Expandable vs. Fixed Blade Broadhead - How To Choose What To Shoot

The Precision of Crossbowry
1 follower
2 Video Views·Sep 7, 2025
Expandable vs. Fixed Blade Broadhead - How To Choose What To Shoot
Alright, what's up everyone?
Today, really quick, we're going to talk about the annual bowhunting hot topic.
That is broadheads.
Everybody loves talking about broadheads.
So, what I want to talk about today is how you should go about choosing whether you're
going to shoot a fixed blade or expandable, and the one question that you should ask yourself
in making that decision.
To start things off, in my opinion, every single broadhead on the market, fixed blade
or expandable, every single one of them has led to a deer being successfully harvested.
Every single broadhead, regardless of whether it's fixed blade or expandable, has also
led to a deer being wounded and not recovered.
And 999 times out of 1000, those deer that are not recovered are because the hunter made
a bad shot.
It wasn't the broadhead's fault, it was the hunter's fault.
So, with that said, the one question I always ask people when they ask me what broadhead
should I shoot?
I always ask in return, what are you most worried about?
And it really kind of comes down to two topics of you're either most worried about penetration
and going through a shoulder blade, or you're most worried about hitting a deer too far
back, like guts, liver, maybe even hindquarter, just a shot that you were not planning on,
too far back, not hitting bone.
So, to start with the shoulder blade one, if you are worried about going through a shoulder
blade, you should shoot the fixed blade.
So, a fixed blade is going to penetrate, in general, better than an expandable every single
time.
A fixed blade has no moving parts, so the arrow loses no energy to open blades.
The fixed blade has a smaller cutting diameter, so there is less resistance, less surface
area of that broadhead going through a deer than an expandable.
And typically, the blade angle of a fixed blade is more swept back, or it's less of
a blade angle.
The blades are more parallel to the arrow shaft than that of an expandable.
All of that is going to lead to more penetration.
All of that is going to give you a better chance going through a shoulder blade.
If you're worried about hitting a deer too far back, or just having an errant shot in
general, then you should consider shooting the expandable broadhead.
So, an expandable is going to have a much bigger cutting diameter than a fixed blade,
which results in a bigger wound channel, and you just simply punching a bigger hole through
the deer.
So, you obviously have more of a chance of hitting vitals, hitting arteries, or just
inflicting more damage on the deer with an expandable than you do a fixed blade.
So, that really is the question, is what are you most worried about?
Are you most worried about going through bone?
Are you most worried about hitting too far back?
Remember, every single broadhead has killed deer, and every single broadhead has resulted
in deer not being recovered.
It's all about you choosing what you are most confident in, and you mitigating risks, and
trying to eliminate what you are most worried about.
I shoot expandables.
I've been shooting expandables for probably, I don't know, five or six years now.
I think that there is not a broadhead on the market that is a 100% guarantee through a
shoulder blade.
Specifically, if you hit the ridge in the middle of the shoulder blade, I'm not talking
about the edges, I'm talking about if you center punch a shoulder blade, and you hit
that big, bony, one-inch ridge through the middle of it, man, there are not a whole lot
of broadheads that 100% of the time will make it through that.
So, I know that I need to avoid hitting a shoulder blade.
I know where I need to shoot, and I like to err on the side of I would rather have a bigger
wound channel potentially going a little farther back, even though that's not where I want
to hit.
I feel more confident in having a bigger wound channel creating more damage than trying to
penetrate through a shoulder blade.
So, that is my personal opinion.
I hope that helps you guys out.
Choose a broadhead this year.
If you haven't already, or if you've been tossing up whether or not you should shoot
expandables, shoot fixed blades, what the best one is, they all work.
All of them work, all of them have killed deer.
Shoot what you are most confident in, shoot what makes you feel like you have mitigated
the most risk, and you guys will all be successful this deer season.
Thank you for tuning in.
Remember, be a sportsman, make a sportsman.
