Chester A. Arthur was never expected to become president—least of all by himself. Known as a well-dressed New York political insider, Arthur rose through the Republican machine before unexpectedly stepping into the presidency after James Garfield’s assassination. Yet instead of continuing the spoils system that had elevated him, Arthur shocked the nation by embracing civil service reform. Quietly battling illness, he expanded the Navy, tempered immigration law, and signed the Pendleton Act, reshaping how government appointments were made. Arthur’s story proves that character can rise to meet the moment—and that change is possible, even in Washington.
Welcome to American Legends. My name is Tiffany Brannan.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories,
but here in America, our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right from our history
pages. Now, some of these heroes are very famous and some are obscure, but each person deserves to
be discovered because each man or woman stands as a great example of how we can be better Americans
Most presidents, before they enter the White House, spend months, if not years,
campaigning to let the people know what kind of leader they will be.
Occasionally, a man is thrust into this important position unexpectedly, having thought he would
only be the vice president. In that case, that individual did not have the chance to really show
the American people what he would do. Yet, of course, everyone who became the vice president
had some sort of political or at least military background. Once in a while, there will be an
individual who completely changes the course of his actions and turns out to be a very different
person than you might have thought. Today, we're going to talk about a president who turned out to
Chester A. Arthur. Chester A. Arthur is the 21st president of the United States.
He was the fourth president who was not elected to the office. He was elected as vice president
under the 20th president, James Garfield, in the year 1880. This was one of many cases,
which were quite common up to that point, where the president and the vice president
were not necessarily political allies. Sometimes, they barely even knew each other or hadn't even
met. They were part of the same party, and the party leaders would decide that this person would
balance the ticket well with that person. Now, that's not to say that such things don't still
happen today, but I think there's at least the illusion of the president and vice presidential
candidates being pals, chums, working together. They didn't even pretend at this point.
And it was an interesting place for the Republican Party in this election of 1880,
because there were two rival sections, the reformers, who were called the half breeds,
and the favoritism system leaders, those part of the spoils system, and they were called the
stalwart faction. When passionate reformer James Garfield gained the nomination, the party decided
the only way to balance the ticket was to appoint someone from the very opposite stalwart side,
and that was Chester A. Arthur. He is quoted as saying,
the office of the vice president is a greater honor than I ever dreamed of attaining.
Yet, it would only be a few months before he unexpectedly attained an even greater honor still.
After his inauguration in March of 1881, just a few months later in July, James Garfield was shot
by an assassin who was disgruntled at not having attained a political position in return for his
help during the campaign. This man, upon shooting the president, shouted out that he was a stalwart
and that Chester Arthur would become president. This started some vicious rumors about Arthur,
that somehow he was connected to this attempted assassination, and I say attempted because
Garfield did not immediately die. In fact, it would be 11 weeks before he eventually
died from blood poisoning. It was at that point in September that Arthur officially took the oath
of office. Now, where did Arthur sit at this point? He was republican and a very devoted party
republican, yet he was coming from a very different political background than the president whom he
was replacing. He didn't expect to become president up to that point, although I'm sure he'd had a few
months to think about that, and now he had to decide what he would do. Would he continue following the
pattern of his political career up to that point, going along with the spoil system and favors,
or would he follow the path for reform which Garfield had set in motion?
Now, it's interesting to look a little bit back at Arthur's background. He was born in Vermont,
the fifth of nine children. His father was a Baptist minister who was born and raised in Ireland
before immigrating to Canada. Another rumor which circulated about Arthur at one point, after he
attained the presidency, was that he was not a natural-born American citizen.
Some people claimed he was born in Ireland, and then later the claim was changed to that he was
born in Canada. There was never any proof to substantiate this, and the rumors didn't go too far,
but that is proof of the fact that Arthur was the second president after Buchanan to be of direct
Irish descent. As a boy, he was noted for having a very genial disposition in school, and he ended up
going to Union College in Schenectady. You see, when he was quite a young boy, his family ended up
moving to New York. His family traveled around a lot during his boyhood, and that was because his
father was a passionate abolitionist, which made him a lot of enemies in his congregation and with
his neighbors, so that's one reason why they had to keep traveling around. This would lead to Arthur
becoming an abolitionist himself before it was necessarily a popular thing to do, even among
the Whig and later Republican Party. As far back as the 1850s, when it still was somewhat controversial
to be anti-slavery in an outspoken way, Arthur felt quite strongly on that point. While he was
studying at Union College, he began getting into teaching, and he would teach during semester
breaks. After he graduated, he got a study teaching position, which he continued having for a few years
while he was studying to become a lawyer. After he passed the bar exam in New York, he joined a law
firm, first as a very minor partner, and eventually his name was added to the title of the firm.
While he was working at this firm in his earliest days, the law firm had a very important case,
which involved a slave owner relocating to New York, and the issue was whether, because New York
was a free state, the slaves should be free in that state. Arthur was a part of this case, not as big
a part as was later claimed during his time as an important politician, but he did serve an
important role in this decisive victory for his law firm. When the Civil War broke out in 1861,
his current job in the New York militia became far more important. He'd had a politically assigned
position of gathering troops, getting the necessary supplies, but there was very little to do during
peacetime. Once the war broke out, however, it became a very important and active job, and he
quickly showed his ability as someone who could raise funds, recruit men, and get the necessary
supplies. He also was appointed as a brigadier general, but he avoided active duty because he
was far more beneficial to the war effort by serving in that political position where he was
getting supplies and recruiting men. Because this position was one which was by political appointment,
he ended up losing the job when a democrat became his superior in the year 1863. He later campaigned,
tried to get back in in 1864, he never ended up getting that position again, but he had shown
his worth and his quality in that role. After that, he realized he could use the connections
he had made during the war in his private practice of law, and he began to get more
involved in politics, particularly the New York Republican Party machine. These days,
after the Civil War, was when the different party systems and political machines really began to
take hold and to become rather corrupt, especially in New York. There was the Democratic Tammany Hall
and then the Republican machine, which was headed by a few important individuals.
By this point, Arthur was a protege of Governor Morgan, who was an important leader of the
Republican machine. Now, what exactly did the machine do? It was particularly connected to
the U.S. Customs House, which would collect all the import duties. Basically, when political
positions needed to be filled, they would be granted to friends, colleagues, most notably people
who would help with election and could guarantee either votes or donations. So, it's sort of a
favor for a favor. Someone would be put in this position and that would guarantee more votes,
and it was just a cycle which kept everything very in-house, very much helping each other
to keep the party moving and to secure continued election. It was in the 1860s that Arthur began
working as part of the Customs House. He wanted to get the job of being in charge of the Naval
Customs Branch, but he wasn't able to attain that position. But in the year 1871, President Ulysses
S. Grant gave him the position of collector of imports at the Customs House, and under this
position, he became an important member of the party. Now, President Rutherford B. Hayes was
a passionate reformer, and he tried to clean up a lot of the favor giving that was in the
Republican Party. Because of this, he removed Arthur from his job as the collector. But Arthur
would remain very involved in the system and in the party, campaigning for various other presidents.
He was quite surprised when he was selected to be the vice presidential nominee for the Republican
Party in the year 1880, but he did run alongside Garfield, who was sort of a dark horse, and they
ended up both getting elected. Now, seeing all that background, where did Arthur stand after Garfield's
death? With Garfield, the reformer, out of the way, he could have reinstated the political machine in
New York and continued on the path which had been his path up to that point. But whether it was because
of Garfield's death to disprove the rumors which were circulating about him, or because he really
had begun to see that it wasn't the right way of conducting business, for whatever reason, Arthur
became just as passionate about cleaning up the civil service world as Garfield had been. Garfield's
death had really shown everyone how dangerous the whole favor-seeking and favoritism situation had
become. This slightly deranged man was so convinced that he had earned a spot that he thought it was
his right to shoot the president, even though he didn't have anything personally against him. He
thought that he was destroying the Republican Party and he was against the stalwart system.
This made a lot of people have very negative feelings about the stalwart system. Continuing
actions which Garfield had begun to put in place, in 1883, he advocated the adoption of the Pendleton
Act, which reformed the appointment of civil servants. And it required that instead of it
being a return for some favor or campaigning, that people holding non-elected federal positions
must pass exams and meet certain qualifications rather than just being friends of the president
or even personal choice of the president. And he also led to it not being so easy to fire these
civil workers when political tides changed, because that had happened a lot too.
It was basically just a position you could hold as long as you were similar to the person who was
in charge or the party that was in favor, rather than you've achieved this role in the government
because you've earned it, because you're the sort of person who should hold that role. So that was
one of the most important things he did. And it really was quite remarkable how Arthur changed
his whole political background. He was called the gentleman boss up to that point, because he was
indeed a political boss, but he was very gentlemanly in his personal conduct and his appearance.
They called him Elegant Arthur. He was reported to own 80 pairs of pants, and he changed his
clothing many times throughout the day. One of the most famous portraits of him, he's wearing
a coat with fur trim on it, very dapper, and he wore very fashionable side whiskers or monkey
chops, which were in vogue in those days. It must be noted that when he was working at the customs
house, he was honest. He didn't pocket the money or embezzle or anything like that, but he very much
had been part of the favoritism system, and that was a good deal how he got into the position where
he was. But he realized, having attained the role of president, that it wasn't a sustainable way of
doing business in the government. And I think he is to be commended for those drastic reforms which
he initiated in the government, largely because they caused him to lose a lot of support and
popularity. Throughout his presidency, he secretly was struggling with ill health. In fact, in his
second year in the White House, he realized he had a very serious kidney condition, a fatal disease,
and he knew he didn't have too many more years to live. But he kept his illness secret because
he didn't want the people to lose faith in him. After all, it would seem very bad luck for two
presidents to die in a row, and there wasn't anyone necessarily set up to take over for the vice
president at this time. And like the three vice presidents who had attained the presidency before
him, Arthur had no vice president throughout his presidency. It wasn't until the 1960s that
a system was arranged for replacing the vice president when the vice president had to become
the president. You'd think they would have put that in place long before, since it had already
happened four times. But they just trusted that the vice president would be able to survive, and
the vice president didn't serve that important of a role except for presiding over the Senate.
And in that case, another man was appointed to be in charge of the Senate, but not officially the
vice president. Another thing which Arthur notably did during his presidency was expand the Navy.
He saw that it was very important for the United States to have a strong naval force, so he
commissioned four new steel warships, and he added a lot of funds and support for the Navy during his
tenure. It's interesting that he seemed to have a bit of a preference for the Navy because he'd
wanted to be in that position earlier that was in charge of the Navy at the Customs House.
Another thing he did was to help end the War of the Pacific between several fighting South
American countries. He also dealt with some immigration laws. At the time, there was a ban
on Chinese immigration that had been in place for 20 years. He saw that this was unconstitutional
because we were supposed to let anyone enter the country, at least from any country. He wasn't quite
ready, seeing the political climate at the time, to completely lift the ban, but he did change it and
remove it from a permanent exclusion to just making it a 10-year ban. So that was, I suppose,
a step in the right direction. He did, however, put in place some other restrictions on immigration,
not specifically related to one country, but to keep people who were extreme paupers,
mentally ill, or criminals from immigrating to the United States. He also worked on reducing the
tariff. Now, he was not able to reduce the national debt, which had been in place since
the Civil War at all, in fact increasing it a bit, but he did make those positive improvements
on a few different areas. Because of his ill health, he wasn't sure he wanted to even run for
a second term. He entertained the idea at one point, but his party did not nominate him for a
second term, largely because he'd moved away from the stalwart faction. Yet because of his background
as this political boss, he wasn't going to get too much support from the other side, the people who
were supporting James Blaine. Thus, he did not end up running for a second term officially,
and he returned to his private law practice, but he didn't have much time to do that because
he died 20 months after leaving the White House. He was quoted as saying upon leaving the White
House, well, there doesn't seem anything else for an ex-president to do but to go into the country
and raise big pumpkins. Whether he raised pumpkins or not, I'm not sure, but it's a rather humorous
quote, I think showing metaphorically even more than literally that he saw there really wasn't
much point in continuing doing other things after that, because some people did want him to run for
a position in the Senate, and there were other presidents who continued being very active in
politics, but I think he saw that his time in politics was over. He had done what he was going
to do, and he needed to just resign from it. Like most presidents who ended up attaining the White
House through rather accidental ascendancy, much of the quotes from him are about the fact that he
took over as president. He said after Garfield's death, men may die, but the fabric of our free
institutions remains unshaken. He also was quoted as saying, no higher proof exists of the strength
of popular government than though the chosen of the people be struck down, his constitutional
successor is peacefully installed without shock or strain. In a way, I think Arthur was trying to
make a statement with that quote rather than just an observation. Firstly, it's interesting that he
said the constitutional successor, because the constitution did not include any provision for
what should happen when the president died. It was vice president John Tyler took it upon himself
to accept the presidency after William Henry Harrison's death, and that became a tradition
which was followed. And I think he also was showing that the people needed to accept him in
this position, because that had become the thing that was done, even though there were some rumors
against him. He believed that you should be open to a bigger role than you have. You should be
always aiming higher and seek to be better than the job you currently hold. Quote, be fit for more
than the thing you are now doing. Let everyone know that you have a reserve in yourself, that you have
more power than you are now using. If you are not too large for the place you occupy, you are too
small for it. I would say that despite his somewhat shady background before becoming vice
president, which some people have described as a filthy mess, he ended up being an excellent
president, showing that he was in fact too large for the role of vice president. He had it in him
to become a reformer and to change his ways when put in a position of such importance.
And I think he remains a great example of how it's possible to change, despite what your political
background might be or other career choices you've made. It's never too late to change. And
at the age of 50, he was able to completely turn around his political image, because he was never
a dishonest man. He always had wanted to do the right thing, but getting him away from that New
York system, he was able to see how one needs to be worthy of the job he takes. And like that quote
says, you shouldn't just barely be able to fill it. You need to be bigger than that role. So thus,
those who have the role of assigning people to important jobs should really consider whether
that person is just barely big enough to fill it or whether he is in fact too large for it and thus
amply qualified. Thank you for spending this time with me talking about the very interesting
21st president, Chester Arthur. I hope you'll join me next time for more American Legends.