NO to MESSIANIC JEWS FOR JESUS – CBC TV show FACE OFF – Rabbi Michael Skobac

Jews for Judaism
54 followers
7 Video Views·Dec 2, 2022
NO to MESSIANIC JEWS FOR JESUS – CBC TV show FACE OFF
We're such a small group, why are they fear us?
I mean, if Jesus, Yeshua, is the Messiah,
then they have everything to fear.
But if He's not the Messiah, why worry about it?
Welcome back to Face Off.
The meaning of Jesus is clear for most Jewish people.
Jews reject the notion that Jesus is the Son of God or the Messiah.
Yet there are groups all over the world who embrace fundamentalist Christianity
and claim that it's compatible with Judaism.
Jews for Jesus is the best known of these messianic groups.
Jewish religious leaders categorically reject them as Jewish.
By accepting Christ, they've left the faith.
I'm not a religious Jew, but I do know that the fundamental tenet of Judaism
is that there is only one God,
and accepting other gods means leaving the religion.
Well, I don't have any problem with Jews converting to Christianity,
but I suspect they should call themselves Christians.
But to debate this, we're joined by Rabbi Michael Skobak of Jews for Judaism
and by Malvern Jacobs,
Dean of the Department of Jewish Studies at Canada Christian College
and Vice President of the Messianic Jewish Alliance of Canada.
Judy?
Malvern, the Torah, which is the law of Judaism,
the book of laws of Judaism, says the Lord is our God, the Lord is one.
How can you possibly say you're Jewish if you believe in the Trinity
and if you believe in Jesus Christ as God?
Yes, that is Shema Yisrael, Shema.
It says he is our unity.
It's the word echad, whereas jahid would mean he would be a single one.
In some of our prayer books, they do say,
Behold God, our unity, and it's Elohim.
So you're saying we just have a different interpretation of the Torah?
Different interpretation, but its interpretation has been handed down by sages,
not all agreeing, but over the years.
It has been even before the 5th century.
Michael, do you see it as just a matter of interpretation?
Well, I think what's clear here is that we need to have clear definitions
and not simply interpretations.
I think that it's fairly clear to most people that if someone raised as a Christian
decides to embrace Islam or Hinduism,
they've essentially left Christianity and have embraced another religion.
For a Jewish person to embrace Christianity, meaning embrace the belief in Jesus,
and to live by the New Testament,
is essentially to embrace the religion of Christianity.
So your concern isn't that people will embrace Christ.
Your concern is that they would embrace Christ and call themselves Jews.
I wouldn't say that it's my only concern.
No, no, I don't mean that that's your only concern.
I think there are two issues here.
As a Jewish teacher, as a rabbi, my concern is to educate Jews
and Jewish people who are uneducated or who stray to other religions.
I see it as part of my responsibility to educate them.
There's a second issue here, which is simply the issue of the ethics of the political delineation
of what we call ourselves,
and it seems that there are a number of Jews who insist on,
although they accept all the tenets of Christianity,
to insist that it's still compatible with Judaism.
What about that, Melvin?
I mean, one of the charges is that you prey on vulnerable Jews,
like, let's say, Jews recently immigrated from the Soviet Union.
You bring them in, they believe that you're Jewish,
but you're really practicing Christianity,
and you're sort of proselytizing them in a kind of dishonest way.
You may want to use the word proselytize,
but I would not use the word that we prey on them, P-R-E-Y, but P-R-A-Y.
We believe in all the tenets of the Jewish faith,
that the Messiah is going to come.
One of our prayers is the same as our counterpart is,
I believe in a firm faith in the coming of the Messiah,
and although he tarry, yet will I wait for him to come.
Yeah, but you believe Jesus is God.
I mean, if there's any difference between Judaism and Christianity,
it's the belief in Jesus Christ.
But I believe it only from the Old Testament tenets.
Everything that I've learned from Genesis 315 up,
all through the scriptures, the 333 prophecies
that prove that he is the Messiah,
without even the printing of the New Testament.
I mean, the Jews believe when the Messiah comes,
we'll have a peaceful world.
Yes, they do believe that.
So why isn't the world at peace?
I think it's important to go back for a second.
Malvin said that he believes in all the tenets of Judaism.
The reality is that he essentially rejects
every major theological Jewish teaching
and accepts and embraces the conservative,
evangelical, Protestant teaching on every single issue,
not just the Messiahship of Jesus,
but the divinity of Jesus, the concept of original sin,
the idea of salvation, the notion of atonement from sin,
the canon of the Bible.
Essentially, if a Jewish person were to go to a Billy Graham crusade
and at the end of that crusade say that I'm a sinner
and I accept Jesus as my savior,
that's exactly what happens at every single Messianic congregation.
They've essentially left the Jewish position on every single case.
Malvin, don't you see an irony here?
I mean, I'm a fairly conservative Protestant.
We had the moderator of the United Church here,
and he's less Christian than you are, I would argue.
Isn't there an irony here?
There is an irony.
But I mean, I look at what you believe,
and it looks pretty much what I believe.
That's why the reading is,
But aren't what you're saying is it's not legitimate to be Jewish?
No, it is legitimate to be Jewish.
If you don't accept Christ.
Isn't that what you're really saying?
You're saying it's not a legitimate belief to be Jewish
unless you accept Christ.
Because if you're saying you accept Christ,
and you believe in the Bible,
then you're saying his belief in the Bible is not correct.
But also my name, by being a Yehudah, to praise God,
is part of my belief.
And that doesn't stop me being a Jew.
Yeah, well, let me put this to you, okay?
I'm a secular Jew,
and yet you wouldn't say to me you're not a Jew.
Exactly.
So why do you say he's not a Jew?
And I wouldn't say that he's not a Jew either.
You see, our teaching is that a person who's born Jewish
or converts to Judaism is a Jew,
and that never changes.
The question is not whether you or someone else is a Jew.
The question is whether they're practicing Judaism.
And our contention is that Malvern is a Jew,
although the religion he's practicing is Christianity.
And I think that that's really what needs to be clarified here,
that we're not going to resolve at this discussion
whether Christianity or Judaism is the true faith.
That's been debated 2,000 years.
The question here is, is the acceptance of Jesus
and the embracing of Christian doctrine in the New Testament,
is that properly called Judaism?
Is it?
I would say it's true.
We're just about out of time.
It is true.
It is true that it's Judaism we're still practicing
because we are looking for him to return to us.
And that's what we have to do, asking God to forgive us.
I'd like to thank our guests, Rabbi Michael Skobak of Jews for Judaism
and Malvern Jacobs,
Vice President of the Messianic Jewish Alliance of Canada.
We'd love to hear what you think about tonight's topic
or any other topic of interest to you.
All of our numbers and addresses will be appearing on your screen shortly.
