Lucy Webb Hayes, wife of President Rutherford B. Hayes, brought intellect, conviction, and warmth to the role of First Lady. As the first First Lady to hold a college degree, she championed education, civil rights, and temperance—not by force, but by moral example. Known for her kindness, she welcomed Black performers to the White House, turned formal dinners into inclusive celebrations, and helped popularize the Easter Egg Roll tradition. Though nicknamed “Lemonade Lucy” for banning alcohol, she was more than a symbol—she was a deeply respected voice in a changing America.
Welcome to American Legends.
My name is Tiffany Brannon.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories.
But here in America, our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right from our history pages.
Now, some of these heroes are very famous, and some are obscure.
But each person deserves to be discovered,
because each man or woman stands as a great example of how we can be better Americans in our daily lives.
As the country where all men are created equal,
the United States has long been the example for liberty and equality for all.
Over the decades and centuries of the United States' existence,
as the laws and customs have changed,
more and more people have been granted equal rights in terms of voting and owning property and holding political office.
But if you take a deeper look at history,
it's interesting to observe how some people who didn't have voting rights
already played very important roles in the fabric of the nation,
most notably women.
It's fascinating to see more about the role of womanhood in American history before the right to vote
by studying the most prominent women in America at the time,
the first ladies.
Today we're going to talk about the wife of the 19th president,
Lucy Webb Hayes.
Lucy Hayes isn't a name which stands out as one of the most famous first ladies.
Maybe that's because her husband, 19th president, Rutherford B. Hayes,
is also not one of the better known presidents.
Rutherford made many important contributions,
but it's even more surprising that Lucy isn't better remembered
because she distinguished herself as a very important first lady
who paved the way not only for other first ladies,
but for the future roles which women would play in American society.
Born Lucy Ware Webb,
she was the daughter of an Ohio doctor and his wife.
She had two older brothers who also became doctors.
She was quite young when her father died,
so like her future husband, she was primarily raised by a widowed mother.
She was the best educated first lady up to that point,
being the first to actually attend college.
When she was a young girl,
she was able to take not the full college course,
but sort of a preparational course at the Ohio Wesleyan College,
where both her brothers actually went to college.
You see, her family were devout Methodists,
so it's natural they would go to the Wesleyan College.
Interestingly, it was at the Ohio Wesleyan College
that she first met her future husband, Rutherford B. Hayes.
At the time, he was 23 and she was 14.
Rutherford's mother hoped that there might be a romantic connection between the two,
but the future president wasn't interested in such a young woman,
saying that he thought she was a little too young to know about falling in love at that time.
They would meet again several years later when she was 19.
This was largely arranged by his sister, Fanny.
They happened to both be guests at a wedding,
and in the cake, apparently, there was a tradition at that time
of hiding some kind of a ring as a token of who would be next to be married,
similar to the bouquet-tossing tradition.
It seems that Rutherford found the ring and gave it to Lucy,
whom he found very enchanting by that point.
He said that she had a low, sweet voice and big, soulful eyes.
She would keep that ring until their engagement,
at which point she returned it to him as a love token,
and he wore it for the rest of his life.
After studying at the Ohio Wesleyan College,
she went to the Wesleyan Women's College,
where she completed her full college education.
When she was 21, they were married at her mother's house.
They would have a very happy life together,
having eight children in all, including one daughter.
Three of their sons, who were on the younger side of the family,
died within their first few years of life,
but the remaining four sons and daughter lived into adulthood
and well into the 20th century.
They spent their honeymoon at his sister's house, that was Fanny,
and Lucy became very good friends with Fanny.
They became almost like sisters,
and they enjoyed going around to concerts together
and even to speeches of noted suffragist figures like Lucy Stone.
It's not known for sure exactly what Lucy Hayes thought about the suffrage movement.
She never made any public statements, she didn't sign any documents
or really publicly support any of the prominent suffragists of the time.
But Fanny was an actual outspoken suffragist,
and it's believed if she had lived longer,
she may have influenced Lucy to become a vocal suffragist.
Sadly, Fanny died in the year 1856 in childbirth,
which was just four years after her brother's marriage to Lucy,
and Lucy would later name her only daughter Fanny in her honor.
Lucy was a woman of very strong convictions.
She was a devout Methodist, a strong abolitionist,
and as a young woman, she pledged herself to temperance.
Interestingly, although she strongly disagreed with drinking alcohol herself,
she did not support prohibition.
Although she died long before prohibition would become law in the United States,
the dry movement and calls for an actual prohibition
had begun far back in the 19th century,
and they tended to be closely aligned with the Republican Party,
as was the suffragist movement.
She believed that people should have the right to choose whether they would drink,
and she didn't particularly mind if people drank in her presence.
But she believed in setting a good example,
and by using persuasion rather than actually banning alcohol,
especially legally, she didn't feel that it could be enforced properly,
which was one of the main criticisms most people had about the whole prohibition idea all along.
It's better to build up a culture of temperance rather than to prohibit it,
because the forbidden fruit always becomes the sweeter.
And she made many impassioned speeches saying that she had many young sons herself
and would not permit any alcohol in the White House
because she wouldn't let it be from her hand that alcohol would first pass her son's lips
and that they might be tempted to something which could cause their ruin,
and she wished the same for other mothers' sons.
She believed very strongly in the rights of education for women and for other races,
advocating for the rights of black people even before the Civil War.
As First Lady, she welcomed many black political figures to come and visit,
particularly with music.
She loved music very much and would host salons in the White House,
and she invited America's first black opera singer,
Marie Celica Williams, to come and perform at the White House.
Lucy was the first First Lady to tour and go to prominent events separate from her husband.
She made a tour of Philadelphia while he was president, when he did not accompany her,
and she visited several women's institutions.
She always made it her calling, really, to serve those who were underserved.
She shared with her husband a passion for helping minorities and those who were underprivileged.
She would dedicate a lot of money as well as volunteering time
at institutions for those who were mentally impaired or deaf,
and during the Civil War, she would accompany her husband to battlefields oftentimes
so she could tend to the soldiers.
And, of course, she visited him and tended to him when he was in the hospital.
She was a very active woman and quite healthy and robust, it seems,
so she would frequently accompany him when he would go to different posts,
and she visited him in Washington and stayed there with him while he was in Congress.
It was while he was president that female lawyers were first allowed to argue cases
before the Supreme Court.
It's quite amazing to think about this, that it was in the 1870s
that there actually were enough female attorneys that that was even an issue,
which really goes to show that the right to vote in U.S. elections
or to hold political office wasn't as closely aligned with female rights
as modern historians might lead you to think.
Women actually were very active in American society, barring those few issues.
Lucy was quite well-read and well-written as a young woman.
When she was in college, she wrote many essays and papers on topics
such as whether it were appropriate from a Christian standpoint to travel on the Sabbath
and certain other papers about the rights of freed slaves
and how they should be integrated into society.
She and her husband would later employ many former slaves, paying them of course,
and this goes from her background in that her father wanted to free some slaves
who had belonged to a relative of his.
But after his death, many of the other relatives advised her mother
to sell the slaves to make some money to support her family.
But her mother boldly declared that she would work as a washerwoman
before she would sell any human being.
And this conviction for abolition greatly influenced Lucy and then her husband,
making him probably a stronger abolitionist as a politician than he would have been.
And I think that right there shows the power of women in this pre-voting period.
So many U.S. presidents were influenced even in their public policies
by views which their wives held.
He always was very grateful for Lucy's advice and not only that,
but the way she earned a good public opinion.
She was a very popular White House hostess.
When she first went to the White House, there was no money from Congress to do redecoration,
as was usually the case.
So instead, the Hayses used some of their own money to work on refurbishing.
But most notably, she looked for all the old furniture that was being stored in the attic
and brought some pieces downstairs and refurbished them to redecorate things
and did the best she could to mend the holes in the rugs and the curtains.
She loved nature.
So one of the main things that Lucy did was to convert some of the rooms into greenhouses.
She made some lovely greenhouses, particularly one off of the dining room,
fitting out the windows so that they could be opened and the plants would be seen.
A quarter of the allowance given for the White House funds
was spent on the maintenance of the greenhouses.
When she ordered new dishware for the White House,
she made it very nature-based, with flora and fauna representing the rich foliage of the United States.
Although one guest did say that she found it a little difficult to eat her soup
when there was a fox springing toward a pine cone in her bowl.
Lucy was the first wife of a president to be commonly called the First Lady.
She wasn't the first to whom the term was ever applied.
That was Mary Lincoln.
But the term was used much more with her.
And because she was so prominent and so well-liked,
the growing number of female journalists in the nation loved to write about her.
They commented on her fashion, which was noted to be in good taste,
very modest, but always tasteful.
And her pretty, charming good looks,
which were, they declared, surprisingly youthful for how many children she had.
She often wore a simple comb in her hair, which you can see in almost every picture of her.
Lucy has been nicknamed Lemonade Lucy
because of the ban on alcohol in the White House during the Hayes presidency.
Since she was a strong teetotaler,
many people believed that this was her doing.
But it's later been realized that this was more of a political move by her husband,
who thought that not embracing the dry movement
would disrupt and ultimately divide the Republican Party.
I'm sure she wasn't against it, because she was a strong total abstainer herself.
But I think they were quite united on that front.
In some of her writings, either in her letters to her husband or in essays she wrote,
she declared that she thought that women should never be put down by men
or seen as the slave of men.
She believed that women should have an equal place of honor in society
while acknowledging that the sexes are different.
And she was mostly concerned with the unfair pay differences between men and women.
She never advocated for voting rights for women,
but she did believe that women should be fairly paid for any job they would do.
She also held that women were just as intelligent as men,
if not superior to them in some regards.
I think she didn't necessarily mean that in a feminist way,
but in the more traditional stance, which I'd say we seem to have left today,
in acknowledging that men and women have different strengths.
And she used those strengths to very great advantage in being a delightful hostess,
surrounding herself with many women who were not necessarily her relatives,
or some of them were nieces or cousins, since she didn't have any adult daughters to help her.
People loved her for her charming role as the First Lady,
and she was definitely the most public First Lady up to that point.
She welcomed people from both sides of the political parties into her circle
and made her dinner parties something which were very enjoyable, but also very informal.
On Thanksgiving, she and her husband invited not only important political members,
but even some of the government postal workers to come and share the meal with them,
and they had three turkeys and a whole pig to serve all the guests.
They even invited other members of the political parties to come over
to unwrap presents on Christmas morning.
It was under her watch that the White House Easter egg roll became a custom on the front lawn.
Before that, the Washington children would roll their Easter eggs on the front lawn of the Capitol building,
but after the Congress members decided they didn't want that to happen anymore,
Lucy allowed that to happen the day after Easter on the White House lawn,
and it has become a very popular tradition ever since.
Lucy loved animals, so while she was in the White House, they had a cat, a bird, two dogs, and a goat.
After the Hazes left the White House, they retired to their home in Ohio,
where Lucy would end up dying in 1889 of a stroke.
That was a few years before her husband would die.
Reportedly, his last words were,
They shared a wonderful, joyous marriage, one of great understanding and support for each other.
They shared the same religious beliefs, the same political beliefs, and just a great bond.
Many people believed that they could influence public politics by getting to Lucy.
However, she wouldn't publicly support any groups or movements which were against the interests of her husband.
She always wanted to support his political ideas, as she was a very devoted wife.
President Hayes said,
I don't know whether she influences the Congress or other people in charge of policy,
but she influences my political views.
Like many of the early First Ladies,
she struck a good balance between being the support for her husband,
the public hostess, and an advocate for important issues of the day,
like education, especially for those who are underprivileged,
more hospitals, libraries, and charities,
and equal rights and pay for the newly freed slaves,
and good pay for women in different jobs.
Lucy Hayes is a very interesting First Lady,
and an inspiring woman in the history of America,
as she was an important balance between some of the First Ladies
who weren't very interested in politics or the whole Washington scene,
and the more recent ones who are very active in politics,
even perhaps things which aren't necessarily aligned with their husbands' work.
She was always supportive of her husband, always his helpmate,
but also her own individual who was able to accomplish things on her own
while not straying from her husband's policies.
I think she remains an excellent example of how to be a very publicly spirited woman
without losing your traditional femininity.
Thank you for spending this time with me.
I hope you'll join me next time to talk about more American legends.