After vanishing from public view for more than 20 days, Xi Jinping suddenly reappeared in Tibet—but his “grand comeback” raised more questions than answers. Why did he wobble as he walked? Why was he in Lhasa for less than 24 hours? Why did key generals skip the trip, leaving only a disciplinary officer by his side? Do they have anything to do with the 4-point consensus reached by various factions at Beidaihe? In this episode, we break down seven strange clues from Xi’s Tibet visit—and what they reveal about his health, his power, and who really controls the Chinese regime.
After showing up at the Great Hall of the People on July 25th to receive credentials from 16
newly-arrived ambassadors, Xi Jinping disappeared from the public view for more than 20 days.
Then, guess what? On August 20th, yesterday, Xi Jinping suddenly reappeared,
making what state media hyped as a grand comeback. So he showed up in Tibet with a massive entourage,
as if he's saying, I'm back. In Lhasa, in the square where they held the celebration,
there was a giant portrait of Xi Jinping erected in the main square.
And state media glorified him, this time with the title, Lin Xiu, or Supreme Leader.
And even the PLA daily resumed calling him He Xin, the core. The message was clear.
The regime wanted to show Xi's grip on power and to show that it was unshakable.
So here's Mr. Wu, one of the dissidents living in the US. And so on August 15th,
he posted what he called the four-point consensus of the Beidaihe meeting.
So there are four points. The first one is to maintain the stability of the party's
central leadership. Xi Jinping will remain in his post and continue to play the role of the
top leader. State propaganda should stay consistent about his status,
but excessive personal worship will no longer be allowed.
Point number two, Xi Jinping will not be permitted to serve in another term.
Number three, party, government, and military powers will be relatively separated.
Number four, the party's coordinating bodies will oversee preparations for the fourth plenum
and begin laying the groundwork for the 21st Party Congress in 2027.
So to me, this consensus looks like a deadlock. It basically says Xi will step down eventually
in 2027 at the 21st Party Congress. But until then, no one knows what to do with him.
So for now, we'll keep him in place until figuring out the next move.
That explains why state media suddenly revived the Xi Jinping core, the core title. And it also
explains why PLA Daily fell in line and why Xi Jinping needed such a dramatic display in Tibet.
Well, officially, his visit was to attend the 60th anniversary of the Tibet Autonomous Region,
or the establishment of the Autonomous Region of Tibet. It was established in 1965,
six years after the 14th Dalai Lama fled into exile in India following the failed
1959 uprising. But here's what's odd about the trip. I have summarized, I think, seven points.
First of all, he didn't need to go at all. Xi Jinping didn't have to go. The 60th anniversary,
which is this year, isn't as significant as the 50th. In fact, back in 2015, 10 years ago,
Xi Jinping didn't attend the 50th anniversary. He sent Politburo Standing Committee member
Yu Zhensheng instead. At the time, Yu's rank was about the same as Wang Huning's rank today.
This time, Xi Jinping went in person, likely because he desperately needed a high-profile
event to show he's still in command. Or, as some people believe, that he desperately needed
divine protections, and so he visited the holy place of Tibetan tantrism.
Number two, he brought an unusually large entourage. Two Standing Committee members
joined him, Wang Huning, the head of the CPPCC, and also Cai Qi, his right-hand man
in charge of party affairs. And alongside them were Li Ganjie, who is the head of the United
Front Work, He Lifeng, vice-premier in charge of the economy, Zhang Guoqing, another vice-premier,
and then Wang Xiaohong, the minister of public security. There's a vice-chairman of the National
People's Congress, who is a Tibetan, Losan Jankang, and then Hu Chunhua, vice-chairman of
the CPPCC, and then Zhang Shenming, central military commission member in charge of military
discipline and anti-corruption. Now, the strangest part is Hu Chunhua because, as you all know now,
that he is in the anti-Xi camp, and he's one of the names floated as a possible successor
to Xi Jinping. And Xi has worked so hard to sideline Hu Chunhua, so it's highly unlikely
that Xi Jinping invited Hu to join him on this trip. And also, Hu Chunhua wasn't needed for this
trip because his boss, CPPCC chairman Wang Huning, was already on the trip. Normally, if the chairman
goes, the vice-chairman stays behind. The fact that Hu went anyway shows that the reformist
faction of the camp insisted on sending Hu, just as checks and balances, and Xi Jinping had no
choice but to accept it. Point number three, Xi Jinping wasn't even the head of his entourage.
State media reported that Wang Huning, and not Xi Jinping, was listed as head of the delegation
from Beijing. This is highly unusual. By CCP's own protocol, the highest-ranking official always
leads the delegation. Number four, Xi Jinping left Tibet early. Not only was he not the head
of the delegation, but he also cut his visit short. He stayed in Lhasa for less than 24 hours.
Compare that to his last visit in 2021, when he stayed for three days. This time, this is very
short. He arrived on the 20th and then left on the 21st. It's not even 24 hours. Even stranger,
the officials who traveled with him, his entourage, the people that I just showed you
on previous slides, they didn't return to Beijing with him. They simply went to the Lhasa airport
to see him off and then stayed behind to finish their business. Isn't that unusual?
And then there's a missing man on this trip. I think you probably can guess that. Yes,
his vice chairman, Zhang Youxia. Now, despite the large entourage,
vice chairman of Central Military Commission, Zhang Youxia, was nowhere to be seen.
In fact, Xi Jinping and Zhang Youxia haven't appeared together for quite some time now.
And this Tibet trip was Xi's fifth domestic visit of 2025. But the first time he inspected
local troops. In the previous four visits, he broke his tradition of always visiting local
troops. And that actually was one of the reasons why people say that he has lost control over the
military because he stopped visiting local troops. Now in Tibet, he went. Usually, or I shouldn't say
usually, it's almost the case when the CMC chairman inspects troops, his vice chairman
should always accompany him. But Zhang Youxia wasn't there. Some might argue that, well,
maybe Zhang Youxia was busy preparing for the September 3rd parade. If so, the next in line,
General Liu Zhenli, the CMC's chief of staff, should go in his place. But he didn't go either.
Liu didn't go either. Instead, the man sent was Zhang Shenming,
the CMC member in charge of discipline and anti-corruption. Zhang Shenming, this Zhang,
isn't a field commander. He's a disciplinary officer. By tradition, someone in his capacity
doesn't accompany the top commander to inspect troops because it's really sending the wrong
message. So sitting to Xi Jinping's left is Zhang Shenming. So this sends a very awkward message.
Was he there to keep an eye on Xi Jinping? Why did an officer in charge of discipline and
anti-corruption go on inspect the troops with Xi Jinping? It's just very odd.
Now, another absence is, this is very odd, is that when Xi Jinping met with the Xinjiang Military
District officers, its commander, Lieutenant General Wang Kai, he was absent. People say
the man sitting next to him, next to Xi Jinping on his right, was his political commissar. This
is what people believe has happened. Wang Kai is closely associated with Zhang Youxia. He built his
career in the 13th and the 14th Group Armies. Both considered Zhang Youxia's strongholds.
Now, remember I told you about a week ago that General Liu Yuan recently toured Sichuan and
Yunnan to rally support within the PLA. Well, the 13th Group Army is based in Sichuan,
in Chengdu, Sichuan, and the 14th is in Kunming, Yunnan. So Wang Kai and Zhang Youxia both held
the title of commander of the 13th Group Army. Of course, they were eight years apart.
Their ties to the 13th Army make them close. His absence from Xi Jinping's reception, alongside
the absence of Zhang Youxia and Liu Zhengli, all point in the same direction. It's a message from
Zhang Youxia, which is that Xi Jinping no longer commands the real muscle of the PLA.
His activities now are mostly symbolic, and Wang Kai's absence was almost certainly ordered by
Zhang Youxia himself. Point number seven, Xi Jinping didn't look healthy. Footage from
Tibet showed him walking slowly and sometimes even wobbly. A medical expert actually said that
Lhasa sits on the high altitude Tibetan plateau, and people with heart conditions or poor health
are not advised to travel there. Now, Xi Jinping has cardiovascular condition.
A medical expert suggested that he must have undergone health physical exams or tests
at the 301 Military Hospital before the trip. And perhaps the three doctors flowing from Shanghai
were likely part of the team assessing whether he was fit to go or not.
So taken together, these signs suggest Xi Jinping's trip to Tibet was more about political
theater than leadership. He would stand there to project unity and to reaffirm his status as
party leader, but it came at the risk of his health because he didn't look too happy. And
that is why he left within 24 hours, leaving his entourage behind to carry out the actual duties,
because his health could not let him stay there for any longer.
And meanwhile, Zhang Youxia and the military deliberately distanced themselves. They sent
only the lowest-ranking CMC member and excluded the Xinjiang commander from Xi's reception.
The message couldn't be clearer. Xi Jinping no longer commands the army.