A Christian Missionary’s Journey to Judaism – Shannon Nuszen
In this powerful and deeply personal lecture, Shannon Nuszen shares her remarkable journey from being a devoted evangelical missionary, raised in the heart of Christian ministry and trained to convert Jews, to discovering the truth of Judaism and embracing it with her whole heart.
What began as a mission to bring others closer to Jesus became a transformative search for truth that ultimately led her to Torah, mitzvot, and a profoundly deeper, more authentic relationship with the Divine. Through her story, Shannon explores how leaving behind everything she once believed was true wasn’t a rejection of God, but the very path that brought her closer than ever before to the Almighty.
In Shannon's exodus from the depths of the church, she discovered how Judaism answered the questions that Christianity could not.
More about Shannon Nuszen:
Shannon Nuszen, a former Evangelical Christian missionary, grew up studying and analyzing Christian scriptural polemics as the daughter of a former Assemblies of God minister. She was deeply immersed in the Evangelical Christian movement from a young age and even traveled with her father as an evangelist in his ministry. Her involvement in the movement provided her with knowledge of the inner workings and manipulative tactics used to convert Jews to Christianity.
As a young adult, Shannon became involved in the Christian messianic movement and affiliated with some of the most deceptive missionary organizations to enter the Jewish community. She has since converted to Judaism and regrets her past associations. Her experience has given her an intimate knowledge of the Christian missionary agenda, which she uses to educate Jewish communities in Israel and the Diaspora about its dangers.
Shannon has worked in various roles within the counter-missionary field for over fifteen years, and recently began speaking publicly about her personal Jewish journey. Her story has been featured in several publications, including The Jerusalem Post, Hamodia, Mishpacha, Hidabroot, Ami Magazine, and has been promoted by organizations such as Aish HaTorah and the Orthodox Union (OU).
After moving to Israel, Shannon founded Beyneynu, an organization that monitors missionary activity in Israel and abroad, and raises awareness of the missionary agenda among Jewish leadership and the worldwide Jewish community. Beyneynu has successfully dealt with high-profile cases that have shaken the Jewish world in recent years and is often cited as a go-to source on missionaries in the news. Shannon is also a sought-after lecturer and inspirational speaker at Jewish events worldwide.
Since 1989, JEWS FOR JUDAISM is has been a trailblazer in global Jewish outreach.
Jews for Judaism wins back to Judaism those Jews who have been influenced by these “Seven Threats to Jewish Survival”:
• Evangelical Christian Missionaries convert 1,000’s of Jews worldwide annually • Destructive Cults induce Jews to abandon family, friends and careers • Eastern Religions are now the spiritual choices for many Jews • Jewish Apathy and Ignorance cause many Jews to assimilate, abandoning Judaism • Intermarriage is exploding at a 75% rate in many locales • Anti-Israel propaganda and lies brainwash millions globally and deter Jewish support for Israel • Antisemitism is promoting global Jew-Hatred and alienating Jews from Judaism
JEWS FOR JUDAISM strengthens preserves and saves Jewish lives through its worldwide Internet outreach, social media, free educational programs, educational literature and counselling services that connect Jewish people to the spiritual depth, beauty and wisdom of Judaism.
To help non-Jews discover the Torah’s path to G-d, Jews for Judaism provides educational programs to help them embrace the Torah’s Seven Noahide Laws for Gentiles.
[Music]
As you can probably guess from the
title, I was not born Jewish. I was born
to an evangelical Christian family. Not
just any evangelical family. My father
was an Assemblies of God minister,
fundamentalist Christian.
Quite a few years ago, I was dedicated
to bringing Jewish people to know about
Jesus. Since then, I have made a 180 and
my life is now dedicated to warning you
about some of the most deceptive tactics
being employed by the church today and
showing you how and why more than a
quarter of a million of our Jewish
brothers and sisters are in the clutches
of the church today.
I was taught to be a missionary from a
young age. I took the mission very
seriously. When the doors of the church
were open, I was there. If there was a
mission available, I was part of it. I
started the first Christian student
union in my high school. And bringing as
many people as I possibly could to Jesus
was a goal that I set for myself every
single day,
especially somebody like you.
If you're Jewish,
why? You probably have no idea what it
meant to somebody like me because a Jew.
Wow. That was the highest achievement
that a missionary like myself could ever
hope to accomplish.
Because although evangelical teachings
have a very world focus, the Jews are
definitely prioritized.
I'm going to give you a little bit of
insight into the mind of a missionary.
The study of end times is huge. Those
who identify as Christian right
conservative
Christian Zionists, they are obsessed
with bringing about the second coming of
Jesus. It was a commandment from Jesus
himself towards the end of the book of
Matthew. He was speaking to a Jewish
audience when he said, "You will not see
me again until you say, "Blessed is he
who comes in the name of the Lord." So,
ladies and gentlemen, you are holding up
the show.
As a Christian, my world was very neat.
It was simple, black and white. There
was good, there was evil. I was taught
to believe that the Jews rejected Jesus
because of this supernatural veil that
they had over their eyes, an unnatural
spiritual blindness. They just couldn't
see. In my church, we were taught that
the Jews collectively turned their back
on God. It was very simple. The Jews
willingly and knowingly turned their
back on their own Messiah, the very
Messiah that they brought into the
world. They willingly rejected him and
worse, they killed him.
I was taught as a Christian that it was
my mission to bring the the news of the
Jewish Messiah to the Jewish people and
that if I was faithful in this, God was
going to allow that supernatural veil to
be removed from their eyes and they
would see it. That was the path that I
went down.
I didn't know many Jews at the time, but
I did know a little bit about the Jewish
people. They're proud. You've probably
met a few,
whether religious or not, even if they
know very little about Judaism,
their stance is almost always, "I was
born a Jew. I'll die a Jew." And oh boy,
are they stubborn. Even God calls his
own people stubborn and stiff necked.
For this reason, the church gave
intensive training coaching on how I
could overcome this Jewish pride. these
natural defenses that Jewish people
have.
I joined classes at the JCC. I took an
Israeli dance class, an oon class. Why?
Because it gave me the opportunity to
meet Jewish people to become a familiar
face in the Jewish community.
I volunteered at events. They came to
depend on me. I delivered meals on
wheels to the elderly. It's very easy to
share the gospel with somebody who is so
lonely that they will talk to you about
just about anything if you'll just sit
with them for a few minutes.
When I say the word missionary, you
probably think about those people
screaming on the streets or the guys
passing out tracks on the street
corners.
Obviously, they're not very successful.
In fact, I don't think that there's a
single person, a Jewish person, who's
ever been converted by one of these
encounters on the street.
Some of you here today might tell me
that you've never encountered a
missionary, but I bet that's not true.
You see, the most successful
missionaries aren't the ones yelling on
a megaphone for you to repent. They're
your everyday churchgoers, your
neighbor, your college roommate, your
friend at work.
And that was the most important part of
my training to become a friend.
We are unfortunately living in a time
where each one of you probably knows
somebody, a friend or a co-orker,
somebody who is converted to
Christianity. If you were to ask that
cousin, that friend, how did it happen?
It's never through the efforts of a
professional missionary.
In nearly every case, it's basic social
interactions. A friend.
So many people tell me that they have a
friend, but that's a Christian that but
they've never tried to convert me. And
I'll tell you, the friends that I made,
the Jewish people that I connected with,
they never felt like I was procilitizing
them. And that was easy. You bring about
the subject of faith in everyday
discussions.
Whether it be a conversation about an
illness, difficulty with our kids,
marriage,
you do it in such a way that they're the
ones to bring up the dis the questions.
Although through every discussion, I was
intentionally leading them to bring up
these questions because when you're a
friend, you're no longer a missionary. I
hope you hear me when I say that.
I began to perfect my interactions with
Jewish people when I learned how to
incorporate their traditions into my own
practices. I learned a whole new way of
speaking, a new way of
presenting the gospel because let's face
it, the name Jesus Christ and images of
crosses don't invoke invoke any warm and
friendly feelings in Jewish people.
There's actually a verse in the New
Testament for more deceptive tactics.
I'll read it to you. It's And to the
Jews I became a Jew that I might win the
Jews. To those who are under the law
that I might win those who are under the
law. To the weak I became weak that I
might win the weak. I become all things
to all men that by all means I would
save some. In other words, you look
like, you speak like, you dress like,
you do whatever it takes to bring that
person to Christ. There are training
manuals on that. I I brought one here
today
is
how to share the Messiah.
It is a a useful manual on the Jewish
culture, the Jewish people, what not to
say to a Jew, and more importantly, what
to say to a Jew in order to bring about
a conversation about the Messiah. In the
middle of this is this handy little card
that you can take a take around with you
in case you encounter a Jewish person.
On the left side it says do say. On the
right side it says don't say. This is uh
how to change the language so that it's
more palatable. We'll go through a few.
Don't say Jesus Christ. That doesn't
sound very Jewish. Instead say Yeshua or
Messiah Yeshua, his Hebrew name. Don't
say Christian. They use that term
amongst themselves but never when
speaking to a Jew. Every Jew knows that
converting is a bad thing. So they'll
tell you to become a completed Jew, a
fulfilled Jew, or more common today, a
messianic Jew. They say don't come to
church. We can't get Jews in sh. They're
not going to church. Instead, say come
to a meeting of Bible believers because
that sounds nicer, doesn't it?
Don't say New Testament. instead instead
say new covenant or brites in in Israel.
I mean you get the idea. Basically the
goal is to change the language and make
it more palatable for a Jew to accept.
But the fundamental beliefs of Messianic
Jews are in every way Christian. You
simply take everything about Jesus. You
repackage it with a Jewish wrapping. You
incorporate Jewish symbols, Jewish
icons, you throw in Jewish traditions,
and you've got a Jewishy Jesus.
The extent of this is shocking to people
who have never encountered it. For
instance, a messianic pesak seder. It
may have all of the appearances of being
Jewish, but I assure you it's not. If
you were to look at a messianic hagada,
you would find out that
they believe that the wine represents
his blood. The three matzas represent
the trinity, the father, the son, the
holy spirit. The matzas represent his
body. You know that there are holes and
stripes in the matzah. They will tell
you that this represents the beating and
the piercing of Jesus.
Even the part of the seder where we
break the middle matzah, they say that
also represents Jesus, the crucifixion
because the New Testament says his body
would be broken for you. The afikomen,
you know that in the beginning we hide
it. They say that represents the death.
We wrap it in a white cloth. They say
that represents the white shroud for
burial.
You know, we bring it back at the end of
the seder. They'll tell you that that
represents the resurrection or the
second coming.
Every aspect of the messianic movement
is entirely Christian. It's just wrapped
up in Jewish symbols and icons. Every
tradition that we hold sacred has been
hijacked to make it appear make
Christianity appear more Jewish.
You will hear arguments like, "But Jesus
was a Jew. The apostles were Jews.
So accepting the Jewish Messiah is the
most Jewish thing you can do."
But what would cause a Jew like yourself
to actually go so far as to cross the
lines and join groups like Jews for
Jesus?
Their message is very compelling. I used
it myself.
They'll tell you, "Nobody's perfect.
We're all sinners. None of us can
possibly stand before a holy God in our
sinful, blemished condition.
We don't have a temple. We can't have
sacrifices today. And without a perfect
sacrifice, they'll tell you, we're
simply not worthy. But by accepting
their Messiah, we would be forgiven
because he was the sacrifice and he bore
the punishment for us. There is a uh New
Testament verse that says, "For God so
loved the world that he gave his only
son that whoever believes in him, he
should not perish but have everlasting
life."
There are a lot of people in this world
who simply feel alone, unloved.
You'd be surprised how easily these
arguments work with young people.
Young people who feel that despite who
and what they are, that somebody loved
them enough to die for them. That
message resonates for a lot of broken
people.
Unfortunately, I was successful in this
and today that hurts me very much.
These techniques worked on less
affiliated Jews.
So, how did I get to where I am now?
Well, my problem came about when I
encountered more religious Jews. I was
fascinated with the Orthodox world. I
was inspired by the commitment they had
to all of their traditions and their
rituals. It was like God was always
central in their world. But I'd been
taught that all of those rituals were
empty. They had no meaning. That Jews
didn't really have a relationship with
God. Not like a Christian does. They
can't. Because as a Christian,
I knew it was impossible to have a
relationship with God without the
forgiveness of sin. So to me, I could
not think of anything more beautiful
than to bring a religious Jew to have a
relationship with his Jewish Messiah.
Jews didn't feel the same way. I
discovered
I was also taught that Jews didn't
really read their Bible and that rabbis
actually forbid them from reading
certain chapters. So, as I turned my
focus into reaching religious Jews, I
was surprised that they often were quite
knowledgeable about their Bible, and
they weren't going to fall for my
emotional plea or my repackaging of
Christianity with a Jewish flavor. To
reach these Jews, I had to learn to
argue the text, the verses, the Tanakh
that I knew proved that Jesus was the
Messiah. In my mind, I knew that if I
could just get a religious Jew to look
at these texts, that that magic would
that veil would be magically removed and
they would see it just as clearly as I
did. It was not easy. Many of them would
blow me off and not give me the time of
day, but occasionally I'd get one to
talk to me. You probably know some
Jewish people who get excited when they
see a missionary because they like to
mess with them. I definitely encountered
those.
Some of them had dabbled in counter
missionary work and knew some of the
arguments and they seemed armed with Q
cards with everything I came to them
with. They'd say things like that verse
is mistransated or you're taking that
out of context. Which I thought was
absolutely absurd. I'd come back to them
and tell them, "You're just
regurgitating what your rabbis tell you,
and if you just look at it yourself,
you'd see
I seem to be getting nowhere with them."
I realized just like I had learned to
change the language, I was just going to
have to find another way to present the
gospel.
So, I started to try to prove their
arguments wrong.
They say it's mistransated.
I'm going to go back and I'm going to
learn the Hebrew of that verse. They say
it's out of context. I'm not only going
to quote the one verse, but I'm going to
I'm going to learn the whole chapter or
the whole book if I have to so that I
can prove it in context like they
insisted.
I thought that by turning the tables on
them, I would at least get them to look
at the text with me.
to do this against the advice of my
church. I began to study from rabbis who
understood the text. And as I began to
understand what the Jewish people
believed, I was stunned. I began to
understand why the church leaders
advised me against this because I
couldn't control the cracks that began
to appear. But I wanted to prove the
Jews were wrong. I was determined.
Obviously, that didn't work out so well
because I was taught to believe that
Jews were blinded. They were bitter.
They were just filled with hatred of
Jesus. It was the only explanation that
made sense.
But the one thing that I was never
taught in church, the one message that
was never conveyed to me in Sunday
school was that the Jews didn't believe
in Jesus because they look at the text
and they simply draw a very different
conclusion.
And now I know why.
Because I would have asked just like any
Christian would have asked, why?
How can the people who produced the very
prophets who prophesied about a Messiah
reject him?
Why would they, the ones who you would
think know the text better than anyone?
After all, you read it in its original
original language. Why would they draw a
different conclusion?
Before this, my world was neat,
complete, well-rounded. We, the
Christians, particularly my
denomination, we had the truth and
everybody else was wrong.
To my absolute shock and horror, I
learned that those verses that I was
using to bring Jews to Jesus, they were
in fact mistransated.
They were taken out of context and in
some cases completely made up. That
discovery was like an atomic bomb in my
life.
But when I began to learn Torah, when I
began to learn what the text really
said, I couldn't get enough.
When I learned Torah without my Jesus
filter, it was so beautiful and so
inspiring.
The deprogramming process wasn't so
easy. The foundation of absolutely
everything I believed to be true had
crumbled. I no longer knew what to
believe at all.
But Torah was my baseline.
And as I came to grips with the fact
that I could no longer trust my
Christian Bible, it became the only
thing that I could depend on.
Perhaps the hardest part of the
transition was the loss of
relationships.
You see, when a Christian rejects Jesus,
they're no longer accepted in those
circles. As I began my to share my
crisis of faith and what I was finding
with those people around me, they
weren't as understanding as I thought
they would be.
The only thing that mattered to them was
that I was rejecting Jesus. And I swore
to them that although I might not
believe the same, I might not go to
church all the time,
I was still their friend.
Although I might stop going to church,
we could still get together after I
would meet them for coffee. We can still
be friends.
But word got around and the pastor of my
church sent out a notice to the entire
congregation.
In it, he quoted a few verses from the
New Testament I wasn't so familiar with
at the time.
One who denies Christ is the Antichrist.
In Christianity, that basically meant I
was the devil.
The difference between you and me is
that you just don't know any better. You
could still be saved if shown enough
love and persistence from a Christian.
But somebody like me who knew Jesus and
rejected him, that's an apostate. And
there's no redemption for such a person.
Another New Testament he was sure to
include was that one who denies Christ
is not welcome in your home. You're
forbidden to have them sit at your
table.
This hurt a lot because my best friend's
wedding was just around the corner. Not
only was I told that I'm no longer part
of the wedding party, I was asked to not
be on the premises.
Emotionally, I was falling apart.
I lost every friend I had. Relationships
that I knew were indestructible had
suddenly been severed.
The unconditional love that had been
preached about my whole life didn't
apply to an apostate like me.
I found myself very alone.
And after experiencing so much loss and
humiliation,
the last thing I wanted to do was to
tell my parents. I love my parents
dearly. I have always shown them
respect.
I couldn't bear to disappoint them or
for worse for them to feel that I was
dishonoring them in some way.
So while I pursued learning Judaism, I
hid it from my parents.
They assumed that my attending synagogue
was part of my commitment to evangelize
the Jewish people, to infiltrate their
communities.
When they visited, I would turn books
backward. Anything with Hebrew writing,
I would hide it. I avoided religious
discussions.
But there was one Friday night that I
will never forget. I had been learning
intensely that day.
I had every translation out. I had my
notes laid on there on the table.
That night, a Friday night, I went to a
conservative synagogue for for Shabbat.
And during the service, I had my phone
off, but my father left a message and he
told me he was coming over, that he had
a meeting in the morning and he needed
to be in the area. He was staying over.
I had absolutely no warning. Absolutely
everything I did not want him to see was
going to be the first thing that he saw
when he walked into the in my house.
I wasn't sure whether I should rush home
and try to beat him there and and and
hide it or was it hopeless and I should
just take my time and process how am I
going to explain myself?
Sure enough, he was already there. And
as I walked in, he was sitting at the
table looking through my studying.
And he motioned for me to come sit next
to him. I felt like a 5-year-old child
ready to get a lecture.
In a very concerned voice, he said,
"Look,
it hasn't gone unnoticed that you have
changed the way you dress, you change
the way you eat." Besides a minister, my
father was also a very military man. and
he went into law enforcement, became a
detective.
He told me, "I've seen this before. I
know what's going on here. It's obvious
to me that you're getting involved in a
cult."
He informed me that we're going to start
learning together and we're going to
straighten this out and I'm going to get
you out of this. We're going to get
through this.
I tried my best to explain to him that
that's not the case. And that in my
quest for answers to some questions, I I
just found some really troubling things.
As we looked through a couple of them
together, he didn't have any immediate
answers, which I could tell bothered
him. But he knew that somehow I was
reaching the wrong conclusions and that
we were going to get these answers and
that he would get explanations and that
we would come back to this at another
time.
I gave him some audios that I was
listening to. I I gave him my notes. I
thought for sure that was going to buy
me at least a week before we had to
broach the subject again. As my father
went into the guest room where he was
staying, I could tell that he was deep
in thought. I went to bed, but I was
certainly not sleeping. I could hear
that rabbi's voice playing in the next
room.
Every time the rabbi revealed an
important point, something shocking, I'd
hear the tape stop. I'd hear the
flipping of pages. I was worried. Is my
dad getting angry? Is he listening? Does
he understand?
At 3:00 in the morning, there was a
knock on my bedroom door asking if I was
awake. And of course, I was. My father
sat quietly on the edge of my bed, and
he didn't say a word. I wasn't sure I
wanted to know what he had to say.
But I waited for several minutes,
and he sat in a catatonic stare at the
wall. And I asked, "Daddy, are you
okay?"
He answered, "He's right. That rabbi,
the Jews, they're right."
I looked up every reference
and the rug has been pulled out from
under me.
I couldn't believe what I was hearing.
He He turned to me and he said, "What do
we do now?"
I cried. He cried. I told him that's
where I'm at. I explained to him that me
and my children want to convert to
Judaism.
My father has since left the church.
He's no longer a minister.
For him, he told me that it was enough
to put that behind him
and that he no longer subscribes to
that. But to learn a whole new religion,
a new culture, a new language, it's too
much for him. He identifies himself as a
Ben Noah. And today he's one of my
biggest fans.
My mother, her reaction was very
different. I used the analogy of the
matrix
to explain what I had discovered. I told
her I felt like I'd been unplugged, and
what I'd found, I just simply can't
unsee it. frustrated. She told me, "Plug
me back in. I don't want to hear it."
And I know what she was thinking. I know
what she was feeling because the church
doctrine on hell is terrifying. The
repercussions of rejecting Jesus are
severe.
The teachings about what will happen at
the end times are horrifying. I had
nightmares as a child that the rapture
might happen and I'd be left behind.
There's an old movie series that we were
we would watch in church about being
left behind. If you don't take the mark
of the antichrist, you'd be beheaded
with a guillotine.
The images of a w a wicker basket to
catch the head are burned into my mind
forever.
I wasn't allowed to listen to secular
music or watch Disney movies because of
their influence. But these films were
more terrifying than any horror movie
that Hollywood could come up with
because it wasn't fiction to us.
These were real consequences.
If you die not believing in Jesus, your
fate is torture, hell,
damnation.
So my mother cried. I was going to hell
and I was taking her grandchildren with
me.
It was more than she could handle.
We've made sort of a peace along the way
and we simply don't get into discussions
that I know will hurt her and that's
okay. My relationship with her is more
important.
But I'm standing today in front of you
as a convert, a Torah observerant Jew
who is now dedicated to protecting
Jewish communities against aggressive
missionaries.
missionaries who are desperately seeking
to convert you, your children, your
grandchildren.
For years, I didn't speak about my past,
especially when I moved to Israel. I
didn't want to be known as a convert. I
didn't want my children to be viewed any
different.
So, for 10 years, I worked behind the
scenes supplying information to a
counter missionary organization that was
working with the Israeli government.
When I would go to Israel, I would
occasionally speak in private meetings
in Knesset or with Jewish leaders,
but for the most part, never publicly.
That changed in 2020 with CO.
I decided to update the statistics that
I had gone over five years earlier when
I made aliyah.
When I first arrived in Israel, the
numbers of Jews who identified
themselves as Messianic believers was
15,000
and there were over a 100 Messianic
congregations.
In only 5 years, I watched that number
double. In 2020, the new estimates were
that there were between 30 to 40,000
Jewish believers in Jesus and more than
300 congregations and organizations,
mostly Hebrewspeaking.
There are now more than 200 Israelibased
websites that are dedicated to
converting Jews to Christianity in
Hebrew and in Russian.
My husband is in an emergency physician.
He has a skill set that makes it
obligated for him to act when he's
needed. Whether we're on vacation and
he's sitting in his bathing suit, if he
hears the call, is there a doctor? He
has to run.
I am not proud of my past.
But it does give me a unique skill set.
I feel pulled to do more and to speak
out in order to warn Jewish communities
about the very world that I came from.
And today it feels like an urgent
situation.
I founded Benu, a nonprofit organization
that monitors missionary activity
worldwide. And for the past few years,
we've exposed some of the most shocking
cases of infiltration into the Jewish
community.
non-Jews disguised as hered taking on
leadership positions, performing sacred
Jewish rituals, some of them with
tremendous hakic ramifications.
I'm often asked, "But why did you choose
Judaism?
What aspects of Judaism
caused you to convert?"
It's hard to narrow that down to just a
few.
And as I remember growing up,
questioning was not only discouraged, it
was seen as dangerous.
Faith, I was told, meant believing
without questioning. In fact, the more
unbelievable something is, the more
faith it took to believe it. And I was
taught that that was a good thing.
Now, boy, did I have faith.
I believed it with all my heart.
The New Testament teaches that if you
have faith as small as a mustard seed
that you can move mountains.
When I was seven years old, I lost my
hearing completely in one ear and 20% in
the other due to complications of a
surgery. The doctor said it was
impossible,
but I prayed for years. I knew that my
hearing would eventually come back.
When I was nine, my grandmother passed
away. I was devastated,
but I had faith. Absolute unshakable
faith. I knew that she would come back.
After all, I read the people in the New
Testament. They'd been resurre
resurrected.
So, I prayed all night before her
funeral. I was certain that I was going
to wake up and I'd find out she was
alive. but she wasn't.
And then there were the faith healers. I
went to so many of these events. I
watched people supposedly being healed,
knee pain, debilitating headaches, back
problems, getting out of their
wheelchairs, and walking across the
stage.
I was a tiny, scrawny little kid, and I
walked around. I walked across so many
of those stages
for my own healing. And for some reason,
nothing was happening.
I started wondering, why aren't my
prayers being answered? What was I doing
wrong? Does God not love me?
Then the questions became deeper.
How come all of these healings aren't
things that really can be verified?
How come we don't see amputees legs grow
back before our own eyes?
How come they're only taking places on
stages and not in hospitals or
children's cancer wards where they're
really needed?
It couldn't be faith because I had
faith. Absolute faith.
And when I started to ask these
questions, I was shut down.
Don't you question God?
The Bible is the divine word of God, and
to doubt is sin.
So, I learned to push these questions
down, but they never really went away.
Years later, as a missionary seeking to
convert Jews to Christianity, I met
religious Jews that challenged my faith.
They asked questions I couldn't answer,
but I had faith, and I knew they were
wrong, and I was right. I just had to
seek out the right answers to come back
at them with.
The answers that I found changed
everything.
So my answer to why I came to Judaism,
what drew me to this flame is
questioning.
The ability to question.
Learning is one of the things I love
most about Judaism. And that questioning
isn't only allowed, it is expected.
Moshe doubted himself and he argued with
God. Abraham questioned and challenged
God. Y of Job, he demanded justice.
The entire Talmud is volumes of debates,
rabbis arguing over every little detail
of Jewish law down to the smallest, most
obscure points. And it's not because
they don't have faith. It's because they
have faith.
This completely flipped my understanding
of what faith was. Faith is not about
blindly accepting something.
It's about engaging,
wrestling,
seeking, and through that strengthening
your relationship with God. I questioned
everything. and my quest for answers is
what drew me into that flame. If I had
not set out the answers to those
questions, I would not have the deep
connection with Hashem that I am so
thankful for today. And let's be honest,
we are all wrestling with a lot of
questions right now.
Life in Israel has been unimaginably
hard lately.
I've been to more funerals in the past
year than I can count.
We buried my own nephew, Binyamin Erley,
who's only 21 years old.
There are still hostages suffering in
unbelievable conditions,
things we can't imagine.
I've seen horrors that I wouldn't wish
on anybody, and I don't have answers for
that. And yet, I have also seen beauty.
I've seen miracles. I've seen terror
attacks that should have s succeeded and
they didn't. I've seen a level of unity,
unity among Jewish people that I never
saw before October 7th.
I've seen people reconnecting to their
roots and finding meaning and purpose.
People that nobody knew were Jewish are
suddenly standing up and proudly
identifying themselves as Jews.
And sometimes I see beauty in the most
unexpected places.
A while back, a woman reached out to me
on Facebook. She told me she followed my
page because she hates me.
She found my work exposing missionaries
offensive and she wanted to prove me
wrong. We'd argue back and forth and at
some point I realized that she was
Jewish. She had converted to
Christianity when she was in college and
she had no idea what Judaism really was.
After October 7th, she reached out to me
again and she said, "Despite our past
disagreements,
I want to offer my condolences to about
your nephew.
He was killed in Gaza one month after
the war."
And that small act of kindness led to a
real conversation, one that lasted for
days. She started asking me about
Judaism.
And I answered her questions one by one.
She started realizing she didn't know
anything about her own heritage. And
slowly she started making her way back.
Today she's no longer a Christian. She's
returned back to the truth and beauty of
the Jewish faith.
On YouTube, you can find a video of a
missionary going around college campuses
asking Jewish students, "What does it
mean to be a Jew?"
Almost every student gives the same
answer. It means my parents are Jewish
and that I don't believe in Jesus.
That's it. That's the number one answer.
That's what they knew. But being Jewish
is so much more than not being something
else.
It's a relationship.
It's a mission. We're taught to be the
light to the nations, to take care of
each other, to lead by example.
While other religions focus on the
afterlife, heaven, hell, 70 virgins.
Judaism is about life here now, making
the world a better place.
Another story. A while back, a young
Jewish doctor reached out to me. He was
engaged to a Christian woman and her
father was a pastor. He was being
pressured to accept Jesus before he
would allow his him to marry his
daughter.
He told me, "I don't know much about
Judaism. My family never really went to
synagogue, but I just feel like it's
important and that I shouldn't let it
go." So, he had a plan. He thought since
I used to be a Christian, maybe I could
convince his fiance that his Jewishness
wouldn't be a threat to their
relationship.
Of course, I did not take that
direction. Instead, I turned the
conversation back to him. I asked, "Why
does Juda Judaism feel so important to
you? What do you believe? What do you
know about?" As we started talking,
he couldn't stop. I called in for
backup, a colleague of mine, a rabbi,
and together on a Zoom call. We spent
two hours discussing the oneness of God,
how Judaism rejects intermediaries, how
human sacrifice is an abomination.
And I watched something incredible in
this young man.
He barely knew anything about Judaism
before, but he was lit up with
curiosity.
By the end of the call, the rabbi asked
him to cover his eye and say the smile
with him.
And then he told him, "Welcome home."
A few weeks later, we learned that they
broke off the engagement. He started
learning Torah. He connected to a local
shul. He even joined a cola
And now just a couple months ago I got a
message from him that he was celebrating
his fourth semium four.
That is the power of being drawn into
the flame. That is the power of asking
questions
because Torah isn't just a book. It's a
conversation. It's a relationship. It's
how we engage with God. How we seek
answers. how we struggle with the
hardest questions in life. And that's
what makes it real. Even in your own
relationships, it's only through really
engaging with the other person,
discovering how they think and how they
feel about any given subject. That's how
we truly get to know a person. When we
learn Torah, we're not just reading
words on a page. We're actively engaging
with God. It's not about having all of
the answers. It's about being on the
journey about searching, learning,
discovering new insights.
Every time we open a safer,
every time we debate haka, every time we
challenge ourselves to grow, we are
stepping into a relationship with God
that is deep, dynamic, and alive.
Engagement.
It's about making Torah personal, making
it a part of your daily lives and
letting it shape the way we think, the
way we speak, the way we act. And the
mitzvot, they are not just rules.
I get asked, especially by religious
Jews
that want to know that the life of a
religious Jew is not so easy. A lot is
required of us. It's expensive.
And I'm asked all the time, "What about
all the rules and restrictions? Wasn't
that hard?" But they're not rules to me.
They're ways to connect with God.
Lighting Shabas candles, keeping kosher,
giving sedanka, these aren't just
obligations. They are love letters to
God. Every mitzvah is an opportunity to
bring holiness into the world.
As a Christian, I was taught that all of
these rituals and traditions that Jews
have that they were empty and that they
don't have a relationship with God like
I did. I could not have been more wrong.
Jews have a relationship with God like
nobody else on this planet.
And when I look at the meaning behind
every mitzvah, I have yet to hear a
boring answer. And I'm not afraid to
ask.
I'm sure at the beginning I got on some
rabbi's nerves because you know how the
kid on a drive keeps saying, "Are we
there yet? Are we there yet?" That was
me saying, "Why? Why? Why?" regarding
every mitzvah.
I went to a sparty shul
and they were about to make kdish and I
noticed that he poured a few drops of
water into the wine.
He was very kind and he delayed kdish
for just a little bit to explain to me
that it was a min and that the wine
represents judgment. And when we're
faced with so much judgment, we asked
that God sprinkle a little bit of mercy.
I melted. I loved that.
The muza, I asked why. One of the
explanations I heard was it's a blessing
on every Jewish home. We're instructed
to pause for a minute as we kiss the
muza and we in doing so separate
ourselves from the outside world, the
struggles we are having, the hard day at
work and recognize that the real
blessing is what's behind that door, our
Jewish home, our Jewish family
was just a little bit of Torah insight,
but it was so beautiful to me. and
Shabbat restrictions.
I look forward to Shabbat every week
because it is the opposite of
restrictions. It is freedom. It's the
one day of the week where I don't have
to say no phones at the table.
I'm unchained from my own phone outside
obligations.
The restriction is to rest, to enjoy
your family, to engage with your
community, and to connect with God.
I thought I had all of the answers. I
thought I was learned.
I thought I had a relationship with God.
My first Shabbat
was with a family, and it was so
humbling and beautiful.
A 5-year-old child proudly stood at the
Shabas table with his weekly para sheet
from school and he gave a devar to that
blew me away. It was certainly much
deeper than anything I knew.
I was violently knocked off of that high
horse that I was on and I realize I know
nothing
and that I envy every single person at
that table because they know how to
engage with God. They know how to pray.
I watched that little kid and I screamed
inside, "How do I go back to
kindergarten and learn like that?"
It wasn't easy to learn everything there
is to know about being a Torah observant
Jew, but I've been doing it. I'm still
committed to it. I still dove in
partially in English and partially in
Hebrew. I've learned to bench completely
in Hebrew, but I'm still growing every
day.
In closing, I want to tell you if you
were born Jewish, I envy you. If you had
the privilege of a Jewish education,
even more so. You have been given such a
gift, and I hope you see it.
My whole life, I just wanted to be close
to God. I thought I had the truth. I
thought I needed an intermediary to
approach God.
I feel like half of my life that
relationship has been robbed from me.
But you have had the truth all along.
You already have that connection to God,
a direct line.
If there's anything you can take away
from this, I hope you can grasp and
appreciate the beauty and the gift that
your Jewish heritage has given to you.
Appreciate the Jewish community around
you. If you don't have one, find one.
Because to be a part of a Jewish
community has given me and my children
so much. I no longer feel alone.
I found meaning and purpose in defending
the Jewish people, the Jewish faith,
doing whatever I can to protect
communities because you're my family.
And please learn your own Bible.
Ask questions. Discover the truth and
beauty of the Jewish faith. I like to
think of it as a favorite song. We all
have that song that we know. every word
to every note.
When you hear somebody else do a cover
of that song and they cut the note
short, they go a little higher, a little
lower, they hold that note a little bit
too long, you hear it immediately. You
recognize it right away.
If we knew the melody of our Bible like
that, if we knew the Tanakh like that,
there is no way that we would be fooled
or fall for any mistransations or out of
context verses because we'd recognize it
right away.
We are not losing Jewish people to
Christianity because Christianity has
something better to offer. We're losing
people because these Jews know nothing
about the faith they're being asked to
abandon.
They're looking for spirituality and
connection, but they don't see that it's
right in front of them and it's been
there all along.
[Music]
Heat. Heat.
[Music]
Heat. Heat.
[Music]