive trails. So if you want to go camping,
you want to see the great outdoors, this Pilot is now capable of doing that. However, the interior
side of the Pilot still maintains minivan-esque levels of usability. The Pilot was always designed
for someone minivan-phobic. They wanted the flexibility of seating and cargo capacity of
the minivan with the higher ride height and truck looks of a SUV, while also still maintaining all
the visibility of the minivan. That's what the new Pilot is all about, from the seating
configurations. This can either be had as a captain's chair second row or a full bench. It
also has a configurability in the higher trim levels, not this trail sport, but the top trim
levels of having the second row middle seat be removed and stored behind the third row. So you
can take it with you, further giving you that flexibility of seating. The third row is large
enough for full-size adults. The second row, regardless of seating configuration, is fairly
comfortable. It is a very, very big SUV. This being on the latest version of the Honda or Acura light
truck platform, it also is quite quiet. It is much quieter than the prior generation Pilot. A lot of
that NVH material has made its way into this vehicle and it's stopping that unwanted frequency
and all that road noise from making its way into the cabin. We're in the loudest or noisiest
configuration of the Pilot and that's due to the trail sports all-terrain tires and still much
quieter than last Pilot I was in. When it comes to the front rows, this has the latest version of
Honda's seat technology, which means it's far more comfortable than it used to be and it still has
all of the storage you know and love in your minivan or Pilot products. So the door cards have
this tiered setup so you can store all your crap in it. There's good flexibility in that regards.
You sit up nice and high as well and have good visibility. The interior technology is ripped out
of all the latest Honda products. So the top trim levels, you get the Bose audio system, but basically
in all the other trim levels, you get the standard infotainment you've seen in all the Honda products.
You get a digital gauge cluster. You get the same infotainment screen, which has wireless Apple
CarPlay and Android Auto at the higher trim levels and it's a good use of physical controls. I will
say this is a huge step up from the prior generation Pilot infotainment, but it is not the
most stable. It works about 98% of the time, but the 2% of the time it doesn't. It is rather
frustrating. Thankfully though, the rest of all the other controls in the Pilot are physical and easy
to use. Whether it be the HVAC controls, which still maintain a good level of tactile feedback,
the drive mode controls, the backup camera, which is on the stock, everything is essentially
idiot-proof. And that's what you want in a giant three-row SUV when you have to haul around all of
your little bastards in the back. But with that out of the way, let's head into the shop and put
this thing up on the lift. Mark, you and I are underneath the all-new Honda Pilot. I went to the
launch event in Sedona for this, where I spoke to all of the senior engineers, including the chief
engineer. So you're going to be hearing from them in this video. Oh, I'm sorry. We have our new AI
girl who's going to be doing most of these videos. I'm going to be firing Jack with all the layoffs
that are going on. Hey, what do you think of the Honda Pilot? I love it. That's all we need to know,
Jack. You're completely replaceable now. Thank God I have a woman who understands me as well. We're
going to start dating, just so you know. Oh, perfect. I might invite you to the wedding. It just depends.
I've learned something about you. That you're very intelligent and also very kind.
Hi, I'm Stephen Fry, and I'm a chief engineer and the development leader for the 2023 Honda Pilot
and Pilot Trailsport. I've been at Honda for 25 years. I started out in fuel design. I was in
project leadership, management in the chassis division, and now I'm in charge of the Honda Pilot.
Our primary benchmark was the previous generation Pilot. When that was launched in
2016, it was so popular. However, the market has shifted towards a more rugged
preference for our customers, so we wanted to move not only the styling of the car to become more
rugged, to better match the performance that we had already designed into it, but take that
performance to another level with this new Pilot. This is a three-row family SUV. I think the win
for this is they're going to feel like they're driving a much smaller car than it is. The car
drives small, and that was one of the taglines that we were discussing during the development.
How do we make this big vehicle drive like a smaller vehicle and give the driver that
confidence when they're driving? And I think that's the big success. So this is on the light
truck platform that is the same platform but heavily modified that the MDX is on. Obviously,
the front and rear suspension geometry are vastly different. This is strut front where the MDX is
double wishbone, and the rear suspension is different due to packaging, and this is just
an enormous vehicle. The benefits of being on this new platform compared to the last generation Pilot
is the same thing you hear in all these videos. It's more rigid, has more sound denting material,
it's a quieter cabin, and this has two different suspension layouts. So obviously, you have the
front-wheel drive and all-wheel drive versions. All of the all-wheel drive versions get the torque
vectoring rear diff. It's the second generation of that, but you can get this as a trail sport as
well. That is what we are under. The trail sport is the off-road version, which means it gets an inch
lift kit, it gets honest-to-god real skid plates front and rear, it gets real recovery points or
tow hooks essentially front and rear that will take twice the gross vehicle weight of this vehicle,
and the biggest thing is it gets all-terrain tires and a reprogrammed but physically identical rear
differential. So in the base all-wheel drive version, it will send up to 70% of the available
torque to the rear. It will torque vector that 70% of the available torque to either left or right,
the trail sport will send up to 75% of the available torque to the rear, and it's also
recalibrated with all the different drive modes to accept picking up a wheel when you're going
off-road. I did off-road this thing and it is surprisingly capable. It's not a Rubicon, it's
not a Bronco, but compared to a Trailhawk or whatever the Subaru variants, the wilderness
editions, it should compete with those in a decent way. It's also an inch higher too. Yes. That's
what really netted you that extra excitement. I also see that you laser etched your name here.
Why does it say Jack right there? It's the Jack point, Mark. That's what it is. Oh, sorry. See,
there you go. Okay. So the other thing to talk about, Mark, is the dynamic priorities. Let's
hear from the engineer first. Hi, I'm Jed Aston. I'm a chassis dynamics engineer at Honda. I think
what the customers really can understand when they drive this car, again, is the lateral rigidity
that's coming from the core, from the body. We have a solid mounted front subframe, which is new,
again, to add in that lateral rigidity so that we could have that great response, fun to drive,
and yet still have better vertical compliance for the ride comfort. Again, it's that balance of
ride and handling and how much more improved it is over what we were doing in the previous
generation. We're very proud of this product. Then for this platform, we also have the benefit of
having our IVTM4 system, which has been around now. This is now our second generation in the
pilot. We're calling it our sec gen two differential. It has a much higher torque capacity than the
previous generation. Then what that differential is doing over the previous is we've gone 40% up
in power capacity at the rear axle. So again, it further can dismiss that disturbance of the power
train that some vehicles might have through the steering wheel and keep the main important power
going to the rear axle so that we have that wonderfully balanced car. The torque vectoring
differential, which you're going to hear more and more about this, is how you transform a front wheel
drive platform to make it feel more rear wheel drive without the complication of developing a
platform just for that. So traditional on-demand systems, your front wheel drive, if the system
detects wheel slip in the front, it just is like an on and off switch. It'll slip a clutch in the
back and send power. But what it's not smart enough to do is send power to each wheel, which seems kind
of strange, but that's the way it works. If one wheel is slipping, it'll just continue to slip.
It's not smart enough to send power to the other side. The torque vectoring unit allows power to go
100% to either side. So if you've got one wheel stuck in the snow, it's like, okay, I'm slipping.
Let's move power to the other side. The benefit of that is more capability, a safer feeling
driving vehicle, and the dynamic part of being able to power the outer wheel in a corner or the
inner wheel in a corner to get you through. So it feels more engaging to drive. It's more capable on
and off road, and it's great in terms of traction. So it's the best of all worlds, of course, without
going to a rear wheel drive platform. So the negative parts is, yes, that differential is more
expensive in the back. If you blow one up out of warranty, it's going to cost two or three
times more than a traditional electromechanical or electromagnetic unit or hydraulic unit that's
in a CRV or some of the more commodity-based products. But it really does make a huge
difference, and we'll talk about that during the drive. As a counterpoint, though, at least in Honda
and Acura's applications, their TBD rear diffs have been extremely reliable. Vehicles are getting
heavier than they used to be, and sooner or later, through sheer unluckiness, you might get into an
accident. And they built the body structure and the crash structure of this vehicle to accept
heavier and heavier vehicles, particularly EVs, that are going to be hitting it in the future.
So they want to basically keep you safe and potentially future-proof this vehicle for, you
know, larger vehicles that are definitely coming, unfortunately, for our roads and for everybody
else associated. And a lot of that, you know, in terms of safety, it is a sad state where, you know,
you're designing your cars around getting hit by like a six-, seven-, eight-thousand-pound vehicle
now. It's like completely reversed. So as everything gets bigger, these are having to be
more complicated in terms of electromechanical systems. All the safety systems have to accommodate
that in terms of how you design the car to handle. They've had to make revisions to the front subframe,
the front steering rack. The steering rack has to be altered to accommodate this extra weight and
load, its off-road capability. So all these finer points of engineering, not just like damper and
spring tuning that you typically see, it's like every point of this has been touched.
This is an entirely different vehicle than the Pilot that it replaces. The last story,
really the big story if you're a Honda enthusiast, is the new V6. It's still a J-Series and it is
going to be the V6 that powers Honda products for the next 10 years. And I can guarantee
that this is also going to make its way into things like the base Acura MDX. When that car
gets refreshed, this V6 will replace that. I'm almost positive. The big thing compared to the
prior generation J-Series is it no longer has VTEC and it is dual overhead cam. And it uses cam
phasers and that's how they're able to vary the performance of it. It's really a compliance
engine, honestly. They've done all the typical things. So the cam phasers are one of them. It
has a new direct injection system, which you're seeing in a lot of new cars. This next generation,
the injectors are smaller, the pressures are higher, the fuel rails are more robust,
the high pressure fuel pumps are different. It still uses cylinder deactivation, it has a
strengthened block, it has forged crankshaft, connecting rods, but it still uses a timing bolt.
So this entire design, the reason they got rid of VTEC and went to cam phasers is it couldn't
meet emissions, the older engine. So you have dual overhead cam, all the modern stuff, but it's not
about power. It's about or trying to be about efficiency, but that's not necessarily true,
at least in the case of the Pilot. And why is that? So fuel economy takes a hit from the prior
generation VTEC engine, but that's not primarily due to the engine, it's due to the design of the
vehicle. People didn't like the egg-shaped design in the last Pilot, since then people have moved
to more truck-looking SUVs. So it takes an aerodynamic hit, and obviously it's a larger
vehicle than it used to be. The engine character as well is vastly different. The last engine,
which you and I enjoyed, we enjoyed for an enthusiast reason. It was Peaky, this crazy
VTEC changeover. That isn't here anymore. Between the 10-speed automatic, it no longer has a ZF,
this is Honda Acura's own gearbox. It puts us in the powerband earlier, and it no longer has to
be winded all the way out. Torque comes in earlier, and it's a smoother-feeling engine.
All you have to do is look at the slide of the old Pilot versus the new Pilot to see what the
mentality was of trying to give you the truck, and then work on the underneath for once, like
actually work on the engineering to make this not feel like just a giant box on wheels.
But Mark, I think now it's time for us to take this for a quick drive on our Illinois roads.
Sounds good. Mark, I finally have a non-premium three-row for you. You, like Nick Cannon,
have gone to the same fertility school. You've had too many kids, but you still want an SUV
that's fun to drive with a V6 and no CVT. This is Nick Cannon. You're idle, like you. You both
have the Child Diversity Program. Forty kids with different women across the entire country.
Is he into compliance V6s? He might be, and that's really the only con of this car,
is the new V6. This is a con? Maybe. No, it's not. Compared to the last V6,
you wanted VTEC changeover. But it's got cam phasers now. You don't need VTEC. You don't,
and the power is smoother and comes in earlier than it used to. And it's naturally aspirated.
There's no turbos. Honestly, man, I went to the launch program a couple weeks ago in Sedona,
and I drove this off-road with Honda Pro Jason in the trail sport that we're in. I drove the
regular Elite variant on the regular roads with snow and salt and everything. I went in with
minimal expectations, and I was blown away by how good this thing is. It rides well. It handles well.
It has a V6. It has a real gearbox. What's there not to love? When you called me, I was like,
I ain't going to this event. And Jack's like, oh, man, I'll go. And I'm like, there's no way
this thing's going to be good. It's going to be a total snoozer. Jack calls me. He's like,
oh my God, bro. This is the pinnacle. I'm like, what food did they give you? What kind of room
did they put you up? Did they fly you first class? It's all the swordfish they gave me.
No. And the first time I drove it, the first time I drove this after it got dropped off,
this is really good for what it is. And I think the big reason it's really good, Jack,
is you're going to go through the one corner that we have to go through here.
Yeah. It's the TBD rear diff. I wouldn't get this thing as a front-wheel drive vehicle, right? You
know, the argument for front-wheel drives is more efficient and it costs less. And traditionally in
the past with on-demand all-wheel drive systems, the only thing the all-wheel drive system was
doing was getting you out of slippery conditions and launch conditions that like get you off the
line. With the TBD rear diff, which is available on every all-wheel drive variant of the MDX and
comes as standard, it's the only way you get this. Sorry, Pilot. It's the TBD out of the MDX. It's
available in every Pilot, like every all-wheel drive Pilot variant. It helps you rotate the rear.
You can drive this thing like a maniac. It's actually so much better than the old one. I mean,
so I think the main one that I'm going to look at is when you talk about the Palisade and Italia
Rider, like the de facto three rows, this car has all of the refinement, it has the quietness,
and now it has the handling without being stupid. Like they haven't made the handling good by
stiffening it up or making it so annoying and obnoxiously stiff to drive. It just is super,
super natural, and this is a perfect example of how you take a big boat and you make it feel
really, really nimble to drive, where you don't have the penalties of driving around a couch.
That's what makes this so special. So what they've managed to do is combine soft ride, the up and down
like compliance is excellent, but it still maintains some level of body control, which is
not what the Telluride does. The Telluride is pure couch, no body control, doesn't deal with
secondary motions at all. It doesn't turn, it doesn't stop. This at least has that going for it.
You can do it. This is quick in a straight line. You can turn the steering wheel and turn the car.
You can have the confidence to even do stupid stuff in fast, going fast, and it has amazing
all-weather performance. The problem with the front wheel drive based SUVs is like the Hyundai
Kia factor. You turn the wheel in wet or any bad condition, all you feel like the car is doing is
getting turned off with stability control. It doesn't go or it feels like it's going off the
road. This feels almost rear wheel drive without feeling unstable rear wheel drive. It just gets
you through all the corners. It almost feels like it has rear wheel steering to that matter because
the TBD works so good in the back. Of course, we're talking a lot about driving character.
A lot of people aren't going to care about driving character. What does this do well from the real
family perspective? So talking about the interior space, this was designed for someone who's minivan
phobic, right? They don't want to be saddled with a minivan. They want the all-weather capability,
which to be fair, you don't have to get the Trailsport. No one is really going to off-road
one of these things. So the crazy skid plates and the recovery points and the lift kit and
the all-terrain tires, you don't really need them unless you are that one person. But it has the
capacity of a minivan, has the right height of an SUV, the usability of a minivan, has a real V6,
it's quiet and it's comfortable. This, to me, the only penalty it has is fuel economy.
What's that? It's high teens, low 20s, which is about the same as a Telluride,
but if you look at a Highlander, this is better to drive than a Highlander or Venza pretty much
every way I can think of other than the fuel economy. And that's the penalty of this thing.
Yeah, so to me, that's true. I think that's the only reason that would deter me from buying this,
and it's not even a deal breaker because having a naturally aspirated V6 that is a
basically a derivative of the J-Series engine that we talked about in the shop,
you know that mostly you have nothing to worry about it. The transmission is a traditional
torque-converted unit. You don't have the hybridization, that putting feeling. You feel
like you're driving kind of a truck. It does have a truck-like feel to it, but still has the great
handling of some of the modern SUVs. They did everything as good as you possibly could do here
for what the price target is and, you know, a three-row vehicle. I'm so impressed with this.
This is, to me, the de facto non-premium three-row. I take this up an Explorer,
a Highlander, a Telluride. I really am shocked that I like this thing. I had minimal expectations.
It doesn't have the flair of the Telluride and Palisade. It doesn't have the wow factor
on the interior. But it drives better. But it really is a better vehicle overall 100%.
All right, Mark. With that, let's head into the final thoughts.
Final thoughts on the Honda Pilot. I wanted to say this first. Huge thanks to all of the
engineers who spent a lot of time with me at the original launch event. Because of all that time,
I think we could give you a more comprehensive look at the Pilot. So what do I think about this
thing? Well, like everything, it becomes a matter of what you prioritize. The Highlander gets better
fuel economy. If you get a Highlander with a hybrid drivetrain setup, it will blow the fuel
economy away in the Pilot. The Telluride may be more big or minivan-esque like, which you may
appreciate. But what the Pilot does better than even the American rural drive Explorer is driving
dynamics. The Pilot is the best driving non-premium three-row SUV currently on sale. They have figured
out the perfect balance between ride quality, the ability to get this thing in and out of corners,
and have some life to it. While it is not the most exciting vehicle to drive in the world,
it does not feel like a penalty box. Yes, the interior space may be a little Honda Civic-y and
generic, particularly in dash layout. But there's good interior usability. It's got a lot of glass,
it's fairly quiet, and there's great storage. That's what I like about this thing so much.
Purely from an objective perspective, I think this is a much, much better product than the
Kia Telluride and the Hyundai Palisade. But again, I'll leave that up to you. Thanks for watching.
Hope to see you soon.
