Could Medieval Longbow Arrows Penetrate Plate Armour?

The Saga of Past Longbows
6 followers
6 Video Views·Sep 1, 2025
Welcome to another Q&A session about history, the longbow, archery or whatever subscribers want to know. Can longbow arrows penetrate plate armour? It's a question that's asked a lot, in varying ways, so here, Kevin Hicks shares his experience and thoughts on the question.
Hi, and welcome to my YouTube channel, The History Squad.
This is not a film.
This is me answering questions.
I get asked so many questions,
and the biggest one I'm asked so often
is do longbow arrows penetrate plate armor?
And I've done lots of experiments.
I've done lots of shooting at armor,
and the arrows bounce off, shatter.
The best is the long bodkin.
It might go in a centimeter.
And I've watched countless, I suppose, other people,
but the fact is, if we go back to the Battle of Agincourt,
the armor was hammered.
It wasn't from rolled steel.
There could be weak spots.
There could be thicker spots.
And if the arrows could penetrate armor,
and I'm asking you this, you know,
why did knights wear armor?
They'd have been much agile
if they'd have just had padding, yeah?
So it's this business, isn't it?
And if you look at Agincourt,
wooden stakes in the ground for the cavalry.
You look at the Battle of Crecy,
they dug pits in the ground.
You had to trick the horses over.
So as far as I can make out,
for everything I've read and I've looked at,
is forget this question.
Did longbow arrows penetrate plate armor?
In my opinion, no, right?
As a general rule, no.
And lots of the modern tests,
it's modern steel, modern bows, modern arrows.
We're trying to recreate it.
But let's go back, go back in time.
There are stories, for instance,
of shattered arrows causing damage.
You look at Henry V when he was the young Prince of Wales.
It was part of an arrow
that went straight through his cheek
because he got his visor up instead of it being down.
If it had been down, it would have deflected the arrowhead.
Ooh, there's a clue, yeah?
And also I've got a couple of stories
and I want you, if you can, my loyal followers,
if you've heard these stories, can you tell me?
Because I can't find the reference to them.
These were told to me years ago
by other bowmen and bowyers.
The one is we were discussing
about the effectiveness of longbow arrows.
I don't know the war.
It could be a hundred years war.
It could be the War of the Roses.
A knight in front of his men has raised his arm
and he's about to do this, I suppose,
when an arrow has hit him here, bang, right in the joint
and he can't get his arm down.
He's been led back through his men.
They've had to take off his vambrace and the whole lot
and refit it and when he comes back,
his troops are gone and the battle's virtually over.
Is that a true story?
I'd love to know because it's one
that's locked in since my Warwick Castle day.
Another one is of a knight who survived a battle
and a hailstorm of arrows, but when he took his armor off,
his jack was soaked in blood
because he'd got pinholes through his armor
and where the arrow heads had pierced, he'd been cut.
Now, one of my subscribers, Sean Henderson,
I asked him if he knew of any of these stories
and the only one he could remember was of William Marshall.
William Marshall, probably the greatest knight ever,
one of my faves, who'd been at a joust tournament
and he'd won, but he couldn't claim the prize
because he'd been battered around the head,
the great helm so much that it was jammed
and whilst they were giving the ceremony of here it is,
the great knight, he'd got an armorer banging the helmet
trying to get it into shape so he could simply get it off.
So back to the beginning, if you want my opinion,
arrows, medieval times, they can dent armor,
they can make pinholes, but unless there's a weak spot,
I doubt hand on heart
that longbow arrows could penetrate armor.
So thank you very much to all my subscribers.
Keep the questions coming in
and I will send you the answers
and I don't mind you disagreeing, yeah,
because this is a great forum.
I'm actually learning some things from other people.
So thanks for listening, give us a thumbs up,
subscribe if you're not already subscribing
and ding that bell.
Thank you very much.
