Though her time in the White House was brief, Lucretia Garfield left a lasting mark. A college-educated political partner to her husband, President James Garfield, she quietly shaped his decisions behind the scenes and later helped preserve his legacy after his tragic assassination. As one of the earliest First Ladies to publicly confront personal grief and private betrayal, she balanced intellect, dignity, and discretion. From advising on policy to creating the first presidential memorial library, Lucretia helped define the evolving role of First Lady in a modernizing America.
Welcome to American Legends. My name is Tiffany Brannan.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories,
but here in America, our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right from our history
pages. Now, some of these heroes are very famous and some are obscure, but each person deserves to
be discovered because each man or woman stands as a great example of how we can be better Americans
The role of a first lady in the United States is one which is not clearly defined in the fabric
which made our country. The constitution doesn't even mention the spouse of the president,
and it really was just many, many years of tradition which showed what the first lady
would be. Each first lady, whether very memorable or extremely obscure, has played a part in the
development of this role. Today we're going to talk about the wife of an almost forgotten president,
James Garfield, and how she would be an example of what future first ladies would do
after leaving the White House. James Garfield was the 20th president of the United States.
Elected in 1880, he was the second president to be assassinated, being shot in July just a few
months after his inauguration, and he ended up dying in September. Thus, he holds the record as
the second shortest time in office of a president, having been in there only a few months. As a result,
his wife didn't have much time to make a big mark on the role of first lady. Nevertheless,
Mrs. Garfield had a very interesting life, and she is an important woman to study when wanting
to know more about the roles of womanhood in the United States in the years of the late 19th century.
Lucretia Randolph, who was known as Crete, was born in Ohio in the year 1832. She was a sickly child,
suffering from lung conditions throughout her life. This would continue to plague her even
in her middle-aged years as a married woman, since she suffered from malaria most of her time
as first lady. Her father was the founder of the Western Reserve Eclectic Institute in Ohio,
where both she and her future husband would study in their more advanced education. Before that,
she learned not only the housewife duties from her mother, such as cooking, cleaning, sewing,
but also basic education, going to grammar school. After that, she attended the Goto Seminary, which
was a freewill Baptist school at that time, and it was there that she first met James Garfield,
who was a year older than she was. At the Western Reserve Eclectic Institute, which would later
become known as Hiram College, she not only studied alongside Garfield, but actually studied
from him as he became a teacher. He most notably taught her Greek. He greatly admired her mind and
her intellect, although he did caution her from spending too much time in her studying. I think
the reason for that was that she was very reserved, and this frustrated him. She wasn't very comfortable
showing a lot of affection or voicing her feelings. And apparently, Mr. Garfield was a much more
passionate young man. They began courting first when they were both at the school, but then as
he was traveling around, they began a letter courtship. Although they were writing letters and
even engaged for quite a few years, he then pursued a romantic relationship with another young woman,
and it was largely because he was convinced that she didn't really care that much about him.
After he ended up returning and seeing her in person, though, it was only after she allowed him
to read part of her diary that he realized how much she did care about him. They ended up getting
married in the year 1858, by which point she was 26, which was a bit older to getting married for
the first time in those days, particularly because they had been courting for many years.
Now, this was largely because he was trying to establish some kind of a profession for himself,
trying to make some money, pursuing different interests such as preaching, traveling, the beginning
of a law profession, teaching. But it was also because they didn't really want to get married.
Neither one of them was that happy upon their marriage. They got married because they felt like
they should. It was expected. And I think because they'd been courting and engaged for so long,
seemed like the thing to do. Nevertheless, their early marriage was not very happy.
They didn't have a honeymoon, but they immediately moved into a boarding house together.
Throughout her life, Lucretia struggled between her more traditional views and her more
progressive views. I don't want to use the term feminism because she didn't support the
suffragist movement, which was just starting around that time. When she was in school and
studying, she believed that women shouldn't lose their whole identity through marriage,
and she believed that women could even pursue a profession after marriage. She would always be a
bit conflicted about not really loving the household duties of a wife, such as being a
homemaker and a housekeeper. In the first five years of their marriage, they only lived together
for 20 weeks. He was gone most of the time, and they really continued living their separate lives.
She was teaching, and she'd often go and be with her family and stay in one place. He was off,
well, then the Civil War started not long after that, so then he was off fighting.
Now, they were together enough for them to have a couple of children during this time,
but after the birth of their first child, he was off again. And one thing which really
put a strain on their marriage was his infidelities. He was known to pursue other
women. To what extent isn't largely known, but he was romantically involved with a couple of
other women while he was married to Lucretia, including the girl whom he was thinking about
marrying after he was engaged to Lucretia. At first, this distressed her, but she decided to
sort of ignore it and turn a blind eye to it. And then there would be various periods where
things would happen to bring them together. For instance, after his first service in the Civil
War in 1861, he became quite ill with dysentery, so he returned to their home, and she nursed him
back to health. This increased their bond really for the first time, and they grew very close.
But then he was off again and looking at other women, and she went back to her separate life.
Then the death of their oldest child really united them in their grief. Finally, after he was
serving in Congress more regularly, she came to Washington with him, and he built a house for
them there. And that was the first time they'd had a home of their own, after having been married
for over 10 years. They later would also establish a farm for themselves, where they enjoyed living
together and developing a deeper bond. After several years of marriage, there was a quote
from him where he said, I feel that we no longer just love each other because we have to or we
ought to, but because we do. So they did grow to really care for each other. And obviously,
it was not an arranged marriage. They were interested in each other, but there was something
with their personalities or maybe differing views that had created a lack of a bond between them,
which led her to want to find some kind of fulfillment in other things, and him to look
for affection from other women, which is quite surprising, considering how passionate he was
about his religious background, that he didn't feel a stronger conscience to be more faithful
to his wife. The issue of his infidelity almost became a prominent feature in the 1880 election,
but somehow they were able to keep it from really breaking the news story. Lucretia was the first
wife of a candidate to be pictured in election materials. Her photograph was used when her
husband was running, but she would only allow one photograph of herself to be taken, and that's the
most famous one you see, of course. Regarding her views on women's suffrage, she didn't support the
suffragist movement because she believed that education for women was needed before true
equality of the sexes could be considered, although she did believe in equality for the sexes.
It's interesting to note that there were women at this time, particularly some of the first ladies
around this era, who believed that women should be well-educated, that they were equally intelligent,
and that they should be paid fairly, but they didn't necessarily believe that women should
vote or hold political office. Going back to the traditional Judeo-Christian Western beliefs of
different gender roles, I think many women, and men too, believed that men and women could be equal
but different, meaning there are some things that women should do and men shouldn't, and some things
men should do and women shouldn't, like men should fight in battle and they should be politicians, but
women should be nurses and homemakers and teachers in many spheres of influence. But at this time,
there also were growing numbers of female reporters, even a few female lawyers, and notably Lucretia's
personal physician was a woman. It really is quite amazing when you think of a hundred years later
with the civil rights movement and women's lib, there was the attitude that women couldn't hold
these positions, but that there were women who had held these positions a hundred years earlier.
So it's fascinating to really get a bit of a more accurate look into what the world really was
like in America at the time. If you've heard the notion that there really was no option for women
besides marrying some man that their fathers had chosen for them, that really isn't true. It was
possible to get an education and have a profession if you so chose, and some women like Lucretia
did both to a degree. As a congressional wife, Lucretia wasn't the most active hostess, but she
was a political advisor. As a very intelligent woman, she was a valuable counsel for her husband
and he enjoyed sharing matters of politics with her and asking for her advice. Once he became
president, he would tell her very private details of his political dealings that he wouldn't tell
to anyone else and thus get her advice by briefing her on the whole situation. She was disappointed,
it must be added, when he became the Republican nominee for president. Not because she didn't
want him to be president, but because he was this dark horse, unexpected candidate who hadn't even
been trying. She thought he just was offered as a solution because there was a tie between the two
more popular candidates, which is true. She had hoped that when he would be nominated and hopefully
elected for president, it would be because he was the most popular candidate at the time. As the
hostess of the White House, Lucretia lifted the alcohol ban which had been instilled by her
predecessor, Lucy Hayes. She didn't want the issue of abstinence to become a major political issue
in her husband's White House. There were enough points of contention with his version of the
Republican Party at the time. She was a very strong supporter and good friend of James A. Blaine,
who was the Secretary of State and a close political ally of her husband. When interviewed
on her political beliefs, she would often say that she strongly supported Blaine. Not long after
going to the White House, Lucretia developed malaria. So as summer approached, James wanted
her to be able to get away from the humid conditions of Washington to a place where she
could recover, so he sent her to New Jersey. She was there when her husband was shot, so she quickly
returned to his side and was there caring for him throughout his illness. After his death,
her widowhood was the subject of great sympathy for the people. She arranged a huge funeral for him,
which was called the biggest funeral of the day. 150,000 people paid their respects to him, which
was the size of the population of Washington, D.C. at the time. She arranged for the train bringing
his body back to Washington to go over a track that was filled with flowers, and she later
arranged several memorials to be put up in his honor. After his death, she arranged his letters,
his writings in his memory, and would create a library with them in the year 1885 in their home
in Ohio. She was the first First Lady to do that, paving the way for future First Ladies like Nancy
Reagan to make a commemorative library with the president's papers to preserve his legacy,
and she spent a good deal of the rest of her life honoring and preserving his legacy. Together,
the Garfields had seven children, five of whom lived to adulthood, and many of them were very
long-lived, living well into the 20th century, even to the 1940s or 50s. Lucretia herself had a long
life as well, and she remained active in politics in her later years, supporting several Democratic
presidents later, like Woodrow Wilson, and she was perhaps not surprisingly, seeing her husband's
views, quite progressive. She ended up taking a winter residence in Pasadena in her later years
in California, enjoying the warm climate, and she even attended the first Rose Parade.
She helped during the First World War, being active in the Red Cross, and she eventually died
in the year 1918. She would be interred alongside her husband back in Cleveland, Ohio.
Although she only was technically the First Lady for a few months, Lucretia Garfield has been
more studied and analyzed than Lucy Hayes, who served an entire four-year term.
It's partly the mystique of the fact that we didn't really get a chance to see what she could
have done in that position. It was also her strong opinions. She was the second First Lady to have
attended higher education, very intelligent, an advocate of education and equal rights for
people of other races. In addition, she's one of the early First Ladies to deal with infidelity
on her husband's part. Most of the presidents before Garfield were quite faithful to their
wives and very loyal, at least as far as we know, but he was definitely one of the first
to have not quite had scandal, but it's quite well known that there were other women in his life.
Despite that, she did really love him and he her, and in the later years of their marriage,
their bond was much deeper and they became close partners mentally and emotionally,
as well as the fact that they were bound together by the marriage with which they both
weren't particularly interested in the beginning. It's interesting to see how they were able to
build their troubled relationship over the years into something which was actually very beautiful,
as she was one of the First Ladies who was a great advisor to him, not just his wife,
not just a hostess, but a true political ally, which was important for many presidents like
Garfield, who did not have vice presidents who really were on the same side as they were.
Arthur was more his opponent than his colleague, so he relied on the advice of his wife as well
as the help of people like his Secretary of State to guide him in those few short months
of his presidency. Lucretia Garfield remains a very interesting First Lady and one who deserves
more attention. So you can read more about either Garfield through the papers which she helped
collect at his commemorative library, and her personal papers are preserved by the Library of
Congress. Thank you for spending this time with me, and I hope you'll join me next time for more
American Legends.