A THIRD HOLY TEMPLE IN JERUSALEM: What Does Judaism Teach? – Rabbi Michael Skobac – Jews for Judaism
Judaism places tremendous importance on the realms of time and space. In the realm of time, we have the holiness of the Sabbath and the holidays. In the realm of space, Israel is special, and in Israel, Jerusalem is even more special. Historically, Jerusalem was the place where both the first and second Holy Temples were located. The second Temple was destroyed by Roman legions in the year 70CE.
However, the scriptures clearly speak about the Temple being restored in the Messianic Age.
In this lecture Rabbi Michael Skobac explores this complicated topic. How exactly will the third Temple be built, and who will build it? In the realm of Torah law, there seem to be a number of serious potential impediments to rebuilding the Holy Temple. This lecture also explores the nature of these issues and suggests possible ways of navigating the difficulties.
●
JEWS FOR JUDAISM is an outreach organization whose primary goal is to win back to Judaism those Jews who have been influenced by the following six threats to Jewish survival that are devastating the global Jewish community.
1. Hebrew-Christian missionaries convert thousands of Jews worldwide every year 2. Destructive cults cause many Jews to abandon family, friends and careers 3. Eastern religions, Buddhism and Hinduism are spiritual choices for many Jews 4. Apathy and ignorance leave many Jews unaware, unaffiliated and assimilated 5. Intermarriage is exploding with a 75% rate in some North American cities 6. Anti-Israel BDS on campus inhibits Jewish students from standing up for Israel and Judaism
To assist non-Jews who have left other religions, JEWS FOR JUDAISM also provides educational programs to help them embrace the Torah’s Seven Noachide Laws for Gentiles.
We achieve our goals through our worldwide Internet outreach, Social Media, free educational programs, educational literature and counseling services that connect Jewish people to the spiritual depth, beauty and wisdom of Judaism.
“I am so grateful to have discovered the wonderful Jews for Judaism YouTube lectures by Rabbi Skobac. I am a Jew who converted to Christianity in college, but now, thanks to your online outreach, I have returned to Judaism. Thank you.” – Rebecca G.
In a nutshell, Jews for Judaism saves Jewish lives and keeps Jews Jewish.
PLEASE SUPPORT JEWS FOR JUDAISM’S LIFE-SAVING WORK! Your help is very much needed and greatly appreciated. Jews for Judaism never charges for its programs, books and counseling services… ever. We rely solely on donations from people like you. To donate click here: https://www.canadahelps.org/dn/24741
Thank you very much.
JEWS FOR JUDAISM 3110 Bathurst St, PO Box 54042, Toronto, ON, CANADA M6A 3B7 T: 416-789-0020 • F: 416-789-0030
Shortly after their exodus from Egypt, the Almighty commanded Israel to build a sanctuary
where his holy presence would be more accessible.
We find this in the book of Exodus, chapter 25, verse 8, where God says,
ועשו לי מקדש ושוחנתי בתוכם.
Make for me a sanctuary, and I will dwell among you.
The tabernacle that they built was portable, and they took it down and reassembled it
each time they moved during their 40 years in the desert.
And even after Joshua led them into the Promised Land, this portable tabernacle
is where they offered sacrifices and which served as their spiritual hub.
Hundreds of years later, King David was outraged that there wasn't a more permanent structure
for God's presence. He thought this was a disgrace.
However, despite his intense desire to build a permanent house for God,
he was not allowed to do this because of all the wars that he had fought.
Even if the wars were completely valid and justifiable, the holy temple is a place of peace.
When its altar was constructed, they were not even allowed to cut the stones with iron,
a symbol of war. So David was not allowed to build the holy temple.
It would have to be built by his son Solomon, who fulfilled his father's dream
and built the first holy temple in Jerusalem.
And it stood for over 400 years until being destroyed by the Babylonian invaders.
When the Jews finally returned to Israel, at least some of them returned after being
exiled for 70 years in Babylon, they set out immediately to construct
the second temple where the first one had stood.
But it was hardly as grand or as beautiful as the first temple.
So hundreds of years later, King Herod renovated and expanded the temple around the year 20 BCE
into a magnificent structure. Unfortunately, this incredible edifice was completely destroyed
by the Romans in the year 70 of the Common Era. Since then, Jews have been praying tearfully
for a new temple in Jerusalem as a place of spiritual centrality where God's presence
could be manifest and where the temple services could be resumed.
Three times a day in our standard prayer, the silent meditation of 19 blessings that we pray,
we say, restore the service to your most holy house and accept in love and favor the
fire offerings of Israel and their prayers. We pray this three times a day and we have
several fast days during the year where we don't eat or drink that commemorate the destruction
of Jerusalem and its temple. And we have numerous practices throughout the year
to remember our holy places. For example, some people will leave the part of a wall
unpainted when they move into a new house. And at weddings, ashes are placed upon the head
of the groom who says under the wedding canopy, the moving words of Psalm 137,
if I forget you, O Jerusalem, let my right hand lose its cunning. Let my tongue cleave to the
roof of my mouth. If I fail to recall you, if I fail to elevate Jerusalem above my foremost joy.
Now, one of the central features of the messianic age will be the restoration of the holy temple
in Jerusalem. We see this in numerous biblical passages in the prophetic books, especially
in numerous chapters in the book of Ezekiel. However, do we have to wait for the Messiah
to build the temple or can we begin its construction prior to his coming?
The truth is, this is not a simple topic. We find numerous views on this question in the Talmud,
in the Midrashim, in the writings of Maimonides, where he seems to take both points of view
himself. So there are various views on this question. One possible resolution to these
differing points of view is that if the temple has not yet been built when the Messiah comes,
he will certainly build it. Maimonides says, and this will prove that he is the Messiah,
but many say that we don't need to wait until the Messiah comes to commence constructing the
holy temple. But it's not so simple. There are many potential obstacles and barriers and
complications in this enterprise. For example, many believe that the commandment to build the
temple only applies when the majority of the Jewish people are living in the land of Israel.
That is one very, very serious point of view. Another view says no. And in point of fact,
they say, if you look at the second temple, when it was built by the returnees from Babylon,
only a very few number of people came back from Babylon. The majority stayed in Babylon.
So they built the second temple without having a majority of people living in the land of Israel.
But this is a debate that goes back and forth. The other point of view says, well, sure,
they were able to build it, even though they weren't a majority, but they had prophets with
them. It's a very involved discussion. However, the debate is now becoming academic because
Israel may already have or is very close to having such a majority of Jewish people living there
at this time. Some people say that another possible impediment to building the third temple
is that it requires having a living prophet to clarify certain issues that are not entirely
clear in the Bible. For example, where exactly do we place the altar in the temple? And this has to
be precisely placed. And there are those who say that unless we have a prophet that can clarify
this, then we are not able to build a temple. Another potential problem is that anyone who
has become ritually impure through direct or indirect contact with a corpse cannot go up onto
the temple mount in the place where the temple will be built. Now, the Torah has very complex
laws of ritual purity and impurity. They don't really all have application today in the absence
of a temple. But one of the points that is still applicable is that the place of the temple
has a degree of holiness where you cannot go if you are in the category that we call a temmeh
meit. There are different levels of ritual, spiritual impurity. The most severe is if you
had any contact with a corpse or something that was in contact with a corpse. You were in the same
room that was enclosed with a corpse. And the presumption is that today every person has had
such contact. So everyone today is presumed to be what we refer to as temmeh meit. And the only way
to be purified of this degree of ritual impurity is through the ashes of a sacrifice called the
para'aduma, the red heifer, which we find in the book of Numbers chapter 19. But it's an extremely
rare animal to find a heifer that is completely red. All the hairs are red. It's not so easy to
find such an animal. Extremely rare. We need to have such an animal before we can purify people
to be able to go up onto the temple mount. Another issue is that we have to be able to verify with
certainty who is a priest and who is not a priest. Only a certified, definite priest is allowed to
serve in the temple. As well, the kohanim, the priests, have to have special vestments, special
garments. And it's not so clear how to make these garments today. For example, one of the colors
that was used in the making of the priest's garments was a dye referred to as tekhelet,
which is a bluish kind of color. The problem is that for many, many hundreds and maybe thousands
of years, we've lost the tradition of what exactly this dye is made from. Now, there are people today
who believe they have found the source of this dye. But it's a debated topic, a hotly debated topic
in the Jewish community. Then there's the issue of the holy ark and the menorah, the candelabra,
and other special vessels from the holy temple. What about those? Now, some people say that they
were buried prior to the destruction of the temple underground in Jerusalem. And there are people
today who claim that the location is known, that we know where the holy ark and the other vessels
are. But this needs to be confirmed at some point, at least. Otherwise, there's going to have to be
some way of constructing these vessels anew. And then there are very practical political
considerations. We know that the government of Israel has given the Islamic Waqf control over
the temple mount. So digging there to find the holy ark and the other vessels will be seen as
provoking war. And of course, there's currently a major mosque sitting on the site where the holy
temple is supposed to be built, which is a very significant obstacle. So clearly this enterprise
of building the third temple is fraught with problems and difficulties and obstacles. So
what lies ahead? And there are basically three views that we find. One view is that God will
build the third temple and it will miraculously descend from heaven. Can't argue with that.
Now, this view is found in the Talmud and in the major commentaries to the Talmud, like Rashi
and Tosafot. However, some sources don't take these views literally and say it's not referring
to an actual temple that will descend from heaven, but to the divine spirit
that will come down and fill a man-made temple. So this again, even though it's one of the three
possible views, we're not unanimous in terms of how it's going to play out. Some believe
that the construction of the third temple needs to be brought about by the Messiah.
Now the Messiah is going to be preceded, we learn from the prophet Malachi, by the return of Elijah
the prophet, who according to the Talmud is going to resolve all the legal issues that have remained
unclear. So with the coming of the Messiah, there'll be the apparatus to resolve many of the
legal issues. Obviously, the coming of the Messiah will presage dramatic political changes in the
world and it could be that that's what will be required, nothing less than the Messiah himself
to be able to construct the third temple. And finally, there are those today who maintain
that we do not need to wait for God's intervention, we don't need to wait for the
Messiah to come, but rather the people of Israel will build the third temple. And they insist that
leading Torah scholars are empowered in every generation to resolve questionable issues of
Torah law, that we didn't need prophets to be able to determine the way through a thicket of
contradictory points of view. And these people today believe that they know exactly where to
construct the temple and exactly where to place its altar. They actually have already constructed
many temple vessels, they've made priestly garments, and they believe they can confirm
the authenticity genealogically of priests. And they've begun training these priests to perform
the temple service. And they have secured several candidate red heifers. So there are people today
who don't only say that it's theoretically possible for human beings to one day build the
temple, there are groups today of Jews who are actively pursuing such a project. Now, whether
other leading Torah sages will go along with their views remains to be seen. People cannot act
unilaterally. And it's not clear how they will overcome the potentially explosive political
considerations. But hopefully, we will all see a positive resolution to these issues
in the very near future.