This video explores the alarming economic decline of China’s major cities, Shanghai and Beijing, where retail sales growth lags far behind the national average. From January to July, Shanghai’s retail sales grew by only 2.5%, while Beijing plummeted by 42%. The service industry’s collapse, marked by a 21.7% office vacancy rate in Shanghai and even higher rates elsewhere, signals a broader economic downturn. Shanghai’s commercial-to-residential policy reflects a desperate attempt to address oversupply, yet it risks exacerbating residential market woes. Foreign investors, once dominant in office leasing, are fleeing, with firms like BlackRock defaulting on properties. This decline, driven by a stalled transition from manufacturing to services, threatens to trap China in a middle-income limbo, ending the era of reform and opening-up that once fueled its urban rise.
Help me grow the channel by donating any amount through the link below—your support makes a difference! https://paypal.me/DonXiang
0:00 Intro 0:57 The Fading Glory of China’s Urban Giants 1:50 The Service Industry’s Critical Role 3:04 Office Buildings as Economic Barometers 3:46 China’s Stunted Office Market 6:49 A Nationwide Real Estate Collapse 7:30 The Fall of Rents and Dreams 8:13 The Oversupply Crisis Unveiled 9:21 The Exodus of Foreign Capital 11:35 A Policy Doomed to Fail 12:21 The End of an Economic Era
Hi, I'm Dong Seong. Welcome to Digging
into China, where we explore China in
depth to review unique perspectives.
Since the latter half of last year, the
growth in retail sales of consumer goods
in major cities like Shanghai and
Beijing has significantly trailed the
national average in China. From January
to July, China's total retail sales of
consumer goods increased by 3 and a
half%. Whereas Shanghai saw a modest
rise of only two and a half%, Beijing
failed even worse, experiencing not
growth but a staggering 4.2%
decline. While we might question the
accuracy of the national 3 and a half%
growth figure, the disparity between the
data from Beijing and Shanghai and the
national figures clearly highlights the
decline of major urban centers like
Beijing, Shanghai, Guangjo and Shenzhen.
Why then are these economically robust
regions with the strongest consumer
spending power declining faster than the
relatively less developed the second and
the third tier cities? In August, the
Shanghai municipal government issued the
implementation opinions on promoting the
renewal and enhancement of commercial
buildings, permitting eligible
commercial buildings to be repurposed
for residential use. elderly care, child
care, or rental housing. This policy,
often referred to as the commercial to
residential reform, may seem unrelated
to Shanghai's steep decline in consumer
spending growth. However, the key to
understanding Shanghai's consumption
downturn lies within this policy. Today,
we will explore this topic in detail. It
is well understood that for a nation's
economy to advance particularly to
transition from a middle income stage to
that of a developed country it must
undergo a vital industrial
transformation. The service sector or
tertiary industry must surpass
manufacturing the secondary industry to
become the primary contributor to GDP.
Every developed nation globally has
experienced this shift from
manufacturing to services. Thus, whether
China's economy has the potential for
further growth and can progress from its
current middle income stage to join the
ranks of developed nations hinges on the
development of its service sector, not
on further expanding its already
oversaturated manufacturing industry.
Shanghai's commercial to residential
policy provides a fresh perspective in
the current economic climate to assess
the state and future trajectory of
China's service industry. This lens
allows us to evaluate whether China will
fall into the middle income trap or
successfully transition to a developed
economy.
Why does the office building market
serve as an indicator of the service
industry? Examining the global
distribution of office buildings reveals
that the vast majority of prime office
stock is concentrated in the core cities
of developed economies in Europe and
North America. New York, Paris, Chicago,
Dallas, Toronto, Munich and others. In
essence, only economically advanced
regions generate a substantial office
building markets. As the world's second
largest economy, China's largest office
markets are in its most developed
cities, Shanghai and Beijing.
Proportionately, China's GDP is nearly
equivalent to that of European Union.
So, one might expect its office building
market to be comparable in scale. Yet
despite China's immense GDP, the total
office building stock in Shanghai, its
largest office market is less than 30%
of Manhattans in New York and under 40%
of Paris. Beijing's market is even
smaller, less than 20% of Manhattan, 25%
of Paris, and under 40% of Berlin. This
discrepancy stems from China's per
capita uh GDP which remains at a middle
income level with its service industry
far smaller than that of developed
nations. The office building sector is a
core pillar of the service industry.
Regardless of a country's overall
economic size, if its per capita GDP
does not reach developed the nation
levels, its office building market will
remain limited. Only when a nation's
economy transitions from manufacturing
to service does significant demand for
office buildings emerge.
In other words, office buildings are
essential infrastructure for a
servicedriven economy.
The rise or fall of the office building
market thus reveals whether China's
economic structure is advancing or
regressing and whether its economy will
stagnate or achieve a breakthrough.
Shanghai's commercial to residential
policy is a reluctant response to the
severe overupp in its office building
market. According to Cordius
International, a prominent commercial
real estate consultancy.
As of the second quarter of 2025,
Shanghai's office building stock totaled
17.73
million square meters with a vacancy
rate of 21.7%.
To put this in context, consider global
comparison. Paris has a vacancy rate of
7.2%, Tokyo 6.2%, New York City average
12 and a half%, London 10.2% and Taipei
10 12%. Shanghai's vacancy rate far
exceeds that of other major global
cities. In 2007, Shanghai's office
vacancy rate was a mere 1.6%.
Today, 18 years later, over 1/if of its
office buildings remain unoccupied.
Yet, Shanghai's vacancy rate is not even
the highest in China. Shenzhen's
vacation rate stands at 31%, Chinga's
35%, Chong Sha at 33%, Wuhan 31% and
Tanjing's 29.3%.
These city's office vacancy rates
significantly surpass Shanghai's.
Nationwide, nearly onethird of China's
office building are vacant, marking the
sector as yet another industry plagued
by severe over supply.
In today's China, over supply is a
pervasive issue across industries. The
collapse of commercial real estate is
arguably more severe than that of
residential real estate. The closure of
shopping malls and retail stores has
become routine. In the first half of
2025, the restaurant industry, the
primary driver of demand for commercial
retail spaces, has been closing at a
rate of six establishments per minute,
equivalent to over 8,800 restaurants
shutting down daily. Consequently, more
malls and retail stores will fall will
fail alongside the restaurant industry.
Simultaneously, the office building
market is collapsing. Some may ask, if
office buildings are in over supply, why
not the lower rents to attract tenants?
Consider Shenzhen's office rental data.
The average rent is currently 156 per
square meter per month, or roughly 5 per
square meter per day, cheaper than a
decade ago. The last time Shenzhen's
office rents were at this level was in
2009. Meanwhile, China's residential
housing prices have only fallen back to
2017 levels, but office rents have
regressed to 2009 levels, indicating
that the residential property prices
still have considerable room to decline.
The severe collapse of the office
building market reflects a broader
decline in China's service industry.
This widespread downturn makes it
impossible for China to transition from
its current middle income stage to that
of a developed nation. Without the
industrial upgrading, there is no room
for future economic growth. Per capita
GDP cannot rise and the economy risks
becoming ins snared in the middle income
trap. The prospect of becoming a
developed nation becomes an unattainable
aspiration, a true Chinese dream.
Moreover, with the service industry
faltering, economic growth can only rely
on manufacturing. Yet, domestic demand
for manufactured goods has been
persistently weak and international
trade faces increasingly high tariff
barriers. Consequently, the
manufacturing sector will become ever
more oversaturated and intensely
competitive, leading to a wave of
industrywide closures. The collapse of
the office building market also signals
a significant trend. The large scale
withdrawal of foreign investment.
Foreign investment in Shan in China
comprises of two main components. The
first is foreign manufacturing
enterprises that combine foreign
technology with China's lowcost labor to
produce and sell products. The second
includes foreign companies in
international trade, professional
services, high techch research
institutions and financial firms
primarily located in office buildings of
Beijing, Shanghai, Guangjo and Shenzhen.
According to CBRE, in 2017, foreign
companies accounted for 66% of the least
space in Beijing's prime office
buildings. During the 2020 pandemic,
CBRE survey of over 6,000 companies in
153 prime office buildings in Shanghai
found that the foreign companies still
occupied 50% of the least office space.
However, following Shanghai's 2022
lockdown, the share of foreign companies
began to plummet in 2023, falling below
10% this year. Recall the news from
February 2025. Black Rock, the world's
largest asset management firm, defaulted
on two office buildings in Shanghai and
abruptly exited, dominating financial
news headlines. Black Rockck's hasty
departure was driven by the mass exodus
of foreign companies from Shanghai
starting in 2023, which triggered the
collapse of the city's office office
building market. Ironically, the
original owner of those two buildings
was AR Asset Management, a company under
Lee Kai, who sold them in 2016. At the
time, Black Rockck was highly optimistic
about China's economy. Yet in less than
8 years, China's economic decline forced
the Black Rockck to default and flee,
suggesting that Western investment firms
may not understand China as well as Lee
Kaiing does. As foreign capital
withdraws and the service industry
collapses, the Shanghai government
introduced the commercial to residential
policy to alleviate the over supply in
the office building market. However,
while reducing office supply, this
policy increases over supply in the
residential market. Is the Shanghai's
housing market currently under supplied
with prices still rising? No. Both
markets are struggling and in attempting
to preserve one, the government
inevitably sacrifices the other.
Ultimately, the office market that they
sought to protect remains unsafe and the
residential market they sacrificed faces
even steeper price declines.
The government now resembles a paper
hanger patching a house riddled with
leaks. No matter how much they patch,
they cannot prevent the structure from
collapsing.
From January to July, Shanghai's retail
sales grew by only 2 and a.5% while
Beijing fell by 4.2%.
These figures reveal the decline of
cities like a Beijing, Shanghai,
Guangjo, and Shenzhen. The root cause
lies in the fact that the service
industry constitutes a far larger share
of GDP in these first tier cities
compared to second and third tier cities
or less developed regions in central and
western China. Foreign companies also
contribute a significantly higher share
of GDP in these cities.
Data shows that Shanghai's approximately
60,000 foreign investor enterprises
account for over a quarter of the city's
GDP, more than a third of its tax
revenue and 1/5ifth of its jobs. Thus
with the service industry collapses and
foreign capital flees the economic
decline in developed regions like a
Beijing, Shanghai, Guangjo and Shenzhen
is far more rapid than in second and
third tier cities or less developed
areas. In essence, the economic collapse
of Beijing, Shanghai, and Shanzhan marks
the end of China's reform and opening up
era, just as their rise once symbolized
its beginning. Yet many in China remain
caught in the illusion of ongoing
economic growth, believing the nation's
economic trend is merely slowing down,
unaware that the era of development has
already concluded.
Thank you so much for watching. If you
find this video helpful, please like it,
drop a comment below, and hit the
subscri sub subscribe button right here.
It really helps YouTube suggest my video
to others. I'll be back with more
content soon.